The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Accordingly, the distribution of the award is modified to the extent that from the balance amount of Rs.4,11,000/-, 75% shall be given to the respondent No.6 and 25% shall be given to the appellant herein. Learned counsel for the parties submits that the awarded amount has not been deposited till date. Accordingly, the respondent Nos. 1&2 herein/United India Insurance Company Limited shall deposit the awarded amount before the learned Tribunal, if not deposited within a period of 6 (six) weeks from today and thereafter, the amount shall be distributed among the appellant and the respondent No.6 as indicated herein above. The allocation of Rs. 3 lakhs and Rs. 2 lakhs fifty thousand is not interfered with.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010227892022
2026:GAU-AS:8292
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : MACApp./789/2022
MOKSHED ALI @ MOSHED ALI PARAMANIK
S/O LATE HOSEN ALI,
VILL.- AMBARI KADOTIKA,
P.O.- BALAR BHITA,
P.O.- BAGUAN,
DIST.- GOALPARA, PIN- 783129.
VERSUS
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER, UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD. AND 5
ORS.
RADHIKA BHABAN, G.S. ROAD, GANESHGURI, P.O.- GANESHGURI,
GUWAHATI- 781005.
2:THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.
BONGAIGAON DIVISION
P.O.- BONGAIGAON
DIST.- BONGAIGAON
PIN- 783382.
3:THE ASSAM BULK CARRIER
C/O SARDAR KARNAIL SHING
CHITRALEKHA PATH
RUKMINIGAON
DISPUR
H. NO. 14
GUWAHATI- 6
Page No.# 2/8
PIN- 781006.
4:JADU MONI SAIKIA
S/O GANGA SAIKIA
VILL.- MORNOI BEBEJIA
P.O.- DHAKUA KHANA
DIST.- LAKHIMPUR
PIN- 787055.
5:THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
THE NEW INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.
BONGAIGAON DIVISION
P.O.- BONGAIGAON
DIST.- BONGAIGAON
PIN- 783382.
INSURED AT REGIONAL OFFICE OF NEW INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.
G.S. ROAD
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI
PIN- 781007.
6:MORZINA BEGUM
W/O LATE JOYNAL ABDIN SHEIKH
VILL.- AMBARI
P.O.- AMBARI BAZAR
DIST.- GOALPARA
PIN- 783129
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS. T BEGUM, MR. A ROSHID
Advocate for the Respondent : MS. M CHOUDHURY (r-5), MS F INTAZ (R-6),MS. A BEGUM (R6),MR M H CHOUDHURY (R-6),MR. M A SHEIKH (R-6),MR. K K BHATTA (R1, R2),MS C
BORAH (r-5)
Page No.# 3/8
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE YARENJUNGLA LONGKUMER
ORDER
11/06/2026
The instant appeal under Section 173 of the MV Act has been preferred by
the father of the deceased Mokshed Ali @ Mokshed Ali Paramanik.
2. The appellant herein has assailed the impugned Judgment and order dated
24.08.2022 passed in MAC Case No. 203/2016 by the MACT, Goalpara whereby
an amount of Rs.9,61,000/- has been awarded as compensation to the claimant.
3. Heard Mr. A. Roshid, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard, Mr. K.K.
Bhatta, learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 & 2, Ms. M. Choudhury,
learned counsel for the respondent No. 5 and Mr. M.H. Choudhury, learned
counsel for the respondent No. 6.
4. The case of the appellant herein is that the appellant and the respondent
No.6 had filed a claim petition before the MACT, Goalpara, for the death of the
appellant’s son in a motor accident on 09.06.2016. The deceased was the
husband of the respondent No.6. The appellant and the respondent No.6 filed
the claim petition as claimant No.1 and claimant No.2 respectively before the
learned Tribunal. The other respondents also received notice and filed the
written statements and contested the claim petition. After hearing the parties,
the Tribunal passed the Judgment dated 24.08.2022 in MAC Case No. 203/2016,
thereby awarding an amount of Rs.9,61,000/- with 7% interest P.A. from the
date of filing the amended claim petition.
Page No.# 4/8
5. The appellant herein has preferred the present appeal on the ground that the
learned Tribunal has illegally held the notional income of the deceased as
Rs.6,000/- per month. The deceased had obtained M.Phil degree and he was
working as a lecturer in West Goalpara Collage. The deceased was also giving
home tuitions and his earning was about Rs.25,000/- per month but the
Tribunal illegally passed the impugned judgment and award by holding that the
notional income of the deceased was Rs.6,000/- per month.
6. The appellant has also contended that the learned Tribunal had divided the
awarded amount of Rs.9,61,000/- in between the 2 (two) claimants i.e, the
appellant and the respondent No.6 as follows, Rs.3,00,000/- (Rupees three
lakhs only) to be kept as fixed deposit in favor of the respondent No.6 and
Rs.2,50,000/- (Rupees two lakhs fifty thousands)to be kept as fixed deposit in
favor of the appellant. The Tribunal also directed that the remaining amount of
Rs.4,11,000/- is to be given to the respondent No.6/wife of the deceased. The
contention of the appellant herein is that the appellant and the respondent No.6
are entitled to get equal share as the appellant is about 75 years old without
any source of income and he needs more financial support for his medications
and daily essential commodities.
7. The appellant herein therefore prays that the judgment and award dated
24.08.2022 passed in MAC Case No.206/2016 should be modified by granting
equal share of the awarded amount to the appellant and the respondent No.6
and to enhance the award holding the income of the deceased as Rs.25,000/per month.
8. The learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 & 2/ Insurer, Mr. K.K. Bhatta
submits that the insurer has nothing to submit regarding the distribution of the
Page No.# 5/8
awarded amount. However, he has stated that the claimant could not produce
any proof of income nor any proof of age before the learned Tribunal. In the
claim petition, the claimants had stated that the deceased was earning a
monthly salary of Rs.7,000/- per month from the West Goalpara Collage and
that he earned Rs.18,000/- from private tuitions per month. However, the
claimants could not produce any salary certificate or any proof regarding the
income during the course of the trial before the Tribunal. Therefore the Tribunal
had rightly held the income as Rs.6000/- per month.
9. The learned counsel for the Insurer/Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 further submits
that the appellant has contended that the age of the deceased was 40 years at
the time of the accident. However, during the trial no proof of age was produced
by the claimant appellant. Therefore, in this regard also, the learned Tribunal
has rightly taken the age of the deceased as 41 to 45 years and as per Sarla
Verma’s Case the correct multiplier of 14 has been applied by the Tribunal
basing on the post mortem report. Therefore, the learned counsel for the
insurer submits that the Tribunal has rightly calculated the amount of
compensation and it is prayed that this Court may not interfere with the same.
10. The learned counsel for the respondent No.6, Mr. M.H. Choudhury has also
adopted the submission made by the learned counsel for the insurer/respondent
Nos. 1 & 2 and further submits that the wife has been rightly granted the bigger
share of the awarded amount in as much as she was fully dependent on her
husband/ the deceased.
11. This Court has considered the submission of the counsel for the parties and
has perused the records placed before the Court. The factum of accident as well
as the demise of the deceased person Joynal Abdin Sheikh in a motor vehicle
Page No.# 6/8
accident on 09.06.2016 is not disputed by any of the parties. It is also not
disputed that the vehicle bearing registration No. AS-01FC-3185(Gas TankerTruck) was the offending vehicle.
12. This Court has perused the Judgment and Award dated 24.08.2022 passed
in MAC Case No.203/2016 in detail. The perusal of the said judgment indicates
that no age proof or income proof was produced by the claim during the trial.
The PW1/Appellant was examined by the Tribunal and during his crossexamination he stated that he was not an eye witness to the accident and he
did not submit any age proof and income proof of his son. The PW2/Respondent
No.6 was also examined by the tribunal and she deposed that the deceased was
aged about 40 years and he was a college lecturer by profession and used to
earn about Rs.25,000/- from all sources per month. However, during her cross
examination PW2/Respondent No.6 also stated that she has not submitted any
document to prove the age and income of her deceased husband. In the light of
such fact and circumstances, the Tribunal has rightly held that the age of the
deceased would be within the age of 41 to 45 years as the post mortem report
also disclosed the age of the deceased as 41 years.
Therefore, it is the opinion of this Court that the proper multiplier of 14 has
been applied by the Tribunal as per the guidelines of the Sarla Veram’s case
since, the age of the deceased would have been within the age group of 41 to
45 years basing on the P.M Report.
13. Regarding the income of the deceased, the PW1 and PW2 both stated that
the deceased was earning Rs.7000/- per month as college lecturer and in the
claim petition also it is stated that the deceased was earning Rs.7000/- per
month from the West Goalpara College and Rs.18,000/- from private tuitions per
Page No.# 7/8
month. However, there was no salary certificate nor any person was examined
by the claimants in order to prove the income of the deceased. The Tribunal
therefore had taken into account the concept of notional income for the purpose
of accessing the amount of compensation and has considered the present day
price index of essential articles and held Rs.6000/- per month as the notional
income of the deceased. This Court does not find any perversity in this finding
of the Tribunal also as the claimants could not produce any certificate nor any
person to prove the income as claimed by them.
14. As far as the distribution of the awarded amount is concerned, this Court is
of the view that the wife of the deceased who was fully dependent on the
deceased during his life time is entitled to 75% of the award and the father of
the deceased/Appellant would be entitled to 25% of the awarded amount.
15.
Accordingly, the distribution of the award is modified to the extent that
from the balance amount of Rs.4,11,000/-, 75% shall be given to the
respondent No.6 and 25% shall be given to the appellant herein. Learned
counsel for the parties submits that the awarded amount has not been
deposited till date. Accordingly, the respondent Nos. 1&2 herein/United India
Insurance Company Limited shall deposit the awarded amount before the
learned Tribunal, if not deposited within a period of 6 (six) weeks from today
and thereafter, the amount shall be distributed among the appellant and the
respondent No.6 as indicated herein above. The allocation of Rs. 3 lakhs and Rs.
2 lakhs fifty thousand is not interfered with.
16. With the above directions, it is further clarified that the amount of
compensation of Rs.9,61,000/- shall be deposited along with interest at 7% P.A.
from the date of filing of the amended claim petition as directed by the learned
Page No.# 8/8
Tribunal.
17. The Registry shall return the Trial Court Record forthwith.
The appeal is disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review