The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. 07.2022, wherein it is mentioned that petitioners merit for their re-engagement at this stage. The core reasoning of the order is inconsistent with the conclusion reached by respondent No. 4. This Court has no hesitation to hold that this is a clerical error, which is duly substantiated by the stand of the respondents, wherein they have categorically denied the entitlement of the petitioners to re-engagement as casual labourers. 12) In view of above, the writ petition lacks merit and is dismissed accordingly. (Rajnesh Oswal) Judge Srinagar,
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND
LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 28.09.2026
Pronounced on: 30.09.2026
Uploaded on: 30.09.2026
Whether the operative part
or
full
judgment
is
pronounced:
Full
WP(C) No.2869/2022
MUSHTAQ AHMAD WAGAY & ORS.
...PETITIONER(S)/APPELLANT(S)
Through: -
Ms. Asiya Nazir, Advocate.
Vs.
UT OF J&K & ORS.
…RESPONDENT(S)
Through: -
Mr. Ilyas Laway, GA.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
The petitioners were initially engaged as casual
labourers, but were discontinued in the year 2002, as stated
in para 03 of the petition.
2)
The petitioners earlier approached this Court through
the medium of SWP No.601/2009 titled “Mohammad Akbar
Rather and others vs. State of J&K and others”, which came
to be disposed of in terms of order dated 08.04.2010.
3)
When the order dated 08.04.2010 was not complied
with by the respondents, the petitioners filed contempt
WP(C) 2869/2022
petition bearing No. 227/2013, wherein the statement of
facts was filed and in para 02 of the statement of facts, it
was stated that there was no work available with the division
concerned, for which the labourers could be engaged from
amongst the petitioners, and accordingly, taking note of the
stand taken by the respondents as mentioned above, the
contempt proceedings were closed in terms of order dated
12.03.2015.
4)
Yet another petition came to be filed by the petitioners
bearing SWP No. 1709/2015, wherein interim order dated
11.08.2015, was passed directing the respondents therein to
consider the claim of the petitioners for their re-engagement.
Yet another contempt petition bearing No. 930/2017 was
filed for non-implementation of order dated 11.08.2015
passed in SWP No.1709/2015, and in para 02 of the
statement of facts filed by the respondents, it was stated that
if any need arises in future in the division, preference will be
given to the petitioners. Pursuant to the directions of the
Court, order dated 25.07.2022 came to be passed by
respondent No. 4.
5)
The petitioners have filed this petition for commanding
the respondent No. 4 to pass necessary orders with respect
to
their
re-engagement because
WP(C) 2869/2022
in
the
order
dated
25.07.2022 passed by respondent No. 4, it is mentioned that
the petitioners have merit for their re-engagement at this
stage. Precisely, it is the contention of the petitioners that in
light of the directions issued by this Court from time to time
and order dated 25.07.2022, they deserve to be re-engaged.
6)
The respondents, in turn, have filed the response, duly
signed by respondent No. 4 only, stating therein that the
petitioners are seeking re-engagement as casual labourers
despite the fact that no legal or statutory right exists in their
favour for such re-engagement. It is further stated that the
department
had
casual/seasonal
utilized
labourers
services
of
locals
as
as
requirement
of
per
projects/schemes for a period of 89 days in one spell. The
Government, vide order dated 02.02.2001 issued by the
General
Administration
Department,
discontinued
the
casual labourers after completion of these projects, and this
discontinuation was a policy decision. It is further stated
that vacancies having arisen from time to time have been
filled through regular recruitments, and the petitioners can
neither claim nor have any preferential right over the said
posts. The petitioners seek re-engagement solely on the basis
of an alleged past casual engagement, which was purely
temporary and need based. Granting such relief would
WP(C) 2869/2022
amount to bypassing the constitutional requirement of equal
opportunity in public employment and result in depriving
the other eligible candidates of the opportunity to compete
for the public employment.
7)
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
8)
The writ petition preferred by the petitioners bearing
SWP No. 601/2009 was disposed of in terms of order dated
08.04.2010, with the following direction:
This petition is, accordingly, disposed of with the
direction to respondents to consider the claim of
the petitioners along with all eligible casual
labourers for re-engagement. It is further made
clear that, only in that case the claim of
petitioners or other persons be considered when
there is work available with the respondents and
there is need to hire the services of persons from
outside the department.
9)
Thereafter, another writ petition was filed, wherein in
terms of interim order dated 11.08.2015, the respondents
therein were directed to consider the claim of the petitioners
for re-engagement with reference to the claim projected in
the representations. In the statement of facts filed in
contempt petition bearing No. 930/2017 arising out of SWP
No. 1709/2015, the stand was taken by the respondents
that if in future any need for engaging the casual workers
WP(C) 2869/2022
arises, preference will be given to the petitioners. Thereafter,
order dated 25.07.2022 was passed by respondent No. 4.
The relevant extract of the order dated 25.07.2022 is
extracted as under:
A large number of complaints have been received
regarding non-payment of wages to the CSLWS
engaged by various departments. While the Govt
fully appreciates the need to rendered yet
experience shows that large number of such
CSLWs have been engaged without any defined
requirement/criteria and with avoidable cost to
the state exchequer apart from resulting in claims
of these worker for regularization in Govt.
services, since such engagements are continued
for years together.
In the circumstances, a need has been felt to
impose complete ban on engagement of casual
/seasonal and need bases workers in al! Govt.
Department including state owned PDUs and
necessary orders for withdrawing existing
delegation of powers are being issued separately.
Accordingly. All the administrative secretaries
and the Managing Directors of all state-owned
PSUs are advised to ensure that not a single
casual/seasonal /need based worker is engaged
under any circumstances henceforth without the
prior specific approval of the department to
assess the need/ justification for the same
Any deviation from the aforesaid directions shall
be attributed to the defaulting Administrative
Secretaries/Managing
Directors/Heads
of
Department
and
shall
attract
severe
consequences.
Whereas, Govt. of J&K through Finance
department vide Govt. order No. 43-F of 2015 dt.
17-03-2015, imposed complete ban on
engagement of casual/seasonal labours (CSLWs)
in Government Departments/States owned PSUs
and ordered that authority to engagement
casual/seasonal labours to various departments
as delegated vide Government orders mentioned
WP(C) 2869/2022
below or any other order is withdrawn with
immediate effect.
1. Govt. order No.239-F of 2005 Dt. 29-01-2005.
2. Govt. order No.138-F of 2013 Dt. 23-05-2013
3. Govt. order No. 105-PD of 2010 Dt. 25-10-2010
Whereas the Hon'ble High Court on the case SWP
No 1709/2015 MP "Issuance notice to
respondents returnable within four weeks
Requisite steps for services within one week MP
NO.01/2015.
Notice as above in MP as well In the
meanwhile, respondents shall consider the
claim of the petitioners for their re-engagement
with reference to the claim projected in the
representation."
Whereas, the Finance Department vide circular
instructions issued under No. A/Misc/2015/364,
D1 17-03-2015 Instructed as under;
A large number of complaints have been
received regarding nonpayment of wages to
the CSLWs engaged by various departments.
While the Govt. fully appreciates the need, to
rendered, yet experience shows that large
number of such CSLWs have been engaged
without any defined requirement/criteria
and with avoidable cost to the state
exchequer apart from resulting in claims of
these worker for regularization in Govt,
services, since such engagements are
continued for years together.
In the circumstances, a need has been felt to
impose complete ban on engagement of
casual/seasonal and need bases workers in all
Govt. Department including state owned PDUs
and necessary orders for withdrawing existing
delegation of powers are being issued separately.
Accordingly. All the administrative secretaries
and the Managing Directors of ail state-owned
PSUs are advised to ensure that not a single
casual/seasonal /need based worker is engaged
under any circumstances henceforth without the
prior specific approval of the department to
assess the need/ justification for the same.
Any deviation from the aforesaid directions shall
be attributed to the defaulting Administrative
WP(C) 2869/2022
Secretaries/ Managing Directors/Heads of
Department
and
shall
attract
severe
consequences.
Whereas, Govt. of J&K through Finance
department vide Govt. order No. 43-f of 2015 dt.
17-03-2015, imposed complete ban on
engagement of casual/seasonal labours (CSLWs)
in Government Departments/States owned PSUs
and ordered that authority to engagement
casual/seasonal labours to various departments
as delegated vide Government orders mentioned
below or any other order is withdrawn with
immediate effect.
1. Govt.order No.239-F of 2005 Dt. 29-01-2005.
2. Govt.order No.138-F of 2013 Dt. 23-05-2013
3. Govt.order No. 105-PD of 2010 Dt.25-10-2010
Whereas, in view of position as elaborated
above, the claim of petitioners has been reexamined and considered in light of the
directions passed by Hon'ble High Court, found
the petitioners merit for their re-engagement at
this stage. Pertinent to mention here that the
judgement passed by the Hon'ble High Court
Dated 08th April 2010 as and when need arises
and work is available the petitioners shall be given
preference. However the petitioners are at liberty
to apply for direct recruitments against the posts
advertised by the Govt. as well.
10)
The textural composition of the order as extracted
above in part would reveal that complete ban was imposed
on 17.03.2015 on engagement of casual/seasonal labourers
(CSLWs) in the Government Departments/State owned
PSUs, and all the orders providing for engagement of
casual/seasonal labourers were withdrawn.
11)
The petitioners, in fact, are taking advantage of the
typographical error crept in the last para of the order dated
25.07.2022, wherein it is mentioned that petitioners merit
WP(C) 2869/2022
for their re-engagement at this stage. The core reasoning
of the order is inconsistent with the conclusion reached by
respondent No. 4. This Court has no hesitation to hold that
this is a clerical error, which is duly substantiated by the
stand of the respondents, wherein they have categorically
denied the entitlement of the petitioners to re-engagement as
casual labourers.
12)
In view of above, the writ petition lacks merit and is
dismissed accordingly.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Srinagar,
30.09.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: NO
WP(C) 2869/2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review