Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 02.06.2026
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE T.V.THAMILSELVI
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2012
S.A.No.966 of 2021
1.Myil Mark Nilayam
Having office at No.431,
Thiruvotriyur High Road
Washermanpet, Chennai-21.
2.M.N.Venkatachalam (died)
3.Meyammal
4.V.Muthiah
5.V.Nagappan
6. V.Gomathi
[A-6 LR of A-2]
Appellants 4 and 5 declared as major
and they discharged from guardianship of A2
vide order date 29.08.2025
... Appellants
/ Defendants 9 to 13.
/ Respondents 8 to 12
Vs.
1.M.Bhanumathi
2.T.Kumari
3.T.R.Selvarajan (died)
4.T.R.Sucheendra Babu
5.Saradambal
Page No:1/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
6.Sulochana
7.V.Muthu Srinivasan
8.Kunchithapatham
9.Saraswathy
10.Geetha
11.Latha
12. Sudha
13.T.S.Kumar
14.Valliammai
15.Meyammai
16.Meenakshi
17.V.N.Venkatesan
18.S.Saraswathy
19.Jeeva
20. Sathya
21.Shanthi
22. V.N.V.Ravi
23.Mallika
24.V.Ramesh
25.V.Vijayan
26.V.Usharani
R5 died. RR 17 to 26 are brought on record as LRs of the deceased R5
vide Court Order dated 25.11.2025 made in CMP.Nos.28220, 28221 &
28222 of 2025
in S.A.No.966 of 2021
RR9 to 13 brought on record as LRs of the deceased R3 viz.,
T.R.Selvarajan vide court order dated 30.09.2021 made in
M.P.No.1 to 3 / 2014 in S.A.SR.No.81261 of 2017.
... Respondents
PRAYER in S.A.966 of 2021: Second Appeal filed under Section 100 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, against the judgment and decree dated 22.12.2006
passed by the learned I Additional City Civil Judge, Chennai, in A.S.No.79
of 1997 reversing the judgment and decree dated 23.08.1996 passed by the
learned II Assistant City Civil Judge, Chennai, in O.S.No.1421 of 1991.
Page No:2/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
S.A.No.947 of 2012
1.Myil Mark Nilayam
2.M.N.Venkatachalam (died)
3.Meyammal
4.V.Muthiah
5.V.Nagappan
6.V.Gomathi
VS
1.T.Kumari
2.M.Bhanumathi
3.T.R.Selvarajan (deceased)
4.T.R.Suchindra Babu.
5.Saradambal
6.Sulochana
7.V.Muthu Srinivasan
8.Kunchithapatham
9.Saraswathy
10.Geetha
11.Latha
12. Sudha
13.T.S.Kumar
14.Valliammai
15.Meyammai
16.Meenakshi
17.V.N.Venkatesan
18.S.Saraswathy
19.Jeeva
20. Sathya
21.Shanthi
22. V.N.V.Ravi
Page No:3/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
23.Mallika
24.V.Ramesh
25.V.Vijayan
26.V.Usharani
..Respondents
R5 died. RR 17 to 26 are brought on record as LRs of the deceased R5
vide Court Order dated 25.11.2025
PRAYER in S.A.No.947 of 2012 : Second Appeal filed under Section 100
of the Code of Civil Procedure, to set aside the judgment and decree dated
14.02.2012 passed in A.S.No.201 of 2011 on the file of III Additional City
Civil Court, at Chennai, confirming the judgment and decree dated
01.04.2010 passed in I.A.No.8080 of 2008 in O.S.No.1421 of 1991 on the
file of II Assistant City Civil Judge, Chennai.
In both Second Appeals:For Appellants
: Mr.T.S.Baskaran
For Respondents
: Mr.R.Sathiyaamurthy for R1 and R2.
R3, R5 died.
R14, R18 left
R15, R16 and R 25- No appearance
R17 – deceased.
R 19, R 20, R24 – unclaimed
R12 and R22 – No such person
R23 – insufficient address
R26 – door locked.
COMMON JUDGMENT
Since the parties and the issues in both the Second Appeals are one
and the same, both Second Appeals are taken up together for hearing and the
matters are disposed of by the Common Judgment.
Page No:4/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
2. In S.A.No.966 of 2021, the appellants herein are the defendants 9 to
13 in O.S.No.1421 of 1991 on the file of II Assistant Judge, City Civil
Court, Chennai. Challenging the reversal findings in A.S.No.79 of 1997, the
defendants 9 to 13 preferred this Second Appeal.
3. Originally the plaintiff filed O.S.2001 of 1982 before Sub Court,
Chengalpet against the defendants for the relief of partition claiming 1/7th
share in the suit properties as described in the plaint A and B Schedule
properties; later it was transferred on the point of jurisdiction before the Sub
Judge, Poonamallee as O.S.182 of 2006 and thereafter the suit was again
transferred and renumbered as O.S.No.1421 of 1991. Pending suit
proceedings, defendants 9 to 13 purchased the properties as purchasers.
They have been subsequently impleaded. Before the trial court, defendants 1
to 6 contested the case.
4. On considering both oral and documentary evidence, the trial Judge
has dismissed the suit holding that the plaintiff is not entitled for the share in
the suit properties.
Aggrieved by the said findings, the plaintiff and
Defendant No.6 transposed as 2nd plaintiff filed A.S.No.79 of 1997 before
the I Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai, wherein, the 1 st Appellate
Page No:5/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
Judge, after considering the oral and documentary evidence and framing
separate points for consideration, finally held that the appellants/plaintiffs
are entitled to get the share in the suit property and the 1 st appeal was
allowed by the First Appellate Judge, thereby, the decree and judgment of
the trial court was set aside.
5. Aggrieved by the said reversal finding, the subsequent purchasers
defendants 9 to 13 preferred S.A.No.966 of 2021.
6. The brief facts of the case are as follows:The plaintiff and the defendants 1 to 6 are the legal heirs of the
deceased T.C.Rajagopala Mudaliar . Originally A and B schedule properties
are the separate properties of Rajagopala Mudaliar. He died intestate leaving
behind defendants 1 to 6 as legal heirs. Admittedly he had two wives. After
the death of the 1st wife, Rajagopala Mudaliar got married to 2nd wife Baby
Ammal and through both wives, he begotten children. The 1st defendant in
the O.S.No.1421 of 1991 is the 2nd wife of Rajagopala Mudaliar and Baby
Ammal died on 30.04.1998.
7. The plaintiff in O.S.No.1421 of 1991 states that the entire suit
Page No:6/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
properties are separate properties of his father Rajagopala Mudaliar. Besides
the said properties, her mother also purchased some house site in T.V.K. 3 rd
street, by selling her jewels. The plaintiff stated on 05.09.1979 there was
partition deed between plaintiff and defendants 1 to 6. But the said document
was not executed in the manner known to law. The male members viz., 2 nd
and 3rd defendants took all the valuable immovable properties and the
plaintiff was given with meagre share of Rs.8000/- which is very much
inequal, but the 2nd and 3rd defendants/her brothers undertook that they
compensate for the said disparity but they have not done so. On 01.10.1982
plaintiff came to know that defendants 2 and 3 purposely undervalued the
suit properties more particularly Item Nos.1 and 2 of B Schedule properties
and played fraud on the plaintiff; defendants 7 to 13 are the pendente lite
purchasers of the partitioned suit properties and thereby stated that the entire
partition is done with fraud and therefore, the partition deed was not
registered nor it was acted upon. Therefore, she claimed that on the death of
their mother, she claimed 1/7th share in the entire suit properties by metes
and bounds.
8. It is the further case of the plaintiff that pending suit proceedings,
the 1st defendant died and her share was modified and the plaintiff claimed
4/21 share of the suit property.
Page No:7/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
9. The Plaintiff submits that the alleged partition deed dated
05.09.1979 was not acted upon and defendants 2 and 3 defrauded them
particularly against female members of the family; also they were not
permitted to ascertain the real market value of the suit properties allotted to
the 2nd and 3rd defendants. However, they entrusted the plaintiff for agreeable
partition and only in the year 1982, she came to know that the properties
were undervalued as per the alleged partition deed dated 05.09.1979.
Thereby, contended that the defendants 2 and 3 committed fraud upon them.
10. The 1st defendant states that she purchased the house site at her
own savings and settled it in favour of her daughter/plaintiff and two sons
viz., Muthuvelu and Thangavelu in the year 1974. In the year 1959 also, 1 st
defendant also purchased two house sites and put up construction by selling
her jewels. The share allotted on her was not bonafide and fair manner. She
also raised objections in respect of the claims made by defendants 2 to 5 in
respect of the properties mentioned in their written statement shown as A, B
and C Annexures. Thereby, she contended that each of the legal heirs are
entitled to equal shares in the suit property and the unfair partition deed
dated 05.09.1979 may be reopened and allotted 1/7th share in the plaint
Page No:8/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
schedule property. To that effect, she paid court fee.
11. As per the written statement of the defendants 2 to 5, 2 nd and 3rd
defendants are the brothers/male members of the family. They submitted that
at the time of marriage, the plaintiff was given jewels worth more than
Rs.50,000/- and marriage was also celebrated in a grand manner. Therefore,
at the time of partition of the property, she was given share accordingly since
the defendants 2 and 3 took other liabilities including debts of the family,
therefore, the property was allotted to defendants 2 and 3 in a fair manner
and one of the sisters viz., D4 has relinquished her share as per the family
arrangement and the other defendants and plaintiff also were agreeable for
division of the immovable properties in respect of the partition deed and
accordingly partition deed dated 05.09.1979 was acted upon but the suit was
filed on 1.10.1982 as such is barred by limitation as the suit is to be filed
within three years. Since the prior Partition Deed dated 05.09.1979 was not
cancelled, the suit for fresh partition is not sustainable. Therefore, the
plaintiff is not entitled to seek for partition ignoring the said prior partition in
which she is also one of the beneficiaries. Therefore, the suit as such is not
maintainable. Along with written statement, they made Annexures ‘A’ ‘B’
‘C’ with regard to the properties which were given by Rajagopala Mudaliar
to the 1st defendant, plaintiff and 2nd defendant. That is Annexure ‘A’ list of
Page No:9/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
properties are given by Rajagopala Mudaliar to his wife/1st defendant.
Annexure B properties are given to plaintiff by her father; C schedule
properties are given to 2nd defendant by his father. Therefore debts and
liabilities were handled by defendants 2 and 3 and accordingly they derived
benefits. About the annexures claimed in the written statement of the 2 nd
defendant, the 1st defendant denied those allegations and contended that
some of the properties were purchased by her by selling her jewels and
claiming right over those properties.
12. Before the trial court, the plaintiff and D1 to D6 contested the case
by adducing oral and documentary evidence. On the side of the plaintiff, she
was examined as P.W.1 and marked Ex.A.1 and Ex.A.2 documents. On the
side of defendants, D.W.1 to D.W.4 were examined and Exhibits B.1 to B.13
were marked. On considering the oral and documentary evidence, trial Judge
framed 8 issues for consideration.
13. As per the evidence, the property belongs to Rajagopala Mudaliar
which was admitted by all the parties and they also admit that Rajagopala
Mudaliar had two wives. After the death of the 1st wife, he married 2nd wife
Baby Ammal and also begotten children. Plaintiff and defendants 1 to 6 are
Page No:10/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
the legal heirs of Rajagopala Mudaliar. The above facts are undisputed.
14. Considering the evidence, the trial Judge held that the plaintiff
approached the court stating that the alleged partition deed was executed for
ulterior purpose and not acted upon. Therefore, burden is on her to discharge
that partition deed was obtained by fraud, coercion, misrepresentation and
by using undue influence. But to prove the same, except P.W.1 no other
independent witness was examined. Further the alleged assurance to give
more amount in future was also not been proved. Besides the suit also not
filed within 3 years after the date of the alleged partition. Therefore, the suit
also not filed within 3 years and the suit is barred by limitation and the
partition deed was executed on 05.09.1979. Further, considering the
evidence of the defendants 1 and 6 and on considering the document
Ex.B.12 and considering the defendants’ evidence D.W.1 and D.W.2, the
trial Judge observed that O.S.No.201 of 1982 was filed before the Sub
Court, Chengalpet. Before the filing of the suit, the plaintiff has not issued
any notice to the defendants claiming share nor alleging that partition deed
was not proper nor made any demand to comply with the agreed terms said
to be made by the defendants 2 and 3 and the suit has not been filed
within 3 years from the date of the said partition. Also held that the
Page No:11/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
plaintiff failed to establish that the document was prepared by
exercising undue influence, under which circumstances, the plaintiff
ought to have sought for the relief of cancellation of the partition deed
but failed to ask, as such, the suit is not maintainable on all the
aforesaid findings and the suit was dismissed.
15. Aggrieved by the above said findings of the trial Judge, the
plaintiff and the 4th defendant transposed herself as 2nd appellant/2nd
plaintiff filed A.S.No.79 of 1997 on the file of the II Additional Judge,
City Civil Court, Chennai.
16. Before the 1st appellate court, the purchasers 6th and 7th
respondent contested the appeal. The other respondents remained
absent. The 1st appellate court framed separate points for consideration.
17. Before the 1st appellate court, 2 applications in CMP.1464 of
2003 and 1785 of 2003 was filed along with appeal. The two CMPs
were filed by the appellants/plaintiffs to receive the certified copy of
the letter dated 20.05.1995 issued by the 2nd and 3rd defendant and out
patient chit issued by KMC Hospital and registration copy of the sale
Page No:12/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
deed dated 21.01.1988 executed by 3rd defendant in favour of the 7th
defendant and notice dated 30.08.2003 for production of original of
Ex.B.12, registration copy of the partition deed and postal
acknowledgement of the said notice in the latter. Reception of those
documents were objected by the contesting respondents stating that
those documents were not relevant.
18. On hearing both sides, the 1st appellate Judge held that those
documents are relevant and marked as Exhibits A-3 to A-7.
19. Considering the evidence on record, the 1st appellate Judge
has held that suit properties are self acquired properties of Rajagopala
Mudaliar and he died by leaving behind his wife and sons and
daughters as legal heirs and thereby legal heirs are entitled to 1/7 th
share. The 1st defendant, wife of Rajagopal Mudaliar died pending
proceedings leaving behind her legal heirs and they are entitled to 4/21
share each. The 1st appellate Judge had observed that original partition
deed Ex.B.12 was not produced inspite of notice issued and the said
document was produced for registration only after 2 years of the
execution ie. in the year 1979. It is also noted that even as early as on
Page No:13/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
1977, it was executed after correction of the year, since it was presented
for registration after two years later, as such, it is void. Further, there
was assurance by the 2nd and 3rd defendants that family properties will
be satisfied in future. So they allotted meagre share of Rs.8000/- to the
plaintiff. By misrepresentation, the 2nd and 3rd defendants obtained
signatures in the said partition deed and the allotment of the share was
also inequal and therefore, held that the partition was not valid and the
partition is to be reopened and fresh partition should be ordered as
prayed for.
20. Further the 1st appellate Judge observed that the original
partition deed Ex.B.12 was not produced. If at all the original is not
with the brothers, they ought to have submitted the reason for non
production of the original document and also adduced secondary
evidence under Section 65 of the Evidence Act by complying with the
other condition to invoke the same. But in the case on hand, they have
assigned no reasons nor taken any attempts to produce Ex.B.12 original
document. But only certified copy was marked as Ex.B.12. Inspite of
the direction to cause production of the document, it was not produced.
Page No:14/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
Therefore, the certified copy produced on the side of defendants 2 and
3 which is marked as Ex.B.12, as such is liable to be rejected. The 1 st
appellate Judge accordingly held that the certified copy of the partition
deed is not valuable one and as much as it was not primarily registered
as contemplated under law. Further, the 1st appellate Judge also held
that even as per Ex.B.12, it was mentioned as 05.09.1979 but the stamp
papers were purchased in the year 1977. D.W.2 also stated that the
document was prepared on 05.09.1977 and it was not registered
immediately. There was material alteration in respect of the year of the
document. As per Section 23 and 25 of the Registration Act, 1908,
document is void. As per Section 23 of the Registration Act, the 1 st
appellate Judge thereby held that the partition deed is not binding on
the appellants/plaintiffs. Further the 1st appellate Judge held that the
said partition deed created is nullity as the original partition deed was
not produced nor it is registered. According to the plaintiff, the
document is void. The plaintiffs are entitled to ignore the said partition.
There is no separate relief sought for by the plaintiffs. Therefore, to
cancel the said document, setting aside the partition deed need not be
required and the points were answered on the above reasonings.
Page No:15/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
21. The purchaser / 7th defendant submitted that he had no notice
about the proceedings and the 7th defendant filed written statement
stating that he was one of the sharers of the suit properties. However,
the purchaser contended that the appellants and the defendants 2 and 3
are colluding and filed the suit against the bonafide purchaser. But there
is no such collusion between the appellants and the vendor of the 7 th
defendant. At the most, they are entitled for equal share of the allotment
of the property of the sharers of their vendors. Thus, the issue was
answered holding defendants 7 to 13 have no right to resist the partition
and allotted 4/21 share in favour of the appellants each and the 1 st
appellate Judge set aside the findings of the trial Judge.
22. The 1st appellate Judge disposed of the 1st appeal in the year
2006 by allowing the appeal filed by the plaintiffs. Aggrieved by the
reversal findings of the 1st appellate Judge, the defendants filed
S.A.No.966 of 2021.
23. Based on the 1st appellate court findings, the 2nd appellant
therein filed I.A.8080 of 2008 in O.S.No.1421 of 1991 and prayed for
Page No:16/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
passing of the final decree based upon the preliminary decree. This
application was objected by the 2nd and 4th defendants viz., Selvarajan
and Saradambal stating that challenging the 1 st appellate court findings,
they have taken steps to prefer Second Appeal. Besides some of the
portion also sold to 3rd parties based upon partition deed. In such
circumstances, appointment of the Advocate Commissioner for division
of the property is not sustainable. One of the purchasers raised
objection stating that as against the findings of the 1 st appellate court,
they filed Second Appeal and Diary No.81261/2007 was assigned but
no stay with regard to final decree proceedings. In the mean while,
Advocate Commissioner was appointed and he visited the property
with the help of Surveyor. During his visit, some of the respondents
appeared; some of the respondents not appeared.
24. On considering the Commissioner's report, the trial Judge
held that there is no stay with regard to the final decree proceedings
based on the valuation report submitted by the Advocate Commissioner
with regard to the value of the A schedule property. But considering the
valuation, the trial Judge held that the plaintiff was allotted with
Page No:17/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
1,84,00,880/- and in respect of the 2nd plaintiff-Kumari, considering the
fact that the plaintiff was allotted 1,84,00,880/- was allotted.
Considering that she was residing in 3rd item of the A schedule property,
in respect of 2nd plaintiff Kumari 1,36,23,920/- amount was awarded
considering the fact that she was residing in 1 st item of A schedule
property. Based on the Commissioner's report, the petitioner in
I.A.No.8080 of 2008 - Kumari was allotted with share. Accordingly
final decree was passed. Commissioner report was marked as Ex.C.1 to
Ex.C.3.
25. Aggrieved by the final decree proceedings, defendants 9 to 13
filed A.S.201 of 2011 before the IV Additioanl Judge, City Civil Court,
Chennai. Along with the said first appeal, 3 CMPs were filed. These
CMPs were filed by the plaintiffs in CMP.Nos.970, 2320 and 73 of
2011 to receive the documents as listed in the petition affidavit and to
receive the additional documents as listed in the petition affidavit as
additional evidence.
26. The petitioners in the CMP prayed to receive the additional
documents related to the valuation made by one of her brothers made
Page No:18/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
alienation which took place on 18.12.1991 pending suit along with
encumbrance certificate and another document viz., deed of
conveyance executed by her brother and sisters including the 3 rd party
purchasers pending suit. Those documents were objected by the
respondents in that application stating that at the appellate stage, those
documents are not relevant nor any reason assigned for not filing at the
initial stage. Thus the documents are not necessary.
27. Considering both sides submission, the 1st appellate Judge has
held that the document sought to receive as additional document dated
17.12.2004 is prior to the date of the disposal of suit in O.S.No.1421 of
1991. Inspite of ample opportunity was available with them, they have
not produced the said documents and only at the stage of the appeal,
filed the said applications to produce those documents, as such is
unacceptable and accordingly, dismissed the CMPs.
28. The appeal preferred by the purchaser in respect of passing of
the final decree in A.S.No.201 of 2011 is concerned, the 1 st Appellate
Judge has held that though the suit was dismissed by the trial Judge,
A.S.No.79 of 1997 was filed and the same was allowed allotting 4/21
Page No:19/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
shares to the appellants/plaintiffs and directed the parties to file
separate petition for appointment of Advocate Commissioner and to file
report. Hence the petitioner filed separate application. Based on that,
the Commissioner visited the property and measured and submitted the
report. Even at that period, the Second Appeal was not taken on file.
The Advocate Commissioner also given valuation of the suit property.
The report of the Advocate Commissioner was objected by the
purchasers stating that the Commissioner report referred about the
ownership of the property which was beyond the scope of the warrant.
Therefore, without any basis, receiving the Advocate Commissioner
report who made division of the property and valued the same without
proper identification is not acceptable. Therefore the mode of division
suggested by the Commissioner is illegal and not acceptable one and no
share was allotted to the 3rd party purchasers nor to their vendors. Once
division was equitable in law and the Advocate Commissioner filed
report dividing the suit property to all the sharers, the 1 st appellate court
held that in respect of the reception of the documents, no proper reason
was assigned. Therefore the findings of the appellate Judge is accepted
in respect of the passing of the final decree.
Page No:20/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
29. The 1st appellate Judge has held that the trial court after due
enquiry, appointed the Advocate Commissioner and some of the
respondents appeared before the trial court and filed the detailed
counter affidavit where they have stated that they have preferred
Second Appeal but only Diary Number was furnished nor any stay was
granted in respect of the passing of the final decree. Besides, some
purchasers purchased part of the suit property pending original suit for
partition preferred in O.S.No.2001 of 1982 before the Sub Court,
Chengalpet. Later it was transferred on the point of jurisdiction before
Sub Court, Poonamallee in O.S.No.182 of 2006 and thereafter it was
transferred to City Civil Court and renumbered as O.S.No.1421 of 1991
and the final decree application was duly considered by the trial Judge.
The Advocate Commissioner inspected the property in the presence of
the parties by giving due notice and the Commissioner also valued the
suit property by due notification from the concerned Sub Registrars
Offices, the guideline as well as the market value of the properties. The
interim report of the Commissioner in Ex.C.1 clearly indicate that the
Commissioner identified the suit property and located the suit
properties with relevant records. Even purchasers as well as aggrieved
Page No:21/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
respondents have not agitated in their counter that they have not
received notice. Apart from that, after filing report of the Advocate
Commissioner viz., Ex.C.1, Ex.C.2 and Ex.C.3, the trial court
adjudicated the matter on various dates. The aggrieved party has not
filed any objections.
30. On considering and verification of the records, the 1 st
Appellate Judge has held that the purchasers who are the pendente lite
purchasers who purchased a portion of the share of the suit property
from other owners, are not entitled to claim their entitlement of equity
in respect of the suit property as they are subsequent purchasers. As
such the appeal was dismissed on the ground of lis pendens.
31. The Commissioner warrant as well as the report of the
Commissioner was duly placed before the trial court. It was not
agitated by the contesting respondents at that time. Therefore, after
careful analysis of the Commissioner report as well as hearing the
parties, the trial Judge has rightly passed the final decree. Therefore the
passing of the final decree in I.A.No.8080 of 2008 is confirmed and
accordingly, the appeal in A.S.No.201 of 2011 was dismissed.
Page No:22/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
32. Aggrieved by the said findings rendered in A.S.No.201 of
2011, Second Appeal No.947 of 2022 has been preferred by the 6th
defendant T.Kumari by raising the following grounds :1. The Court below ought to have dismissed the final decree as
the appellants had preferred a second appeal against the preliminary
decree.
2. The Addl City Civil Judge failed to consider that the 1 st
respondent had filed three petitions to receive additional documents in
the appeal against the final decree only to support the statements made
in the Advocate Commissioner report and the same will clearly prove
that the report of the Advocate Commissioner is not supported by
material evidence. The Learned Addl. City Civil Judge dismissed the
petitions for receiving additional documents and thus the Advocate
Commissioner report is not supported by any data or documents
regarding his conclusion. Hence, the report of the Advocate
commissioner to be scrapped.
3. The courts below failed to consider that the description of the
suit properties and its physical features stated in the advocate
Commissioner Report are incorrect.
4. The courts below failed to consider that the Advocate
Commissioner had in his report referred about the possession of the
property and the ownership of the property, which was beyond the
scope of his warrant.
5. The courts below ought to have rejected the report of the
advocate commissioner on the sole ground that the commissioner
without any basis or reasoning had made division of properties and
valued the same.
6. The courts below failed to consider that the Advocate
Page No:23/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
Commissioner identifying that suit items 2,5,6 and 7 are alone is
divisible is incorrect and the divisions suggested by the Advocate
commissioner
are
also
inequitable
and
unjust.
7. The courts below failed to consider the possession of the
appellants in the suit schedule property and also the improvements
made by them in the suit property while passing the final decree.
8. The Additional City Civil Judge failed to consider that other
respondents filed their counter after the filing of preliminary report by
the Advocate Commissioner raised various objections but the same was
conveniently omitted to be considered by the courts below.
9. The Additional City Civil Judge failed to consider that even in
the preliminary report the Advocate commissioner has not stated
anything about the issuance of notice to the parties for the inspection of
properties.
10. The Addl City Civil erred in holding that the Advocate
Commissioner arrived at the value of the properties by due notification
from the Sub registrar office, the guideline value and market value is
made without any basis. The Addl City Civil Judge findings are made
without perusing the documents properly, hence the same is erroneous
and
liable
to
be
set
aside.
11. The Addl City Civil Judge finding that the non filing of
objections to the Advocate commissioner disentitles the appellants to
question the same is unsustainable as the appellants counsel raised all
the objection at the time of enquiry, but the same was not considered by
the trial court, hence the Addl City Civil Judge ought to have
considered
the
objections.
12. The Addl City Civil Judge finding that the appellants are not
the bonafide purchasers as they had purchased the property pending the
suit is perverse and unwarranted.
13. The Addl City Civil Judge failed to consider that the
Page No:24/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
appellants are the defendants in the suit and they are contesting the
preliminary decree proceedings. As the appellants were the purchasers
of one of the suit schedule properties from the sharer, they are stepping
into the shoes of the sharer and they have all the rights as the sharers
and hence they are entitled to raise all objections.
14. The Addl City Civil Judge finding that the appellants who are
the pendent lite purchasers and they have to work out their remedy
separately against their vendor is highly erroneous and against the well
settled principles of law.
15. The Addl City Civil Judge finding that the claim of the
appellants are hit by the principles of lis pendens and they are not
entitled to claim equity as they purchased the suit property pending suit
is unsustainable in law and liable to be set aside.
33. The Second Appeal No.947 of 2022 was admitted on the
following substantial questions of law:-
1. Whether the Courts below have failed to adhere to the principles of
natural justice and fair play in considering the correctness of the
valuation furnished in the commissioner’s report for allotment of shares
in accordance with the preliminary decree?
2. Whether the First Appellate Court, being the final court of appeal on
facts has failed to exercise its jurisdiction to consider the objections
raised by the appellants on the ground that they were not given
Page No:25/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
reasonable opportunity to file their objections and raise their objections
regarding the mode of division suggested by the Advocate
Commissioner in his report?”
34. Second Appeal No.966 of 2021 has been filed as against the
findings of the 1st Appellate Judge passed in A.S.No.79 of 1997. The
defendants 9 to 13 preferred appeal on the following grounds:1. The Learned First Additional Judge erred in granting a decree for
partition when admittedly the parties had already stood divided as
evidenced by the registered deed of partition marked as Ex.B12 and the
plaintiffs had admitted the due execution and registration of the said
deed of partition, and the plaintiffs had not sought to set aside the same
and reopen the partition.
2. The Learned First Additional Judge failed to appreciate that the
plaintiffs only contention was that the defendants 2 to 5 had agreed to
compensate them by way of owelty to equalize their shares and that the
sum agreed was Rs.50,000/- each to the daughters and that the
defendants failed to pay the said sum and hence sued for partition. The
learned First Additional Judge did not note that the only remedy of the
plaintiffs was only to sue for the owelty amount and having admitted
the execution and registration of the deed of partition it cannot be
reopened unless the plaintiffs seek to set it aside the same in
accordance with law.
3. The Learned First Additional Judge reasoning that the shares were
unequal on the face of the document and that the suit for partition was
maintainable as the deed of partition was vitiated by fraud is highly
perverse as it goes beyond the pleadings of the plaintiffs in the suit.
4. The learned First Additional Judge failed to see that the plaitniffs had
Page No:26/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
never alleged that they are forced to sign the deed of partition or that
they had not appeared before the Sub-Registrar for admitting execution
of the document and admittedly the document was registered only in
the presence of the plaintiffs. In such circumstances, it was not open to
the plaintiffs to file another suit for partition without reopening the
earlier one in accordance with law.
5. The Learned First Additional Judge committed a grave error in
holding that the partition deed was registered contrary to the provisions
of the Registration Act and hence void.
6. The Learned First Additional Judge had not appreciated the fact that
the plaintiffs had no where alleged in the plaint that they had not signed
the document and that they were not party to the document presented to
the registrar for registration on 3.9.79, even if the date of the document
had been corrected as alleged it is always open to the parties to the
document to alter the date of execution by mutual consent and present
it for registration. The plaintiffs having admitted the execution of the
document on the date mentioned in the said document before the SubRegistrar, the plaintiffs are estopped from disputing the date of
execution of the said document.
7. The Learned First Additional Judge ought to have rejected the
petition for additional evidence as the documents produced by the
plaintiffs cannot be accepted for its face value and it had to be proved
by oral evidence and for which there had been no pleading or oral
evidence let in at the time of trial.
8. The Learned First Additional Judge reasoning that the deed of
partition need not be set aside as the original document was not
produced before court is unknown to law and precedents.
9. The plaintiffs having come forward with a plea that there was an
earlier partition evidence by a registered document ought to have filed
atleast a certified copy of the same to prove their case. On the contrary
the plaintiffs relied only on the certified copy of the document filed by
the defendants as Ex.B.12. The Learned First Additional Judge had
shifted the burden of proof wrongly on the defendants on the ground
Page No:27/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
that in a suit for partition all are plaintiffs and all are defendants.
10. The conclusion of the Learned First Additional Judge that the deed
of partition though was presented for registration on 3.9.79 was
registered only after the institution of the suit by the plaintiffs and since
no document was available for cancellation the plaintiffs need seek for
cancellation of the same is fallacious.
The Second Appeal No.966 of 2021 was admitted on the following
substantial questions of law:1. Whether the learned First Additional Judge was right in decreeing
the suit for partition when the plaintiffs had not sought for any relief to
set aside the earlier registered deed of partition dated 03.09.1979 and
when the plaintiffs hence stood admitted divided?
2. Whether the learned First Additional Judge was right in declaring the
deed of partition dated 03.09.1979 void for the reason that the same
was presented in violation of Section 23 and 25 of the Registration Act
when the plaintiffs were themselves party to the registration of the said
document?
3.Whether the learned First Additional Judge was right in allowing the
application for additional evidence without being satisfied of the
requirements under law for the same and when there was no pleading
or evidence in support of the additional documents?
35. By way of reply, the learned counsel for the respondents 1 and 2
submits that the plaintiff and the defendants 1 to 6 are entitled to 1/7 th share
in the suit properties which belong to Rajagopala Mudaliar as the legal heir
of the property, but the defendants 2 and 3 who are the male members of the
family ignoring all the other family members executed the partition deed in
Page No:28/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
the year 1977. Subsequently material alterations were made as if it was
executed in the year 1979. Meagre share was given worth about Rs.8000/and property was received in a remote place. However, in respect of the
defendants 2 and 3 , their properties are situated in the heart of the City and
it was partitioned and the family members were not permitted to assess the
property value. At that time, having done the valuation in the year 1982, one
of the sisters filed suit for partition who alleged the ulterior motive of D2
and D3; that apart, they also undervalued the property. On the other hand,
they sold the property to the 2nd wife and given share to her daughter and
two sons and and her brother family also colluded with other members by
way of partition. The trial Judge, without considering all the facts,
erroneously dismissed the suit as if the partition deed was acted upon. But
the 1st appellate Judge has rightly held that partition deed itself is void one
and it was not properly executed and registered by the contesting defendants
and the shares allotted to the plaintiff is also inequal in nature. The
defendants 2 and 3 also not established that the partition was held with
consent of all the parties and as such, rightly held that the document is void
and non-est in law. Accordingly, directed for equal partition of suit
properties, however dismissed the prayer for reopening of the partition deed
and set aside the findings of the trial Judge by allowing the appeal in part in
granting the decree by allotting 4/21 share on the death of the 1 st defendant
Page No:29/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
pending proceedings. Accordingly, the preliminary decree was passed and
also held that the purchase made by the third party purchasers pending suit
proceedings would not bind the plaintiffs as they purchased the portion of
the suit property. The defendants 7 to 9 are purchasers and it would not bind
the plaintiff. The learned counsel submitted that the order passed by the 1 st
appellate Judge is sustainable and the appeal was rightly allowed and there is
no substantial question of law merit acceptance. The learned counsel for the
plaintiff/respondents 1 and 2 in S.A.No.966 of 2021 prayed to dismiss both
the second appeals as devoid of merits.
36. Considering both side submissions, it is an admitted fact that the
original plaintiff and the defendants for the sake of convenience, the parties
are denoted as per the ranking before the trial court.
37. Defendants 1 to 6 and the plaintiff are the legal heirs of
Rajagopala Mudaliar who died in the year 1977 leaving behind those
legal heirs in respect of the self acquired properties suit schedule A and
B properties. According to the plaintiff, the male members of the family
D2 and D3 ignoring the other family members arranged a partition but
it is very much unequal in nature. Immediately after the death of the
Page No:30/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
father, the document was altered materially altered as 1979. In that
partition deed, equal share was not allotted to the plaintiff. But when
she demanded her share, it was assured by the defendants 2 and 3 that
she will be given due amounts in future. She raised objections. The
brothers assurance that she will be compensated in future. But they
have not done so. On the other hand, they grabbed the property having
more value and allotted lesser value property to her. So the plaintiff
prayed for reopening of the allotment and sought 1/7th share in the
property by way of passing preliminary decree.
38. On the side of the defendants, defendants 2 to 5 filed written
statement stating that 1st defendant is the mother of the plaintiff as well
as the 2nd wife of Rajagopala Mudaliar and claiming that by selling her
jewels she purchased some of the house sites and settled the same in
favour of her daughter and two sons. The 1 st defendant also purchased
some property which is her absolute property and in respect of which
other defendants has no right and title and she settled such properties in
respect of other brothers. In respect of the property purchased by the 1 st
defendant, the same is not under dispute.
Page No:31/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Though the 2 nd and 3rd
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
defendants contended that during the life time of Rajagopala Mudaliar
the 1st defendant was given with other properties but all those properties
were absolute properties of the 1st defendant and there is no dispute and
those properties were absolute properties of the 1 st defendant. The
defendants 2 and 3 contested the case stating that the plaintiff was
given in marriage in a grand manner during the life time of the father.
Further it is stated that loan was taken by the father for family purpose
and they settled it and the plaintiff is no way connected with the said
family property.
39. Admittedly, the property belongs to Rajagopala Mudaliar and
it is a valuable immovable property; the partition deed relied on by the
defendants 2 and 3 was marked as Ex.B.12 as only certified copy of the
document and not only original partition deed. On a bare perusal of the
said document, it would show that equal share was not allotted to the
plaintiff and other female members.
40. On a bare perusal of Ex.B.12, it reflects that valuable
property were allotted to male members of the family viz., D2 and D3
Page No:32/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
and only very meagre extent of amount Rs.8000/- was given to the
plaintiff and one of the sisters Sarathambal who is also sailing with that
of the plaintiff. She has not raised any objection for the said division of
properties. Therefore, even assuming that partition deed was executed
on the face of it, it reflects that the properties are divided in inequal
manner. However, the 2nd and 3rd defendant contended that it was due
to liability was incurred by them due to the business from the business
conducted by the deceased father Rajagopala Mudaliar. However,
certain items of the property were allotted to them I.e, factory was sold
and after satisfying the liability it was given and thereby they
convinced the plaintiff that she given in marriage in a grand manner
and to that effect the objection raised was subdued and settled the
issues. Further the 2nd defendant was allotted with more property
because he was not well settled and he was economically and
educationally backward when compared to other sharers who settled in
their life. But the fact is all the valuable properties are taken away by
male members and female members were allotted less in share and it is
disproportionate and that they also very much well settled. No evidence
was produced before the trial court that they are economically
Page No:33/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
backward. Though the defendants 2 and 3 contended that other liability
of the family that in respect of factory and the workers retrenchment,
the workers were paid to the extent of Rs.21,000/- and thereafter the
factory was assigned to them and the female members of the family
was not at all not concerned with the burden of liability. Considering
the fact that they took the business along with liability so that cannot be
equated with the plaintiff’s share in the property.
41. Above all, defendants 2 and 3 were not able to submit any
evidence to prove the liability and no evidence whatsoever produced
before the trial court. Even as per their submission, even before the
Panchayat, property was divided already; however no individual
Panchayatdar was examined to prove the same. When the plaintiff
alleged that under misrepresentation, consent was obtained and
assurance was given that in the future she will be compensated and in
this regard burden is heavily on the defendant to prove the family
arrangement as well as the registered partition about the division of the
property, but no individual witness was examined on their side.
Therefore, the defendants miserably failed to establish that the family
Page No:34/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
arrangement was held before the division of the property in the
presence of Panchayat as stated in the written statement. On the other
hand, the plaintiff proved that the alleged partition said to be of the year
1979 was an inequal partition. It is also relevant that the said partition
deed was registered only in the month of November 1982, but the suit
was filed on October 1982. Therefore, on the date of filing of the suit,
there is no partition deed as alleged by the defendants 2 and 3.
Therefore, necessity not arose for the plaintiff to declare the partition
deed as null and void since no document was registered on the date of
the filing of the suit. Moreover the facts also reveals that the partition
deed was registered inspite of the notice, however, original partition
deed was not produced by the defendants 1 to 3 but a copy of the said
partition deed was only produced which shows that with malafide
intention, the document was not produced. Moreover the document was
registered only on 24.11.1982, however, there is a correction with
regard to the date of the execution i.e. 03.09.1977. With regard to the
execution also, there is contrary views that is it is mentioned as
03.09.1979 but in one place, it is shown as 1977 which reflects the
alleged partition deed was not properly executed. Therefore, it is seen
Page No:35/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
that the partition deed was not properly executed as per the Registration
Act. It is seen that the alleged partition deed has not been registered on
03.09.1979 and also it was not registered within 4 months from the date
of the presentation indeed it was only during the year 1982 near about 3
years later, that after filing of the suit which itself shows that with
malafide intention of the male members to grab the entire share of the
property, ignoring share of the plaintiff. Therefore, the said document is
a void document. To that effect, the 1st appellate Judge rightly
concluded and this court is not inclined to interfere with the said
findings.
42. Learned counsel appearing for the appellants submits that
though Section 4 of the Registration Act provides for four months for
presentation, but no time limit is fixed for registration and mere bar in
registration will not make the document ineffective. In this connection,
it is useful to refer the authority relied on by the learned Senior counsel
appearing for the plaintiff in the decision reported in 2011 (2) MWN
(civil) 65 G.Muthalu Reddiar Vs. 1. Srinivasan Padayatchi (died) 2.
Lakshmiammal and others, wherein, in the Headnote, it is held as
Page No:36/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
under:“Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908), Section 23 – Sale
Deed executed in 1981 – Presented for registration on
same day – Document registered in 1986 – Though
Section provides four months’ time for presentation, it
does not fix time limit for actual registration – Mere
delay in registration does not make document ineffective
– sale, held, valid. “
43. The above said proposition will not apply to the facts of the
present case for the reason that the original document was not produced
by the defendants 2 and 3; even the certified copy itself revealed the
year 1977 as well as 1979 and the same was only material alteration.
According to the plaintiff, it was subsequently registered by defendants
2 and 3. Even assuming that it was executed on 1979, it was presented
for registration only after filing of the suit; there is delay of 3 years for
registration of the document and that the document was not presented
for registration immediately nor assigned any reason why it was
registered after filing of the suit and there is inordinate delay which
Page No:37/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
reflects that there was malafide intention in defeating the lawful claim
and rights of the plaintiff. Therefore, the authority cited will not apply
to the facts of the present case. Hence the finding of the 1 st appellate
Judge that Ex.B.12 is valid in law is well reasoned one and require no
interference. Accordingly, Substantial question of law No.2 is answered
accordingly.
44. Since the document itself is void in nature and also not
registered on the date of the filing of the suit, there is no necessity to
cancel the partition deed as it was void and non est in nature and not
binding the plaintiff. Therefore, the 1st Appellate Judge rightly held
that the alleged partition deed dated 03.09.1979 would not bind the
plaintiff nor it requires the cancellation. No interference to that effect is
called for in this Second Appeal. The substantial question of law is
answered accordingly.
45. Pending First Appeal, the plaintiff/appellant filed CMP to
receive the additional document which shows that exchange of
deliberations between the parties as well the sale deed executed in
Page No:38/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
favour of the 7th defendant and exchange of notice for production of
original partition deed Ex.B.12 and for admission of copy of the letter
dated 20.05.1995 issued by D2 to D3 suggesting payment of
compensation to the appellants/plaintiffs were found necessary as it
covers the facts of the case and the said documents were received by
the 1st appellate Judge as the 1st appellate court is continuity of the suit
proceedings and the said finding of the First Appellate Judge does not
require any interference. Accordingly, Substantial question of Law
No.3 is answered accordingly.
46. Therefore, S.A.No.966 of 2021 is dismissed. The finding of
the 1st appellate Judge is confirmed.
47. In respect of the findings of the final decree passed in
I.A.8080 of 2008 in O.S.No.1421 of 1991 , it reveals that some of the
respondents have not accompanied the Advocate Commissioner at the
time of the visit. The contention of the learned counsel for the
appellants is that as on date, the value of the property is increased. It
would reveal that some portion of the property was also purchased by
Page No:39/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
the purchasers. In the share allotment to the vendor, purchasers entitle
to claim equity. But the trial court has failed to apply the law of
equitable relief as purchase were made in lis pendens, they bound to
workout their remedy in the share allotted to the vendor. However, the
learned counsel for the appellants submits that the final decree passed
in I.A.No.8080 of 2008 is to be set aside and prayed to allow the
Second Appeal No.947 of 2012.
48. Considering the fact that the nature of the suit is one of
partition, parties are directed to approach the trial court for passing of
the final decree. Since some of the respondents accompanied the
Advocate Commissioner and the plaintiff and her sister filed
application for passing of the final decree application, the final decree
was passed on 01.04.2010. Therefore, the final decree passed by the
trial Judge in I.A.No.8080 of 2008 in O.S.No.1421 of 1991 needs no
interference. S.A.No.947 of 2012 is dismissed. The other sharers are
concerned, they shall work out their remedy before the trial court by
paying necessary court fee. Pendente lite purchasers shall work out
their remedy with their vendors under law and on equity in the
remaining share of the properties.
Page No:40/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
49. Accordingly, both Second Appeals are dismissed. The
findings of the First Appellate Court is confirmed. Considering the
relationship between the parties, the parties shall bear their own costs.
02.06.2026
Index:Yes/No
Internet:Yes/No
Speaking order: Non-speaking order
nvsri
Page No:41/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
To
1. The IV Additional Judge, City Civil Judge, Chennai.
2. The II Assistant Judge, City Civil Judge, Chennai.
3. The I Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai.
3.The Section Officer, V.R.Section, High Court, Madras.
Page No:42/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.Nos.966 of 2021
and 947 of 2022
T.V.THAMILSELVI, J.
nvsri
S.A. Nos.947 of 2012
and 966 of 2021
02.06.2024
Page No:43/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review