Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34sl I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF J(JLY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
WRIT APPE AL NO: 148 40F 2025
writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Appeal filed against the
order Dated 14t1112025 passed in writ petition No.17884 of 2025 on the file of the
High Court
Between:
of Sri Abid Hussain @ Sri Abid
years,
Dealer and-Proprietor of M/sV|MAL
Uuiiain Agarwal, aged about 38
FILLING SfnloN, carrying on business at Nos 5 and 6, Tandur Road'
Dharur-501121, Vikarabad iistrict, Resident of H.No24-389, Ranga Reddy
Nagar, QuthubullaPur, HYderabad
MT MOHD.MUZAFFAR HUSSAIN' son
vrT.lvinanr- FILLING SrRrtoru, Rep. by its Proprietor and Dealer
Mr.Mohd.MuzaffarHussain,sonofSriAbidHussain@SriAbidHussain
ng"*"1 aged about 38 years, carrying on business at Nos 5 and 6' Tandur
n"o"o, on"ir"501121, Vikarabad District, Resident of H No 24-389' Ranga
ReddyNagar,Quthubullapur,Hyderabad.
...A,'ELLANT',pETtloNERS
AND
INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LIMITED, (a Government of lndia enterprise),
R6.6y it. Cn"it."n and Managing-Director' having its Regd Office at G-9'
Bandra (East), Mumbai -400051
Ali Yavar Jung Marg,
-DIRECTOR
AND STATE HEAD, Telangana and Andhra
2 iHe exEcuilvE
at-lndian
Pradesh State office, lndian oil Corporation Limited, having its office
Sanath
Estate'
OiL Bn.rrn, Fateh Bagh, Moosapet, Kukatpally lndustrial
Nagar (Post), Hyderabad-5000'18.
...REspoNDENTs ,RESpoNDENTs
t.A. NO: 10F 2025
in
'1
Petition under Section 15 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
theaffidavitfiledinsupportofthepetition'theHighCourtmaybepleasedto
suspend the Order / Judgment dt-1411112025 in WP No'17884/2025 passed by the
Learned Single Judge of this Honorable Court till the disposal of main Appeal
Counsel for the Appellants: SRI MANU
Counsel for Respondents: SRI DOMINIC FERNANDES
SC FOR IOCL
The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
HIGH COUR T FOR TH E STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDE RABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
.
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
WRIT APPEAL NO.1 484 0F 2025
DATET L6.O7.2026
Between
Mohd. Muzaffar Hussain and Another
Appellants
And
lndian Oil Corporation Limited, rep. by its
Chairman & Managing Director and Another
Respondents
Mr. Manu, lcarncd counsel appcaring lor thc appcllants.
Mr. Dominic Fernandes, thc lcarnt:d Standing Cou nsel for lOCl- appearing for the
respondents.
JUDGMENT:
1.
(Per llon'ble Jusrrce \loushLrmr tshaLlacharya)
The present Writ Appeal arises out olan order passed by the learned
Single Judge on 14.11.2025 dismissing W.p.No.I7884 of 2025, filed by the
appellants/writ petitioners witb liberty to the appellants to avail the remedy
provrded undcr thr: Dcalcrshrp AgrcemcnL clatccl 22.12.2O2O cxecuted
between thc partles.
2.
Thc appellants filed rhe Wrir. [,e tition praving fbr a Writ of Mandamus
against thc rermination Ierler dated O6.06.2O25 issued by the respondent
No.1/tndian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCLJ and for quashing of the same.
The appellants also pral'ed for a declaratron with regard to the IOCL
stopping tl.i e suPPIr oI NloLor Spirit & High SpeeC I)rcsel (MS & HSI)') to the
appellant No.2 /w'rit pelilirrncr No.2 lrom 05.05 2025 dcsprte receivtng an
amount oi Rs.12,70.0OO '- irom Lhe appellants/u'rit' petitioners for the
suPPll, of N4S & HSD
3.
The learned Srnele,ludge clismissccl thc Writ Pctltion on, rnter atru, the
grouncl that the Dcalership Agrcement binds the parties to the terms of the
contract and tl-rc appe.llanrs apprchension ln availing the remedial
mechanisnr lrndt'r tlte Dclrlc.rshrp Agrr)cme11l is barsclcss The learncd Singlc
Judge also found that thcre is no procedural rml)roprillLv in the impugned
tcrmination order dated 06.06.2025.
4.
l,e:Lrned couttsel appcanng lor lhc appcllants urgcs that the
responde nt No. 1 l locl- and its Executive DirccLor hacl i iolared Lhc principles
of natural jusrice bv being-]urlges in their o$,n cause. counsel submits that
the Deputv C}encral lvlar-lttgcr. Scc:r:ndcrabad. Sri Abhishek Chou'dhary, l*''as
prcsCnt :lt thc pcrs()r-tal hcanng c'Oncluctcd br thc olficers oI thr: respondent
No.1/IOCL on 17.02.2025 and that there $'as even likelihr)od thal the
Deput]' (ieneral Manager influenced the decision of thc Executive Director to
pass tlrc te rminat ttrn orcler against rhe appellernl s
the pr.ocedurr: acloPte:cl u as,
he nc:e,
unfttir attd
Counscl submrts that
Lrnl
ust and that the
appellitnts \\'ere noL qivetl anr opport u nl[]-' to rnltlate rrrbitration proceedings
before the impugned letter ol termination rt.as issued to the appellants on
06.06.l()25. Counsel submiIs thaI cven olhcrwis('. lhe rcrmination \vas
amen:rble to juilicial re'ricrr sinc:e thcre utrs no iinding of deliberate
tampering u'ith the drspernsing uniL or deficiency'in delivery of fuel and the
stock variations of MS & HSD were found to be within permissible limits in
an earlier inspection conducted by authorised GVR technicians on
16.11.2023. lt is also submirrcd thar rhe learned Single Judge failed t<.r
consider several matters of factual importance including that the respondent
No. 1/ IOCL had not grven any' adverse comments
in the said earlier
inspection. It is also submitted that the statutory remedy in the instant
case is illusory and incifcctive and thal the Marketing Discipline Guidelines
('MDG) of IOCL do nor havc any statutory force.
5.
Learned Standing Counsel appearrng for the respondent No.1/IOCL
objects to the maintainabrlitl ol thc Writ I)eLition. Counsel submits rhat thc
appellants have an appellate remedy available to them under the MDG
which were followed by the respondent No.1/IOCL in issuing the show cause
notice on 28.O8.2024. Counsel also submits that the appellants were given
a personal hearing and the replies given by the appellanLs were duly
considered and that respondent No.l/lOCl, passed a reasoned order of
termination in accordance with the Deaiership Agreement as w'ell as the
MDG. Counsel relies on Clausc 8.9 ol the MDG u,hich, inter alia, provides
for a right of the Dealer to appeal before lhe appellate authorig through the
concerned Divisional, Territorial or Regional Office of the Oil Marketing
Company li'ithrn 30 da1,s from the date of the receipt of an order of
termination arising out ol invocarion of the MDG, Counsel also relies on an
amended appellate Clause made by t\.a-v.' of a Policy Circular dated
18.O5.2024 making thc appellatc procedure tairer than the earlier Clause
8.9. Counsel submirs lhat in ar)y evcnt, the relationship betu'ecn the
parties is purelr,'contrilctuill in nature and thc Writ Corrt dor:s not have to
intervene 1n contra('tual lnitIcrs tlhere lhc pa:ties ilrc bound bv their
obligations as given unde l hc tcrms of the contra(.t.
6.
Thc- dates rclc\,ant Lo thc adjudrcation are bricflv staled belou,
22.12 2020
D,:alcrship Agreement execu:ed betueen the appellant No.1 and
the respondent i\*o.1i'lndian Oi1 Corporation Limiled (.lOCL,) ior
a pe:rocl of l5 r ears till 2 1. l2 2C35
16. i 1.2023
GVR Sen ice Technicians (authorised agents of IOCL) visited the
rr'tarl oiltlct lor calibration ar,d ;Lnnual stamplng ir.t the presence
ol r h(, ,\ L\l O
21 01.202+
Panclranarra conducted and thc.+ Member Committec (3 from
IOCI. ancl 1 Irom GVR) insp,:cted the Retail Ourlet in the
pr(,set-t( e oi tht- Dcaler.
26.06 202 t
\lr. Shaik Az1.z, Lhe brother of Cealer ,,,"as ph-r sicallr present at
(',\'R s 'IACC lab il Coimbato-r' as 'deaier reprcsentati\e, for
\\ rin('ssinq tlre handing over ar.,.l opentng of sealed box
I
9.07 202 1
28.08.202.+
(;\ li s L ,\(lC Laborator\ lleport
Shou Cause Notice issued bv the Corporation for'lermination of
L)e;ilership Asreement.
30.08 202.+
I?cplr ro Shorv Cause Notice
t7 .a2.2A2r
I)ersonal Hearing conducled and rninuLes of the personal
Ilerrrirrg conciucrted rn thc presellce ()l (il Oxecutive Director &
Starc IIcad. IAPSO. (ii) GeneraLl Manrtger (Retail Sales). (iii) Dv.
(ieneral Nlanager, Secunderabad Divrsional Olficer, (iv) Sr.
!lanager (Lar,,), Tr\PSO, (r.l Appcll,rnt No 1 it)ealer of the
.\p;)cl:a n t \o.2)
06.06 2 02..l
I'ermrnarron of Dcalership r\gr..cment dateLl 2 ). I 2.2O2O
l+.112(r.2.i
,)r,ler Dasscd b-\ the Learned Srngle,lr_rclgc rn W.p.No.17gg.l ol
.lil .I :
7.
Thc abor,c seqllcncc ol events $,ould indicate that the fact of
[amper]ng \\'as not ascertained b1 u'a' of a solitary onc-time exercise but on
[rvo slrccessive cccasiolts. First, \r.hcn a regular inspcction/annual
calibration process rr-as undertaken on 16. l l.2023 bv the dcsrgnated team
of GVR tcchniciarrs. rn lhr_' prcs.nce ol thc Assistaltt I_egal Metrolog,. Olfice r
(ALMO), where the team noticed tampering with the dispensing unit.
Second, on 24.O1.2024 u,hen a Panchanama was conducted and the Four
Member Commit[ec again inspected the Retail Outlct in thc presence of the
Dealer and seized certain parts ol the dispensing units, and thereafter sent
them in a sealed box to the TACC Laboratory at Coimbatore in J.une 2024
for examination that took place in the presence of the brother of the Dealer
on 26.06.2024.
8.
The evidence was also given to the TACC Laboratory lor proper
verification. IOCL issued the Shou, Cause Notice to the appellants for
Termination of the Dealcrship Agrecmcnt onll' after all of the aforesaid
stages, The Sho'"r' Causc Notice issued oo 28.O8 2024 rr"'as also followed by a
personal hearing given to the writ appellant No.1/Dealer of the Retail Unit in
the presence ol Four High-ranking Officers of IOCL on \7.O2 2025
g.
The Minutes of lhe Pcrsonal Hearing dated 17.02.2025 show that the
appellant No.1 (Dealer of the appellant No.2, i.e., M/s. Vimal Filling Station)
!\,as present in person and his representation was taken on record The
Minules rccord thal copies of thc Minutes oi the Box Opening conducted at
the Laboratory at Coimbatorc, dated 26062024, wcrc also taken on record,
and appellant No.I acknou'ledged the signature of Mr' Shaik Aziz (his
brother), who represented thc Retail Outlet Dealcrship on that daLe. The
Termination Noticc datcd 06.06.2025 u'as issued only thereafter.
O. The complaint of the appellants with regard to the violation of the
principles of natural justice rs baseless as all the above mentioned slages of
procedurc. urhich rcsult.cl rn rhe Sholu Causc Notice and thereafter the
Terminatlor.r N"orice. rie-re in .rccordancc uith thi: Ill)(1. It is relcvant to nole
that the Dealership Asreemenr stipulares thar rhc l)cdler is to abide bv the
MDG,
1. Cl:ruse 45(k) ol rl'rc Dcalershrp Agrcerncnt provrdcs that the
Corporation (IOCI-) shall bt'at libert-r'to terminatc.rhc Agrccmcnt, including
in cases uhcre rhe l)calcr docs not adhcrr: to the instruc rions / guideline s
issued from time 1o ttme br thc Corporation (IOCL) in connection u.ith
Nlarketinq I)rscrplrnL: arr.l i or salc practiccs to trc iollorvcd b.r' the Dcaler in
the sale. suppir'. antl storaqc of the Corporatior-r's products or otheru,ise
.
12. The MDG. u,rth eflecr from 2,1.1O.2O2q, is on record. Clause 5. 1.4 of
the MD(i proriclcs lbr r,rn indcpcndcnt opinron of the Original trquipment
Manufac'turcr ({)EM) ir cases of unauthoriscd [ittrngs/gears lound in
dispensing unirs or ramJrering s.ith a dispensing unit. Clause g.2 of the
Ml)G prr>vides litr thc pr1111j5lmcnt for violation ol CIausc 5. 1.4 ri,ith regarcl
to crirrc:;rl lrrcqul:Lrities . 'l he ai'rion lor such ir-rcgularities is "l'crmination
at the FIRST ir-rstzrnct:'. Clausc 5. 1.4 *.as amended in 2022 to provide lor
the likelihood of manrpultrtion rriLh rcgard to dclivcn,.
13 wc no',r' consider r he question as to the mainLainabirit!. of the writ
Petition.
(11:rusc 8.9.I rhe Ml)() pro'ides Ibr 'Appcllate procecdings'.
clause
8.9 is sr,'t ou1 belo\\
"ln case o.f terminatton arisitlg out of inuocatrcn of MDA, the dealer uill haue the ight
to appeal Luithin a penod of 30 dags Jrom the dote of receipt of order, before the
Appetlote AuthoitA. throuqh tlLe corcerned Diuisional/ Territory/ Regional ofrtce oI lhe
Al Marketirtg Cornpany (OMC). The Appellate AuthoitA is empoluered to decide the
matter and the appeat shall be disposed of preferabty within 9O days from the dote of
fitlinq the appeal ir the Diuistornl/ Territory / Reoional office of the concerned OMC
Forallappeatsfiled'bgtheDealer(s)onterminationoftheirRodea[ershipdueto
inuocatton' of MbC except termtnation in case of SC/ ST dealerships, the appellate
quthonty *iu b. th" ED (Reto]il) in the Head olftce or ang other ED leuel offi'cer at the
Head Offce so nominated bA the companA,"
15. The above clause makcs iI clear that the Dealer (the writ appellants) ls
entitled to approach the Appellate Authorit) through the prescribed route.
clause 8.9 also provrdes lor the timc period for the disposal of the appeal.
Clause 8.9 was amended b-v a Policy Circular dated 18'05 2024 The
following part was added to Clause 8 9 after the amendment'
". .uhere tenntnation is by approuing authoritA belou' the rank of ED in the State
OfJice. Houeuer, tf the termtnaiwn is by approving authoritA of the rank of ED in the{iate OfJice, then'the appellate authoiig LUiII be a committee of 2 EDs' so nomrnated
bA the companA."
16. The addition to Clausc 8.9, hence, makcs the Appellatc Authoritll
more broad-based and minimiscs thc probability of any kind of influence or
personal interest being exertecl by the Appellale Authority ln the present
case, the Termination Notice datcd 06.06.2025 was issued by the Executive
Director and State Head of locl. Hence, the Appellate Authority in the
prescnt case \\'ould consisl. of a Commrttce ol two Executive Directors
nominated by IOCL.
.
The conclusion v!,oul.l then be that the writ. appellants/ $'rit petitioners
have an Appeltate I'orum u'ilhrn the frameu'ork oi Lhc MDG The MDG
forms part ol the Dealership Agreement $'hich binds the parties Hence'
the
appellants cannor sa\ t:rar rhe writ court is thcrr onlr recourse against the
impugnld Tcrm ina rron \, ,'ir c.
18. Tirer sourcc oi the appclrarlrs'apprehension is thert the appe llant No.1's
la tl-rcr had lodgcd a conplainr against Sri Abhishck cho*.dhary..
white this
courl is n.t irr.lirrr:d ro clislodg. thc point ol'a. alt<,rnaLrvc remedv being
avtrilable to the aLppellants, u'c cieem ir necessan to record the eipprehension
expresscd lrv thc appellanrs against Sri Abhishek Chorvdharv.
19. In anr c,,cnr. thrt scopc of lnter\.cntion b., a Wrrt CourL in respect ol
contractual m.fters is extrcmerr. limited, if not absent altogether. The writ
court can int€ r'en(' ri'hcri,. ri>r example, rhe Dealership is tcrminated on an
irrelcv.nt or no. exist(,'t caLlsci. Ncedlcss to sal\., the f)ealershtp
AgreemcnL has to
br, c.erncclled sLricth rn consonance with the
rules/euidelines r'ramed bv Lhe IocL/oil company. The High court
cannot
act as an Appellatc Aurhorrrr in disciprinary procecdings or re appreciate
thc er rdencc bt'Lre thc I'-.quin' ofricer, 'r'he High courI c.1n onlv step
u'here thcre rs a r iolal ion 01' the principles of ,aturar justice,
or the enquirl
is c.n Lran' to th(, proccd ure prescribccl in tha t bcha lf, .r e'en *.herc
authorities *'ere influen.eci bv irrele'ant or extraneorrs co n sideratron
that tho deriven,was
petroleum Caroorotton Ltmited
l?rl?r:.tian
'. :!:.r,:,
2024 (3)ALD s66 lrS)
v Dhoromnoth Singh 12C24 SCCOnLine SC 9871
L,ntteo ord Othprs v puntob Motat St-ore ord Another..2022
1lB)
a
sp^c iiic finding thar rhc
Inspec'tion Report of IOCL cortained a clear recording
'. Hindustoo
the
s:.
20. ln ('hoirn.cut cq, ,X/.1)., IOCL, Neut Delhi tt Ramlal Aganual..,
Co-ordinatc Bench o1' this Court came to.i
in
SCC OnLine p&H 42791
found to be 'ok' from both the HSD nozzles of the dispensing unit The
Division Bench accordingly held thar the findings of the learned Single
Judge were in consonancc with the Inspection Report and that the
Termination No[ice was hencc illegal and arbitrary'
21. In the present case, there were at least two Inspections held in
November 2023 and,.Ianuary 2024, respectively which founcl [ampering'
The sealed Box containing the parts of the dispensing unit was
handed over
ro the TACC Lab in coimba[ore in J une 2024 after the two inspections
Laboratory confirmed that the Show Cause Notice issued to
The
the writ
petitioners in August 2024 was pursuant to the examination
report
confirming tamperrng u'ith the dispensing unit'
22. ln Hindustan Petroleum corporotion Ltd. u. M/ s. Hoji Abdul Rehmana '
Drvision Bench ol the erstwhile united Andhra Pradesh High
specific avermcnt of the u rit petitioner that the weights
Court noted a
and measures seal
was found broken at the hands ol the Quality Control Ofhcer'
found a divergence of opinion on this issue and held
against the writ petitioner' The Division Bench also
deviation lrom thc contractual obligations ol
be established upon a tarr enquiry and
Iay with the Oil
by the Oil Company
found that the fact of
the re sponden ts / dealers must
that the extreme step of termination
cannot unilaterally be taken by the Oil Companv
'zorQ (r) nLo qer
The Court
that the burden to
prove the tampering at the hands ol the r'l'rit petitioner
Company since the original allegation had been madc
a
23. In ti'ls contexl . it rr.a\ be rt'lcvant 1o note that the MDG relel'ant to the
present case crame inlo c lfcc t in 2O24. u'hcrcas the decision ol rhe Division
Bench of tl're Andhri Pratlesh flrgh Courl that \ras reliccl upon is of 20 10. It
is settlerl that a Wrir Crrurt c'an cntertain a Writ Petition despite the
existencc of an altcr-n:rtir e e lficacious remedl' s'here there has bcen a breach
of the principies of natural justrce, an absence of jurisdiction. or a breach of
fundamental righrs. The prcsent casc docs lrot concc-rn anl of the above
contrngencics Hence, u e .rcccpt- the argumcr)t made on behalf of the
responclcnts rhat the prcs('nt Writ Petition is not maintainablc since the
appellauts/$.rit peririoncrs have an cfficacious rcmedl under C)iause 8.9 of
the MDC) for carrylng rheir grievance to the AppeLlate Authoritl'.
24.
We accordtngll do not lind ant crror in thc impugned order passed bv
the learned Srnglc, Judgc u he re the Court pnmarilr. r-elied on the Appellate
Mechanism providcd uncler rhc MDG and thc, u rit petitioners' failure to
demonstrarc an.n' r ir>laLiorr of rhc principles ol natural .lustice, malafide intent
or marrifest injusrrcr:. \,\'r, also note thar Claulsc 61(a) ol thc Dealership
Agreemcnr provides for Arbirratron br, the l)ircctor (Markcting) of IOCL. The
appellants also complain abour rhe likel.ihood of a conllict of interest in this
respeiL. Although the stage of Arbirration hirs nor been reached )et, $'e
deem it sorLhuhile to calltion thc rr:sponclcnt No. 1/IOCL that thc
Arbitration must bc c onclucLcd. if and r','hen ir is done, in accordance r.vith
the settled lau' laid clort,r-r b.,, rhc Supreme cc,u1s-1 11r15 regard to unilateral
appoiltl mCltl oi .llt ,\r:)rr r.rtor.
25 we also deem rt fit to mcntion that thc respondent No. 1/rocl shalr
takc all sreps to obviate the apprehension of bias and likelihood of influence
on Lhe part of thc appcllants with regard to the' participation of
Mr. Abhishek chowdhary in the Disciplinary proceedings even before the
Appellate Authority.
26. Notwithstanding our advice to the respondent No.1/rocL as stated
abovc, we do not find an1'ground to intcrfcre with the views of the learned
single Judge as expressed in the impugned ordcr dated 14. lr.2o2s. we
also hold that the appeliants have a structured Appeal Mechanism/Forum
under Clause 8.9 of the Marketing Discipline Guidelines, which the
appellants must llrst exhaust. we extend thc time Lill 07 .0g.2026 for the
appellants to approach the Appellate Authority.
27 .
w A. No. 1484 of 2025 is accordingll' dismissed for the reasons stated
above, including rhe facr that thc writ l)eLition is not maintainable in the
hrst place. All connectcd applications are dismissed. Interim orders, if any,
shall stand vaca[ed. 'l'here shall bc no order as to costs.
Sd /.NAYANI CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO
EPUTY REGISTRAR
/ITRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFTCER
To,
..tLrng lvlarg. Bandra (East), Mumbai
(a
The Chairman and Managing Director, lndian Oil
-Limited."
Office at G-9' Ali Yavar
Regd
its
having
enteipri"se;,
lndia
of
Government
Corporation
- 40005'l '
and Andhra Pradesh
The Executive Director nnd state Head, Telangana office at lndian oil
iLL;;, i"dian oit co'poiation Limited' having its
Kukatpallv lndustrial Estate' Sanath Nagar
;;;;";, i;i"h aagt ' lvlooslpet,
8'
(Post). Hvderabad-50001
3. bn" CC io Sri Manu Advocate [OPUC]
io 5ii oor"i"i" Fernandes (si FoR locL) Advocate [oPUC]
4.
5. Two CD CoPies
tM BC
N\
il; &
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1610712026
(
o
r-)
1 HE
STA 14:
17 ,!ilt ?tr26
\,
{ l.
\..,,
\.* ..
\_..
JUDGMENT
WA.No.1484 of 2025
DISMISSING THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
?I
L
\a
yr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review