Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
I
I
:
[ 3488 ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
SRI
THE HONOURABLE
WRIT APP EAL NO: 9 OF 2026
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent preferred against the order
dated. 12t12t2025 in W.P.No.3148 of 2025 on the file of the High Court.
Between:
ttIr. Syed Zainul Abideen Hussaini Quadri, S/o..SyeQ Arifullah Hussaini, Aged
aUorl'+2 years, Occ. Pvt. Employee, R/o. H.N6. 9-10-5, Rowshannadowla
Village, Balapur, R.R. District.
2 Mr Syed Mohammed lmam Quadri, s]q 9yg9 Khusroo tt4ohiuddin, Aged
iOoui'45 years, Occ. Pvt. Employee, R/o. H.No.9-10-13, Rowshannadowla
Village, Balapur, R.R. District.
about 35 years,
3. Mr. Syed Azmath Quadri, S/o. Sved Nusrath Hashmi, Aged Village,
Balapur,
Rowshannadowla
0-tO-t2,
Occ Pvt Employee, R/o. H.No
R.R. District.
4." ttflr. Syed Afzal Quadri, S/o.Syed [hajltVoinuddin,.AgPd.about 55 years, Oc!.
piirit" emptoyee, R/o. H.No'.9-10-2, Rowshannadowla Village, Balapur, R.R.
District.
Aged
5. It/lr. Syed Kamal Pasha Quadri, S/o. -S.yed. Mahemoodullah Hussaini,Sahab
Nawab
19-4-279N4,
H.No.
R/6.
Employee,
years,
Pvt.
Occ.
iOori'+S
Kunta, Hyderabad.
Hussaini
6. Mr. Syed tvlisbaullah Hussaini Quad( S/o Syed Waheedullah
19-3-14,
H.No.
R/o.
Empioyee,
years,
Pvt.
Occ.
OJaOri-Aged aOout 45
HYderabad.
Jahannuma, Lancer,
Ahmedullah Hussainjr.4g"9
7. Mr. Syed Waliullah Hussaini Quadri,.S/o. Sy_ed
'R/o.
H.No.23-5-971A, Aliabad,
iOort'-O+ yeirs, Occ. Pvt. Employee,
HYderabad
..APPELLANTS
AND
Quadri, 9/o. Late Syed Ghouse Mohiuddin
Syed Mohammed
- Mohiuddin
Otatri',-'-'Age SS years, Occ.Business, R/o-. H.No:17-1-1821D133,
Santoshnagar, HYderabad - TS.
rl
,d:
r;
The State of Telangana, Rep by its Principal Secretary, Minority Department,
Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
J The Telang ana State Wakf Board, Rep by its Chief Executive Officer,
Nampally, H aj House, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
lA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition. the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the order of the learned Single Judge in WP No.3148/2025,
dt.12.12.2025, pending disposal of the Writ Appeal.
Counsel for the Appellants: SRI VEDULA SRINIVAS, Sr. COUNSEL, REP.
SMT VEDULA CHITRALEKHA
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI ASHFAQ AHMED
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI ANANTHULA RAVI,
GP FOR SOCIAL WELFARE
Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI FARHAN AZAM KHAN,
SC FOR WAQF BOARD
The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH COI'RT FOR THE STATE OF TEI,ANGANA
AT I{YDERABAI)
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH I$TVIAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT
No.9 o f 2026
DATE: o + 02.2026
BETWEEN:
Syed Zarnul Abideen Hussaini Quadri
and 6 others.
....Appellants
AND
Syed Mohammed Mohiuddin Quadri
and 2 others.
....Respondents
JUDGMENT
The present writ Appeal is directed against the order dated
12.1.2.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.No.3148 of
2025, whereby the learned Single Judge allowed the Writ Petition and
set aside the proceedings dated 18.L2.2O24 issued by the Telangana
State Waqf Board (for short "the Board") appointing the appellants
(respondent Nos.3 to 9 in the Writ Petition) as President and Members
of the Towliath committee of Dargah Haztath Imam Ali Shah Quadri
(R.H.), Balapur, and further directed the Board to reconstitute the
said Committee considering the claim of respondent No' 1 (writ
petitioner) for the post of President with preferential status.
2.
For the sake of clarity and brevity, the parties are hereafter
referred to as they were arrayed in the writ petition.
Factual background (succincfly stated)
3.
Dargah HazraLh Imam Ali Shah euadri, Balapur (for short ,the
Balapur Dargah') is a notified waqf institution bearing Serial No.295g,
as published in rhe Gazette dated og.o2.l9g9. Upon thc demise of the
original Mutar,r,alli, disputes arose regarding succession to the office of
Mutawalli. In order to resolve the said disputes, a Family compromise
dated 25.o2.1960 (for short 'the compromise Deed,) was recorded in
Case No.13/2 of i959.
4. The key terms of the Compromise Deed rvvere
A Tou'liath (Management) committee shall be constituted
ii. Syed Ghouse Mohiuddin euadri (father of the Writ
Petitioner and grandfather of respondent No.3) shall be
the President.
iii. In case of any eventuality concerning the president, his
legal heirs or nominee would succeed him.
5.
Subsequent disputes between the parties culminated in further
litigation. A Division Bench of this court, by Judgment in w.A.No.23
of 1992, directed the constitution of a fresh Towliath committee
strictly in accordance with the compromise Deed, while continuing
Syed Ghouse Mohiuddin euadri as the chairman thereof. In
:i
E
a
g
I
*
::3
r
compliance with the said directions, the Waqf Board constituted a
I
i
i
five-member Towliath Committee uide proceedings dated 03.04.1993.
6.
Upon the demise ol Syed Ghouse Mohiuddin Quadri, his 2nd
son, Syed Sultan Mohiuddin Quadri, who is the brother of the writ
petitioner, was appointed as Mutawalli/President of the Balapur
Dargah through GazeLte Notifications dated 20.O1.2005 and
O8.O2.2OO7. The said appointment made under Section 63 of the
Waqf Act, 1995 (for short 'the Act'), was assailed belore the Waqf
Tribunal (for short 'the TribunalJ. However, the challenge was
dismissed and the appointment was upheld by the order dated
16.09 .2006 in O.A.No .4 of 2005.
7.
Subsequently, the Board appointed Syed Sultan Mohiuddin
Quadri as Mutawalli under Section 42 of the Act uide proceedings
dated 29.06.2012. The said appointment was assailed in O.A.No.45
of 2016 before the Tribunal. The Tribunal, by judgment dated
Ol.lO.2O21, allowed the O.A, set aside the impugned appointment,
and issued elaborate directions for reconstitution of the Towliath
Committee in strict conformity with the Compromise Deed and the
proceedings dated 03.04.1993. The Tribunal categorically held that
the office of President shall be filled from the first branch, namely the
branch of Syed Ghouse Mohiuddin Quadri, and that the remaining
members of the committee shall be drawn from each of the five
branches of the family.
li
T
::4ii
8.
The order of the Tribunal was challenged in c.R.p.No. i60g of
2021. The said c.R.P. r.tas disposed of by this court on 27.og.2o23
with a modification, as follows:
"The waqf Board is directed" to constitute a Towliath Comnittee
front tlrc
rrtentbers of all the brarrches atrcl tlrc presld.ent shail be altpoirtted.
front the
fi.rst branrch as per the temts of compronise d.ated 2s.02.1960 dnd. as per
the direciiort of the Diuision Bench of this court in w.A.No.23 of 1992 dated
03.02.1992."
The order dated 27.o9.2o23 passed by this courr in c.R.p.
No.1608 of 2o2l was carricd to the Hon'ble supreme court bylr,ay of
a Special Leave Petition (sLp). The Hon'ble Supreme court disrnissed
the said sLP on 16.02.2024 thereby confirming the order passed by
this Court in the said C.R.p.
9.
In compiiance of the order in the said c.R.p.No.160g of 2021,
the Board issued the impugned proceedings dated 1g.12.2024
appointing respondent No.3/appellant No.l herein i.e., Syed Zainu.l
Abideen Hussaini Quadri as president and respondent Nos.4 to
9/appellant Nos.2 to 7 herein as Members of thc Towliath Committee.
The respondent No.3 is the grandson of syed Ghouse Mohiuddin
Quadri (daughter's son i.e., maternal grandson).
10.
The writ Petitioner, being the son of late Syed Ghouse
Mohiuddin Quadri, challenged the proceedings dated 1g.12.2024
before the learned single Judge, contending that the appointment of a
maternal grandson as President, overlooking him, violated the terms
of the Compromise Deed, the directions of this Court and Article 14 of
the Constitution.
i.i
T
t!
I
11. The respondent No.3 aggrieved by the order of the learned
Single Judge preferred the present writ appeal. The primary [hrust of
the appellant's challenge is on the maintainability of the writ petition.
It is vehemently contended that the learned Single Judge committed a
jurisdictional error in entertaining the writ petition when a complete,
efficacious, statutory alternative remedy by way of an application
under Section 83 of the Act, was available to the writ petitioner. On
merits, it is argued that the term 'legal heirs'in the Compromise Deed
and the '[irst branch' in the Court's order are broad enough to include
a grandson and the Board had validty exercised jurisdiction under
Section 63 of the Act.
L2. The learned Single Judge, repelling the objection as to
maintainability and by relying on the judgment in Whirlpool
Corporation u. Registrar of Trademarksr, held that the writ
petition was maintainable. On merits, it was held that the son (writ
petitioner) and the daughter's son (appellant No. i) were not equals;
the son had a preferential claim. It was also held that mere pendency
of complaints against the writ petitioner could not disqualify him
without enquiry. Consequently, the learned Single Judge set aside the
impugned proceedings and directed the Board to reconstitute the
Committee, giving preference to the writ petitioner for Presidentship.
I
' (1998) 8 SCC r
::6::
13.
Heard Sri Vedula Srinivas, learned Senior Counsel representing
Smt. Vedula Chitralekha, learned counsel for the appellants;
Sri Ashfaq Ahmed, learned counsel for respondent No.1,
Sri Ananthula Ravi, learned Govcrnment Pleader for Social Welfare
appearing for respondenl- No.2 and Sri Farhan Azam Khan, learned
Standing Counsel lor Telangana State Waqf Board appearing for
respondent No.3 and perused the record.
Submissions of learned counsel for the appeliants
L4. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants submitted:
i. That the learnecl Single Judge committed a jurisdictional
error by cntertaining the writ petition despite the
availability of an efficacious alternative statutory remedy
undcr Section 83 of the Act. The Tribunal has exclusive
jurisdiction to adjudicate any dispute relating to an order
of the Board. Reliance was placed on M.P. Waqf Board
i
I
I
I
t
l
J
a. Subho,n Shall.z, and Kanuar Singh Scini a. High
Court of Delhis.
ii. That the exception in Whirtpool Corporation (supra 1)
I
'
does not apply to the present case, as no violation of any
i
j
,i
I
fundamental right or legal right of the writ petitioner; or
'l
l
jurisdictional error, is made out by the writ petitioner.
2 (20061 10 SCC 696
3 (2ot2l4 SCC 307
iii. That the learned Single Judge erred in applying Article 14
of the Constitution to the Mohammedan law, religious
office context. The post of President of a Towliath
Committee is not a public office amenable to strict
scrutiny under Article 14 of the Constitution. The
Board's discretion under Section 63 of the Act is wide and
administrative.
iv. That the Compromise Deed and the subsequent judicial
directions use the expression "legal heirs or nominee".
Under Mohammedan law, which governs the Waqf Act,
and as per Section 205-A of Mulla's Principles, a
daughter's son is a legal heir and is not excluded from
consideration. The Board correctly interpreted that sons
and grandsons (including through daughters) from the
first branch are eligible.
v. That the learned Single Judge transgressed into the realm
of factual appraisal, reappreciating the suitability of
candidates, which is the Board's domain under Section
63 of the Act.
vi. That the Board's impugned order was passed in
meticulous compliance with the directions in C.R.P.No.
1608 of 2021, which only mandated appointment from
the "first branch", without specifying "son" to the
exclusion of "grandson".
Submissions of learned counsel for the respondents
15. Learned counsel for respondent No. 1/writ petitioner supported
the learned Single Judge's order and contended that the Board's
action was in blatant violation of specific judicial directions and u,as
arbitrary, thus rvarranting intervention under writ jurisdiction, by
making the follou,ing submissions:
i. That the rvrit jurisdiction was rightly invoked as the Board's
order rvas in flagrant violation of specific directions of this Court
in c.R.P.No.i608 of 2021, which constituted a jurisdictional
error. Furthermore, the appointment of the committee under
the impugned order r,vas arbitrary and violated Article 14 of the
Constitution.
ii. That thc core direction of this court was to appoint the
President "from the first branch". The natural, ordinary and
legal meaning of succession in the context of the compromise
Deed, v'here the founder's intent was family-based
management, mandates that the immediate male descendant
(son) succeeds, not a descendant from a daughter who moves
into another family line, after her marriage.
:
$
i:
;
iii. That when the Board makes an appointment; its action must be
non-arbitrary. Treating a son and a daughter's son as equals for
'i
.,i
this specific religious-office succession is irrational, as their
degrees of relationship and lines of descent are fundamentally
different.
u
ti
g
I
..o..
iv. That the compromise Deed aimed at family harmony and
preventing disputes, by clarifying lineal succession from the
named President. This intent is defeated by appointing a
maternal grandson over a Son aS a President of the committee.
L6. The learned Counsel for the respondent No.1/writ petitioner in
support of their case has placed reliance on the following decisions:
i. Whirlpool Corporation (supra 1)
ii. Harbanslq.l Sa.hnia and another u. Indian Oil
Corporation Limited and other{
ilr. Radha Krishan Industries u. State of
Hima,cho,l
Prq.d.esh and otherss
w. M/s. Godrej Sara I*e Limited v. The Excise and
Taxo;tion Officer-cum-Asses sing Authoritg and others6
L7. Learned Standing Counsel for Waqf Board (respondent No.3),
adopted the arguments on maintainability and added:
i. The Board, after considering all applications and the
historical context, has found that representation from the
flirst branch was satisfied by appointing a grandson as the
president and a great-grandson as a member of the
Committee. The Board's decision was a bona ftde exercise
of power under Section 63 of the Act.
o
lzoo:1 2 scc 107
t (zozr) 6 scc77r
r\4R,\ u/sc/0086/2023
il
Z
E
t
I
::10::
ii. The alleged criminal compraints against the writ
petitioner were a relevant, though not a sole factor for
considering the o'erall suitability for managing a large
Waqf propertli.
18.
we have taken note of the respective contcntions urged and
perused the material on record
Consideration by this Court
of
t
19. The foremost challenge rvhich eclipses all other questions and
which needs to be resolved at the threshold is the very maintainability
of the underlying writ petition fiied under Article 226 in the face of
Section 83 of the Act; and whether the learned Single Judge ought to
have exercised writ jurisdiction in the face of the explicit statutory
scheme delineated in the waqf Act. section g3 of the Act, so far as
material, is extracted belo'uv:
83. Constitution of Tribunals, etc The state Gouernment shall, bg notift.cation in the official Gazette,
constitute as monA Tribunq.ls as it mqA thini Jit, fo, the
detennination of ang dispute. question or other matter-relaiing to a
waqf or waqf properlg, euiction of a tenant or d.etermination of ights
and obligations of the lessor and. the lessee of such propertg, uid.",
this Act and define tle local limits and. jurisdiction oy iucn ribunals.
(2)Ang mutawalli person interested. in a utaqf or ana other person
aggrieued bg an order made und.er this Act, ; rules mad"e
tltereunder, may make an apprication within the time specified. in this
Act or where no such time has been specifted., withii sich time as
mag be prescrtbed, to the Tribunal jor the d.eterminqtion of ang
dispute, question or other matter relating to the waqf.
(3)xxtcx
(4)nux
:
d
i
x
I
I
::11::
(5) The Tibunal shatt be deemed to be a ciuil court and shall haue
the same potuers as maa be exercised by a civil courT under the code
of Ciuit Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), uthile trying a sutt, or executing
a decree or order.
(6)Notwithstanding angthing contatned in the Code of Ciuil
Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), the Tibunal slrull follow such procedure
as maA be prescribed.
(7)The dectsion of tlrc Tribunal shall be final and binding upon the
parties to tLrc applicatiort and it shall haue the force of a decree made
by a ciutl court.
20. Another provision having a bearing on this issue is Section 85
of the Act which is extracted hereunder:
85. Bqr of jurisdiction of civil courts.
No suit or other legal proceedirtg shall he in antg ciuil court, reuenue court
and ang other authoitg in respect of ang dispute, question or other matter
relatirtg to ang waqf, waqf property or other matter which is required by or
under this Act to be determined by a Tnburwl.
2L. The Waqf Act, i995 provides a complete mechanism for
adjudication of disputes relating to waqfs through the Tribunal
constituted under Section 83. It is a settled principle of law that
where an efficacious alternative remedy is available under a statute,
the High Court would ordinarily refrain from entertaining a writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.
22. tn Rashi d Wali Beg u. Farid Pindari and othersT the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has held that once the property is admitted to be waqf
property, any dispute arising in respect thereof, including its
management and administration shall be filed before the Tribunal.
Further, the Apex Court in W.B. Wakf Board u, Anis Fqtma
Begums, has held that:
'i
a
j
.
n
1zozz14 scc 414
8 (2010) 14 SCC sB8
::12::
7. The dispute in tle present case relates to a wakf. In our
opinion, all
It rnag be
rnentioned that the Wakf Act, 1995 is a re,cent parliamentary
statute
wltich has cottstituted a Speciat Tribumil
deciding
tlisputes relatinq to
for
wakfs. The obuious purpose of constitutirtg suclr a iiibunal wos tltat
a Lot
of ccses relating to wakfs wete lteitg filed h the ccurts irt Incrut
attd. tltey
tDere ocanpging a lot of tirne of ail the corrrls in tlte court
try tuhiclt resulteC
irt increase in pendencg of cases in the courts i-Ience, a
Special T'ribunal
has been ccnstitutedfor d.eciclhtg sttclt ntatters.
(errtp hasis sttp p tied)
23. The Flon'ble Supreme courr in Kiran Devi u. The Bihar state
Sznni Wakf Board an(l otherss has held that:
Th.e jurisdiction of the High court is restricte.d.
to <>rtLy exantirte the
correctness' regaritg or propietg of the
fincrings record.ed. bg tte wakf
Tribunal.' Tlrc High Court in exercise of tlrc jurisclictiott cortfened
und"i,
prouiso to Sub-sectiort (9) of Section 83 of tl:te Act tloes not
act as the
appellate court.
24. The constitution Bench in subhan shalz's case (supra 2) and
the three-Judge Bench in Kanutar singh satni,s case (supra 3) have
unequivocally held that where a statute provides a specific forum and
remedy, the parties must exhaust such remedy before invoking writ
jurisdiction. The jurisdiction of the Tribunal under the Act
is exclusive
and comprehensive. The exceptions carved out in whirlpool
corporation's case (supra 1), namely violation of lundamental rights,
breach of principles of natural justice, or complete lack of jurisdiction,
are not attracted in the present case. The grievance raised relates
to
the interpretation of the expression "first branch" and the suitability
of a candidate for appointment, u,hich are matters u,hich
within the a{iudicatory competence of the Waqf Tribunal.
e MANU/SC
/O23sl2O2t
fall squarely
::13::
I
I
I
I
1l
t
25, The reliance placed by respondent No.l/writ petitioner on
Whirlpool Corporation's case (supra 1), Harbanslal Schntor's
(supra 4), Radha Krishan Industries's case (supra 5) and M/s.
Godrej Sarcr Lee Limited's (supra 6/ is misconceived and does not
advance his case. The said decisions only carve out limited exceptions
to the rule of alternative remedy, which are not attracted herein. The
dispute raised pertains to matters squarely falling within the exclusive
jurisdiction o[ the Waqf Tribr-rnal under Section 83 of the Act, and
mere allegations of arbitrariness or violation of Article 14 are
insuflicient to bypass the statutory remedy.
26. It is pertinent to note that Section 83 of the Act is not a mere
procedural formality; it constitutes comprehensive and exclusive
jurisdictional architecture for disputes pertaining to waqfs. Section
33(i) establishes the Tribunal. Section 83(2) is expansively worded,
conferring upon the Tribunal jurisdiction to determine "any dispute,
question or other matter relating to any waqf, waqf propertg or other
matter which is required ba or under this Act to be determined by a
Tibunal". The expression 'any dispute'leaves no room for any doubt
regarding the amplitude of the jurisdiction of the Tribunal.
27. It is to be noted that the learned Single Judge's reliance on
Whirlpool Corporation's case (supra 1) to bypass this statutory
remedy was, with respect, misplaced. The mere assertion of a violation
of a Court order or Article 14 does not, by itself, justify the exercise of
:: 14: :
a"
writ jurisdiction when the Tribunal is fu[y empowered to examine
such qtrestions. The Tribunal, uid"e jwdgment clated ol.lo.2021, has
already demonstrated a sophisticated understanding of
the
compromise and the applicable law.
There was no compelling reason to by-pass this alterna[i'e
remedy. The relevant portion of the decree darecl 0i.10.2o2r is
extracted hcrcunder for ready reference:
This original Application is coming on this d.ag before us
for finar
hearing irL the presence of Mr.slted Attaf Mehclt. Ad.uocate
for
applicants, Mr. Asif Amjad, standing counsel for respond"ent No.l o"nd.
Mr.Klnja Moiztddin, Aduocate for resportclent No.2 and. hauing stood,
ouer for cottsideration till this day, this Tnburtal doth ord.erecl ancl
decreed as under:-
That the original Apptication of the Applicant be ancl the same is
herebg allowed;
Tlrc impugned proceedings dt.29-o6-2012 is set aside, with the
follo,.uing dir e ctio ns : 1) Respondent No.l slto.tt reconstitute the Totuliath contmittee of the
subject Dargah or before O l - I 1 -202 1.
2) Respondent No.l for reconstitution of the Totutiath contmittee shall
take ftue members i.e., one member from each branch of the Towtiath
commiltee constituted uide proceedings dt.03-04- 1993, uiz.,
1. Janab Syed Ghause Mohiuddin euad.i.
2. ,Ianab Faqeer Mohiuddin euadri.
3. Janab Sultan Mohiuddin euadri
4. Janab Khaja Mohiuddin euadri and
5. Janab Badashah Sahib Mohiuddin euadri.
3) The son of a member shoutn in direction No.2 aboue. or grand. son or
great grand-son or a nominee mad.e from the said. branch shail be
member in the neut Towliath Committee.
4)The President shalt be appointed in tLrc proceedings d.t.3-4-93,
from
the first brancll if there is consensu s in the members. If there is no
consensus, the President shall befrom second branch" or third branch
or fourth branch or fifth branch bg giuing opportunitg of consensus to
euery branch as slnwn in section 2os A of Mutta's Mohemmed.an Law,
mentioned in tlrc judgment. If still there is no consensus for the
President of tlrc Towliath committee, respond.ent No.l shall be at
libeftg to appoint ang member from Jiue branches stated. in direction
No.2 aboue.
--, .. .*,\?...#(--q
.l'r/
::15::
5) For resoluing ang dispute in future the bases shall be from the
:
t
follouing (3) sources: -
!
ti
7. Compromise deed dt.25'2-1960.
2. Duision Bench judgment of the Hon'ble lligh Court of A.P. in
W.A.No.23 of 1992, dt.3'2'1992.
3. Proceedings of the Waqf Bocu'd dt.3 4'1993.
Titl the reconstituttng of the Totuliatlt Contrnittee on or before 0l-11'
202 1, tnanagement of the sttbiect Dctrgali shall be continued as
existing as on todag.
As stated hereinabove, in the present case, the grievance is
fundamentally about the interpretation of a family compromise and
the application of the term 'first branch' to a specific set of family
relationbhip. These are essentially 'disputes' precisely of the kind, the
waqf Tribunal is constituted to decicle. The Tribunal is not just an
alternative forum, it is the primary and speciahzed adjudicatory body
endowed with the expertise in waqf law and Mohammedan law,
necessary to unravel such intricate famiiy and reiigious disputes.
29. Consequently, we hold that the Writ Petition itself was not
.
maintainable, and the learned Single Judge ought to have relegated
the parties to the remedy under Section 83 of the Act. The impugned
order is therefore vitiated by a jurisdictional error.
30.
Having held that the Writ petiLion itself was not maintainable
for the reasons stated above, we considered it neither necessary not
appropriate to adjudicate upon the substantive merits of the rival
contentions, including the learned Single Judge's observations
regarding the terms of 'legal heirs' and 'first branch', or the principle
of Mohammedan Law pertaining to succession.
:: l6::
31. Any observations rnade by the learned Single Judge on the
aforementioned merits of the dispute, including those relating to
the
cligibility of a daughter's son for consideration as a legal heir under
thc Compronrise Deed or Mohammedan Lavt,, are expungc(I.'lhese are
complex questions intertwining the interpretation of a family
settlemcnt, personal law and the Board's discretionary power under
Section 63 of the Act, u,hich squarely fall within thc specialized
jurisdiction of ttre waqf Tribunal under Section g3 of thc waqf
Act,
1995.
32.
we refrain from expressing any opinion, even tcntati'e, on these
aspects, lest it should prejudice or pre-empt a fair ancl full
adjudication of all factual and legal issues by the Tribunal. The merits
of the claims of the respective parties, including the correctness of the
Bo.ard's impugned order dated L9.12.2o24 are left entirel.v open
for
fresh and uninfluenced consideration, in accordancc rvith la,,v irv
competent Tribunal.
Conclusion
33.
For the foregoing reasons, we are constrained to allow the writ
Appeal. Accordingly:
i.
The order dated L2.12.2o25 passed by the learned single Judge
in W.P.No.3148 of 2O2S is set aside.
:'
ii.
=
;
Consequently, the writ petition is dismissed on the ground of
non-maintainability, due to the availability of an efficacious
i
alternative remedy under Section 83 of the Act.
iii. This dismissal shall not preclude any aggrieved person from
seeking appropriate relief in accordance with law before the
competent forum i.e., Telangana State WaqtTribunal, subject to
all just exceptions including limitation.
iv. It is made unequivocally clear that this Court has not expressed
any opinion whatsoever on the merits o[ the claim of either
party concerning the constitution o[ the Torvliath Committee or
on the suitability of any individual for anv post. All rights and
contentions on merits are left open.
As a sequei, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed' No order as to costs'
sD/- M.RAMANA KRT'HNA
JOINT
//TRUE COPY//
I
j
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
(For His Lordships kind perusal)
One Fair Gopy to the Hon'ble SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
(For His Lordships Kind Perusal)
To,
1. The Principal Secretary, [Vlinority Department, Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad,
Hyderabad, State of Telangana.
2. The Chief Executive Officer, Telangana State Wakf Board, Nampally, Haj
House, Hyderabad
3. 11 LR Copies
4. The Under Secretary, Union of tndia, Ministry of Law, Justice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi
5. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association, Library, High Court
Buildings, Hyderabad.
\
I
ir
!
6. One CC to SMT VEDULA CHITRALEKHA, Advocate [OPUC]
7. One CC to SRI ASHFAQ AHMED, Advocate [OPUC]
8. One CC to SRI FARHAN AZAM KHAN, SC FOR WAQF BOARD [OPUC]
9. Two CCs to GP FOR SOCIAL WELFARE, High Court for the State of
Telangana at Hyderabad [OUT]
10.Two CD Copies
BSR
TKS
HIGH COURT
DATED i 0410212026
\
.$
.s
%
q
JUDGMENT
WA.No.9 ot 2026
o
lr-
\
\
!.:
ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEAL ,
WITHOUT COSTS
c\\
j"
1b
1t
v
1tc
c
t
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review