Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 26106 of 2025
Monoranjan Roy
Vs.
HDFC Bank Limited & Ors.
Mr. Joydip Kar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Rudraman Bhattacharyya, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Biswaroop Bhattacharyya
Mr. Niladri Bhattacharjee
Mr. Subhrojyoti Mukherjee
Ms. Deblina Chattaraj
Mr. Sayan Banerjee
Mr. Suman Majumdar
Mr. Shraman Mukherjee
....For the petitioner.
Mr. Jishnu Chowdhury, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Sayak Ranjan Ganguly
Ms. Srijani Ghosh
Ms. Kripa Kami
….For the HDFC Bank.
Mr. Aman Agarwal
Mr. Debabrata Das
Mr. Arunabha Sarkar
Mr. Pratick Acharjee
….For the RBI.
Hearing Concluded On : 16.06.2026
Judgment Delivered On : 02.07.2026
Judgment Uploaded On : 02.07.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1.
The petitioner has filed the present writ petition challenging the Show
Cause Notice dated 13th October, 2025, wherein the bank has directed
the petitioner to show cause within 21 days as to why the account of
the petitioner should not be categorized and reported as fraud as per
the Reserve Bank of India (hereinafter referred to as “RBI”) Guidelines.
2.
Mr. Joydip Kar, Learned Senior Advocate along with Mr. Rudraman
Bhattacharyya, Learned Senior Advocate, representing the petitioner
submits that the bank has issued the show cause notice on the basis of
the Forensic Audit report but the Forensic Audit report is not
conclusive and the Auditor has mentioned in the report that the report
has been prepared solely for the purpose of providing selected
information on a confidential basis to which it is issued and should not
be used for any other purpose without their consent.
3.
Mr. Kar submits that on 13th October, 2025, the respondent no. 2 has
issued show cause notice to the petitioner with respect to the
transactions in the State of West Bengal from the year 2013 to 2018, on
the basis of the Forensic Audit report dated 26th May, 2025 conducted
by R. Dokania and Company. On receipt of the said notice, the
petitioner has submitted a detailed reply on 24th October, 2025, stating
that the M/s. Pincon Spirit Limited (hereinafter referred to as “PSL”)
had been conducting its business activities with due diligence, integrity
and best efforts. It was informed to the bank that the petitioner and
other directors of PSL had been arrested on 2nd November, 2017 and all
supporting documents with regard to the operation of PSL and the
petitioner has been seized by the Directorate of Economic Offences
(hereinafter referred to as “DEO”). It was also informed that the offices
and production units of PSL along with business units of the
subsidiary/associate companies were sealed by the DEO in the month
of November/December, 2017, due to which it is not possible for the
petitioner to provide documents with regard to transactions of the
company.
4.
Mr. Kar submits that it was also informed that the loan account of the
company has a long satisfactory credit standing with the consortium
member banks including the HDFC Bank and the account of the
company turning into NPA is not due to intentional or willful and
malafide motive or default on the part of the management of the
company. He submits that due to stoppage of production at the
manufacturing units of Kolkata, the company’s revenue generation has
been adversely affected.
5.
Mr. Kar submits that by a communication dated 12th January, 2018,
issued by the authorized signatory of HDFC Bank addressed to the
Deputy Superintendent of Police of the Office of the DEO, Kolkata
informed that the consortium banks have lent to the company after
completion of due diligence on the company and its promoters as per
the bank’s/RBI guidelines. He further submits that due to the stoppage
of production at the manufacturing units at Kolkata, the company’s
revenue generation has been adversely affected, which was resulted in
non-servicing of the loans with the consortium of banks. If any delay in
non-servicing of interest or non-rooting of sales/ revenue through the
bank account will result in the account being categorized as Non
Performing Assets (NPA). Revival of the company thereafter will be
difficult effecting all the stakeholders. Vide the letter dated 12th
January, 2018, the bank requested the DEO, West Bengal to revoke the
orders issued to seal the registered office or the manufacturing units of
PSL since no cases were registered against the Company and other
directors.
6.
Mr. Kar submits that during the consortium meeting held on 31st
January, 2018, the DEO, West Bengal has seized the stocks at the
plants of the company, despite such reports, no action was taken by
the HDFC Bank or any other member bank of the consortium against
the DEO, West Bengal for safeguarding the stocks which were
hypothecated to the consortium as prime security. He submits that the
company has been impleaded in a number of litigations with reference
to its operation. The alleged corporate debtors have also initiated
Corporation Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) against the company
before the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata. The said
application was taken up for consideration on 30th September, 2019,
along with other applications wherein it is mentioned that the DEO,
West Bengal had attached the property of the corporate debtor (PSL) as
if it is the proceed of crime under the provisions of West Bengal
Protection of Interests of Depositors in Financial Establishment Act,
2013.
7.
Mr. Kar submits that the Tribunal by its order dated 19th February,
2020, observed that the contention that the assets attached by the
respondent therein are assets obtained by the corporate debtor
company out of the funds collected illegally by the group company
under the contrail of Pincon Groups seems to be devoid of any merit in
the absence of any supporting evidence and material. The Tribunal also
observed that the property of the corporate debtor attached by the
respondent is liable to be detached and as such the DEO was directed
to detach the property vide notice dated 16th April, 2018 and to restore
possession thereof to the liquidator.
8.
Mr. Kar submits that on perusal of the Forensic Audit report, it reveals
that the said report has been prepared in the absence of all necessary
documents and evidences. He submits that Forensic Audit report is an
incomplete document and the same cannot be the basis of issuance of
the show cause notice. He further submits that the show cause notice
is issued in violation of principles of natural justice.
9.
Mr. Kar in support of his submissions, has relied upon the judgment in
the case of T. Takano Vs. Securities and Exchange Board of India
and Another reported in (2022) 8 SCC 162 and submits that a quasijudicial authority has a duty to disclose the material that has been
relied upon at the stage of adjudication. An ipse dixit of the authority
that it has not relied on certain material would not exempt it of its
liability to disclose such materials if it is relevant to and has a nexus to
the action that is taken by the authority.
10. Mr. Kar further relied upon the judgment in the case of Milind Patel
Vs. Union Bank of India and Others reported in 2024 SCC OnLine
Bom 745 and submits that the purpose of disclosure of information is
not merely individualistic, that is to prevent errors in the verdict but is
also towards fulfilling the larger institutional purpose of fair trial and
transparency.
11. Mr. Jishnu Chowdhury, Learned Senior Advocate representing the
HDFC Bank submits that the show cause notice dated 13th October,
2025, was issued detailing the allegation against the petitioner. In the
show cause notice, Forensic Audit report was enclosed, thus the
petitioner cannot say that the Forensic Audit report is not served upon
the petitioner.
12. Mr. Chowdhury submits that the petitioner has submitted a detailed
reply to the show cause notice dated 13th October, 2025 and submits
that all the issues raised by the petitioner in the present writ petition is
agitated in his reply. In the said reply, the petitioner has not prayed for
supply of any documents.
13. Mr. Chowdhury submits that as per Master Directions on Fraud Risk
Management in commercial bank, reasonable time of 21 days was
provided to the petitioner for submission of his reply to the show cause
notice and only after receipt of notice, the bank shall consider the
request of the petitioner and after giving an opportunity to the
petitioner, the bank will consider whether the entities will be declared
as fraud or not. He submits that instead of waiting for the decision of
the bank, the petitioner has filed the instant writ petition, thus the writ
petition is not maintainable.
14. Mr. Chowdhury in support of his submissions, has relied upon the
judgment in the case of Union of India and Another Vs. Kunisetty
Satyanarayana reported in (2006) 12 SCC 28 and submits that in
some very rare and exceptional cases, the High Court can quash a
show cause notice if it is found to be wholly without jurisdiction or for
some other reason if it is wholly illegal.
15. Mr. Chowdhury has relied upon the judgment passed by this Court in
the case of Hemant Kanoria & Anr. Karnataka Bank Limited in
WPA 11390 of 2024 dated 10th February, 2026 wherein this Court
held that without submitting any reply and without requesting the
respondent for supply of documents, has filed writ petition, and this
Court dismissed the said writ petition. He submits that in the present
case, the petitioner has filed show cause reply without any allegation
that no document has supplied or requested for any documents.
16. The respondent bank has issued the show cause notice to the petitioner
on the basis of the Forensic Audit report of R. Dokania and Company
dated 26th May, 2025. As per Forensic Audit report, the Bank has
appointed R. Dokania and Co., Chartered Accountants to conduct a
Forensic Audit of the books of accounts of the Borrower for the
financial year 2013 to 2018.
17. The petitioner has submitted detailed reply to the show cause notice by
dealing with each and every allegation. The petitioner has not informed
that no documents are available with the petitioner or the petitioner
required further documents. The petitioner has also not taken the plea
that the Forensic Audit report is not conclusive or cannot be relied
upon. On the other hand, the petitioner in his reply requested for
details of the official of the HDFC bank for personal discussion and
interaction with the bank official at Kolkata instead of Bangalore.
18. In the conclusion part of the Forensic Audit report, it is recorded that
“it is the professional opinion of R. Dokania & Co., that PSL has engaged
in a ‘well-orchestrated scheme of financial misrepresentation, fraud and
fund diversion, through a network of shell entities and through
unauthorized individual payments, with the sole intention of defrauding
institutional lenders.”. This conclusion is based on available evidence
and is subject to further findings if complete financial records and
cooperation are provided by the Borrower. In reply to the said
conclusion of the Forensic Audit report, the petitioner has not stated
that the said documents were not with the petitioner or the petitioner
will submit the said documents or the said documents were with some
other authorities. On the other hand, the petitioner has submitted
detailed reply to the show cause notice.
19. Directorate
of
Economic
Offences,
West
Bengal,
has
initiated
investigation with regard to the transactional operation of the PSL and
seized the stocks and plants of the PSL. The DEO, filed an application
before the Tribunal being CA (IB) No. 577/KB/2019 and prayed for
dismissal of the CIRP proceeding initiated against the petitioner being
C.P. (IB )No. 93/KB/2018. The Learned Tribunal by an order dated 30 th
September, 2019, passed the following order:
“14. A very look at the name of the company
reveals that Sl. No. (e) (5th company) name is
Pincon Infrastructure Ltd. The Corporate Debtor
is Pincon Spirits Limited. The Corporate Debtor
company was Incorporated under the provisions of
the Companies Act, 1956 for carrying on business
of manufacturing, importing, exporting and
manufacturing of every kind of spirit. It has come
out in evidence that Corporate Debtor is not doing
any financial service business activities as alleged.
There is no material furnished before us to prove
that Corporate Debtor company is a chit fund
company or a financial service provider comes
under the purview of the 'WBPIDFE Act'. No
claimant also came forward claiming refund of
deposit if any deposited in the CD company. In the
absence of sufficient materials to prove that the
Corporate Debtor in any manner whatsoever come
within the scope of purview of 'WBPIDFE Act' we
are unable to hold that the proceedings initiated by
this Adjudicating Authority is illegal and improper.
23. The Resolution Professional though made
his efforts to get back the assets of the Corporate
Debtor from the 'DEO, WB', but he failed in having
any access to the books of account, without which
he could not verify the claim received from the
creditors and could not complete their valuation
because of the sole reason of non-cooperation of the
'DEO, WB' the inability of the Resolution
Professional in not getting a successful resolution
applicant cannot be faulted. Accordingly, we have
no other alternative other than to pass an order of
Liquidation.
(j) CA (IB) Nos. 577/KB/2019 is dismissed
with cost of Rs.5 lacs payable within two
months from the date of receipt of the copy of
the order to the account of the CD either by epayment facility into bank account of the
corporate debtor or by way of DD, failing
which the Liquidator can realise the said
amount from the applicant in accordance
with applicable law.”
20. The Liquidator has filed an application before the Learned Tribunal
being CA (IB) No. 1741/KB/2018 for de-attachment of the assets of the
Corporate Debtor under Liquidation. Learned Tribunal by an order
dated 19th February, 2020, disposed of the said application by passing
the following order:
“9. From a reading of section 3 of ‘WBPIDFE
Act’, it appears to us that this provision is
inconsistent with section 14 of the I & B Code and
therefore, Section 14 as well as Sub Section (5) of
Section 33 of the Code will prevail over Section 3 of
‘WBPIDFE Act’. Therefore, it appears to us that all
the property of the Corporate Debtor attached by
the Respondent is liable to be de attached.
Accordingly, this application is allowed upon the
following among:ORDERS
i.
The Respondent Directorate of Economic
Offences, Government of West Bengal, is
hereby directed to de-attach all the properties
attached vide notice dated 16/04/2018 and
to restore possession thereof to the Liquidator
within 15 days of the receipt of the copy of
this order.
ii.
CP (IB) No. 93/KB/2018 connected with
CA(IB) No.1741/KB/2018 is disposed of.
However, no order as to cost.”
21. In the case of T. Takano (supra), it is held that:
“28.3. Transparency and accountability : The
investigative agencies and the judicial institution
are held accountable through transparency and not
opaqueness of proceedings. Opaqueness furthers a
culture of prejudice, bias, and impunity—principles
that are antithetical to transparency. It is of utmost
importance that in a country grounded in the Rule
of Law, the institutions adopt those procedures that
further the democratic principles of transparency
and accountability. The principles of fairness and
transparency of adjudicatory proceedings are the
cornerstones of the principle of open justice. This is
the reason why an adjudicatory authority is
required to record its reasons for every judgment or
order it passes. However, the duty to be
transparent in the adjudicatory process does not
begin and end at providing a reasoned order.
Keeping a party bereft of the information that
influenced the decision of an authority undertaking
an adjudicatory function also undermines the
transparency of the judicial process. It denies the
party concerned and the public at large the ability
to effectively scrutinise the decisions of the
authority since it creates an information
asymmetry.
30. It would be fundamentally contrary to the
principles of natural justice if the relevant part of
the investigation report which pertains to the
appellant is not disclosed. The appellant has to be
given a reasonable opportunity of hearing. The
requirement of a reasonable opportunity would
postulate that such material which has been and
has to be taken into account under Regulation 10
must be disclosed to the noticee. If the report of the
investigating authority under Regulation 9 has to
be considered by the Board before satisfaction is
arrived at on a possible violation of the regulations,
the principles of natural justice require due
disclosure of the report.”
22. The petitioner has relied upon the order passed by the Learned
Tribunal and the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court but the case
made out by the petitioner in the show cause reply is otherwise. The
petitioner has not taken the plea of appointment of Liquidator or the
documents available with the Liquidator or with the DEO. The
petitioner has not requested for supply of any documents relied by the
bank while issuance of show cause notice. In reply to show cause
notice, the petitioner only requested the bank for providing details of
the officials of the Kolkata Branch so as to enable the petitioner to
discuss personally.
23. In the case of Hemant Kanoria vs. Bank of India passed in WPA No.
28329 of 2023 dated 2nd February, 2024, the Coordinate Bench of
this Court framed the guidelines with respect to declaring the accounts
“fraud” under the Master Directions keeping in view of the judgment
passed in the case of State Bank of India and Others Vs. Rajesh
Agarwal and Others, reported in (2023) 6 SCC 1 and held that:
“64. First, a show-cause notice is to be
issued, enumerating the exact offences alleged
against the borrower/Director. If any FAR or other
document forms the basis of the show-cause, the
same is to be served along with the show-cause
notice. (Both the said criteria have, in fact, have
been satisfied in the present case in respect of BOI,
BOB and UBI.)
65. A fortnight thereafter would be ample time
to give reply to the showcause notice. In its reply,
the noticee shall, apart from addressing the
allegations and controverting those specifically,
specify the documents which are required to be
provided to the noticee by the Banks/financial
institutions. If necessary, in the reply, the
borrower/Director or promoter can reserve its rights
to give a further additional reply upon receiving
such documents.”
24. In the present case, the petitioner has received show cause notice and
had submitted detailed reply of each and every allegation of the show
cause notice without questioning the Forensic Audit report or
requesting for any further document.
25. Considering the above, this Court did not find any justification to
interfere with the show cause notice issued by the bank to the
petitioner dated 13th October, 2025.
26. WPA No. 26106 of 2025 is dismissed.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review