Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed
by
SHAYNA
KADRI
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 9376 of 2023
1 - Mukund Hela S/o Late Shri Kailash Ram Aged About 32 Years R/o
Bhatthapara, Ward, No. 45, Ambikapur, District Sarguja Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Urban Administration
And Development Department Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal
Nagar, Naya Raipur, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2 - The Director, Directorate Of Urban Administration And Development
Indravati Bhawan, 4th Floor Blcok-D, Naya Raipur, District : Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
3 - Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Ambikapur, District Sarguja
Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Anukul Biswas, Advocate
For State
:
Ms. Vartika Shrivastava, Panel Lawyer
For Resp. No. 3
:
Mr. Bhupendra Singh, Advocate
SB- Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
28/02/2026
1.
The present writ petition is being filed seeking following reliefs:-
“(I)
That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to quash Annexure P-1 and direct
claim petitioner and the respondent authority
to reconsider of the compassionate grant
appointment within stipulated period, in the
interest of justice.
(II)
2.
Any other relief which may be suitable in the
facts and circumstances of the case, may also
be granted.”
Facts of the case, in brief, is that the father of the petitioner, late
Kailash Ram, was employed as a Sanitary Worker under the
Municipal Corporation of Ambikapur. Unfortunately, he passed
away while still in service on 03.09.2017, leaving behind his wife,
three sons, and one daughter, all of whom were fully dependent
on the deceased employee for their livelihood. His untimely
demise created a financial and emotional void for the family. In
light of these circumstances, the petitioner filed an application for
compassionate
appointment
on
27.11.2017,
seeking
an
opportunity to provide for his family in the absence of his father.
However, the application was rejected on the grounds that the
petitioner’s mother was employed as a Safai Karmachari. The
rejection of the application was based on the assumption that the
petitioner’s mother’s employment provided sufficient support to
the family. Following the rejection of his application, the petitioner
submitted a further appeal to the Director, clarifying that his
mother, who is currently employed, will be retiring in the year
2028. After her retirement, the petitioner and his family would
have no financial support, and they would face extreme difficulties
in meeting their basic needs. On this basis, the petitioner argued
that the rejection of his application was not justified. In response,
the Director, in a letter dated 17.07.2018, forwarded the
petitioner’s case to the Commissioner for reconsideration. This
communication
demonstrates
the
acknowledgment
of
the
petitioner’s concerns and the need for further review. Despite the
submission of the above letters, the petitioner once again filed an
application for compassionate appointment on 27.06.2018,
highlighting a precedent where two other individuals, namely
Surendra Bahadur Singh and Suraj Kirwar, were granted
compassionate appointments even though their mothers were
employed in Government jobs. The petitioner sought to make the
case that his circumstances were similar and that the same
consideration should be extended to him. Despite the various
communications and appeals made by the petitioner, his claim for
compassionate appointment has not been reconsidered. This
inaction is contrary to the established policy of the State
Government, which provides for compassionate appointments
under specific circumstances such as those faced by the
petitioner. The failure to act on the petitioner’s case is unjust and
inconsistent with the Government’s own policy.
These facts
demonstrate the petitioner’s continuous efforts to seek support
and recognition in light of his family’s financial distress following
the death of his father. Despite following the proper procedures
and appealing through the appropriate channels, the petitioner’s
case remains unresolved.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the actions of
the respondent in rejecting the petitioner’s application for
compassionate appointment are arbitrary, discriminatory, and
unconstitutional. The rejection of the petitioner’s request was
based solely on the employment of his mother, who is currently
working as a Safai Karmachari. This reasoning is manifestly
unjust and violates the principles of equality and fairness
enshrined in the Constitution of India. The petitioner’s family was
left without a primary breadwinner following the untimely death of
his father, and the assumption that the mother’s employment
would suffice to support the entire family is not only unreasonable
but also dismissive of the dire financial and emotional situation the
family is facing. The refusal to grant compassionate appointment
under
such circumstances constitutes
a violation
of the
petitioner’s fundamental rights to equality and social justice as
guaranteed under Articles 14, 15, and 21 of the Constitution of
India. In response to the rejection, the petitioner made further
submissions to the Director, emphasizing the pressing need for
compassionate appointment based on the fact that his mother will
retire in the year 2028. The petitioner highlighted the fact that
once his mother retires, the family will be left without any source
of income or support, making it impossible for them to meet their
basic needs. This ground, which was brought to the attention of
the authorities, renders the initial rejection of the application even
more unjustifiable. The failure to consider the family’s future
financial insecurity, as well as the short time left before the
mother’s retirement, demonstrates a lack of sensitivity to the
petitioner’s vulnerable position. The continued denial of the
compassionate
appointment
under
these
conditions
is
unreasonable, and the respondent’s actions must be considered
unconstitutional as they ignore the practical realities and needs of
the petitioner’s family. It is worth noting that in response to the
petitioner’s
appeal,
the
Director,
through
a
letter
dated
17.07.2018, acknowledged the seriousness of the matter and
forwarded the petitioner’s case to the Commissioner for
reconsideration. This action indicates that the Director recognized
the merit in the petitioner’s request and the necessity of a
thorough reevaluation of the case. However, despite this official
communication from the Director, no substantive action has been
taken, and the petitioner’s application for
compassionate
appointment remains unaddressed. The delay in reconsideration
of the case further highlights the lack of due diligence and
attention to the petitioner’s legitimate claims. It is imperative that
the authorities give prompt attention to the petitioner’s case in
accordance with the policies and guidelines set by the State
Government. The petitioner has also brought to the attention the
fact that two other individuals, namely Surendra Bahadur Singh
and Suraj Kirwar, whose mothers are employed in Government
jobs, were granted compassionate appointments. This serves as
a crucial point of comparison and demonstrates that similar
circumstances have been treated differently by the authorities. If
compassionate appointments were granted in these cases, the
petitioner is entitled to the same treatment under the principle of
equality before the law. The failure to grant the petitioner a similar
opportunity amounts to discrimination and a violation of the
petitioner’s right to equal treatment under Article 14 of the
Constitution. This disparity in treatment raises serious concerns
about the fairness and transparency of the process followed by
the
authorities.
The
petitioner’s
claim
for
compassionate
appointment is in line with the policies and procedures set out by
the State Government, which are designed to provide financial
relief to families who lose their primary breadwinners. Despite
this, the respondent’s refusal to reconsider the case, especially
after multiple representations and the submission of new facts, is
not only unjust but also contrary to the policy framework of the
State Government. The petitioner’s case clearly falls within the
ambit of the compassionate appointment policy, and the
authorities have failed to act in accordance with their own
established rules. This delay and inaction are detrimental to the
petitioner’s rights and contradict the principles underlying the
State Government's policy on compassionate appointments. In
light of the above submissions, it is submitted that the
respondent’s refusal to grant the petitioner compassionate
appointment is arbitrary, discriminatory, and unconstitutional. The
petitioner’s family is in a state of financial distress, and the denial
of compassionate appointment has exacerbated their hardships.
The actions of the respondent have violated the petitioner’s
fundamental rights to equality, social justice, and fair treatment.
Therefore, it is prayed that this Court may kindly direct the
respondents to reconsider the petitioner’s application in light of
the facts and circumstances presented, and in accordance with
the applicable policies and the principles of justice. Additionally,
the petitioner seeks an immediate resolution of the case, ensuring
that the family is provided with the necessary support through
compassionate appointment as per the law and established
norms.
4.
Learned State counsel would submit that the instant petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been filed by the
petitioner seeking to quash the order dated 30.05.2018 passed by
the Municipal Corporation, Ambikapur, rejecting the petitioner’s
application for compassionate appointment. The petitioner’s
application for compassionate appointment was rejected on the
grounds that his mother is employed as a Safai Karmachari. It is
further submitted that the petitioner is seeking relief against
respondent No. 3, the Municipal Corporation, Ambikapur, which is
an autonomous body and not a department of the State
Government.
Since no relief has been sought against
respondents No. 1 & 2, the State of Chhattisgarh, they are only
formal parties in this petition.
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent No. 3 submits that the
petitioner is not entitled to the relief sought in this petition, as the
claims made are devoid of merit. The petition challenges the
impugned order dated 30.05.2018 passed by respondent No. 3,
rejecting
the
petitioner’s
application
for
compassionate
appointment. However, the petitioner’s application is not in
accordance with the established policy for compassionate
appointments, and therefore, he is not entitled to any relief from
the answering respondent. The rejection of the application is
based on valid grounds and in compliance with the applicable
rules and regulations.
The petitioner has further moved an
application to the Director of Urban Administration (respondent
No. 2), requesting compassionate appointment, citing that his
mother will retire in the year 2028. However, the application was
rejected by the Director, who found that the grounds presented by
the petitioner were not justifiable. It is crucial to note that the
policy for compassionate appointments, as outlined in the
Compassionate Appointment Direction Policy of 2013, clearly
stipulates in Rule 6-A that if any other member of the deceased
Government
employee’s
family
is
already
employed
in
Government service, no other member of the family is eligible for
compassionate appointment. The petitioner’s mother is currently
employed as a Safai Daroga, which means that one family
member is already in Government service. Therefore, in
accordance with Rule 6-A of the Compassionate Appointment
Policy, the petitioner does not qualify for compassionate
appointment. The rejection of the petitioner’s application by the
answering respondent is in strict compliance with the policy.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also
perused the documents enclosed along with the petition.
7.
Upon consideration of the submissions and facts of the case, it is
apparent that the petitioner’s family lost its primary source of
livelihood
due
to
the
untimely
demise
of
his
father.
Compassionate appointments are intended to provide immediate
relief to such families in distress. The circumstances of the
petitioner are compelling, and a mechanical application of the rule
regarding the mother’s employment would result in undue
hardship and defeat the very purpose of compassionate
appointment.
It is, therefore, held that the ground of the
petitioner’s mother being employed as a Safai Karmachari is not
required
to
be
considered
for
the
purpose
of
granting
compassionate appointment in this case.
8.
The objective of compassionate appointment is to provide
financial support to the family of the deceased employee, and this
objective would be defeated if the petitioner is denied relief on
such a technical ground. The employment of the petitioner’s
mother, or the post he seeks, does not warrant consideration in
light of the broader purpose of providing relief to the bereaved
family.
9.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of State of U.P. v. Premlata,
reported in (2022) 1 SCC 30 has reiterated that compassionate
appointment is meant to relieve the family from financial hardship,
and the competent authority must examine the financial status
and dependency of family members before deciding the claim. It
was held as under :
“8. While considering the issue
involved in the present appeal, the law
laid down by this Court on
compassionate ground on the death of
the deceased employee are required to
be referred to and considered. In the
recent decision, this Court in State of
Karnataka v. V. Somyashree [State of
Karnataka v. V. Somyashree, (2021) 12
SCC 20 : 2021 SCC OnLine SC 704] ,
had occasion to consider the principle
governing the grant of appointment on
compassionate ground. After referring
to the decision of this Court in N.C.
Santhosh v. State of Karnataka [N.C.
Santhosh v. State of Karnataka, (2020)
7 SCC 617 : (2020) 2 SCC (L&S) 861] ,
this Court has summarised the principle
governing the grant of appointment on
compassionate ground as under : (V.
Somyashree case [State of Karnataka
v. V. Somyashree, (2021) 12 SCC 20 :
2021 SCC OnLine SC 704] , SCC para
10)
“10.1. That the compassionate
appointment is an exception to
the general rule.
10.2. That no aspirant has a right
to compassionate appointment.
10.3. The appointment to any
public post in the service of the
State has to be made on the
basis of the principle in
accordance with Articles 14 and
16 of the Constitution of India.
10.4.
Appointment
on
compassionate ground can be
made only on fulfilling the norms
laid down by the State's policy
and/or satisfaction of the eligibility
criteria as per the policy.
10.5. The norms prevailing on the
date of the consideration of the
application should be the basis for
consideration
of
claim
for
compassionate appointment.”
9. As per the law laid down by this
Court in a catena of decisions on the
appointment on compassionate ground,
for all the government vacancies equal
opportunity should be provided to all
aspirants as mandated under Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution. However,
appointment on compassionate ground
offered to a dependant of a deceased
employee is an exception to the said
norms. The compassionate ground is a
concession and not a right.
9.1. In State of H.P. v. Shashi Kumar
[State of H.P. v. Shashi Kumar, (2019) 3
SCC 653 : (2019) 1 SCC (L&S) 542] ,
this Court in paras 21 and 26 had an
occasion to consider the object and
purpose
of
appointment
on
compassionate ground and considered
decision of this Court in Govind
Prakash Verma v. LIC [Govind Prakash
Verma v. LIC, (2005) 10 SCC 289 :
2005 SCC (L&S) 590] , it is observed
and held as under : (Shashi Kumar
case [State of H.P. v. Shashi Kumar,
(2019) 3 SCC 653 : (2019) 1 SCC
(L&S) 542] , SCC pp. 665-68, paras 21
& 26)
“21. The decision in Govind
Prakash Verma [Govind Prakash
Verma v. LIC, (2005) 10 SCC 289
: 2005 SCC (L&S) 590] , has
been considered subsequently in
several decisions. But, before we
advert to those decisions, it is
necessary to note that the nature
of compassionate appointment
had been considered by this
Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal v.
State of Haryana [Umesh Kumar
Nagpal v. State of Haryana,
(1994) 4 SCC 138 : 1994 SCC
(L&S) 930] . The principles which
have been laid down in Umesh
Kumar Nagpal [Umesh Kumar
Nagpal v. State of Haryana,
(1994) 4 SCC 138 : 1994 SCC
(L&S)
930]
have
been
subsequently followed in a
consistent line of precedents in
this Court. These principles are
encapsulated in the following
extract : (Umesh Kumar Nagpal
case [Umesh Kumar Nagpal v.
State of Haryana, (1994) 4 SCC
138 : 1994 SCC (L&S) 930] , SCC
pp. 139-40, para 2)
‘2.
…
As
a
rule,
appointments in the public
services should be made strictly
on the basis of open invitation of
applications and merit. No other
mode of appointment nor any
other consideration is permissible.
Neither the Governments nor the
public authorities are at liberty to
follow any other procedure or
relax the qualifications laid down
by the rules for the post.
However, to this general rule
which is to be followed strictly in
every case, there are some
exceptions carved out in the
interests of justice and to meet
certain contingencies. One such
exception is in favour of the
dependants of an employee
dying-in-harness and leaving his
family in penury and without any
means of livelihood. In such
cases, out of pure humanitarian
consideration
taking
into
consideration the fact that unless
some source of livelihood is
provided, the family would not be
able to make both ends meet, a
provision is made in the rules to
provide gainful employment to
one of the dependants of the
deceased who may be eligible for
such employment. The whole
object of granting compassionate
employment is thus to enable the
family to tide over the sudden
crisis. The object is not to give a
member of such family a post
much less a post for post held by
the deceased. What is further,
mere death of an employee in
harness does not entitle his family
to such source of livelihood. The
Government
or
the
public
authority concerned has to
examine the financial condition of
the family of the deceased, and it
is only if it is satisfied, that but for
the provision of employment, the
family will not be able to meet the
crisis that a job is to be offered to
the eligible member of the family.
The posts in Classes III and IV
are the lowest posts in nonmanual and manual categories
and hence they alone can be
offered
on
compassionate
grounds, the object being to
relieve the family, of the financial
destitution and to help it get over
the emergency. The provision of
employment in such lowest posts
by making an exception to the
rule is justifiable and valid since it
is
not
discriminatory.
The
favourable treatment given to
such dependant of the deceased
employee in such posts has a
rational nexus with the object
sought to be achieved viz. relief
against destitution. No other posts
are expected or required to be
given by the public authorities for
the purpose. It must be
remembered in this connection
that as against the destitute family
of the deceased there are millions
of other families which are
equally, if not more destitute. The
exception to the rule made in
favour of the family of the
deceased
employee
is
in
consideration of the services
rendered by him and the
legitimate expectations, and the
change in the status and affairs,
of the family engendered by the
erstwhile employment which are
suddenly upturned.’
*
*
*
26. The judgment of a Bench of
two Judges in Mumtaz Yunus
Mulani v. State of Maharashtra
[Mumtaz Yunus Mulani v. State of
Maharashtra, (2008) 11 SCC
384 : (2008) 2 SCC (L&S) 1077]
has adopted the principle that
appointment on compassionate
grounds is not a source of
recruitment, but a means to
enable the family of the deceased
to get over a sudden financial
crisis. The financial position of the
family would need to be evaluated
on the basis of the provisions
contained in the scheme. The
decision in Govind Prakash
Verma [Govind Prakash Verma v.
LIC, (2005) 10 SCC 289 : 2005
SCC (L&S) 590] has been duly
considered,
but
the
Court
observed that it did not appear
that the earlier binding precedents
of this Court have been taken
note of in that case.”
10. Thus, as per the law laid down by
this Court in the aforesaid decisions,
compassionate appointment is an
exception to the general rule of
appointment in the public services and
is in favour of the dependants of a
deceased dying-in-harness and leaving
his family in penury and without any
means of livelihood, and in such cases,
out of pure humanitarian consideration
taking into consideration the fact that
unless some source of livelihood is
provided, the family would not be able
to make both ends meet, a provision is
made in the rules to provide gainful
employment to one of the dependants
of the deceased who may be eligible for
such employment. The whole object of
granting compassionate employment is
thus to enable the family to tide over
the sudden crisis. The object is not to
give such family a post much less a
post held by the deceased.”
10.
Thus, it is evident from the above that while considering the claim
for compassionate appointment, the competent authority is
required to examine whether the family is still in financial distress.
11.
It would be apt to mention that the respondent – Corporation has
given compassionate appointment to the person, the case of
which are identical to the petitioners. In the case of similar placed
person, their mothers are employed in government service on
account of death of father, they were granted compassionate
appointment,
as
such,
the
petitioner
cannot
be
denied
compassionate appointment.
12.
It has also been brought to the attention of this Court that two
other individuals, namely Surendra Bahadur Singh and Suraj
Kirwar, were granted compassionate appointments by the
respondent–Corporation despite the fact that their mothers were
already employed in Government service. It is submitted that the
cases of the aforesaid individuals are identical to that of the
present petitioner, inasmuch as their fathers had died and their
mothers were in Government employment, yet compassionate
appointment was extended to them. In such circumstances, when
similarly situated persons have been granted the benefit of
compassionate appointment, denial of the same to the petitioner
would be arbitrary and discriminatory. Therefore, the petitioner
cannot be deprived of compassionate appointment when the
respondent–Corporation has extended the said benefit to other
similarly placed persons.
13.
In view of the above facts and in the light of decision of Hon ’ble
Supreme Court,
the
order
dated 30.05.2018 passed by
respondent No. 3 rejecting the petitioner’s application for
compassionate
appointment
(Annexure
P-1)
is
quashed.
Respondent No. 3 is hereby directed to grant compassionate
appointment to the petitioner at the earliest possible date,
following due procedure and formalities, but without raising any
objection on account of the mother’s employment.
14.
The writ petition is, accordingly, allowed.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
Shayna
(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review