Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
D.B. Criminal Misc Suspension Of Sentence Application (Appeal)
No. 1037/2025
In
D.B. Criminal Appeal No.231/2025
1.
Smt. Sayra Bano Alias Guddi Wife Of Mumtaz Khan, Aged
About 30 Years, R/o Miyan Ki Dhani Police Station Ranoli
District Sikar (Raj) (At Present Lodged In Mahila Karagar
Central Jail Jaipur)
2.
Subhash Chand Son Of Rameshwarlal, Aged About 23
Years, Resident Of Bajiya Ki Dhani, Tan Ladhana Police
Station Ranoli District Sikar (At Present Lodged In Central
Jail Bikaner)
----Petitioners
Versus
State Of Rajasthan, Through The Public Prosecutor
----Respondent
Connected With
D.B. Criminal Misc Suspension Of Sentence Application (Appeal)
No. 1571/2025
In
D.B. Criminal Appeal No.231/2025
Mohammad Hanif @ Idu S/o Shri Azam Khan, Aged About 43
Years, R/o Village Miyan-Ki-Dhani, Police Station, Ranoli, District
Sikar. (Presently Lodged In Central Jail At Bikaner)
----Petitioner
Versus
State Of Rajasthan, Through Public Prosecutor.
----Respondent
D.B. Criminal Misc Suspension Of Sentence Application (Appeal)
No. 2099/2025
In
D.B. Criminal Appeal No.231/2025
Mumtaz Khan Son Of Shri Azam Khan, Aged About 72 Years,
Resident Of Miyan-Ki-Dhani, Police Station, Ranoli, District Sikar,
(Raj.) (Presently Lodged In Central Jail At Bikaner)
----Petitioner
Versus
State Of Rajasthan, Through Public Prosecutor.
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Swadeep Singh Hora
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Vivek Sharma, PP
(2 of 6)
[SOSA-1037/2025]
Mr. V.R. Bajwa, Sr. Adv. assisted by
Mr. Amar Kumar,
Mr. Ved Prakash Bishnoi &
Ms. Savita Nathawat
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE CHANDRA PRAKASH SHRIMALI
Order
09/01/2026
The accused-applicants (for short, ‘the applicants’) have
been convicted and sentenced by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge No.4, Sikar (for short, ‘trial Court’) vide judgment dated
29.04.2025 as under:
1.
Under Section 148 IPC: One
year
simple
imprisonment
and fine of Rs. 1,000/- in default thereof, seven days additional
imprisonment.
2.
Under Section 341 IPC: One year simple imprisonment
and fine of Rs. 500/- in default thereof, five days additional
imprisonment.
3.
Under
Section
323/149
IPC:
Six
months
simple
imprisonment and fine of Rs. 1,000/- in default thereof, seven
days additional imprisonment.
4.
Under
Section
325/149
IPC:
Four
years
simple
imprisonment and fine of Rs. 5,000/- in default thereof, one
month additional imprisonment.
5.
of
Under Section 302/149 IPC: Life imprisonment and fine
Rs.
20,000/-
in
default
thereof,
six
months
additional
imprisonment.
Sentences to run concurrently.
Learned counsel for the applicants-Mr. Swadeep Singh Hora
submits that the allegation of assaulting the deceased is against a
large number of persons whereas, he has received only three
injuries out of which, two are simple in nature. He further submits
(3 of 6)
[SOSA-1037/2025]
that post-mortem report of the body of the deceased Yakub (Ex-P33) reflects three injuries out of which, injury on his head was
found to be fatal as per the statement of Dr. Ram Lakhan Meena
(PW-18) who conducted the autopsy. He submits that without
recording any finding that the common object of the unlawful
assembly comprising of the applications, was to cause death of
Mukarab Khan or any of his family member, learned trial Court
convicted them under Section under Section 302 read with Section
149 IPC although, in the same breath, while acquitting them
under Section 307/149 IPC, it was held that the prosecution has
failed to establish common object of the unlawful assembly to
cause death of the injured persons. Learned counsel submits that
even otherwise, from the prosecution evidence, it is reflected that
deceased Yakub happened to be present at the place of incident
by chance and therefore, it could not be presumed that the
applicants intended his death in furtherance of their common
object. Relying upon the observations made by their Lordships in
the case of Kuldip Yadav & Ors. vs. State of Bihar: (2011) 5
SCC 324, learned counsel contends that it was imperative for the
learned trial Court, before recording their conviction under Section
302 with the aid of Section 149, to record a clear finding regarding
the common object of the assembly as also analysis of the
evidence reflecting not only the nature of the common object; but
also, that the object was unlawful. Learned counsel-Mr. Swadeep
Singh Hora submits that before recording the conviction under
Section 149 IPC, the essential ingredients of Section 149 IPC must
be established.
(4 of 6)
[SOSA-1037/2025]
Mr. Hora submits that initially, after investigation, charge
sheet was filed only against Shafiq Ahmed and later on,
supplementary charge sheet was filed against the co-accusedSharif Ahmed including the applicants-Hanif @ Idu and Subhash
Chand. He contends that the applicants Sayra @ Guddi and
Mumtaz Khan were added as accused under Section 319 Cr.P.C.
Lastly, he submits that all the applicants were on bail during trial
with no allegation of misuse of their liberty. Learned counsel
submits that hearing of the appeal is likely to take time and prays
for suspension of their sentence during its pendency.
Per contra, learned Public Prosecutor, assisted by learned
Senior Counsel for the complainant, vehemently opposed the
applications. He submits that it was a cold blooded murder carried
out in furtherance of common object of the unlawful assembly
wherein, an overt act has been attributed to each of the
applicants. He submits that in this case, the investigation has
been defective and the applicants should not be extended its
benefit. He, therefore, prays for dismissal of the applications.
Heard. Considered.
A perusal of the judgment impugned reflects that while
acquitting the applicants along with co-accused persons of the
charge under Section 307/149 IPC, it was observed by the learned
trial Court that had the common object of the unlawful assembly
been to cause death of the injured person, they would not have
received either simple injuries or grievous injuries on non vital
part of the body. However, while convicting them under Section
302/149 IPC, no such finding has been recorded with regard to
(5 of 6)
[SOSA-1037/2025]
their common object to cause death; either of deceased Yakub or
any member of the complainant side. In the case of Kuldip
Yadav (supra) it was held as under:
“36. In order to understand the rival claim, it
is useful to refer to Section 149 which reads as
follows:
"149. Every member of unlawful assembly
guilty of offence committed in prosecution of
common object If an offence is committed by any
member of an unlawful assembly in prosecution of
the common object of that assembly, or such as the
members of that assembly knew to be likely to be
committed in prosecution of that object, every
person who, at the time of the committing of that
offence, is a member of the same assembly, is
guilty of that offence."
The above provision makes it clear that before
convicting the accused with the aid of Section 149
IPC, the Court must give clear finding regarding
nature of common object and that the object was
unlawful. In the absence of such finding as also any
overt act on the part of the accused persons, mere
fact that they were armed would not be sufficient to
prove common object. Section 149 creates a
specific offence and deals with punishment of that
offence. Whenever the court convicts any person or
persons of an offence with the aid of Section 149, a
clear finding regarding the common object of the
assembly must be given and the evidence discussed
must show not only the nature of the common
object but also that the object was unlawful. Before
recording a conviction under Section 149 IPC, the
essential ingredients of Section 141 IPC must be
established. The above principles have been
reiterated in Bhudeo Mandal v. State of Bihar.”
Further, in view of the nature of injuries received by the
deceased, the nature of the weapon allegedly used by the
applicants, they being on bail during trial, absence of allegation of
misuse of the liberty and the possibility of hearing of the appeal
taking time, we deem it just and proper to allow the applications.
Accordingly, the suspension of sentence applications are
allowed. The substantive sentence awarded to the applicants by
(6 of 6)
[SOSA-1037/2025]
the learned trial Court vide judgment dated 29.04.2025 shall
remain suspended during pendency of the appeals provided each
of them furnishes bail bonds to the satisfaction of the learned trial
Court to the effect that they shall appear before this Court on or
before 10.02.2026 and as and when called upon to do so till
disposal of the appeal and subject to following conditions:
1.
That they will appear before the
learned trial court in the month of January of
every year till the appeal is decided.
2.
That if the applicants change the place
of residence, they will give in writing their
changed address to the learned trial Court as
well as to counsel in the High Court who shall, in
turn, inform their learned Court.
3.
Similarly, if the sureties change their
address(s), they will give in writing their changed
address to the learned trial Court.
The learned trial Court shall keep the record of attendance of
the accused-applicants in a separate file. Such file be registered as
Criminal Misc. Case relating to original case in which the accusedapplicants were tried and convicted. A copy of this order shall also
be placed in that file for ready reference. Criminal Misc. file shall
not been taken into account for statistical purpose relating to
pendency and disposal of the cases in the trial Court. In case, the
said accused-applicants do not appear before the learned trial
Court, learned trial Judge shall report the matter to the High Court
for cancellation of benefit extended by this order.
(CHANDRA PRAKASH SHRIMALI),J
GAURAV SHARMA /19-21
(MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review