Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 46 OF 2023
Ms. Jui Das,
D/o Lt.Bakul Chandra Das, resident of
Ushabazar, Chinaini, P.O. Ushabazar,
P.S.Airport, District-West Tripura.
….Appellant.
Vrs.
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Health & Family Welfare, Government of Tripura,
New Capital Complex, Agartala, P.O. Secretariat Complex,
Agartala, P.S. New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura.
2. The Director,
Family Welfare and Preventive Medicine,
Government of Tripura, Gurkhabasti, P.O. Secretariat Complex,
Agartala, P.S. New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799010.
3. The Director of Health Services,
Government of Tripura, Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
District-West Tripura.
4. The Chief Medical Officer,
West Tripura, Agartala.
Present:
For the appellants
….Respondents.
: Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), Advocate.
Ms. Rumpa Dey, Advocate.
For the respondents
: Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
: 24.01.2024
Date of delivery of
judgment & order
: 23.02.2024
Whether fit for reporting
: Yes
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[ Arindam Lodh, J.]
The instant writ appeal is directed against the impugned judgment
and order dated 31.03.2023, passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C)
No.406 of 2022 whereby and whereunder the learned Single Judge has
dismissed the writ petition.
2.
Facts of the case of the appellant (here-in-after referred to as the
petitioner), in a nutshell, are that the father of the petitioner, namely, Bakul
Chandra Das was a regular employee of the Department of Health & Family
Welfare, Government of Tripura who died in-harness on 16.12.2017. He was
posted as Ex-Talua at Narsinghar PHC, West Tripura District. The petitioner
being the daughter and one of the legal heirs of said Bakul Chandra Das looks
after her mother since the death of her father with severe hardship as there is
none in her family to maintain their livelihood. The petitioner studied upto
Class-X and she made an application to the respondents on 15.03.2021 for her
employment on compassionate ground under Die-in-harness Scheme for the
untimely death of his father. The father of the petitioner left behind two
dependants as it is apparent from the survival certificate dated 04.04.2018
issued by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Mohanpur, West Tripura [Annexure11 to the writ petition]. The other survivor namely Mrs. Sajal Rani Das (wife)
has executed a no objection certificate by way of swearing an affidavit to the
competent authority undertaking that she would have no objection if the
petitioner, namely, Jui Das is appointed under Die-in-harness Scheme for the
death of her husband. But, the prayer made by the petitioner on 15.03.2021
was rejected by the respondent No.3 vide letter dated 26.04.2021 on the
ground that the petitioner had submitted her prayer after prescribed period of
submitting application for appointment under the Die-in-harness Scheme.
Accordingly, the petitioner had approached this court by way of filing a writ
petition for an appropriate direction upon the respondents particularly, upon
the respondent No.3 to provide her a compassionate appointment under the
Die-in-harness Scheme framed by the Government of Tripura as she is eligible
to be appointed in a suitable post under the said Scheme. The learned Single
Judge of this Court vide its judgment and order dated 31.03.2023 dismissed
the writ petition with the following observations:
“In view of above discussion and after perusal of the material
evidence on record, this Court is of the opinion that the scheme upon
which the present writ petition has been filed seeking compassionate
appointments which is 26th December, 2015 is no longer invoked. Since,
in the year 2019 a new scheme has been notified by the Government of
Tripura and the petitioner made an application in 2021. Accordingly, the
petitioner cannot succeed for any relief referring the scheme which has
already been abolished. Accordingly, no rights have been conferred to the
petitioner for getting relief under this scheme. Hence, the present petition
is devoid of any merits and thus, the same stands dismissed…”
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and order, the
appellant has filed the instant appeal.
3.
At the time of hearing, Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel
appearing for the original petitioner has submitted that learned Single Judge
did not consider that the administrative order or executive order cannot have
retrospective effect so as to take away the right accrued in favour of the
petitioner. She mainly stressed upon the fact that the deceased father died at
the time when the Die-in-harness Scheme of 2015 was in force not under the
present Scheme of 2019. Further, Mrs. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel reiterated
that the respondents failed to provide the necessary guidelines to the original
petitioner making her aware about the Scheme for compassionate appointment
and necessary assistance to enable her to file an application. According to
Mrs. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel for the petitioner, since the father of the
petitioner died in the year 2017, the Die-in-harness Scheme framed by the
Government under notification dated 26.12.2015 would be applicable in
regard to the case of the petitioner. It is further submitted that the members of
the family of the deceased may not be aware of the provision of Die-in-
harness Scheme and the formalities to be completed for making such an
application and, keeping in mind such type of situation, a provision has been
engrafted in the Scheme of 2015 that as soon as the concerned department
receives the information about the death of an employee while in service,
communication in writing should be made to the family members of the
deceased so that application for employment under the Scheme can be
submitted within the stipulated period. Hence, Mrs. Deb (Gupta), learned
counsel prays for quashing/setting aside the impugned judgment and order
passed by the learned Single Judge since according to Mrs. Deb (Gupta),
learned counsel, the impugned judgment and order is based on an incorrect
appreciation of law and facts.
4.
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the State-
respondents inter alia contended that the deceased person, namely, Bakul
Chandra Das, Ex-Talua was born on 13.05.1961 and the date of his demise
was on 16.12.2017. Therefore, Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. relying upon
the counter affidavits submitted that the deceased was 56 years 7 months and
3 days at the time of his death while he was in service and that the claim of the
petitioner cannot be considered for compassionate appointment under the Diein-harness Scheme. Moreso, the petitioner had submitted application for
appointment after expiry of 1(one) year from the date of death of the
Government Servant. Further, learned Addl. G.A. submitted that in the
meantime, the financial benefits i.e. gratuity, leave salary and group insurance
etc. have already been released to the mother of the petitioner. Hence, Mr.
Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. candidly submitted that there is no scope to avail
the benefits under the aforesaid Scheme after the inordinate delay of almost 3
years and 3 months from the date of death of the deceased. Thus, learned
Addl. G.A. supported the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned
Single Judge and accordingly prayed for upholding the same.
5.
In view of the submissions made by learned counsel for the
parties, we have gone through the factual aspects of the case of the petitioner.
First of all we see that the petitioner was aged about 27 years at the time of
death of her father while he was in service. She studied upto Class-X and there
is no other earning member in their family. The deceased left behind only two
dependent family members in their family i.e the petitioner herself and her
mother. Admittedly, the petitioner had applied for compassionate appointment
after lapse of more than three years as she was not aware of the formalities of
seeking compassionate appointment and consequences of not applying within
time. But, the respondents had turned down her prayer on the ground that the
prayer had not been made within the statutory period of one year from the date
of death of the deceased. Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. also stressed upon
this proposition that the petitioner could not make her prayer within the
prescribed period of one year.
6.
We have perused the Memorandum dated 02.03.2019, issued by
the General Administration (Personnel & Training) Department, Govt. of
Tripura by which a ―Scheme for Compassionate Appointment/Benefit for
Government Employees of Tripura, 2019‖ [for short, Scheme, 2019] had been
framed and came into force in supersession of all earlier instructions issued by
the Govt. of Tripura in connection with Die-in-harness Scheme. Admittedly,
the father of the petitioner had died at the age of 56 years 7 months while he
was in service disentitling the petitioner for compassionate appointment since
the Scheme of 2019 provides that if an employee dies at an age more than 50
years, then, his/her dependents would not be entitled for compassionate
appointment, but, provisions have been made extending financial benefits.
7.
In view of the above context, we may revisit Clause 3.2 and
Clause 9 of the Scheme 2019, which is reproduced here-under for the sake of
convenience.
“3.2 Support Category-1
If the age of the affected Government Servant is equal to or more
than 50 years on the date of occurrence, then the family will be paid
Special Pension amounting to difference between last drawn salary and
pension in addition to the normal pension till the affected employee would
have attained 60 years of age, provided that there is no earning member
in the family. After attaining 60 years of age, only normal pension will be
paid.”
“9. Time limit for considering applications for compassionate
appointment:
For Government appointment and admissible financial assistance,
requests to be submitted within one year from the date of occurrence of
the deceased government servant or missing or permanent invalidation
while on government duty.
Provided that for administrative financial assistance, time period for
application can be extended by 1(one) year on valid grounds.”
8.
Here, in the instant case, admittedly the petitioner applied for her
compassionate appointment in the year 2021 while her father died-in- harness
in the year 2017 i.e. after three years which is beyond the statutory period of
one year from the date of death of her father. Scheme, 2019 is very clear that
for Government appointment and admissible financial assistance, requests to
be submitted within one year from the date of death of the deceased
government servant which the petitioner could not make. After more than
three years, the petitioner applied for such compassionate appointment, which
was rejected on the basis of the prevalent Scheme of 2019 which has been
framed in supersession of all other earlier Schemes. From the Survival
Certificate [Annexure-1 to the writ petition] it appears that it was issued on
04.04.2018 i.e. within 3(three) and half months from the date of death of the
deceased and no objection was there from any corner in applying the same.
9.
Having gone through all these aspects, we may gainfully revisit
some observations made by the Apex Court which are as follows:
10.
In Umesh Kumar Nagpal vs. State of Haryana, reported in
(1994) 4 SCC 138, Hon‘ble Supreme Court observed that— the object of
granting compassionate employment is to enable the family of a deceased
government employee to tide over the sudden crisis by providing gainful
employment to one of the dependants of the deceased who is eligible for such
employment. That mere death of an employee in harness does not entitle his
family to such source of livelihood; the Government or the public authority
concerned has to examine the financial condition of the family of the deceased
and it is only if it is satisfied that, but for the provision of employment, the
family will not be able to meet the crisis, that a job is to be offered to the
eligible member of the family, provided a scheme or rules provide for the
same. This Court further clarified in the said case that compassionate
appointment is not a vested right which can be exercised at any time after the
death of a government servant. That the object being to enable the family to
get over the financial crisis which it faces at the time of the death of the sole
breadwinner, compassionate employment cannot be claimed and offered after
lapse of considerable amount of time and after the crisis is overcome.
11.
In Haryana State Electricity Board vs. Hakim Singh, reported in
(1997) 8 SCC 85, Hon‘ble Apex Court placed much emphasis on the need for
immediacy in the manner in which claims for compassionate appointment are
made by the dependants and decided by the concerned authority. Hon‘ble
Apex Court cautioned that – it should not be forgotten that the object of
compassionate appointment is to give succour to the family to tide over the
sudden financial crisis that has befallen the dependants on account of the
untimely demise of its sole earning member. Therefore, Hon‘ble Apex Court
held that – it would not be justified in directing appointment for the claimants
therein on compassionate grounds, fourteen years after the death of the
government employee. That such a direction would amount to treating a claim
for compassionate appointment as though it were a matter of inheritance
based on a line of succession.
12.
In State of Haryana vs. Ankur Gupta, reported in AIR 2003 SC
3797 the Apex Court held that— in order for a claim for compassionate
appointment to be considered reasonable and permissible, it must be shown
that a sudden crisis occurred in the family of the deceased as a result of death
of an employee who had served the State and died while in service. It was
further observed that appointment on compassionate grounds cannot be
claimed as a matter of right and cannot be made available to all types of posts
irrespective of the nature of service rendered by the deceased employee.
13.
In the above backdrop, Hon‘ble Supreme Court very recently in
the case of Bank of Baroda Vrs. Baljit Singh, reported in 2023 SCC OnLine
SC 745 referring to the case of N.C. Santosh Vrs. State of Karanata, (2020) 7
SCC 617 and State of Himachal Pradesh Vrs. Sashi Kumar, (2019) 3 SCC
653 emphatically held as follows:―…….In N.C.Santhosh vs. State of Karnataka (supra) a
three-Judge Bench of this Court reiterated that appointment
on compassionate basis is a concession and not a right and the
criteria laid down in the Rules and Schemes applicable must be
satisfied by all aspirants. Therefore, the case for compassionate
appointment has to be considered in accordance with the
prevalent Scheme.
Similarly, in State of Himachal Pradesh Vs. Shashi
Kumar (supra), this Court has observed that –compassionate
appointment being an exception to the general rule, the
dependents of deceased government employee are made eligible
by virtue of the policy of compassionate appointment and they
must fulfill the terms of the policy which are framed by the
States/Employers.”
14.
In the instant case, it appears that the father of the petitioner died
in harness on 16.12.2017 while in service at the age of 56 years and odd and at
Para 12 of the counter affidavit filed by the respondents it also transpires that
the petitioner had duly informed the date of death of her father and as a result
provisional family pension was also sanctioned vide order dated 14.05.2018.
Therefore, the respondents within five months from the date of death of the
deceased completed the entire process of service benefits and released the
same to the family of the deceased which facts were, no doubt, within the
knowledge of the petitioner and her mother. The petitioner at that time also
could have pursued the matter with the respondents had she been informed in
terms of Clause 10(ii) of 2015 Scheme for compassionate appointment.
15.
Keeping in view the analogy depicted at Para 19 of the case of
N.C. Santhosh (supra), where the three-Judge Bench of Hon‘ble Supreme
Court held that – ‗the norms prevailing on the date of consideration of the
application should be the basis for consideration of the claim for
compassionate appointment. The Bench further held that the dependant of a
government employee, in the absence of any vested right accruing on the date
of death of the government employee, can only demand consideration of his
application and hence he is disentitled to seek the application of the norms
prevailing on the date of death of the government servant‘, the
petitioner/appellant is not entitled to get any compassionate appointment and
her claim would be considered in terms of the Scheme of 2019, which was
prevalent in the year 2021 when the petitioner had submitted her application
for compassionate appointment.
16.
One noticeable feature, we find that sub-clause (ii) of Clause 10
of the Scheme of 2015, dealing with the “responsibilities of the department‖
itself says that sometimes the members of the family of deceased may not be
aware of the provisions of the Die-in-harness scheme and the formalities to be
observed in submitting the application (i.e. time limit of submission of
application, consequence of submission of false documents etc.). The said
clause further speaks that on being informed about the death of any of the
employees, while in service, the department is under obligation to
immediately communicate in writing to the respective family so that the
family members of the deceased employee can submit application for
employment/financial assistance within the prescribed period as mentioned in
the Die-in-harness scheme. In the instant case, the State-respondents have
failed to place any record before the Court that though they received the
information of death of the father of the petitioner in the year 2017, but they
failed to make any endeavour to make the family members of the deceased
aware of the benefits stated in the scheme. According to us, it is an obligation
cast upon the concerned department to intimate the family members of the
deceased as regards the extent of benefits provided in the Die-in-harness
scheme and the period by which such family member would submit
application seeking benefits of the scheme they are entitled to get.
17.
In view of this, we are not in agreement with the submission of
learned counsel and the stand taken by the State-respondents that the
petitioner is not entitled to get the benefit of the scheme as she failed to submit
application within one year from the date of death of her father.
18.
Admittedly, the petitioner had submitted application for
compassionate appointment under the Die-in-harness scheme on 15.03.2021
when the scheme of 2019 was prevalent. Keeping in mind the principles laid
down in N.C. Santosh(supra) that the norms prevailing on the date of
submission of the application should be the basis for consideration of the
scheme for compassionate appointment, we are of the view that the competent
authority of the department had to consider the application submitted by the
petitioner within the ambit of the Scheme of 2019 as regards the extent of
benefit provided in Scheme of 2019, but the respondents failed to do so.
19.
It is settled that appointment on compassionate ground is an
exception to Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. It cannot be
claimed as a matter of right. Further, the Scheme of 2019 clearly lays down
that compassionate appointment would not be allowed to any of the family
members of the deceased employee if the age of such government servant is
equal to or more than 50 years on the date of occurrence. In such a case, the
dependent family members shall be provided with financial assistance. In the
instant case, admittedly, the father of the petitioner died at the age of more
than 56 years. As such, the petitioner is not entitled to claim appointment on
compassionate ground under the Die-in-harness scheme prevalent in the State.
20.
Under clause 3.2 scheme of 2019 extracted in the preceding
paragraph, the respondents are under obligation to extend a lump sum
financial assistance to the petitioner since the father of the petitioner died at
the age of 56 years while in service.
21.
As a logical consequence to the aforesaid fact, the respondents
are directed to pay financial assistance to the petitioner as is admissible in
Clause 3.2 of the Scheme, 2019 i.e. the petitioner shall be paid Special
Pension amounting to difference between last drawn salary and pension in
addition to the normal pension till the deceased father of the petitioner would
have attained 60 years of age since there is no other earning family members
in the family of the deceased.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of 3(three)
months from the date of receipt of copy of this judgment and order.
22.
In the light of above observations and directions, the instant
appeal stands partly allowed and disposed of. Pending application (s) if any,
shall also stand disposed of.
(ARINDAM LODH),J
sanjay
Digitally signed
SANJAY
SANJAY byGHOSH
2024.03.01
GHOSH Date:
16:38:47 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH),CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review