The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. In the light of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the preventive detention of the petitioner is held to be illegal which warrants quashment of detention Order No. DMS/PSA/15/2025 dated 03.05.2025 passed by respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar read with consequent approval/confirmation/ extension order from the end of the Government.
23. The petitioner is, thus, ordered to be restored to his personal liberty by his release from the concerned jail for which the Superintendent concerned Jail to enlarge the petitioner free to his personal liberty.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 29.01.2026
Pronounced on:
24.02.2026
Uploaded on: 24.02.2026
HCP No.97/2025
…Petitioner(s)
Muzaffar Farooq Mir
Through:
Mrs. Sania Ghulam, Advocate.
Vs.
UT of J&K and Ors.
Through:
...Respondent(s)
Mr. Jahingir Dar, GA.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
Judgment
1. This is a writ of habeas corpus which came to be
preferred
on
14.05.2025
by
the
petitioner-
Muzaffar Farooq Mir (aged 36 years) a resident of
Shahzadpora
Dangerpora,
Tehsil
B.K
Pora,
District Badgam acting through his father- Farooq
Ahmad Mir.
2. The petitioner is undergoing detention custody
with effect from 05.05.2025 being detained in
District Jail, Jammu.
3. The detention of the petitioner came to be ordered
by
the respondent
Srinagar
in
No.2- District
terms
No.DMS/PSA/15/2025
of
dated
Magistrate
an
Order
03.05.2025,
purportedly acting under section 8 of the Jammu
& Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978, by reckoning
that the petitioner’s state of personal liberty is
prejudicial to the maintenance of security of the
State, thus, warranting its curtailment.
4. A case for preventive detention custody of the
petitioner
was
actually
mooted
by
Senior
Superintendent of Police (SSP) Srinagar, who vide
his communication No. LGL/Det/2025/1422629 dated 29.04.2025 submitted a dossier and
other connected documents to the respondent
No.2-
District
projecting
the
Magistrate
alleged
Srinagar,
thereby
objectionable
and
prejudicial state of activities of the petitioner, in
the face of which the security of State was likely
to be prejudiced.
5. For the purpose of passing the detention order
No. DMS/PSA/15/2025 dated 03.05.2025, the
respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar, by
reading of the dossier as a foundational material,
drew grounds of detention for drawing purported
subjective satisfaction for ordering the preventive
detention of the petitioner.
6. In the grounds of detention so formulated, the
respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar
refers that an extremist ideology has a strong
hold on the petitioner and that he is in constant
touch with some people who encouraged him to
engage in anti-national activities on the basis of
which the petitioner got motivated and indulged
in anti-national activities by inciting the Public
particularly the young people of the area and the
surrounding areas to engage them in illegal
activities. The petitioner within a short span of
time is said to have become an incorrigible antinational element of the area.
7. Drawing further from the dossier reference of the
Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP) Srinagar,
the respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar,
refers the petitioner to be a hardcore active entity
in the area posing threat to the locality including
educational institutions, business establishments
and Government offices and by the given ideology
of the petitioner the return of normalcy to the
Kashmir
valley
was
reckoned
to be getting
resisted and that there was a consistent attempt
by the ideology of the petitioner to destabilize the
Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir through
unlawful activities.
8. The petitioner is said to have come into contact
with active terrorists and OGWs of banned outfit
LeT, motivating the petitioner to work for the
outfit as an over ground worker for providing
logistic support. The petitioner is alleged to have
been sharing all sensitive information regarding
moment of Police and Security Forces in the area.
9. By reference to FIR No.185/2021 of Police
Station Saddar for alleged commission of offences
under section 307-IPC, 13/38 UAPA, 7/27
A.Act, the petitioner is said to have been arrested
and involved in the case to be bailed out later on,
but still remaining bent upon the ways of antinational and unlawful activities.
10.
In the grounds of detention, the petitioner’s
previous preventive detention is also referred to
build
up
case
for
second
time
preventive
detention of the petitioner taking place by virtue
of the detention Order No. DMS/PSA/15/2025
dated 03.05.2025.
11.
In the name of latest adverse reference to the
petitioner, Patrol Book entries and GD report of
Police Station, Nowgham came to be cited in the
grounds of detention by the respondent No.2District Magistrate Srinagar. Patrol Book entry
dated
26.04.2025
and
GD
report
also
of
26.04.2025 came to be cited before coming to
the final part of the grounds of detention that
the alleged state of activities of the petitioner are
reckoned to be adverse so far as maintenance
of public order is concerned, but finally the
activities are reckoned to be highly prejudicial
to the security of the State and, therefore,
warranting passing of detention order against
him.
12.
With passing of preventive detention order
No. DMS/PSA/15/2025, dated 03.05.2025 the
petitioner came to be arrested on 05.05.2025
and handed over to the custody of the District
Jail, Jammu.
13.
Within
ten
days
of
his
detention,
the
institution of the present writ petition by the
petitioner came to take place on 14.05.2025.
14.
Following the purported approval by the
Government of UT of J&K of the detention order
No. DMS/PSA/15/2025, the Advisory Board’s
opinion is said to have been solicited by the
Government upon getting which by virtue of a
Government Order No. Home/PB-V/1080/2025
dated 02.06.2025, the preventive detention of the
petitioner was confirmed to last for periodic
duration/s of detention.
15.
The
petitioner
in
his
writ
petition
has
assailed the exercise of jurisdiction at the end of
the
Senior
Superintendent
of
Police
(SSP),
Srinagar followed by the respondent No.2- District
Magistrate, Srinagar and lastly on the part of the
Home Department, Government of Jammu and
Kashmir, UT of J&K, on the basis of the grounds
as set out in paragraph- 6 (a to n).
16.
The counter affidavit to the writ petition
came to be filed on 04.08.2025 by Mr. Akshay
Labroo (IAS)-District Magistrate Srinagar. The
averments in the counter affidavit follow the
script of the grounds of detention without any
shade of difference. The counter affidavit is
unaccompanied with any annexure whatsoever as
if filing of a counter affidavit in a habeas corpus
writ petition bears no sense of responsibility on
the part of the detaining authority to support the
averments
in
the
counter
affidavit
with
corresponding serve of documents therewith.
17.
This manner of filing of counter affidavit is
meant to be a risk to
stay on the side of
preventive detention order making authority when
defending the detention order in a constitutional
court of law as is in the present case and,
therefore,
the
respondents
cannot
expect
a
constitutional court to extend any courtesy and
concession in favour of UT of Jammu and
Kashmir and District Magistrate concerned in
overlooking the casualness in the matter of filing
counter affidavit.
18.
The
preventive
detention
order
of
the
petitioner is fundamentally flawed and that is by
the state of application of mind on the part of the
respondent No.2- District Magistrate, Srinagar in
scripting and signing the very detention order
reflecting the pedantic level indulgence on the
part of the respondent No.2- District Magistrate,
Srinagar.
19.
In
the
grounds
of
detention,
previous
detention of the petitioner has been referred. The
respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar
refers to the previous detention of the petitioner
by drawing the reference to the order as follow:
“Order
No.
DMS/PSA/151/2022
dated
15.11.2024”. If the respondent No.2- District
Magistrate Srinagar is not in a position to re-read
the draft of his grounds of detention to come
across with a patent error of mention of date of
previous detention order of the petitioner then the
application of mind of the respondent No.2District
Magistrate,
Srinagar
is
not
worth
trusting that in passing second time detention
order of the petitioner due application of mind
was taking place from his end. Previous detention
order
of
the
petitioner
was
“Order
No.
DMS/PSA?151/2022 dated 15.11.2022”.
20.
What is a casual for the District Magistrate
Srinagar is a causality to the fundamental right of
the personal liberty of the petitioner which is
further reflected on the grounds that by reckoning
the alleged activities of the petitioner being
adverse of the Government to the maintenance of
public order, the quantum leap to order the
detention of the petitioner by reference to the
same activity being prejudicial to the security of
the State is reflective of sense of loss of legal
distinction at the end of the respondent No.2District Magistrate Srinagar.
21.
Nothing can be more absurd than the
inherent
contradiction
so
obtaining
in
the
grounds of the detention formulated by the
respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar on
the basis of which the preventive detention order
came to be passed against the petitioner
22.
In the light of the aforesaid facts and
circumstances, the preventive detention of the
petitioner is held to be illegal which warrants
quashment
of
detention
Order
No.
DMS/PSA/15/2025 dated 03.05.2025 passed
by respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar
read
with
consequent
approval/confirmation/
extension order from the end of the Government.
23.
The petitioner is, thus, ordered to be restored
to his personal liberty by his release from the
concerned jail for which the Superintendent
concerned Jail to enlarge the petitioner free to his
personal liberty.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
24.02.2026
“Opinder”
Whether the judgment is speaking:
Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable:
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review