Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE K. SUJANA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.1203 OF 2023
CNR.NO. HBHC010162382023
AND
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.1808 OF 2023
CNR.NO. HBHC010289982023
Reserved on : 14.08.2026
Pronounced on : 03.09.2026
Uploaded on
:07.09.2026
C.R.P.No.1203 of 2023 :
BETWEEN:
Jamia Ilahiyat-e-Nooria & two others
…..Petitioners/Plaintiffs
And
Syed Ahmed Mohiuddin Jeelani
…..Respondent/Defendant
C.R.P.No.1808 of 2023 :
BETWEEN :
Syed Ahmed Mohiuddin Jeelani
…..Petitioner
And
Jamia Ilahiyat-e-Nooria & two others
...Respondents
: COMMON ORDER :
These Civil Revision Petitions are filed aggrieved by the
order dated 02.11.2022 passed in I.A.No.841 of 2022 in
O.S.No.76 of 2022 by the Telangana Waqf Tribunal (for short
‘Tribunal’), wherein the revision petitioners in C.R.P.No.1203 of
2023 filed an interlocutory application under Order XXXIX
Rules 1 and 2 of CPC
requesting the Tribunal to grant ad-
interim injunction restraining the respondent therein from
interfering into the duties of plaintiff No.3 as Sajjadah Nasheen
over
Khanka-e-Nooria
and
Rauza-e-Nooria
situated
at
Bandlaguda, Hyderabad.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties herein after
referred to as arrayed in C.R.P.No.1203 of 2023.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that Petitioner No.3’s father,
late Syed Ahmed Mohiuddin Jeelani @ Syed Noori Shah, created
two Waqf institutions, namely, (i) Jamiya Ilahiyaat-e-Nooria and
(ii)
Khanqaah-e-Nooria
Waqf
Alal
Aulad.
The
said
Waqf
institutions were published in the Gazette and Muntakhabs
bearing F.No.17/2/Indiraj-City/1970, dated 23.01.1970, and
F.No.19/2/Inderaj-City/1970, dated 10.11.1971. The properties
covered by the said documents comprised Sy.Nos.57, 58, 59,
60, 61, 92 and 93, to an extent of Ac.8.33 guntas, in respect of
Jamiya Ilahiyaat-e-Nooria, and Sy.Nos.54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 60,
61, 94 and 95, to an extent of Ac.16.02 guntas, in respect of
Khanqaah-e-Nooria Waqf Alal Aulad. The two institutions were
also registered under Waqf Deeds executed by Petitioner No.3’s
father on 14.08.1970. Petitioner No.1 is a registered society
established by the father of Petitioner No.3 for promoting
education among oppressed and needy persons. The Waqf
Deeds provided for the rights and duties of the Mutawallis and
Sajjadah Nasheens and prescribed the manner of selection of
the Sajjadah Nasheen after the death of the founder, with a view
to preserving the legacy and sanctity of the Dargah Shareef.
4.
Petitioner No.3, being the fourth son of late Syed Ahmed
Mohiuddin Jeelani @ Syed Noori Shah, assumed the office of
Sajjadah Nasheen after the death of his brother, late Arifuddin
Jeelani. His position was accepted by Petitioner Nos.1 and 2
and other persons associated with the institution. Petitioner
No.3 is stated to be well-versed in religious studies and to have
authored several religious books. Petitioner Nos.1 and 2
conducted meetings and passed resolutions dated 20.03.2022
and 26.03.2022 declaring Petitioner No.3 as the Sajjadah
Nasheen of the institution and recognising his authority to
perform
the
religious
ceremonies
at
the
Dargah.
The
respondent was stated to have no qualification or experience in
religious matters and, under the terms of the Waqf Deeds, was
not entitled to claim the office of Sajjadah Nasheen. During the
lifetime of the respondent’s father, the respondent was never
appointed as Sajjadah Nasheen of Silsila-e-Nooria or Rauza-eNooria.
5.
The respondent, despite having no right or entitlement,
allegedly interfered with the day-to-day religious and ritual
activities of the Dargah and obstructed Petitioner No.3 in
discharging his duties as Sajjadah Nasheen. Hence, the
petitioners
sought
an
interim
injunction
restraining
the
respondent, his agents and persons claiming through him from
interfering with the duties and functions of Petitioner No.3 as
Sajjadah Nasheen of Silsila-e-Nooria and Rauza-e-Nooria.
6.
The respondent therein filed counter denying the material
allegations made in the petition and contended that the father of
the petitioner No.3, late Syed Ahmed Mohiuddin Jeelani @ Syed
Noori Shah (Rh), had established Petitioner Nos.1 and 2 and
other Waqf institutions, which were registered with the Waqf
Board and for which Muntakhabs were issued.
It was
contended that the legal heirs of late Syed Ahmed Mohiuddin
Jeelani @ Syed Noori Shah (Rh), particularly S.M. Nasiruddin
Jeelani, failed to carry forward his legacy and were involved in
greed, deceit, fraud and misappropriation of Waqf funds. The
respondent further stated that the petitioner No.3 was facing
criminal cases registered by the Waqf Board in relation to such
alleged irregularities and that the Waqf Board had taken the
institution under its direct management. The respondent
claimed to be the Sajjadah Nasheen and stated that he had
been performing the rituals associated with the Dargah and
Khankah. According to him, no other person was entitled to
interfere with or perform such rituals. He denied that Petitioner
No.3 was discharging the duties of Sajjadah Nasheen or that the
respondent
had
interfered
respondent
further
with
contended
his
that
alleged
the
duties.
The
petitioners
had
approached the Court with unclean hands and had suppressed
material facts, the petitioners had failed to establish prima facie
case and that the balance of convenience was not in their
favour. According to the respondent, continuation of the ex
parte interim injunction would cause irreparable loss and injury
to him and would also create law and order problems. Hence,
the respondent sought dismissal of the said petition.
7.
On behalf of petitioners Exs.P.1 to P.9 are marked and on
behalf of respondent, Exs.R.1 to R.6 are marked.
After
considering the submissions made by both parties, the petition
and counter averments, the trial Court disposed of the said
petition and allowed petitioner No.3 and respondent to continue
with their individual daily prayers and performing rituals
separately without interfering with each other keeping in view
the peace, tranquility and decorum of the subject institution.
Aggrieved by the said order, both the parties filed these two
revision petitions.
8.
Heard Sri A.Najeeb Khan, learned counsel appearing for
petitioner
in
C.R.P.No.1808
of
and
respondent
in
C.R.P.No.1203 of 2023 and Sri M.A.K. Mukheed learned counsel
appearing for petitioners in C.R.P.No.1203 of 2023 and
respondents in C.R.P.No.1808 of 2023.
9.
The contention of revision petitioners in C.R.P.No.1203 of
2023 is that the Tribunal, without properly appreciating the
facts, the material documents and the applicable law, disposed
of the injunction petition by permitting both parties to
participate separately in the rituals without interfering with
each other, which was erroneous and unsustainable. He
contended that, as per the wish of the Waqif and the Waqfnama,
the sons of the original Waqif are entitled to perform the
religious rituals. The respondent, being the grandson of the
original Waqif, could not be permitted to participate in the
rituals when the sons were available. The Tribunal failed to
consider the relevant provisions of the Waqfnama in this regard.
Learned counsel further contended that, as per Ex.P.5-Waqf
Deed, only the surviving sons are entitled to hold the office of
Sajjadah Nasheen of the Dargah. The Tribunal failed to consider
the said document, though it was material for deciding the
issue. He also contended that the respondent was neither a
scholar nor possessed knowledge of Islamic law or religious
practices, whereas Petitioner No.3 is a Ph.D. holder in Islamic
Law, a retired Professor of Nooria Arabia College and an author
of nine books on various Islamic subjects. The Tribunal,
however, failed to consider these aspects.
10.
It
is
further
contended
that
the
Tribunal
had
misunderstood the petitioners’ case. The petitioners claimed the
office of Sajjadah Nasheen in accordance with the document
executed by the founder of Dargah, whereas the Tribunal had
dealt with the issue of Mutawalli and the direct management of
the Waqf Board, which was not the subject matter of the
dispute.
Learned counsel further submitted that Ex.P5 also
disclosed existence of the societies and their day-to-day affairs
and duties and, therefore, Petitioner Nos.1 to 3 are necessary
and relevant parties to the proceedings. It is further contended
that
the
respondent’s
father
had
never
appointed
the
respondent as Sajjadah Nasheen of Silsila-e-Nooria, during his
lifetime as
the
respondent was not qualified
and such
appointment was also contrary to the wishes of the founder.
11.
Learned counsel further contended that the Waqfnama
prohibited the grandchildren from holding the office of Sajjadah
Nasheen of Silsila-e-Nooria and Rauza-e-Nooria when the
children of the founder were alive. The Tribunal failed to
consider this material aspect. He also contended that, though
the
Tribunal
respondent,
initially
it
granted
subsequently
an
injunction
modified
the
against
same
the
without
assigning proper reasons. The respondent had no locus standi
to interfere with the affairs of Silsila-e-Nooria, Rauza-e-Nooria
and the Dargah. Petitioner No.3 had already assumed the office
of Sajjadah Nasheen and was recognized by Petitioner Nos.1 and
2, had been discharging his duties even prior to institution of
the suit. Thus, petitioners had established a prima facie case,
but the Tribunal failed to properly appreciate the same.
12.
The contention of learned counsel for respondent Sri
Abdul Najeeb Khyan, is that the Tribunal failed to consider that
the Wakf Act, 1995 is a special enactment and that the
provisions of the Societies Registration Act have no application
to matters relating to the administration, supervision and
management of a Wakf institution. The Tribunal failed to
consider that the Waqif had formulated a scheme under the
Waqf Deed for appointment of a Sajjada Nasheen and, therefore,
the suit itself is not maintainable. The Tribunal also failed to
consider that the alleged resolution passed by Respondent
Nos.1 and 2 is contrary to the terms of the Waqf Deed and it
also failed to properly consider the Waqf Deed dated 14.08.1970
and, thereby, committed an error.
13.
The
learned
Tribunal
failed
to
consider
that
the
respondent’s father, who was the Sajjada Nasheen, died on
10.03.2022 as such, respondent was nominated as Sajjada
Nasheen in accordance with the Waqf Deed.
14.
The learned Tribunal ought to have examined the
pleadings, the reliefs sought, the claims of the parties and the
real controversy between them, and ought to have considered
whether petitioner No.3 had discharged the initial burden of
satisfying the requirements of Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the
C.P.C. The Tribunal failed to consider that petitioner No.3 was
guilty of misappropriation of the funds of the Waqf institution,
that an enquiry conducted by the Waqf Board had found him
guilty, and that he was also involved in criminal cases.
Hence,
the order of Tribunal is nothing but erroneous, as such, prayed
this Court to set aside the same.
The learned counsel for
petitioners would further contend that petitioner No.3 in
I.A.No.841 of 2022 is the son of wakib and according to Waqf
deed, the wakib intention is that after his demise his three sons
are entitled to be in the institution. According to 20-c of the
waqf deed, his three sons are successors and they will become
the donors of trust and Mutawallies who will permanently
generation by generation having been permanent member of the
managing committee will perform the work, whereas the
respondent in I.A.No.841 of 2022 is not the son of wakib,
therefore, he cannot perform the duties of Sajjadah Nasheen.
The second contention of learned counsel for the petitioners is
that petitioner No.3 is a scholar and he did his P.hd and wrote
nine books on several topics of islam and he is also a retired
professor in Nooria Arabia College whereas the respondent is an
illiterate person and he is not entitled to perform the duties of
Sajjadah Nasheen. The third contention is that Waqf Board had
also appointed petitioner No.3 as Sajjadah Nasheen vide Ex.P.6
and it is a collective decision of committee members. On that
ground also petitioner No.3 is entitled for the relief, but the
Tribunal failed to consider the same.
15.
The contention of learned counsel for the respondent is
that the respondent is the grandson of the Waqif and that,
under Clause 2-C of the Waqf Deed, the Waqif had mentioned
his three sons and specifically provided that each of his
successors would be entitled to nominate, during his lifetime, a
successor from among his male descendants. It was further
provided that, in the event of any successor relinquishing his
membership of the Board of Trustees, his nominated successor
would succeed him from generation to generation. Learned
counsel would submit that the said clause clearly demonstrates
that the father of the respondent was competent to nominate his
son
as
his
respondent
to
successor
and,
perform
the
accordingly,
duties
of
nominated
Sajjadah
the
Nasheen.
Therefore, the petitioners cannot contend that the respondent is
not entitled to act as Sajjadah Nasheen.
16.
He would further submit that there is no prescribed
qualification for being appointed or recognised as Sajjadah
Nasheen. Merely because petitioner No.3 is a Ph.D. scholar, the
respondent cannot be disqualified from performing the said
duties, as no such educational qualification is prescribed under
the Waqf Deed. He would also contend that petitioner No.3 had
misappropriated the funds of the Waqf Board and that an
enquiry was conducted in that regard, wherein he was found
guilty. Therefore, on this ground also, petitioner No.3 is not
entitled to perform the duties of Sajjadah Nasheen. Hence,
learned counsel requested this Court to set aside the order
passed in I.A.No.841 of 2022 and dismiss the said application.
Therefore, requested the Court to set aside the order by
dismissing I.A.No.841 of 2022.
17.
Considering the submissions made by learned counsel for
both the parties and upon perusal of the material available on
record, this Court finds that the dispute essentially relates to
the entitlement of the sons and grandson of the Waqif to
perform the duties of Sajjadah Nasheen. The Waqf Deed,
particularly
Clause
determining
the
2-C
thereof,
intention
of
assumes
the
Waqif
significance
in
with
to
regard
succession.
18.
A plain reading of Clause 2-C of the Waqf Deed shows
that the three sons of the Waqif were designated as his
successors and that each successor was entitled, during his
lifetime, to nominate a successor from among his male
descendants. It was further contemplated that such succession
would continue from generation to generation. Thus, the terms
of the Waqf Deed do not indicate any intention on the part of
Waqif to restrict the right of succession exclusively to his sons.
On the contrary, the provision specifically recognizes the right of
the
sons
successors.
to
nominate
Therefore,
their
the
male
descendants
contention
of
as
their
petitioners
in
I.A.No.841 of 2022 that, so long as a son is available, the
grandson cannot be permitted to perform the duties of Sajjadah
Nasheen, cannot be accepted at this stage, particularly in view
of the specific terms of the Waqf Deed.
19.
It is also relevant to note that the Waqf Board appointed
petitioner No.3 as Sajjadah Nasheen, apparently taking into
consideration his educational qualifications and experience,
including the fact that he is a scholar, a retired Professor, holds
a Ph.D. and has authored books on Islam. The Waqf Board also
appears to have proceeded on the premise that the intention of
the Waqif was to confer the right of succession upon his sons.
However, such an interpretation does not appear to be
consistent with the express terms of Clause 2-C of the Waqf
Deed, which specifically provides for nomination of a successor
from among the male descendants. When the Waqf Deed itself
recognizes
succession
through
nomination
of
a
male
descendant, the right cannot be confined only to the sons of the
Waqif.
20.
However, the present proceedings arise out of I.A.No.841
of 2022, which was filed under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of
CPC. Therefore, while considering the entitlement to interim
relief, the petitioners are required to establish a prima facie
case, balance of convenience and the likelihood of irreparable
injury. In this regard, the petitioners contended that petitioner
No.3 had been performing the duties of Sajjadah Nasheen for
about two months prior to the filing of suit. On the other hand,
the respondent contended that he himself had been performing
the said duties. The Tribunal, however, has not recorded any
specific finding as to who was actually performing the duties of
Sajjadah Nasheen as on the date of filing of I.A.No.841 of 2022.
21.
The documents relied upon by the petitioners, marked as
Exs.P.1 to P.9, also do not establish that petitioner No.3 was
performing the duties of Sajjadah Nasheen as on the date of
filing of the said application. Exs.P.1 and P.2 are copies of the
registration
certificates
of
Jamiya
Ilahiyat-e-Nooria
and
Khanqaahe Nooria; Ex.P.3 is a copy of the bye-laws of
Khanqaahe Nooria; Ex.P.4 is a copy of FIR No.569 of 2021;
Ex.P.5 is a copy of the Waqf Deed of plaintiff Nos.1 and 2;
Ex.P.6 is a copy of the resolution of plaintiff Nos.1 and 2; Ex.P.7
is a copy of Gazette No.23; Ex.P.8 is a copy of the Muntakab
dated 14.08.1970; and Ex.P.9 consists of copies of letters. None
of these documents, by themselves, establish that petitioner
No.3 was in actual performance of the duties of Sajjadah
Nasheen on the date of filing of I.A.No.841 of 2022.
22.
More importantly, the petitioners in C.R.P.No.1203 of
2023 have not placed any cogent material on record to
establish, prima facie, that the respondent, being the grandson
of the Waqif, was disqualified from succeeding to or performing
the duties of Sajjadah Nasheen. On the contrary, Clause 2-C of
the Waqf Deed expressly provides for nomination of a male
descendant by the successor during his lifetime. Therefore, the
contention that the existence of a son, by itself, excludes the
grandson from succession is contrary to the express terms of
the Waqf Deed.
23.
In the circumstances, this Court is of the view that the
petitioners in C.R.P.No.1203 of 2023 have failed to establish a
prima facie case in their favour so as to justify the interim
injunction sought by them. The material on record does not
support their contention that the respondent is not entitled to
perform the duties of Sajjadah Nasheen merely on the ground
that he is a grandson of the Waqif. As such, C.R.P.No.1203 of
2023 is liable to be dismissed and C.R.P.No.1808 of 2023 is
liable to be allowed.
24.
Accordingly, C.R.P.No.1203 of 2023 is dismissed and
C.R.P.No.1808 of 2023 is allowed setting aside the order dated
02.11.2022 passed in I.A.No.841 of 2022 in O.S.No.76 of 2022
by the Telangana State Waqf Tribunal, Hyderabad. No costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand
closed.
_______________
K. SUJANA, J
Date :03.09.2026
Rds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review