Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:104
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 15th JULY, 2016
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
Appellant :
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd.
Having its Head Office at Gangtok, Sikkim,
and Gyalshing Branch Office at Gyalshing,
West Sikkim.
Versus
Shri Madan Lall Sharma,
S/o Shri S.R. Sharma,
Proprietor M/s Anil Traders,
Naya Bazaar,
Gyalshing,
West Sikkim.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Respondent :
Mr. Jorgay Namka and Ms. Panila Theengh, Advocates for the
Appellant.
Mr. K.T. Bhutia, Senior Advocate with Ms. Bandana Pradhan,
Advocate for the Respondent.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appeal under Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The questions that arise for consideration in this Appeal are;
(i) Whether there was service of Notice to the
Respondent as envisaged under Section 138 of the
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881? and
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
(ii) Whether Exhibit-C (the Notice) issued to the
Respondent, fulfils the requirements of Section 138(b)
of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (hereinafter
“NI Act”)?
2.
According to the Appellant, it had filed a Private Complaint
Case No. 01 of 2014 under Section 138 of the NI Act, against the
Respondent, before the Court of the learned Judicial Magistrate,
West Sikkim at Gyalshing, on account of dishonour of cheque issued
by the Respondent to it on 7.12.2013. The facts being that the
Respondent had applied for cash credit of Rs.10,00,000/- (Rupees
ten lakhs) only, from the Appellant Bank on 27.6.2009 and as on
7.12.2013 a sum of Rs.14,08,000/- (Rupees fourteen lakhs and eight
thousand) only, was outstanding against the Respondent duly
acknowledged by him. Towards repayment of the said loan, the
Respondent issued Cheque bearing No. 32003446 dated 07.12.2013,
drawn on the Union Bank of India, Gyalshing. The said cheque,
when presented, was dishonoured, which was duly communicated
to the Complainant vide Bank return Memo dated 11.12.2013.
Thereafter, the Appellant issued a Legal Notice through its counsel
on 7.1.2014, at the last known address of the Respondent demanding
that he make the payment as covered by the dishonoured cheque,
issued by him, within fifteen days from the receipt of the Legal
Notice which was duly served on 9.1.2014. Despite receipt of Notice,
the Respondent failed to comply with the demand, thus, being left
with no option the Complainant filed the aforesaid Private
Complaint Case. The Learned Trial Court after considering the
evidence on record, as well as the documents exhibited took
cognizance of the Case and summoned the Respondent, who sought
time to settle the matter with the Complainant. On 5.3.2014, the
Counsel for the Respondent undertook to pay Rs.4,00,000/- (Rupees
four lakhs) only, as settlement. On failure to repay the amount, the
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
learned Trial Court on 21.3.2014 finding sufficient prima facie
materials against the Respondent framed Charge under Section 138
of the NI Act. The Respondent being aggrieved by the said Order
preferred a Revision before the Learned Sessions Judge, West Sikkim
at Gyalshing, who rejected the same. Thereafter, the witnesses of the
Appellant Bank were examined, the Accused was examined under
Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. He sought to
and was allowed to examine two witnesses in his defence. The
learned Trial Court on examining the entire evidence, including the
documentary evidence, convicted the Respondent and sentenced
him to a fine of Rs.20,00,000/- (Rupees twenty lakhs) only, by its
Judgment and Order on Sentence dated 30.7.2014. Both were
assailed before the Learned Sessions Judge, West Sikkim at
Gyalshing in Criminal Appeal No. 07 of 2014.
3.
The Appellate Court vide its Judgment dated 22.4.2015, set
aside the Judgment and Order on Sentence of the Learned Trial
Court on the ground that the Notice served upon a person other
than the Accused is not a proper service as required under Section
138(b) of the NI Act, placing reliance on M.D. Thomas vs. P.S. Jaleel &
Another, since reported in (2009) 14 SCC 398. Being, thus aggrieved, the
instant Appeal has been preferred.
4.
The grounds canvassed in this Appeal are that the learned
Appellate Court has erred in holding that the case of the
Complainant does not fall within the ambit of the NI Act which is
contrary to the evidence on record and findings of the learned Trial
Court. That, the Appellate Court has also erred in holding that the
Notice issued to the Accused was not served to the Addressee, and
hence did not comply with the provisions of Section 138(b) of the NI
Act, thus arriving at a wrong finding. It was contended by learned
Counsel for the Appellant that the evidence before the learned Trial
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
Court clearly indicates commission of the offence under Section 138
of the NI Act. The further arguments pivoted around the point of
service of Notice. According to him, merely because the Respondent
did not receive the Notice from the Postman cannot wish away the
fact that his son had indeed received the Notice and had made it
over the Respondent on 29.1.2014. While placing reliance on Rekha
Mahindra Shah vs. Gautam United Parmar and Anr. : 2013 CRI. L.J. 2415,
he endeavoured to bring home this point in view of the findings
therein. In the said Judgment, while dealing with service of notice on
the husband of the appellant, the High Court of Bombay held that
the notice was issued and served, although the applicant did not
receive it personally, but was received by her husband. That, both
the courts below did not commit any error in holding that the notice
is duly served and received as well. Further, to fortify his
submissions reliance was also placed on C.C. Alavi Haji vs. Palapetty
Muhammed and Another : (2007) 6 SCC 555, wherein the Hon’ble Apex
Court while discussing the matter of service of notice held that
where the payee dispatches the notice by registered post with
correct address to the drawer of the cheque, the principle
incorporated in Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, would be
attracted. In the matter at hand, it is contended that the correct
address was given on the Notice, on the basis of which the son of the
Respondent duly received it, therefore, the Respondent cannot now
turn around and raise the bogey of non service. To further buttress
his point, assistance was also taken of the decision of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in Indo Automobiles vs. Jai Durga Enterprises And Others :
(2008) 8 SCC 529, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court while discussing
the case of K. Bhaskaran vs. Sankaran Vaidhyan Balan : (1999) 7 SCC
510, held that the context of Section 138(b) of the NI Act, invites a
liberal interpretation favouring the person who has the statutory
obligation to give notice under the Act because he must be
presumed to be the loser in the transaction, and provision itself has
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
been made in his interest and if a strict interpretation is asked for
that would give a handle to the trickster cheque drawer. Hence, the
Judgment and Order of the learned first Appellate Court be set
aside.
5.
Per contra, the thrust of the arguments advanced by learned
Senior Counsel for the Respondent, pivoted around the defects in
the Notice issued under Section 138 of the NI Act, purportedly
issued to the Respondent, however, the fact of service of Notice was
duly acknowledged during the course of the arguments. He has
walked this Court in detail through the provisions of Section 138 of
the NI Act, and contends that as per Section 138(b), there must be a
specific demand mentioning the amount due. That, Exhibit-C,
purportedly the Notice, issued by the Appellant does not mention
that the Respondent owes the Bank Rs.14,08,000/- (Rupees fourteen
lakhs and eight thousand) only. It is further argued that on careful
perusal of Exhibit-C, his stand would be vindicated leading to the
undeniable fact that the Notice is defective. That, the learned Trial
Court failed to examine the Notice in the first instance. Reliance was
placed on the decision of M/s Rahul Builders vs. M/s Arihant Fertilizers
& Chemical & Anr. : 2008 CRI. L.J. 452, wherein it was, inter alia, held
that unless a notice is served in conformity with Proviso (b)
appended to Section 138 of the Act, the complaint petition would
not be maintainable. That, it is one thing to say that the demand may
not only represent the unpaid amount under cheque but also other
incidental expenses like costs and interests, but the same would not
mean that the notice would be vague and capable of two
interpretations. The decision in Suman Sethi vs. Ajay K. Churiwal and
another : AIR 2000 SC 828, was also invoked wherein at Paragraph 8,
it was held as follows;
“8. It is a well settled principle of law that the notice has to
be read as a whole. In the notice, demand has to be made for
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
the “said amount” i.e. cheque amount. If no such demand is
made the notice no doubt would fall short of its legal
requirement. Where in addition to “said amount” there is
also claim by way of interest cost etc. whether the notice is
bad would depend on the language of the notice. If in a
notice while giving up breakup of the claim the cheque
amount, interest damages etc. are separately specified, other
such claims for interest, cost etc. would be superfluous and
these additional claims would be severable and will not
invalidate the notice. If, however, in the notice an omnibus
demand is made without specifying what was due under the
dishonoured cheque, notice might well fail to meet the legal
requirement and may be regarded as bad.”
(emphasis supplied)
6.
To further buttress his submissions, learned Senior Counsel
also placed reliance on Yankay Drugs and Pharmaceuticals Limited vs.
Citi Bank and Another : 2001 CRI. L. J. 4157, wherein it was held, inter
alia, at Paragraph 12 as follows;
“12. In this case on hand, the amount covered by the cheque,
which was dishonoured by the bank is Rs.9,972/-. But in the
notice issued under Section 138(b) of the Act the
complainant failed to make any demand for payment of the
said amount, instead it was stated in the notice that the
cheque, which was dishonoured, was issued for Rs.3,871/-.
From this it is clear that the notice clearly fell short of the
statutory requirement under Section 138(b) of the Act.”
7.
In the second limb of his argument, he disputes the fact that
the Respondent had issued the cheque for an amount of
Rs.14,08,000/- (Rupees fourteen lakhs and eight thousand) only.
Taking the stand that the Respondent had issued ten blank cheques
against the loan taken by him, having duly signed the cheques but
without inserting the dates. It is expostulated that on the relevant
date i.e. 7.12.2013, the Bank has filled in the details in the cheque and
presented it for encashment, without the knowledge of the
Respondent and therefore, he is not liable for any consequences that
arise on presentation of such a cheque in the absence of the
Respondent’s knowledge.
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
8.
I have heard the rival contentions of both learned Counsel and
given due consideration to the same. I have also carefully perused
the entire records of the matter including the evidence on record, the
Judgment and Order on Sentence of the learned Judicial Magistrate,
West Sikkim at Gyalshing and the impugned Judgment of the
learned Sessions Judge, West Sikkim at Gyalshing. Decisions of the
Hon’ble Apex Court relied on by learned Counsel for the parties
have also been perused by me.
9.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant had painstakingly argued
on the point of service of notice contending that the Notice had been
duly served on the Respondent, as before the learned Court of the
Magistrate, West Sikkim at Gyalshing, it was contended that the
Notice was not served and further, the learned Sessions Court, West
Sikkim at Gyalshing, also set aside the Judgment of the Learned
Trial Court on the grounds of non-service of summons on the
Respondent. The arguments before this Court placed by learned
Senior Counsel for the Respondent, however, clearly indicates that
he has no quarrel with the service of Notice. Inasmuch as, he admits
receipt of the Notice, therefore, this point requires no further
discussion. The first question set out above is consequently settled.
10.
Now dealing with the second question, it has been pointed
out by learned Senior Counsel that the provisions of Section 138(b)
of the NI Act, have not been complied with since the specific amount
of the cheque has not been mentioned in the Notice.
11.
On this point, on careful perusal of Exhibit-C, it is clear that
the Respondent has been given notice of the amount due from him
duly recapitulating that on 27.6.2009 he was sanctioned a cash credit
loan with a limit of Rs.10,00,000/- (Rupees ten lakhs) only, for a
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
period of 12 months. The said loan amount was sanctioned at the
interest rate of 13% per annum with an additional penal interest of
2% per annum to be charged in case of default. It has also been laid
out in the Notice that he failed to settle the outstanding despite
repeated reminders, but on 7.12.2013 issued a cheque bearing No.
32003446 in the name of the Complainant Bank to deposit it with the
assurance of sufficient funds in his account. However, what cannot
be lost sight of is the glaring fact that the specific amount of the
dishonoured cheque being Rs.14,08,000/- (Rupees fourteen lakhs
and eight thousand) only, has not been specified in the Notice which
makes the Notice fall short of its legal requisites. For better
appreciation, the relevant portions of the Notice are extracted herein
below;
“……………………………………………………………….…
1.
That on 27.06.2009, you were sanctioned a Cash
Credit Loan with a limit of Rs.10,00,000/- (Rupees lakh only)
(sic) by my client for a period of 12 months.
2.
That the said loan amount was sanctioned to you at
the interest rate of 13 % P.A. and an additional 2% P.A, Penal
Interest was to be charged in case of default.
3.
.………………….………………………………………
4.
…………………………………………………………….
5.
That my client, on several occasions had verbally
informed you about the outstanding amount payable by
you, however despite several assurances from your side, you
had not settled the same. However, you assured my client
that you had credited your account No 574401010050021,
maintained in my client’s Bank, i.e, Union Bank of India and
issued a Cheque bearing No.: 32003446, dated 07.12.2013 in
the name of my client requesting my client to deposit the
same in the bank and also assured that there is sufficient
balance in your account and the cheque would not be
returned without encashment.
6.
……………………………………………………………....
7.
…………………………………………………………….”
12.
In M/s Rahul Builders case (supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court
discussed the observation made in Suman Sethi’s case (supra) and
concluded that;
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
“13. As in the instant case, no demand was made for
payment of the cheque amount, we are of the opinion that
the impugned judgment cannot be faulted.”
13.
Similarly, as already mentioned for reasons best known to the
Appellant, the cheque amount has not been categorically specified in
the Notice and hence, I have to agree with the submissions of
Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent that the Notice is not in
conformity with the provisions of Section 138(b) of the NI Act. This
Court is alive to the fact that a wide interpretation has to be given to
the provision of Section 138(b) of the NI Act, so that the wrongdoer
does not benefit by raising the question of shortfalls in the
technicalities.
However,
when
there
is
a
categorical
legal
requirement, the party demanding payment cannot circumvent the
provisions. At the same time the fact of non-exhibition of Exhibit-C
by the Appellant in the learned Trial Court needs to be mulled over,
it is only on an Application filed by the Respondent before this
Court seeking to exhibit a copy of Exhibit-C, which was in the
possession of the Appellant Bank, duly filed by them before the
learned Trial Court and allowed by Order of this Court dated
13.4.2016, that the document came to be exhibited before the learned
Trial Court, despite vehement opposition to the Application by the
Appellant.
14.
Without the benefit of having examined Exhibit-C, the
learned Trial Court in its Judgment at Paragraph 22, held as follows;
“22. With regard to the notice issued by the complainant
bank to the accused, upon a proper edification of the
evidence, it is firstly inferred that although the complainant
bank has not exhibited the legal notice issued to the accused,
however I cannot reject their case on mere non-exhibition of
the notice when PW-4 examined by the complainant bank
has proved that legal notice was issued by him to the
complainant bank, which could not be discarded by defence.
Also the denial of its existence by defence does not hold
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
much weight when the witnesses of the defence itself have
duly acknowledged its receipt in their evidence.”
15.
The observation of the learned Trial Court that there was
compliance of procedural aspects merely relying on the evidence of
PW-4, cannot be countenanced as the learned Court had no
opportunity of examining Exhibit-C. The Court has failed to take
into consideration that the “said amount” has not been disclosed in
the Notice. On the other hand, it would be pertinent to point out that
the argument of the Respondent that he had given blank cheques to
the Appellant cuts no ice, in view of the non production of
counterfoils before the learned Trial Court to substantiate this point.
However, this argument has no bearing now, for the reason that in
the first instance the Appellant has failed to abide by the provision
of Section 138(b) of the NI Act, as already reflected in the foregoing
discussions.
16.
Accordingly, the Judgment and Order on Sentence of the
learned Trial Court in Case No. 01 of 2014 dated 30.7.2014, is set
aside.
17.
The acquittal of the Respondent by the learned first Appellate
Court is upheld but for a different reason, i.e. the learned Court of
Sessions while relying on M.D. Thomas’s case (supra), was of the
opinion that since
the Notice was
not served upon the
Respondent/Accused but on his son, the requirements in terms of
Clause (b) of the proviso of Section 138 of the NI Act had not been
complied with. Now, however, the Respondent admits receipt of the
Notice. It was also observed that PW-4, has deposed that he
specifically mentioned the cheque number, date and the amount.
This is contrary to the contents of Exhibit-C, therefore, this opinion
is not tenable.
2016:SHC:104
Crl. A. No. 10 of 2015
M/s Sikkim State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Madan Lall Sharma
18.
Hence,
in
view
of
the
discussions
hereinabove,
the
Respondent is accordingly acquitted of the Charge under Section
138 of the NI Act.
19.
Appeal is dismissed.
20.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Courts of the learned
Sessions Judge, West Sikkim at Gyalshing and the learned Judicial
Magistrate, West Sikkim at Gyalshing for information, along with its
records.
21.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
15.7.2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review