Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34el I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TEITNGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BI.E JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
CMA Nos. 242 and 243 oI 2O25
CMA.No.242 ot 2025
Appeal under Order 43 Rule 1 of C.P.C. against the order dated 06{3-2025
passed in {.A.No.SzlO of NZO in O.S.No.146 of 2O20 on the file of the Court of the Xl
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar.
Between:
Murazban Murad Dhanji Shaw Oomr(7a|, S/o Late Dhajishar Oomrigar, Aged
about 75 years, Occ: Doclor, R/o Rajab Mahal, Church Gate, Mumbai,
Maharashtra State Rep. by his GPA Holders:
1 . Shahveer lrroni S/o J.S. lrani, Age: 63 years, Occ: Business R/o. 5-2-27, R.P.
Road, Secunderabad.
2. J.D. Amar Duft, S/o Dev Dutt, Age: 39 years, Occ: Business, No.5-2-27,
R.P. Road, Secunderabad.
AND
...AppellanUPetitioner/Plaintiff
1. M/s Frontline Euilders, O/o Flat No G-'l , Oualia Plot No. 208, Swamy Ayyappa
Society, Madhapur, Hyderabad Rep. by its working partners Arani Ram
Prasad Reddy S/o A. Jayarami Reddy, Aged about 4B years, Occ: Business
Rl/o Flat No. 'l 104, Pegasus-A Wirg Meenakshi Sky Lourpe, Khanarnet,
Kondapur, R.R District-Soo 0B4 Telangana
2. M/s. Sanghvi lnfra, Registered Partnership Firm, ffice at 44-933 to 935, Flat
No. 204 Royal Plaza, Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad Telangana State - 500 0O1
Rep by its Managing Partner Vijay Kumar Sanghvi S/o Late Nandla Sanghvi,
Aged about 53 years, Occ. Business, Rl/o Flat No. 204, Royal Plaza, Sultan
Bazar, Hyderabad - 50O 001 T.S.
3. S. lndrasena Reddy, S/o S. Rala Reddy, Aged about 64 years, Occ.
Business, Ri,/o Flat No. 502, Gowthami Paradise, Masjidbarda, Kondapur,
R.R. District, Telangana - 500 084.
4. M/s Neptune Projects Pvt. Ltd, Registered ofFrce at lanco House, Plot No.4,
Software Units Layout, Hitech City, Madhapur, Hyderabad
Rep- by its authorized signatory Mr. Venkateswara Rao Kancherla, S/o Late
Shri. Kameshwara Rao, Aged about 58 years, Rl/o Jayadarsini Residency, B45. Whitefield, Kondapur, Hyderabad-5O0004, TS.
5. M/s Dione Properties Pvt. Ltd.
(Formerly known as M/s Dimond Farms Pvt. Ltd.). Re; stered office at Lanco
House, Plot No. 4, Sofharare Units Layout Hitech City lr adhapur, Hyderabad,
rep. by its authorized signatory Mr. Venkateswara Rtu Kancherta, S/o Late
Shri Kameshwara Rao, Aged about 58 years, Rl/o Jayi larsini Residency, B45, Whitefi eld, Kondapur, Hyderabad-500004, TS.
6. Potlapalli Lakshmi Madhavi, Wo Dontula Rakesh, Age i?years, Occ:
Employee R/o H.No.7-62, Chinnagopathi Viltage, Konijrr la Mandal,
Khammam District, T.S.
7. Arani Ramprasad Reddy, S/o A. Jayarami Reddy. Age3 about 46 years, Occ:
Business, R/o Flat No. 1104, Pegasus-A Wing, Me:nakshi Sky lounge,
Khanapet, Kondapur, Hyderabad-500084, TS.
8. Thammireddy Sreehari Reddy, S/o T. Narayana Reddy, \ged about Sl years,
Occ. Business, Fi/o Villa No.274, lndu Fortune FielJ , KpHB, Hyderabad
500072, T.S.
9. Tatikonda Lachi Reddy, S/o T. Veera Reddy, Aged i bout 54 years, Occ.
Business, Rl/o H.No.261/A, Sathyanarayanapr r rm, Chaitanyapuri,
Hyderabad-500060, T.S.
10.Smt. Gaddampally Laxmi, Wo G. Ravinder Reddy, ,A led about 34 years,
Occ. Employee, Rl/o H.No.5$-1A6, Plot No. 46 Roaci \o. 1, Vaidehinagar,
Beside Litfle Flower Vanasthalipuram, Hayathnagar, r rnga Reddy District,
Telangana State.
11.Smt, Doulagar Shivani, Wo Doulagar Kistrsre, Aged i bout 34 years, Oc,c.
Employee, R/o H.No.10-2-17111 , Flat No. 3, Road l.k. 1, Near Narayana
Concept School, West Manedpally, Nehrunagar, Hyderir rad - 500 026
l2.Gaddampatly Vinay Reddy, S/o. Gaddampally Prabhakz - Reddy, Aged about
33 years, Occ. Business, R/o H.No. 3-121, Pullicheda, l,eddawra, Nalgonda
District TS - 508 266.
l3.Potlapalli Sarojini, Wo Seshagiri Rao, Aged about 57 ye ars, Occ. Housewife,
Ri/o Konijeda, Chinna Gopathi, Khammam Districl TS -5C / 305.
14.Kaitha Bhaskar Reddy, S/o Kaitha Malla Reddy" Aged bout 55 years, Occ.
Employee, R/o H.No.14-47, Reddy Colony, HuasnabaC Karimnagar District
TS -505 467.
15.Nukala Pitchamma, W/o Katkuri Satyanarayana Reddy,,,ged about 74 years,
Occ. Housewife, Rl/o H.No.16-1021311113, Vidya ltagar, Road No.6,
Suryapet, Nalgonda Dist. TS-50821 3.
16.P.R. Vinod, S/o Ravindranathan V, Aged about 47 year:; Occ. Employee, R/o
Perumbarode House, Athipolla, Tarur-ll, Palakkad, Athig< fta, Kerala$78 544.
17. Kasarla Varun, S/o Kasarla Venkat Reddy, Aged al xt 27 years, Occ.
Employee, Rl/o H.No.1-6-11zt3l11t3, 6h Ward, V< yanagar, Suryapet,
Nalgonda District TS-508 213.
'lB.Thokala Sumana, S/o Thokala Jithender Reddy, Aged i bout 54 years, Occ.
Business, Rt/o H,No.1-7-1251, Advocates Colony Main load, Near Ekashila
Park, Balasamaudram, Hanamkonda, Warangal District I 3-506 001 .
19.Bathi Bhasker Reddy, S/o Bathi Ramana Reddy, Aged i bout 37 years, Occ.
Employee, R/o PIot No.67, Om Vihar Colony, Medipally ihatkesar, MedchalMalkajgiri District TS-509098.
20.Bongarala Tirumala Srinivasa Rao, S/o Bongarala Ve,t abhadra Rao, Aged
about 39 years, Occ: Emptoyee Rl/o Flat No. T3, pl(,t No. 43, 44, Bhanu
Brijesh Residency, Neknampur, Ranga Reddy District T[; 500 089.
2l.Gangaraju Sailendra Kumar, 9o Gangaraju Balakrishnama Raju, Aged about
43 years, Occ. Employee, Rr/o H.No.13-1-212, Fht No. 204, Sri Balaji
Nilayam, Spencer Super Market. Balaji Swamapuri Colony, Hyderabad TS18.
2Z.Gunam Kavya Reddy, D/o Satyanarayana Reddy, Aged about 24 years, Occ.
Service, R:/o H.No.1-12, Thimmapuram, Anumula Mandal, Yacharam
Nalgonda District TS-508 266.
23. Yogeshwar Waman Rao Kuntawar, S/o Waman Rao Kuntawar, Aged about
47 years, Occ. Service, Rl/o H.No. 14$5, Prestige Park, Gundlapochampally,
Secunderabad, TS.
24.Smt. Arepally Kavitha, Wo Peri Naveen Reddy, Aged about 39 years, Occ.
Employee. R:/o H. No. 42-271133, Nandhi Hills, Near Anus School, Svaiguda,
Mahabubnagar District TS-509 1 03.
25.Bethi Ram Reddy, S/o Bethi Venkat Reddy, Aged about 65 years, Occ.
Retired, Rl/o H. No. 1-9-315 and 316, Deccan Crescent Heights, Street No.
15, 3d Floor, Flat No. 305, Vidyanagar, Hyderabad TS -500044.
26. Yeleswarapu Sirisha,, Wo Bulusu Phani Kumar, Aged about 43 years, Occ.
Housewife, R:/o Flat No. 2lC)2, Plot No.909, Sri Sai Data Residency, Defence
Colony, Sainikpuri, Hyderabad, TS.
27.Smt. Talla lGvitha, Wo Venkat Reddy, Aged about 43 years, Occ:
Housewife, R/o Flat No. z()'t, Suyshma Sai Nagar, Road No, 1, Near SR Digi
School Vanasthalipuram, Hayathnagar, Ranga Reddy Dist. T3-500070.
28.Smt. Talla Kavitha, Wo Venkat Reddy, Aged about 43 years, Occ.
Housewife, R:/o Flat No, 401, Suyshma Sai Nagar, Road No. 1, Near SR Digi
School Vanasthalipuram, Hayathnagar, Ranga Reddy Dist. T5-500070.
29. Kandukuri Vijaya Laxmi, Wo K. Janardhan Reddy, Aged about 55 years, Occ.
Housewife, R/o H.No.1-1-265121501 , Srinivasa Nagar, Near Radhika Theatre,
Kapra, Ranga Reddy District T5-500062.
30.Alluri Venkata Satya Dahrma Rama Raju, S/o Alluri Rama Krishna Raju, Aged
about 56 years, Occ: Business, F/o H.No.SO-1 17-2114, Seethammadhara NE
Layout, Near Public Health Office, P and T colony. Visakhapatnam (Urban)
AP-s30013.
31 .TatikoMa Padma, Wo Tatikonda Lachi Reddy, Aged about 49 years, Occ.
Housewife. R:/o H. No.261/A, Satyanarayanapuram Near Raghava Flospital,
Chaitanyapuri, Hyderabad TS-500 060,
32.Takikonda Lachi Reddy, S/o T. Veera Reddy, Aged about 56 years, Occ.
Business, R/o H.No.2€1lA, Satyanarayanapuram, Near Raghava Hospital,
Chaitanyapuri, Hyderabad TS- 500 060.
33.Smt. Pola Dhana Laxmi, Wo Pola Lakhsman Kumar, Aged about 52 years,
Occ: Housewife, Rito Plot No. 43, Jagdish Nagar Colony, Rasoolpura,
Secunderabad TS-50OOO3.
34. Smt. Sumana Panjala, W/o Pratap Chandra Beemagani, Aged about 34
years, Occ: Service Ri/o Flat No. 102, Yogesh Residency, Chanda Nagar,
MMT, Siva Temple, Hyderabad TS-5O0050.
35.Smt. Madireddy Sai Kumari, Wo Prasanna Rao, Aged about 54 years, Occ:
Housewife R/o H.No.4-1-54l2. Super Bazar Centre, Ramalayam Temple
Road, Fourth Ward, Bhadrachalam. Khammam Dist. TS-507 111.
36.Smt. Goddeshi Lavanya, W/o 8. Chandar Rao, Aged about 30 years, Occ:
Housewife, R/o H.No.3-5-1 4Ol4l4, Jammigada, Suryapet TS-508 213.
3T.Allareddy Srihari Reddy, S/o A. Mallikarjuna Reddy, \ged about 30 years,
Occ: Private Employee, R:/o Plot No.62 and 69, Flat hi( . G-1 , Aditya Niliyam,
Near E-seva, Moti Nagar, Balanagar, Medchal-Malkajgri i District, TS-SOOd1S.
38.Vishnu Vardhan Kethi Reddy, S/o K. Sudhakar Reddr,, Aged about 39 years,
Occ: Pvt. Employee, Rl/o Parlapalli, Vidavalur, Kothar: rgallu, Nellore tiistrict
AP-524317.
39.Karempudi Sreedhar Reddy,, S/o Ramama Reddy, r.ged about 55 years,
Occ: Business, Rl/o Plot No. 351 and 356, Flat No. :Z 12, Sy No. 96 to 103,
Poojitha Srinivasam, Friends Colony, Manikonda, t,r ppaliguda, Gandipet
Mandal, R.R. District T5-500089.
40.Kaitha Sruthi, D/o Kaitha Bhaskar Reddy, Wo Thumt,l r prudvi Kumar, Aged
about 28 years, Occ: Software Engineer, R/o Flat \ l. 104, pruthvi Siyle
Home, Mahesh Nagar, EC[L, Hyderabad-500062
Presently residing at#1528 Darien Lake DR, Darien tt iOS61-5083, USA.
...Respondents/Res I ondents/Defendants
(Case against Respondents Number is 3, 4; 5,6, 1), 13, 14, 15, 12, 1g,
24,27,37,38, 39, 40 is not pressed as they are fomri I parties)
fA NO:2 OF 2025
Petition under order 39 Rule 1 & 2 R;rw Section 15 I cpc praying that in
the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support or ne peiition, t-ne nigrt
court may be pleased to restrain the Respondents/Defencri nts from proceeding
with the @nstruction or changing the nature of the properti >s mentioned herein
pending the disposal of the Suit:
a. All that part of the in sy.No.31 admeasuring to arr extent Ac.5.22 Gts.
Situated at Kokapet, the Gandipet Mandal, Ranga ieddy district more
particularly described in Schedule-A and
b.
All hat part of the property in Sy.No.37(31t2) admeasuring to an
extent Ac. 1-18 Gts. Situated at Kokapet, t r : Gandipet Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District more particularly describe I in Schedule_B.
SCHEDULE-A
All that part of the property in sy.No.31 admeasuring r ) an extent Ac. s.22
_
Gts. situated
at Kokapet, the Gandipet Mandar, Rangz Reooy district and
bounded by:
North: Part of land in Sy.No.30
South: 100 feet Road towards Shankerpally
East: Remaining land of the plaintiffs in Sy.No.31
West: Land in Sy.No.33 belongs to plaintiff
SCHEDULE-B
All that part of the property in sy.No.34 (34t2) adme, suring to an extent
Ac-1-18 Gts. situated at Kokapet, the Gandipet Mandal, ll rnga Reddy district
and bounded by:
North : Part of land in Sy.No.31 & 33
South : 100 feet Road towards Shankerpally
East : Remaining land of the plaintiffs in Sy.No.37
West : Land in Sy.Nos.36 & 37 betongs to ptaintiff
Counsel for the Appellant: Sri Thomas George, counsel representing
Sri Manav Gecil Thomas
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: Sri E. Ajay Reddy, Senior Counsel
representing Ms. E. Anisha Reddy
Counsel for the Respondents No.1,7,8,9,1 1,12,16,19,2O,21,22,23,
25,26,28,29,30,31,32,33,34 and 36 : Sri Sunil B. Ganu, Senior Counsel
representing Ms. Manlari S. Ganu
CMA.No.243 ol 2O25
Appeal under Order 43 Rule 1 of C.P.C. against the order dated 06{3-2025
passedinl.A.No.541 of 2O2O inO.S.No.1z16of 2O2Oonthefileof theCourtof theXl
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar.
Between:
Murazban Murad Dhanji Shaw Oomrigal, S/o Late Dhajishar Oomrigar, Aged
about 75 years, Occ: Doctor, R/o Rajab Mahal, Church Gate, Mumbai,
Maharashtra State Rep. by his GPA Holders:
1. Shahveer lrroni S/o J.S. lrani, Age: 63 years, Occ: Business R/o.5-2-27, R.P.
Road, Secunderabad.
2. J.D. Amar Duft, S/o Dev Duft, Age: 39 years, Occ: Business, PUo.5-2-27,
R.P- Road, Secunderabad.
...AppellanUPetitioner/Plaintiff
AND
1. lt/Us Frontline Builders, O/o Flat No G-1, Qualia Plot No. 208, Swamy
Ayyappa Society, Madhapur, Hyderabad Rep. by its working partners Arani
Ram Prasad Reddy S/o A. Jayarami Reddy, Aged about 48 years, Occ:
Business Fi/o Flat No. 1't04, Pegasus-A Wing Meenakshi Sky Lounge,
Khanamet, Kondapur, R.R District-500 084 Telangana
2. Ws. Sanghvi lnfra, Registered Partnership Firm, OfFrce at 44-933 t'o 935,
Flat No. 204 Royal Plaza, Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad Telangana State - 500
001 Rep by its Managing Partner Vijay Kumar Sanghvi S/o Late Nandla
Sanghvi, Aged about 53 years, Occ. Business, F/o Flat No. 2O4, Royal Plaza,
Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad - 500 001 T.S.
3. S. lndrasena Reddy, S/o S. Raja Reddy, Aged about 64 years, Occ.
Business, Rl/o Flat No. 502, Gowthami Paradise, Masjidbanda, Kondapur,
R.R. District, Telangana - 500 084.
4. M/s Neptune Projects P\i{. Ltd, Registered office at Lanco House, Plot No. 4,
Software Units Layout, Hitech City, Madhapur, Hyderabad
Rep. by its authorized signatory Mr. Venkateswara Rao Kancherla, S/o Late
Shri. Kameshwara Rao, Aged about 58 years, Rl/o Jayadarsini ReskJency, B45, Whitefi eld, Kondapur, Hyderabad-500004, TS.
5. Ws Dione Properties Pvt. Ltd.
(Formerly known as M/s Dimond Farms Pvt. Ltd.). Registered offlce at Lanco
House, Plot No. 4, Software Units Layout Hitech City Madhapur, Hyderabad,
rep. by its authorized signatory Mr. Venkateswara Rao Kancherla, S/o Late
Shri Kameshwara Rao, Aged about 58 years, Rl/o Jayadarsini Residency, B45, Whitefi eld, Kondapur. Hyderabad-S00OO4, TS.
6. Potlapalli Lakshmi Madhavi, Wo Dontula Rakesh, Ar; r: 32 years, Occ:
Employee R/o H.No.7{2, Chinnagopathi Village, Ko I erla i/andal,
Khammam District, T.S.
7. Arani Ramprasad Reddy, S/o A. Jayarami Reddy. Ary, .d about 46 years, Occ:
Business. R:/o Flat No..1104, pegasus_A Wing, I eenakshi Siy lounge,
Khanapet, Kondapur, Hyderabad-5000g4, TS.
8. Thammireddy Sreehari Reddy, S/o T. Narayana F eddy, Aged about
S.l
years, Occ. Business, R/o Villa No.274, lndu F lrtune Fields, KpHB,
Hyderabad 500072, T.S.
9. Tatikonda Lachi Reddy, S/o T. Veera Reddy, Agel about 54 years, Occ.
Business, R/o H.No.2{1/A, Sathyanaiayanalr rram, Chaitanyapuri,
Hyderabad-500060, T.S.
10.Smt. Gaddampally Laxmi, Wo G. Ravinder Reddy Aged about 34 years,
Occ. Employee, R:/o H.No.S-6-1216, plot No. 46 Ror I No. 1, Vaidehinagar,
Beside Liftle Flower Vanasthalipuram, Hayathnagar Ranga Reddy District,
Telangana State.
11.Smt. Doulagar Shivani, W/o Doutagar Kishore, AgeJ about 34 years,
Occ.
Employee, R/o H.No.10-2-17111 , Flat No. 3, Road I lo. 1, Near Narayana
School, West Marredpalty, Nehrunagar, Hydr: abad - 500 026
. ^ ?l"."pt
l2.Gaddampally
Vinay Reddy, S/o. Gaddampalty prabhirt ar Reddy, Aged about
33 years, Occ. Business, Rl/o H.No.3-121, pullicherl.r, Peddavura, Natgonda
District TS - 508 266.
'l3.Poflapalli Sarojini, Wo Seshagiri Rao, Aged about
57 r ears, Occ. Housewife,
R:/o Konijerla, Chinna Gopathi, Khammam District TS .l 07 30S.
14.Kaitha Bhaskar Reddy, S/o Kaitha Ma[a Reddy, Agec about 55 years,
occ.
Employee, R/o H.No.14-47, Reddy corony, Huisniba r, Karimnagar district
TS -505 467.
15. Nukala Pitchamma, wo Katkuri Satyanarayana Redd.r
Aged about 74 years,
Occ. Housewife, R/o H.No..t-6-102l311it3, Vidya t,llgar, Road 'No.o,
Suryapet, Nalgonda Dist. TS-50821 3.
16.P.R. Vinod. S/o Ravindranathan V, Aged about 47 year Occ. Employee,
,
R/o
Perumbarode House, Athipolla, Tarur-ll, palakkad, Atl i ,otta, feraia6Z8 'S++.
lT.Kasarla Varun, S/o Kasarla Venkat Reddy, Aged z )out 2Z years, Occ.
Employee, Rt/o H.No.16-1021311113, 6u' Ward, ,/ jyanagar, Sr.Vrp"t,
Nalgonda District TS-S08 213.
l8.Thokala Sumana, S/o Thokala Jithender Reddy, Agert about 54 years,
Occ.
B.usiness, Rl/o H.No.1-7-1251 , Advocates corony Mairr Road,
Near Erashlta
Park, Balasamaudram, Hanamkonda, Warangal 6istri.t 15-S06
001.
19.Bathi
Bhasker Reddy, S-/o Bathi Ramana Re-ddy, egerl about 37 years, Occ.
Employee, R/o Plot No.67, Om Vihar Colony, f.,,teOipatt,, Ghatkesar,
UeOcnat_
Malkajgiri District TS-509098.
20.Bongarala Tirumara srinivasa Rao, S/o Bongarara Vr,t rabhadra Rao,
Aged
about 39 years, Occ: Employee R/o Flat ru6. fe, plc No. +S, +a, eninu
Brijesh Residency, Neknampur, Ranga Reddy District --: ;_ SO0
Og9.
21 'Gangaraju Sairendra Kumar, S/o Gangaraju Balakrishna
na Raju, Aged about
j.3 years, Occ. Employee, R/o H.No.1S_,t_ZlZ, Fta No. Zb+, -Sri Aaia;i
Nilayam, Spencer Super Market. Bataii Swarnapuri Cr ony, iyol*o"Jis_
-
18.
22.Gufiam Kavya Reddy, D/o Satyanarayana Reddy, Aged about 24 years, Occ.
Service, R/o H.No.1-12, Thimmapuram, Anumula Mandal, yacharam
Nalgonda District TS-508 266.
23.Yogeshwar waman Rao Kuntawar, s/o waman Rao Kuntawar, Aged about
47 years, Occ. SeMce, R/o H.No. 14{5, prestige park, Gundlapocihampally,
Secunderabad, TS.
24.Smt. Arepally Kavitha, Wo peri Naveen Reddy, Aged about 39 years, Occ.
Employee. R/o H. No. 42-211133, Nandhi Hifls, Neai Anus School, Svaiguda,
Mahabubnagar District TS-5091 03.
2s.Bethi Ram Reddy, S/o Bethi Venkat Reddy, Aged about 65 years, Occ.
Retired, R/o H. No. 1-9-315 and 316, Deccan Crescent Heights, Street No.
15, 3d Fbor, Flat No. 305, Vklyanagar, Hyderabad TS -SOOO44.
26. Yeleswarapu Sirisha,, Wo Bulusu phani Kumar, Aged about 43 years, Occ.
Housewife, Rl/o Flat No. zlo2, plot No. 909, Sri Sai Data Residency, Defence
Colony, Sainikpuri, Hyderabad, TS.
27.Smt. Talla Kavitha, Wo Venkat Reddy, Aged about 43 years, Occ:
Housewife, R:/o Flat No. 401, Suyshma Sai Nagar, Road No. 1, Near SR Digi
School Vanasthalipuram, Hayathnagar, Ranga Reddy Dist. TS-SO0070.
28.Smt. Talla Kavitha, Wo Venkat Reddy, Aged about 43 years, Occ.
Housewife, FUo Flat M. 40i, Suyshma Sai Nagar, Road No. 1, lriear SR Digi
School Vanasthalipuram, Hayathnagar, Ranga Reddy Dist. T5_500070.
29.Kandukuri Mjaya Laxmi, Wo K. Janardhan Reddy, Aged about 55 years,
Occ. Housewife, R/o H,No.1-1-26St2lSO1, Srinivasa Nagar, Near RaOniU
Theatre, Kapra, Ranga Reddy District T5-500062.
30.Alturi Venkata Satya Dahrma Rama Raju, S/o Alluri Rama Krishna Raju,
about 56 years, Occ: Business, Rl/o H.No.SO-117-21i4,
4S"d
Seethammadhara NE Layout, Near public Health Office, p and T mlony.
Visakhapatnam (Urban) AP-S3OO1 3.
31 .Tatikonda Padma, Wo Tatikonda Lachi Reddy, Aged about 49 years, Occ.
Housewife. Rl/o H. No.2-61lA, Satyanarayanapuram Near Raghava Hospital,
Chaitanyapuri, Hyderabad TS-500 060.
32.Takikonda Lachi Reddy, S/o T. Veera Reddy, A,ged about 56 years, Occ.
Business, R/o H.No.2€1lA, Satyanarayanapuram, Near Raghava Hospital,
Chaitanyapuri, Hyderabad TS- 500 060.
33.Smt. Pola Dhana Laxmi, Wo Pola Lakhsman Kumar, Aged about 52 years,
Occ: Housewife, R/o Plot No. 43, Jagdish Nagar Cotony, Rasoo-lpura,
Secunderabad TS-5O0O03.
34.Smt. Sumana Panjala, W/o Pratap Chandra Beemagani, Aged about 34
years, Occ: Service Rt/o Flat No. .102, yogesh Residency, Chanda Nagar,
MMT, Siva Temple, Hyderabad TS-S00050.
35.Smt. Madireddy Sai Kumari, Wo Prasanna Rao, Aged about 54 years, Occ:
Housewife R/o H.M.4-1-54l2. Super Bazar Centre, Ramalayam Temple
Road, Fourth Ward, Bhadrachalam. Khammam Dist. TS-507 1 11.
36.Smt. Goddeshi Lavanya, Wo B. Chandar Rao, Aged about 30 years, Occ:
Housewife, R/o H.No.3-5-1 40t4t4. Jammigada, Suryapet TS-S0A 213.
3T.Allareddy Srihari Reddy, S/o A. Mailikarjuna Reddy, Aged about 30 years,
Occ: Private Employee, Ryo Ptot No.62 and 69, Flat No. G-i, Aditya Nilayam,
Near E-seva, Moti Nagar, Balanagar, Medchal-Malkajgiri District, TS-500018.
38.Vishnu Vardhan Kethi Reddy, S/o K. Sudhakar Reddy Aged about 39 years,
Occ: Pvt. Employee, R/o Parlapalli, Vidavalur, Kothavi ngallu, Nellore District
AP-524317.
39.Karempudi Sreedhar Reddy,, S/o Ramama Reddy, \ged about 55 years,
Occ: Business, Wo Plot No. 351 and 356, Flat No. 2 )2, Sy No. 96 to 103,
Poojitha Srinivasam, Friends Colony, Manikonda, I) rppalaguda, Gandipet
Mandal, R.R. District T5-500089.
40. Kaitha Sruthi, D/o Kaitha Bhaskar Reddy, Wo Thumrr r Prudvi Kumar, Aged
about 28 years, Occ: Software Engineer, Rl/o Flat I o. 104, Pruthvi Style
Home, Mahesh Nagar, ECIL, Hyderabad-500062
Presently residing at#1528 Darien Lake DR, Darien lt. ;0561-5083, USA.
...Respondents/Res;1 ondents/Defendants
(Case against Respondents Number is 3, 4, 5, 6, :0, 13, 14, 15, 17,18,
24,27,37,38, 39,4() is not pressed as they are fornr Ll parties)
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under order 39 Rule 1 & 2 R/w Section 151 O ,C praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the g,r tition, the High Court
may be pleased to restrain the Respondents/Defend,: rts from alienating,
mortgaging or creating any third party interest over the r'roperties mentioned
herein:
a, All that part of the in Sy. No. 31 admeasuring to arr extent Ac. 5.22 Gts.
Situated At Kokapet, the Gandipet Mandal, Rang: Reddy district more
pa(iculady described in Schedule-A and
b. All that part of the property in Sy. No. 37 (3712) adnr, a5uling to an extent
Ac. 1-1 8 Gts. Situated At Kokapet, the Gandipet 14 rndal, Ranga Reddy
district more particulady described in Schedule-B
SCHEDULE-A
All that part of the property in Sy. No.31 admeasrr ng to an extent Ac.
5.22 Gts. Situated At Kokapet, the Gandipet Mandal, Ran3 I Reddy district and
bounded by:
North: Part of land in Sy. No. 30
South: 100 feet Road towards Shankerpally
East: Remaining land of the Plaintiffs in Sy. No. 31
West: Land in Sy. No. 33 belongs to Plaintiff
SCHEDULE-B
Alt that part of the prope(y in Sy. No. 37 (3712) adne asuring to an extent
Ac. 1- 1B Gts. Situated At Kokapet, the Gandipet Mandal, t anga Reddy district
and bounded by:
North: Part of land in Sy. No. 31 & 33
South: 100 feet Road towards Shankerpally
East: Remaining land of the Plaintiffs in Sy. No. 37
West: Land in Sy. Nos. 36 & 37 belongs to Plaintiff
Counsel for the Appellant: Sri Thomas George, counsel representing
Sri Manav Gecil Thomas
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: Sri E. Ajay Reddy, Senior Gounsel
representing Ms. E. Anisha Reddy
Counsel for the Respondents No.1,7,8,9,1 1, 1 2,16,19,2O,21,22,23,
25,26,28,29,30,31,32,33,34 and 36 : Sri Sunil B. Ganu, Senior Counsel
representing Ms. Manjari S. Ganu &
Sri T.S. Praveen Kumar
The Court delivered the following: COMMON JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH CCI{.JRT FORTHE STATE OFTELANGAI{A
ATF{YDERABAD
THE Hoiltsl.E JUSTICE MOUSIIUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
CMA Nos.242 and 243 ot 2025
Date: .r 41-2026
CI'IA 1.1o.242 of 2025
Behween
Muadan Murad Dtnnji StBw Oomrigal represented by his GPA Holders
Appellant
And
M/s. FronUine &rilders and 39 otprs
ne+onOents
COMIIIOI{ JUDGMENTz (per Honble Justice Gadi Praven Kumall
1. Since these Civil Miscellaneous Appeals arise out of the common order
' dated 06.03.2025, they are being disposed of by this common judgment.
2. Heard Sri Thomas George, learned counsel for the appellant duly assisted
by Sri Manav Gecil Thomas, Sri Sunil B. Ganu, learned Senior Counsel
representing Ms.Manjiri S.Ganu, learned counsel for the respondents, duly
'
assisted by Sri T.S.Praveen Kumar, Iearned counsel, and Sri E.Ajay Reddy,
, : .'i.!*'te:r'ned Senior Counsel representing Ms.E.Anisha Reddy, learned counsel for
.;,'-.iJ1 .; j...
.{.i1';;;i :,ttre respondent No.2.
Both the CMAs are $led being aggrieved by the common order passed in
I.A.Nos.540 and 541 of 2020 in O.S.No.1.16 of 2020 dated 06.03.2025 by the XI
Additional District & Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District ;r' L.B.Nagar, which
were filed under Order )OO(X Rules 1 and 2 read with Sectior 151 CPC seeking
to restrain the respondents from proceeding with constrl tion or changing
nature of schedule property and also to restrain the espondents from
alienating, mortgaging or creating any third party interest ,ver the schedule
property.
4. The /s arises out of a long-standing dispute conceming e; tensive extents of
land situated at AraziMaktaKokapet, now known as Koket :t Village. within
Gandipet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, forming part tf the erstwhile
Hyderabad State and presenuy within the State of Telanganl The lands involve
portions of Survey Nos.31, 36 and 37(property) forming part cf a larger extent
historically described as AraziMaktaKokapet,the charlter, ownership,
possession, and legal incidents attached to the said lands fr,r n the core of the
dispute.
5. The appellan{plaintiff claims rights over the suit schedul : lands basing on
the registered sale deeds executed in the month of October . 965, whereas the
respondents/defendants assert independent title, possessi) r and enjoyment
through separate chains of @nveyance, revenue recorc;/ and statutory
permissions.
6. The appellanVpetitioner contends before the trial : ,urt that having
purchased part of the property under a registered sale dee(l lated 20.10.1965
and the remaining extent having been purchased by iri ; sister under a
registered sale deed dated 19.10.1965. It was pleaded that he petitioner and
his sister were in peaceful possession and enjoyment of tl: properties ever
(
I
sirrce the purchases and that, upon the death of his sister in tl're year 2018, the
petitioner became the absolute owner of her share also by virtue of a Will dated
09.L2.2017, which was duly probated by the High Court of Bombay'
7. It was further contended that taking advantage of the abnormal escalation
of land values and the absence of the petitioner, certain third parties and land
grabbers created false and fabricated documents and, in collusion with the
respondents, illegally entered upon the suit schedule property in the year 2018.
The petitioner asserted that earlier interference in the year 2011 was resisted
by filing O.S. No.337 of 2011 for injunction, which was decreed in his favour,
thereby recognising his possession.
8. The petitioner contends that despite issuance of public notice and reply
thereto asserting his ownership and possession, the respondents proceeded to
purchase the property under registered sale deeds of the year 2016, which,
according to the petitioner, are void and not binding, as the vendors themselves
had no title. It was contended that based on such invalid documents, the
respondents obtained construction permissions from HMDA and comrnenced
construction, compelling the petitioner to approach the High Court and
thereafter the civil court as advised.
9. It was contended that he had never conveyed or transfurred the suit
schedule property to any person and that the respondents are rank trespassers,
who are attempting to change the nature of the property and create third-party
rights. The petitioner pleaded that he has made out a strong prima facie case,
that balance of convenience lies in his favour, and that irreparable loss would
be caused if the respondents are not restrained fronr proceeding with
construction and alienation.
10. On these premises, the petitioner sought temporary inir nction restraining
the respondents from changing the nature of the suit sch,: lule property and
from alienating or creating third-pafi interest therein penci rg disposal of the
suit.
11. The respondent No.l/defendant No.1 filed counter-affidirr it before the Trial
Court and the same was adopted by the respondents/defenrl; nts No.l, 7,8,9,
t7, t2, 16, 19,20,21,22,23,25,26,29,29,30,31,32,:i. , 34 and 36. The
respondents contentedthat the suit, as ftamed, is wholly m s :onceived, legally
untenable, and founded on incorrect and suppressed le is. Though the
petitioner asserts that he was dispossessed in the year 2013 the respondents
categorically denied the same and pleaded thatthe suit sch3lule propefi has
been in the continuous possession and enjoyment of the resl rndents and their
predecessors in title from as early as 1979-1981 onwards. . : was specifically
pleaded that neither the petitioner nor his predecessos were r ver in possession
of the suit lands and that the plea of dispossession is a false e rd invented claim
intended to bring the suit within limitauon.
12. The respondents further contended that the petitioners claim of title is
fundamentally flawed, as his alleged vendors themselves had no title or
possession over the suit schedule property.
It was a; erted that late
NawabNusrat Jung-I was never the owner or possessor of the ,ubject lands and
that the so-called twenty-eight persons projected as his legal I eirs are fictitious
and had no legal relationship or interest in the property. Cc rsequently, they
(
had no authority to execute any power of attorney. The alleged power of
attorney relied upon by the petitioner was stated to be vague, not describing
the property, survey numbers or extent, tracing no title, created for a limited
purpose, and not zubsistlng on the date of execution of the alleged sale deeds
of 1965, rendering the said sale deeds void and inoperative.
13. The respondents contended that the title to the subject lands, particularly
in Survey No.31 admeasuring Ac.16-13 guntas, vested in one Mohammed Azam
Saab, whose name stood recorded as pattadar and possessor in the
KhasraPahani fior the year 1954-55. After his death, his legal heirs alienated
various extents of land through registered sale deeds commencing from the
year 1979 onwards. Thereafter, the property changed hands through a series of
registered conveyances in the years 1981, 1984, 1986, 1989, 1997,2004 and
2006, all supported by mutations in revenue records, issuance of pattadar
passbooks and tiue deeds, and continuous enjoyment by successive purchasers.
14. The respondents contended that entities such as M/s. Prabhakar
Investment h/t. Ltd., M/s. Padmalaya Enterprises h^. Ltd' (later known as M/s'
Yamuna Enterprises h/t. Ltd.), M/s. Ruby Agro Farms h^. Ltd., M/s. Diamond
Farms hrt. Ltd., M/s. Pearl Farms h/t. Ltd., M/s. Neptune Projects Art. Ltd. and
M/s. Uranus Projects h/t. Ltd. derived valid title under registered instrunrents,
carried on agricukural operations, developed orchards and farmhouses, and
their possession stood reflected in revenue records for decades. Ultimately,
under registered sale deeds dated 22.08.2016, the respondents acquired the
suit schedule extents, after which further alienations and development
agreements were executed, resulting in creation of :hird-party righE,
construction of residential complexes, and occupation by pun hasers.
15. It was therefore contended that the petitioner, havir I neither title nor
possession, cannot seek declaration or injunction in resp,r
J of lands which
stood alienated long prior to the institution of the suit. It I 'as urged that the
suit is hopelessly barred by limitation, that the petiuoner fa I d to establish any
prima facie case or balance of convenience, and that n,t ineparable injury
would be caused to him by refusal of injunction, whereas tErnt of injunction
would seriously prejudice the respondents and innorr nt third parties.
Accordingly, the respondenE prayed for dismissal of the interlocutory
applications.
16. Respondent No.2/defendant No.2 filed a separate count :r-affidavit before
the Trial Court contending that the suit schedule property i rms part of patta
lands originally owned and possessed by one Mohammed ! uam Saab, whose
name stood recorded as pattadar and possessor in the Ktri srapahani for the
year 1954-55 and in successive pahanipatrikas till 1978-79. tpon his death on
t2.03.1973, his legal heirs succeeded to the estate anc alienated various
extents through registered sale deeds commencing fror the year 1979
onwards. From that point, the property passed through an rnbroken chain of
registered conveyances, mutations, and revenue entri€ s culminating in
acquisition by the respondents and their predeoessors, iti of whom were
reflected as pattadars and possessors in the official revenue re:ords.
17. Itwas contended that the lands in survey Nos.31 and i7, to the extent
relevant to the present proceedings, were successively alier rted in favour of
r
Dr. M. Nagarathnamma, Sri K.P. HarikrishnaBabu, M/s. Prabhakar Investments
A/t. Ltd., M/s. Padmalaya Enterprises h/t. Ltd., and thereafter in favour of
various corporate entities, including M/s. Ruby Agro Farms h/t. Ltd., M/s.
Diamond Farms hlt. Ltd., and M/s. Peari Farms hrt. Ltd., all under registered
instruments. Each such alienation was followed by mutation in revenue records,
issuance of pattadar passbooks and title deeds, and continuous possession and
enjoyment of the land, including agricultuml operations and development
activities.
18. Respondent No.2 further contended that it acquired title to specific extents
under registered sale deeds dated 22.08.2016 and thereafter entered into
development agreements, while Respondent No.1 obtained development rights
from several landowners, consolidated contiguous extents, secured statutory
permissions from HMDA' and commenced construction of a multi-storied
residential complex. It was asserted that substantial construction has been
completed and third-party rights have been created pursuant to valid
development agreements and conveyances, thereby altering the nature of the
property long prior to the institution of the suit.
19. It was specifically contended that the petitioner's claim of title based on
Muntakhab No.57 of 1955 and ttre sale deeds of the year 1965 is wholly
untenable. According to Respondent No.2, the said Muntakhab has been
declared vold and unenforceable by governmental orders and judicial
pronouncements, which attained finality up to the Honble Supreme Court. It
was pleaded that neither NawabNusrat Jung-l nor his alleged legal heirs were
ever reflected in the rerrenue records as owners or possesso6 of the lands in
Kokapet Village and that the petitioner failed to establish ny flow of title or
,
possession from the said Muntakhab.
20. Respondent No.2 therefore contended that the petitir ner, whose name
never figured in revenue records and whose vendors them s :lves had no right,
title, or interest, cannot seek declaration or injunction again t the respondenG,
who trace their title through lawful conveyances and long-r;t lnding possession.
It was urged that the suit and interlocutory applications are an abuse of
process, filed after noticing extensive development, and J at no prima facie
case, balance of convenience, or irreparable injury is marl
out. Accordingly,
R6pondent No.2 prayed for dismissal of the petition with e>r mplary costs.
21. Basing on the above pleadings, the Trial Court framed he following point
for its consideration:
"Whether the petitions can be allowd as prayed for re*aining t e respondents from
changing the nature of the petition schedule proprty ard aliena, hg or creating third
pa fty in terest th ereo ver ? "
22. During the course of enquiry, the Trial Court marked I xs.P.l to p.31 on
behalf of the appellant and Exs.R.l to R.90 & 90/A m behalf of the
respondents.
23. While recording various contentions in the backdrop of t re documents, the
Trial Court finally held that the primafacie case and balance ,f convenience are
not in favour of the appellant, though he can be, if at ,l , to be stated, a
dispute worth gone into during trial but it is not substantia :nough to restrain
the respondents from alienating the suit schedule properq, :o third parties or
change the nature of the property, therefore, held the: the balance of
convenience is not sufficiently proved 5r
'.- aopellanVpetit r ner so as to order
I
injunction against the respondents as prayed for. Therefore, the question of the
appellant suffering loss or hardship is a remote possibility and accordingly,
dismissed the applications.
24. Learned counsel for the appellant contends that AraziMaKaKokapet was
originally purchased under registered sale dd
vide document bearing
No.948/65 dated 20.10.1965 and appellanfs sister, viz.,l4s.FaridhaDhanji shaw
oomrigarpurchased land in suwey Nos.31 and 36 under registered sale deed
dated 19.10.1965. It is further zubmitted that originally AraziMaktaKokapet was
purchased in the year 1852 by NawabNusrat Jung-I as his self-acquired
property and that the said land never formed part of any Jagir or Government
land.
25. The learned counsel for the appellant, upon the demise of Nusrat Jung-I,
succession disputes arose among legal heirs, leading to various enquiries before
the competent authorities of the erstwhile Hyderabad state to determine the
true legal heirs and the nature ofthe land.
26. Learned counsel further cOntends that after exhausting enquifies, the
authoritative categorically held that tfre land was the self-acquired property of
Nusrat Jung-I and that his legal heirs were entiued to succeed to the sarne. In
support of the same, he placed strong reliance upon Atiyavlnam proceedings'
which further culminated in the issuance of Muntakhab l,lo. 57 0f 1955,
declaring the legal heirs of Nusrat Jung-I as the holders of AraziMaktaKokapet.
27. It is also contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the Atiyat
court, being a civil court under the releyant statute, passed a final and binding
order, and that no appeal was preferred within the statutory period, thereby
rendering the Muntakhabas a final document and that the sr t sequent attempts
by revenue authorities to question, cancel or refuse impl€ xentation of the
Muntakhab were legally impermissible and contrary to statutor / provisions.
28. The appellant further contends
that multipl( governmental
correspondences, internal notes, and memoranda issued ov: several decades
acknowledging the binding nature of the Muntakhab rnd directed its
implementation, though such directions were not canied out r practice.Learned
counsel also submits that administrative failure or inaction c r the part of the
State cannot defeat or dilute vested proprietary rights recog r sed by judicial or
quasi-judicial orders.
29. Learned counsel for the appellant further contends that all the legal heirs of
Nusrat Jung-I executed General Powers of Attorney in favour r f Sri J.H. Krishna
Murthy, authorising him to manage, recover and alienate the ands covered by
the Muntakhab.He asserts that acting under valid authority, t re said Power of
Attomey holder executed registered sale deeds in October' 1965, conveying
portions of the land in Survey Nos.31, 36, and 37 in favour 01' he appellant and
his sister.
30. According to the learned counsel for the appellant, tte execution of
registered sale deeds conferred absolute title, and symbolic or legal possession
followed such conveyance, even if physical possession ,r ls subsequently
disturbed.It is further contended that the appellanfs sister, wh > purchased land
in Survey No. 31, passed away on 28.11.2018 after t xecuting a Will
bequeathing the property in favour of the appellant and that I robate has been
granted by a competent Court.
31. It is further contended that the appellant and his predecessors were
constrained to reside outside Hyderabad for long periods, cluring which time
unauthorised third parties began to interfere with the suit lands.Learned
counsel relies upon earlier civil proceedings, including a suit for injunction filed
in the year 2011, wherein injunction was granted against third-party
interference, to contend that possession was recognised by Courts.
32. Learned counsel further submits that degite issuance of legal notices
objecting to proposed alienations and developments, the respondents
proceeded to execute sale deeds and obtain permissions without resolving the
underlying title dispute.It is alleged that ttle statutory authorities granted
permissions mechanically, without proper verification of title or consideration of
objections raised by the appellant.
33. Learned counsel for the appellant contends that subsequent constructions,
developments and creation of third-pafi irterests by the respondents are
illegal, void, and subject to the outcome of the suit pending before the learned
Trial Court, therefore, prays that unless injunctive relief is granted, the suit
itself would be rendered infructuous and that the appellant would be subjected
to irreparable loss.
34. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent Nos.l, 7,8,9, lL, 12, L6,
19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 25, 26, 28, 29, 30, 3L, 32, 33, 34 and 36, would contend
that the subject suit filed for declaration of title and reco\ery of possession and
therefore the entire burden lies upon the appellant to establish a clear, valid,
and subsisting title.The respondenb placed reliance on Muntakhab No.57 of
't2
1955, without proof of its implementation or delivery of pt;session, does not
confer actionable title capable of being enforced against the t tird parties.
35. Leamed counsel for the res@ndents further assert th,r the alleged legal
heirs of Nusrat Jung-I never obtained possession pursuant o the Muntakhab
and were themselves continuously approaching the Governl ent for release of
lands, which demonstrates lack of possession.It is specificrr y contended that
the Power of Attorney relied upon for the 1965 sale deeds I rd limited validity,
stood expired prior to execution of the sale deeds and was n )t executed by all
persons named in the Muntakhab.According to the respor( ents, the alleged
vendors under the 1965 sale deeds had no marketable or tr:r sferable title, and
therefore could not convey any valid right to the appellant.
36. Leamed counsel for the respondenB also conten,l .that no survey
identification or demarcation of lands was ever effectec pursuant to the
Muntakhab, rendering the appellant's claim vague and rrr enforceable.It is
contended that revenue records, including Khasrapahani cf 19S4-S5 and
subsequent pahanis, consistently reflect possession of third pi rties and not the
appellant or his predecessors.
37. It is further contended by the learned counsel that the re;pondents mainly
rely upon mutation orders, registered sale deeds from the y( lr 1981 onwards
and continuous revenue entries to establish settled possesskrr and enjoyment;
and that prior civil proceedings resulted in findings that ttrt heirs of Nusrat
Jung-I were entiued only to commutation or monetary be r :fits
possession of the land.
"nJ'ffi***-"-
38. Learned counsel finally submits that the appeal is misconceived and is liable
to be dismissed, only on the ground that the appellant approached the Court
with inordinate delay and acquiescence, disentitling him to equitable relief.
Therefore, contended that the learned Trial Court has rightly dismissed the
applications, since, the appellant has failed to satisff the three
requirements, rrz,primafacie case, balance of convenience, and ineparable loss
would be caused if injunction is not granted.
39. Learned counsel for the respondent No.2 submits that the respondent No.2
is a bona fide purchaser/developer which acquired rights through registercd
conveyances from persons whose names stood recorded as pattedars and
possessors in revenue records.It is asserted that revenue entries beginning
from the KhasraPahani of 1954-55 onwards constitute primary record-of-rights,
carrying statutory presumption of correctness.
zl0. Learned counsel for the Respondent No.2 further submits that neither the
name of the appellant nor his predecessors were ever reflected in revenue
records at any point of time and that the respondent No.2 obtained all statutory
permissions and sanctions, including development permissions and occupancy
certificates, after thorough verification by the competent authorities.
41. Learned counselalso asserts that substantial @nstruction has been
completed and that third-party purchasers have acquired flats and formed
associations, thereby creating irreversible third-party rights.It is vehemently
contended that granting injunction at this stage would severely prejudice
innocent purchasers who are not parties to the original transactions of 1965
and that the appellant had deemed notice of registered trar ;actions under the
Registration Act and Transfer of Property Act.
42. According to the learned counsel for the respondent ilo.2, the suit and
interlocutory applications wereinstituted making an attentt t to unsettle the
settled rights after decades of silence and therefore contenc ( C that damages, if
any, would be an adequate remedy and that injuncti,/ r relief is wholly
unwarranted and submits that the Trial Court has rightly ext:r :ised its discretion
and refused to grant temporary injunction warranting interft:r :nce by this Court
and contended to dismiss the appeals with exemplary costs.
43. We have given our earnest considerdtion and perused tlr record.
.14. Upon considering the various aspects and for better r nderstanding, we
once again examine'Khasra'as held by the Hon'ble Suprem,: Court in State of
Andhra Pradsh tfirough Principal Secretaty and otlers Vs. hatap
Karan and othetl, 'Khasra' is a register recording the inc lents of a tenure
and is a historical record. Khasra would serve the purpos€ tf a deed of tiUe,
when there is no other title deed.
45. On the other hand, a 'Muntakhab' is a document recogrri ;ed under Section
74 of the Indian Evidence Act as a public document. It ordiri nly contains a list
of names along with the survey numbers or fields held by il- r original grantee
or his successors. A certificate issued by the competent aLt rority recognising
succession may form part of a Muntakhab or may, by rt;elf, constitute a
Muntakhab. When such recognition is preceded by an enrl iry, it involves a
determination of rights. Nevertheless, though a Muntakhet is a public and
'1zo ro1 z scc az
privileged document within the meaning of Sections 74 aN 123 of the Evidence
Act, the rights flowing therefrom must be shown to have been implemented
and translated into possession and revenue recognition in accordance with law'
z16. Keeping the above principles in view, it is to be noted tlrat o.s. No.146 of
2020 was instituted by the appellant seeking declaration of title and recovery of
possession, along with I.A. Nos.540 and 541 of 2020 seeking ternporary
injunction to restrain the respondents from alienating, mortgaging or creating
third-party interest over the suit schedule property. The material on record
reveals that the appellant has failed to demonstrate a clear and subsisting title.
on the conkary, Respondent No.2 traces iE title through predecessors whose
names are reflected in the KhasraPahani for the year 1954-55. significantly, the
appellanrs name does not find place in the KhasraPahani or in any subsequent
revenue records.
47.Tlr- appellanfs claim of title is founded primarily on Muntakhab No.57 of
1955. However, the said Muntakhab was declared void by Memo dated
21.05.2005 issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh, which attained
finality up to the Hon'ble supreme court by order dated 04.10.2017 in civil
Appeal Nos.15 57 L-72 of 2Ol7 . Once the root document itself has been declared
void and unenforceable, no right, title or interest can be claimed or traced
therefrom.
48. The flow of title, as borne out by the respondents'documents, is traceable
to Mohammed Azam saab, whose name is recorded as pattadar and possessor
in the KhasraPahani for the year 1954-55. The said KhasraPahani, being the
primary record of rights in respect of agrrultural lands in the state of
'1
Telangana, constitutes strong prima facie evidence of tifle rnd possession in
favour of the respondents' predecessors.
49. A further examination of the appellanfs documents shrr rs that reliance is
placed on a General Power of Attorney dated 05.09.1962 alt: pdly executed by
the legal heirs of Nusrat Jung-I. The said GpA does not :oeciry the survey
numbers or extents of the subject land. Though it purP ,rtedly authorised
recovery of the propefi from the Government and alienal:i rn thereof, it was
valid only for a limited period and stood expired prior to th, execution of the
registered sale deeds of the year 1965. Moreover, the ; leged legal heirs
themselves are not shown as vendors in the sale deeds, ar , the GpA holder,
having no independent title, could not have conveyed any vEl J right.
50. Apart from the above, Section 47 of the Andhra pradesl- (Tetangana Area)
Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act mandates prior permiss ( n of the Tahsildar
for transfer of agricultural lands during the relwant period. 1 lmittedly, no such
permission was obtained for the sale deeds dated 19.10.19,( 5 and 20.10.1965
relied upon by the appellant. Consequenfly, the said sale 11, ,eds are invalid in
law and incapable of conferring any right, title or interest.
51. The record further discloses that the appellant was ne\4 r in possession of
the suit schedule property.Even the earlier litigation, incturirg W.p. N0.227 of
1960, proceeded on the footing that possession was witl the Govemrnent.
There is no pleading or material to show that the GpA holde r ever took steps to
recover possession pursuant to the Muntakhab. In fact, Jespite prolonged
litigation spanning several decades, the Muntakhab tas never been
implemented and possession was never delivered to tlre alleged legal heirs of
Nusrat lung-I.
52. On the other hand, the respondents have produced voluminous
documentary evidence, including Sethwar, KhasraPahani (Exs.R-l to R-10),
subsequent pahanis (Ex.R-11), registered sale deeds from the year 1981
onwards (Ec.R-12 to R-U), and revenue proceedings (Exs.R-18 to R-31),
which clearly demonstrate a consistent and successive tracing of title and
possession. These documents establish continuous enjoyment of the property
by the respondents and their predecessors from 195't-55 till date.
53. It is also relevant to note that the registered sale deeds executed from July
1981 onwards constitute deemed notice under Section 3 of the Registration Act
and Section 3 of the Transfer of Propefi Act. Despite such long-standing
registered transactions and revenue entries, the appellant remained silent for
decades and has now sough! at a belated stage, to cancel documents executed
between 1979 and 2010, which relief is clearly barred by limitation.
54. The appellant has not placed on record a single document evidencing
settled possession at any point of time. The allegation of dispossession in the
year 2018 is vague, unsupported by particulars and not followed by prompt
legal action. Such bald assertions cannot dislodge consistent revenue entries
and registered @nveyarrces standing in favour of the respondents.
55. The learned Trial Court, upon a detailed consideration of the nnterial,
rightly held that the sale deeds dated 19.10.1965 and 20.10.1965 did not
:
emanate from persons having valid and transferable title and, therefore, could
not create any right, title or interest in favour of the appellant. Per contra, the
respondenb' tiUe is traceable through lawful conveyarx 3s supported by
revenue records dating back to 1954-55.
56. The record further reveals that Respondent No.l obrirned all statutory
permissions, completed construction, obtained occupancy rr rtificate from the
Hyderabad Metropolitan Development Authority and sold f rts to third-party
purchasers, who have also formed a registered association. ( rant of injunction
at this stage would unsettle crystallised third-party rights and cause grave
prejudice.
57. In applications filed under order )cc(x Rules 1 and 2 lpc, the plaintiff
must cumulatively establish a prima facie case, balance o' convenience and
irreparable injury. In the present case, the appellant has f;i:d to establish a
prima facie right, any alleged injury and even balance of r onvenience is in
favour of the respondents, who are in setHed possession anJ have altered the
nature of the property pursuant to lawful permissions.
58. considering the various rival claims and considering th e exhibits marked
therein, the learned rrial court rightly held that there is no rima facie case,
balance of convenience and ineparable injury in favour or the appellants.
Therefore, basing on the material available on record, the kr, rned rrial court
arrived at a right conclusion that the appellants have failed c establish their
case.
59. This Court is of the view that the said findings recorded b,r lhe tearned Trial
court cannot be interfered with, since the said findings are r-' orded based on
the evidence on record.
60. However, to meet the ends of justie, we deem it fit to direct the leamed
Trial court to decide tfrc suit as expeditiously as possible on priority basis.
61. Accordingly, C.M.A.Nos.242 and 243 of 2025, along with all connected
applications, are dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs'
Sd/. K. SRINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGISTRAR
/TTRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
to',.
,n" Xl Additlonal District and sessions Judge' Ranga Reddy
L.B.Nagar.
Advocate[oPUCl
z. O""Cdt Sri ManavGecil Thomas'
Advocate !91rcl
;. il; ca i; M". E. AnishaS' Reddv'
;. o;; cc to tt". Manjari Ganu' Advocate [oPUCl
5. Two CD CoPies
k &tTt ,w
r
District at
HIGH COURT
DATED:0810112026
Fi
1 HE
o
C)
COMMON JUDGMENT
CMA.Nos .242 and 243 ot 202
DISMISSING BOTH THE CMA's
o
t(
1',)
rl-
?
*
t
clI
7[?f,
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review