Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 16
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl.Petn. No. 61 of 2023
Shri. Moina Singh Phyllut
Date of Decision: 25.08.2023
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Vs.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Thapa, Adv.
Mr. B. Snaitang, Adv.
Mr. S. Khyriem, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
This is an application under Section 482 Cr.P.C with a prayer for
quashing of the FIR dated 19.11.2018 and the corresponding proceedings in
G.R. Case No. 297 of 2018 under Sections 109 and 188 IPC pending before
the Court of the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, West Jaintia Hills
District, Jowai.
2.
Heard Mr. S. Thapa, learned counsel for the petitioner who has
submitted that the background facts leading to the filing of this instant
petition is that sometime in the year 2018, a dispute arose between certain
groups as to who should be the priest to perform pujas at Nartiang Durga
Temple, Nartiang. Following such dispute, a writ petition was filed before
this Court by interested parties being WP(C) No. 335 of 2018. This Court,
on hearing the parties, has, vide order dated 18.10.2019 (Annexure-1 of this
petition) disposed of the said writ petition with the observation as under:
“3. Learned counsel for the parties agreed that during the
pendency of the writ petition, the dispute has been amicably
settled between the parties and Shri. Oni Maskut Deshmukh
whose family has been performing the ritual as Priest for 26
generations has been allowed to continue as the Priest of
Nartiang Durga Temple. It was thus prayed that in view of the
above, the writ petition has been rendered infructuous and may
be disposed of as such.
4.
3.
Ordered accordingly.”
The learned counsel has further submitted that in course of a puja
being performed in the temple, there was an altercation between the two
rival groups, for which police force was deployed in and around the said
temple in compliance with the relevant orders passed by this Court.
4.
After a month of the said incident, an FIR was lodged on
19.11.2018 by Inspector A.D. Sangma as Officer-in-Charge, Nartiang
Police Station, the same being registered as Nartiang P.S. Case No. 50 (11)
2018 under Sections 109 and 188 IPC, the petitioner herein being named as
one of the accused person therein. The said case was charge sheeted and a
regular case was registered as G.R. Case No. 297 of 2018 under Sections
109 and 188 IPC, now pending before the Court of the learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, West Jaintia Hills District, Jowai.
5.
It is the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that
the said FIR could not have been filed and that too under the provisions of
Sections 188 and 109 IPC, which in the context of the case of the petitioner
speaks of abetment of the commitment of offence under Section 188 IPC
and consequently, the impugned order dated 05.01.2023 was passed by the
learned JMFC in the said G.R. Case No. 297 of 2018 holding that a prima
facie case under Sections 109 and 188 IPC is made out against the
petitioner herein. The same could not have been passed in view of the bar
under Section 195 IPC, submits the learned counsel.
6.
On the provision of the application of Section 195, the learned
counsel has cited the case of Daulat Ram v. State of Punjab reported in
1962 Supp (2) SCR 812, para 3 & 4 and also the case of C. Muniappan &
Ors v. State of Tamil Nadu: (2010) 9 SCC 567 at para 32 & 33.
7.
In conclusion, the learned counsel has submitted that proceeding
with the said G.R. Case No. 297 of 2018 would be a futile exercise and as
such, the said proceedings may be set aside and quashed by this Court.
8.
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, learned GA appearing on behalf of the State
respondents has defended the impugned proceedings and the steps taken by
the police when the said FIR was filed, inasmuch as, the factual situation at
the relevant point of time is that the order of this Court was to be upheld
and the police personnel who were present when the alleged violation of
this Court’s order took place, had to resort to due procedure and
accordingly, the FIR was filed.
9.
The submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
matter has been settled between the parties is correct to a certain extent,
however, the police force which is required to look into the law and order
situation has to deal with the situation at the relevant point of time and the
petitioner herein being identified as one of the instigator of a conflict
between the two rival groups when the said puja was performed at Nartiang
Durga Temple, therefore, the proceedings which followed the filing of such
FIR is justified. It is further submitted that the petitioner may be allowed to
assert his innocence before the Trial Court.
10.
The learned GA has also submitted that the police officer being a
public servant and on noticing that this Court’s order was violated,
therefore, he is competent to file the said FIR.
11.
In reply, the learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that,
if it relates to an alleged violation of the High Court’s order, then the
provision of Section 340 Cr.P.C would be applicable as the said section
stipulates that a complaint filed in compliance to the proceedings of Section
195 where the Court making the complaint is a High Court, by such officer
of the Court as the Court may appoint, whereas, in this case, firstly, there
was no complaint filed by the Court and no officer of the Court was ever
authorized to file any such complaint.
12.
This Court has considered the submission made and would not
reiterate the facts as has been indicated above. What is understood is that
the petitioner, while assailing the impugned order and proceedings, has
maintained that for an offence to fall under Section 188 IPC, which speaks
of disobedience to order duly promulgated by a public servant, firstly, the
said order has to be clearly specified and the public servant said to have
issued the said order has to be made known.
13.
Again, Section 195 Cr.P.C provides for prosecution for contempt
of lawful authority of public servants and under the said section, Clause (a)
(i) & ii of sub-Section 1 provides that no Court shall take cognizance of any
offence punishable under sections 172 to 188 IPC or of any abetment of, or
attempt to commit, such offence, except on the complaint in writing of that
Court or by such officer of the Court as that Court may authorize in writing
in this behalf or of some other Court to which that Court is subordinate.
14.
An interpretation of the above according to the petitioner would
be that, firstly, for an offence under Section 188 IPC, the proper procedure
would be for a complaint to be filed by the concerned public servant or by
an officer duly authorized by the Court, order(s) of which has been violated.
Apparently, this is not the case here as the informant who has filed the FIR,
though being a police officer, was not a public servant whose orders have
been violated and was also not authorized by any Court to file the said FIR.
15.
In the case of C. Muniappan (supra) at para 32 and 33, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has referred to the case of Daulat Ram (supra), also
cited by the petitioner herein and has observed as follows:
“32. In Daulat Ram v. State of Punjab, AIR 1962 SC 1206,
this Court considered the nature of the provisions of Section
195 Cr.PC. In the said case, cognizance had been taken on the
police report by the Magistrate and the appellant therein had
been tried and convicted, though the concerned public servant,
the Tahsildar had not filed any complaint. This Court held as
under: (AIR pp. 1207-08, paras 4-5)
"4. …The cognizance of the case was therefore wrongly
assumed by the court without the complaint in writing of
the public servant, namely, the Tahsildar in this case.
The trial was thus without jurisdiction ab initio and the
conviction cannot be maintained.
5.
The appeal is, therefore, allowed and the
conviction of the appellant and the sentence passed on
him are set aside."
(Emphasis added)
33. Thus, in view of the above, the law can be summarized
to the effect that there must be a complaint by the public
servant whose lawful order has not been complied with. The
complaint must be in writing. The provisions of Section 195
Cr.PC are mandatory. Non-compliance of it would vitiate the
prosecution and all other consequential orders. The Court
cannot assume the cognizance of the case without such
complaint. In the absence of such a complaint, the trial and
conviction will be void ab initio being without jurisdiction.”
16.
In view of the authority cited above, in the context of the issues
raised before this Court as regard the proceedings in G.R. Case No. 297 of
2018, this Court is of the considered opinion that a wrong procedure was
indeed followed and the proceedings has clearly hit by the provisions of
Section 195 Cr.P.C.
17.
Accordingly, the submission of the learned counsel for the
petitioner has force and the same is agreed to by this Court.
18.
Consequently, this petition is allowed and the proceedings in G.R.
Case No. 297 of 2018 are hereby set aside and quashed.
19.
The petitioner is discharged from any liability in the case.
20.
In view of the above, this petition is accordingly disposed of. No
costs.
21.
Registry is directed to return the C.D.
Judge
Meghalaya
25.08.2023
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review