Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-12025:KER:29766
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. NITIN JAMDAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.MANU
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 31592 OF 2024
PETITIONER/S:
MUJEEEB RAHMAN
AGED 50 YEARS
SON OF ABDUL SALAM, KOTTILINGAL HOUSE, PATTAMBI
P.O, PATTAMBI VILLAGE, PATTAMBI TALUK, PALAKKAD
DISTRICT, PIN - 679303
BY ADVS.
P.M.ZIRAJ
IRFAN ZIRAJ
RESPONDENT/S:
THE STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
WATER RESOURCES DEPARTMENT, ROOM NO.393, MAIN
BLOCK, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, GOVERNMENT OF
KERALA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
IRRIGATION DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN 695001
KERALA IRRIGATION INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION LIMITED (KIIDC)
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING
DIRECTOR, SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, WATER
RESOURCES DEPARTMENT, ROOM NO.393, MAIN BLOCK,
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-22025:KER:29766
GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, GOVERNMENT OF KERALA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
KERALA IRRIGATION INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION LIMITED (KIIDC), PARVATHY, TC-36/1,
NH-66 BYE PASS SERVICE ROAD, CHACKAI P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695024
STATE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
AUTHORITY(SEIAA)
KSRTC BUS TERMINAL COMPLEX, THAMPANOOR,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, KERALA REPRESENTED BY ITS
MEMBER SECRETARY, PIN - 695001
CHIEF SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, GOVERNMENT OF KERALA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
M/S. KSR MARINE SERVICES PVT LTD.
HAVING REGISTERED ADDRESS AT: 2-98/3, 10-B,
BLOCK-B, KAKATEEYA NAGAR, HABSIGUDA, HYDERABAD500007 REPRESENTED BY AUTHORIZED SIGNATORY ANEESH
K.R, S/O G. KARTHIKEYAN, AGED 54 YEARS, RESIDING
AT PPRRA-11, PALAPPARAMBU ROAD, ELAMAKKARA,
ERNAKULAM – 682025 IS IMPLEADED AS ADDL.R7 AS PER
ORDER DATED 20/03/2025 IN I.A 2/2025.
BY ADVS.
PIRAPPANCODE V.S.SUDHEER
M.P.SREEKRISHNAN
JOLLY JOHN
AKASH S.(K/980/2008)
GIRISH KUMAR M S(K/001593/2018)
SRIVIDYA K(K/001476/2018)
RICHU THERESA ROBERT(K/002427/2021)
RAJALAKSHMI.R.(K/001978/2023)
LIZA MEGHAN CYRIAC
C.S.RESHMI
IRENE BABU
MEHNAZ P. MOHAMMED
RUBIN SHIBU
K. P. HARISH, SR. GP
THIS
ADMISSION
WRIT
ON
PETITION
03.04.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
(CIVIL)
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-3-
JUDGMENT
2025:KER:29766
Dated this the 3rd day of April, 2025
Nitin Jamdar, C. J.
Heard Mr. Irfan Ziraj, learned counsel for the Petitioner, Mr.
Pirappancode V. S. Sudheer, learned counsel for Respondent Nos. 3
and 4, Mr. M. P. Sreekrishnan, learned counsel for Respondent No. 5,
Mr. Jolly John, learned counsel for Respondent No. 7 and Mr. K. P.
Harish, learned Senior Government Pleader.
2.
The main anxiety expressed by the Petitioner is that the State and
the Official Respondents might permit the dredging of large quantities
of sand without there being any environmental clearance or without
conducting any environmental study. A counter affidavit is filed on
behalf of the Kerala State Environment Impact Assessment Authority
(Authority) in which it is stated as under:-
“2. The above Writ Petition is filed seeking interference of
this Hon’ble Court in the matter of sand mining based on
Exhibit P1, Bid document in connection with tender No.
KIIDC/ACUTION/07/2024-25 dated 14.08.2024 issued by
the 4th respondent, Chief Executive officer Kerala Irrigation
Infrastructure Development Corporation.
3. It is submitted that from the Exhibit P1 documents, the
proposed activity is mentioned as desiltation of the deposits
(1.5 km “upstream and 0.5km downstream) near regulator
cum bridge at Kankakadavu which is under construction,
across Bharathapuzha River in Kuttipuram Panchayat. From
the Google imageries it is observed that river is meandering
in the area mentioned in the bid i.e., between Kuttipuram
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-42025:KER:29766
bridge and the Kanakakadavu RCB. It is also evident that
huge quantity of sand is deposited at an average 1.5m above
the current water level in the inner edge (a point bar) due to
the meandering effect. Since the project is still under
construction and not yet commissioned, the proposed desilting of sand from the upstream and downstream sections of
Bharathapuzha River shall be regarded as Capital Dredging.
Therefore the activity is not exempted from obtaining
Environmental - Clearance as per Appendix — IX of the EIA
Notification, 2006.
4. As per the Bid Document, the activities proposed are desiltation, Stocking, Cleaning and selling of processed
products. All these processes would come under the term
Winning. Any operation undertaken for the purpose of
winning -any- mineral shall be considered as mining and the
proposed de-silting project from Bharathapuzha river Basin
shall be considered as sand mining rather than de-siltation.
Therefore, the activity requires Environmental Clarence as
per EIA Notification, 2006.
5. In the instant case the de-siltation, is not for the purpose of
maintenance or Flood Control as in the case of dam or river
or reservoir, which may not be considered as mining. But the
activity proposed to be carried out for capital dredging which
requires a clear cut scientific plan regarding dredging, the
depth of dredging the extent of dredging, quantity to be
dredged out, the protection and rejuvenation plan for the
river bank and riparian vegetation, the stocking and
transportation plan and Environment Management Plan for
dredging approved by a competent authority, etc... are
required. The minerals present in the proposed
de-siltation/dredging area is for commercial purpose. Hence,
it has to be considered as mining.
6. It is submitted that any operation undertaken for the
purpose of winning any mineral shall be considered as
‘mining’. Accordingly, if desilting is undertaken per se with
the objective of winning a mineral then it will be construed as
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-52025:KER:29766
a ‘mining’ operation. Here, the desilted sand is stocking /
processing and transporting for further usage. Hence, the
proposed desilting project from the river basin shall be
considered as a ‘mining’ activity. The soil investigation report
also indicates the desilted material contains 90% sand of
different quality.
7. The Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change
(MoEF&CC) published Environmental Impact Assessment
Notification 1994 which is only applicable for the Major
Minerals more than 5ha. In order to cover the minor minerals
also into the preview of EIA, the MoEF&CC issued EIA
Notification 2006 for Major & Minor Mineral more than 5
Ha. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in its Judgment dated the
27 February 2012 in I.A. No.12- 13 of 2011 in Special Leave
Petition (C) No.19628-19629 of 2009, in the matter of
Deepak Kumar etc, Vs. State of Haryana and Others etc.
made prior environment clearance mandatory for mining of
minor minerals irrespective of the area of mining lease. In
order to comply with the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme
Court, the Ministry issued S.0.141 (E) dated 15.01.2016.
Further, MOEF&CC published Sustainable Sand Mining
Management Guidelines 2016 for scientific and sustainable
sand mining in the Country. The recommendations for the
management of sustainable sand extraction are the key
objective of the Guidelines. Special emphasis is given on
monitoring of the mined out material, which is key to the
success of the environmental management plan. Use of IT
and IT-enabled services for effective monitoring of the
quantity of mined out material and transportation along with
process re-engineering has been made a part of the
Guidelines. Guidelines support the fundamental concept,
promote environmental protection, limit negative
physiological, hydrogeological and social impacts
underpinning sustainable economic growth.
8. The Hon'ble NGT in its order dated 04.09.2018 in O.A.
173/2018 in the matter of Sudarsan Das vs. State of West
Bengal & Ors. Interalia observed that “There can be no two
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-62025:KER:29766
views that an effective institutional monitoring mechanism is
required not only at the stage when Environmental Clearance
is granted but also at ‘subsequent stages”. “The guidelines
focus on the preparation of District Survey Report and the
Management Plan’ ... We are of the view that all the
safeguards which are suggested in sustainable sand mining
guidelines as well as notification dated 15.01.2016 ought to
be scrupulously followed. “...It is a known fact that in spite of
the above-suggested guidelines being in existence, on the
ground level, illegal mining is still going on. The existing
mechanism has not been successful and effective in
remedying the situation.” “...Since there is an utter failure in
the current monitoring mechanism followed by the State
Boards, SEIAAs and DEIAAs, it is required to be revised for
effective monitoring of sand and gravel mining and a
dedicated monitoring mechanism be set up.”
9. Based on the above directions the Ministry of
Environment, Forest and Climate Change also issued the
Enforcement and Monitoring Guidelines for Sand Mining
(EMGSM-2020). The Hon’ble National Green Tribunal
(NGT) ordered all states and union territories to strictly
adhere to the Sustainable Sand Mining Management
Guidelines (SSMMG-2016) and the Enforcement and
Monitoring Guidelines for Sand Mining (EMGSM-2020).
These directives were further strengthened by mechanisms
for the preparation of District Survey Report, Environment
Management Plan, replenishment studies, the assessment and
recovery of compensation, the seizure and release of vehicles
involved in illegal mining, and other safeguards against
violations. The EMGSM 2020 also explicitly deliberated
about monitoring mechanism on transportation, stacking, etc.
10. Pursuant thereto, the Institute of Land and Disaster
Management (ILDM), Revenue Department, Government of
Kerala prepared the District Survey Reports for River Sand
Mining across the State as per the guidelines issued by the
MoEFCC dated 25.07.2018. The ILDM entrusted a NABET
Accredited Consultant, CSIR-National Institute of
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-72025:KER:29766
Interdisciplinary Science and Technology (NIIST), with the
task of preparing District Survey Reports and the mining plan
for the sustainable of removal of sand from the river bed. The
DSR of the Bharathapuram River stretches in the Palakkad,
Malappuram and Thrissur Districts were prepared by
following all the procedures including public consultation as
per above said guidelines and EIA Notification, 2006 and
approved by the State Environment Impact Assessment
Authority.
11. It is submitted that, the District Survey Report (DSR), is
an important initial step before grant of mining lease/LoI.
The DSR emphasizes the areas of aggradation/deposition
where mining can be allowed and demarked the areas of
erosion and proximity to infrastructural structures and
installation where mining should be prohibited. It was also
assessed the annual rate of replenishment, time for
replenishment after mining, the ways of scientific and
systematic mining; the quantity to be extracted, cluster
conditions, measures for protection of environment and
ecology as well as for protection of bank erosion, benchmark
(BM) with respect to mean Sea Level (MSL) in mining
channel reaches (MCR), below which no mining shall be
allowed. The DSR also identified the potential ‘kadavus’ for
the stacking of the mined material.
12. As per the EIA Notification, 2006 for the removal of
river sand requires Environmental Clearance from the State
Environmental Impact Assessment Authority. However, the
desilting of reservoir, dredging for upkeep and maintenance
of structures, channels and averting natural disasters will not
be treated as mining for the purpose of environmental
clearance. In the present case, the Regulator Cum Bridge is
only under construction and the proposed activity cannot be
considered as an upkeep and maintenance of structures,
rather than sand mining. Besides, the authority which
conducted the study is not a NABET Accredited Agency and
are not entitled to conduct the environment impact study as
per EIA Notification. In view of the above the proposed
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-82025:KER:29766
activity is not entitled to be start without first obtaining a
Prior Environmental Clearance. It is submitted that as per the
provisions of EIA Notification, 2006 the project proponent
has to make an application in the prescribed form-1 though
PARVISEH Portal for obtaining a Prior Environmental
Clerance. Once an application is received through
PARIVESH Portal, for an Environmental Clearance, the
same can be considered in terms of EIA Notification, 2006.
It is brought to the kind attention of this Hon'ble Court that
any activity which requires a prior Environmental Clearance,
if started without obtaining Prior Environmental Clearance,
would amount of violation of provisions of EIA Notification,
2006 and consequently, the provision of Environment
Protection Act, including proceedings u/s.15 r/w. S.19 of
Environment Protection Act, 1986. In the above facts and
circumstances of the case, as the activity is not yet started, the
above writ petition may be disposed of directing the Project
Proponent to make an application for an prior
Environmental Clearance before the answering respondent
though PARVIESH Portal. The Report of Field inspection
conducted on 01.10.2024 pursuant to the Orders of this
Hon’ble Court on 12.09.2024 may also be read as part of this
Affidavit. It is prayed accordingly.”
3.
Therefore, the stand of the Authority in the affidavit, as reiterated
by the learned counsel for the Authority is that the activity, which is
the subject matter of this petition, requires an environmental clearance,
and before starting the activity, the project proponent will have to
make an application for prior environmental clearance to the
Authority. This affidavit, according to us, takes care of the
apprehension expressed by the Petitioner Public Interest Litigant in
this petition. Therefore, it goes without saying that the activity as
contemplated in the petition shall not be carried out without there
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-92025:KER:29766
being any environmental clearance as pointed out above.
4.
Accepting the statements made in the counter affidavit of the
Authority and the observations as above, the writ petition is disposed
of.
Sd/NITIN JAMDAR
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/S. MANU
JUDGE
Eb
W. P. (C) No. 31592 of 2024
-102025:KER:29766
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 31592/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF BID
DOCUMENT IN CONNECTION WITH TENDER NO.
KIIDC/ACUTION/ 07/ 2024-25 DATED
14.8.2024 ISSUED BY THE FOURTH
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE SCHEDULE IN CONNECTION
WITH EXHIBIT P1 TENDER DETAILS
PUBLISHED BY THE FOURTH RESPONDENT
DATED 27.8.2024
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT OF KERI
PUBLISHED BY THE THIRD RESPONDENT DATED
NIL IN JANUARY 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review