Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34sl I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
.
FRIDAY, THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
WRIT APPEAL NO: 642 OF 2026
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters patent Appeal prefened Against
the Order dated 27.02.2026 in WP No 11087 ot 2026 on the file of the High Court.
Between:
'1. Mr.Pindi Narsimha Reddy, S/o Late Mr.Pindi pulla Reddy Aged about.70
years, Occupation .Business Rl/o Biramal Guda Old yillage, 7-1-173,
Karmangat Ranga Reddy Telangana
2. Mr.Pindi Mahender Reddy, S/o Late Mr.Pindi Pulla Reddy Aged about .64
years, Occupation. Business R/o 8-7-93/ne/19, Opp ppR Garden, pindi pulla
Reddy Colony Hasthinapuram North Extension, Saroomagar, Vaishalinagar,
Ranga Reddy District, 500079
3. Mr.Pindi Srinivas Reddy, S/o Late Mr.Pindi pulla Reddy Aged about .64
years, Occupation Business, R/o 8-7-93/ne/19, Opp ppR Garden, pindi pulla
Reddy Colony
...APPELLANTS
AND
1. Mr.Khaja Fahat Hussain, S/o Khaja Shakir Hussain R/o H.No. 12-13-98,
Tarnaka, Secunderabad.
2. Mrs.Mutktharunnisa, W/o Late Khaja Nazir Hussain R/o H.No. 12'13-gB,
Tarnaka, Secunderabad.
3. Khaja Wajid Hussain, S/o Khaja Nazir Jussain R/o H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad-
4. Mohd. Ameen, S/o Khaja Nazir R/o H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka, Secunderabad
5. Mir Sattar Ali, S/o Late Mir Sadath Ali R/o H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad.
6. Mir Hameed Ali, S/o Late Mir Sadath Ali Rl/o H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad
7. Mir Muzzamil Ali, S/o Late Mir Razack Ali R/o H.No 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad
8. Mir Dastagir AIi, S/o Late Mir lftekhar Ali R/o HNo 12-13-98 Tarnaka
Secunderabad
...RESPONDENTS/WRIT PETITIONERS
9. Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District At Hyderabad
10. Revenue Divisional Officer, Hyderabad East Division Malakunta Gosha Mahal
Hyderabad
11.Tadeti Sai Reddy, S/o Venkat Ram Reddy R/o Bairamalguda Saroornagar
Mandal Ranga Reddy District
'12. Edulakanti Narsimha Reddy, s/o narsis Reddy R/o Bairamalguda Saroornagar
Mandal Ranga Reddy District
13. G Ram Reddy, S/o Narsi Reddy Rio Bairamalguda Saroornagar Mandal
Ranga Reddy District
14. Chakali Venkaiah, S/o Agaiah Rio Karmanghat village Saroornagar Mandal
Ranga Reddy District
15.P Ramanand Guptha, S/o Gunnaiah Gupta R/o Saroornagar village Mandal
RR District
'16.W Raju, S/o Tirupathi Raju Rio Bairam alguda village Saroornagar Mandal
Ranga Reddy District
'17. Smt Devamma
@ Devakamma, Wo Satyanarayana Reddy R/o
18. T. Ramanand guptha, S/o Gunnaiah Guptha R/o Karmanghat
village,Saroornagar Mandal, R.R. District.
'19. Gajasimha
Rao, S/o Anantha Kishan Rao Rio Karmanghat village,
Saroornagar Mandal, R.R. District.
20. Devamma@ Devakamma,
Wo Satyanarayana Reddy, R/o Karmanghat
village, Saroornagar Mandal, R.R. District.
21. Edulakanti Bal Reddy, S/o Narsi Reddy, R/o Bairarnalguda village,
Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
22. Edulakanti Lachma Reddy, So Narsa Reddy R/o Bairam alguda village,
Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
23. G. Ram Reddy, S/o Narsi Reddy R/o Karmanghat village, Saroornagar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy Distriit.
24. Darsi Laxma Reddy, S/o Malla Reddy, Rio Sultan valva village, Saroornagar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
25. Sama Yad Reddy, S/o Mutha Reddy R/o Champapet village, Saroornagar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
26. Sama Bal Reddy, Sio Seetha Reddy. R/o Champapet village, Saroornagar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
27.Sama Kista Reddy, So Yella Reddy R/o Champapet village. Saroornagar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
28. Sama Rami Reddy, S/o Bal Reddy R/o Champapet village Saroornagar
Mandal Ranga Reddy District
29. Seethamma, W/o Yella Reddy R/o Bairam alguda village Saroornagar Mandal
Ranga Reddy District
.
30.Eluventi Anji Reddy, S/o Kistaiah R/o Champapet village Saroornagar Mandal
Ranga Reddy District
31. Elimineti Anji Reddy, S/o Kistaiah R/o Champapet village Saroornagar Mandal
Ranga Reddy District
32. Elimineti Rama Reddy, S/o Kistaiah Rio Champapet village Saroornagar
Mandal Ranga Reddy District
33. Elimineti Buchi Reddy, S/o Janga Reddy Rio Champapet village Saroornagar
Mandal Ranga Reddy Diskict
34.Vennu Prathap Reddy, S/o Yella Reddy Rio Champapet village Saroornagar
Mandal Ranga Reddy District
35.Vennu Prathap Reddy, S/o Yella Reddy Rio Champapet village Saroornagar
Mandal Ranga Reddy District
36. Jakka Balamma,
Wo late Badaru Shivaiah Rio Champapet village
Saroornagar Mandal Ranga Reddy Dist
Dismissed For Defaulty Against RR 11 To 29, 32, 34, To 36
37.T Pradeep Kumar, S/o Late T Ramanath Guptlia Aged about 70 years Occ
Business and Agriculture Rio Karmanghat Siroornagar Mandal Ranga Reddy
District
38.T Vidya Bhushan, s/o Late TRamanath Guptha Aged about 67 years occ
Business and Agriculture Rio Karmanghi Saroornagar Manal Ranga Reddy
District
39.T Virupaksha, S/o Late T Rarnanath Guptha Aged about 67 years occ
Business and Agriculture Rio Karmanghit Saroornagar Manal Ranga Reddy
District
RR 37 to 39 implead as per CO dt 13.09.2023 lA No I of 2022
40. Koyalakonda Sudhakar, S/o Late K Sathaiah Aged about 60 years Occ
Business R/o PNo 549 Vaidehi Nagar Opp Allahabad Bank Saheb Nagar
Kalan Vanasthalipuram Ranga Reddy District
RR 40 implead as per CO dt21.02.2025lA No 1 ol 2025
41. Koyalakonda Ravinder Kumar, So Late K Babaiah Aged about 55 years Occ
PvtEmployee R/o HNo 8-1-238 Old Karmanaghat Village Near Gandhi Statue
Saroornagar Ranga Reddy District
42. Koyalakonda Raj Kumar, S/o Late K Babaiah Aged about 45 years Occ
PvtEmployee R/o HNo 8-1-238 Old Karmanaghat Village Near Gandhi Statue
Saroornagar Ranga Reddy District
43. Koyalakonda Mahender Kumar, S/o Late K Babaiah Aged about 55 years Occ
PvtEmployee R/o HNo 8-1-238 Old Karmanaghat Village Near Gandhi Statue
Saroornagar Ranga Reddy District
44. Koyalakonda DevRaj, S/o Late K Ramulu Aged pbout 45 years Occ
GovtEmployee R/o HNo 8-1-235 Old Karmanaghat Village Near Gandhi
Statue Saroornagar Ranga Reddy District
RR 41 to 44 implead as per CO dt 04122025 lA No 2 of 2022
Respondents Nos 11 to 44 are not necessary parties
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 4OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend
the operation of the order dated 27 -02-2026 in WP.No.'1 1087 of 2004- to the extent
of setting aside the Occupancy Right Certificate issued to Late Mr.Pindi Pulla Reddy
in respect to Acres 03-00 Gts in Sy.No.18 of Karmanghat Village vide proceedings
dated 10-12-1979 in Proc No E1336197..
Counsel for the Appellant: SRI VIVEK JAIN FOR SRI SAMHITHA NIMMALA
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 8: SRI SRINIVASA RAO PUTLURI
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.9&10: SRI MURALIDHAR REDDY KATRAM,
GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.11 lo 44: - - The Court made the following; JUDGMENT
HIGH COURT F
sTATE O F
GAN A
AT HYD E
THE HON1BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI
BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN
KUMAR
WRIT AP PEAL No .642 oF 2026
DATE: 1 7 .o7.2026
Between:
Mr. Pindi Narsimha Reddy and two
othcrs
Appellants
And
Mr Khaja Fahat Flussain and 43 others
Responden ts
\,1r. Vivek Jain, icarncd counsr,l
. cprcscnting Ms Samhirha Njmmala,
learned counsel
appca-ng lor thc appcllanLs.
\4r. Srint,,asa Rar.: porlur.r. iearn(,d coLrnsel
appcarlng lor the respondent Nos. l g
Vr. Muralrdhar Rcdd-! l\..rJm,. tn, rcorn,
d Covcrnment pleadcr [or
appea ng lo. the respono(nt \os o 6no 1g
Revcn ue
JUDGM ENT:
1.
(Per tlon blc Justrce Moushumi
Bhattacharya)
The Writ Appeai has been lilcd against
27 .02.2026 passed b.v- a learned
an order dated
Single Judge of this Court,
allowing W.p.No.I lOgT ol 2OO4 liled by
the respondent Nos.l g
herein, secking a Writ of Certiorari
and to quash a Common
Order dated 03.03 2004 passed by
the Joint Collecror, Ranga
Reddl' District, in several Appeal Cascs,
whereby the Joint
Collcctor conlirmr:d the Occupanc,r, Rights grantcd in favour ol
tht' nrspondct-rIs b.' tht' Rcvcnue Divisional Officer, East
Division. Ranga Rcddr District.
2.
'l'he erppcllants are the sons and legal representatives ol
the respondcnt Nrr. 13 in thc Writ Petition
3.
Bv thc impugncd order dated 27 .02.2026, the learned
Single,luclge alloucd the WriL PcLjtion br, qLrashing thc Contmon
Order clated 03.03.2001 passed br the Joint Coilector. Ranga
Reddl DistricL. and bl sctting aslde thc orders of lhe Revenue
Divisional Ollicer. trast Ili.. isron. Rang:r llcdclr' DistricL ('ltDO)
granting Ocr:upancv Righr Ccrtificates (OIiCs) rn favour of thc
r''spondenr \os..l .1J tirer.irr.
4.
The leirrnecl Sinlllc ,JLrdge also rcmandcd the mattcr to thc
RI)O to concluct a frcsh cnquin anci drspose r,l tht' mattcr in
accordance ,.r'ith 1au'. altcr issuing noti(--es :.o all thc u-ril
p('titioners (, he lcqal hcirs ol thc original inamdtrr), as u.ell as tcr
thc private respondents. and alfording thenr a reasonable
opportr-rni[v of bcing ]'rearc1. Thc RDO u,trs further directed to
rt'cord specilic lindings on all jurisdictional iacts, including
posscssron as on 0 1 I 1 1973, and to ('ompl( te lhc r:xcrcise
rr
ithin six rnontl'rs from the dzrte o1 rcc(-.ipl ol a copl of the
in.rpugned o:-clcr.
J
5.
Learned counsei appearing for lhe appellants submits
that the proceedings before the RDO attained finality in 2008
upon deletion of thc u.rit petilioners' holding and in vierv of the
lailure oi thc u,rit pcritioncrs/legal heirs of the original inamdar
to question the said dcletion procecdings. Counsel furlher
submits that the respondent No. I3 in rhc Writ Petition (the
lather of thc writ appellants) passed a\.\,'ay on 04.09. 1991, which
ought to have becn takcn into considcration by the learned
Single .Judge as a fundamental defect in granting any relief
against thc respondent No. 13.
6.
The respondcnt Nos. I 8 (writ petitioners) are represented
7.
After hearing lcarncd counscl appcarlng for the partics
and considcring the fact that the learned Single Judge has
directed the RDO ro arrive at a final decision onl1. after issuing
notice and affording a sufficient opportunity of being heard to
all the concerned parties, we deem it fit to disposc of the Wnt
Appeal by drrecting thc RDO to specifically consider the
submissions made b1'' the appellants on behalf of the
respondent No.13 in the Writ Petition, rvith regard to the failure
ol writ petitioncrs/lcgai heirs of the original inamdar to
challenge the delction ol holdings rn 2008 and the disputed
questions having attaincd finalitf in 2008 itsel[. The RDO shall
-+
also take into consideralion the fact that the respondent No
in the Writ Petrlion (the father of the appellants) passed awav in
lggl.u,hereasthewrltPetitionrt.asliledin2004seekingrelief
against several respondents, including the responrlent No 13'
8.
Since the impugne d Common Orcier dated 27 02 2026
has bcen challcngeci b-r rlal ol the prcsent Writ Appcal' r'u'e deem
it appropriale to extend the tlme granted b1' the learned Single
Judge to the RDO to dispose of the matter' The RDO shall
dispose of rhc miitter n irhrn stx months frorn thc date of reccipt
ol a copy of this order' Needless to sa)', an'u' sL(rps taken up b]-
anr authoriLl . including the RDO, in relation to the subject
matter of disputc, shall remain stayed until the matter is finally
drsposed of br rhe RDO bi passing a rcasoncd order, as directed
by Lhe learnecl Srnglc Judge.
9.
W.A.No 642
of 2026, along "r'ith all
connected
app[cations, rs accordrngll disposed of tn lerms of Lhe above
There shall bc no ordcr as to costs.
RAO
Sd/.NAYANI CHANDRA SEKHAR
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
,/TRUE COPY//
SECTI ON OFFICER
To,
District At Hyderabad
The Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy'
Malakunta Gosha
Officer Hyderabad East Division
2 The Revenue Divisional
Mahal HYderabad
3. One CC to SRt SAMHTTHA N|MMALA, Advocate tOpUCl
4. One CC to SRt SRTNIVASA RAO PUTLUR|, Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two ccs to GP FoR REVENUE, High court for the state of rerangana at
Hyderabad . [OUT]
6. Two CD Copies
PMK
HIGH COURT
CC TODAY
DATED: 1710712026
JUDGMENT
1 HE ST4 14:
?
)
WA.No.642 ot 2026
17.t!!r 2!i?6
I
{.
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
q
1 'iL
\:J.
.P
:,/
/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review