Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
AB No.62 of 2025
1.Mrs Rosamma Sabu
W/o- Sri Sabu Mathew, resident of Sreekanda- Mangalam, Kottayam
District, Kerala, 686562, presently residing at Banikya Chowmuhani,
Khayerpur, P.S- Bodhjungnagar, District- West Tripura.
2.Sri Sabu Mathew
S/o- Matheu Pulinkalayil, resident of Sreekanda- Mangalam, Kottayam
District, Kerala, 686562, presently residing at Banikya Chowmuhani,
Khayerpur, P.S- Bodhjungnagar, District- West Tripura.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura represented by Ld. P.P, High Court of Tripura,
Agartala.
….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Arindam Bhattacharjee,Advocate.
Mr. B.K.Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R.Saha, Addl.PP.
Date of hearing
:
12.01.2026
Date of Pronouncement/
delivery of Judgment /
Order
:
30.01.2026
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
No
=B=E=F=O=R=E=
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Heard Ld. Counsel of both sides.
[2]
This application for pre-arrest bail under Section 482 of Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (earlier Section 438 Cr.P.C) is submitted
by the petitioners (husband and wife) in connection with Bodhjungnagar
-2-
P.S. Case No.2023 BJN 034 registered under Sections 420, 468, 471 and
120(B) of the Indian Penal Code (for short, ‘IPC’).
[3]
The FIR was lodged by the authorized signatory of an
organization, namely, R1 International (India) Pvt. Ltd. on 28.03.2023,
alleging, inter alia, that their company had entered into an agreement with
another organization, namely, ‘Rose Rubber’, of which the present
petitioners are the proprietor, for purchase of natural rubber for supply to
its own customers. As per their agreement, from the side of R1
International (India), they made payment of a total sum of Rs.93,29,252/against their invoices and same are reflected in the FIR in the following
manner:
Invoice No. No. RR/22-23/18 paid Rs.34,16,236 (Net of
TDS Rs.3619, Incidental chg. Rs.100) [Exhibit-X(a)]
Invoice No. No. RR/22-23/19 paid Rs.34,16,236 (Net of
TDS Rs.3619, Incidental chg.Rs.100) [Exhibit- X (a)]
Invoice No. No. RR/22-23/20 paid Rs.24,96,780 (Net of
TDS Rs.2645, Incidental chg.Rs.100) [Exhibit- X (b)]
[4]
It is also alleged that the petitioners provided to R1 International
(India) all the documents such as Invoice, Lorry Receipt issued by the
transporter, namely Fortigo Transport Agency Pvt. Ltd., Weight slip etc.
along with photographs of the vehicle loaded with those items to give the
impression that the goods were dispatched by the petitioners. But,
ultimately, it was detected by the informant that all those documents were
manipulated and fake; created for the purpose of deceiving them and
actually, no goods were supplied to them though the petitioners received
the above said amount from R1 International (India) Pvt. Ltd. and even the
accused persons have also raised a further bill of Rs.27,77,250/- on
09.01.2023. It is further alleged that even during the said process, said
Fortigo Transport Agency was also delivering them the tracking report via
WhatsApp
on
regular
basis
regarding
the
movement
of
those
consignments. But ultimately, when the truck did not reach the destination
i.e. TVS, Rudrapur within the normal time, the informant, then, inquired
-3-
with the transporter and on 14.01.2023, they detected some foul play going
on in connivance between said Rose Rubber and Fortigo Transport
Agency and ultimately, on 16.01.2023, the Fortigo Transport Agency
admitted such manipulation and revealed that the materials/consignment
were not at all moved and all the dispatched documents and photographs
were fake. They also stated that the materials loaded on 09.01.2023 for
Ralson India, Ludhiana was also unloaded, thereafter. On consultation with
the petitioner Mr. Sabu Mathew, he also admitted said fact.
[5]
According to the informant, after continuous follow-up, the 1st load
of rubber to the consignee TVS, Rudrapur was dispatched on 21.01.2023
and was delivered at the destination on 28.01.2023. But,
2nd
and
3rd
loads addressed to TVS, Rudrapur and Ralson India, Ludhiana were never
dispatched despite the fact that already payment had been received by the
petitioners. Thereafter, representatives of R1 International (India) visited
Agartala, on 31.01.2023, discussed the matter with the petitioners wherein
they assured that the remaining pending loads of rubber would be
dispatched on 06.02.2023 and 15.02.2023. Discussion was also minuted
on paper. But, despite several persuasions, nothing was dispatched by the
petitioners and therefore, the FIR was lodged.
[6]
Learned counsel, Mr. A. Bhattacharjee appearing for the
applicants/petitioners submits that after the FIR was lodged there was a
verbal agreement between the parties that the outstanding amount of
Rs.46,36,165/- (Rupees forty six lakh thirty six thousand one hundred and
sixty five) would be paid in 9 (nine) installments. Accordingly, the
petitioners also paid a total of Rs.2,00,000/- [Rupees two lakh] in 3(three)
installments. Even earlier thereto, out of three consignments to be
delivered to the informant company, one consignment was already
delivered and therefore, there was no mens rea of cheating on the part of
the petitioners to deceive the informant-company on any occasion and
thus, the criminal proceeding does not lie against them.
[7]
Learned counsel, Mr. Bhattacharjee also submits that the FIR
itself will manifest that it was a contract between the parties centering
round which the dispute has arisen and due to financial crisis, the
petitioners could not refund the entire amount though they issued two
-4-
undated cheques of Rs.34,16,235/- (Rupees thirty four lakh sixteen thous
two hundred and thirty five) only and Rs.24,96,780/- (Rupees twenty four
lakh ninety six thousand seven hundred and eighty) only to the informantcompany which was also communicated to them vide communication
dated 10.02.2023 [Annexure-7 to the bail application].
[8]
Therefore, according to Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel, even
by encashing those cheques, they can realize their outstanding amount.
Learned counsel also in this regard relies on a decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Rikab Birani & Anr. vs. State of Uttar
Pradesh & Anr., SLP (Crl.) No.8592 of 2024, decided on 16.04.2025
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court made the reference to another
decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Kunti & Anr. vs. State of UP
& Anr., (2023) 6 SCC 109, wherein, it was observed that a breach of
contract does not give rise to criminal prosecution for cheating, unless
fraudulent or dishonest intention is shown right at the beginning of the
transaction. Merely the allegation of failure to keep a promise will not be
enough to initiate criminal proceedings.
[9]
Learned counsel, Mr. Bhattacharjee also submits that on three
occasions the I.O. issued notice under Section 41(A) of Cr.PC to both the
accused-petitioners but during the period of issuance of first notice, the
petitioner, Sabu Mathew was ill and was hospitalized for which the
petitioners could not appear before him and accordingly, they informed the
matter to I.O. On second occasion, when the notice was issued again by
the I.O., at that time both the petitioners were at their hometown in Kerala.
Therefore, they could not appear and when third notice was issued to them
immediately thereafter, they filed the instant application for pre-arrest bail
apprehending that for the purpose of causing their arrest, such notices
were issued to them.
[10]
Learned counsel, Mr. Bhattacharjee, also submits that it is
true that once all the three consignments were loaded in the vehicle
through the transporter for the purpose of giving delivery to the victim
consignee, but meanwhile, due to sudden fluctuation of the rate towards
higher side of the rubber in the
market, it was not possible for the
accused-petitioners to maintain the contractual rate and therefore, with an
-5-
intention to return those items to the original suppliers from whom they had
procured such items, they unloaded the same from the vehicle. However,
learned counsel also fairly submits that in this regard explaining such
situation, no further communication was made by the accused-petitioners
to the informant-company.
[11]
Learned counsel, Mr. Bhattacharjee further contends that
the on-going transaction between the parties though may be of smaller
amount itself indicates that the accused-petitioners had/have no criminal
mens rea since inception to cheat the informant-company, and therefore,
no purpose will be served by taking them into custody by the I.O.
[12]
Finally, learned counsel Mr. Bhattacharjee submits that both
the petitioners are married couple having three school-going minor children
and therefore, their detention will create serious inconvenience and
harassment to those children.
[13]
Learned Addl. P.P., Mr. Rajib Saha, however, seriously
opposes the prayer for bail of the accused-petitioners and submits that 5
times notices were issued to the petitioners, but none of them appeared to
explain the situation and such conduct of the petitioners itself indicates that
there was criminal intention of the petitioners of cheating. Further, learned
Addl. P.P. submits that the vehicle registration numbers as reflected in the
Consignment Note (CN), issued by the transporter, do not match with the
vehicle registration numbers as reflected in the photographs which were
sent by the present petitioners to the informant.
[14]
Learned Addl. P.P. further submits that after registration of
the FIR, more than two and half years have elapsed but a very paltry sum
of amount has been returned by the accused-petitioners to the informantcompany and moreover, due to their non-cooperation, the investigation is
also not progressing further.
[15]
Learned Addl. P.P. also contends that if at all, according to
the accused petitioners, the case is of civil nature, they could very well
appear before the I.O. to cooperate with the investigation. Therefore, from
-6-
the above conduct of the accused-petitioners, it is easily discernible that
they have had their intention of cheating since very inception.
[16]
Learned Addl. P.P. referring to the C.D. submits that after
the registration of the FIR, only Rs.3,00,000/- (Rupees three lakh) only was
paid in 5 (five) installments, whereas as per their verbal settlement, it was
agreed that by 9 (nine) installments they would refund the whole amount
and now, only 4 (four) installments are remaining further for them to cover
up the whole dues and their conduct indicates that they are not at all willing
to make the payment.
[17]
Learned Addl. P.P. also submits that two security cheques
were issued by the accused-petitioners to the informant-company but
sufficient fund was not there in the account of the accused-petitioners to
honour the cheques.
[18]
This Court has considered the submissions of both sides
and has also gone through the relevant materials placed in the Case Diary.
[19]
According to this Court, prima facie, this case cannot be
treated as a case of simple breach of contract falling within the ambit of
Civil Court’s jurisdiction. The reason behind such observation is that if for
any bona fide reason the petitioner(s) had failed to deliver the items to the
R1 International (India), certainly, immediately after failing to do so, they
would inform the matter to the informant side, but they did not do so.
Rather, without dispatch of any items, they raised their bills, seeking
payment and also issued tax invoices. They also communicated the receipt
of Weighbridge, consignment note and photographs of vehicle along with
loaded rubber sheets therein. Even through WhartsApp, the tracking report
was also being sent by Fortigo Transport Agency Pvt. Ltd. to show that the
vehicle has crossed Kumarghat, Pecharthal, Karimganj etc. Prima facie, it
appears that all these things were sent to the informant company to give a
false show that they had discharged their obligation of dispatching those
rubber. Such conduct, prima facie, manifests the existence of criminal
mens rea of cheating since inception when they omitted to dispatch and
deliver those items to R1 International (India). Despite receiving huge
-7-
amount of money of Rs. 93,29,252/-, they did not even return the same or
any considerable part thereof, rather, grabbed the same.
[20]
The CD also shows that at least 5 times notices were
issued under Section 41(A) of Cr.P.C to the petitioners to appear before
the Investigating Officer, but, only once they gave reply to the I.O that the
mother of Rosamma Sabu was ill and therefore, they sought 30 days’ time
to appear and after giving such reply, they never appeared before the I.O.
Thus, it appears that they are also not cooperating with the I.O. The
explanation, as offered by the Ld. Counsel Mr. Bhattacharjee regarding the
appearance of these accused persons before the I.O., is not supported by
any material and is not convincing. Though, after the happening of such
incidents, they agreed with the R1 International to dispatch goods by
15.02.2023, but, again they failed to comply their own assurance and they
only delivered one load of such rubber to TVS, Rudrapur on 28.01.2023.
Even after delivery of said consignment, when Rs.47,36,165/- was due
from the petitioners to said R1 International Pvt. Ltd, it was also agreed by
the petitioners that the balance amount would be cleared up in 9
installments, but, it appears that during the period from 04.09.2023 till
06.01.2026, they only refunded Rs.3,00,000/- in 5 installments.
[21]
Though Ld. Counsel Mr. Bhattacharjee, submitted that two
cheques of Rs.34,16,235/- and Rs. 24,96,780/- were already lying with the
R1 International issued by the petitioners from which the informant can get
their money back by encashing those cheques, but Ld. Addl. PP submitted
that no amount was found lying in the bank account of the petitioners. On
asking by the Court, no satisfactory reply could also be given from the side
of the petitioner as to whether sufficient funds are available in the said
bank account or not. Therefore, as already discussed above, there are
prima facie materials to infer the existence of criminal mens rea of cheating
and fraudulent activities on the part of the petitioners since the inception.
Thus the submissions made on their behalf, do not impress much to grant
pre- arrest bail in their favour.
[22]
The very purpose of granting of pre-arrest bail is to save
innocent persons from undue harassment towards them by falsely
-8-
implicating them in criminal proceedings. For the reasons discussed
above, the case of the petitioners does not fall within said category.
[23]
Considering all these aspects, the prayer for pre-arrest bail
of both the petitioners is rejected.
Interim protection granted earlier to the applicants stands
cancelled.
The matter is accordingly disposed of.
[24]
Return the CD to Ld. Addl. PP with copy of this order.
JUDGE
SUKHENDU
BIKASH DEBROY
SUKHENDU BIKASH DEBROY
Date: 2026.01.30 18:33:09
+05'30'
Saikat Sarma
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review