Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Case:-CRM(M) No.141/2020
CrlM No.527/2020
Reserved on: 09.03.2026
Pronounced on: 23.03.2026
Uploaded on: 23.03.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced
Mushtaq Ahmad Ganie
….…Petitioner
Through: Mr. Bilal Ahmad Malla, Advocate.
VERSUS
Union Territory of J and K
& another
.…. Respondents
Through: Mr. Jehangir Dar, Government Advocate.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
1.
The petitioner has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court
under Section 482 of Criminal Procedure Code, seeking quashment
of First Information Report No.60/2020 dated April 11, 2020 qua
the petitioner, registered at Police Station, Sumbal, Bandipora.
2.
Relevant facts in brief are that in the year 2020 due to
outbreak of Covid-19 Pandemic, the Government has taken
restrictive measures at all levels so as to prevent its spread across
the country and in this regard the District Magistrate, Bandipora,
also had issued order dated March 25, 2020 imposing general
restrictions, followed by another order on April 4, 2020 under
CRM(M) No. 141/2020
Section 144 Cr.P.C for immediate prevention of danger to human
life, health and safety. The District Magistrate Bandipora has
imposed restrictions on the movement of any individual for any
reason whatsoever into and out of Villages Konan, GundQaisar,
Gund-Dachina of Tehsil Bandipora & Villages Hakbara & Madwan
of Teshil Hajin.
3.
Furthermore, Senior Superintendent of Police, Bandipora,
was directed to implement the orders in letter and spirit. It was also
provided that any violation of the order imposing restrictions under
section 144 Cr.P.C shall invite punitive action under Section 188 of
Indian Penal Code and other relevant provisions of law.
4.
During the currency of the aforementioned orders, the
petitioner along with co-accused, were found moving/travelling in
vehicles, in violation of the lockdown restrictions, therefore, they
were accordingly intercepted by the Police Patrol Party deployed for
enforcement of the said lockdown restrictions. Upon questioning, no
satisfactory explanation could be furnished by them for their
presence on the spot. It is further alleged that the petitioner
assaulted the police party, as a result whereof an FIR under Section
188, 269 and 353 IPC, came to be registered.
5.
Accordingly, investigation in the aforesaid FIR was duly
carried out and on culmination of the investigation, challan was
presented before the Court of learned Judicial Magistrate Ist Class,
Sumbal on November 26, 2020, however in the meanwhile, the
petitioner has filed instant petition.
6.
The grievance of the petitioner is that he is a Journalist by
profession and at the relevant point of time, while he was returning
to home, he was intercepted by the Naka Party and for no reason he
was harassed and an FIR was registered against him. The further
CRM(M) No. 141/2020
submission of the petitioner is that under Section 60 of the Disaster
Management Act, 2005, (Act of 2005) no cognizance of the offence
can be taken except on a complaint made by the competent
authority. Further plea raised by the petitioner is with regard to the
non-compliance of Section 195 of the Criminal Procedure Code
which inter alia provides that no Court shall take cognizance of any
offence punishable under Section 172 to 188 of the Indian Penal
Code except on the complaint in writing of the public servant
concerned, but according to the petitioner these mandatory
provisions have been observed in breach by the prosecution.
7.
Besides above, petitioner has also made factual references
in defence, but no foundation regarding the relevancy of these
references is laid down, therefore, it is not deemed necessary to go
into that aspect of the matter.
8.
On the other hand, while opposing the petition, besides
giving factual narration in the objections filed by the respondents, it
is also argued that the petitioner was found roaming in violation of
restrictions imposed by the District Magistrate under Section 144
Cr.P.C and has also assaulted the police personnel on duty,
therefore, in the light of the material collected during investigation,
prima facie, the culpability of the petitioner is established, as such,
this petition under Section 482, Cr.P.C is not maintainable and
therefore, same may be dismissed.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and also gone
through the record.
10.
Since the petitioner has invoked the extra ordinary
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C, therefore, be it
noted that jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C, cannot be liberally
exercised and it has to be sparingly exercised, in cases where there
CRM(M) No. 141/2020
is a dire need of exercise of this power. It is also trite that correctness
of allegations against the accused to be decided only in trial.
11.
To the contention of the petitioner that he is a Journalist
by profession and at the relevant point of time, he was returning
home, there is nothing on record to substantiate that either he is a
Journalist or at the relevant point of time, he was permitted to
perform his duty as such, despite imposition of restrictions under
Section 144 Cr.P.C.
12.
Going by the allegations contained in the FIR and the
material collected during the investigation, it appears that in order
to prevent the spread of Covid-19 Pandemic, the restrictions under
Section 144 Cr.P.C came to be imposed by the District Magistrate,
Bandipora, but the petitioner along with co-accused were found
roaming in disobedience to the said restrictions order thereby
alleged to have facilitated the spread of the disease by their negligent
acts. During questioning by the Naka Party, the petitioner alleged to
have assaulted the police personnel on duty and in this regard,
allegation is also borne out from the material collected during the
investigation.
13.
Perhaps the petitioner is reeling under the impression that
he has been booked under the wrong provisions of law and further
a complaint was required to be filed in terms of Section 195 of
Cr.P.C, and other relevant provisions of Act of 2005, which is lacking
in this case, therefore, he invoked the jurisdiction of this Court
under section 482 Cr.P.C.
14.
To the contrary, on wading through the record, it is seen
that the District Magistrate, Bandipora had already filed a complaint
dated April 11, 2020 in terms of Section 195 Cr.P.C qua the
commission of offence under Section 188 IPC, nonetheless Section
CRM(M) No. 141/2020
195(1)(a)(i) of Cr.P.C bars the Court from taking cognizance of any
offence punishable under Sections 172 to 188, respectively of the
Indian Penal Code, unless there is a written complaint by a public
servant concerned, however, there is neither any bar nor any
prohibition in registration of FIR and investigation of the case but
only on completion of investigation the embargo in Section 195
Cr.P.C would come into play and the Court would not be competent
to take cognizance.
15.
Turning to the case on hand, the petitioner has
approached this Court prematurely at the pre-cognizance stage.
Therefore, the question whether there is any violation of section 195
Cr.P.C is wholly far-fetched, being ipse dixit of the petitioner. Rather
it appears to be an attempt to circumvent the procedure prescribed
under the Code, in that, all these factual assertions are available to
the petitioner at the stage of hearing on charge/discharge, including
violation if any of the provisions of law before the trial court.
16.
The trial Court is well within its jurisdiction to examine, as
to whether or not there is compliance of Section 195 Cr.P.C or as to
whether on the basis of the material collected during investigation,
prima facie, commission of offence as alleged is made out, coupled
with the fact that the Court can also alter or add to any charge at
any time under Section 216 of Cr.P.C.
17.
The assertions made by the petitioner predominantly can
be raised and effectively available at the stage of charge/dis-charge,
which expressly includes the question of compliance of Section 195
Cr.P.C. This Court in exercise of powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C
is not required to and, in fact, cannot enter into the factual
assertions made by the petitioner, as the same would necessitate
appreciation of evidence, a function which is exclusively reserved for
the trial Court.
CRM(M) No. 141/2020
18.
In the given facts and circumstances of the case, Section
26 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, needs to be taken note of which
provides that where any act or omission constitutes an offence
under two or more enactments, then offender shall be liable to be
prosecuted and punished under either or any of these enactments,
but shall not be liable to be punished twice for the same act. This
provision expressly gives prosecution the liberty to elect any
applicable enactment(s). The only restriction is double punishment
for the same offence.
19.
The Investigating Officer on completion of investigation
files the chargesheet under the relevant sections of the penal laws,
as he deems fit, as this is the discretionary assessment of the I.O on
the basis of material collected during the investigation.
20.
At
cognizance/framing
of
charge
stage,
the
Court
examines prima facie material and is competent to frame/alter
charges. The Court is not bound by the Investigating Officer’s
discretionary assessment of applicable provisions, but Court acts on
the basis of material available on record, therefore, it can add/alter
the charges.
21.
The petitioner in the case on hand has raised the grouse
regarding violation of the provisions of Disaster Management Act,
2005, section 195 of the Criminal Procedure Code and Pandemic
Disease Act, 1897, however, neither the chargesheet has been
presented under the Act of 2005 nor under any of the provisions of
Act of 1897, therefore, the petitioner cannot have a valid and legal
justification to question the legality of chargesheet as same having
been presented in violation these statutes, rather this is the
discretion of the Investigating Officer based on the material collected
during investigation and on filing of the chargesheet, the competent
Court has ample jurisdiction to examine the material collected
CRM(M) No. 141/2020
during investigation to form an opinion as to whether ingredients of
the alleged act of omission and commission, are made out or not,
but in any case, the accused cannot insist for presentation of
chargesheet under the penal statute of his choice, when such acts
are punishable under two different statutes.
22.
At the stage of framing of charge, the Court is only required
to see whether there is strong suspicion or prima facie existence of
the factual ingredients of the offence alleged in the chargesheet. It
is not the stage to decide which statute is more appropriate. The
Court will frame the charge under the existing chargesheet or if
material does not disclose prima facie culpability of the accused
then certainly it will result in discharge of the accused, but in any
case, the Court cannot re-write the chargesheet.
23.
For the foregoing reasons, no case for interference is made
out, accordingly, petition is dismissed along with connected CrlM.
24.
Let the trial Court record be transmitted forthwith and the
trial Court shall commence the trial without further delay.
25.
However, it is made clear that the observations made are
only for the purpose of deciding the present petition and shall not
be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case.
The learned Trial Court shall proceed with the matter uninfluenced
by
any
of
these
observations
and
shall
decide
the
case
independently on its own merits in accordance with law.
(SHAHZAD AZEEM)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
23.03.2026
Surinder
Whether order is speaking: Yes
Whether order is reportable: Yes
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
CRM(M)
No. 141/2020
authenticity of
this
document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review