Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------D.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ &
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, J.
----------------------------------------------------------------------Writ Petition (Civil) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd.,
Regd. Office at 355-359, Daisy Plaza,
6th Street, Gandhipuram,
Coimbatore (Tamil Nadu) &
Branch Office at Samdrupling Building,
Kazi Raod, Gangtok,
Sikkim-737 101.
Through:
Mr. P. Ravichandran, Manager,
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd.,
Gangtok, Sikkim.
… Petitioner.
versus
1.
Union of India,
Through its Secretary,
Ministry of Finance,
Department of Revenue,
North Block, Delhi.
2.
Commissioner of Service Tax, Siliguri,
C.R. Building, Harendra Mukherjee Road,
Hakimpara, Siliguri HO, Dist. Darjeeling,
West Bengal.
3.
Superintendent of Central Excise & Service Tax,
Gangtok Range, Gangtok,
East Sikkim-737 101.
4.
The State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, Sikkim.
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
5.
Sikkim State Lotteries,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Director, State Lotteries,
10-National Highway, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
… Respondents.
AND
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd.,
Through its Director Mr. Naresh Mangal,
Baluwakhani, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
Through:
Mr. Prem Kishore Parashar,
Office In-Charge/Authorized Signatory of
Gangtok Branch of M/s Summim Online
Trade Solutions Private Limited.
… Petitioner.
versus
1.
Union of India,
Through its Secretary,
Ministry of Finance,
Department of Revenue,
North Block, Delhi.
2.
Commissioner of Service Tax, Siliguri,
C.R. Building, Harendra Mukherjee Road,
Hakimpara, Siliguri HO, Dist. Darjeeling,
West Bengal.
3.
Superintendent of Central Excise & Service Tax,
Gangtok Range, Gangtok,
East Sikkim-737 101.
4.
The State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, Sikkim.
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
5.
Sikkim State Lotteries,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Director, State Lotteries,
10-National Highway, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
… Respondents.
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. A.R. Madhavrao, Ms. Pragya Awasthi, Ms. Laxmi
Chakraborty and Ms. Manju Rai, Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. B.K. Gupta, Advocate for Respondents No. 1, 2
and 3.
Mr. Santosh Kr. Chettri, Assistant Government
Advocate for Respondents No. 4 and 5
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(23.03.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
Assailing the legality and validity of the amendments
made in the Finance Act, 1994 (Service Tax) by the Finance Act,
2016, whereunder the Section 65B was amended, as being ultra
vires the Constitution of India under Entry 34 and Entry 62 of List
II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India; also
seeking a declaration that the transactions in buying and selling
lottery tickets are not liable to Service tax under the provisions of
the Finance Act, 1994 as amended by the Finance Act, 2016 and
further seeking for quashing of Notifications No.18/2016-ST
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
dated
01.03.2016,
these
Writ
Petitions
are
filed
by
the
petitioners, with prayer of incidental and consequential relief.
2.
Both the Writ Petitions raise the one and the same
questions of law arising from the identical cause of action and, as
such, are being considered and disposed of by this common
Judgment.
3.
The
petitioners‟
firms,
incorporated
under
the
Companies Act, 1956, are engaged in business of buying and
selling of lottery tickets organized by the Government of Sikkim.
An Agreement between the petitioners and the Government of
Sikkim
was
arrived
at
on
06.06.2016
and
09.11.2012
respectively, enabling the petitioners‟ firms to purchase lottery
tickets in bulk from the Government and re-sell the same to the
public at large, through authorized agents, stockists, resellers
etc. The validity of the said Agreements is five years. Certain
amendments were made time and again in the Finance Act,
1994, which came to be challenged in several cases before this
Court and consistent decisions were rendered holding that the
Parliament lacks competence to frame the law for imposing
service tax on lottery dealers. The issue asto whether the lottery
distributors, as the petitioners herein, are agents of the State
Government, was also considered and decided in favour of the
petitioners holding that they were the outright purchasers and
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
not the agents of the State Government, when the State
Government alone is competent to organize a paper lottery or
online lottery or both under the provisions of the Lotteries
(Regulation) Rules, 2010 and the Lotteries (Regulation) Act,
1998.
In the meantime, in the teeth of several decisions as
discussed in the following paragraphs, the Parliament came out
with an amendment by the Finance Act, 2016 to the following
effects: “The relevant provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 (as amended by
Finance Act, 2016) state as under:”
In Section 65B(b) in clause (44), in Explanation, 2, in sub clause (ii), for
item (a), the following item shall be substituted, namely(a) by a lottery distributor or selling agent on behalf of the
State Government, in relation to promotion, marketing,
organizing, selling of lottery or facilitating in organizing
lottery or any kind, in any other manner, in accordance with
the provisions of the Lottery (Regulation) Act, 1998.”
4.
intimation
In furtherance thereof, the petitioners were served an
regarding
changes
vide
communication
dated
10.06.2016, calling upon the petitioners to make payment of
service tax. It is also sought to be questioned in the instant writ
petitions.
5.
Mr. A. R. Madhavrao, learned Counsel appearing for
the petitioners, would contend that there is no change in the
legal position even after the amendments made vide the Finance
(Amendment) Act, 2016, as laid down by this Court on several
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
decisions. To garner support for his contention, he refers to and
relies on a decision of the Supreme Court in Sunrise Associates
v. Government of NCT Delhi1 and decisions of this Court in
Future Gaming Solution Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India2, Future
Gaming Solution India Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India3
and
Future Gaming & Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of
India4. It is then contended that the Agreements entered into
between the petitioners and the State Government are valid
Agreements in public policy, thus, is not violative and void
merely because the consideration is inadequate in the teeth of
Section 23 (2) (sic. Sec. 25 (2)) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872,
as pleaded by the respondents, as the Agreements were
executed in compliance and consonance with the Lotteries
Regulation Act, Rules and Model Agreement. The invoices were
raised
by
the
State
Government,
which
clearly
made
procurement of lottery tickets by the petitioners as outright
complete sale. Learned Counsel would further contend that the
amendment made by the Parliament for imposition of service tax
is ultra vires as the lottery falls within the definition of „betting
and gambling‟ and, as such, the same falls in the State List of the
Seventh Schedule, thus, seek a declaration that the amended
--------------------------------------------1
(2006) 5 SCC 603
2015 (37) STR 65 (Sikkim)
2014 (36) STR 733 (Sikkim)
2015 VAT Infoline 449 (Sikkim)
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
provisions are ultra vires the Constitution and consequential
notification be held as null and void and be quashed.
6.
In oppugnation, Mr. B. K. Gupta, learned Counsel
appearing for the respondents 1, 2 and 3, would submit that the
service tax is not imposed on lottery but on the services rendered
by the distributors or selling agents for marketing, promoting and
organizing lottery since the lottery is not exigible to Service tax
as the lottery is conducted by the State of Sikkim and the State
of Sikkim is not liable to pay any service tax.
The Supreme
Court held in Sunrise Associates (supra) that lottery ticket is
an actionable claim and, as such, it is included in the negative list
and there is no imposition and levy of service tax on lottery. Mr.
Gupta would further contend that the definition of “service” as
per clause (44) in Section 65B, in Explanation 2 in sub-clause (ii)
provides for services rendered by a lottery distributor or selling
agent on behalf of the State Government in relation to
promotion, marketing, organizing, selling of lottery or facilitating
in organizing of lottery of any kind or in any manner, in
accordance with the provisions of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act,
1998 and, as such, the services provided by the petitioners
herein fall within the ambit of service tax.
Further, it is
contended that under the provisions of the Lotteries (Regulation)
Act, 1998, the transaction between the State Government and
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
the petitioners herein, is on the principal to agent basis.
Any
other contrary contract may be hit by the provisions of the Indian
Contract Act, 1872. Learned Counsel would further reiterate that
pursuant to Rule 7C of the Service Tax Rules, 1994, the
distributors or his selling agents are liable to pay service tax for
the taxable service of promoting, marketing, organizing or
assisting any organizing lottery.
The service tax was imposed
not for the purpose of earning revenue but in the larger interest
of society. It is not disputed by learned Counsel that Entry No.
92-C incorporated by the Constitution (88th Amendment) Act,
2004, in the Union List of the Seventh Schedule has not yet been
brought into force. However, the Parliament is competent to levy
service tax on sale of lottery for the services rendered in
organizing lottery under the residual Entry No.97 of Union List
(List I). The validity of levy of service tax on services has been
upheld by the Supreme Court in Federation and Association of
Hotels and Restaurants Association of India v. Union
of India5.
It is further stated that Explanation 2 of Section 65B
(44) contemplates imposition of service tax on any activity
carried out by a lottery distributor or a selling agent on behalf of
the State Government. Mr. Gupta would further urge that under
provisions of Section 268A, which has been inserted later on, the
---------------------------------------5
(1989) 3 SCC 634
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
Parliament is competent to impose service tax. Learned Counsel
would also submit that the conduct of lottery itself is known as
„service‟ in the international context and classifiable under the
Heading No.96920 of the UN-CPC classification.
7.
We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the
parties, perused the pleadings and examined the documents
appended thereto.
8.
Article 268A of the Constitution of India, providing for
levy of service tax by Union and collected and appropriated by
the Union and the States, was inserted by the Constitution
(Eighty-eight Amendment) Act, 2003.
However, the same was
later on omitted by the Constitution (One Hundred and First
Amendment) Act, 2016.
Accordingly, Entry 92C in List I – Union
List of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution for legislation to
levy service tax was inserted by the same Eighty-eighth
Amendment.
However, the same was never notified.
In the
meantime, along with the omission of Article 268A, Entry 92C
was also omitted by the Constitution (One Hundred and First
Amendment) Act, 2016.
9.
Finance Act, 2012 provides for imposition of service
tax on all the activities except those specified in the negative list
or otherwise, etc. The relevant clause reads as under:
“65B: In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires, -
(1)
„actionable claim‟ shall have the meaning assigned to
it in section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882;
………………………
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
(34) „negative list‟ means the services which are listed in
section 66D;
………………………
(44) „service‟ means any activity carried on by a person
for another for consideration, and includes a declared
service but shall not include(a)
any activity which constitutes merely……………………
(iii) a transaction in money or actionable
claim
(51) „taxable service‟ means any service on which service
tax is leviable under section 66B;
66B.
Charge of service tax
There shall be levied a tax (hereinafter referred to as the
service tax) at the rate of twelve per cent on the value of all
services, other than those services specified in the negative list,
provided or agreed to be provided in the taxable territory by one
person to another and collected in such manner as may be
prescribed.
66D.
Negative list of services
The negative list shall comprise of the following services,
namely: …………
(i)
betting, gambling or lottery;
…………”
Lottery being in the negative list was exempted from payment of
service tax.
10.
The first petitioner assailed the constitutional validity
of clause (zzzzn) of sub-section 105 of Section 65 of the Finance
Act, 1994, as inserted by Finance Act, 2010, whereby a new
category i.e. “to any person, by any other person, for promotion,
marketing, organizing or in any other manner assisting in
organizing games of chance, including lottery, Bingo or Lotto in
whatever form or by whatever name called, whether or not
conducted through internet or other electronic networks”, is
placed under the ambit of “taxable service”.
amendment, thus introduced, reads as under: -
The relevant
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
“(105) “taxable service” means any service provided or to be
provided,…………
(zzzzn)
to any person, by any other person, for
promotion, marketing, organizing or in any other manner
assisting in organizing games of chance, including lottery,
Bingo or Lotto in whatever form or by whatever name
called, whether or not conducted through internet or other
electronic networks;”
11.
A Division Bench of this Court in Future Gaming
Solutions2, considering all aspects of the matter, came to the
following conclusion: “(XXI) From the discussion and consideration of judgments noticed
hereinabove, it clearly emerges that where the transaction is
purely that of sale and purchase and does not involve any
component of service in it, which cannot be clearly segregated and
discernible, no Service Tax is payable.
However, where two
components in a transaction, i.e. “sale” and “service”, are capable
of compartmentalization so as to segregate the element of service
from the transaction of sale, Service Tax may be leviable on the
service component in a transaction.
xxxxx
xxxxx
(XXXII)
In view of the above clarification, it is pleaded on
behalf of the petitioners that receipt of consideration for providing
“taxable service” is one of the essential ingredients to establish
that any service is a “taxable service”. It is submitted that in the
instant case, the Government does not pay any consideration in
any form for the activities to be performed by the petitioner for
promotion of the sale by advertisement etc. To the contrary, the
petitioner is paying the minimum guaranteed sum towards the full
sale consideration to the Government and thus the entire claim of
the respondents that the petitioner is providing taxable service is
belied by its own circular and understanding of the nature of the
petitioner‟s activity.”
12.
The Division Bench further considered the competence
of Parliament to enact law in exercise of its residuary legislative
power under Entry 97, List I to Seventh Schedule of Constitution
of India de hors the entries and held as under: “19. In view of the above conclusions, we allow these
petitions, strike down the clause (zzzzn) to sub-section 105 of
Section 65 of Finance Act, 1994 as introduced vide Finance Act,
2010 as ultra vires to Constitution of India having been enacted in
contravention to Entry 97, List I to Seventh Schedule read with
Article 248 of Constitution of India.”
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
13.
We are informed that a Civil Appeal assailing the said
Judgment is pending consideration before the Supreme Court of
India, without there being any stay of the judgment and order.
14.
Again, in 2012, Section 65B was amended by inserting
clause 31(A), and also by amending Explanation 2 of Section 66D
(negative list), with effect from 01.07.2012, as under: “(e)
after clause (31), the following clause shall be inserted,
namely: (31A) “lottery distributor or selling agent” means a person
appointed or authorized by a State for the purpose of
promoting, marketing, selling or facilitating in organizing
lottery of any kind, in any manner, organized by such State
in accordance with the provisions of the Lotteries
(Regulation) Act, 1998 (17 of 1998);
………
(g)
in clause (44), for Explanation 2, the following Explanation
shall be substituted, namely: “Explanation 2 – For the purpose of this clause, the
expression “transaction in money or actionable claim” shall not
include –
…………
(ii)
any activity carried out, for a consideration, in
relation to, or for facilitation of, a transaction in money or
actionable claim, including the activity carried out –
(a)
by a lottery distributor or selling agent in
relation to promotion, marketing, organizing, selling of
lottery or facilitating in organizing lottery of any kind, in any
other manner;
Amendment of section 66D (Negative list).
“Explanation – For the purpose of this clause, the
expression „betting, gambling or lottery‟ shall not include
the activity specified in Explanation 2 to clause (44) of
section 65B.”
15.
In pursuance thereafter, the Superintendent of Central
Excise and Service Tax, Gangtok Range, Gangtok issued a letter
bearing
No.
V(3)7/ST/FGSI
Pvt.
Ltd./GTK/2009/295
dated
06.07.2012 informing the petitioner that as per Notification No.
36/2012-ST dated 20.06.2012 read with Rule 6(7C)
of the
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
Finance Act, 1994 (as amended) the petitioner was liable to pay
service tax as per the prevailing provisions since they had been
rendering service to the State Government in relation to
promotion, marketing, organizing and assisting in organizing
games of chance including lottery services.
The said letter came
to be assailed in W.P.(C) No. 32 of 2012 (Future Gaming
Solutions India Pvt. Ltd. vs. UOI3)
by the first petitioner.
The Division Bench of this Court, referring to the earlier
judgment in Future Gaming Solutions Pvt. Ltd. vs. UOI2, held
as under:“70.
In view of the facts and circumstances and the discussions,
our conclusions are as under: (i)
In the light of sub-section (1) to Section 65B read with subsection (44) thereof lottery is excluded from the definition
of „service‟ being actionable claim‟;
(ii)
Even under sub-section (34) of Section 65B read with
Sections 66B and 66D lottery stands excluded from the
purview of Service Tax under the Finance Act, 2012 as
being one in the „negative list‟‟
(iii)
The activity of the Petitioner comprising of promotions,
organizing, reselling or any other manner assisting in
arranging of lottery tickets of the State Lotteries does not
establish the relationship of a principal or an agent but
rather that of a buyer and a seller and, on principal to
principal basis in view of the nature of the transaction
consisting of bulk purchases of lottery tickets by the
Petitioner from the State Government on full payment on a
discounted price as a natural business transaction and,
other related features like there being no privity of contract
between the State Government and the stockists, agents,
resellers under the Petitioner.
(iv)
The impugned letter C. No. V(3)7/ST/FGSI Pvt.
Ltd./GTK/2009/295 dated 6-7-2012 does not have the
sanction and authority of either the Constitution or the law
as there is no provision anywhere for imposing of Service
Tax on „lottery‟ and the action of the respondents to impose
such tax on the Petitioner on the basis of Notification No.
36/2012-S.T., dated 20-6-2012 and the Service Tax Rules
is ultra vires the very provision of the Finance Act being in
excess of the powers vested therein.”
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
16.
Subsequently, the Finance Act, 1994 was again
amended on 13.05.2015 by the Finance Act, 2015, with effect
from 01.06.2015, whereunder certain changes were made in
various Sections, i.e. Sections 65B, 66D and 67, which read as
under: “Amendment of section 65B
105. In the Finance Act, 1994, save as otherwise
provided, in section 65B, ………
(e)
after clause (31), the following clause shall be
inserted, namely: (31A) “lottery distributor or selling agent” means a
person appointed or authorized by a State for the
purpose of promoting, marketing, selling or
facilitating in organizing lottery of any kind, in any
manner, organized by such State in accordance with
the provisions of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998
(17 of 1998);
………
(g)
in clause (44), for Explanation 2, the following
Explanation shall be substituted, namely: ‘Explanation 2. – For the purpose of this clause, the
expression “transaction in money or actionable
claim” shall not include………
(ii)
any activity carried out, for a
consideration, in relation to, or for facilitation
of, a transaction in money or actionable
claim, including the activity carried out –
(a)
by a lottery distributor or
selling agent in relation to promotion,
marketing,
organizing,
selling
of
lottery or facilitating in organizing
lottery of any kind, in any other
manner;
………‟
Amendment of section 66D.
107. In Section 66D of the 1994 Act, with effect
from such date as the Central Government may by
notification in the Official Gazette, appoint, ………
(3)
in clause (i), the following Explanation
shall be inserted, namely:Explanation – For the purpose of this clause,
the expression „betting, gambling or lottery‟
shall not include the activity specified in
Explanation 2 to clause (44) of section 65B;‟
Amendment of section 67.
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
109. In section 67 of the 1994 Act, in the
Explanation, for clause (a), the following clause shall
be substituted, namely: (a)
“consideration” includes –
(i)
any amount that is payable for the
taxable services provided or be provided;
………
(iii)
any amount retained by the lottery
distributor or selling agent from gross sale
amount of lottery ticket in addition to the fee
or commission, if any or as the case may be,
the discount received, that is to say, the
difference in the face value of lottery ticket
and the price at which the distributor or
selling agent gets such ticket.
………”
17.
Under the amended provisions, the petitioners were
held as service providers in respect of service provided as lottery
distributor and selling agents and, as such, amenable to service
tax, as prescribed under Rule 6(7C) of the Service Tax Rules,
1994. The said provisions came to be challenged in W.P.(C) No.
39 of 2015 (M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (Pvt.)
Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.) and W.P.(C) No. 40 of 2015
(M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of
India & Ors.).
The petitioners therein were intimated vide
letters dated 25.05.2015, 18.05.2015 and 12.06.2015, seeking
enforcement of the said provisions, which made the petitioners
therein to file the aforestated writ petitions. The Division Bench
of this Court considered all aspects in the historical perspective of
various decisions handed down by this Court, and allowed the
writ petition as under: “95.
(i)
For the reasons aforesaid, we hold as follows:
The Petitioners in buying and selling the lottery tickets is not
rendering service to the State and, therefore, their activity does
not fall within the meaning of „service‟ as provided under
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
Clauses (31A) and (44) of Section 65B and, therefore, outside
the purview of Explanation 2 to the said Section;
(ii)
In any case, since by the Explanation the scope of Section 66D
which is the main provision which is to be expanded, it would
be ultra vires the Finance Act, 1994 and is accordingly struck
down;
(iii)
The impugned letter dated 25-05-2015 to the PetitionerCompany in WP(C) No. 39 of 2015 and letters dated 18-052015 and 12-06-2015 to the Petitioner-Company in WP(C) No.
40 of 2015 having been issued on an erroneous interpretation
of Section 66D of the Finance Act, 1994, as amended by the
Finance Act, 2015 requiring the Petitioners to pay tax under the
Service Tax Rules, 1994, as amended, in the absence of specific
provision in the Finance Act and that Sub-Rule (7C) of Rule 6 of
the Service Tax Rules, 1994, only provides an optional
composite scheme for payment of tax and, therefore, does not
create a charge of service tax and is a Subordinate piece of
Legislation, hereby stands quashed. Resultantly, Circular under
D.O.F. No. 334/5/2015-TRU dated 19-05-2015 referred to in
the aforesaid letters in the two Writ Petitions also stand
quashed; and
(iv)
The Respondents, their agents, servants, officers and
representatives are restrained directly or indirectly, and in any
manner whatsoever, from demanding any amounts by way of
service tax or enforcing the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994
on the activity of the Petitioners in relation to lottery tickets.”
18.
The Finance Act, 1994 was again amended by the
Finance Act, 2016, whereunder clause (44) defines “service”
means any activity carried out by a person for another for
consideration, and includes a declared service, but shall not
include the following activities : (a)
an activity which constitutes merely, (i)
a transfer of title in goods or immovable
property, by way of sale, gift or in any other
manner; or
(ii)
such transfer, delivery or supply of any
goods which is deemed to be sale within the
meaning of clause (29A) of article 366 of the
Constitution; or
(iii)
a transaction in money or actionable claim;
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
(b)
a provision of service by an employee to the
employer in the course of or in relation to his
employment;
(c)
fees taken in any Court or tribunal established
under any law for the time being in force.
19.
In
2016,
by
the
Finance
Bill
2016,
further
amendments were made in sub-clause (ii) for item (a) in
Explanation 2 to clause (44), as under:
“(a)
by a lottery distributor or selling agent on behalf of the
State Government, in relation to promotion, marketing,
organizing, selling of lottery or facilitating in organizing lottery
of any kind, in any other manner, in accordance with the
provisions of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998”
20.
In Municipal Council, Kota, Rajasthan vs. Delhi
Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd., Delhi and others6, wherein
“Dharmada”, being levied only on goods brought within municipal
limits
of
Kota,
was
under
challenge,
the
Supreme
Court
examined the ambit and scope of levy of taxes, held as under: “16. Whenever a challenge is made to the levy of tax, its
validity may have to be mainly determined with reference to
the legislative competence or power to levy the same and in
adjudging this issue the nature and character of the tax has
to be inevitably determined at the threshold. It is equally
axiomatic that once the legislature concerned has been held
to possess the power to levy the tax, the motive with which
the tax is imposed becomes immaterial and irrelevant and
the fact that a wrong reason for exercising the power has
also been given would not in any manner derogate from the
validity of the tax.
In Jullunder Rubber Goods
Manufacturers’ Assn. v. Union of India : (1969)2 SCC 644
this Court while dealing with a challenge to the levy of
rubber cess under section 12(2) of the Rubber Act, 1947 as
amended in 1960 observed that the tax in the nature of
excise duty does not cease to be one such merely because
the stage of levy and collection has been as a matter of
----------------------------------6
(2001) 3 SCC 654
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
legislative policy shifted by actually providing for its levy
and collection from the users of rubber, so long as the
character of the duty as excise duty is not lost and the
incidence of tax remained to be on the production or
manufacture of goods. Likewise, once the legislature is
found to possess the required legislative competence to
enact the law imposing the tax, the limits of that
competence cannot be judged further by the form or
manner in which that power is exercised.
In (Morris)
Leventhal v. David Jones Ltd. : AIR 1930 PC 129 the
question arose as to the power of the legislature to impose
“bridge tax”, when the power to legislate was really in
respect of “tax on land”. It was held therein as follows:
“The appellants‟ contention that though
directly imposed by the legislature, the bridge tax is
not a land tax, was supported by argument founded
in particular on two manifest facts. The bridge tax
does not extend to land generally throughout New
South Wales, but to a limited area comprising the
City of Sydney and certain specified shires, and the
purpose of the tax is not that of providing the public
revenue for the common purposes of the State but of
providing funds for a particular scheme of
betterment.
No authority was vouched for the
proposition that an impost laid by statute upon
property within a defined area, or upon specified
classes of property, or upon specified classes of
persons, is not within the true significance of the
term a tax. Nor so far as appears has it ever been
successfully contended that revenue raised by
statutory imposts for specific purposes is not
taxation.”
(emphasis supplied)”
21.
In T.N. Kalyana Mandapam Assn. vs. Union of
India and Others7, wherein the appellants contended that
service tax levied on services rendered by mandap-keeper as
defined in Sections 65, 66 and 67 amounted to tax on land and
was in view of Entries 18 and 49, List II, within the exclusive
legislative competence of the State Legislature.
The Supreme
Court, analyzing the earlier decisions on the issue, held as
under:“58. A tax on services rendered by mandap-keepers and
outdoor caterers is in pith and substance, a tax on services and
not a tax on sale of goods or on hire-purchase activities.
Section 65 clause (41) sub-clause (p) of the Finance Act, 1994,
------------------------------------7
(2004) 5 SCC 632
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
defines taxable service (which is the subject-matter of levy of
service tax) as any service provided to a customer
“by a mandap-keeper in relation to the use of a
mandap in any manner including the facilities
provided to [a customer] in relation to such use
and also the services, if any, rendered as a
caterer”.
The nature and character of this service tax is evident
from the fact that the transaction between a mandap-keeper
and his customer is definitely not in the nature of a sale or hirepurchase of goods. It is essentially that of providing a service.
In fact, as pointed out earlier, the manner of service provided
assumes predominance over the providing of food in such
situations which is a definite indicator of the supremacy of the
service aspect. The legislature in its wisdom noticed the said
supremacy and identified the same as a potential region to
collect indirect taxes. Moreover, it has been a well-established
judicial principle that so long as the legislation is in substance,
on a matter assigned to a legislature enacting that statute, it
must be held valid in its entirety even though it may trench
upon matters beyond its competence. Incidental encroachment
does not invalidate such a statute on the grounds that it is
beyond the competence of the legislature (Prafulla Kumar v.
Bank of Commerce : AIR 1947 PC 60). Article 246(1) of the
Constitution specifies that Parliament has exclusive powers to
make laws with respect to any of the matters enumerated in
List I in the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution. As per
Articles 246 (3), the State Government has exclusive powers to
make laws with respect to matters enumerated in List II (State
List). In respect of matters enumerated in List III (Concurrent
List) both Parliament and the State Governments have powers
to make laws. The service tax is made by Parliament under the
above residuary powers.”
22.
Again
in
Gujarat
Ambuja
Cements
Ltd.
and
Another vs. Union of India and Another8, the question of
imposition of service tax on the customers or clients of goods
transport operators and of forwarding and clearing agents came
up for consideration. The Supreme Court held as under:
“32. Since service tax is not a levy on passengers and goods
but on the event of service in connection with the carriage of
goods, it is not therefore possible to hold that the Act in pith
and substance is within the States‟ exclusive power under Entry
56 of List II. What the Act ostensibly seeks to tax is what it, in
substance, taxes. In the circumstances, the Act could not be
termed to be a colourable piece of legislation. It is not the case
of the petitioners that the Act is referable to any other entry
apart from Entry 56 of List II. Therefore the negation of the
petitioners‟ submission perforce leads to the conclusion that the
--------------------------------------8
(2005) 4 SCC 214
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
Act falls within the residuary power of Parliament under Entry
97 of List I.”
23.
In All India Federation of Tax Practitioners and
Others vs. Union of India and others9, wherein the issue
arose for consideration on the constitutional status of levy of
service tax and legislative competence of Parliament under Entry
97,
List
I
of
Seventh
Schedule
of
Constitution
also
the
competence of Parliament to levy service tax on chartered
accountants, cost accountants and architects, having regard to
Entry 60, List II of the Seventh Schedule and Article 276 of the
Constitution of India, the Supreme Court held as under:
“44. Competence to legislate flows from Articles 245, 246
and the other articles in Part XI. A legislation like the Finance
Act can be supported on the basis of a number of entries. In
the present case, we are concerned with the constitutional
status of the levy, namely, service tax. The nomenclature of a
levy is not conclusive for deciding its true character and nature.
For deciding the true character and nature of a particular levy,
with reference to the legislative competence, the court has to
look into the pith and substance of the legislation. The powers
of Parliament and the State Legislatures are subject to
constitutional limitations. Tax laws are governed by Part XII
and Part XIII. Article 265 takes in Article 245 when it says that
the tax shall be levied by the authority of law. To repeat,
various entries in the Seventh Schedule show that the power to
levy tax is treated as a distinct matter for the purpose of
legislative competence. This is the underlying principle to
differentiate between the two groups of entries, namely,
general entries and taxing entries. We are of the view that
taxes on services is a different subject as compared to taxes on
professions, trades, calling, etc. Therefore, Entry 60 of List II
and Entries 92-C/97 of List I operate in different spheres.”
24.
In Karnataka Bank Ltd. vs. State of Andhra
Pradesh and Others10, wherein levy and realization of tax on
the persons as defined under clause 2 (j) of the Andhra Pradesh
---------------------------------9
(2007) 7 SCC 527
(2008) 2 SCC 254
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
Tax on Professions, Trades, Callings and Employments Act, 1987
was under consideration. The Supreme Court examined the legal
position comprehensively and held that Article 265 of the
Constitution prohibits the levy or collection of tax except by an
authority of law which means only a valid law.
25.
In M/s Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. and Others
vs. State of Bihar and others11, the Supreme Court examining
the ambit and scope of Article 254 of the Constitution and
observed as under: “67. Article 254 of the Constitution makes provision first, as
to what would happen in the case of conflict between a Central
and State law with regard to the subjects enumerated in the
Concurrent List, and secondly, for resolving such conflict.
Article 254(1) enunciates the normal rule that in the event of a
conflict between a Union and a State law in the concurrent field,
the former prevails over the latter. Clause (1) lays down that if
a State law relating to a concurrent subject is „repugnant‟ to a
Union law relating to that subject, then, whether the Union law
is prior or later in time, the Union law will prevail and the State
law shall, to the extent of such repugnancy, be void. To the
general rule laid down in cause (1), clause (2) engrafts an
exception, viz., that if the President assents to a State law
which has been reserved for his consideration, it will prevail
notwithstanding its repugnancy to an earlier law of the Union,
both laws dealing with a concurrent subject. In such a case,
the Central Act, will give way to the State Act only to the extent
of inconsistency between the two, and no more. In short, the
result of obtaining the assent of the President to a State Act
which is inconsistent with a previous Union law relating to a
concurrent subject would be that the State Act will prevail in
that state and override the provisions of the Central Act in their
applicability to that State only. The predominance of the State
law may however be taken away if Parliament legislates under
the proviso to clause (2).
The proviso to Article 254(2)
empowers the Union Parliament to repeal or amend a
repugnant State law, either directly, or by itself enacting a law
repugnant to the State law with respect to the „same matter‟.
Even though the subsequent law made by Parliament does not
expressly repeal a State law, even then, the State law will
become void as soon as the subsequent law of Parliament
creating repugnancy is made. A State law would be repugnant
to the Union law when there is direct conflict between the
two laws. Such repugnancy may also arise where both laws
------------------------------------11
(1983) 4 SCC 45
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
operate in the same field and the two cannot possibly stand
together : See Zaverbhai Amaidas v. State of Bombay : AIR
1954 SC 752; M. Karunanidhi v. Union of India : (1979) 3 SCC
431 and T. Barai v. Henry Ah Hoe : (1983) 1 SCC 177.”
and further held:
“74.
It is equally well settled that the various entries in the
three Lists are not „powers‟ of legislation, but „fields‟ of
legislation. The power to legislate is given by Article 246 and
other Articles of the Constitution. Taxation is considered to be
a distinct matter for purposes of legislative competence.
Hence, the power to tax cannot be deduced from a general
legislative entry as an ancillary power. Further, the element of
tax does not directly flow from the power to regulate trade or
commerce in, and the production, supply and distribution of
essential commodities under Entry 33 of List III, although the
liability to pay tax may be a matter incidental to the Centre‟s
power of price control.”
26.
In the instant petitions, we are concerned with the
amendments made in the Finance Act, 1994 by the Finance Act,
2016.
The previous Division Benches in the cases (supra) have
come to a conclusion that no service tax is imposable and
leviable on lottery, but we are dealing with the service tax on
related activities in distribution and sale of lottery tickets.
27.
On gleaning through various amendments made from
2010 onwards, it is evident that the service tax was intended on
promotion, marketing, organizing, selling of lottery or facilitating
in organizing lottery of any kind, in any other manner. By the
impugned amendment a cosmetic change has been made in the
Amendment Act, 2010, as initially the words “any person or any
other person” was used. In 2015, it was modified to the extent
that any activity carried out, for a consideration, in relation to or
for facilitation of, a transaction in money except an actionable
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
claim excluding the activity carried out (a) by a lottery distributor
or selling agent in relation to promotion, marketing, organizing,
selling of lottery or facilitating in organizing lottery of any kind, in
any other manner.
The lottery distributor or selling agent is a
person appointed or authorized by a State for the purpose of
some activities.
By the impugned amendment the words “a
person appointed or authorized by a State for the purpose of
……………” were substituted by the words “by a lottery distributor
or selling agent on behalf of the State Government, …………”. The
substitution does not make substantial changes and the intention
remains the same in pith and substance.
28.
In the case on hand, Article 268A, which was
incorporated by the Constitution (Eighty-eighth Amendment) Act
of 2003, has recently been omitted by the Constitution (One
Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016.
Entry 92C was
inserted by the same constitutional amendment, but admittedly
never notified, as pleaded by the learned counsel appearing for
the parties and the same has also been omitted by the
Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016.
Thus, reliance can be placed on Entry 97 invoking competence to
impose service tax.
However, Article 268C confers power and
competence on the Union-Parliament to levy service tax on the
service providers for consideration.
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
29.
In T.N. Kalyana Mandapam Assn. and All India
Federation of Tax Practitioners7, the Supreme Court held that
service tax was made by the Parliament under the residuary
powers.
30.
It is deducible from the aforestated cases that the
Union – Parliament is competent to impose service tax for the
services rendered for consideration by a person. It is well settled
principles as laid down in the cases (supra) that entries in the
three lists are fields of legislation. Taxation is a distinct matter
for the purpose of legislative competence and it must flow from
the specific entry provided for levy and imposition of taxes.
The
relevant service tax leviable is not on the lottery as also
submitted by the respondents, but on promotion, marketing,
organizing, selling of lottery or facilitating in organizing lottery of
any kind, in any other manner.
31.
For the analysis and reasons mentioned hereinabove,
we are of the considered and conscience view that the UnionParliament is conferred with the power and competence under
Article 268A read with Entry 97, List I (Union List) to impose and
levy service tax on other related activities, as aforestated. The
impugned amendment brought in Finance Act, 2016 is not
unconstitutional.
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
32.
It is apposite to state that the Division Benches of this
Court in W.P.(C) Nos. 36 & 23 of 2011 (Future Gaming
Solutions Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of India); W.P.(C) No. 32 of
2012 (Future Gaming Solutions India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of
India) and W.P.(C) No. 39 of 2015 (Future Gaming & Hotel
Services Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of India) have categorically held
that the Union-Parliament lacks competence to impose service
tax and the concerned amendments were held as ultra vires to
the Constitution of India.
Thus, question arises as to whether
this Division Bench can take a contrary view when the judgments
rendered by the Division Benches have attained finality on the
issues therein and are pending consideration in appeals before
the Supreme Court of India.
33.
It is beneficial to refer to the observations made by
the Supreme Court in this respect in Union of India & Anr. vs.
Raghubir Singh (Dead) by LRs. Etc.12, the Constitution Bench
of the Supreme Court held as under: “28.
We are of opinion that a pronouncement of law by a
Division Bench of this Court is binding on a Division Bench
of the same or a smaller number of Judges, and in order
that such decision be binding, it is not necessary that it
should be a decision rendered by the Full Court or a
Constitution Bench of the Court. We would, however, like
to think that for the purpose of imparting certainty and
endowing due authority decisions of this Court in the future
should be rendered by Division Benches of at least three
Judges unless, for compelling reasons, that is not
conveniently possible.”
34.
Again in Pradip Chandra Parija and others vs.
------------------------------------12
(1989) 2 SCC 754
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
Pramod Chandra Patnaik and others13, a Constitution Bench
of the Supreme Court reiterated the same principles of law.
35.
Further, in Chandra Prakash and Ors. Vs. State of
U.P. and Anr.14, the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court,
referring to earlier decisions, laid down guiding principles as
under: “22. A careful perusal of the above judgments shows that
this Court took note of the hierarchical character of the
judicial system in India. It also held that it is of paramount
importance that the law declared by this Court should be
certain, clear and consistent.
As stated in the above
judgments, it is of common knowledge that most of
the decisions of this Court are of significance not merely
because they constitute an adjudication on the rights of the
parties and resolve the disputes between them but also
because in doing so they embody a declaration of law
operating as a binding principle in future cases.
The
doctrine of binding precedent is of utmost importance in the
administration of our judicial system. It promotes certainty
and consistency in judicial decisions. Judicial consistency
promotes confidence in the system, therefore, there is this
need for consistency in the enunciation of legal principles in
the decisions of this Court. It is in the above context, this
Court in the case of Raghubir Singh held that a
pronouncement of law by a Division Bench of this Court is
binding on a Division Bench of the same or smaller number
of Judges. It is in furtherance of this enunciation of law,
this Court in the latter judgment of Parija (supra) held that–
“But if a Bench of two learned Judges concludes that
an earlier judgment of three learned Judges is so
very incorrect that in no circumstances can it be
followed, the proper course for it to adopt is to refer
the matter before it to a Bench of three learned
Judges setting out, as has been done here, the
reasons why it could not agree with the earlier
judgment.
If, then, the Bench of three learned
Judges also comes to the conclusion that the earlier
judgment of a Bench of three learned Judges is
incorrect, reference to a Bench of five learned Judges
is justified.”
In the aforestated background, we are hard put to take a
contrary view.
-------------------------------------13
(2002) 1 SCC 1
(2002) 4 SCC 234
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
36.
There is another aspect that the Union of India is
competent to impose and levy service tax on the services
rendered by a person, however, for want of proper mechanism
service tax is not enforceable on respondents. This issue came
up
for
consideration
in
National
Mineral
Development
Corporation Ltd. vs. State of M.P. and Another15, and the
Supreme Court came to the conclusion that “when it is clear from
the computation provision that it is meant to supplement the
charging provision and is, on its own, a substantive provision in
the sense that but for the computation provision the charging
provision alone would not work. The computing provision cannot
be treated as mere surplusage or of no significance; what
necessarily flows therefrom shall also have to be given effect to”.
37.
In Union of India and others vs. Martin Lottery
Agencies Limited16, examining the judgment and order arising
from this Court, wherein the question of imposition of service tax
on lottery tickets was under consideration, the Supreme Court
observed as under: “22.
Service tax purports to impose tax on services on two
grounds (1) service provided to a consumer, and (2) service
provided to a service provider. Service provided in respect of
the matters envisaged under clause (19) of Section 65 of the
Act must be construed strictly. Before a tax is found to be
leviable, it must come within the domain of legitimate business
and/or trade.
xxxx
xxxx
29.
-----------------------------------15
(2004) 6 SCC 281
(2009) 12 SCC 209
Services can be rendered in respect of activities of the
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
State if they are permissible in terms of sub-clause (ii) of clause
(19) of Section 65 of the Act and the State itself has been
rendering services and not otherwise. While we say so, we are
not unmindful of the fact that in terms of the agreement, the
respondent not only distributes the lottery tickets printed by the
tate but also distributes prizes worth less than Rs.5000.
It
issues an advertisement. It has a right to be consulted in respect
of design of a lottery ticket. It may also have a say in the matter
of arranging for the lottery. But we are not sure as to how
service element of the entire transaction is to be ascertained.”
38.
A Division Bench of this Court examining this aspect in
Future Gaming Solutions Pvt. Ltd.2 held as under: -
(XXX) Rule 6 of the Service Tax Rules, 1994 provides
modes for payment of Service Tax. The Government of
India issued Notification No.49/2010-Service Tax, dated 8th
October, 2010 introducing sub-rule 7(C) under Rule 6
providing for the mode of payment of Service Tax as
regards the promotion, marketing, organizing or in any
manner assisting in organizing lottery is concerned. The
relevant extract of the said Rules reads as under:“7(C)
The distributor or selling agent, liable to pay
Service Tax of promotion, marketing, organizing or in any
other manner assisting in organizing lottery, shall have the
option to pay an amount at the rate specified in column
(2) of the Table given below, subject to the conditions
specified in the corresponding entry in column (3) of the
said Table, instead of paying service Tax at the rate
specified in Section 66B of Chapter V of the said Act :
TABLE
Sl.
No.
(1)
1.
2.
Rate
Condition
(2)
Rs.7000/- on every
Rs.10 Lakh (or part of
Rs.10
Lakh)
of
aggregate face value
of
lottery
tickets
printed
by
the
organizing State for a
draw.
Rs.11000/- on every
Rs.10 Lakh (or part of
Rs.10
Lakh)
of
aggregate face value
of
lottery
tickets
printed
by
the
organizing State for a
draw.
(3)
If the lottery or lottery
scheme is one where
the guaranteed prize
payout is more than
80%.
If the lottery or lottery
scheme is one where
the guaranteed prize
payout is less than
80%.
Provided that in case of online lottery, the aggregate face
value of lottery tickets for the purpose of this sub-rule
shall be taken as the aggregate value of tickets sold, and
Service Tax shall be calculated in the manner specified in
the said Table.
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
Provided further that the distributor or selling agent shall
exercise such option within a period of one month of the
beginning of each financial year and such option shall not
be withdrawn during the remaining part of the financial
year.
Provided also that the distributor or selling agent shall
exercise such option for financial year 2010-11, within a
period of one month of the publication of this sub-rule in
the Official Gazette or, in the case of new service provider,
within one month of providing of such service and such
option shall not be withdrawn during the remaining part of
that financial year.”
The petitioners‟ case falls in Sl. No. 2, the prize
money being less than 80%.
(XXXI) On a conjoint reading of Sections 66, 67 and Rule
7(C) it appears that the Service Tax payable by a service
provider for promotion, marketing, organizing or in any
manner assisting in organizing lottery is @12% or assessed
in the manner indicated in the table above on the value of
the service provided or to be provided. In respect of the
online lotteries the aggregate value of the lottery ticket is to
be taken as the value of the service on which Service Tax is
payable. In respect to the paper lottery also the same
mode has been adopted and gross value of the lottery ticket
has been taken as the valuation for the purpose of levy of
Service Tax. During the course of argument, Mr. Razzak
after seeking instructions admitted that the Service tax is
being charged at the gross value of the lottery ticket i.e. Re.
1/- or in the manner prescribed in the Rule 7(C) as
introduced vide Notification dated 8th October, 2010. It is
relevant to note that according to Mr. Razzak‟s submission
the 30% discount allowed by the State Government to the
petitioners is for rendering service, whereas admittedly 70
paise is the price of the lottery ticket.
According to
respondents own case only 30% of the gross value can be
taken as the valuation for providing service if at all the
activity of petitioners is to be construed as a service falling
within the definition of “taxable service”. The Ministry of
Finance (Department of Revenue), Central Board of Excise
and Customs, Government of India has also issued a
clarificatory circular dated 10-11-2006 laying down the
criterion for levy of Service Tax. The relevant extract is
reproduced hereunder:“4.
To levy Service Tax, the following criteria are to be
satisfied :
The service provided or to be provided satisfies the
definition of taxable service.
There should be receipt of consideration for the taxable
service provided.”
(XXXII)
In view of the above clarification, it is pleaded
on behalf of the petitioners that receipt of consideration for
providing “taxable service” is one of the
essential
ingredients to establish that any service is a “taxable
service”. It is submitted that in the instant case, the
Government does not pay any consideration in any form for
the activities to be performed by the petitioner for
promotion of the sale by advertisement etc.
To the
contrary, the petitioner is paying the minimum guaranteed
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
sum towards the full sale consideration to the Government
and thus the entire claim of the respondents that the
petitioner is providing taxable service is belied by its own
circular and understanding of the nature of the petitioner‟s
activity.”
39.
Again in Future Gaming Solutions India Pvt. Ltd.3
it is found that there is no mechanism to ascertain and compute
the service rendered by a person for promoting, marketing,
selling or facilitating in organizing lottery of any kind, in any
manner, organized by such State in accordance with the
provisions of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998.
40.
It is submitted by the learned counsel appearing for
the Petitioners that as per the agreement, the invoice provided
for sale proceeds to the extent of Rs.67,34,800/-.
The
components of the sale proceeds are given as under: -
Draw charges per day70,100/-
Rs.5,60,800/-
(Minimum
Guarantee Revenue) x 8
(No. of draws)
Admin charges – 3000 x 8 Rs. 24,000/(No. of draws)
Printing
charges
of Rs.10,50,000/-
Rs.3500 per lac of lottery
tickets
Taxable
prize
money Rs.51,00,000/-
above Rs.10,000/Add: Other charges
Rs.67,34,800x
(each
day
is
under
a
name)
draw
different
–
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
Rs.4,71,43,600/-
Rs.
65,000/Add – Non-taxable prize Rs.140,69,02,721/money up to Rs.10,000/is Rs.20,09,85,206/- x 7
(each day draw is under a
different name)
Total -
41.
Rs.145,41,11,321/-
It is further submitted that there is no payment of any
consideration for incidental activities like advertisement etc. and
there is no denial of the fact by the respondents that there is any
methodology to distinguish the consideration paid for the
services for the purposes as aforestated.
In such view of the
matter, when consideration is unascertainable for the services
rendered by a distributor or selling agent, the service tax is not
imposable and liable to be set aside.
42.
For the reasons and analysis made hereinabove, we
allow the writ petitions partly and hold that the amendments
carried out by the Finance Act, 2016, are not capable to being
implemented for imposition and levy of the service tax on the
services allegedly provided by the petitioners. Consequently, the
impugned letter dated 10.06.2016 issued by respondent No.3,
the circular dated 29.02.2016 and Notification No. 18/2016-ST
are quashed.
WP.(C) No. 34 of 2016
M/s Future Gaming & Hotel Services (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 48 of 2016
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd. vs. UOI & Ors.
43.
Resultantly, the writ petitions are allowed to the
above extent. No order as to costs.
jk/pm
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
Sd/Judge
Sd/Chief Justice
23.03.2017
23.03.2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review