Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/27
GAHC040007072026
2026:GAU-AP:669
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/221/2026
Mori Riba
Son of Late Tamo Riba, presently serving as Divisional Forest Officer, Banderdewa,
Forest Division, Papum Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 2 Ors
represented by the Chief Secretary cum Principal Secretary, Department of EF and
CC, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
2:The Principal Chief Conservator o Forest and Head of Forest Force
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:Taba Teni
Age: 0
Occupation :
presently serving as Assistant Conservator of Forest
Office of the Divisional Forest Office
Social Forestry FD
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
Bam,Ligam Nochi
: Rintu Saikia, Sr. Adv, Idak Bam,Muchi Mele,Mindo Taso,K
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), Nani Kuru,Oken Duggong,Atong Nangu,Phunai
Wangpan,Baby Palon,Kirpi Nyorak,Duge Soki,Nikita Danggen
Page No.# 2/27
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
29.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment :
22.07.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
:
No
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
:
Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. R. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. I. Bam, learned
counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. R. H. Nabam, learned Additional
Advocate General for the State respondents and Ms. N. Danggen, learned
counsel for the respondent No. 3.
2.
The challenge made in this writ petition is to the transfer and posting order
dated 28.04.2026, issued by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & Head
of Forest Force, Department of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (in
short PCCF & HoFF, E, F & CC Dept.) Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
whereby the petitioner, who was serving as Divisional Forest Officer (DFO),
Banderdewa Forest Division, has been transferred and posted as Deputy
Conservator of Forests (DCF) (Industries) in the Office of the PCCF, Itanagar,
and Respondent No. 3, who is an Assistant Conservator of Forest (ACF) (Entry
Grade) and admittedly on probation, has been posted in his place as DFO,
Banderdewa Forest Division. The petitioner has also assailed the subsequent
speaking order dated 12.05.2026 passed by the PCCF & HoFF, whereby, the
Page No.# 3/27
representation submitted by the petitioner against the impugned transfer order,
pursuant to the direction of this Court in WP(C) No.192/2026, has been
rejected.
3.
The case of the petitioner, in brief, is that he is a member of the Arunachal
Pradesh Forest Service (APFS) governed by the Arunachal Pradesh Forest
Service Rules, 2019 (hereinafter referred to as “the APFS Rules, 2019”) and is
presently serving as DFO and in the cadre of Deputy Conservator of Forests. He
states that the APFS Rules, 2019 classify the service into four grades, namely
Entry Grade, Senior Grade, Selection Grade and Administrative Grade and also
prescribe the cadre strength under Schedule-I. It is his case that an officer
promoted to the Entry Grade remains on probation for two years under Rule
21(b) and becomes fully entitled to discharge cadre functions only upon
confirmation under Rule 24.
4.
The petitioner states that while serving as DFO, Mehao Wildlife Sanctuary,
he was transferred to Sagalee Forest Division vide order dated 14.02.2024 and
thereafter posted as DFO, Banderdewa Forest Division vide order dated
08.11.2024, pursuant to which he joined on 13.12.2024. However, by order
dated 24.12.2024, the earlier order was partially modified and the petitioner
was retained at Sagalee, while Shri Goba Doke, an ACF (Entry Grade) on
probation, was posted as DFO, Banderdewa in his place.
5.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner submitted a representation dated
31.12.2024 contending that the transfer order was contrary to the APFS Rules,
2019, as an officer in the Entry Grade on probation could not be posted against
a higher cadre duty post. As no decision was taken, he filed WP(C) No. 58/2025,
wherein this Court directed consideration of his representation. Pursuant
thereto, the same was rejected by a speaking order dated 21.02.2025, leading
Page No.# 4/27
the petitioner to file WP(C) No. 76/2025 challenging both the transfer order
dated 24.12.2024 and the rejection order.
6.
The petitioner states that this Court, by judgment and order dated
19.05.2025 passed in WP(C) No.76(AP)/2025, held that the transfer order dated
24.12.2024 was legally unsustainable, primarily on the ground that an officer
who was not even in the cadre of the Selection/Senior Grade and who was
serving as an ACF on probation could not be permitted to hold the charge of
DFO by replacing the petitioner. Consequent upon the said judgment, the
respondent authorities issued an order dated 12.06.2025 permitting the
petitioner to assume charge as DFO, Banderdewa Forest Division in compliance
with the directions of this Court.
7.
According to the petitioner, after resuming charge at Banderdewa pursuant
to the judgment of this Court, he continued to discharge his duties in
accordance with law. However, before completion of the normal tenure
prescribed under the Government guidelines on transfer and posting, the
respondent authorities issued the impugned transfer order dated 28.04.2026
transferring the petitioner from Banderdewa Forest Division and posting him as
DCF (Industries), while Respondent No. 3, who had been promoted as ACF
(Entry Grade) on 25.02.2026 and was still on probation, was posted as DFO,
Banderdewa Forest Division. According to the petitioner, the impugned order
substantially recreates the situation earlier interfered with by this Court in
WP(C) No. 76(AP)/2025, despite the findings recorded therein.
8.
It is the case of the petitioner that immediately after issuance of the
transfer order dated 28.04.2026, he submitted a representation dated
29.04.2026 seeking review of the same on the ground that the posting of
Respondent No. 3 as DFO, Banderdewa was contrary to the APFS Rules, 2019
Page No.# 5/27
and amounted to frequent and mid-term transfer in violation of the Government
transfer policy. Since the representation remained undecided, he filed WP(C) No.
192/2026. By order dated 04.05.2026, this Court disposed of the writ petition
directing the competent authority to decide the representation by a reasoned
order and to maintain status quo regarding the postings of the petitioner and
Respondent No. 3 till such decision.
9.
Pursuant to the order of this Court, the PCCF & HoFF passed the impugned
speaking order dated 12.05.2026 rejecting the petitioner’s representation.
According to the petitioner, the rejection was based only on the general principle
that transfer is an incident of service and that no Government servant has a
vested right to a particular posting. It is his case that the authority failed to
consider the core issue, namely, whether an ACF on probation under Rule 21 of
the APFS Rules, 2019 could be posted as DFO against a post allegedly
earmarked for a higher cadre under the Rules and also ignored the earlier
judgment of this Court in WP(C) No. 76(AP)/2025.
10. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, being aggrieved by the
impugned transfer and posting order dated 28.04.2026 as well as the speaking
order dated 12.05.2026, the petitioner has approached this Court by filing the
present writ petition seeking appropriate reliefs.
11. Mr. R. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner, submits
that the impugned transfer order dated 28.04.2026 and the consequential
speaking order dated 12.05.2026 are arbitrary, illegal and contrary to the APFS
Rules, 2019. He submits that Respondent No. 3 was promoted as ACF on
25.02.2026 under Rule 5 of the Rules and is still on probation under Rule 21(b),
and therefore cannot be treated as eligible to hold a duty post under Schedule-I
without confirmation under Rule 24. According to him, despite the statutory
Page No.# 6/27
scheme governing probation and confirmation, the authorities have again placed
a probationary Entry Grade officer as DFO, thereby displacing the petitioner
from a higher cadre post and defeating the statutory framework governing the
service.
12. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the issue is substantially
covered by the earlier judgment of this Court in WP(C) No. 76/2025, wherein
the earlier posting of a probationary ACF as DFO, Banderdewa was interfered
with. He submits that despite the said judgment and the petitioner’s restoration
to the post of DFO, Banderdewa vide order dated 12.06.2025, the respondent
authorities have again, within a short span, issued a similar transfer order dated
28.04.2026, thereby attempting to reintroduce an arrangement already
disapproved by this Court. It is submitted that such action amount to
overreaching the earlier judgment and renders the provisions under the APFS
Rules, 2019 illusory.
13. Mr. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel, further submits that the petitioner has
been subjected to repeated mid-term transfers within a short span without any
administrative justification. He submits that after being posted to Banderdewa
pursuant to the judgment of this Court, the petitioner was again transferred
before completion of the normal tenure prescribed under the Government
transfer
guidelines
dated
02.06.1998,
19.12.2008
and
circular
dated
18.08.2021. Though the said guidelines may not have statutory force, it is
contended that they reflect the State’s policy and ought not to be departed from
arbitrarily without any exceptional reason. It is also submitted that since the
petitioner is due to retire in March, 2027, the impugned transfer within one year
of retirement is also contrary to the said guidelines.
14. It is contended by the learned Senior Counsel that the reasons recorded in
Page No.# 7/27
the speaking order dated 12.05.2026 indicate that the transfer is based on
allegations regarding the petitioner’s alleged failure to effectively prevent illegal
earth cutting and encroachment in Banderdewa Forest Division. According to
him, such observations are stigmatic in nature, as they attribute inefficiency and
lapses in discharge of duties without any disciplinary proceedings or opportunity
of hearing. It is submitted that a transfer founded on such allegations relating to
conduct or efficiency ceases to be a routine administrative measure and
assumes a punitive character, which is impermissible in law.
15. In this regard, reliance has been placed on the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Somesh Tiwari v. Union of Indiareported in (2009) 2 SCC
592, wherein it has been held that though transfer is an incidence of service,
the same would be vitiated if it is based on irrelevant considerations or suffers
from malice in law and that a transfer order passed in lieu of punishment or on
extraneous allegations not supported by any enquiry is liable to be interfered
with in exercise of judicial review. Reliance is also placed upon the decision of
this Court in Panpong Tangha v. State of Arunachal Pradesh & Ors.,
reported in 2022 (3) GLT 241, wherein the principles laid down in Somesh
Tiwari (supra) have been followed and it has been held that where a transfer
order is founded on allegations touching upon misconduct or irregularities
without initiation of disciplinary proceedings, the same amounts to a punitive
transfer in nature and is liable to be interfered with in judicial review in absence
of bona fide administrative exigency or public interest. It is contended that the
ratio of the said decision squarely applies to the present case, as the impugned
transfer is based on allegations of alleged dereliction of duty in forest protection
measures, thereby rendering it punitive in character.
16. Learned Senior Counsel lastly submits that the impugned speaking order
Page No.# 8/27
dated 12.05.2026 proceeds on wholly irrelevant considerations by observing
that the petitioner cannot dictate who should succeed him, whereas the real
grievance of the petitioner is not against any individual officer but against the
violation of the statutory provisions governing cadre posts and probation under
the APFS Rules, 2019. According to him, the respondent authority has
completely misdirected itself by treating the petitioner's challenge as a personal
objection against Respondent No.3 instead of examining whether the impugned
posting is permissible under the statutory Rules.
17. It is, therefore, submitted that both the transfer order dated 28.04.2026
and the consequential speaking order dated 12.05.2026 are liable to be set
aside being arbitrary, contrary to the APFS Rules, 2019, violative of Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution of India and also in disregard of the earlier judgment
rendered by this Court in WP(C) No.76(AP)/2025.
18.
Per contra, Mr. R. H. Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General
appearing for the State respondents, submits that the transfer and posting of
the petitioner has been effected by the competent authority strictly in
accordance with administrative exigencies and in public interest and the writ
petition proceeds on an erroneous understanding of both facts and the
applicable service law principles governing transfers within the Arunachal
Pradesh Forest Service.
19. It is the categorical stand of the State respondents that transfer is an
incident of service and a Government servant has no vested or enforceable right
to remain posted at a particular place of his choice. It is submitted that all
transfer orders are issued in the interest of efficient public administration and
proper functioning of the Forest Department and judicial review in such matters
is extremely limited unless mala fides, arbitrariness, or violation of statutory
Page No.# 9/27
provisions is demonstrated, which is wholly absent in the present case. The
petitioner, having been transferred in the normal course of service, cannot insist
on continuance at a particular station or seek to substitute administrative
discretion with his own preference.
20. In this regard, Mr. R. H. Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General, has
placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pubi Lombi
v. State of Arunachal Pradesh & Ors., reported in (2024) 12 SCC 292,
wherein the Apex Court, after referring to the earlier decisions in Union of
India v. S.L. Abbas, reported in (1993) 4 SCC 357 and N.K. Singh v. Union
of India, reported in (1994) 6 SCC 98, reiterated the settled principle that
transfer is an incident of service and the scope of judicial review in matters of
transfer is extremely limited. It was held that, unless the transfer order is shown
to be vitiated by mala fides, passed in violation of any statutory provision, or
demonstrably arbitrary and detrimental to the employee, the High Court ought
not to interfere in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
21. It is submitted that obedience to lawful orders of transfer is an essential
requirement of discipline in public service and any non-compliance with such
orders amounts to insubordination under the applicable conduct rules. Reliance
is placed on the settled legal position that a Government servant is required to
first comply with the order of transfer and thereafter avail appropriate remedies
in accordance with law, and cannot adopt a course of defiance.
22. Reliance has also been placed on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in S. C. Saxena v. Union of India & Ors., reported in (2006) 9 SCC
583, wherein it has been held that a Government servant cannot, as a matter
of right, disobey an order of transfer and thereafter seek to challenge the same
Page No.# 10/27
without first complying with the order. The Court observed that a transfer order
is required to be obeyed in the first instance and any grievance against it must
be ventilated only after reporting at the place of posting. It was further
emphasised that such conduct of non-compliance with transfer orders and
resort to litigation tends to disturb administrative discipline and cannot be
countenanced, as it encourages indiscipline in public service.
23.
It is further submitted that the petitioner, having earlier obtained
favourable orders through judicial intervention, has repeatedly failed to comply
with administrative directions, thereby reflecting a pattern of conduct which is
not conducive to disciplined service functioning. The State respondents submit
that such conduct has administrative consequences, as it affects the smooth
functioning of the department and undermines institutional discipline. The
petitioner’s repeated insistence on remaining at a particular posting, despite
transfer orders, is stated to be contrary to the expectations of a responsible
public servant.
24. Itis submitted that serious administrative lapses were noticed during the
petitioner’s tenure in the Banderdewa Forest Division, particularly relating to
protection of forest resources in the Drupong Reserved Forest area, where
allegations of encroachment, illegal earth cutting, and failure to take timely
preventive action were reported. It is submitted that such lapses have resulted
in ecological degradation and have also given rise to complaints before the
National Green Tribunal. The petitioner’s service record, according to the State,
is not free from blemish, and departmental proceedings on serious charges
involving financial irregularities are stated to be pending, thereby raising
legitimate administrative concerns regarding continuation in sensitive postings.
25. It is submitted that the impugned decision to transfer the petitioner and
Page No.# 11/27
post Respondent No. 3 in his place has been taken on purely administrative
considerations, having regard to the functional requirements of the division and
the need for effective forest management. It is stated that Respondent No. 3,
though recently promoted to the post of ACF and presently on probation, has
long experience in the Forest Department in various capacities and is well
acquainted with the geographical terrain and field conditions of the concerned
division. It is further submitted that due to acute shortage of Indian Forest
Service cadre officers in the State, several posts of DFO are being manned by
officers of the Arunachal Pradesh Forest Service on an officiating or functional
basis and such arrangements are necessitated by administrative exigencies and
cannot, by themselves, be termed illegal or arbitrary.
26. The State respondents further clarify that the APFS Rules, 2019, do not
impose any absolute embargo on posting of eligible officers against duty posts
in exigent circumstances and the Rules themselves contemplate officiating
arrangements where cadre officers are not available. It is submitted that
transfer guidelines relied upon by the petitioner are merely administrative in
nature and do not confer any enforceable legal right. It is well settled that such
guidelines are meant for internal guidance of the administration and cannot
override public interest or curtail the discretion of the competent authority in
matters of posting and transfer.
27. It is also submitted that the petitioner has not suffered any prejudice in
service conditions as a result of the impugned transfer, inasmuch as he has
been posted to Itanagar, which is the State capital and is located within close
proximity to his earlier place of posting. There is no change in his rank, pay
scale, or service status, and the transfer is purely lateral in nature. In such
circumstances, the petitioner cannot claim violation of any legal or fundamental
Page No.# 12/27
right.
28. It is further submitted that the representation submitted by the petitioner
has been duly considered by the competent authority and rejected by a
reasoned speaking order after due application of mind and therefore the
allegation of non-consideration is factually incorrect. The competent authority
has taken into account all relevant administrative factors and has found no merit
in the petitioner’s objections. It is submitted that mere disagreement with
administrative decision does not render the order arbitrary or illegal.
29. Finally, it is submitted that the writ petition is devoid of merit, as no mala
fides, arbitrariness, or violation of statutory provisions has been established. The
transfer order is a bona fide administrative decision taken in the interest of
public service and interference by this Court would adversely affect
administrative discipline and forest governance in the State. It is therefore
prayed that the writ petition may be dismissed and any interim protection
granted be vacated.
30. Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 3, submits
that the writ petition proceeds on a fundamental misconception of the cadre
structure under the APFS Rules, 2019 as well as the nature of duty posts in the
Forest Department, which are essentially functional and administrative in
character.
31. It is submitted that the petitioner has no vested or indefeasible right to
claim posting as DFO in any particular forest division. It is contended that the
post of DFO is not a rigidly defined cadre post in the sense suggested by the
petitioner but is a functional designation assigned to the head of a forest
division depending upon administrative requirements. It is further submitted
Page No.# 13/27
that postings and transfers are purely administrative in nature and are guided
by public interest, availability of officers, and exigencies of service. She submits
that there is no provision under the APFS Rules, 2019 which creates any
embargo on posting of an officer on probation against a duty post and the
contrary contention raised by the petitioner is misconceived and contrary to the
scheme of the Rules.
32. It is specifically submitted that Schedule-I of the APFS Rules, 2019 provides
that the duty post in Banderdewa Forest Division is shown as an attached post
under the Additional Deputy Conservator of Forests; however, the post of
Divisional Forest Officer is functionally required to be manned by an officer of
the Indian Forest Service cadre as per the Cadre Strength Regulations notified
under the Government of India. In this regard, reliance is placed on the Indian
Forest Service (Fixation of Cadre Strength) Amendment Regulations, 2022
notified vide Gazette dated 09.03.2022. It is submitted that Banderdewa Forest
Division is an IFS cadre post and, therefore, ordinarily required to be held by an
IFS officer. However, due to acute shortage of IFS cadre officers in the State,
APFS officers are posted on temporary and functional basis to ensure continuity
of administration. It is, therefore, submitted that the petitioner, being an officer
of the APFS, cannot claim any exclusive or indefeasible right to hold the said
post.
33. In this regard, reliance is placed on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in N. Suresh Nathan and Anr. vs. Union of India and Ors., reported in
1992 Supp (1) SCC 584, wherein it has been held that a consistent
departmental interpretation of recruitment rules, if based on a possible and
reasonable construction, should not be unsettled merely because another view
is also possible, as stability and certainty in service matters are essential. It is
Page No.# 14/27
submitted that the said principle squarely applies to the present case, where a
long-standing administrative practice of making temporary postings/functional
arrangements of APFS officers against DFO posts due to shortage of IFS cadre
officers has been consistently followed in exigency of service and such settled
practice ought not to be interfered with in absence of any illegality or
arbitrariness.
34. It is further contended that the petitioner’s contention that an officer on
probation cannot be posted to a duty post is wholly untenable. The APFS Rules,
2019 do not contain any provision which prohibits a probationary officer from
being assigned functional duties in the exigencies of service. Such an
interpretation, as sought to be advanced by the petitioner, is stated to be a
“figment of imagination” and contrary to established administrative practice. It is
submitted that the State Government is empowered to make temporary and
functional arrangements depending upon availability of officers and such
arrangements cannot be invalidated merely on the ground of probationary
status.
35. The learned counsel, referring to RTI information from the Department of
Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
submits that due to shortage of eligible cadre officers, officers of lower cadres
have also been assigned duty posts in various forest divisions. The RTI
disclosures indicate that ACF, ADCF, DCF (Selection Grade) and other officers are
presently holding such posts, showing that such functional arrangements are
made as a matter of administrative practice depending upon exigencies of
service. It is further submitted that under the Arunachal Pradesh Forest Service
Rules, 1999, a similar structure existed, and the petitioner himself, while serving
as ACF, was posted as DFO, Dibang Forest Division, Roing, vide order dated
Page No.# 15/27
17.08.2012. It is therefore contended that the petitioner cannot be permitted to
approbate and reprobate after having benefited from similar arrangements.
36. It is also contended on behalf of the respondents that the consistent
administrative practice of assigning functional charge of duty posts, including
DFO-level responsibilities, to officers of the APFS, finds support from the flexible
scheme of the Rules, particularly when read in light of provisions such as Rule
28, which recognises that duty posts may, in appropriate cases, be held by
officers outside the strict cadre allocation depending upon administrative
exigencies. While Rule 28 is primarily referable to IFS officers, the underlying
principle of administrative flexibility in manning duty posts lends support to the
respondents’ contention that such arrangements are permissible in exigent
circumstances and do not, by themselves, render the posting illegal.
37. It is submitted that the petitioner has suffered no prejudice whatsoever by
the impugned transfer, inasmuch as he has been posted as DCF (Industries) in
the office of the PCCF at Itanagar, which is an equivalent post in terms of rank,
status, and pay. It is therefore submitted that the transfer is purely lateral in
nature and does not involve any reduction in rank or alteration of service
conditions. It is further stated that respondent No. 3 was released on
29.04.2026 and had duly joined, but owing to the petitioner’s refusal to hand
over charge, he could take over only on 15.05.2026.
38. It is also submitted that the petitioner’s reliance on transfer guidelines is
wholly misconceived, inasmuch as such guidelines are administrative in nature
and do not confer any enforceable legal right. Even otherwise, the guidelines
themselves contemplate that officers posted in field or work divisions may be
shifted to headquarters one year prior to retirement and therefore the
petitioner’s contention regarding violation of retirement proximity norms is
Page No.# 16/27
incorrect and contrary to the language of the guidelines.
39. It is further submitted that the petitioner’s challenge to the impugned
transfer order is based on mere apprehensions and misconceived assumptions
and no legal right has been violated. The State has acted within its lawful
authority in issuing the impugned transfer order in public interest, ensuring
effective forest administration and optimal utilization of available human
resources.
40. In support of her contention, Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel, has placed
reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rajendra Singh &
Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors., reported in (2009) 15 SCC 178, to
contend that a Government servant has no vested right to remain posted at a
particular place and transfer is an incident of service. It is further submitted that
courts should ordinarily refrain from interfering in transfer matters unless the
order is vitiated by mala fides or is in violation of statutory provisions, and that
assessment of suitability or comparative merit of officers for a particular posting
lies exclusively within the domain of the employer.
41. Reliance is also placed on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Union of India & Ors. v. Janardhan Debanath & Anr., reported in (2004)
4 SCC 245, to contend that transfer is an incident of service and ordinarily
does not warrant interference by the Courts unless it is shown to be vitiated by
mala fides or in violation of statutory provisions. It is further held that even
where allegations of misconduct or undesirable conduct form the background of
a transfer, the employer is not required to hold a detailed enquiry prior to
effecting transfer, and the satisfaction of the competent authority based on
prima facie material is sufficient to justify administrative action in public interest
or exigency of service.
Page No.# 17/27
42. In view of the above, it is submitted that the writ petition is devoid of
merit, as the petitioner has failed to establish any violation of statutory
provisions, mala fides, or arbitrariness. It is therefore prayed that the writ
petition be dismissed.
43. Rejoining his submissions, Mr. R. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the petitioner, submits that the petitioner has rendered more than thirty
years of service in the Forest Department and has discharged his duties with
diligence. The allegations now sought to be relied upon by the respondents
regarding the petitioner's performance are denied as baseless. Learned Senior
Counsel submits that if the respondents were of the view that the petitioner had
committed any misconduct or indiscipline, it was always open to the competent
authority to initiate disciplinary proceedings in accordance with law. However,
the respondents could not resort to a transfer founded on such allegations.
44. Learned Senior Counsel also submits that although a departmental charge-
sheet had earlier been issued to the petitioner, the same is being contested and
the petitioner has denied all the allegations contained therein. According to him,
the pendency of such proceedings cannot furnish justification for the impugned
transfer.
45. It is contended that the petitioner's representation against the impugned
transfer was rejected without proper application of mind and without examining
the principal grievance raised therein. Learned Senior Counsel reiterates that the
impugned transfer is contrary to the APFS Rules, 2019 as well as the
Government transfer guidelines and is liable to be interfered with.
46. I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
and also carefully perused the materials on record.
Page No.# 18/27
47. The issue which arises for determination in the present writ petition
essentially relates to the legality of the transfer and posting of the petitioner
from the post of DFO, Banderdewa Forest Division to the office of DCF
(Industries), Itanagar and the consequential posting of Respondent No. 3, an
ACF (Entry Grade) admittedly on probation, as DFO, Banderdewa Forest
Division.
48. In the present case, the principal contention of the petitioner is that the
post of DFO, Banderdewa Forest Division, under the scheme of the APFS, 2019,
is required to be manned by officers belonging to a higher cadre, namely
Senior/Selection Grade and that an ACF in the Entry Grade, who is still under
probation, is not eligible to be posted against the said duty post.
49. In order to appreciate the said contention, it is necessary to refer to the
relevant statutory provisions of the APFS Rules, 2019.
““...3. Constitution of service and its classification:
(1) There shall be constituted a State Forests Service to be known as Arunachal Pradesh
Forest Service.
(2) The service shall have the following 4(four) grades namely:(a) Entry Grade
(b) Senior Grade
(c) Selection Grade
(d) Administrative Grade
(3) The posts specified in all Grades shall be State Civil Services Group-"A" (Gazetted) posts.
(AUTHORISED PERMANENT STRENGTH OF THE POSTS)
4.Strength of the Service:
The authorised permanent strength of the service and the posts includedtherein shall
be as specified in Schedule-I.
Page No.# 19/27
(i). The number of posts in Senior Grade of the service shall be 30% of the duty postsinclusive
of Deputation Reserve, Training Reserve and Leave Reserve.
(ii). The number of posts in Selection Grade of the service shall be 20% of the duty posts
inclusive of Deputation Reserve, Training Reserve and LeaveReservementioned in Schedule-I.
(iii). The strength of the posts in the 'Administrative Grade' shall be as specified in Schedule-I.
(However, this strength should not exceed 15% of the duty posts, inclusive of
DeputationReserve, Training Reserve and Leave Reserve).
(iv). Subject to such conditions and limitations as may bespecified by the Government, duty
posts for such period by order may be created.
(v). The Government may, in consultation with the Commission, include in the service, any
posts other than those included in the said schedule.
(vi). The Government may, in consultation with the Commission, appoint to the service the
regular incumbent of such post which has boon included in the service to permanent or
temporary capacity, as may be deemed fit. The suitability of such officers for appointment
shall be assessed by the Departmental Promotion Committeeconstitutedunder Rule-14.
(vii). Notwithstanding, anything contained in sub-rule (iv) and (v) of these Rules, in case any
regular Incumbent of such post which has been included in the service under sub-rule (v) is
not found suitable for appointment to the service under sub-rule (vi), he will continue to hold
the post and for the purpose, the post will be treated to have been excluded from the service
till it is held by such incumbent. Such person may bereconsidered by the Committee at
appropriate occasions.
21. Period of probation:
(1) Every person appointed under Rule-5 or Rule-16 to the Arunachal Pradesh Forest Service
Entry
the
service,
shall
be
on
probation
as
below:(a) Officers appointed to the service by direct recruitment shall be on probation for a period
of 3 years i.e. 2 years for training in the State Forests Service Course and 1 year for on the job
training
in
the
Department.
(b) Officers appointed to the service by promotion from Range Forest Officer will be on
probation for a period of 2 years.
(2) The Government may In the case of any person for reasons to be recorded in writing,
extend or reduce the period of probation.
(3) A probationer who has no lien on any post under the Central Government or any State
Government shall be liable to be discharged from the service at any time without any notice
Page No.# 20/27
if;
(a) On the basis of his/her performance or conduct during probation, he/she is considered
unfit
for
further
retention
in
the
service,
or
(b) If on the receipt of any information relating to his nationality, age, health or antecedents,
the Appointing Authority is satisfied that he/she is ineligible or otherwise unfit for being a
member
of
the
service.
(4) A probationer, who holds a lien on a post under the Central Government or any State
Government may be reverted to such a substantive post at any time in any of the
circumstance
specified
in
subrule
(3)
(a)
(b).
(5) A probationer who is not considered suitable for confirmation at the end of the period of
probation in sub-rule (1) or at the end of extended period of probation, if any under sub-rule
b-rule (2), shall be discharged or reverted in accordance with sub-rule (3) or sub-rule (4), as
the case may be.
24. Confirmation in service:
A person who has been declared to have satisfactorily completed his/her probation period
may be confirmed in the service by the Departmental Confirmation Committee prescribed at
Rule-14.
25. Selection for officiating appointment:
If at any time the Government is of the opinion that the number of officers available
in the list referred to in sub-rule (7) of Rule-15 for appointment to duty posts is not adequate
having regard to the vacancies in such posts, it may direct the committee to consider the case
of officers who have officiated for a period of not less than 5 (five) years in any of the posts
mentioned in Schedule-I and prepare a separate list of officers selected. The selection for
inclusion in the list shall be based on merit and suitability in respects for officiating
appointments to duty posts with due regard to seniority. The provision of sub-rule (3) to (8)
of Rule-15 shall apply mutatis-mutandis in the preparation of the list under this rule.
26. Officiating appointments to duty posts of the service:
(1). If any member of the service is not available for holding a duty post, the post may be
filled on an officiating basis:(a) by the appointment of an officer included in the list referred to in sub-rule (7) of Rule-15,
or
Page No.# 21/27
(b) If no such officer is available, by the appointment of an officer included in the list
prepared under Rule-25.
(2). Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, if the exigencies of public service so
require, a duty post for which a member of the service is not available, may be filled on an
officiating basis with prior consultation with the Commission by an officer belonging to a
Forest Service of any of the State/UT Government on deputation for such period or periods
ordinarily not exceeding 3 (Three) years as the Government may consider it necessary.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, where appointment to a duty post is
to be made purely as a local arrangement for a period of not exceeding 6 (Six) months, such
appointments may be made by the Government from persons who are included in the list
prepared under sub-rule (7) of Rule-15 or who are eligible for inclusion in such a list.
(4) Any appointment made under sub-rule (3) above shall be reported by the Government to
the Commission forthwith.
27.Posting of member of the service:
(i). Every member of the service shall, unless he/she is appointed to an ex-cadre post, or is
otherwise not available for holding a duty post owing to the exigencies of public service, be
posted against a duty post under the Government of Arunachal Pradesh in or outside the
State by the Government.
(ii). A member in the service shall have compulsorily served a minimum tenure of period in
duty posts as may be specified by the Government from time to time.
SCHEDULDE-I
C. Post under Additional Deputy Conservator of Forests as attached Officer in
various Forest Division as under (19 posts):
Sl. No. Name of Upgraded post of No. of post
APFS
Pay Level in the
Pay
Matrix
Level-11,
Rs.
67700-208700
Addl. Dy. Conservator of
3.
-do-
Forests, Banderdewa
Division
”
50. A plain reading of the aforesaid provisions shows that the Arunachal
Page No.# 22/27
Pradesh Forest Service under the APFS Rules, 2019 comprises four distinct
grades, namely, Entry Grade, Senior Grade, Selection Grade and Administrative
Grade. The post of Assistant Conservator of Forest falls under the Entry Grade,
whereas the posts of Deputy Conservator of Forests/Additional Deputy
Conservator of Forests are borne in the higher grades of the service. The
authorised permanent strength of the service and the posts included therein are
specified in Schedule-I.
51. Schedule-I(C) provides for the sanctioned posts of Additional Deputy
Conservator of Forests as attached officers in various Forest Divisions, including
one such post attached to the Banderdewa Forest Division. However, the
Schedule only indicates the cadre strength and the distribution of sanctioned
posts under the service. It does not state that the post of Divisional Forest
Officer, Banderdewa Forest Division, must be held only by an officer belonging
to the Senior or Selection Grade, nor does it say that an officer of the Entry
Grade cannot be assigned the functional duties of DFO.
52. The contention of the petitioner is based on Rules 21 and 24 of the APFS
Rules, 2019, which deal with probation and confirmation. It is submitted that
Respondent No. 3, being an ACF in the Entry Grade and admittedly on
probation, was not eligible to be posted as DFO. However, Rules 21 and 24 only
regulate the period of probation and the conditions for confirmation of a
member of the service. They do not contain any provision which bars the
Government from giving a functional posting to an officer who is still on
probation. In the absence of any such legal restriction, the Court cannot read
such a limitation into the Rules.
53. Rules 25, 26 and 27 of the APFS Rules, 2019 mainly deal with officiating
appointments and the posting of members of the service against duty posts.
Page No.# 23/27
These provisions are part of the overall scheme of the Rules. However, the
present issue is not about the validity of an officiating appointment under Rules
25 or 26. Therefore, these provisions do not directly decide the question raised
by the petitioner, namely whether an ACF on probation is automatically
disqualified from being given the functional duties of DFO.
54.
On the other hand, it has been consistently stated by the State
respondents and Respondent No. 3 that the post of DFO, Banderdewa Forest
Division, is normally meant to be held by an officer of the Indian Forest Service,
and due to shortage of such officers, officers of the Arunachal Pradesh Forest
Service are assigned such duties as a matter of administrative need. It has also
been shown that similar arrangements have been followed in the Department
over the time. Whether this practice is ideal is not for this Court to decide. The
only question is whether it is prohibited by the APFS Rules, 2019.
55. Upon consideration of the APFS Rules, 2019, this Court is unable to find
any legal bar which requires that the post of DFO, Banderdewa Forest Division,
can be held only by an officer of the Senior or Selection Grade, or which
prevents the Government from assigning the functional duties of DFO to an ACF
in the Entry Grade. The interpretation suggested by the petitioner would require
reading a restriction into the Rules which is not supported by its language. In
the absence of such restriction, the challenge to the posting of Respondent No.
3 being violative of provisions of the APFS Rules, 2019, cannot be accepted.
56. It is also pertinent to note that this Court, in WP(C) No. 331(AP)/2025
and WP(C) No. 445(AP)/2025 (Hano Moda vs. State of Arunachal
Pradesh & Ors.), while considering an identical issue under the APFS Rules,
2019, held that Schedule-I only indicates the sanctioned strength and
distribution of posts and does not create an absolute bar confining the post of
Page No.# 24/27
Divisional Forest Officer to a particular cadre. It was further held that, in the
absence of any clear prohibition, the State may make functional arrangements
on administrative exigencies, including shortage of officers in the higher cadre,
by assigning charge of such posts to officers of a lower grade, provided there is
no prejudice or alteration in service conditions.
57.
The reliance placed by the petitioner on the decision in WP(C) No.
76(AP)/2025 undoubtedly deserves consideration. However, it is equally well
settled that a precedent operates within the factual matrix in which it is
rendered.
If
the
competent
authority
demonstrates
that
the
present
arrangement is necessitated by distinct administrative circumstances, including
shortage of IFS cadre officers and functional requirements of the division, the
earlier decision cannot be applied mechanically without examining the changed
or distinguishing facts.
58. It is also of significance that the petitioner has been transferred to an
equivalent post of DCF (Industries) in the office of the PCCF at Itanagar. There
is no reduction in rank, pay, status or service benefits. The transfer is, therefore,
purely lateral in nature. In such circumstances, the plea of prejudice raised by
the petitioner does not commend acceptance.The contention regarding
proximity to superannuation also does not, by itself, create any legal bar on the
exercise of the power of transfer, particularly when the same is shown to be
based on administrative exigency and public interest. In absence of any
statutory restriction or demonstrated arbitrariness, the timing of the transfer,
even in relation to the petitioner’s nearing retirement, cannot be a ground to
invalidate the same.
59. The contention of the petitioner that the impugned transfer is punitive in
nature also does not merit acceptance. A careful reading of the speaking order
Page No.# 25/27
shows
that
the
competent
authority
has
taken
into
account
certain
administrative inputs relating to the functioning of the petitioner in the
Banderdewa Forest Division, along with broader considerations of public interest
and
effective
forest
management.
However,
mere
reference
to
such
administrative or performance-related aspects, without initiation of disciplinary
proceedings or imposition of any stigma in the nature of punishment, does not
convert an otherwise administrative transfer into a punitive measure. As held by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Janardhan Debanath (supra), where the
competent authority is prima facie satisfied, on the basis of available material,
that transfer is necessary in the interest of maintaining discipline, ensuring
smooth administration or meeting administrative exigencies, it is not incumbent
upon the employer to hold a prior departmental enquiry before effecting such
transfer. The question whether the allegations are ultimately established is a
matter to be examined independently in appropriate disciplinary proceedings, if
any, and does not govern the validity of the transfer order.
60. In the present case, the respondents have justified the impugned transfer
on grounds of administrative exigency and public interest, including concerns
relating to the effective management of the Forest Division. The speaking order
also records certain administrative inputs relating to the petitioner’s functioning
in the Banderdewa Forest Division. The mere reference to the petitioner’s
functioning in the speaking order, by itself, cannot render the transfer punitive in
nature, particularly when the impugned order does not entail any civil
consequences such as reduction in rank, pay or status, nor does it impose any
penalty recognised in service jurisprudence. The transfer, being to an equivalent
post, therefore retains its character as an administrative transfer effected in
public interest and in exigency of service.
Page No.# 26/27
61. It is further stated by the respondents that disciplinary proceedings are
pending against the petitioner; however, the same are stated to be independent
and unconnected with the impugned transfer order and have not been relied
upon or formed the basis for issuance of the said order. The mere pendency of
such proceedings, therefore, does not affect the validity of an otherwise
administrative transfer made on grounds of public interest and administrative
exigency.
62.
No material has been placed on record to establish mala fides,
arbitrariness, or violation of any specific statutory provision under the APFS
Rules, 2019. The challenge is essentially founded on an interpretative dispute
regarding the cadre structure and applicability of the Rules, which, upon proper
construction, does not support the interpretation advanced by the petitioner.
63. The reliance placed by the petitioner upon Somesh Tiwari(supra) and
Panpong Tangha(supra) does not advance the petitioner’s case. In Somesh
Tiwari (supra), the Supreme Court interfered with the transfer order as it was
founded solely on an extraneous and unsubstantiated anonymous complaint,
which had been found to be baseless in enquiry, yet was still acted upon,
thereby rendering the order punitive in character. Similarly, in Panpong Tangha
(supra), this Court interfered with the transfer upon finding that the order was
founded on allegations of misconduct without initiation of disciplinary
proceedings and in the absence of any discernible administrative exigency or
public interest, thereby amounting to a punitive transfer.
64. The factual position in the present case is clearly distinguishable. The
impugned transfer is not shown to be based on any unverified complaint or
treated as a substitute for disciplinary proceedings, nor is there any material to
establish that it is punitive in nature. On the contrary, the respondents have
Page No.# 27/27
justified the transfer on the basis of administrative exigency and public interest
considerations. In absence of any pleaded or proved mala fides or violation of
statutory provisions, the principles laid down in the aforesaid decisions do not
warrant application to the facts of the present case.
65. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no merit in the
challenge to the impugned transfer and posting order dated 28.04.2026 as well
as the speaking order dated 12.05.2026.
66. Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed being devoid of merit. There
shall be no order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review