Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP No. 213/2025
Pronounced on: 16.07.2026
Mushtaq Ahmad Dar
…Petitioner(s)
Through:
Mr. Imtiyaz Ahmad Sofi, Advocate
Vs.
Union Territory of J&K and Anr.
...Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. Faheem Nisar Shah, GA
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well
as learned counsel for the respondents.
2.
Perused the writ pleadings and documents
annexed therewith.
Also
examined the
detention
record produced from the end of the respondents
relating to the petitioner’s detention.
3.
The
petitioner
is
in
preventive
detention
custody w.e.f. 02.05.2025 lodged in the District Jail,
Rajouri.
HCP No. 213/2025
4.
The petitioner through his father-Mohd Subhan
Dar, is throwing a challenge to the exercise at the end
of respondents No. 1 and 2 on the basis whereof he
has been ordered to suffer preventive detention
custody under J&K Public Safety Act, 1978 meant to
last for full period of two years w.e.f. 02.05.2025.
5.
A case for seeking preventive detention of the
petitioner was mooted by the Senior Superintendent of
Police, (SSP), Handwara who, vide his communication
No.Pros/Dossier/2025/2342-46 dated 27.04.2025
supplemented by a communication No.Pros/ Dossier/
2025/2407 dated 29.04.2025, submitted a dossier to
the respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Kupwara
thereby seeking exercise of jurisdiction at his end
under the J&K Public Safety Act, 1978 to order
preventive detention of the petitioner so as to prevent
him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the
security of the State.
6.
The dossier with reference to the petitioner
refers to the criminal antecedents of the petitioner by
reflection of his involvement in FIR No. 153 of 2012
of the Police Station, Handwara by reference to which
HCP No. 213/2025
criminal case is said to be sub-judice with the
petitioner being enlarged on bail as an under-trial.
7.
The petitioner even after his release on bail, is
said to have continued with his alleged objectionable
ways and, as such, was subjected to preventive
detention custody in the year 2012 by reference to an
Order No. 07-DMK/PSA of 2012 dated 21.07.2012
which is said to have been quashed by this Court on
mere
technical
grounds
but
the
petitioner
still
remained inclined towards anti-national activities with
respect to which the respondents are said to have
confidential reports and reports received from Sister
Agencies. The petitioner is said to have even been
subjected to the security proceedings under section
126 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
8.
The
dossier
so
submitted
by
the
Senior
Superintendent of Police, (SSP), Handwara persuaded
the respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Kupwara to
hold that a case was made out for the preventive
detention of the petitioner and the basis for the said
opinion of the respondent No.2-District Magistrate,
Kupwara came to rest upon the grounds of detention
HCP No. 213/2025
formulated which are repetition of the contents of the
dossier submitted by the Senior Superintendent of
Police, (SSP), Handwara.
9.
The
Kupwara
respondent
came
to
issue
No.2-District
detention
Magistrate,
order
No.05-
DMK/PSA of 2025 dated 29.04.2025 directing the
preventive
detention,
arrest
and
custody
of
the
petitioner so as to prevent him from acting in any
manner prejudicial to the security of the Union
Territory of Jammu and Kashmir to be kept detained
in the District Jail, Rajouri.
10.
The detention order No. 05-DMK/PSA of 2025
dated 29.04.2025 does not bear an essential recital to
the effect that the petitioner being ordered to be kept
in preventive detention custody is for how much period
to be settled by whom.
11.
The
Kupwara,
respondent
by
virtue
of
No.2-District
his
Magistrate,
communication
No.
DMK/PSA/2025/169 dated 29.04.2025, addressed
to the Principal Secretary to the Government, Home
Department, Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir
HCP No. 213/2025
apprised about the issuance of detention order against
the
petitioner
and
submitting
the
file
for
the
consideration of the Home Department, Government of
Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir for the
purpose of according approval to the detention order.
12.
Likewise,
the
respondent
No.2-District
Magistrate, Kupwara, by virtue of communication No.
DMK/PSA/2025/170-176 dated 29.04.2025 thereby
serving as a notice of detention to the petitioner and
simultaneously apprising him thereby that he has a
right of making a representation to the Government or
to him against his preventive detention.
13.
The
execution
of
detention
warrant
upon
petitioner came to take place through SI Nazir Ahmad,
PID No. 965928 of Police Station/Post, Kralgund. The
petitioner is said to have been handed over the
documents in the form of detention order, notice of
detention, grounds of detention and dossier total
compilation of 28 leaves and is said to have been
explained in the language understood by him to the
extent of translated copy of detention order in Urdu.
HCP No. 213/2025
14.
The execution report generated by SI Nazir
Ahmad bears a recital that the petitioner was informed
about his right to make a representation to the
competent authority against his detention order, if he
so
desires,
without
specifying
which
competent
authority was indicated to the petitioner for the
purpose of enabling him to exercise his constitutional
right of making a representation to the Government as
well as to the detention order making authority,
whereas, the receipt of the grounds of detention taken
from the petitioner bears a recital that he was
informed of his right to make a representation to the
Government.
15.
By virtue of Government Order No. Home/PB-
V/780 of 2025
dated 05.05.2025, approval to
detention order No. 05-DMK/PSA of 2025 dated
29.04.2025 came to be accorded and the case was
forwarded on 05.05.2025 to the Advisory Board for its
opinion.
16.
It was on 20.06.2025 that the petitioner had
come forward with the institution of the present writ
HCP No. 213/2025
petition after he has suffered forty nine days of
detention custody in the District Jail, Rajouri.
17.
The petitioner had addressed a representation
dated 06.05.2025 against his preventive detention
through
his
father-Abdul
Subhan
Dar
to
the
Government.
18.
Report
The Advisory Board, by virtue of its Opinion
dated
22.05.2025,
came
to
hold
the
petitioner’s preventive detention based upon justifiable
grounds is suffering no procedural deficiency or defect
and also considered the representation made on behalf
of the petitioner and found the same to be without any
substance.
19.
The Advisory Board’s Opinion Report, thus,
facilitated
issuance
Home/PB-V/1040
of
of
Government
dated
Order
No.
29.05.2025
confirming the detention of the petitioner for a period
w.e.f 02.05.2025 till 01.11.2025 at first instance for a
period of six months and the place of lodgment
continued to be in the District Jail, Rajouri.
HCP No. 213/2025
20.
The petitioner’s representation so submitted to
the Government came to earn its disposal by virtue of
a communication No. Home/PB-V/191-2025 dated
29.05.2025 addressed to the respondent No.2-District
Magistrate, Kupwara to apprise the petitioner about
the fate of his representation being negative.
21.
The petitioner came to be handed over the
requisite
communication
representation against
detention
came
to
of
rejection
of
his
a receipt. The petitioner’s
be
further
extended
from
02.11.2025 to 01.05.2026 by virtue of Government
Order
No.
Home/PB-V/1983
of
dated
31.10.2025.
22.
The petitioner in his writ petition has come to
assail his preventive detention on the grounds as set
out in para 3 (i) to (xviv).
23.
The petitioner has referred to the fact that
entire basis of his preventive detention custody is
resting solely upon reference to his involvement in
criminal case under FIR No. 153 of 2012 of the Police
Station, Handwara which is still pending trial in which
HCP No. 213/2025
he is on bail and therefore, a reference to such a long
distant incident of 2012 in the dossier as well as in the
grounds of detention was nothing but an attempt to
cover up the fact of lack of material in the context of
present state of activities of the petitioner so as to give
a bad name to the petitioner and legitimize the
preventive detention exercise initiated at the end of
Senior Superintendent of Police, (SSP), Hadwara and
the respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Kupwara.
24.
The petitioner submits that the proceedings
under section 126 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 at no point of time were ever taken to
logical end but still the bond furnished by him was not
breached from his end while a case for preventive
detention of the petitioner was processed and served
by making said proceedings under section 126 of
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 as the
referral point.
25.
The grounds of detention and the dossier being
a mirror image of each other have been agitated by the
petitioner to show that the sponsoring authority as
well as the detention order making authority were both
HCP No. 213/2025
acting with a bankruptcy of facts at their disposal for
subjecting
the
petitioner
to
preventive
detention
custody.
26.
The petitioner has referred to the said fact that
the copy of communication No. Pros/ Dossier/ 2025/
2407 dated 29.04.2025 from the end of Senior
Superintendent of Police, (SSP), Handwara as referred
to in the order of detention was never ever provided to
him.
27.
It is further submitted that the purported
reference to confidential reports and reliable reports
from the Sister Agencies were never ever provided to
the petitioner for enabling him to make an effective
representation. The petitioner submits that he was
deprived of his right of appearing before the Advisory
Board
despite
having
made
a
request
in
his
representation.
28.
The petitioner refers to the fact that in the year
2012 when he was subjected to preventive detention
custody vide order No. 07-DMK/PSA of 2012 dated
21.07.2012, same was quashed by this Court in HCP
HCP No. 213/2025
No. 104/2012 dated 29.10.2012
but the same
narrative was set up against the petitioner as had been
pressed at this time.
29.
on
The respondents, in their counter affidavit filed
24.09.2025,
have
defended
the
preventive
detention of the petitioner by support of dossier,
grounds of detention and further stating that all
procedural compliances were carried out leaving no
scope for the petitioner to have any grouse against his
detention.
30.
When this court examines the underlying basis
of the petitioner’s detention both from the end of the
Senior Superintendent of Police, (SSP), Handwara in
the context of preparing the dossier and from the end
of the respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Kupwara in
the context of formulating the grounds of detention for
the purpose of drawing subjective satisfaction as to
whether the petitioner’s personal liberty needs to be
curtailed by subjecting him to preventive detention
custody, this court finds that misplaced reference to
the petitioner’s criminal antecedents under FIR No.
153 of 2012 is to be taken out of consideration for the
HCP No. 213/2025
simple reason because by reference to the said aspect,
the petitioner was subjected to preventive detention
custody in the year 2012 by virtue of respondent No.2District Magistrate, Kupwara’s order No. 07-DMK/PSA
of 2012 dated 21.07.2012. This court is observing the
same on the strength of the grounds of detention itself
which in paras 2 and 3 are meant to say the said fact.
31.
Thus, once this court takes out the reference to
the petitioner’s antecedents relatable to FIR No. 153
of 2012, in the rest of the dossier as well as in the
grounds of detention there is no whisper of factual
content with intent on the basis whereof the Senior
Superintendent of Police, (SSP), Handwara could have
conceived of reckoning the petitioner’s alleged state of
activities to be prejudicial to the security of the State.
32.
It is only by a heavily loaded opinionated
assessment
of
the
petitioner’s conduct
that
the
petitioner has been condemned to suffer preventive
detention custody by labeling him as a bearer of
subversive behavior having a strong association with a
banned terrorist organization like Lashkar-e-Taiba
with a bad character and with relevant entries against
HCP No. 213/2025
his behavior recorded in the concerned Police Station
from time to time.
33.
This court wonders how against such a type of
dossier and grounds of detention, a detenu can
conceive of making any representation whatsoever
except to say that he or she does not bear the said
state of conduct or indulgences as attributed to him or
her from the end of the District Police and borrowed by
the District Magistrate.
34.
This type of grounds of preventive detention of
a person qualifies to be vague and baseless, and,
therefore, any preventive detention resting upon such
vague and baseless grounds cannot be allowed to be
sustained
except
at
the
cost
of
sacrificing
the
fundamental right of personal liberty of a detenu to
which a constitutional court cannot lend its nod.
35.
In view of the aforesaid, this court holds the
preventive detention custody of the petitioner to be
based purely on vague and baseless grounds without
any iota of factual content and, therefore, declares
detention order No. 05-DMK/PSA of 2025 dated
HCP No. 213/2025
29.04.2025
read
with
approval/confirmation/
extension order(s) passed by the Home Department,
Government of Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir
as illegal and are, accordingly, quashed.
36.
The petitioner is directed to be released from
his preventive detention custody from the concerned
Jail wherever the petitioner is kept detained and the
Superintendent of the concerned Jail shall release the
petitioner forthwith.
37.
The detention record being in photostat form
needs not be returned and is to be retained on the file.
38.
Disposed of.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
16.07.2026
“Manzoor”
Whether the judgment is speaking
:
Yes / No
Whether the judgment is reportable
:
Yes / No
HCP No. 213/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review