Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 7
Reg. Cause List
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP 269/2025
… Petitioner(s)
MUZAFER AHMAD SHEIKH
Through:
Mr. M. Ashraf Malik, Advocate
Vs.
UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND
ORS.
...Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Ilayas Laway, GA
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JAVED IQBAL WANI, JUDGE
ORDER
19.02.2026
1. The petitioner in the instant petition filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution has sought quashment of Detention Order No.
13/DMA/PSA/DET/2025 dated 26.04.2025 (for short “the impugned
order”) passed by respondent No. 2 (herein for that “the detaining
authority”) under and in terms of the provisions of J&K Public Safety
Act, 1978 ( for short the Act of 1978).
2. The petitioner has challenged the impugned order on multiple grounds
urged in the petition.
3. Counter affidavit has been filed to the petition opposing the same on
the premise that the detention of the petitioner came to be ordered on
the basis of dossier and other material furnished to the detaining
authority by the sponsoring agency and that the detaining authority
ordered the preventive detention of the petitioner after fulfilling all
statutory requirements and following Constitutional guarantees, while
stating further that the order of detention came to be executed upon
the petitioner on 28.04.2025 and, accordingly, the grounds of
detention as well as the warrant of detention were read over and
explained to him in the language he fully understood in lieu whereof,
he, the petitioner subscribed his signatures thereof and that the
petitioner was also informed that he can make a representation against
his detention to the detaining authority or to the Government and that
the detention case of the petitioner was placed before the Advisory
Board which opined in favour of the detention of the petitioner and
consequently the order of detention came to be confirmed by the
Government vide order dated 03.06.2025.
(A)
Rejoinder affidavit has also been filed by the
petitioner to the counter affidavit filed by the respondents,
stating therein that the impugned order has been passed
purportedly in view of the alleged involvement of the petitioner
in three criminal cases being FIR Nos. 92/2016, and 98/2016
Registered with Police Station, Dooru and FIR No. 155/2017
registered with Police Station Banihal and that post release in
the said FIR’s, no activity alleged to be prejudicial to the
security of the State or public order has been attributed to the
petitioner thereby there is no live link qua the FIRs in question
being remote in point of time and the impugned order.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
4. Notwithstanding multiple grounds of challenge urged by the petitioner
against the impugned order, the counsel for the petitioner confined the
challenge against the impugned order primarily to the ground that the
impugned order owes its origin to the alleged involvement of the
petitioner in three FIR’s which are remote in point of time having no
live link with the impugned order as no activity muchless either
prejudicial to the security of the State or public order has been
attributed to the petitioner after the registration of the said FIRs
thereby rendering the impugned order legally invalid.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would further contend that a
representation against the impugned order came to be submitted by
the petitioner on 28.05.2025, which, however, came to be decided by
the respondents belatedly on 12.08.2025, without explaining delay in
deciding the same thereof, therefore, vitiates the impugned order.
5. On the contrary, the learned counsel for the respondents, would
defend the impugned order and while opposing the aforesaid
submissions of the counsel for the petitioner would contend that the
sponsoring agency after noticing the activities of the petitioner having
been found to be prejudicial to the security of the State, post release of
the petitioner in the aforesaid FIRs, the detaining authority validly
found it imperative to detain the petitioner under preventive law.
Learned counsel would further submit that the delay occurred
in disposal of the representation on account of seeking of necessary
comments from sponsoring agency and that otherwise also delay in
disposal of the representation would not vitiate the impugned order
but would render the continuous detention invalid.
6. Insofar as the aforesaid first plea raised by the counsel for the
petitioner is concerned, record bares testimony to the fact that that the
detaining authority has taken cognizance of the involvement of the
petitioner in aforesaid three FIR’s and has seemingly based its opinion
as well as drawn subjective satisfaction thereby for preventive
detention of the petitioner, and although the sponsoring agency in the
dossier has stated that the petitioner has got involved in activities
prejudicial to the security of the State post release in the said FIR’s,
yet no details of any such activity have been spelt out in the dossier
and the detaining authority seemingly has without application of its
independent own mind ordered the preventive detention of the
petitioner.
Besides the FIR’s in question admittedly are remote in point of
time viz-a-viz the impugned order, and as such the live link essential
for preventive detention is found missing in the detention case of the
petitioner.
Perusal of the record also tends to show that both the sponsoring
agency as well as the detaining authority seemingly have merely
referred and reflected the past criminal history of the petitioner
without indicating therein the record or the impugned order including
the grounds, any compelling reasons owing thereby, necessitating the
preventive detention of the petitioner. Thus, it is manifest that the
detaining authority has acted in a mechanical manner and has failed to
apply its independent mind while ordering preventive detention of the
petitioner in terms of the impugned order.
7. Records reveals that admittedly the representation of the petitioner
dated 28.05.2025, has been decided by the respondents on 12.08.2025
and detention thereby conveyed to the petitioner on 02.09.2025.
8. Insofar as the aforesaid next plea of the counsel for the petitioner
regarding delayed disposal of the representation of the petitioner by
the respondents is concerned law is no res-intgra and stands settled
by series of judgments rendered by the Apex court including in case
titled as “State of Manipur Vs. Buyamayum Abdul Hanan 2022 (19)
SCC1455” wherein at paras IV and V following has been observed:-
4. “Before we consider the first submission of learned counsel, a few
more facts need be stated. In the writ petition, the petitioner alleged
that he had submitted the representation on May 13,1981, which fact
was denied by the respondents in their counter-affidavit; they asserted
that the representation was submitted not on May 13, but May 31.
This has not been controverted before us by Mr. Garg. It has further
been stated in the counter-affidavit and not denied by the petitioner
that the petitioner submitted the representation to the Superintendent
of the District Jail, Dhanbad, where he was detained, the
superintendent District Jail, sent it by registered post on the following
day, namely, June 1, and the Home (Special) Department of the
Government received it on June 5. It has been stated further in the
counter-affidavit that “the representation contained certain points
which needed a report” from the District Magistrate. A copy of the
representation was sent on June 10, to the District Magistrate,
Dhanbad, through a special messenger, for comments, which were
received on June 24. The respondents explained that since the
Advisory Board was going to sit for consideration of the petitioner’s
case on June 29, they sent the representation of the petitioner to the
Advisory Board for consideration and placed the comments of the
District Magistrate before the Advisory Board. The Advisory Board’s
report was received on June 29 and the following day, the Home
Department examined the representation as well as the opinion of the
Advisory Board on June 30, and endorsed the file on July 1 to the
Chief Minister who approved the detention.
5. But the respondents have not explained their inaction during (i) the
period of five days from June 5 to June 10 taken by the Home
Department to send the representation to the District Magistrate for
his comments; (ii) the period of fourteen days from June 10 to June
24 taken by the District Magistrate to send his comments and (iii) the
period of five days from June 24 to June 29 taken by the Home
Department in placing the District Magistrate’s comments before the
Advisory Board and placing the matter before the Chief Minister.
Thus the total period of inaction of the respondents is twenty four
days”.
A similar view earlier had been taken by the Apex Court in case
titled as “Abdul Nasar Adam Ismail Vs. State of Maharashtra and
Ors reported in 2013 (4) SCC 435” wherein at para 16 following has
been observed:-
16. The principles which have been laid down by the Constitution
Bench and the other judgments which we have referred to earlier
can be summarised. Article 22(5) of the Constitution casts a legal
obligation on the Government to consider the detenu’s
representation as early as possible though no time-limit is
prescribed for disposal of the representation, the constitutional
imperative is that it must be disposed of as soon as possible.
There should be no supine indifference, slackness or callous
attitude. Any unexplained delay would be a breach of the
constitutional imperative and it would render the continued
detention of the detenu illegal. That does not, however, mean that
every day’s delay in dealing with the representation of the detenu
has to be explained. The explanation offered must be reasonable
indicating that there was no slackness or indifference. Though
the delay itself is not fatal, the delay which remains unexplained
becomes unreasonable. The court can certainly consider whether
the delay was occasioned due to permissible reasons or
unavoidable causes. It is not enough to say that the delay was
very short. Even longer delay can as well be explained. So the test
is not the duration or the range of delay, but how it is explained
by the authority concerned. If the inter-departmental consultative
procedures are such that the delay becomes inevitable, such
procedures will contravene the constitutional mandate. Any
authority obliged to make order of detention should adopt a
procedure calculated towards expeditious consideration of the
representation. The representation must be taken up for
consideration as soon as such representation is received and
dealt with continuously (unless it is absolutely necessary to wait
for some assistance in connection with it) until a final decision is
taken and communicated to the detenu.
9. In view of the aforesaid settled position of law, the respondents
indisputably have shown a very callous approach in considering and
disposal of the representation of the petitioner and have in the process
failed in discharge of their Constitutional obligation enshrined under
Article 22 (5) of the Constitution. The impugned order thus on this
core as well becomes legally untenable.
10. Viewed thus for what has been observed, considered and analysed
hereinabove,
the
impugned
order
No.
Order
No.
13/DMA/PSA/DET/2025 dated 26.04.2025 is quashed with a
direction to the respondents including concerned Jail authority to
release the petitioner from preventive detention unless he is required
in any other case.
11. The detention record produced by the counsel for the respondent is
returned back in the open Court.
12. Disposed of.
(JAVED IQBAL WANI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
19.02.2026
“S.Nuzhat”
Whether the order is speaking
Whether the order is reporting
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review