Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/munna-sahni-vs-the-state-of-bihar-20260729/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Civil

Munna Sahni vs The State of Bihar

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Patna High Court
Date
29 July 2026
Case No.
CWJC 379/2026
Result
Allowed
Bench
A. Abhishek Reddy
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

12. Having regard to the above, the present writ Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 10/10 petition stands allowed and consequently the impugned order dated 12.12.2025 is set aside. The petitioner is restored to the post of Mukhiya.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.379 of 2026 ====================================================== Munna Sahni S/o Badri Sahani, R/o Ward No. 13, Rasalpur, Dahia, P.S. Bhagwanpur, Begusarai, Bihar- 851112. 1. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus The State of Bihar through Principal Secretary, Panchayati Raj Department, Government of Bihar. 2. Divisional Commissioner, Munger. 3. The District Magistrate, Begusarai. 4. The Block Development Officer, Bhagwanpur, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance : For the Petitioner/s For Respondent For the Respondent/s : : : : : : : Mr. Dayanand Singh, Adv. Mr. Apurv Harsh, Adv. Mr. Manu Tripurari, Adv. Ms. Jaya Singh, Adv. Ms. Tanu Priya, Adv. Mr. Government Pleader (10) Mr. Satya Vrat, AC to GP10 ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. ABHISHEK REDDY ORAL ORDER 29-07-2026 Heard the learned counsel for the parties. The present writ petition has been filed for the following relief(s):“I. For issuance of appropriate writ / orders /direction thereby quashing / setting aside the order as contained therein memo no. 14861 dated 12.12.2025 whereby and whereunder the Petitioner has been removed from post of Mukhiya under Section 18(5) of Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006. II. For issuance of appropriate writ / orders /direction thereby staying the operation of the order as contained therein memo no. 14861 dated 12.12.2025 during the pendency and till disposal of the instant writ petition. III. Any other appropriate writ or direction which may deem fit and proper including the cost.” Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 2/10 3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner submits that the impugned order dated 12.12.2025 passed by the respondent authority under 18(5) of Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006 is contrary to the provisions of the Act, principles of natural justice and equity and also the evidence on record. Learned counsel submits that the petitioner was elected as Mukhiya in the year 2021 and thereafter, on a complaint made by the Upmukhiya made an unsubstantiated allegation of misappropriation and embezzlement of funds of the Gram Panchayat against the petitioner and approached this Hon’ble Court by way of CWJC No. 9231 of 2022. The said CWJC was disposed of on 19.01.2024 directing the Addl. Chief Secretary, Panchayati Raj to take action under Section 18(5) of the Act. Thereafter, the Lok Prahari case was instituted and the petitioner was issued notice, the notice sought the explanation of the petitioner and why action should not be taken against the petitioner. That the Lok Prahari vide order dated 10.09.2024 in Lok Prahari Case No. 2 of 2024 had categorically held that the petitioner has not misappropriated/ embezzled any funds of the panchayat funds and action may be taken for violation of guidelines and procedure of the Panchayati Raj Act. Thereafter, the respondent authority has issued a notice dated 20.12.2024 Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 3/10 which did not contain any specific allegation against the petitioner and the said notice was issued on the basis of an observation made by the Lok Prahari. That the petitioner has appeared before the said authority and filed his written reply on 03.01.2025. Thereafter, after a gap of almost more than 11 months, the authority vide order dated 12.12.2025 has passed the impugned order and the petitioner was removed from the post of Mukhiya. Learned counsel submits that the order passed by the authority does not contain any details of the embezzlement/ misappropriation or the lapses committed by the petitioner except vaguely alleging that the petitioner has not discharged his duties in a proper manner and has acted contrary to the departmental guidelines. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that once the Lok Prahari had given a categorical finding that the petitioner had not embezzled or misappropriated any money from the Gram Panchayat merely because the petitioner has not followed the guidelines, the same cannot be a ground for removal of the petitioner from the elected post of Mukhiya. Further, learned counsel submits that neither the order passed by the Lok Prahari nor the show cause notice issued to the petitioner contain any specific allegations or specific averments with regard to the guidelines that were Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 4/10 prescribed and the violations of the said guidelines, if any. That the petitioner cannot be equated with an employee of the Gram Panchayat, as he is an elected member. That the removal of the petitioner is contrary to the well settled principles of law and also the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and this Hon’ble Court wherein it has been held that persons elected through democratic means should not be removed in a casual manner. Further, learned counsel submits that the impugned order absolutely does not contain any reasons except stating that the petitioner has not followed the guidelines of the department. Learned counsel therefore, prays this Hon’ble Court to allow the prayer sought in the present writ petition and consequently, set aside the impugned order dated 12.12.2025 and restore the petitioner as Mukhiya of the Gram Panchayat, Rasalpur Panchayat, Block- Bhagwanpur, District- Begusarai. 4. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent authority has vehemently opposed the very maintainability of the present writ petition. Learned counsel has stated that though the Lok Prahari has held that the petitioner has not embezzled or misappropriated any amounts, the Lok Prahari had categorically given a finding that the petitioner has violated the guidelines issued by the Department Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 5/10 while procuring material and also issuing work orders to contractors. Learned counsel has stated that the authority has passed the impugned order duly taking into account the observations made by the Lok Prahari which is a competent authority for taking action against the petitioner. Learned counsel has stated that the petitioner has misused his office and spent the funds of the Gram Panchayat contrary to the guidelines issued by the Panchayat Raj Department from time to time. Learned counsel has therefore, prayed this Hon’ble Court to dismiss the present writ petition. 5. In order to appreciate the issue involved in the present writ petition, it is necessary to extract the relevant portions of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006 more specifically, Section 18(5) which reads as under; “18. Resignation or Removal of Mukhiya or Up-Mukhiya — (1) ….. (2) ….. (3) …… (4) …… (5) Without prejudice to the provisions under this Act, if, in opinion of the Commissioner having territorial jurisdiction over the Gram Panchayat, a Mukhiya or an UpMukhiya of Gram Panchayat absents himself without sufficient cause for more than three consecutive meetings or sittings or willfully omits or refuses to perform his duties and functions under this Act, or abuses the power vested in him or is found to be guilty of misconduct in the discharge of his duties or becomes physically or mentally incapacitated for Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 6/10 performing his duties or is absconding, being an accused in a criminal case for more than six months, the Commissioner may, after giving the Mukhiya or UpMukhiya a reasonable opportunity for explanation, by order, remove such Mukhiya or Up-Mukhiya, as the case may be, from office. The Mukhiya or Up-Mukhiya so removed shall not be eligible for re-election as Mukhiya or Up-Mukhiya or Member of Gram Panchayat during the remaining term of office of such Gram Panchayat. (6) Appeal shall lie before the Member, Board of Revenue against the order of the Commissioner.” 6. The impugned order dated 12.12.2025 vide Order No. २प/ववि०-17-04/2024/14861/पपं०ररा० पटनरा passed by the authority removing the petitioner from the post of Mukhiya is extracted below for easy understanding; “ललोक प्रहरर-सह-आययुक्त, मयुमुंगगेर प्रममुं डल, मयुमुंगगेर द्ववारवा ववाद समुं ० -02/2024 मगेमुं पवाररत आदगेश कर प्ररत रवभवाग कलो उपलब्ध करवायर गयर हहै । 2. उक्त आदगेश मगेमुं ललोक प्रहरर-सह-आययुक्त, मयुमुंगगेर प्रममुं डल, मयुमुंगगेर द्ववारवा द्ववारवा शर मयुन्नवा सहनर, मयुरखियवा, गवाम पमुं चवायत-रसलपयुर, प्रखिण्ड-भगववानपयुर, रजिलवा-बगेगगूसरवाय कलो रवभवागरय आदगेश कर अवहगे लनवा करतगे हयुए रवत्तरय अरनयरमततवा बरतनगे हगे तयु दलोषर मवानतगे हयुए रबहवार पमुं चवायत रवाजि अरधरनयम, 2006 कर धवारवा-18(5) कगे अधरन कवारर्रववाई करनगे कर अनयुशमुंसवा कर गयर हहै । 3. इस क्रम मगेमुं रवभवागरय पतवामुंक -12255 रदनवामुंक 20.12.2024 द्ववारवा गरठित आरलोपलोमुं कगे समुं बमुंध मगेमुं एवमुं पररववादर शर लक्ष्मण कयु मवार रवाय , उप मयुरखियवा द्ववारवा मवाननरय उच्च न्यवायवालय, पटनवा मगेमुं दवायर ववाद समुं ख्यवा -9231/2023 मगेमुं पवाररत न्यवायवादगेश कगे अनयुपवालन मगेमुं आरलोरपत मयुरखियवा एवमुं पररववादर शर लक्ष्मण कयु मवार रवाय , उप मयुरखियवा, अपर मयुख्य कवायर्रपवालक पदवारधकवारर, बगेगगूसरवाय तथवा प्रखिण्ड पमुं चवायत रवाजि पदवारधकवारर, तगेघडवा कलो पक्ष रखिनगे हगे तयु नलोरटस रनगर्रत रकयवा गयवा। 4. रनगर्रत नलोरटस कगे अनयुपवालन मगेमुं रनधवार्रररत रतरथ कलो शर मयुन्नवा सहनर , मयुरखियवा, गवाम पमुं चवायत रसलपयुर, प्रखिण्ड-भगववानपयुर, रजिलवा-बगेगगूसरवाय, पररववादर शर लक्ष्मण कयु मवार रवाय , उप मयुरखियवा एवमुं अपर मयुख्य कवायर्रपवालक पदवारधकवारर , बगेगगूसरवाय तथवा प्रखिण्ड पमुं चवायत रवाजि पदवारधकवारर, तगेघडवा उपरसथत हयुए। 5. आरलोरपत मयुरखियवा द्ववारवा अपनगे बचवाव मगेमुं कहवा गयवा रक ललोक प्रहरर नगे अपनगे जिवाजाँच मगेमुं गबन कवा आरलोप प्रमवारणत नहरमुं पवायवा। इस समुं बमुंध मगेमुं रवसतवारपगूवर्रक ललोक प्रहरर कगे आदगेश कगे अवललोकनलोपरवामुंत यह सपष्ट हयुआ रक जिवाजाँच रकयगे गयगे चवारलोमुं यलोजिनवाओ मुं मगेमुं असथवायर गबन एवमुं गलत मद सगे अरगम रनकवासर/अरनयरमत रनकवासर/रनरध कवा गलत मद मगेमुं उपयलोग पवायवा गयवा हहै । अततः आरलोपर मयुरखियवा कवा यह बचवाव सवरकवार यलोग्य नहरमुं हहै । Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 7/10 6. आरलोरपत मयुरखियवा द्ववारवा यह भर वरणर्रत रकयवा गयवा रक रवरभन्न यलोजिनवाओ मुं कगे रदशवा-रनदगेर्रश कगे समुं बमुंध मगेमुं प्रखिमुं ड रवकवास पदवारधकवारर कगे ममौरखिक आदगेश कगे अनयुसवार कवायर्र रकयवा गयवा। ललोक सगेवक हलोनगे कगे नवातगे आरलोरपत मयुरखियवा इस बवात सगे अवगत हलोमुंगगे रक सरकवारर रदशवा -रनदगेर्रश ममौरखिक रगूप सगे प्रवाप्त हलोनगे कर रसथरत मगेमुं ससमय सम्पयुरष्ट हलोतर हहै , ऐसगे मगेमुं मवात प्रखिमुं ड रवकवास पदवारधकवारर कगे तथवाकरथत रनदगेश कगे आललोक मगेमुं अपनर व्यरक्तगत इच्छवा कगे अनयुरपगू गलत व्यय (expenditure) कर दगेनवा अथववा रनणर्रय लगेनवा अनयुरचत हहै । 7. आरलोरपत मयुरखियवा द्ववारवा ववादर उप मयुरखियवा कगे रवरगूद्ध करतपय आरलोप लगवातगे हयुए कहवा गयवा रक वगे आपरवारधक प्रववरत्त कगे व्यरक्त हहैमुं। इस समुं दभर्र मगेमुं यद्यरप आवगेदक कगे रवरगूद्ध रकसर भर प्रकवार कगे आरलोप हलो , उसगे मयुरखियवा कगे द्ववारवा गलत करनगे कगे रलए आधवार नहरमुं मवानवा जिवा सकतवा हहै । 8. अततः ललोक प्रहरर सगे प्रवाप्त अनयुशमुंसवा एवमुं सयुनववाई कगे क्रम मगेमुं उपसथवारपत अरभलगेखिलो आधवार पर पवायर गयर सथवारपत अरनयरमततवाओमुं कगे आललोक मगेमुं आरलोरपत मयुरखियवा शर मयुन्नवा सहन कलो रबहवार पमुं चवायत रवाजि अरधरनयम, 2006 कर धवारवा-18(5) कगे अधरन आदगेश रनगर्रत रकयगे जिवानगे कर रतरथ सगे गवाम पमुं चवायत-रसलपयुर, प्रखिण्ड-भगववानपयुर, रजिलवा-बगेगगूसरवाय कलो मयुरखियवा कगे पद सगे हटवातगे हयुए यह आदगेश रदयवा जिवातवा हहै रक शर मयुन्नवा सहनर आदगेश रनगर्रत रकयगे जिवानगे कर रतरथ सगे पमुं चवायत रनकवायलोमुं कगे रकसर भर रनववार्रचन मगेमुं अगलगे 05 वषलोर्रमुं तक उम्मरदववार हलोनगे कगे पवात नहरमुं हलोमुंगगे। 9. सवाथ हर रजिलवा पदवारधकवारर, बगेगगूसरवाय मयुरखियवा द्ववारवा उप मयुरखियवा कगे रवरयुद्ध लगवायगे गयगे आरलोपलोमुं कर जिवाजाँच रजिलवा पमुं चवायत रवाजि पदवारधकवारर सगे 15 रदनलोमुं कगे अन्दर करववानवा सयुरनरशचत करगेमुंगगे। आरलोप सहर पवायगे जिवानगे पर ललोक प्रहरर कगे समक्ष उनकगे रवरगूद्ध भर कवारर्रववाई हगे तयु अनयुरलोध करगेमुंगगे। प्रसतवाव पर सरकवार कवा अनयुमलोदन प्रवाप्त हहै ।” 7. A perusal of the above order makes it abundantly clear that the same is bereft of any reasoning or details of the lapses committed by the petitioner. Neither the show cause notice nor the impugned order dated 12.12.2025 reveals as to what are the specific allegations made against the petitioner with regard to the violation of the guidelines issued by the Gram Panchayat, the lapses committed by the petitioner. 8. This Court as well as the Hon’ble Supreme Court in catena of cases has held that elected representatives cannot be removed at the drop of a hat the authority should be very careful Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 8/10 while taking any action against the elected representatives. The impugned order passed by the authority does not inspire any confidence in this Court with regard to the reasons given and further, it is to be noted that the explanation filed by the petitioner to the show cause notice was also not adverted to. 9. In Assistant Commissioner, Commercial Tax Department, Works Contract and Leasing, Kota vs. Shukla and Brothers, reported in (2010) 4 SCC, 785, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as under: “………. while exercising the power of judicial review on administrative action and more particularly the judgment of courts in appeal before the higher court, providing of reasons can never be dispensed with. The doctrine of audi alteram partem has three basic essentials. Firstly, a person against whom an order is required to be passed or whose rights are likely to be affected adversely must be granted an opportunity of being heard Secondly, the authority concerned should provide a fair and transparent procedure and lastly, the authority concerned must apply its mind and dispose of the matter by a reasoned or speaking order..… ……. A litigant who approaches the court with any grievance in accordance with law is entitled to know the reasons for grant or rejection of his prayer Reasons are the soul of orders Non-recording of reasons could lead to dual infirmities; Firstly, it may cause prejudice to the affected party and secondly, more particularly, hamper the proper administration of justice. These principles are not only applicable to administrative or executive actions, but they apply with equal force and, in fact, with a greater degree of precision to judicial pronouncements. The orders of the court Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 9/10 must reflect what weighed with the court in granting or declining the relief claimed by the applicant." 10. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Tarlochan Dev Sharma Vs. State of Punjab and Ors. reported in (2001) 6 SCC 260 has held as under; “7. In a democracy governed by rule of law, once elected to an office in a democratic institution, the incumbent is entitled to hold the office for the term for which he has been elected unless his election is set aside by a prescribed procedure known to law. That a returned candidate must hold and enjoy the office and discharge the duties related therewith during the term specified by the relevant enactment is a valuable statutory right not only of the return candidate but also of the constituency or the electoral college which he represents. Removal from such an office is a serious matter. It curtails the statutory term of the holder of the office. A stigma is cast on the holder of the office in view of certain allegations having been held proved rendering him unworthy of holding the office which he held.” 11. Having regard to the above mentioned facts and circumstances and also the law laid down by this Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases mentioned above, this Court is of the opinion that the impugned order dated 12.12.2025 passed by the authority is nothing but an abuse of process of law vitiated by perversity and therefore, liable to be held as bad, illegal, arbitrary and contrary to the provisions of the Act, 2006. 12. Having regard to the above, the present writ Patna High Court CWJC No.379 of 2026(5) dt.29-07-2026 10/10 petition stands allowed and consequently the impugned order dated 12.12.2025 is set aside. The petitioner is restored to the post of Mukhiya. 13. All pending I.As., if any, are deemed to have been disposed of. (A. Abhishek Reddy, J) Ayush/U

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Patna HC judgments →