Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extra-Ordinary Jurisdiction)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. MUHAMED MUSTAQUE, CHIEF JUSTICE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) 10 of 2023
Mrs. Bimla Devi,
Wife of Mr. Ramesh Chandra,
Resident of Chandmari, Gangtok,
East Sikkim-737101.
...
Petitioner
Versus
1.
The Chief Commissioner of CGST & CX,
Kolkata Zone, GST Bhawan, 2nd Floor, 180 Shantipally,
Rajdanga Main Road, Kolkata - 700107.
2.
The Commissioner of CGST & CX,
GST Bhawan, Haren Mukherjee Road, Hakimpara,
Siliguri- 734001.
3.
The Assistant Commissioner of CGST & CX,
Gangtok Division,
Sikkim-737101.
...
Respondents
---------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Ms. K.D. Bhutia, Ms. Subaksha Pradhan and Mr. Lhandup Dorjee
Lepcha, Advocates for the Petitioner.
Ms. Sangita Pradhan, Deputy Solicitor General of India with Ms.
Natasha Pradhan, Ms. Sittal Balmiki and Mr. Amit Kumar Sharma,
Advocates for the Respondents.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing
: 08.04.2026
Date of Judgment
: 08.04.2026
Date on which uploaded : 13.04.2026
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(Hon’ble Mr. Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque, C.J.)
The Petitioner, Mrs. Bimla Devi, worked on a voucher payment
basis as a Safai Karmachari since July, 1984. She worked as a Safai
Karamchari at the office of the Assistant Commissioner of CGST &
WP(C)/10/2023
(Mrs. Bimla Devi Vs. The Chief Commissioner of CGST and CX and 2 others)
CX, Gangtok Division, Sikkim (Respondent No.03). Her engagement
came to an end in May, 2023 (as submitted by the learned Counsel
for the Petitioner). She has approached this Court by way of the
present writ petition seeking the following reliefs:“(i) a writ, order or direction in nature of mandamus
directing the respondents to regularize the service of
the petitioner who has completed more than 36
years of service with retrospective effect.
(ii) A writ or order or direction or declaration that the
petitioner is entitled for regularization of her service
with retrospective effect i.e. 1994 under the scheme
of “Grant of Temporary Status and Regularization
Scheme of Government of India, 1993” with all
consequential benefits.
(iii) A Writ or order or direction or declaration that
the
claim
of
the
petitioner
for
appointment/regularization of service shall be duly
considered with effect from the year 1997 and shall
be given respective ranks and service benefits on her
appointment and/or her services may be regularized
with effect from the respective date when she had
initially joined in service as full time farash cum
safaiwala with effect from 01.09.1994 when other
employees similarly circumstanced with her were
regularized and/or from a reasonable date;
(iv) To grant all the consequential reliefs for which
the petitioner is entitled for.
(v) A writ or order or direction or declaration that
the seniority of the petitioner in the respective posts
and ranks in the regular establishment shall be
maintained by the respondents.
(vi) Cost of the proceedings;
(vii) Any other writ or order or direction or
declaration as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and
proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.”
2.
In the counter-affidavit filed by the Respondents, it is stated
that the Petitioner was engaged w.e.f. 01.09.1994; however, there
is no specific denial of the claim made by the Petitioner in the writ
petition that she had been engaged from 1984 onwards, except for
the contention that her claim of having worked since 1984 is not
supported by any document.
3.
The Petitioner claims that she ought to have been regularized
in light of the Scheme introduced by the Central Government in the
year 1993. The Scheme is called the Casual Labourers (Grant of
WP(C)/10/2023
(Mrs. Bimla Devi Vs. The Chief Commissioner of CGST and CX and 2 others)
Temporary Status and Regularization) Scheme of Government of
India, 1993.
4.
The
question
is
whether
the
Petitioner
is
entitled
to
regularization in light of the aforesaid Government Scheme. As seen
from the Scheme as well as from the counter-affidavit, temporary
status or regularization was granted as a one-time measure under
the Scheme, 1993, only to those persons who were engaged prior to
1992 and had worked continuously for at least one year. It is an
admitted fact that the Petitioner was engaged as a full-time
Safaiwala from 01.09.1994 on a “no work no pay” basis (on voucher
payment basis) in the Gangtok Range Office. It is also admitted that
prior to being engaged as a full-time Safaiwala, she was engaged
only as a part-time Safaiwala (04 hours a day). It is not discernible
from the records produced that whether the Petitioner had worked
prior to 1992 continuously for at least one year. However, the
Petitioner made another claim based on a judgment of the Apex
Court in Narendra Kumar Tiwari and others v. State of
Jharkhand and others1.
5.
It is further stated in the counter-affidavit that the Petitioner
had never applied for regularization in light of the Apex Court’s
judgment in Narendra Kumar Tiwari case (supra). It is to be noted in
Narendra Kumar Tiwari case (supra) at paragraph 6, the Apex Court
has laid down the law as follows:-
“6. ....................
11. The object behind the said direction in para
53 of Umadevi (3) is twofold. First is to ensure
that those who have put in more than ten
years of continuous service without the
protection of any interim orders of courts or
tribunals, before the date of decision in
Umadevi (3) was rendered, are considered for
regularisation in view of their long service.
Second
is
to
ensure
that
the
departments/instrumentalities
do
not
perpetuate the practice of employing persons
(2018) 8 SCC 238.
WP(C)/10/2023
(Mrs. Bimla Devi Vs. The Chief Commissioner of CGST and CX and 2 others)
on daily-wage/ad hoc/casual basis for long
periods and then periodically regularise them
on the ground that they have served for more
than ten years, thereby defeating the
constitutional or statutory provisions relating to
recruitment and appointment. The true effect
of the direction is that all persons who have
worked for more than ten years as on 10-42006 [the date of decision in Umadevi (3)]
without the protection of any interim order of
any court or tribunal, in vacant posts,
possessing the requisite qualification, are
entitled to be considered for regularisation. The
fact that the employer has not undertaken such
exercise of regularization within six months of
the decision in Umadevi (3) or that such
exercise was undertaken only in regard to a
limited few, will not disentitle such employees,
the right to be considered for regularization in
terms of the above directions in Umadevi (3)
as a one-time measure.
......................................”
6.
The law is clear in this regard. An employer, particularly the
State, cannot exploit labour by denying benefits to which they are
entitled otherwise. When law is declared by the Apex Court, it is the
responsibility of the employer to ensure that such directions are duly
complied with.
7.
The Petitioner belongs to poor strata of society and also
belongs to a Scheduled Caste (SC) community. It cannot be
expected from a lady, like the Petitioner, to take up the matter
through legal means. Lack of knowledge and lack of access are
impediments for such members of society. Apex Court in fact
following the judgment in Secretary, State of Karnataka And
Others v. Umadevi(3) And Others2, ordered regularization of
such employees that means the Petitioner is also entitled for the
benefits of the judgment. It is to be noted that in Umadevi(3) case
(supra), the Apex Court has laid down the law as follows:“........................
53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There
may be cases where irregular appointments
(not illegal appointments) as explained in
S.V.
Narayanappa
(supra),
R.
N.
Nanjundappa (supra), and B. N. Nagrajan
(supra) and referred to in paragraph 15
above, of duly qualified persons in duly
(2006) 4 SCC 1.
WP(C)/10/2023
(Mrs. Bimla Devi Vs. The Chief Commissioner of CGST and CX and 2 others)
sanctioned vacant posts might have been
made and the employees have continued to
work for ten years or more but without the
intervention of orders of courts or of
tribunals. The question of regularization of
the services of such employees may have to
be considered on merits in the light of the
principles settled by this Court in the cases
above referred to and in the light of this
judgment. In that context, the Union of
India, the State Governments and their
instrumentalities should take steps to
regularize as a one-time measure, the
services of such irregularly appointed, who
have worked for ten years or more in duly
sanctioned posts but not under cover of
orders of courts or of tribunals and should
further ensure that regular recruitments are
undertaken to fill those vacant sanctioned
posts that require to be filled up, in cases
where temporary employees or daily wagers
are being now employed. The process must
be set in motion within six months from this
date. We also clarify that regularization, if
any already made, but not sub judice, need
not be reopened based on this judgment,
but there should be no further by passing of
the
constitutional
requirement
and
regularizing or making permanent, those
not duly appointed as per the constitutional
scheme.
................................”
8.
It may not be possible for this Court to consider the claim for
regularization in the light of the Scheme of the year 1993, in the
absence of any material to hold that she was working from 1984
onwards. However, there is no denial of the fact that she was
working as a full-time Safaiwala from 1994 onwards. Learned
Deputy Solicitor General of India would argue that the Petitioner was
engaged on a voucher payment basis for four hours a day and that
she would receive wages only for the days she worked. Therefore, it
is contended that she is not eligible for regularization. On the other
hand, learned Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the nature of
engagement, duration, and intention of the employer are required to
be considered in the light of the Umadevi(3) case (supra).
9.
In Jaggo v. Union of India and Others3, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court had observed as follows:
“ ......................
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826.
WP(C)/10/2023
(Mrs. Bimla Devi Vs. The Chief Commissioner of CGST and CX and 2 others)
22.
The
pervasive
misuse
of
temporary
employment contracts, as exemplified in this case,
reflects a broader systemic issue that adversely
affects workers’ rights and job security. In the
private sector, the rise of the gig economy has led
to an
increase in precarious employment
arrangements, often characterized by lack of
benefits, job security, and fair treatment. Such
practices have been criticized for exploiting workers
and undermining labour standards. Government
institutions, entrusted with upholding the principles
of fairness and justice, bear an even greater
responsibility
to
avoid
such
exploitative
employment practices. When public sector entities
engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it not
only mirrors the detrimental trends observed in the
gig economy but also sets a concerning precedent
that can erode public trust in governmental
operations.
..............................................
25. It is a disconcerting reality that temporary
employees, particularly in government institutions,
often face multifaceted forms of exploitation. While
the foundational purpose of temporary contracts
may have been to address short-term or seasonal
needs,
they
have
increasingly
become
a
mechanism to evade long-term obligations owed to
employees. These practices manifest in several
ways:
• Misuse of “Temporary” Labels: Employees
engaged for work that is essential, recurring, and
integral to the functioning of an institution are
often labelled as “temporary” or “contractual”, even
when their roles mirror those of regular employees.
Such misclassification deprives workers of the
dignity, security, and benefits that regular
employees are entitled to, despite performing
identical tasks.
• Arbitrary Termination: Temporary employees
are frequently dismissed without cause or notice,
as seen in the present case. This practice
undermines the principles of natural justice and
subjects workers to a state of constant insecurity,
regardless of the quality or duration of their
service.
• Lack of Career Progression: Temporary
employees often find themselves excluded from
opportunities for skill development, promotions, or
incremental pay raises. They remain stagnant in
their roles, creating a systemic disparity between
them and their regular counterparts, despite their
contributions being equally significant.
• Using Outsourcing as a Shield: Institutions
increasingly resort to outsourcing roles performed
by temporary employees, effectively replacing one
set of exploited workers with another. This practice
not only perpetuates exploitation but also
demonstrates a deliberate effort to bypass the
obligation to offer regular employment.
• Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits:
Temporary
employees
are
often
denied
fundamental benefits such as pension, provident
fund, health insurance, and paid leave, even when
their tenure spans decades. This lack of social
security subjects them and their families to undue
hardship, especially in cases of illness, retirement,
or unforeseen circumstances.
WP(C)/10/2023
(Mrs. Bimla Devi Vs. The Chief Commissioner of CGST and CX and 2 others)
26. While the judgment in Uma Devi (supra)
sought to curtail the practice of backdoor entries
and ensure appointments adhered to constitutional
principles, it is regrettable that its principles are
often misinterpreted or misapplied to deny
legitimate claims of long-serving employees. This
judgment aimed to distinguish between “illegal”
and “irregular” appointments. It categorically held
that employees in irregular appointments, who
were engaged in duly sanctioned posts and had
served continuously for more than ten years,
should be considered for regularization as a onetime measure. However, the laudable intent of the
judgment is being subverted when institutions rely
on its dicta to indiscriminately reject the claims of
employees, even in cases where their appointments
are not illegal, but merely lack adherence to
procedural formalities. Government departments
often cite the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) to
argue that no vested right to regularization exists
for
temporary
employees,
overlooking
the
judgment’s explicit acknowledgment of cases where
regularization is appropriate. This selective
application distorts the judgment’s spirit and
purpose,
effectively
weaponizing
it
against
employees who have rendered indispensable
services over decades.
27. In light of these considerations, in our opinion,
it is imperative for government departments to lead
by example in providing fair and stable
employment. Engaging workers on a temporary
basis for extended periods, especially when their
roles are integral to the organization's functioning,
not only contravenes international labour standards
but also exposes the organization to legal
challenges and undermines employee morale. By
ensuring fair employment practices, government
institutions can reduce the burden of unnecessary
litigation, promote job security, and uphold the
principles of justice and fairness that they are
meant to embody. This approach aligns with
international standards and sets a positive
precedent for the private sector to follow, thereby
contributing to the overall betterment of labour
practices in the country.
..........................................”
10.
Therefore, considering the above judgment and the facts of
the present case, in the light of Umadevi(3) case (supra), the
Petitioner will be eligible for regularization, as she had completed 10
years of service as on the date of the judgment of the Apex Court in
the Umadevi(3) case (supra).
11.
As a result, I do not see any reason to deny the Petitioner the
benefit of the above judgment merely on the ground that she had
not applied for the same.
12.
Accordingly, the writ petition succeeds.
WP(C)/10/2023
(Mrs. Bimla Devi Vs. The Chief Commissioner of CGST and CX and 2 others)
13.
The Petitioner will be entitled to regularization with effect from
10.04.2006, the date of the judgment in the Umadevi(3) case
(supra).
14.
All consequential benefits shall be paid to the Petitioner within
a period of two months from the date of this judgment.
Chief Justice
Approved for Reporting: Yes
ami
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review