Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY,THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
APPEAL SUIT NO: 543 OF 2025
Appeal Under Section 96 R/w. Order 41 Rule 1 of CPC aggrieved by the
Order dated 11-09-2025 in l.A.No. 527 of 2025 in O.S.No. 258 of 2025 on the file
of the Court of the lll Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy District at
L. B. Nagar.
Between:
1. Mrs. Thaslima Azeem, W/o. Late Abdul Azeem, Age. 48 yrs., Occ. Housewife,
F/o. 11-18-235/1, Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad, Telangana State
2. Mohammed Tabreez Azeem, S/o. Late Abdul Azeem, Age. 29 yrs., Occ.
Business, R/o. 11-18-235/1 , Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad, Telangana State.
3. Tabassum Azeem, C/o. Mohammed lrfan Ali, Age. 23 yrs., Occ. Housewife
No. 17-8-533177, Bagh-E-Jahanara, Charminar, Hyderabad.
4. lanwer Azeem, C/o. Syed lsmail, Age.22 yrs., Occ. Student
5. Tayyaba Azeem, D/o. Mohammed Abdul Azeem, Age. 21 yrs., Occ. Student,
No. 11-18-235i1, Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad.
6. Ayeesha Siddique, D/o. Lage Mohammed Abdul Azeem, Age. 19 yrs., Occ.
Student, F/o. 11-18-235/1 , Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad.
7. Abdul Maqeeth Quadri, D/o. Mohammed Abdul Azeem, Age. 14 yrs., Occ.
Student, Fyo. 11-18-235/1 , Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad. Rep. by Smt. Thaslima Azeem,
...APPELLANTS/ Plaintiffs
AND
1. Sri Mekala Ram Reddy, S/o. Penta Reddy, Age.60 yrs., Occ. Business, Ri/o.
Plot No. 2218, Green Hills Colony, L.B. Nagar, Rangareddy District.
2. Smt. K. Madhavi, D/o. M. Ram Reddy, Age.45 yrs., Occ. Software
Professional, Rl/o. Plot No.22lB, Green Hills Colony, L.B. Nagar, Rangareddy
District.
3. Smt. Vittal Reddy Gari Archana, D/o. M. Ram Reddy, Age. 44 yrs., Occ.
Software Professronal, Fl/o. Plot No.22lB, Green Hills Colony, L.B. Nagar,
...RESPONDENTS/ Defendants
Rangareddy District.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
suspend the operation of the decree and order passed in lA No.. 527 of 2O25 in
OS No. 258 of 2025 dated 1110912025, on the file of Honourable lll Addl District
Judge, Ranga Reddy District, At LB Nagar., till the disposal of the main Appeal
and to pass such other order or orders in the interest of .justice.
Counsel for the Appellants: SRl. M. LAXMAN RAO
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI P. AMARENDER REDDY
The Court delivered the following Judgment :
IN'tHE I{IGH COtilt-I'FOR THE S]'A-I'E OF TEI-;\NGANA
AT I{\'DEITABAD
HON'BLT] SRI.ITISTICE K. LAKSHMAN
,\ND
HON'BLE JUSTICI] VAKI'TI RAMAKRISHNA I{EDDY
AI'P[..{l- SL II'\o.5{3 OI'- 2025
Date:08.01.2026
Bctrr ecrr
-[has
lirla Azeenr
and sir othcrs
.....Appellants
nnd
Mekrla Rarr l{eddy
and [*'o others
....Respondents
'I'his Court delivered the following
JI. DC}I[,\T:
(Per Hon'blt Sri Justicc K. l-irkshnral)
l.leard Sri M. Laxman Rao, learned couusel lor thc Appellants
and Sli P. Amarender Reddy, learncd cor.rnsel lor the responclents.
2. This appeal is filed challcnging order dated I I.09.2025
passcd in I.A.No.527 o12025 in O.S.No.258 of 2025 by thc lcamed lll
Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy District, at LB Nagar.
3. 1'he appetlants herein filed a suit vide O.S.No.258 ol 2015
agairrst respondents to declare the actior-r ol the rospondents -
f
dclendants in cancclling the agreement ol sale dated 08.I0.20I8
erecut.-d bv I-ate Mckala Subhashini in lavour o1'Maharnrred Abdttl
Azcor in respect ol'thc suit schedule propertv by issuing legal notice.
dated -10.07.201-1.
lts
illegal and consequentll', to direct thc
rcspondcnts to execLlte and rcgister sale deed in their lavour in respect
of- the suit schedulc propefty by receiving balance sale consideratiort
ol' t{s.-.0.00,()0()/- (Rupces Fil'tl Lakhs only). In the cvcnt ot
rcspondenls - del'endants l'ails to execute and register the sale decd, the
Courl to exccute and rcgister the sale dced on bchall ol thc
respondents - delbndants
4. Irr thc plaint, the plaintills contended:-
i. I'laintill' No.l is the wife of late Moharnrlcd Abdul
,\zce'rr s/o M.A.Sattar and Plaintiff Nos.2 to 7 arc thcir
sons
and daughters. The said late Moharnmed Ahdul
Azecrn rvas tcnant ol IJ.No.7-34. Shop No.3 (Mulgi). (i- I
['loor in H.No.7-34. admeasuring 640 square leet situated at
MRIt Cornplex. Madhurapuri Colony. DilshLrknagar.
Saroornagar Mandal. Itanga Reddy District (lbr short.
'sub.icct propcrt!,'). Late Srnt. Subhashani was the original
o\\,ner ol' the suit schedule property. Deltndant
No.
I is thc husband of saicl late Srnt. Subhashani and
De't-cnclants No.2 and 3 are tircir daus.htcrs.
ll.
During Iil-e tir.ne, late Mohanicd Abdul Azcern. purchased
the suit schcdulc propert), ll'orn l-atc Snrt. Subhashrni.
l-he sale consideration u,as t-rxed at Rs. 1.00,00.000/(Rupees One Crore only). Having received an arnount of
Rs.50,00.000/-(Rupees lriliy I-akhs), late Snrt.
SLrbhashini had execr-rted an agrecment ol- sale on
0lt.l 0.2018 in whicli it is agrecd to pay' balanc:e amount
u'ithin i (three) nronths lbr execution ol registered sale
dced.
llt.
Despite several requests made by said late Mohamed
Abdul Azeem, for execution of registered sale deed, Snrt.
Mekala Subhashani postponed the same on onc reason or
the other. Meanwhile she died on 29.10.2019 leaving
behind thc defendants herein as her legal heirs. 'l'he said
Mohamed Abdul Azeem, also died on 25.05.1020 leaving
behind hirn the plaintiff's as his legal heirs. Evcn after his
death, in August/September 202 l, the plaintiffs along
u,ith their uncle lequested Def-endant No. I tc'r execute
-1
registcrl-d sale dced lbr which he refused and stated that
thcre is mortgage over the schedule property and hc
w'oulrl crccute rcgistcrcd sale deed after releasing thc
nl()ngaqL'.
l\'.
Instead ol'erecuting legistererl sale deed. the Dcfbndant
Nt'r.
I got issucd legal notice dated 30.7.2024 cancclling
lhc agrec'nre nt ol' :ale datcd 08. 10.201 8 lorfe itinr
llttt()ttnls paid and also dernancled to vacate the plerniscs
and pav darnage s. f he Plaintills sent reply
clrll -
dcnrancl noticc datcd 14.08.2024 to the said notice.
denling thc allegations rnade by the defendants and
called Lrpon thcnr to execute the sale deed in their t'avour
b,v receiving 1l're balance sale consideration. I'he
clelendants had issucd a rejoinder notice dated 09.09.202,1
u,ith lalse allegations and also expressing to enter into
ile.recrrent olsale and sale deed with third parties
\,. Elen afier notices ancl reply notices, on 05.05.2025.
plaintifl- No.2 along with his maternal uncle, requested
l)clendant No. l to cxecute sale deed by receiving the
halancc sale consideration. -Ihe Defendant No.l
dernanded an additional anrount of Rs.30,00,0001
(Rupees I'hirty l.akhs Only) tbr execution of' registered
salc' dccd. \\/hen the plaintill.s expressed thcir inabilitl ,
thc dcfendants have issued another lcgal notice dated
l'1-0 I -2015 r-rndcr Section 106 of I'ransle r ol [)ropenr
Act, with all t-alse allegations stating that their tenancl is
terrninatecl and to vacate the shop in 15 days and pal'
rental drres Rs. 15.86, l82l-. The Plaintiffs, issued repll'
dated l0-01-2025 denying the same.
vl.
l'he deftndants are bound to execute rcgistered sale dced
by receiving balance sale consideration. The delendants
created niortgagc over the suit schedule propefiy to
Dcccan lloLrsing Finance Corporation Ltd., and did not
kecp their promise. Ptaintiffs obtained encumbrancc
cefiillcate dated 06-08-2024 and, car.ne to know that thc
del'endants cleared the mortgage only on 21.06.2024 and
sot issued thc atbresaid notice dated 30.7 .2024 rvith talsc
allcgations to nrakc illegal gains. Plaintitf! have got
issued rcply on 14.08.2024 requesting to execute
rcg stc rccl
saL' decd by receiving balance sale
con:idcratit',n. I herefirre. thc suit.
5. l'lic de lcndarrts flled I.A.-\o.517 ol 1025 in the present suit
under Olclcr Vtl Rule- I l(l) read u'ith l5l of CPC, to reject the plaint
in the albresaid suit contcnding
-l'hc
suit is rrot maintainablc. the reliel'claimed is bad in
lau' and barred bv limitation.
ii.
Thcre is no cause of action for ptaintiff to sue tbr
<leclaration ancl specific pertirrrnance of agreement ol'
salc
l
'fhcre r.r'as stipulation tbl a period three rnonths only front
tht'date of ugreernent of sale to execute r-egistered salc
deed
l\
I']lrintifli did not file thc suit w,ithin three years frorn the
dale ol-executiorr of aglccment o1'sale dated 06. I0.2018
'['hc plaintifl- u,ithout issuing notice, filed the present suit
6. Opposing the said petition, the plaintilfs filed counter'
contending:-
i.
l)elendant No. I exltressed that thel would execute sale deed
but ll'onr to titnc he postponed the sarne.
l
II
Since their lather died on 15.05.2020, Defendant No. I issued
notice dated 30.07.1024 cancelling the agreement of sale dated
0tl. I 0.10 I 8. 1'he plaintilT issued reply and Dclendant r,,vo. I
issued rejoinder.
'l
herelbre, the cause of action is continuing
aud not barred bv linritation.
l
Dcspite requcsts nrade by the fbther of the plaintiffs, Defendant
No. I postponed the same tl'orn time to time under onc pretext or
tl-re otht-r
7. Vidr inrpugncd order, learned trial Court allowed the said
pctitiorr reje'cting the plair.rt in O.S.No.258 of 2025 holding that the
suii i: harrcd lrr lirnilati,ut.
8. Challenging thc said order, dated 11.09.2025 passed ln
I.A.No.5l7 ol'1025 in 0.S.No.158 o12025 by the leamed trial Court,
thc plaintitl.s fllcd the present appeal on the following grounds:-
i.
[-carr.red trial Cour.t f'ailed to consider that the suit lbr
declaration to declare the tcrrnination notice dated 30.07.2014
must bc tlled wirhin 3 vears from the date of the said notice.
'l.l.rey
havc tl led the suit u,ithin one year as such the suit is
u'ithin Iinritatior.r undcr Article 58 of the Limitation Act.
i
s
I1
Learned trial ( ourt tailcd to consider tlic efforts made bv lather
ol'thc plaintifl.s tlurinc lris litctirne clenranding tor execution of
rcgistercd sale dced rlithin -l rnonths irr tcrms of agreernent of
salc and also tailed to sce that it is onlv the del'e ndants rvho
postponed the e rccution inlcntionallv.
lll
As pcr Order 7 RLrlc I l(cl) ol CPC, the averments in the plaint
and the docunrerrts tllccl alon,, ri'ith the plaint are only to be
considered. But thc' lcarnecl trial C]ourt did not retbr the plaint
pleadings, br-rt only' rclic-d upon the avc'nnents in the petition
filed unde r Older 7 Rulc I I (dt olCP('.
l\'.
Learned trial Court crrcd in holding that the plaintilfs, legal
heirs ot' \4r. .,\bdLrl Azecnr. renrainecl silent till thc det'cndants
issued legal notice dated 30 07.2024 to vacate and for payment
of arrears ol'rcnt b1'tenninating the agreement of sale.
Learned trial ('ourt lhiled to consider the settled precedents ol
Apex court and other t{igh ( ourls relied upon by the Plaintiffs
and crroneously' rcjcctcd thc plaint
vt.
l-he cause of action liling the suit for declaration and specific
perfcrrrnance arose li'orn thc date of legal notice dated
()
-10.07.2024 and the suit Iiled on 19.06.2025 is well within the
period ol'limitation
vii. ' re [-irlitutit'rn is nrixecl cluestion of facts and larv. In thc
Irrcscnt ca:c. it is thc urattcr ol lhct which will be established in
duc coulsc of tlial and it is not a question of law to decide the
linritation on thr- cause ol-action.
viii.
l.carned Irial Court t'ailed to consider that defendants had
cleared nrortqa-sL- on the sr"rit propefty only on 21.06.2024, rtll
s,'hictr datc. dcll'ndants obligation to discharge the encumbrance
be tbrc salc unrlcr Scction 55 ( I ) (a) ol'I'ransfcr of Property Act
\\ AS
inconrplcte u hich clcarly shows that the delendants
thcmselves were not readv and dela-ved execution of registered
srle clc.'d. ..\ticr clearance tll'rnoftgagc only, the Vendor issued
legal notice on 10.07.2024 cancelling the agreement of sale
wlrich savc rise to lllinc ol'the suit on 19.06.2025 which is
*'ithin lirnitatior-r.
!). With thc alirrcsaid sr.rbnrissions, the appellants sought to set
aside thc impugncd order dated t 1.09.2025.
\
10. In support o[ their case, the appellants - Plaintiffs placed
reliance on the principle laid down by the Apex Court in
I
l0
P.Kumarakurutraran vs. P.Naravan'. Sol."* D.Agboahvala vs.
Shamalji Odrlhav.ii T'hakkarr. Sri l]ovenepallv vs. Sri
,Iavav:rrrlhan vs. \'.Nirupanra l{cddt-\ .{nnamalai vs. Vasanthil.
ancl I).f)souza vs. Shontl rilo Naitlu'.
I 1. Thc responden ts/de icndants contended that thc suit is barrcd
br lirnitation. thc plaintil'1.s clr'r'crlr dralicd the plaint u,ith illusorr
pleadings. 1hc plaintiffs. instcad ol sceking specific perlbrmancc of
agrcement of sale. sought lbr cleclaration of noticc dated 10.07.1024
issued by defendants terminating the agreernent of sale dated
08.10.2018 as illegal only, to get over tiom the limitation and also to
fill up lacuna / Iaches. i!{ere possession over the suit schcdule
promptly rvill not ertend lirnitation to rhe plaintiffs to llle the suit. On
consideration of the said aspects onl1. lealned trial Court allorved the
pctition trlcd by the del-endants under Order VII Rutc I l(d) oI CPC
seeking rejection olplaint. lt is a reasoned order. Therc is no error in
lt
r
r
2025 Livelatv (SC) 50s
Orderdated l7.Og.2O2l in(livil Appeal No.i64l ol202l
'Ordcr dated 29.07.2025 in Civil Appcal No-*---oll025
(arising out ofSLP (C) No.57i2 ol'2015
'2025 l-aw Suit (SC) l416
' loM l-aw suir ( sc) 7l 7
1l
12. In support ol theil case, the respondents - Def'endants
placed reliance on thc plinciple laid dou'n by the Apex Court in
Nikhila Dirlang Mehta V. Hitesh P. Sanghvi6, Fatheji and
Company V. l-.M.Nagpal ,, Khatri Hotles Private Limited Vs.
Union8, The Correspondence RIIANMS Educational Institution
Vs. B. Gunashekare, Dahiben vs. Aravindbhai Kalyanji
Ilhansusali (Gujra)r0,, Indian Evangelical Lutheran Church Trust
Association vs. Sri llala and Companyt' on the judgment of this
Courl in P. Ramakrishna vs. Coverdhan Ileddy G) Gopal ReddyD
and also on the judgnicnt of i\'ladras High Court in Vasumathi H
Shah Vs Pushpa Rajrr.
1-1. We lrave licarcl lcarnctl counsel on cithcl side and gave
thoughtful considcration olthe subrnissions made and judgments cited
by thern
2025 SCC Onlinc SC 779
' zo r sltyscc ;lo
t t 1e; scc rzo
'zo
e
2025 SCC Online SC 739
scc :i66
rr
2025 sCC online sc .,18
'o zozo(l)
rr
zoz:1ay nLo:50 ltst
" 20 15 3 Lw 825
I4. [n the present case, the undisputed facts are as tbllows:i. Mr. Mohd. Abclul Azeern, husband and t?rther respecl.ivelv of
plaintiffs entercd into an agreerncnt o1' sale datcd t18.10.201IJ riith
Mrs. Mekala Subhashini. rvil-c and rnothel respectively ol lhe
deltndants ri,iLh rcgard to the sale ol suit schcdulc proper11,. 'lhe total
salt' considcration aqrecd rvas I{s. 1.00,00.000,'-. Vendec 113,s paid an
anroLult ol Rs.->0.00.000i- toriards adrance salc consiclcration i.c. I{s.
10.00,000i- vide checluc No.148777, dated 06. 10.20 18. Rs. 10,00,000i-
vide chequc No.248778, dated 25.0ti.1018. draw'n on Axis Bank,
Dilsukhragar Branch and Rs.30,00,000/- by rvay ofcash. Vendor has
rcceived and acknowledged tl're said arlount. Vendee agreed to pay
the balance sale consideration rvithin thrce months lrorl thc date ol'
aglcernent of'sale or at the time ol rcgistration, whichever is earlier
The said ttrree rnonths period w'as expired on 07.0 I .2019.
ii. \'errdor died on 29. 10.20 19. Vendee died on 15.05.1020
\/cndee, i.e.. late Mohd. Abdul Azeem w'as the tenant of the suit
schedule property. After death ol the vendor, their legal heirs got
iss,idJegal notice dated 30.07.2024 to the legal heirs of the vendee
tenninating the agreement of sale dated 08. 10.2018. Legal heirs of
verrdee got issued a reply dated 14.08.2024 to the legal heirs of the
il
vendor. l,egal heirs of vendor issued interim rejoinder dated
09.09.2024 to thc reply dated 11.08.20)4 issued by the legal heirs ol
tlrc Vcndec. On l:1.01 .2015. thc l.-uirl hcirs ol'the vendor issued notice
ol' tclrnination 1cluit notice) undel Section l0(r ol the 'fransfbr of
Properlr' Act, 1981, demanding thc legal hcirs of thc vendee to vacate
the subject propefiy ',r'ithin one rlonth fl'onr the date ol receipt of the
said notice and also to pay an arrount o1' t{s. 15.86,182/- towards
r rrears of rcnt.
Ptaintifls tlled r suit in O.S.No.l58 ot'2025 on 19.06.2025
against thc defendants seeking to dcclarc thc tern-rination notice dated
30.07.2024 issucd by thc defendants tenninating the agreement of sale
dated 08.10.2018, as illegal and also tbr specific performance of
agreement of salc dated 08.10.20 18. 'fhe dettndants llled an
application under Order VII Rulc I l(d) ol CIPC seeking rejection of
plaint on I1.08.1025. Vide order dated 11.09.2025, the leamed trial
Court allowed the said application and reiected the plaint
iv. As discussecl supra, thc defendants l'rled an application vide
I.A.No.527 of 2025 under Order Vll Rule ll (d) of CPC to reject the
plaint on the afbresaid grounds. more particularll,, that thc suit is
barred by Iirnitation. Accorcling to thcrn, the plaintil'i! should have
l4
tlled the suit on or bctbre 08. I 0.201 l. Thev have filed the suit on
19.()6.101-< end therclirre. tlre sarnc is barred bl linritatiorr
\.\/hcreas. accordin,,. to thc plaint pleadirrgs. the lccal licils ol
thc vendor have issuccl uoticc datcd i0.07.1024 tcrnrinating thc
ilsrccnlcnt ol' sale clatcd 08.10.20 18.
-fherelbre.
thcy har c lilcd plaint
on 19.06.1015 i.e. rr ithin three vears ll'orn the said datc
15. In thc- light oltlre above. it is apt k) note that Oldcr - \'ll.
Rulc - 1 I olCPCl deals rvith 're-iection of plaint'. 'I'he sanre is rclevant
and extracted as under:
"11. Rejection of plaint. 1'he plaint shall bc
re.iected in the lbllowing cascs:-
(a) rvhero it does not disclose a causc of action:
(b) s hcrc the rcliel clainred is underr,alued. and
the plaintiff, on being required by the Court
to correct the valuation within a tirne to bc
fixed by the Court, fails to do so:
(c) ri'here the relief claimed is properll, valucd.
but the plaint is returned upon papcr
insulliciently stamped, and the plaintiff- on
being required by thc Court to suppll.thc
rcquisite stamp-paper within a time to he
tixed by the Court, fails to do so;
(d) rvhcrc the suit appcars tiom the statemcnt in
thc plaint to be barred b1,, any lau,;
(e) u,here it is not fili:d in duplicate:
( f-)
s herc the plaintifl' lails to comply rvith the
provisions o l- rulc 9:
Plorided that thc tinrc fixed h1 thc Court lur
thc correclion of'the valuation or supplying ol the
requisitc stanrp-paper shall not bc extendcd unless
the Court. firr reasons to be recorded. is satisfied
that the plaintiff rvas pro'ented b1' any cause of an
exceptional naturc fionr corrcclilig thc valuation or
supplf ing the rcquisite starnp-paper. as the oasc
rnay bc. within thc tirne llxed by the Coun antl that
rcfusal to cxtend such tinre r.vould causc sravc
injustice to thc plaintifi"
16. In Dahibcn (supra), the Apex Court considered the scope
and anrbit olOrder - Vll. Rulc - ll of'Cl)C and held as under:
"23.1. -l'he renre dy under Order 7 Rulc I 1 is an
independent and spccial renredy, rvhercin thc court
is empowered to sumnarily dismiss a suit at the
threshold. wilhout procccding to record evidcncc,
and conducting a trial. on thc basis ol- the cvidence
adduced. if it is satisfied that the action should be
terminated on anl ol thc grounds containcd in this
provision.
23.3. l'hc underlying object of Order 7 Rule I l(a)
is that if in a suit. no causc of'action is disclosed.
or the suit is barrcd by lirnitation under Rule ll(d).
l6
the court s'ould not perrnit thc plaintifl to
runnccessarilr prottact thc procecdings in the suit.
In:trth lr eusc. il uoultl he rrecessarl t() put an cnd
1o tire sharr litigation. so that hrlther.judicial tinre
ir nrrt $ uslcd.
13.1. ln l:lutr
llus,sairtv. Rajiv Gandhi 11986
Supp SCC' I I5. l;ollowed in Munvendrasinhji
lluttiil.:inltli,lutk:.jut'. I'ijaykunt,erbu. 1998 S('('
()nl inc (irti l8l : (1993) ) Gt.Il 8231 this Clourt hcld
that the rrholc purpose ol conlerment ol porlers
Lrntler this provision is to ensure that a litigation
rvhich is rncaninglcss, and bound to provc
atrortivc. should not be pennitted to waste judicial
tinrc ol'the courI. in the lollowing words : (SCC p.
-i2.1. para l2)
1-r. .. -fhe rvhole purpose of confemrent of
such poners is to cnsure that a litigation which is
meanirrslcss. and bound to prove abortive should
not bc pennitted to occupy the time of the court.
and crercisc' tht' mind of the respondent. The
srvord of' Damocles ncad not be kept hanging
or,cr his head umccessarily without point or
purposc. Even irr an ordinary civil litigation, the
crrurt reatlily exercises thc power to reject a
plaint- il'it does not disclose any cause ofaction."
2 ].5.
Thc powcr oonlerred on the court to
lcrnlinatc a civil aclion is. however, a drastic one.
lr
and the conditions enumerated in Order 7 Rule I I
arc rcquired to be strictll adhered to.'-
l1 ln Hari Shanker,fain vs. Sonia Gandhirr. the Apex C-ourt
hc'ld tliat the cxpression "czluse ol action" has becn compendiously
de tl ned
to meau cverv lact wh ich it wou ld be ncce ssarv lor the
plaintifl'to prove. il traversed, in order to support his right to the
.]ur,lgnrent of Court. Ornissior-r o1- a singlc nratcrial l'act lcads to an
incornplctr' causc of'action and the statenrent of clairn becomes bad.
I-lre lirnction of thc parlv is to pre sent as ltLll a picturc ol the cause ol
irction \vith suclr turther intbn-nation in detail as to make the opposite
party- understand the case he will have to mce1. Mercly quoting the
u'ords o I' the section like chantine of a mantra does not amount to
staLing rnaterial lacts. Material t'acts would include positive statement
o1- lacts as also positive averment of a negative f'act.
if necessary.
I-ailurc to plcad "rnaterial facts" is latal to thc election pctition and no
anrendmcnt o['thc pleadings is permissible to introduce such material
thcts after the time-limit prescribed tbr filing the clection petition. It
is the dutv ol the CoLu-t to examinc the pctition in'espectivc of any
rvlitten staternellt or denial and reject the petition il it does not
''. (:00 t) 8 SCC :i:
l8
disclose a causL- of action. l'o cnable a Court to re.iect a plaint on the
groLrnd that it (ioes nor clisclose a cause of action, it should look at the
plaint and nothing r'lsc. ('ourts have alrvays fiorvned upon vaguc
pleedings u hiih lcar.' a n id.' scope to adcluce any cr idence. \o
anlount o1'c'r'irlencc .a11 cr.ll'e basic dettct in the pleadings
18. It is apt t() rlotc tllat the said .ludgment is in rcspcct o1- an
election petitiou and it is on consideration ol scope and anrbit of
St-'ction - til (I)(a)ol'the Reprr'sentation ol'the People Act. 195 I
19. ln C lrurch of (lhrist Charitable Trust antl F.ducational
Charitable Socictr. rep.b-r' its Chairman v. Ponniamman
Etlucational I-rust. rcp.bl its Chairperson/Managing Trusteers,
q'herein the date ol- Agrcerncrrt of Sale is not mentioned in the plairrt,
considering f:orms 47 and "18 of Appendix 'A' of CPC, the Apcx
Court held that lirilure to r.nention the date violates the stalutor.v
requirerrcrrt and il the datc is one which attracts the bar of lirlitation.
the plaint has to corrfbrnr to Older - VII Rule - 6 and specifically plead
tlre ground upon ri hich exerllprion lronr limitation is claimed. The
Apex Coufl founcl tault u,ith the pleadings of the plaint in the said
r'. teo
1q2 8
scr uoo
l9
casc and hcld that thcre rvas shortt-all in the plaint averments and
statutor)' provisions. nameli,, C)rder - VII Rule - I 1, Rule - 14 (l) and
RLrle - l-1 12), Folrrs 47 and-lti in Appendix A olthc CPC rvhich are
slirttilot\ ln r)atufc
lhe Aper Courl also held that the lcarned Sinelc
.lutlge ol'the I Iigh Court has correctll, concluded that in the absence ol
3n\ causc ot'action sho\\,n as against the flrst delendant therein, the
sr"rit canrrot be plocccded either tbr specitic perfbnnance or tbr the
rL-c()verv o1- rnone]' advanced rvhich according to thc plaintiff was
!.i\ r'n to thc sectrnd clclenclant in thc suit and rightly rc.iectecl thc plaint
a: against the tl rst de l'endant
10. In thc said.judgnrent, relbrring to Order - VII, Rules - I I (a)
arrd ll (d). ttre Apex Courr held that the Courl has to satisff that the
plaint discloses a caLlse of aclion and does not appear to bc barred by
anv lau. 'l'he statutory lbnns require the date of agreetnent to be
nrcntioned to retlect that it does not appear to be bared by lirnitation.
In addition to the san1e. in a suit for specific performance, tl-rere should
be an agrecrnent by the del'endant or by a person duly authorised by a
powel of attorrrcy erecuted iri his f'avour by the owner. It was further
held that in the plaint, the plaintiff has to specifically plead the ground
upon rvhich exenrption fiom lin'ritation is clairned
21.
ln Kamala Kumar r'. Prcmlata Joshir6 the Apex Courl
hcld as lbllos ,
"lt is a scttled principle ol la\v that the grant ol'
relir'l ol' spocilic perlirrrnance is a discrctionarl
and cquitablc rclict,
'l
lrc material questions. \vhich
arc requirctl to be gorre into fbr grant of the relicf
ol ipeci [ic llcrl'rlrrnlrrcc. are:
Iirst. *hcthcr thcrc cxists a ialid and concluded
contract bct\\'ccn the parties tbr sale/purc:hase 0l'
the su it propcrtr,:
Sccond. rrhethcr thc plaintitFhas bcen rcadl and
u,rlling to pcrlbrm his part ol'contract and whethcr
hc is still readl' and uilling to perlonn his part as
nrcnt ioncd in thc contract:
hird. u lrcthcr thc plairrtilf [ras. in tact,
pcrlbrnred his par1 ol'the contract and, il so, horv
I
arrd to nhal extcnt and in rvhat rnanner hc has
pc'rlbnncd and 'rr hcther such perfonnance was in
conlonnit]'$,ith the terms olthc contract.l
lrourth. rlhcthcr it uill be equitable to grant the
relicf o1' specific perfbnnancc to the plaintiff
agains( thc dclendant in relation to suit property
or it will cause anv kind ol hardship to thc
delcndant and. ifso. hou, and in rvhal rnanner and
'0. {20 t91y 3 scc ,o.t
2t
thc extent if such relief is eventuallv sranted to the
plaintiti-: and
Lastli. rvhether the plaintilT is entitlcd for grant
of' anr other altrnativq relicl. nanrcl1,. rclirnd o['
calncst nr()ne) ctc. and, if'so. on rvhat grounds."'
22. [n Bhargavi Constructions vs. Kothakapu Muthyam
Rctldyr', the Apex Court hcld that the term 'law' used in Order - VII,
I{ulc - ll td)o1'('l'C' inclucles not onl1, legislative cnactments but also
iudicial dc'cisions cll' the .\pex Clour-t ir.r view ol' Article - l4l ol thc
( onstitution ot- India
23. Therc is no dispute that Lhe law laid down by thc Apex
Courl is binding on all the Courts including trial Couft and this Court
in tcrnrs ol' Articlc - I 4l of thc Constitution ol India.
l;1. In Mohintlcr Kaur vs. Sant Paul Singhrs, the Apex CoLut
held that rvhere the agreemcnt of sale l-ras been cancelled by Vendor,
thc' parll ltas to scek reliet'ot'declaration of such cancellatiorl, in
addition to seek rclie {'ol- spc-cific perlbrurance of such agreement of
I (]o t8) ki-sr_-c t8o
' rl0l9) e s(t l5s
sale. The said principle u'as also reiterated by thc Apex Court in R.
Kandasamv (since tlead) v. T.lt.K. Saraswathvre.
25. C'orrsiderirrg the pleaclings. in Manickarn v. Vasanthar".
wherein suit $'as filcd lbr specitrc perlbrnrancc ol' agreer.nent ol salc.
the Apex CoLrrt helcl thilt rclief ol-specific pertbrmance of contract is a
discretionarl, r'elief', ancl pleadinqs in a suit tbr specific pertbrrnancc
have to be verw dilect. spccilic and accurate. A suit lbr specitic
perlonnancc bascd on l.ald ancl r agr-re pleadings rnust necessarill' bc
rejected. Section - l(r (c)of the Specitrc Relief'Act requires readiness
and willingness to be pleaded and proved by the plaintifF in a suit for
specific pcrlorurancc ol'contracl and thc sarnc are nrandatory.
26. Rct-erring to thc principle Iaicl down in T. Arivandandam
v. T.V. Satvapalrr arrd other judgrnents in Indian Evangelical
Lutheran Church Trust Association2:. the Apex Couft helcl that the
Court while dealing rvith an application f rled under Ordcr - VlI, Rule -
1l of CPC, has to consider tl.re whole plaint and whole plaint has to
consider the has to be lead, not any particular plca. 1'he avemrents in
''. 1zo2s; : scc : r;
20.
1zo4l1 scc ont-ine sc ll)s6
'z'. 1t9zz; + scc ,loz
2', 2025 SCC Ont-ine SC 4li
l-1
the plaint as a wholc have to be seen to find out whether Clause - (d)
of Rule - t I, Order - VII ol CIPC is applicable. The relevant facts
which need to be iooked into fbr dcciding an application thereunder
are the avennents in the plaint rvhich are germane.--Ihe pleas taken by
the defendant either in the aflldavit tlled in support of an application
tlled under Order - VIl, Rulc - I I of CPC or in the written statement
u'ould be uholly in'elevant at that stage. Under Order - VII, Rule -l I
of CPC, the Court has to take a decision tooking at the pleadings of
the plaintiff'only and not on the rebuttal made by the delendant or any
other matelial produced by the detendant.
i) Refening to the
Limitation Act, 1963, the Apex Court furlher held that Limitation Act
does not confer any substantive right, nor defines any right or cause of
action. The Law of Limitation is based on delay and laches. Unless
there is a completc cause ol action. lirnitation cannot run and there
cannot be a complete cause of action unless tl-rere is a person who can
sue and a person who can be sued.
ii) ln Annamalai (supra), the Apex Court referring to the
principle laid down by it in earlier judgments in A. Kanthamani v.
t,1
Nasreen Ahnrc'd2'r^ l.S. Sikandar
K. Su branrani2a and
Il. Kandasamr' (Supra), consiclercd zts to u'hcn a declaratorl' reliel is
essential. Paragraph Nos.25 to ]2 arc rclevant and thc sattte are
extractcd as urtder:
"\Yhen a dcclaratorl rclief is csscntial
15. When a declaratory' rcliet'is cssentiirt 15. A declaratorr rcliel'
sceks to clcar rvhat is doulrtlirl. and uhich is ncccssurY to nrakt it
clear. Ifthcre is a doubt on thc rir:h( ol'a plaintill.:rnd sith,rLrl the
doubt being cleared no t-urthcr relicl'can bc grantcd, a dcclaratory
relief hecomes essential becaLrse u,ithout such a declaralion the
consequential reliel' nral. not he available to the plaintil'l lSce:
Ananthula Sudhakar r,. P. lluchi Reddl tdcad) b1 L.lt.s and others.
(2008) 4 SCC 594. For exanrple. a doubt as to plaintills title to a
property may arise because olexistence of an instlurncnt relatinq to
that property. If plaintiff is pri\'! to that instrument. Section 3l of
Specific Relief Act. l96i cnatrles him to institutc a sLrit tbr
cancellation ol the instrumcnt \\,hicli ma) bc void or voidahte qua
him. If plaintiff is not privr to the instnunent. hc ntav seek a
declaration that the same is void or does not aff'ect his rights. When
a document is void ab initio. a decree lor setting aside the same is
not necessary as thc samc is non est in the e1,c of larv. beinu a
nullity. 'lherefore, in such a case, if plaintil'f is in possession t,1'thc
property which is subject mattcr of such a void instrunrent. he nrav
seek a declaration that the instrumenr is not binding on him.
However, if he is not in possession, he nray sue lor possession and
the limitation period applicable would be rhar as applicablc under
rr. (2017) 4 scc
'0. 12ol3y t5 scc 27
l5
Article 65 of the [-in.ritation Act. l9(ri on a suit lor possession9.
Rationale ol the aloresaid principlc is that a void instrument
/transaction can bc ignored by a court rvhile granting thc main relief
based on a suhsisting right. tlut. lhclc the plaintifls right falls
under a cloud. thcn a declalation allilnrir.rg the right of the plaintilf
t.ual he necessar\ lor sranl ()l l c()r)scqucntial ielief-- IIowever.
whether such a dcclaration is requirccl lbr the consequential relief
sought is to be assessed on a casc-lo-case basis- dependent on its
facts.
26. A breach of a contract nral bc by nonperlbrmance or by
repudiaticrn. or br both. In.llsrlr'' I.d\t ()/ ('ontruct (29th Oxford
Edn.), under thc heading "Furuts of tsrcach Which Justily
Dischargc". it is stated thrrs:
"The right ol a pan\ t() he tr!'atc(l as discharged from lurther
pertbrnrance nray arise in anr one ol lhrec wa\s: the other party to the
corltract (a) mav rcnoullcc its liabilrtrc' undcr rt. (b) may by its own
conduct make it impossible to tirlllll tlrcnr, (c) may fail to perform
rvhat it has prornised- Of thcse frrrrrs ol'breach. the llrst two may take
place not onlf in the coursc ol'perlirrnrance but also while the contract
is still whollv erecutor) i.c.. bcttrre cither parrv is entitled to demand a
performance bv the other partl of thc ()ther's promise. ln such a case
thc breach is usually tenrred an anticipahrv breach. The last can only
take place at or during thc tirnc tbr pcrli'rnrance of the contract."
27. Ordinarily. for a breach of coDtract, a part1, aggricvcd by the
breach i.e., tailure on the part ol thc other party to perfbrm its part
under the contract can claim compcnsation or darnages by acccpting
the brcach as a termination ol the contract. or/ and, in ccrtain cases,
obtain specific perlbrmance b)' rlr)t rccognizing the breach as
termination of the contract. (See: O['G l)o*er (icneralion Private
Linrited v. Enexio I'ouer' ('rxrlin{r Solutions lndia Pvt. I-td. and
l6
anothcr. (1015) 2 SCC 417. paragraph 106.1. In a case where the
contract bct\\'een the parties conl'crs a right on a party to thc
contract to unilateralll- terminatc th,.' contract in ccrtlil.t
circumstances. and the contract is temrinated exercising that right. a
merc suit lirr specitic performancc' *'itht,trt scckitr" a .leclarali()n
thal such tcrmination rs invalid nlav not bc maintainablc. I'his is ',',
hecausc a doubt /cloud on subsistcnce ol the contlact is crcaled
rvhich needs to be cleared beforc grant of a dccrec cnfirrcing
contractual obligations of tlre parties to thc contract.
18. Norv rle shall consider teu decisions ol'this ( ourt rrhcre lltc
question ol'qrant oI rcliel of specilic pcrlirrrnancc of a c()ntrsct in
tccth ol termination ol the contract r'vithout sceking it declaratiotr
qua subsistence of thc contract was consitlered. In l.S. Sikandar v.
K. Subramani [(2013) t5 SCC 271. llte agrccmcut li,r salc
stipulated sale within a stipulated time lianie: on liilurc ol llre
ptaintifl io respond to the notice seeking execution ol sale. thc
agrcemeul was terminated. In that contexl. this Court hcld:
"16. Since the plaintiff did not perlornr his part o{'corttraot rvithir thc
extended period in the legal notice referred tt, supra- thc agrccnlent ol-
sale was terminated as per noticc dated 28-:l- 1985 and thus. thcre is
termination of the agreement of salc betwcen thc plaintitT and
dclendarrts l4 w.e.f. l0-4 - 1985
17. As could be seen from the prayers sought tbr in thc original suit.
the plaintifT has not sought lor declaratory reliel' trr declare tlrc
terminalion of agreement of sale as bad in larv. [n the ahsence ol such
prayer by the plaintiff the original suit filcd b1.hinr belore the trial
court for grant ofdecree for specilic perfonnancc in respect ol'the suit
scheduled property on the basis of agreemcnt of salc and
conscqucntial relief of decree for pennanent injurrction is nr.rt
maintainable in law. 38. Thereforc, we have to hold that thc relicl'
sought for by the plainliff ior the grant of dccrce fbr spccific
)i
perlbrmance ofexecution ol-sale deed in respect ofthe suit scheduled
property in his f'avor on thc basis ol'non-existing agreenlent of sale is
whollv unsustainable in lau."
29. In A. Kanthamani (sLrpur). tlle Jecision in LS. Sikandar (supra)
was considered. and it \\3\ hcl(l:
"30.i. 'l'hird, it is a well settled principlc of law lhat the plea regarding
the maintainabilitv ol suit is rcquired tti lre raiscd il the first instancc
in the pleading (!\'ritten statcnlent) thcn onlr such plea can be
adjudicated b1'thc trial coun on its mcrits as a prclinrinary issuc under
Order l4 Rule I CPC. Orce tlre lirrding is rendcrc'd on the plca, the
same can be exanrined hv lhc lirst or/ and sccond appcllatc court. It is
only in appropriate cascs. rrhcre the courl prima frrcie finds h1' mere
perusal of plainl allegatirrrrs llrat thc suit is harred by an) e\press
provision of larv or is nor lcgalll nraintainable duc to an) legal
provision; a judicial noticc can bc trken to avoid abtrse oi.iudicial
process in prosecuting such suit. Such is. lx^vevcr. not the case here.
30.4. Fourth, the decision rclicd on b1 the leanred counsel lor the
appellant in l.S. Sikandar lurns on the l'ircts inrolved thcrein and is
thus distinguishable."
30. In R. Kandasamy (since dcad) and others v. T.R.K.
Sarawathy and another [(2025) 3 SC(] 5131, this Court
considered both I.S. Sikandar (supra) and A. Kanthan.rani (supra),
and clarified the law by obscr\ ing as under:
"47. However, we clarily that ary failurc or or,rission on the part of
the trial court to frame an issuc on nraintainabilitl of a suit touching
jurisdictional lact by itself cannot trinr the powcrs ol the highcr court
to examine whcther thc.iurisdictional lact did exist for grant ol relief
as claimed, provided no nc\\ tacts rverc required to be pleaded and no
new evidence led.''
31. From the aforesaid decisions u,hat is clcar is that though a plea
regarding maintainabilit), of the suit. g1,gn il not raised irr urirrcu
lll
statcnlcnt, rnav be raised in appeal, particularly when tro new facts
or cvidencc is required to address the same, thc issuc whether a
tleclarakrrr rclief is essential or not would havc (o hc addressed on
the facts ol each case.
ll. [n our ricrv. a declaratory relief would be r€cluircd wherc a
tloLrbt or a cloud is thcre on the right ol'the plaintill':rnd grant ol'
rclicl to thc plaintiff is dependent on removal of that douht or cloud.
llorvever. uhether there is a doubt or cloud on tlre right of thc
plaintitl'trr seck consequential reliel-, the samc is to bc delernrincd
()n tllc tacls ufcach case'. For exan.rple. a colrtract nrar civr' riuhl to
the parties. or any o[e of thc parties, to terminate thc contract or)
cristence of certain conditions. In terms thcreot. the eontract is
tcrnrinated. a doubt over subsistence ol the contract is created lindthereltrre. rvithout sceking a declaration that termination is bad in
laq'. a decree for spccific performance may not he available.
Ilow'ever. rhere there is no such right conferrcd on an)' part) to
tcnrlinate tlle contract- or the right so conferred is r,'aived. r,et tho
contract is tenninated unilaterally, such termination rnav he takcn as
a breach ol'contract by repudiation and the party aggricved rnal. by
treating the contract as subsisting, sue for speciljc perfrrmrancc
\\'ithout sceking a declaratory relief qua validitl ol' suclr
tcrrnina1ion."
27.
'flre
surn and substance of the principle laid dorvr-r in thc
atbresaid j udgmerrts is that when the agreement olsale is cancelled hr
the vendor, the vendee has to seek declaration and also specillc
perlirrnrancc of agreernent of sale, but not only specilic pcrlbnnance
ol' agreement of sale
l9
28. A declaratory reliel w'ould be required where a doubt or a
cloud is there on the right ol the plaintiff and grant ol relief to the
plaintit'f is dependerrt orr rer.novirl o1'that cloub[ or cloud. Where thcre
is a doubt or cloud on the right of the plaintilT to seek consequential
rclicl. the sarne is to be deternrincd on thc tacts ol-cach case.
i) Where there is no such right conf-erred on any partv to
tclnrinatc the contract, or thc right so conlcrrcd is uaived, )'ct the
contracl is tcrminated unilaterall).', such tcrmination rna-y'' bc taken as a
breach ol contract by repudiation arrcl tlrc party aggrieved nray, by
treating the contract as subsisting, suc [br specific perfomance
without seeking a declaratory r'eliel4rrrr validity ol-such temrination.
29. White considering the application filed under Order VII
Rule li (d) of the CPC to rcject the plaint, the trial Court lras to
consider pleadings of the plaint and documents liled along with the
plaint nothing more. The trial Court cannot consider pleadings in the
altidavit filed in support of a petition filed under Ordcr VII Rule I I
(c) ol CPC and pleadings in rvritten staternent and documents filed by
the dcfbndants.
t0
10. In thc light olthe aforesaid principte, coming to tlrc t'acts ol'
the prcscnt case. ihe vendor i.e. Smt. Mekala Subhashini. u ile and
motht'r rcspecti!cly of thc det'endants entered into an agrc.-nrent ol'
salc datr'cl 08.l0.l0ltt uith Mohd. Abdul Azeeni, husbancl anrl lathc'r
respecti\ clv o1' thc plaintitls on thc specil'ic telms and conclitions
mentionccl therein. The total sale consideration aqrecd
\l its
Rs. I.()0.(X).000/- and hc has paid an amount of Rs.50.00.000, tort'ards
advancc sale consideration. Ile agreed to pay the balancc arrount
within three monlhs lrorn the date of agreement of sale. 'fhc said threc
months period w'as expired on 07.01.2019.
-l
l. In thc present case, the important aspect is that Srnt
Mckala SLrbhashani rnortgaged the suit schedule property with l)eccan
Housing Finance Corpot'ation Limited Ameerpet brancl-r hr rvay o1'
erccution ol'a registered lnortgagc deed bearing document No.3 165 ol
20 17. dated 05.07.2017. The said fact was not mentioned in the
agrecnrent oi sale datcd 08. I 0.2018. On the other hand, in clar.rsc No.-S
o1'thc agreernt-nt of sale, she has declared and indemr-rified the vendcc
that suit sclredule propefty is free tiom allencumbrances such as sales.
gilis. nrortgagcs, Iiens and courl attachments etc., whicli is lirctuallr
incon'ect. Prior to the said agreement of sale itsell, thc vendor has
I
t
II
mortgaged the subject propefty rvith Deccan Housing Finance
Corporation Lirnited. Ameerpet branch. Thus, there is suppression of
tlre said fact h1, the r cndor in the agrccmcnt o1- salc datcd 08. 10.10 l8
i2 It is also not in dispute that r.'endor died on 29.10.:0 l9
'[-herc'after,
legal heirs of the vendor i.e. the delendants hercin cleared
the said loan, released the said rrortgage by rvay of execution of a
relcase deed, releascd mortgage rights or re-conve)'ance dced bearing
docunrent No..i202 ol 1024 dated 21.0(r.202.{. lhercaflcr. they harc
issuecl legal notice dated 30.06.2025. It is the specilic contention ol
the plaintilfs hcrein that the vendee during his liGtime approached the
vcndor with a request to receive the balance sale considerate and
exccute registered sale deed in his i-avour. He has also expressed his
readiness and willingness to pay the balance sale consideration and
obtairr registered sale deed. It is the vendor wl-ro postponed the same
on onc pretext or the other.
.l3. It is also the specific contention ol' thc plaintills that alter
the death of tl.re vendee, the plaintiff No. I approached the defendant
No.l along with the brother of the plaintifl'No.l Mr.Mohammad
Mohiuddin Abkhan requested the defendant No.l for execution of
ll
re gistercd
salc decd and defendant No.l inlormed that therc \\ S
I'I
nrortqage or el tlrc' schcdr-rle propenv and he rvill execute after releasc
ol the mortlLauc l'herc u,erc spc'citic assefiions in paragraph Nos.2 to
6 olthe plaint
-.i-1.
In paraglaph No.t3 ol thc plaint. there is specilic nrention
that thr'rlcfflrclrrnls crcalcd rnortgaqe ovel thc suit schedtrle pl'opcrtv t(r
I!1i s DHi C L, rnd thc1, pronrised to release the mortgage and cxccute
salc dc'ed in thr our ol'the plaintilfi and recently after rcceiving legal
notice. plainti ll.s obtained encumbrance certificate dated 06.08.2014
and canrc to knou, that the delbndants cleared the mortgage ()lt
21.06.?021 and got issued temtination notice dated 30.07.2024
fhercallci'. tlrerc w'as exchangc ot'noticcs and reply notices bet"veen
thern.
-lhus, they lrave t]led the said suil on 19.06.2025
seeking
cleclalation aml also spccitrc pertbnnance ol- agreement of sale, datccl
08.10.10 18 ii,ell rvithin limitation i.e. three years from the date o1i ssuarrce
-.j
o t- tenl ination notice dated 3 0.07 .2024.
As cliscussed supra, it is not in dispute that legal heirs ol'
vendor cleared thc rrortgage on 21.06.2024. Thereafter, instead ol
rL'cluestinr-l the plaintillt. to pa1, the balance sale consideration ancl
)_)
obtain registered sale deed, they have issued legal notice dated
30.01 .2024 terminatinq the aqreement of sale dated 08. 1 0.20 1 8. There
is no cxplanation hrrn thc c[t-endants rvith regard to suppression ol'
reqistcred rllorlgage dced bcaring document No.3 165 ol 2017 dated
05.07.1017 executed bv the vendor, in favour of M/s DFIFCL. tbr
obtaining loan for Mis MRR Bar and Restaurant represented by Mr
Nlcktla Ram Reddy, dct'endant No.l, husband of the vendor
i6. As discussed supra, in the present case, once therc is
cancellation ol- agreenrent ot'sale, necessarily the plaintilt's have to
seck only declaration and the1, cannot seck specific perfomrance o1'the
agrcenlent of sale dated 08.10.2018. The said principle was also laid
dori n by the Apex Court in the aforesaid judgments. Thus, the
plaintitf tiled the said suit sceking to declare the tennination noticc
datcd 10.07.2024 as illegal and :rlso for specific perfolrnancc o1-thc
a!.r.cnrent of sale dated 08.10.2018. There is no error in it. It is not an
illusori'pleading and the plaint is not cleverly drafted plaint as alleged
by the defendants.
37. It is also not in dispute that the vendee, the husband and
t-ather ol the plaintil'ls, was tenant of the suit schedule propefty.
l1
l'herefore. the dcl-endants issued quit notice dated 24.0 1.2025 under
Section 106 ol- the
.[
P .\ct
-l'here
is no dispute with regard to legal
position that posscssion of'the suit schcdulc- propefiv cannot extend
limitation to tl lc- u sr.rit lirl sIccific perlbrurance of agrecment sale. But
in thc prescnt case, thc lrcts are different. Vendor, the wife and
rlrother ol the dclendanls suppressL'd about the registered mortgage
deed in thc agrecnrent ol'sale dated 08.10.10 I 8. l" detbndant. husband
o1'the vcnclor. obtained loan ll'om ivl/s DHFCL, by way of execution
ol'registered ll-lo(gage cleed in respect of suit schedule property prior
to the su['r.iect irgrecmcnt of sale and thev havc cleared the said
mortgase blr ri,av ol- crecuting a rcgistered release deed only on
2l .06.1014.
18. 'fhus. it is the speci{ic case of the plaintills herein that the
de'tcndants, Iesal hcirs ol the r.eudors specifically stated with them
that thev will clear the loar-r, release the mortgage and then execute
rcgistercd salc de-cd irr their l'avour. There are specitic pleadings to the
said eilcct in the plaint right fi'onr paragraph Nos.2 to 10. Even the
plaintitii havc spc'cificallr lnentioned about the lintitation and cause
ol action in the plaint. .fherefbre. the trial Court has to consider the
contents of thc plaint and clocr,rnrents filed along ivith the plaint. '[rial
Court cannot consider anything beyond the same while deciding an
application unclcr Older Vtl Rule ll(d) of CPC. The said principle
rt as also laid down bl the Aper Court in the. judgments cited siqrra
lnstcad of considerir-rg tlre saicl aspects. vide impugned order dated
I 1.0q.1025. lcarned n'ial Court en'oncously held that the vendee, thc
husband ancl t'ather ol' thc plaintitfs did not approach the vendor
clulin-r her lifitime or alier her death, her husband and children
(dctindants) \\ith a request to receive the balance sale oonsideration
and crecute registcred sale deed, he did not even issued legal noticc
r.r'ithin thrce nronths demanding the specific performance or return thc
advancc sale consideration. The trial Court also erred in giving finding
r.vith regard to l.rossessir-l.r of the subject property by the plaintift'. It is
apt to note that the plaintifl.s never sought extension of limitation
basing on posscssion.
i9. It is tlieir spccific case that the vendor suppressed about the
legistcred r.nortgage of the subject propefty with M/s DHFCL. The
vendee during his lifbtime requested the defendants and after her death
to reccive thc balance sale consideration and execute a registered sale
t6
decd. in his favour. L-}'en afle'r thc death ol thc vendee, the plaintiffs
approached 1'' clet'endant, hLrsband ol- the vendor, u'ith a request to
reccivc brlancc'sale consideration arrd exccr.lte registercd sale deed.
'l'he1' har.' ir-r lirrrned that therc is urortgagc oV'er the suit schcdule
propert). thcy irill clear the sanre and cxecutcd register salc in f'avour
ol the plaintills. 'l'hc trial Court rnissed the said aspects in the
ir.npugned older clatcd I 1.09.1025. [hc trial Court also missed thc lact
that there is supprcssion o1'the said legistered mongage of the suit
schedule propcrt), b1' the r,'endol in thc agrcement of sale dated
08. r0.20 r8
40. As discr.rsscd supla. the said aspccts are triable issues. 'I'he
trial Court cannot considcr the said aspccts while decidir-rg a petition
under Ordcr VII Rule tl of- CIP('. I'he detendants have to take the
pleadings in thc $ ritten statemcrlt. also during trial and it is lor the
trial Clourt to consider the said aspccts. 'l'hcrefbre, the impugned order
dated I1.09.1025 is not on considcration of the said aspects and also
principle laicl dorvn bv thc Apex Coult in the aforesaid judgrnents. lt is
liable to be set aside.
t7
4l . ln the light ol'the atbrcsaid discussion, this Appeal Suit is
alloq'ed. Thc ordcl tlatecl 1109.2025 in I.A.No.527 ol 2025 rl
O.S.No.l5ti ol l0li l,lsscd b) the III Additional District Judge,
llanga Rcddl District. et L .B.Nrsar, is set aside. LA.No.527 of 2015
is disurissed. I lou'er cr'. thc- trial Couft shall decide O.S.No.258 o1'
1025 strictll, in accolclunce rvith larv, considering the evidence both
oral and docunrentalv s ithour being influenced by any of the findings
in the pre scnt ordcr. l.ibe(,r, is sranted to both the plaintiffs and
del-endants to take all thc c ontentions/grounds which they have taken
in the present appeal, in thc suit and it is lor the trial Court to consider
I
the same.
Conscquently. nr iscellaneous petitions, if any, pending ir-r this
appcal shall stand closcd
Sd/- K.SRINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGISTRAR
,TRUE COPY'
To,
G
SECTION OFFICER
. The lll Additional DiStrict Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B. Nagar. ( with
records )
2. One CC to SRl. M. LAXMAN RAO, Advocate [OPUC]
5 on" cCtJsRl. P. ATMARENDER REDDY, Advocate [oPUC]
4. Two CD Copies
kul/ba
Yx
\
HIGH COURT
DATED:08/01/2026
t
.{ HT. SIA
I
't)l:Cl{t:l:
JUDGMENT
APPEAL SUIT No.543 ot 2025
ALLOWING THE APPEAL SUTT
WITHOTJ]'COSTS
Ge"
9toa
(. )
U
2 B JAil 2U6
*
:1)
;--t.:5"-)-i
L
*
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY,THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
APPEAL SUIT NO: 543 OF 2025
Between:
1. Mrs. Thaslima Azeem, W/o. Late Abdul Azeem, Age. 48 yrs., Occ. Housewife,
Rl/o. 11-18-235/1 , Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad, Telangana State.
2. Mohammed Tabreez Azeem, S/o. Late Abdul Azeem, Age. 29 yrs., Occ.
Business, Rl/o. 1 1-18-235i 1 , Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad, Telangana State.
3. Tabassum Azeem, C/o. Mohammed lrfan Ali, Age. 23 yrs., Occ. Housewife
PJo. 17-8-533177, Bagh-E-Jahanara, Charminar, Hyderabad.
4. Tanwer Azeem, C/o. Syed lsmail, Age. 22yrs., Occ. Student
5. Tayyaba Azeem, D/o. Mohammed Abdul Azeem, Age. 21 yrs., Occ. Student,
R/o. 11-18-235/'1 , Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No.5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad.
6. Ayeesha Siddique, D/o. Lage Mohammed Abdul Azeem, Age. 19 yrs., Occ.
Student, R/o. 'l 'l-18-235/'1, Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad.
7. Abdul Maqeeth Quadri, D/o. Mohammed Abdul Azeem, Age. 14 yrs., Occ.
Student, R/o. 1'1-18-235/1, Bhagat Singh Colony, Road No. 5, Saroor Nagar,
Hyderabad. Rep. by Smt. Thaslima Azeem,
...APPELLANTS/ Plaintiffs
AND
1. Sri Mekala Ram Reddy, S/o. Penta Reddy, Age. 60 yrs., Occ. Business, Rt/o.
Plot No. 2218, Green Hills Colony, L.B. Nagar, Rangareddy District.
2. Smt. K. Madhavi, D/o. M. Ram Reddy, Age. 45 yrs., Occ. Software
Professional, Rl/o. Plot No.2218, Green Hills Colony, L.B. Nagar, Rangareddy
District.
3. Smt. Vittal Reddy Gari Archana, D/o. M. Ram Reddy, Age. 44 yrs., Occ.
Software Professional, R/o. Plot No.22lB, Green Hills Colony, L.B. Nagar,
...RESPONDENTS/ Defendants
Rangareddy District.
Appeal Under Section 96 RArv. Order 41 Rule 1 of CPC aggrieved by the
Order dated 11-09-2025 in l.A.No. 527 ot 2025 in O.S.No. 258 of 2025 on the file
of the Court of the lll Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy District at
L.B.Nagar.
The appeal coming on for hearing, upon perusing the
Memorandum of grounds filed in the Appeal, the Judgment and
I
Decree of the Lower Court and the record in the case and upon
hearing the arguments of
Sri M. Laxman Rao, Advocate for the
Appellants and Sri P. Amarender Reddy, Advocate for Respondents.
This Court doth order and decree as follows:
1. That the Appeal Suit be and hereby is allowed
2. That the Order dated 1'l -09-2025 in l.A.No. 527 ot 2025 in O.S.No. 258 of
2025 passed by the lll Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy District at
L.B.Nagar be and hereby is set aside.
3. That l.A.No. 527 ot 2025 is dismissed. The trial Court shall decide
O.S.no. 258 ot 2025 strictly in accordance with law, considering the
evidence both oral and documentary without being influenced by any of
the findings in the present order.
4. That Liberty is granted to both the plaintiffs and defendants to take all
the contentions/ grounds which they have taken in the present appeal,
in the suit and it is for the trial Court to consider the same.
Sd/. K.SRINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGISTRAR
/iTRUE COPY//
G
SECTION OFFICER
To
'1. The lll Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar.
2. Two C.D.Copies
kul
\qr
HIGH COURT
KLJ & VRKRJ
DATED:08/01/2026
DT,CRET,
APPEAL SUIT No.5a3 of 2025
AT,LOWING'I'H T] APPF],AI, STJ IT
WITHOTiT C'OSTS
.d\c\)-\
K'w
e-}>
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review