Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM, GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HON’BLE SHRI SATISH KUMAR AGNIHOTRI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2014
1.
Mr. Angu Lepcha,
R/o Upper Zangu, North Sikkim.
Head Constable, General Duty (HC/GD)
Serving at SHQ SSB Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Mr. Karma Wangyal Bhutia,
R/o Upper Tathangchen, Gangtok,
East Sikkim,
Head Constable, General Duty (HC/GD)
Serving at: 46 Bn. SSB Rhenock, East Sikkim.
3.
Mr. Baichung Bhutia,
R/o Jalipool, East Sikkim.
Constable, General Duty (CT/GD)
Serving at: 52 Bn. SSB Yuksom, West Sikkim.
…
Petitioners
Versus
1.
The Director General,
Sashastra Seema Bal
East Block-V, R.K. Puram,
New Delhi-110066,
2.
The Secretary (Ministry of Home Affairs),
Government of India,
North Block, Raisina Hill,
New Delhi.
3.
The Secretary (Ministry of Finance)
Government of India,
North Block, Raisina Hill,
New Delhi.
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
4.
The Deputy Inspector General,
Sector Head Quarter, SSB, Gangtok
Shamlee Building, Development Area,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…
Respondents
WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance :
Mr. A.K. Upadhyaya, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Aruna
Chettri, Advocate for the Petitioners.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Government Advocate
with Ms. Pollin Rai, Advocate for the Respondents.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(29.06.2016)
SATISH KUMAR AGNIHOTRI, J.
1.
Assailing the purported withdrawal of payment of
Special Duty Allowance (for short “SDA”) while working in the
North Eastern Region including Sikkim (for short “NER”), when
posted outside NER, the instant Petition has filed.
2.
The Petitioners are stated to be Head Constables/
Constable, serving in the Respondent force/Sashastra Seema
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
Bal (for short “SSB”), have come up with the instant Petition
seeking a direction to continue with the payment of SDA, as
aforestated, to them.
3.
The facts in nutshell, as posited by the Petitioners
are that the Petitioners were getting SDA for the entire period of
their attachment/temporary duty outside NER, when they were
having their declared Headquarters in the NER.
It is further
stated
Government
that
the
employees
of
other
Central
Organizations, having posted in the NER are receiving SDA while
they proceed on tour to places outside the NER. The Petitioners
further urged that the Respondents, by Circular bearing No.
1/20/2008/SSB/PERS-II/2981-3065
dated
22.02.2011,
withdrew the said SDA, arbitrarily without any rationale or
reason. Thus, this Petition.
4.
Mr.
A.K.
Upadhyaya,
learned
Senior
Counsel,
assisted by Ms. Aruna Chettri, learned Advocate appearing for
the Petitioners, would submit that the Petitioners have been
enjoying the SDA for their posting outside the NER when their
declared Headquarter was NER.
It is further urged that other
person working in other forces, have been enjoying the said
SDA. Thus, discontinuation of payment of SDA is unreasonable,
arbitrariness and discriminatory.
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
5.
Opposing this submission, per contra, Mr. Karma
Thinlay, learned Central Government Counsel assisted by Ms.
Pollin Rai, learned Advocate, appearing for the Respondents,
would submit that no members of Para Military Forces and other
Organizations are receiving any SDA for their posting outside
the NER when their declared Headquarter is NER.
Referring to
the Circular dated 21.12.2012 issued by the Ministry of Home
Affairs, learned Central Government Counsel, would contend
that non-grant of SDA to all the employees headquartered at
NER
while
posted
outside
the
NER
is
clear
from
the
endorsement of the said Circular to all the Para Military Forces.
It is further contended that the submission of the Petitioners
that the members of other Central Government employees and
members of other forces are getting SDA for posting outside the
NER is without any basis as no document to this effect has been
produced
by
the Petitioners.
Mr.
Karma Thinlay,
lastly
contended that non-payment of SDA to the employees posted
outside the NER is a policy decision of the Central Government,
which may not be interfered with by this Court.
6.
Having given my anxious consideration to the
submission advanced by the learned counsel for the parties,
perused the pleadings and documents appended thereto, it is
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
evident that no circular or document is placed on record which
indicates that any member of any Para Military Force or Central
Government employees headquartered at NER is receiving SDA
for their posting outside the NER.
7.
The Para Military Forces like, Border Security Force
(BSF), Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), Central Reserve
Police
Force
(CRPF),
Indo
Tibetan
Border
Police
(ITBP),
Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB) (the concerned force), National
Security Guards (NSG) and Assam Rifles (AR) are working under
the umbrella of Ministry of Home Affairs with the sole purpose to
quell the public disorder, when local police failed and proved
ineffective and also to assist the Army depending on their place
of posting, while guarding the borders of India.
8.
The Ministry of Home Affairs, Director General, SSB,
vide Memo dated 21.11.2007 took a decision on non-payment
of allowances admissible in NER to the personnel attached at
Force Hqrs. New Delhi, which reads as under: “SUB:
NON-PAYMENT
OF
ALLOWANCES
ADMISSIBLE IN NORTH EAST REGION TO
THE PERSONNEL ATTACHED AT FORCE
HQRS. NEW DELHI.
It has been noticed that some of the field units
are discontinuing the allowances admissible in North
East Region to the personnel attached on temporary
duty at Force Hqrs or out of their jurisdiction.
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
2.
This matter has been examined in depth with
reference to the rules provision on the matter at Force
Hqrs. and it has not been decided that as per provision
of para-III of Appendix – 9 of FR SR Part-1, Special Duty
Allowance will not be admissible during the period of
leave training beyond 15 days at a time and beyond 30
days in a year. The personnel posted in N.E. Region
presently attached at Force Hqrs. or else where on
temporary duty or other words will be treated on tour/
temporary duty and as such are entitle to their pay and
allowances as admissible in North East Region for the
entire period of their attachment on temporary duty.
3.
9.
This issues with the approval of D.G. (SSB).”
Thereafter the issue was clarified vide Circular No.
1/20/2008 / SSB/PERS-II/2981-3065 dated 22.02.2011, which
reads as under: “No. 1/20/2008/SSB/PERS-II/2981-3065 dated 22nd Feb. 2011.
CIRCULAR
Subject: -
Non payment of Special Duty Allowance
It has been observed that personnel posted in
North East Region and attached at FHQ or elsewhere are
being paid Special Duty Allowance (SDA) as admissible
in NE-Region for the entire period of their attachment,
which has invited audit objections. As per MHA, OM
No. A.I.3/Inst-Acctts-3/PF.III dated 03/08/2005 it has
been clarified that these allowance would be admissible
only to the personnel who are actually working in the
NE-Region.
2.
A person on attachment at a location and
establishment where Special Duty is admissible will be
entitled to it.
However, a person whose declared
Headquarters is in such location/establishment and
proceeds on attachment to a location/establishment
where the allowance is not admissible, will be ineligible
for the said allowance during the period of attachment.
3.
The Director General, SSB has approved to ensure
compliance of orders and stop payment of Special Duty
Allowance to personnel posted to North East Units but
not actually working there. It has also been approved to
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
draw up a comprehensive list of all individuals involved
and amount to be recovered etc. The same information
may be provided to FHQ at the earliest so that a
decision on how the recovery should be made is taken
accordingly.
This issues with the approval of DG, SSB.”
10.
Subsequently, Ministry of Home Affairs, vide Circular
21.12.2012 on the advice of Ministry of Finance, reiterated the
decision of non-grant of SDA to the employees serving in the
NER States (including Sikkim) and UTs when they are posted
outside the NER. The Circular reads as under: -
“Sub: Grant of Transport Allowance, HRA and SDA to
the CAPF personnel during the period of their
attachment with offices/establishments other than
their declared headquarters, at the rates as
admissible at the place where they are attached.
Based on proposal of CRPF, a proposal for grant of
Transport Allowance/HRA/SDA to all the personnel of
CAPFs and AR during the period of their attachment with
offices/ establishments other than their declared
headquarters, at the rates as admissible at the place
where they are attached, was recommended by MHA to
Ministry of Finance.
2.
Ministry of Finance (Deptt. Of Exp.), vide their ID
Note No. 2(20)/2011-E.II(B) dated 09.02.2012, advised
the following:
“It is clarified that HRA/Tpt Allowance are
regulated w.r.t. the place of duty and not on the
basis of attachment. Para 4(b)(xi) of MoF’s OM
dated 27.11.1965, as amended from time to time,
provides that “During the period of transfer not
exceeding 90 days, HRA/CCA is admissible at old
duty station rates and during the periods of
transfer exceeding 90 days, HRA/CCA is to be
regulated w.r.t. the new HQ.
For temporary
transfer, initially made for a period not exceeding
90 days, but later extended beyond this period,
the benefit of the provision contained in Para
4(b)(x) shall be allowed from the date of issue of
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
the order converting the transfer into a
permanent one or at the end of 90 days,
whichever is earlier.” The limit of 90 days for
treating a transfer as temporary transfer which
has been raised to 180 days for the purpose of
drawal of Daily Allowance has not been extended
to 180 days for the purpose of drawal of HRA/CCA
during temporary transfer prescribed in Para 4
(b)(xi). Special (Duty) Allowance is granted to
the eligible Central Government employees
serving in the N.E.R. States (including Sikkim)
and UTs of A & N and Lakshadweep group of
islands.
As the proposal of MHA for grant of HRA,
Transport Allowance & SDA on attachment basis is
contrary to the extant instructions on grant of
these allowances, the same is NOT agreed to.
3.
The proposal was again taken up with MoF
for reconsideration by treating the place of attachment
of the attached CAPF personnel as their place of duty.
4.
However, MoF, vide ID Note No. 2(2)/2011E.II(B) dated 11.12.2012, has reiterated that the
proposal of MHA for grant of HRA, Transport Allowance &
SDA on attachment basis is contrary to the extant
instructions on grant of these allowances, and therefore,
NOT agreed to.
5.
This issues with the approval of MoF (Deptt.
Of Exp.) vide ID Note No. 2(20)/2011-E.II(B) dated
09.02.2012 and 11.12.2012 and integrated Division of
this Ministry, vide their CF No. 76768 dated
19.12.2012.”
11.
This Circular was made applicable to all the Para
Military Forces from the date of endorsement made therein.
From the aforestated various Circulars, it is eloquent that the
Ministry of Home Affairs had taken a policy decision not to grant
SDA to the members of all Para Military Forces who are already
getting SDA while posted at their declared Headquarters at NER
(including Sikkim) while posted temporarily outside the NER.
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
I
do
not
find
any
infirmity,
illegality,
arbitrariness
or
unreasonableness as pleaded by the Petitioners.
12.
The next question arises as to whether the policy
decision as aforestated is required to be interfered with by the
Court in exercising of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
13.
It is beneficial to refer certain observations made by
the Supreme Court in this respect.
In
Premium
Granites
and another vs. State of T.N. and others1 wherein the Rule
39 of T.N. Mineral Concession Rules, 1959 was under assail, the
Supreme Court held as under:
“54. It is not the domain of the court to embark
upon unchartered ocean of public policy in an exercise to
consider as to whether a particular public policy is wise
or a better public policy can be evolved. Such exercise
must be left to the discretion of the executive and
legislative authorities as the case may be. The court is
called upon to consider the validity of a public policy
only when a challenge is made that such policy decision
infringes fundamental rights guaranteed by the
Constitution of India or any other statutory right.
……………………”
---------------------------1
(1994) 2 SCC 691
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
14.
In M.P. Oil Extraction and another vs. State of
M.P. and others2, the fixation of royalty was challenged on the
ground of being exorbitant and unreasonable, the Supreme
Court held as under: -
“41. …………………………………….
The executive
authority of the State must be held to be within its
competence to frame a policy for the administration of
the State.
Unless the policy framed is absolutely
capricious and, not being informed by any reason
whatsoever, can be clearly held to be arbitrary and
founded on mere ipse dixit of the executive functionaries
thereby offending Article 14 of the Constitution or such
policy offends other constitutional provisions or comes
into conflict with any statutory provision, the Court
cannot and should not outstep its limit and tinker with
the policy decision of the executive functionary of the
State. This Court, in no uncertain terms, has sounded a
note of caution by indicating that policy decision is in the
domain of the executive authority of the State and the
Court should not embark on the unchartered ocean of
public policy and should not question the efficacy or
otherwise of such policy so long the same does not
offend any provision of the statute or the Constitution of
India. The supremacy of each of the three organs of the
State i.e. legislature, executive and judiciary in their
respective fields of operation needs to be emphasized.
The power of judicial review of the executive and
legislative action must be kept within the bounds of
constitutional scheme so that there may not be any
occasion to entertain misgivings about the role of
judiciary in outstepping its limit by unwarranted judicial
activism being very often talked of in these days. The
democratic set-up to which the polity is so deeply
committed cannot function properly unless each of the
three organs appreciate the need for mutual respect and
supremacy in their respective fields.”
---------------------------------2
(1997) SCC 592
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
15.
In yet another case, Narmada Bachao Andolan vs.
Union of India and others3, wherein the issue involved was
relief and rehabilitation of oustees on account of construction of
Sardar Sarovan Dam, the Supreme Court observed as under:
“229. It is now well settled that the courts, in the
exercise of their jurisdiction, will not transgress into the
field of policy decision.
Whether to have an
infrastructural project or not and what is the type of
project to be undertaken and how it has to be executed,
are part of policy-making process and the courts are illequipped to adjudicate on a policy decision so
undertaken. The court, no doubt, has a duty to see that
in the undertaking of a decision, no law is violated and
people’s fundamental rights are not transgressed upon
except to the extent permissible under the Constitution.
Even then any challenge to such a policy decision must
be before the execution of the project is undertaken.
…………….”
16.
In N.D. Jayal and another vs. Union of India and
others4, again a case of relief and rehabilitation of persons on
account of construction of Tehri Dam, the Supreme Court
observed as under : -
“9. In Sardar Sarovar Project case it was also
held that when two or more options are possible and the
Government takes a policy decision it is then not a
function of the court to re-examine the matter by way of
appeal. Necessary analogy could also be drawn from
BALCO Employees; Union (Regd.) v. Union of India.”
--------------------------------3
(2000) 10 SCC 664
(2004) 9 SCC 362
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
17.
Again in State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Narmada
Bachao Andolan and Another5, the Supreme Court held as
under: -
“36. The Court cannot strike down a policy
decision taken by the Government merely because it
feels that another decision would have been fairer or
more scientific or logical or wiser. The wisdom and
advisability of the policies are ordinarily not amenable to
judicial review unless the policies are contrary to
statutory or constitutional provisions or arbitrary or
irrational or an abuse of power. (See Ram Singh Vijay
Pal Singh vs. State of U.P., Villianur Iyarkkai Padukappu
Maiyam vs. Union Of India and State of Kerala vs.
People Union for Civil Liberties.)”
18.
Recently in Census Commissioner and others vs.
R. Krishnamurthy6, three Hon’ble Judges’ Bench, referring and
construing all the cases including the aforestated cases in
respect of interference by the Court in policy decision held as
under: -
“33. From the aforesaid pronouncement of law,
it is clear as noon day that it is not within the domain of
the courts to embark upon an enquiry as to whether a
particular public policy is wise and acceptable or whether
a better policy could be evolved. The court can only
interfere if the policy framed is absolutely capricious or
not informed by reasons or totally arbitrary and
founded ipse dixit offending the basic requirement of
Article 14 of the Constitution. In certain matters, as
often said, there can be opinions and opinions but the
court is not expected to sit as an appellate authority on
an opinion”.
---------------------------------5
(2011) 7 SCC 639
(2015) 2 SCC 796
2016:SHC:88
W.P.(C) No. 50/2014
Mr. Angu Lepcha & Ors. Vs. D.G., SSb & Ors.
19.
In the conspectus of aforestated, it is luculent that
the Ministry of Home Affairs has taken a considered decision to
withdraw the SDA purportedly payable to the members of Para
Military Forces, who are posted and headquartered in NER and
getting special allowances when they are posted temporarily
outside the NER.
The Petitioners have failed to point out any
violation
fundamental
of
a
right
or
other
constitutional
provisions as required to interfere with a policy decision of the
Government.
20.
For the reasons stated herein above, the Court is not
inclined to pass any order as sought for in the Petition.
Accordingly, the Petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.
Judge
29.06.2016
Approved for Reporting
Internet
jk
: Yes
: Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review