Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3443 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TI.JESDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
CIVIL REVISION
ON NO: 3415 OF 2015
Petition under Section 115 of CPC aggrielred by the order dated 18.11 .2013
passed in E.A. Sr.No. 1731 of 2013 in E.P.No. 3 of 2013 on the file of the Court of
the lll Additional Chief Judge, City Civit Courts, Hyderabad.
Between:
1. Mukesh Singh, S/o. Late Shankar Singh, Occ: Dhobi and Government
Employee, R/o. House No. 10-5-2l1l24lD DhobiGhat Masab Tank Hyderabad.
2. Basanti Bai, Wo. Late Shankar Singh, Occ: Dhoban R/o. House No. 10-52l1t24tD Dhobi Ghat Masab Tank Hyd-erabad.
...Petitioners
AND
1. DR. B. Manik Chandra (died per tr's)
2. B. Ramchandra, S/o. Late Dr. B. Manik Chandra, Occ: Retd. Service R/o.E-39,
AFOCHS, Sainikpuri Secunderabad.
3. B.K. Chandra, S/o. Late Dr. B. Manik Chandra Occ: Retd. Service R/o E-39,
AFOCHS, Sainikpuri Secunderabdd.
4. Dr. B. Jagdish Ghandra, S/o. Late B. Manik Chandra, Aged: 61 years, Occ.
Retd. Service, R/o. 10-1-70 Shyam Nagar Colony Hyderabad.
5. Dr. B.N. Chandra, S/o. Late B. Manik Chandra, Aged: 57 years, R/o.
Chinautpally Dhanavram, Krishna District Occ: Retd. Service.
6. Dr. Vijayalakshmi Kalekar, Wo. Dr. K. Maschinder, Aged 63 years, Occ.
Medical Practitioner R/o. Develand, U.K. rep. by G.P. A B.K. Chandra S/o. Late
Dr. B. Manik Chandra r/o. E-39, AFOCHS, Sainikpuri, Secunderabad.
7. Smt. Krishna Sidhartha, Wo. H.P. Sidhartha, Aged: 57 years, R/o. G-06
Shikharam Apartments, Opp. Corner House Marathalli Main Road, Bangalore
Occ. House hold rep. by GPA holderB. Ramchandra.
8. The Governrnent of A.P., Rep. by the Secretary to the Government Revenue
Department, Govt. of A.P., Hyderabad
9. The Revenue Divisional OfFlc€r, Hyderabad Division, Hyderabad.
10' The Terhsirdar, Gorconda Mandar (presenty
Asifnagar Hyderabad
11' syed M;ahmood (died after passing
t.A. No. I
Asifnagar Mandar), Marepary,
of Judgment & Decree,.dated 21.03.2000)
...Respondents
o.
Petition under Section 151 cPC praying
that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit fited in supp.orr of the petition, tne
nr:sn
ffiffit:J'grant stay
of all further prcceedings in EP.No. 3 0t
2o1d;
i;"
fil.
of
the
lll Additionat chief
Judge, CCC., l-lyderabad, pending disposal
of the above CRp
c;;;t!,;
Counsel for the petitioners : Sri. Rakesh
Sanghi
counsel for th* Respondent No.s & 7 :
M/s Manjiri S Ganu
counser for thei Respondent No.3 aq sriiorrli"ii"i
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTTCE NARSING RAO NANDTKONDA
C.R.P. No3415 of 2015
6th Janu ary,2L26
Between:
Mukesh Singh and another
..Petitioners
AND
Dr.B.Manik Chandra & 10 others
Respondents
ORDER:
This Civil Revision Petition is filed by the petitioners under
Section I l5 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (for short C.P.C) assailing
the order dated 18.11 .2013 in E.A.SR.No.I731 of 2013 in E.P.No.3 of
2013 passed by the III Additional Chi€f Judge, City Civil Courts,
Hyderabad, (for short,'the impugned order').
l.
The petitioners herein are third parties and, being aggrieved by the
decree passed in O.S.No.240 of 1994, fild an application under Order 2l
Rules 97-10[ read with Section 47 of the C.P.C., seeking to refuse to
execute the execution proceedings i.e., E.P.No.3 of 2013.
2.
TtLe brief facts of the case are that the decree holders had filed
O.S.No.l140 of 1994 on the file of the III Additional C.hief Judge, City
Civil Crrurts, Hyderabad, against respondent Nos8 to 10, seeking
'. declaration of title and consequential perpetual injunction ir. respect of
premises bearing H.No. I 0- I -24, Saifabad, Hyderabad, admeasuring 2,965
square yards, claiming title over the suit schedule property which situated
in Survey No.157 of Mallepatly Village correlating to R.S.No.266lB of
Khairtat'ad Village. After the demise of the original decree holder,
respon&:nt Nos.2 to 7 were brought on record as his legal heirs.
il
3.
It is contended that the decree in O.S.No.240 of 1994 was obtained
by the cleceased judgment debtor by suppressing material facts, namely
that the father of the first claim petitioner and husband of the second
claim p,:titioner, late Shankar @ Shankar Singh, was in possession of
Govemlnent land bearing Town Survey No.20 (part), admeasuring 1,024
square yards, for several decades, which constitutes the northern portion
of the total extent claimed by respondent Nos.2 to 7. It is further
contended that Manikchandra had earlier instituted trro suits, namely
O.S.No. 1856 of 1980 on the file of the V Assistant Judge, City Civil
Court, Hyderabad, and O.S.No.3232 of 1980 on the file of the VIII
Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, seeking perpetual
injunction against Shankar @ Shankar Singh on the basis ofa registered
:3
sale deed, and that both the suits were dismissed on the ground that
Manikchandra failed to,prove title, entitlement, and posqession. Appeals
in A.S.No.I49 of 1989 and r':S.No.9l of 1990 were atso dismissed by the
Additional chief Judge, city civil ceyt, Hyderabad, byjudgment dared
08.07. lgg4,holding that the judgment debtor failed to piove the location,
title, or possession, as the boundaries and extent could not be determined.
4. It is further contended that in the said suits, it was specifically
pleaded that the father of claim petitioner No.l and husband of claim
petitioner No.2 was in possession of the diryuted vacant land, and
therefore the question of granting injunction did not arise, and
accordingly the suits were dismissed. It is the contention of respondent
Nos.2 ro 7 in O.S.No.240 of 1,994 that their deoeased father was in
possession of the application schedule site and additional land bearing
Municipal No.l0-l-24, Masab Tank, Hyderabad, correlating to Revenue
Survey No.266lB of Khairtabad Village andSurveyNo.l5T of Mallepally
Village, Golconda Mandal, admeasuring 2,950 square yards for decades
lt is alleged that they suppressed the fact that they were not in possession
of the balance extent of [,250 squar€ yards under occr4ation of late
Shankar, located in Town Survey No.20 on the northern side of Town
Survey No.25.
'.:4::
5.
It is further contended that the learned Govemment Pleader failed
to bring to the notice of the learned Judge that the crucial.entry relating to
the extent of Town Survey No.25 relied upon by the respondents had
' been ilk,gally tampered with, wherein the original entry of 0:13 squale
meters ''ras ahbred to 12 acres 25 square meters by rounding off the
original entry with a pencil. It is further contended that the judgment and
decree in o.S.No.240 of Lgg4 were obtained fraudulentty and
clandestinely by playing fraud upon the Court and by falsely claiming
possession over lands in Town Survey Nos.2, 20, and 25 ofMailepally
i,
I
I
t
I
lr
t:
Village, and that revenue officials colluded with respondent Nos.2 to 7
and ignored the tampering of TSLR entries.
!
i
i
6.
I
I
I
It is also contended that the f,rrst and second claim petitioners and
I
l
I
I
their farnily members f,rled separate apptications for regularisation of their
t
I
t:
j
:
.
I
I
respective plots admeasuring approximately 224 square yards and 200
square yards under G.o.Ms.No.l66 dated 16.02.2008, admitting
I
i
occupation of Government land situated in Town Survey No.20, Block
i
l
i
'G', ward No.37 of Mallepally Village, and that the Government
accepteC the regularisation amounts, though execution of conveyance
deeds is pending on account of writ petitions filed by respondent Nos.2 to
7 in w.P.Nos. 12174, t2175, t2176, 12371. and 12372 of 2011. It is
l
:
;
I
I
T
I
I
further submitted that respondent Nos.2 to 7, _nor heino .^tisfied with
:f,
grabbing of the application schedule {and comprising a vast extent of
Government land, instituted a bogus suit in O.S.No.21O5 of 20O9 by
suppressing earlier litigation and obtained injunction. It is contended that
the decree holders' claim is based on fraud and collusion, as the property
covered under the alleged sale deed of 1918 A.D.'is different from the
lands situated in Town Survey Nos.20 and25.
7. It is further contended that respondent Nos.2 to 7 had earlier
institnted O.S.No.457 of 1979 in respect of premises,No.l0-I.24,
Saifabad, Hyderabad, falsely correlating the salne to Survey No.266lB,
and that an implead petition filed by Shankar Singh in that suit was
dismissed. In C.R.P.No.4802 of 1987, the plaintiffs gave an undertaking
before this Court that the property involved therein was differ-ent fiom the
one claimed by Shankar Singh, based on which the Civil Revision
Petition was dismissed. It is further contended that the judgrnents and
decrees passed in O.S.No.240 of 1994 and O.S.No.457 of 1979 are not
. binding on the claim petitioners
in tenns of Section 43 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872.
8.
It is further contended that since respondent Nos.2 to 7 arc denyrng
the title of the Government over the application schedule site, they are
estopped from claiming adverse title and are, therefore, land grabbers,
i
I
I
J
i
:
I
I
I
)
::6::
and that the claim petitioners have already filed L.G.C.No.33 of 2012
under the provisions of the Andhra Pradesh Land Grabbing (Prohibition)
Act, 19821. It appean that the application under Order XXI Rules 97-l0l
read with Section 47 of the CJ.C. .r,as filed before the Executing Court at
the stage of adrdssiSn;,66 without adjudicating either the admissibility
or the rnerits of the claim, lhs learned Executing Court rejected
E.A.SR.I.lo.l73l of 2013 at the inception stage.
9.
Ag;grieved thereby, the present Civil Revision Petition has been
filed contending that the learned Judge failed to consider the mandatory
provisiorts of Section 47 of the C.P.C., which require that all questions
relating to execution, discharge, or satisfaction of a decree must be
decided,rcy the Executing Court and not by way of a separate suit. It is
further oontended that the learned Judge ignored the fact that the
responde,nts themselves have filed writ petitions challenging the
assignmr:nts made by the Government in favour of the petitioners, and
thereforer the claim petitioners, who are concemed with the suit schedule
land fonning part of the execution proceedings, ought to have been heard
and adjudicated during execution. [t is further contended that the
petitioners and their family members became owners of the suit schedule
land vide Government Orders dated 29.04.2011 and, being
representatives of the judgment debtor, are entitled to contest the
execution proceedings, and that the application ought to have been
decided on merits insteadof being rejected at the threshold,
10. It is further contended that the petitioners had no alternative
remedy except invoking Section 47 of the C.P.C., and that the leamed
trial court ignored the pendency of proceedings under the Andhra Pradesh
Land Grabbing (Prohibition) Act, tg82, wherein the respondents were
alleged to have illegally occupied a substantial portion of the suit tand.
Learned counsel for the petitioners argued that the petitioners,.being legal
heirs oflate'shankar Singh and being in possession of Government lan4
:rryere entitled to be heard, and that the decree in O.S.No.240-of:,1994 is
fraudulent; iltegal, non est, and not binding upon them. It was further
argud that by filing the execution petition for eviction,",'the decree
holders.are attempting to exert pressure on revenue authorities to interfere
with the suit schedule property.
11. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents contended that the
petitioners are merely relying upon Covernrnent Orders and that no
conveyance deeds were ever issued in their favour, and that status quo
orders were operating against them.
12. Lt:arned counsel for the petitioners placed reliance on the
judgmerLts of the Honlble Supreme Court reported in AIR 2002 SC 2572,
(2013) S;CC 97, AIR 1958 Se 394, and also on 1457 AP 784.
13. On a consideration of the en'tire mateda! placed on record and the
rival sutrmissions, it appears that the learned Executing Court rejected the
application solely on the ground that the petitioners were neither parties
to the suit nor to the execution proceedings. Such rejection at the
incepticn stage, without affording an opportunity to the petitioners to
establish their claim under Section 47 of the C.P.C. and Order XXI Rules
97-101, cannot be sustained. The Executing Court ought to have afforded
an opportunity to the petitioners and adjudicated their claims on merits.
Order )(XI Rule 96 has no application to the f,acts of the present case, as
the exe:cution does not relate to delivery of possession of a different
nature
14. lt'his Court is of the considered opinion that the rejection o[ the
application at the threshold is erroneous and unsustainable in law and
warrants interference. Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed,
and tht: order dated 18.11.2013 passed by the III Additional Chief Judge,
of
City Civil Courts, Hyderabad, in E.A.SR.No. 173 I of 2013 in E.P.No.3
..r-_
2013 is set aside. The matter is remitted back to the Executing Court to
::9::
decide the said application on merits, after affording opportunity to both
parties, and to dispose of the same in accordance with law.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
SD/- L VIJAYA LAXMI
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFIGER
To,
.
.1.1 ...
.'
The lllAdditiona! Chief Judge, City Civil Courts, Hyderabad.
2. One CC to M/s ManjiriS Ganu, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to Sri Rakesh Sanghi, Advocate [OPUC]
4. One CG to Sri.G.Dhananjai, Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two CD Copies
1.
Sa/PSL
tw
.t
/
t
/
I
HIGH COTJRT
DATED: 06/01 12026
1 t-tE S
(
ORDER
CRP.No.3415 of 2015
*
ALLOWIT{G THE CRP
7(s
s/"/ze -
I
F t:
I 2l,:6
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review