Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:2093
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ORDER RESERVED ON 02.01.2026
ORDER DELIVERED ON 13.01.2026
ORDER RESERVED ON 13.01.2026
MCRC No. 8849 of 2025
1 - Mukesh Manchanda S/o Late Indra Kumar Manchanda Aged About
57 Years R/o Aishwariya Empire, House No. 108, Akanti Vihar, Raipur,
District- Raipur (C.G.)
... Applicant(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through ACB/EOW Raipur, District - Raipur
(C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
MCRC No. 8857 of 2025
1 - Atul Singh S/o Late Shri Nag Narayan Singh Aged About 58 Years
R/o 67/b, Street 12, Smriti Nagar, Motilal Nehru Nagar, District- Durg
(C.G.)
---Applicant(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Eow Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Shri Anil Pillai assisted by Shri Achyut
Tiwari and Shri Gendesh Dadsena,
Advocates
For Respondent/State
:
Dr. Saurabh Kumar Pande, Dy.AG
(HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE ARVIND KUMAR VERMA)
C A V Order
Since both the bail applications have arisen out of the same crime
number, involve identical allegations, are founded upon a common set
of facts, and the applicants Manish Manchanda and Atul Singh stand
similarly situated, this Court deems it appropriate to dispose of the
present applications by this common order.
2.
These applications under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure/Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita have
been preferred by the applicants seeking regular bail in connection with
Crime No.04/2024 registered at Police Station Economic Wing/AntiCorruption Bureau, Raipur (C.G.) for offences punishable under
Sections 420, 467, 468, 471, 120-B of the Indian Penal Code and
Sections 7 and 12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
3.
report
The prosecution case, in brief, emanates from a confidential
submitted
by
the
Enforcement
Directorate
bearing
ECIR/RPZO/11/2022/279 dated 11.07.2023, on the basis of which Crime
No.04/2024 came to be registered by the Economic Offence Wing/Anti-
Corruption Bureau, Raipur. It was alleged that during investigation
conducted by the Enforcement Directorate, a criminal syndicate was
found to be operating in the State of Chhattisgarh, which was allegedly
involved in extorting illegal commissions in the sale of liquor and in
unauthorized sale of unaccounted liquor through government liquor
shops, thereby generating proceeds of crime to the tune of
approximately ₹2161 crores.
4.
On receipt of the said information, EOW/ACB, Raipur conducted
secret verification and thereafter took up the matter for investigation.
Initially, the Enforcement Directorate carried out investigation and
provisional attachment orders were executed against certain accused
persons.
5.
The FIR, contains the names of about 70 persons as accused,
including the present applicants. However, it is evident from the FIR
itself that no specific overt act has been attributed to the applicants
therein. The allegations, as reflected from the FIR and the material
placed on record, are primarily founded upon the written information
received from the Enforcement Directorate and broadly relate to
formation of syndicates and payment of exorbitant commissions to
facilitate liquor-related transactions.
6.
Upon completion of investigation, the Economic Offence Wing
filed the initial charge-sheet No.03/24 dated 29.06.2024 against four
accused persons namely (i) Arunpati Tripathi, (ii) Arvind Singh, (iii)
Anwar Dhebar and (iv) Trilok Singh Dhillon. Subsequently, under
further investigation, supplementary charge-sheets bearing Nos.3A/24,
3B/24, 3C/25, 3D/25 and 3E/25 were filed on different dates.
7.
During the course of investigation, the applicants were repeatedly
summoned, their premises were subjected to investigation,and they
were questioned on multiple occasions. It is not disputed that the
applicants cooperated with the investigation and responded to the
summons issued by the investigating agency.
8.
The applicants were thereafter arrested by the Jharkhand Police
pursuant to registration of Crime No.09/2025 dated 07.07.2025 at Police
Station Economic Wing/Anti-Corruption Bureau, Raipur (C.G.) for
offences under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471, 409, 107, 109 IPC read
with Sections 7-C, 12 and 13(1)(a) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
In the said case, bail has already been granted by the competent court
in Jharkhand and the formalities for release have been complied with.
9.
Subsequently, while the applicants were in custody in Jharkhand,
they were produced before the Special Judge (Prevention of Corruption
Act), Raipur through production warrant, whereupon they were formally
arrested in the present crime. Since the date of such arrest, the
applicants continue to remain in judicial custody at Raipur Jail.
10.
The bail applications filed by the applicants before the learned
Special Court was rejected, compelling the applicants to approach this
Court.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANTS
11.
At the outset, it is submitted that the present applications deserve
to be considered and allowed by this Court on the touchstone of
constitutional liberty, settled principles governing grant of bail, absence
of incriminating material, and parity, particularly when the entire
prosecution case rests on conjectures, surmises and unsubstantiated
inferences.
I.
BACKGROUND AND UNIMPEACHABLE BONA FIDES OF THE
APPLICANTS
12.
The Applicants, who are facing identical allegations arising out of
the same crime number, are engaged in the business of marketing,
promotion and distribution of alcoholic beverages, including IMFL, FMFL
and beer, for Indian and international manufacturers. It is alleged that
prior to the year 2020, they were associated with each other in this line
of business and operated as recognized trade intermediaries with
established commercial relationships across the States of Madhya
Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand, predominantly in Chhattisgarh.
Upon the revision of the Excise Policy in the year 2020, the Applicants
restructured their business operations in conformity with the altered
regulatory framework and jointly incorporated M/s Om Sai Beverages
Private Limited, which was duly granted a valid FL-10A licence for
distribution and stocking of liquor.
13.
The applicants stand on identical factual and legal footing, the
allegations against them arise out of the same charge sheet, same
transaction, and same set of circumstances. The prosecution has failed
to draw any intelligible distinction between the applicants and other
similarly situated persons.
14.
Prior to the change in Excise Policy in the year 2020, the
applicants were operating as partners for over two decades. Pursuant to
the change in policy, they lawfully incorporated M/s Om Sai Beverages
Pvt. Ltd., obtained FL-10A licence, and commenced operations.
15.
It emerges from the charge sheet itself that:
•
the applicants participated in the tender process;
•
no irregularity in the grant of licence has been alleged;
•
no violation of excise rules in procurement or supply has been
attributed to them.
II. ABSENCE OF PRIMA FACIE OFFENCE OR CULPABLE INTENT
16.
The gravamen of the prosecution case rests upon a vague and
undefined concept of a so-called “Syndicate”. However, the charge
sheet:
•
does not identify the constituents of such Syndicate with certainty;
•
does not attribute any specific overt act to the applicants;
•
does not demonstrate any meeting of minds, which is the sine qua
non for criminal conspiracy.
It is trite law that criminal conspiracy cannot be inferred on the
basis of suspicion alone. There must be clear, cogent and unequivocal
evidence demonstrating conscious participation.
17.
In State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, (2005) 11 SCC 600,
the Supreme Court held that:
“Suspicion, however strong, cannot take the place of proof. Conspiracy
has to be established by evidence which shows a prior meeting of
minds.”
The entire material against the applicants, even if taken at face
value, fails to satisfy this legal threshold.
III. CHARGE SHEET BASED ON SURMISES AND SELF-SERVING
NARRATIVES
18.
•
A careful reading of the charge sheet reveals that:
the narration is largely derivative, based on statements allegedly
made by other accused persons;
•
there is no independent corroboration by documentary or forensic
evidence;
•
no recovery of illegal proceeds has been made from the
applicants.
The Apex Court in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of
Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116, has categorically held that “Suspicion,
however grave, cannot be a substitute for legal proof.” The present
cases, at its highest, raises suspicion, but falls woefully short of legal
proof, even at a prima facie level.
IV.
APPLICANTS
THEMSELVES
EMERGE AS
COERCION
19.
Strikingly, the charge sheet itself indicates that:
VICTIMS
OF
the applicants’ firm was pressurized and coerced into making
•
commission payments;
the applicants refused to pay cash and insisted on accounted
•
transactions;
coercive tactics involving influence and intimidation were allegedly
•
exercised by co-accused persons.
20.
The
applicants,
therefore,
cannot
be
treated
as
willing
participants, but rather appear as victims compelled to comply under
duress. In R. Venkatkrishnan v. CBI, (2009) 11 SCC 737, the Apex
Court observed that “Mens rea is an essential ingredient of economic
offences and must be demonstrable from the material on record.” The
material on record does not disclose any mens rea, much less criminal
intent, on the part of the applicants.
V.
TOTAL ABSENCE OF FINANCIAL TRAIL OR UNACCOUNTED
GAIN
21.
It is an admitted position that all transactions of the applicants’
firm were through banking channels, the income tax returns were
furnished; no authority, including the Income Tax Department, has found
any unaccounted income.
The Apex Court in P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of
Enforcement, (2019) 9 SCC 24, held that “In economic offences, the
existence of a money trail is a crucial factor while considering bail.”
In the present matters, no money trail whatsoever links the
applicants to the alleged proceeds of crime.
VI.
DISPROPORTIONATE
TARGETING
AND
SELECTIVE
INVESTIGATION
22.
The charge sheet itself acknowledges allegations against
certain Excise Officers; however, none of them have been arrested
or subjected to custodial interrogation, while private businessmen
like the applicants have been sought to be implicated. Such selective
prosecution raises serious doubts about the fairness of the
investigation, which cannot be ignored at the stage of bail.
VII. PARITY AND SETTLED BAIL JURISPRUDENCE
23.
He submits that the applicants’ case stands on absolute parity
with similarly placed accused persons. Denial of bail in such
circumstances would violate Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The
Supreme Court in Dataram Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2018) 3
SCC 22, reiterated that “Grant of bail is the rule and refusal is the
exception. Every accused is presumed innocent until proven guilty.”
Further, in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, (2012) 1 SCC 40, it was held that
“Pre-trial incarceration should not be resorted to as a measure of
punishment.”
VIII. NO REQUIREMENT OF CUSTODIAL INTERROGATION
24.
He next submits that the investigation is complete. Charge sheet
has been filed. All documents are in possession of the prosecution.
Continued custody of the applicants would serve no useful purpose and
would amount to punitive detention, impermissible in law.
25.
In the light of the aforesaid factual and legal analysis of the
charge sheet, it is most respectfully submitted that by no stretch of
imagination can the alleged involvement of the applicants be termed
incriminating. The charge sheet does not disclose a single circumstance
indicative of willful participation, conscious intent, or culpable mens rea
on the part of the applicant in the commission of the alleged offence.
Mere association, commercial engagement, or regulatory participation,
absent criminal intent, cannot be elevated to criminal liability.
26.
It is further submitted that upon an overall conspectus of the
charge sheet, except for the narrative or script woven by the
Investigating Officer—bereft of any legally admissible or independent
evidence—certain striking and revealing features emerge, which
fundamentally erode the prosecution’s case:
(i) The charge sheet itself demonstrates the active participation of one
Sanjay Diwan in the execution and facilitation of the alleged offence.
Despite his prominent and decisive role emerging from the prosecution’s
own
record,
the
Investigating
Agency
has,
with
conspicuous
convenience, chosen to project him as a prosecution witness, thereby
shielding him from criminal liability.
(ii) The illegal activities attributed to Sanjay Diwan, as per the
Investigating Officer’s own narration, are demonstrably more grave and
direct than those attributed to the present applicants. Yet, paradoxically,
Sanjay Diwan enjoys the status of a prosecution witness, while the
applicant is sought to be incarcerated, which exposes the selective and
discriminatory approach of the investigation.
(iii) It is further relevant that Vijay Bhatia, against whom the charge
sheet attributes a far greater and controlling role in the management
and orchestration of the alleged illegal activities, has already been
granted bail by this Court in M.Cr.C. No. 5601/2025 vide order dated
25.09.2025. The acts attributed to Vijay Bhatia are of a significantly
higher degree of gravity than those alleged against the present
applicants. Denial of bail to the applicants, therefore, would offend the
settled principle of parity.
(iv) The facility of non-arrest extended to the Excise Officers, though
named as accused in the charge sheet, is also a circumstance that
warrants serious judicial consideration. The Investigating Officer has
justified
such
non-arrest
by
relying
upon
cooperation
during
investigation, drawing sustenance from the law laid down by the
Supreme Court in Siddharth v. State of Uttar Pradesh, Criminal
Appeal No. 838 of 2021, wherein it has been categorically held that
custodial arrest is not mandatory where the accused has cooperated in
the investigation. The same standard, however, has been selectively
denied to the applicant, despite his undisputed cooperation for over a
year.
27.
It is further submitted that the applicant has cooperated fully and
unconditionally with the Investigating Agency since 11.04.2024, has
appeared pursuant to summons, and has furnished every conceivable
detail including financial records, bank statements, and income tax
returns. The charge sheet itself reflects that it is predominantly based on
statements and disclosures, rather than any independent, cogent, or
tangible evidence. The Supreme Court has repeatedly cautioned that
arrest cannot be used as a tool of punishment or coercion, particularly
after completion of investigation.
28.
The more disturbing question that arises for consideration is as to
what compelling circumstance necessitated the custodial arrest of the
applicant, despite his prompt and sustained cooperation, and why the
Investigating Agency adopted a pick-and-choose policy while effecting
arrests. Such an approach not only undermines the fairness of
investigation but also strikes at the root of Article 14 and Article 21 of the
Constitution of India.
29.
It is submitted that the entire charge sheet does not contain even
a solitary fact which may indicate that the applicants were a willing or
voluntary participant in earning wrongful gains. On the contrary, the
charge sheet itself reveals the coercive environment under which the
applicants were compelled to function, thereby constituting a significant
mitigating circumstance in favour of the applicants. The applicants are in
judicial custody since 07.07.2025, including detention in Jharkhand Jail.
The investigation stands concluded, the charge sheet is voluminous,
and the list of prosecution witnesses is extensive. It is thus evident that
the trial is likely to be protracted, and continued incarceration of the
applicant, in the absence of substantive evidence, would amount to pretrial punishment, which is impermissible in law.
30.
It is further submitted that accused persons namely, Vijay Bhatia,
whose role is far more dominant and Abhishek Singh, who stands on
parity with the present applicants, have already been granted bail by this
Court. Denial of bail to the present applicants in such circumstances
would be manifestly arbitrary and contrary to settled bail jurisprudence.
The Supreme Court in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, (2012) 1 SCC 40, has
held that deprivation of liberty must be considered a punishment unless
it is required to ensure the presence of accused at trial. Similarly, in
Dataram Singh v. State of U.P., (2018) 3 SCC 22, it has been
reiterated that grant of bail is the rule and refusal is the exception.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
Nature and gravity of the offence
31.
The present matters pertain to a deep-rooted, multi-layered
economic conspiracy which has caused colossal loss to the State
exchequer and has systematically subverted the Excise administration
of Chhattisgarh. The offence is not a simple financial irregularity but an
institutionalized criminal syndicate that manipulated liquor policy,
licensing, procurement, pricing and retail distribution for illegal
enrichment. The Supreme Court has consistently held that economic
offences corrode the fabric of governance and public trust and must be
treated as grave crimes. In Gulabrao Baburao Deokar v. State of
Maharashtra, (2013) 16 SCC 190, the Apex Court held that the
seriousness of economic offences and their impact on society are
crucial considerations while dealing with bail. He submits that between
the financial year 2019-20 to financial year 2022-23, the syndicate
earned approximately ₹3,200 crore, directly depriving the public
exchequer of lawful revenue.
II. Role of the applicant is central and not peripheral
32.
The applicant Atul Singh was not a passive license holder. He was
selected by the syndicate as a trusted intermediary for implementing the
FL-10A license mechanism.
33.
The evidence on record shows that the applicant and his partner
Mukesh Manchanda were pre-selected by the syndicate before the
February 2020 tender. They were informed in advance that 60% of the
profits of their FL-10A company would be paid to the syndicate and only
40% retained by them. Om Sai Beverages was incorporated
specifically for this purpose and was granted FL-10A licenses for three
consecutive financial years. The company earned about ₹68 crore (₹41
crore post-tax) and ₹41 crore (60%) was earmarked for the syndicate.
This shows a pre-designed criminal profit-sharing arrangement, which
squarely attracts Sections 120-B, 420 IPC and Sections 7, 12 of the PC
Act.
34.
It is borne out from the record that the company of the applicant
Atul Singh, namely M/s Om Sai Beverages, in partnership with Mukesh
Manchanda, was granted the FL-10A licence for three consecutive
financial years pursuant to the design of the criminal syndicate. During
this period, the said company generated a total profit of approximately
₹68 crores, out of which about ₹41 crores represented post-tax profits.
In accordance with the pre-arranged understanding with the syndicate,
60% of these profits, amounting to approximately ₹41 crores, was
contractually earmarked to be paid to the syndicate as illegal
commission, leaving only 40% to be retained by the company.
35.
Since payment of such a substantial amount in cash posed
practical difficulties, a large portion of the syndicate’s share,
approximately ₹23 crores, was systematically routed and parked in the
form of unsecured loans in entities controlled by syndicate associates,
including Dhillon City Mall, owned by Trilok Singh Dhillon, and Sai
Prasanna Developers, owned by Gautam Manik. The remaining
portion of the syndicate’s share continues to remain outstanding,
thereby reflecting the continuing financial nexus between the applicant
and the syndicate.
36.
It is further revealed that from the 40% retained share of the
profits of Om Sai Beverages, 52% was held by Vijay Bhatia, a close
associate of the syndicate, who received approximately ₹5.5 crores,
while the balance of about ₹13 crores was secured and channelled by
him through unsecured loans to his own firms and allied entities, thereby
layering and concealing the true character of the proceeds of crime.
III. Financial trail and laundering through unsecured loans
37.
The applicants adopted a structured method to conceal their
retained 40% share by routing profits as “unsecured loans” to third
parties Specifically ₹4 crore was routed via Manav Saxena → Chandan
Jha, with interest returned to the applicant. The FY 2022-23 books of
Om Sai Beverages show ₹21.27 crore in unsecured loans to
multiple shell-like entities including Nilai Syndicates, Samanvaya
Iron & Steel, New Era Enterprises, Maruti Nandan Construction, Jai
Gurudev Infrastructure etc.
These entries are not commercial loans but layering and
placement designed to conceal illicit profits.
38.
Additionally, commission-related funds for FY 2023-24 were found
parked in DSNR, another company of the applicants. Such conduct
demonstrates money-laundering-like layering, which can be witnessed
only when the accused remains in control of corporate structures and
financial channels.
V. Investigation is still ongoing and custodial necessity continues
39.
It is further submitted that the record shows that there are Multiple
supplementary charge sheets (up to 03(E)/2025) have been filed, 29
Excise officials and multiple associates are still under investigation.
Further investigation into money trail, layering, shell companies and
syndicate routing is actively in progress.
The Supreme Court in
Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar, (2020) 2 SCC 118, has held that bail can be
cancelled or denied if the High Court fails to consider the seriousness of
allegations and the necessity of custodial presence in complex
conspiracies. In economic conspiracies, custody is not merely for
interrogation but for preventing further concealment and manipulation of
evidence.
V. Real risk of tampering, intimidation and destruction of evidence
40.
The applicants Controlled the companies and its financial
accounts, has deep links with co-accused, promoters, shell entities, and
syndicate beneficiaries. He is therefore eminently capable of destroying
or fabricating digital and financial records Influencing witnesses
Obstructing money-trail tracing.
41.
In State of U.P. v. Amarmani Tripathi, (2005) 8 SCC 21, the
Supreme Court held that likelihood of tampering with evidence,
influencing witnesses and evasion of justice are decisive grounds to
deny bail. The present matters squarely satisfies all three.
VI. Length of custody does not entitle bail in grave economic crime
42.
The applicants may seek bail citing period of incarceration.
However, the Supreme Court has categorically held that custody
duration alone is not decisive. In State of U.P. v. Amarmani Tripathi
(supra) and Prahlad Singh Bhati v. NCT of Delhi, (2001) 4 SCC 280,
it was held that where gravity of offence, likelihood of tampering, and
seriousness of allegations exist, custody cannot be the basis of bail. In
the present matters, the applicants are charged with being an architect
of a revenue-diverting mechanism, not a minor participant.
VII. Bail jurisprudence mandates refusal in such structured
conspiracies
43.
In Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan, (2004) 7 SCC 528,
the Supreme Court held that bail must not be granted unless the Court
records prima facie satisfaction regarding the absence of serious
involvement. Here in the instance case, prima facie, the applicants
entered into a 60-40 profit-sharing criminal contract and earned crores
from an illegal licensing framework, concealed profits through loan
layering and actively facilitated diversion of public revenue. This is not a
case of regulatory breach but of organized economic crime.
VIII. Statements under Section 161 CrPC are admissible at bail
44.
In Indresh Kumar v. State of U.P., Criminal Appeal No. 938 of
2022, the Supreme Court held that Section 161 statements can be
considered while deciding bail. The prosecution relies on such
statements to demonstrate:
•
Pre-selection of Atul Singh
•
Knowledge of the 60-40 split
•
Routing of profits
•
Syndicate linkage
These materials cannot be ignored at the bail stage.
IX. Legal Grounds for Rejection of Bail
45.
It is submitted that the law governing grant or refusal of bail has
been consistently and authoritatively settled by a catena of judgments of
the Supreme Court. At the stage of consideration of the applications for
bail, the Court is required to undertake a careful judicial evaluation of
well-recognized parameters, namely:
•
the likelihood of the accused absconding or fleeing from justice;
•
the possibility of the accused tampering with evidence; and
the likelihood of the accused influencing or intimidating witnesses.
46.
These principles have been lucidly laid own by the Supreme Court
in State of U.P. v. Amarmani Tripathi, (2005) 8 SCC 21 (paras 16–19
& 21), which continue to hold the field. In the said decision, the Apex
Court held that while considering an application for bail, the Court must
be satisfied, inter alia, on the following aspects:
(i) whether there exists a prima facie case or reasonable ground to
believe that the accused has committed the offence;
(ii) the nature and gravity of the accusation;
(iii) the severity of punishment in the event of conviction;
(iv) the danger of the accused absconding or fleeing from justice if
released on bail;
(v) the character, conduct, position and standing of the accused;
(vi) the likelihood of the offence being repeated;
(vii) the reasonable apprehension of witnesses being tampered with;
and
(viii) the larger interest of justice, including the possibility of justice being
thwarted by grant of bail.
47.
It has been further held by the Apex Court further held that mere
long incarceration by itself is not a determinative factor for grant of bail,
particularly where the allegations are serious and supported by material
on record.
48.
The above principles were further reinforced in Dolat Ram v.
State of Haryana, (1995) 1 SCC 349, wherein the Apex Court
emphasized that rejection of bail at the initial stage and cancellation of
bail already granted operate on different footings, and that interference
with the course of justice, evasion of justice, or abuse of the concession
of bail constitute strong grounds to refuse or cancel bail.
49.
Thus, where the material on record discloses a strong prima facie
case, involvement of the accused in a serious and organized economic
offence, and the real likelihood of tampering with evidence, influencing
witnesses or subverting the administration of justice, the discretion to
grant bail must be exercised with utmost circumspection.
50.
In the present matter, the allegations disclose a systematic, well-
organized and financially massive criminal conspiracy, involving
diversion of public revenue and generation of illegal proceeds through
layered financial transactions. Having regard to the nature of
accusations, the magnitude of the offence, the continuing investigation
and the applicants’ position within the syndicate, the parameters laid
down in Amarmani Tripathi (supra) and allied judgments squarely
operate against the grant of bail.
51.
Lastly, he submits that the applicants are not innocent
businessmen but core beneficiaries and facilitators of a criminal
revenue-diversion
syndicate
Department.
scale,
The
that
operated
sophistication,
within
money-trail,
the
Excise
continuing
investigation and influence of the applicants make them wholly
disentitled to bail. He submits that Grant of bail at this stage would:
•
Endanger the investigation
•
Enable destruction of financial evidence
•
Allow intimidation of witnesses
•
Undermine public confidence in the justice system
The application therefore deserves to be rejected in the interests of
justice.
FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION :
52.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties at length and having
perused the voluminous material placed on record, including the chargesheets, supplementary reports, statements, financial documents and
digital records and proceeds to evaluate the rival submissions in the
light of the settled principles governing grant of bail.
53.
The task before the Court is to strike a judicious balance between
the imperatives of a fair and effective investigation on the one hand and
the inviolable right to personal liberty enshrined under Article 21 of the
Constitution on the other. Despite the filing of the main charge-sheet
and multiple supplementary charge-sheets, the record does not reveal
any allegation that the applicants exercised coercive authority, decisionmaking control over public officials, or operational command over the
alleged policy framework. The accusations against the applicants are
essentially founded upon financial linkages and business transactions,
which, at this stage, remain matters requiring full-fledged trial and
cannot be conclusively adjudicated in bail proceedings.
54.
The very magnitude of the present case underscores the utter
futility of subjecting the applicants to prolonged pre-trial incarceration.
As per the prosecution's own averments, the matter implicates as many
as 51 accused persons, with a staggering 1110 witnesses proposed to
be examined and approximately 990 documents comprising thousands
of pages of material. Notably, charges remain unframed against several
accused, and the investigation is stated to be ongoing. In such
circumstances, any prospect of an early culmination of the trial is, at
best, illusory and, at worst, non-existent. It is trite law that prolonged
detention in a case of this complexity and dimension would tantamount
to imposing punishment prior to conviction, which is impermissible in our
constitutional jurisprudence. Furthermore, it would constitute a gross
violation of the applicant's fundamental right to a speedy trial, enshrined
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India—a right repeatedly affirmed
by the Supreme Court in Hussainara Khatoon v. Home Secretary,
State of Bihar (1980) 1 SCC 81 and P. Ramachandra Rao v. State of
Karnataka (2002) 4 SCC 578, inter alia. The rigours of Article 21
demand that pre-trial detention must be the exception, not the rule,
particularly where trial progression is demonstrably protracted.
55.
It is equally material that the investigation remains open-ended
and continuing, even after a considerable lapse of time. While the
prosecution asserts the necessity of custodial detention for effective
investigation, this Court is guided by the consistent position of law that
custody cannot be used as a substitute for investigation nor as a tool for
extracting confessions or compelling cooperation. The Supreme Court in
Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Satender Kumar Antil v. CBI has
unequivocally held that pre-trial incarceration must not be permitted to
assume the character of punishment, particularly when the evidence is
largely documentary and already in the custody of the investigating
agency.
56.
The prosecution’s principal objection is founded upon the
seriousness of the economic offence and the alleged magnitude of
financial diversion. While the gravity of the offence is undoubtedly a
relevant factor, the Supreme Court has consistently clarified that gravity
alone cannot eclipse the constitutional mandate of liberty, especially
when the accused is not a flight risk and when investigation has
substantially progressed (Nikesh Tarachand Shah, P. Chidambaram).
57.
The apprehension of tampering with evidence or influencing
witnesses, though strenuously urged, remains general and unsupported
by any concrete material. The evidence in the present cases are
primarily financial, documentary and electronic, which is already in the
possession of the investigating agency. Such evidence is inherently less
vulnerable to manipulation, and any residual apprehension can be
sufficiently addressed by imposing stringent conditions of bail.
58.
This Court finds that the plea of parity raised by the Applicants is
not merely attractive but constitutionally compelling. The doctrine of
parity flows directly from Article 14 of the Constitution, which mandates
that similarly situated persons must receive similar treatment in matters
of personal liberty. In a prosecution of this magnitude, involving 51
accused spread across six charge-sheets, the selective incarceration of
a few while the rest — including those with demonstrably graver roles —
enjoy liberty, cannot withstand constitutional scrutiny.
59.
From the material placed on record, it is evident that several co-
accused, who have been specifically alleged to be kingpins, cash
aggregators, departmental facilitators and major beneficiaries of the
alleged liquor syndicate, have already been granted bail by the
Supreme Court. These include Arun Pati Tripathi (A-1), alleged to be
the mastermind of the syndicate; Trilok Singh Dhillon (A-5) and
Anurag Dwivedi (A-5), described as principal beneficiaries and
handlers of illicit proceeds; Arvind Singh (A-2), having direct Excise
Department linkage; as many as 29 Excise Officials who are alleged to
have been involved in the very same liquor scam and against whom
serious allegations were levelled by the prosecution, have already been
enlarged on bail by the Apex Court, who stand on a footing far graver
than the present Applicants, yet they have been enlarged on bail by
superior court and the co-accused namely Sanjay Kumar Mishra (A-4),
coordinating between distillers and political beneficiaries; and Vijay
Bhatia (A-41) and Sunil Dutt (A-10) have been granted bail by this
Court.
60.
This Court is, therefore, of the considered view that the continued
detention of the Applicants, in the face of liberty granted to co-accused
with greater and more direct culpability, cannot be sustained on the
touchstone of constitutional equality and fairness, and their claim for bail
on the ground of parity deserves to be upheld
61.
This Court also takes note of the fact that there is no material to
suggest that they have ever attempted to evade investigation or flee
from justice. The trial, considering the volume of material and number of
accused, is likely to take considerable time, and continued incarceration
would amount to pre-trial punishment, which is alien to criminal
jurisprudence.
62.
The law laid down in Amarmani Tripathi, Kalyan Chandra
Sarkar, Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar and Sanjay Chandra makes it clear
that bail is to be refused only when the triple test of flight risk, tampering
with evidence, or likelihood of influencing witnesses is satisfied. On a
cumulative assessment of the material before this Court, none of these
conditions is attracted against the applicant.
CONCLUSION :
63.
In the considered opinion of this Court, continued detention of the
applicants is neither necessary for the purposes of investigation nor
justified on the touchstone of constitutional proportionality. The
presumption of innocence, the principle of parity, the documentary
nature of evidence, and the absence of any demonstrated risk of
absconding or interference with justice all tilt the balance in favour of
liberty. Having bestowed anxious consideration to the material placed on
record and having evaluated the rival submissions in the light of the
governing principles of bail, this Court finds that the continued
incarceration of the Applicants is no longer justified.
64.
In the absence of any material demonstrating that the role
attributed to the present Applicants is graver, distinguishable or
exceptional vis-à-vis those co-accused who are already on bail, the
selective continuation of their custody would amount to hostile
discrimination and would be contrary to the settled principles governing
the grant of bail. Liberty cannot be denied on the basis of pick-andchoose enforcement, particularly when the alleged conspirators,
facilitators and beneficiaries of the same transaction have been granted
freedom by superior courts. This Court is also mindful of the settled
position that pre-trial incarceration is not punitive and that detention
must be justified by compelling reasons such as the likelihood of
absconding, tampering with evidence or influencing witnesses. No such
exceptional circumstances have been demonstrated against the
Applicants so as to warrant their continued confinement, especially
when the investigation has been completed against the present
applicants and charge sheet has already been filed before the trial court
and the case now rests on documentary and electronic material already
in the custody of the prosecution.
65.
Without venturing into the merits of the allegations and confining
the present consideration strictly to the question of bail, this Court is of
the considered opinion that no compelling or justifiable reason now
survives for further curtailment of the Applicants’ liberty. The ends of
justice would be sufficiently safeguarded by enlarging them on bail,
subject to appropriate conditions.
70.
Accordingly, the present bail applications are allowed. It is
directed that each of the Applicants shall be released on bail upon
furnishing a personal bond in the sum of ₹1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh
only) along with two local sureties of the like amount to the satisfaction
of the learned Trial Court, subject to the following conditions:
(i) they shall surrender his passport, if any, before
the Trial Court;
(b)
the
applicants
must
cooperate
with
the
investigation and the trial proceedings;
(c) they shall not directly or indirectly make any
inducement, threat or promise to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case;
(d) they shall commit no offence whatsoever during
the period they are on bail; and
(e) in case of change of residential address and/or
mobile number, the same shall be intimated to the
Court concerned by way of an affidavit.
(f) any stringent conditions as may be imposed by
the trial court.
Any violation of the above conditions will
entitle the prosecution to move application for
cancellation of bail which shall be considered
promptly and on merits.
71.
It is clarified that the observations made herein are confined solely
to the adjudication of the present bail applications and shall not be
construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case. The
Trial Court shall proceed independently and uninfluenced by any
observation contained in this order.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
Digitally signed
by SUGUNA
SUGUNA DUBEY
DUBEY Date:
2026.01.14
17:08:38 +0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review