The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 09.2018 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Karauli (for short-`the learned trial court’) in Sessions Case [2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB] (2 of 14) [CRLAD-394/2018] No.61/2015 (104/15) CIS 917/2015 whereby, the appellants have been convicted and sentenced as under: Appellant No.1- Muneem Section 302 IPC: Life imprisonment and fine of Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, three months additional simple imprisonment. Section 307 IPC: Ten years rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, three months additional simple imprisonment. Section 3/25 Arms Act: Three years simple imprisonment and fine of Rs.3,000/-; in default whereof, one month additional simple imprisonment. All the sentences to run concurrently. Appellant No.2- Banee Singh Section 302/34 IPC: Life imprisonment and fine of Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, three months additional simple imprisonment. Section 307 IPC: Ten years rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, three months additional simple imprisonment. Both the sentences to run concurrently. The relevant facts, in nutshell, are that the injured Smt. Kamlesh (PW1) made a parcha bayan (Ex.P1) dated 09.08.2015 at General Hospital, Karauli stating therein that on that very day, at about 6-7 am, when she, along with her sister-in-law Smt. Bhagwanti and daughter-in-law Kashmira, was at their water tank, the appellants ca…
09. 08.2015 came to be [2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB] (3 of 14) [CRLAD-394/2018] registered at the Police Station Kudgaon, District Karauli for offence under Sections 143, 307 and 302 IPC. After investigation, the police charge-sheeted the appellants as well as co-accusedHariom for the offence under Sections 341, 324, 302/34, 307/34 and 120B IPC. Charges under Sections 341, 302/34, 307 and in alternate, under Sections 307/34, 324 and 120B were framed against the appellant-Banee Singh, charges under Sections 341, 302/34, 307/34 and 120B IPC were framed against co-accused Hari Om and against appellant-Muneem, under Sections 341, 302, 307, 324, 120B of IPC and 3/25 of the Arms Act. After trial, while, Hariom was acquitted of the charges framed against him, the appellants have been convicted and sentenced by the learned trial court, vide judgement dated 19.09.2018, as stated hereinabove. Assailing the judgement impugned, learned counsel for the appellants contended that their conviction has been recorded by the learned trial court on the basis of conjectures and surmises without any legally admissible evidence to connect them with the alleged offence. He submitted that though, the police has reached the house of the complainant-party soon after the incident; but, they refused to lodge the report rather, much delayed it which raises a grave suspicion as to true genesis of the case. He further sub…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
D.B. Criminal Appeal (Db) No. 394/2018
1.
Muneem S/o Banee Singh, Aged About 25 Years, R/o
Bholupura, Police Station Kudgaon, District Karauli, Raj.
(Presently Confined In Jail, Karauli).
2.
Banee Singh S/o Moti Singh, Aged About 45 Years, R/o
Bholupura, Police Station Kudgaon, District Karauli, Raj.
(Presently Confined in Jail, Karauli).
----Accused-appellants
Versus
State of Rajasthan, Through PP.
----Non-petitioner
For Appellant(s)
:
Shri Tarun Jain
For Respondent(s)
:
Shri Amit Kumar Punia, PP
Shri Naresh Kumar Gupta, PP with
Ms. Neha Goyal
Shri Ritesh Kumawat for Shri Abdul
Rahim Khan
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAMEER JAIN
Judgment
Date of Conclusion of Arguments
::
10/02/2026
Judgment Reserved On
::
10/02/2026
Whether the full judgment or
only the operative part is pronounced : : Full Judgment
Judgment Pronounced On
: : 17/02/2026
Per Hon’ble Mahendar Kumar Goyal, J.
This criminal appeal is preferred by the accused-appellants
(for
short-`the
appellants’)
assailing
the
judgement
dated
19.09.2018 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Karauli (for short-`the learned trial court’) in Sessions Case
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(2 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
No.61/2015 (104/15) CIS 917/2015 whereby, the appellants have
been convicted and sentenced as under:
Appellant No.1- Muneem
Section 302 IPC: Life
imprisonment
and
fine
of
Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, three months additional
simple imprisonment.
Section 307 IPC: Ten years rigorous imprisonment and fine
of Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, three months additional
simple imprisonment.
Section 3/25 Arms Act: Three years simple imprisonment
and fine of Rs.3,000/-; in default whereof, one month
additional simple imprisonment.
All the sentences to run concurrently.
Appellant No.2- Banee Singh
Section
302/34 IPC:
Life imprisonment
and fine
of
Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, three months additional
simple imprisonment.
Section 307 IPC: Ten years rigorous imprisonment and fine
of Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, three months additional
simple imprisonment.
Both the sentences to run concurrently.
The relevant facts, in nutshell, are that the injured Smt.
Kamlesh (PW1) made a parcha bayan (Ex.P1) dated 09.08.2015
at General Hospital, Karauli stating therein that on that very day,
at about 6-7 am, when she, along with her sister-in-law Smt.
Bhagwanti and daughter-in-law Kashmira, was at their water tank,
the appellants came along with four other co-accused and the
appellant-Banee opened gun fire which hit all three of them
resulting in death of Bhagwanti. It was stated that the incident
was witnessed by S/Shri Dhara Singh and Ram Swaroop. Based
thereupon,
an
FIR
No.118
dated
09.08.2015
came
to
be
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(3 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
registered at the Police Station Kudgaon, District Karauli for
offence under Sections 143, 307 and 302 IPC. After investigation,
the police charge-sheeted the appellants as well as co-accusedHariom for the offence under Sections 341, 324, 302/34, 307/34
and 120B IPC. Charges under Sections 341, 302/34, 307 and in
alternate, under Sections 307/34, 324 and 120B were framed
against the appellant-Banee Singh, charges under Sections 341,
302/34, 307/34 and 120B IPC were framed against co-accused
Hari Om and against appellant-Muneem, under Sections 341, 302,
307, 324, 120B of IPC and 3/25 of the Arms Act. After trial, while,
Hariom was acquitted of the charges framed against him, the
appellants have been convicted and sentenced by the learned trial
court, vide judgement dated 19.09.2018, as stated hereinabove.
Assailing the judgement impugned, learned counsel for the
appellants contended that their conviction has been recorded by
the learned trial court on the basis of conjectures and surmises
without any legally admissible evidence to connect them with the
alleged offence. He submitted that though, the police has reached
the house of the complainant-party soon after the incident; but,
they refused to lodge the report rather, much delayed it which
raises a grave suspicion as to true genesis of the case. He further
submitted that from the evidence on record, it is apparent that
there
has
been
improvement
and
embellishment
by
the
prosecution witnesses on material aspects of the case which
renders the prosecution story to be unreliable. Inviting attention
of this Court towards the statement of injured witnesses and other
eye witnesses, learned counsel contended that their deposition as
to their location vis-a-vis the position of the appellants at the time
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(4 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
of commission of offence, who shot the gun and the number of
gun fires, is self contradictory and mutually destructive which is
fatal to the prosecution case. He also contended that prosecution
version as to motive of the crime is also full of contradictions
rendering it totally unreliable. He, therefore, prayed that the
judgement impugned dated 19.09.2018 be quashed and set aside
and they be acquitted of the charges framed.
Per contra, learned Public Prosecutor, assisted by learned
counsel for the complainant, opposing the submissions made and
supporting the findings recorded by the learned trial court, prayed
for dismissal of the appeal.
Heard. Considered.
Indisputably, Smt. Bhagwanti has succumbed to injury on
account of a gun shot and Smt. Kamlesh (PW1) as also Smt.
Kashmira (PW9) have received gun shot injuries. Now the
question before us is as to whether the prosecution has been able
to connect the appellants with the alleged offence.
The prosecution story begins with the parcha bayan of
injured witness Smt. Kamlesh (PW1) made at General Hospital,
Karauli on 09.08.2015 at 12.40 PM wherein, it was alleged that
when she, along with deceased Smt. Bhagwanti and injured
Kashmira, was washing hands at their water tank after meeting
the call of nature, the appellants came along with four other
accused persons and Banee opened gun fire hitting all three of
them. Soon thereafter, the injured as also the deceased were
shifted to their residence where the police also reached within half
an hour; but, despite presence of a large number of male
members of the family, FIR was not lodged immediately; but, was
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(5 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
delayed by about more than five hours. Smt. Kamlesh (PW1) has
stated that they started for the hospital two hours after being hit
and in the interregnum, they were at their residence with the male
members. This testimony stands corroborated from the deposition
of S/Shri Dhara Singh (PW2), Ram Hari (PW4), Hansraj (PW6),
Hakim Singh (PW10) as also of the Investigating Officer Shri
Gulab Singh (PW28). While S/Shri Dhara Singh, Ram Hari, Hansraj
and
Hakim
Singh
have
stated
specifically,
in
their
cross
examination, that they could furnish no reason as to why the FIR
was not lodged at the residence; the prosecution witness Shri
Hansraj (PW6) has even admitted that when the villagers were
coming to their residence, Kashmira and Kamlesh were explaining
in detail the entire episode; but, he also failed to furnish any
reason as to why the FIR was not lodged. The Investigating Officer
has stated that despite request, the family members refused to
lodge the report on the premise that they would first get the
injured treated in the hospital. In the hospital, they denied to do
so on the pretext that the report would be lodged by the injured
herself. It has also come in evidence that before making the
parcha bayan, Smt. Kamlesh had consulted the male members of
the family. In view thereof, it is apparent that the parcha bayan
was made after much deliberation still, as we would discuss at the
appropriate place, the prosecution has made much improvement
in it rendering the genesis of the prosecution case to be doubtful.
From the evidence on record, we find that there are much
contradictions in it as to who opened the gun fire, how many guns
were used as also, how many shots were fired.
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(6 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
In the parcha bayan, it is alleged that only Banee shot one
gun fire which hit all three. However, improving her version, Smt.
Kamlesh (PW1) has stated that both, Banee as also Muneem,
opened the gun fire. In her cross examination, she has stated that
only one gun was used by both the appellants; first by Banee and
thereafter, by Muneem after snatching it from Banee. She feigned
ignorance as to number of gun shots fired by Muneem. However,
her deposition reveals it to be more than one. When confronted
with her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. (Ex.D1),
she denied to have made such a statement that “Banee Singh did
not open fire.” Thus, from her deposition as PW1, it is apparent
that she has completely contradicted her parcha bayan.
Shri Dhara Singh (PW2) has also stated that both the
appellants used only one gun and while Banee shot only one fire,
Muneem shot two. In his cross examination, he has also stated
that in his police statement (Ex.D2), it was wrongly mentioned
that all the injuries were inflicted only by one gun fire. Although,
Shri Ram Swaroop (PW3), has, in his examination-in-chief, stated
that both the appellants shot one gun fire each; but, in his cross
examination, he has stated that Muneem fired four gun shots.
Further, he admits that his statement recorded under Section 161
Cr.P.C. (Ex.D3) contains that the gun shot fired Banee Singh did
not hit anybody and the injuries were caused by the gun shot fired
only by Muneem; but, he has denied to have stated so. Although,
Shri Ram Hari (PW4) is not an eye witness; but, he has claimed to
have heard firing of three gun shots. Shri Hansraj (PW6),
contradicting other prosecution witnesses, has claimed, in his
examination-in-chief, that both the appellants were having their
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(7 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
individual gun; although, in his cross examination, he has stated
that he has wrongly stated that the appellants were having a gun
each. He also claimed that both the appellants opened multiple
fires. However, as per the recovery memo (Ex.P3), only two
empty cartridges were found that too at the place from where the
appellant-Muneem is alleged to have opened the gun fire.
Conspicuously, no cartridges were found at the place where Banee
Singh is alleged to have shot the gun fire.
This aforesaid evidence not only belies the genesis of the
prosecution case, i.e., the parcha bayan of the injured witnessSmt. Kamlesh; but, the prosecution case that both the appellants
have shot gun fire from different places that too, more than a
couple of time.
Furthermore, the testimony of the injured witness Smt.
Kamlesh (PW1) reflects that the first gun fire was opened by
Banee Singh from place “A” which had hit herself as also
Kashmira. It may be pertinent to note here that Kashmira has
been examined as PW9; but, she has turned hostile. During her
cross-examination by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor, she
has denied the suggestion that the appellants opened gun fire
which caused death of Bhagwanti and injuries to self and Kamlesh.
Further, the Investigating Officer has admitted in his crossexamination that the pallets from the gun shot fired from place
“A” in the site plan, i.e., the place from where Banee Singh is
alleged to have opened the fire, could not have hit the person
washing hands at the tap on the water tank as claimed in the
parcha bayan. We may mention here that this testimony of the
Investigating Officer is based on his own observation at the site
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(8 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
and not based on the statement made to him by the witnesses so
as to be hit by Section 162 Cr.P.C.
In the conspectus of the aforesaid analysis, we are convinced
that the prosecution has not come out with true genesis of the
case and has suppressed it.
Moreover, in the parcha bayan, S/Shri Dhara Singh (PW2)
and Ram Swaroop (PW3) are claimed to be present at the place of
incident. Shri Dhara Singh claims presence of self, Ram Swaroop
and Hansraj at the scene of crime at the time when the injured
and the deceased came there after meeting the call of the nature.
However, in his cross-examination, he has stated that when he
reached the scene of crime, all others were already present there.
Further, Shri Hansraj as PW6 has, contradicting the deposition of
the PW2, stated that when he was going to meet the call of nature
in the morning of the fateful day, he was chased by the appellants
along with co-accused whereupon, he reached back to the water
tank where he found others and in his cross-examination, he has
categorically stated when he had gone to meet the call of nature,
none was present at the water tank and he found them only when
he returned.
Further, all the eye witnesses, other than the injured eye
witnesses, have claimed to have seen the incident from a
“chhappar”, (a makeshift hut) situated within 10 to 15 feets of the
water tank; but, conspicuously, it is not shown in the site plan
(Ex.P4). The absence of the chhappar in the site plan is rendered
of much significance in view of their cross-examination which
creates doubt as to whether they have, as a matter of fact, seen
the incident. Shri Dhara Singh (PW2) has feigned ignorance when
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(9 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
confronted with his Section 161 Cr.P.C. statement (Ex.D2) as to
why, it did not contain the averment that they were hiding in the
chhappar. While, Dhara Singh has claimed that when they were
hiding in the chhappar, they were not visible to the accused; Shri
Ram Swaroop, as PW3, has stated that they were visible to the
accused while hiding in the chhappar and the accused were
clamouring to drag them out. He has also claimed that 2-3 gun
shots were fired in the chhappar; however, feigned ignorance
when asked as to why these averments are absent in his police
statement (Ex.D3). Shri Hansraj (PW6) stated that he was
unaware as to whether the accused have seen them hiding in the
chhappar although, he claims that Muneem had opened a gun fire
at the chhappar. Therefore, from the above testimony, it is not
established, beyond doubt, that these witnesses were hiding in a
chhappar in the vicinity and have seen the crime.
The Hon’ble High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in Ajeet
Kumar Kanwar vs. State of Chaattisgarh and Manoj Soni &
Ors. vs. State of Chattisgarh, MANU/CG/1545/2024, held as
under:
“29. The Supreme Court in the matter of Shingara Singh vs.
State
of
Haryana
and
Another-MANU/SC/0869/2003:
(2003) 12 SCC 758 has held that the omission to show
essential feature in the site plan is a lapse on the part of
the Investigating officer and observed in paragraph-29 as
under:"29. The evidence on record with regard to the
existence of cots in the court- yard of Gurdeep Singh,
the existence of a bicycle, as also about the existence
of a ladder is rather unsatisfactory and creates a
serious doubt as to whether the prosecution witnesses
are telling the truth. The omission to show them in both
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(10 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
the site plans cannot be attributed to a mere lapse on
the part of the investigating agency. In fact so far as
the
site
plans
are
concerned,
the
case
of
the
prosecution is that they were prepared in the presence
of PW 5 and another witness and on their pointing.
However, PW 5 denied that the plans were prepared in
his presence. The other witness was not examined."
30. Similarly, in the matter of Baldev Singh and Another vs.
State of Madhya Pradesh-MANU/SC/0001/2003 ; (2003) 9
SCC 45, it has been held by the Supreme Court that the site
plan is not a mere formality and it is essential feature to
highlight the importance of the site and held as under:"13…..The site plan prepared by Arvind Khare does not
show the presence of cycles or the bushes although the
site plan mentions the place wherefrom the two
witnesses claim to have seen the incident."
We also find from the prosecution evidence that it is doubtful
that the gun shot fired from place ‘B’ in the site plan (Ex.P4), i.e.,
the place from where the appellant-Muneem is alleged to have
opened the gun fire, could hit the victims.
Smt. Kamlesh (PW1) has stated, in her cross-examination,
that when Muneem opened gun fire, they were hiding behind the
water tank. Clarifying further, she has stated that she was hiding
towards the side where the sun sets and Muneem was also on that
side of the water tank. If her testimony is examined on the touch
stone of site plan (Ex.P4), then, in between her and the appellantMuneem, there was the water tank rendering it impossible of her
being hit from the gun fire opened by Muneem who was standing
in front of the government water tank at place `A' and she was
hiding behind another water tank at place `B'. She has also
claimed that Kashmira was also towards another side of the tank
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(11 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
beyond the reach of Muneem. Shri Dhara Singh (PW2) has stated
that the deceased Bhagwanti was hiding along with Kamlesh
behind the water tank. He has further stated when the second fire
was opened (obviously by appellant-Muneem), the accused were
on eastern side whereas, all the three ladies were in the western
side, as also claimed by Smt. Kamlesh a PW1. Similar is the
deposition of Shri Ram Swaroop (PW3) who has stated that when
the gun was fired, the ladies were towards other side of the water
tank. From the Ex.P4-the site plan, it is apparent that while the
accused, including the appellant-Muneem, were standing in front
of the government water tank at a distance of about 50 yards, all
the three ladies were hiding towards western side, i.e., behind
another water tank not in the direct trajectory of the pellets
released rendering it impossible of being hit from the gun shot
fired by the appellants.
Thus, from the conspectus of aforesaid analysis of the
evidence available on record, we are not convinced that the
prosecution has been able to establish, beyond reasonable doubt,
that the ladies were hit by the gun shots fired by the appellants.
As already held, the allegation that Banee Singh opened gun fire
from place "A" could not be established on account; firstly, no
empty cartridge was found from that place and secondly, from the
testimony of the prosecution witnesses including the testimony of
the Investigating Officer, it is disclosed that it was not possible to
hit the ladies from the gun shot fired from place "A". Similarly,
although, two empty cartridges were found at place "B" where the
appellant-Muneem is alleged to have opened multiple gun shots;
but, from the testimony of the injured witness, other eye
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(12 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
witnesses and from the site plan, it is established that the victims
were not in the direct trajectory of the gun shots.
Furthermore, from the evidence on record, we are not
satisfied that the prosecution has been able to establish motive
behind commission of the offence. Although, in the case of ocular
evidence, motive is not of much significance; but, in the instant
case,
the
prosecution
story
suffers
from
the
vice
of
self
contradiction in this regard. While, in the parcha bayan, which, as
already held by us, was made after much deliberation, it was
specifically stated that there was no old enmity with the accusedparty, however, Smt. Kamlesh, during her cross-examination as
PW1, has stated that this averment was wrongly mentioned. She
has further stated that Hansa (Hansraj) and Kailash were facing a
trial with regard to beating of Banee Singh. Shri Dhara Singh as
PW2 has claimed old enmity of the accused with the ladies. He has
further stated that they were having enmity as goat of the
accused party had come in their field whereupon, Banee was
beaten by Hakim, Kailash, Atar Singh, Hansraj and Sahab Singh.
Shri Ram Swaroop (PW3) has deposed that the enmity was on
account of grazing of the goats and buffaloes by the accused-party
in their field. He denies any previous litigation in between them.
Shri Hansraj (PW6) though, has claimed to have been chased by
the accused while going to meet the call of nature; but, has
admitted, during his cross-examination that he ran about 60-70
meters to escape from the accused and despite being clearly
visible to them and having opportunity to do so, they did not open
any gun fire upon him. Further, he has denied any enmity of the
accused with the ladies completely contradicting the testimony of
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(13 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
Shri Dhara Singh (PW2). In view of aforesaid testimony, we are
not convinced that the prosecution has been able to establish
motive of the appellants in commission of the offence.
Although, a 12 bore gun, allegedly used in commission of the
offence by the appellants, has been recovered on the disclosure
statement made by the appellant-Muneem; but, in view of the
aforesaid discussion by us, wherein, we have found the ocular
testimony to be highly doubtful, mere recovery would not be
sufficient to uphold the findings of the guilt.
In view of the aforesaid discussion and analysis of the
evidence on record, we are of the considered view that the
prosecution could not establish, beyond reasonable doubt, that the
appellants are guilty of the charges levelled against them and the
learned trial court has recorded their conviction ignoring the
important aspects of the matter which has vitiated its findings.
Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The judgement impugned
dated 19.09.2018 passed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Karauli
in Sessions
Case No.61/2015
(104/15) CIS
917/2015 is quashed and set aside and the appellants are
acquitted of the charges framed against them. The sentence of
appellant-Banee was suspended, therefore, his bail bonds are
discharged. He need not surrender and shall be at liberty. The
appellant-Muneem is in jail. He shall be released forthwith, if not
required to be detained in any other case.
In view of the provisions of Section 481 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the appellants are directed to
furnish a personal bond in the sum of ₹25,000/- each, and a
surety in the like amount before the Registrar (Judicial) of this
[2026:RJ-JP:6809-DB]
(14 of 14)
[CRLAD-394/2018]
Court which shall be effective for a period of six months with the
stipulation that in the event of Special Leave Petition being filed
against the judgment or on grant of leave, the appellants
aforesaid, on receipt of notice thereof, shall appear before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
(SAMEER JAIN),J
RS/
(MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review