The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. 10.2022. In effect, there was no application of mind to the matter and the parawise comments furnished by the police for a full ten days. It was only on 02.11.2022 that an endorsement was made in the Note-fie that the representation may be rejected, basing on the recommendation by the Police Department. This led to the actual rejection order being passed on 03.11.2022. [6] Though the Central Government did not file a separate reply, Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned Sr. PCCG, placed before this Court a copy of the e-mail instructions received by him from the PITNDPS Division, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Government of India. Perusal thereof reflects that the representation of the petitioner was kept in abeyance in terms of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Ankit Ashok Jalan Vs. Union of India and others {(2020) 16 SCC 127}, awaiting the report of the Advisory Board. Thereafter, W.P. (Crl) No. 55 of 2022 Page 3 upon receipt of the comments from the State Government on 02.11.2022 and the confirmation order on 10.01.2023, the petitioner’s representation was stated to have been examined by the competent/appropriate authority, viz., the Secretary (Revenue), Government of India, and it was rejected on 20.01.2023. In this regard, it may be noted that the aforestated judgment of the Supreme Court did not arise under the provisions of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narco…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KABORA Digitally signed
MBAM by
KABORAMBAM
SINGH
SANDEE SANDEEP
Date: 2023.02.01
16:17:10 +05'30'
P SINGH
Item No. 6
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Crl.) No. 55 of 2022
Mrs. Moichingmayum Ongbi Epham Yasmine, aged about 23
years, w/o Md. Abdul Kalam of Moijing Awang Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur – 795138.
Petitioner
Vs.
1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Commissioner/
Special
Secretary
(Home),
Government
of
Manipur,
Secretariat Building, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur – 795001.
2. The Union of India, through the Secretary (Finance)
Government of India, Ministry of Finance, North Block,
New Delhi – 110001.
3. The
Superintendent,
Manipur
Central
Jail,
Imphal,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SANJAY KUMAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MV MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
: Mr. K. Modhusudon, Advocate
For Respondent Nos. 1 & 3
: Mr. Athouba Khaidem, Government Advocate
For Respondent No. 2
: Mr. S. Samarjeet, Sr. PCCG
Date of Order
: 01.02.2023
ORDER (ORAL)
Sanjay Kumar (C.J.):
[1]
By way of this writ petition, the petitioner assails the order dated
13.09.2022 of the Special Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur, whereby she
W.P. (Crl) No. 55 of 2022
Page 1
was subjected to preventive detention in exercise of power under Section 3(1) of
the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,
1988. She seeks a consequential writ of habeas corpus to set her at liberty
forthwith.
[2]
Heard Mr. K. Modhusudon, learned counsel for the petitioner;
Mr. Athouba Khaidem, learned Government Advocate, for respondents No. 1 & 3;
and Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned Sr. PCCG, appearing for respondent No. 2.
[3]
The primary ground of attack urged by Mr. K. Modhusudon, learned
counsel, is the unexplained delay in the disposal of the petitioner’s representation
against her detention. Her representation was dated 13.10.2022. It was rejected
by the State Government on 03.11.2022 and by the Central Government on
20.01.2023.
[4]
The affidavit-in-opposition filed by the Deputy Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur, reflects that the said representation was forwarded to the
Home department by the Inspector General of Prisons, Manipur, on 14.10.2022
and it was then forwarded to the Central Government on 19.10.2022. The delay in
such forwarding was sought to be explained by stating that there was a high
volume of PIT-ND&PS cases and other time-bound cases that were being dealt with
by the Home Department. It was pointed out that 15.10.2022 and 16.10.2022 were
holidays, being the weekend. The Deputy Secretary further stated that the Home
Department called for para-wise comments from the Police Department under letter
dated 19.10.2022 and, thereafter, upon consideration of the material on record,
the representation was rejected on 03.11.2022. The delay in disposal of the
representation and forwarding the report was stated to be due to the high volume
of proposals received and other routine works of the Department.
W.P. (Crl) No. 55 of 2022
Page 2
[5]
Mr. Athouba Khaidem, learned Government Advocate, produced the
file of the detaining authority. Perusal thereof reflects that the Superintendent,
Manipur Central Jail, Imphal, forwarded the petitioner’s representation to the
Inspector General of Prisons, Manipur, on 13.10.2022 itself and it was also received
on the very same day. In turn, the Inspector General of Prisons, Manipur, forwarded
the representation to the Special Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur, under
letter dated 14.10.2022 and it was received on the very same day. However, the
Deputy Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur, addressed a letter to the
Director General of Police, Manipur, seeking para-wise comments on the said
representation only on 19.10.2022. The representation was also forwarded to the
Central Government on the said day. The Superintendent of Police, Thoubal,
submitted para-wise comments to the Home Department under letter dated
21.10.2022. The Note-file reflects that an entry was made therein only on
31.10.2022, referring to the para-wise comments received under letter dated
21.10.2022. In effect, there was no application of mind to the matter and the parawise comments furnished by the police for a full ten days. It was only on 02.11.2022
that an endorsement was made in the Note-fie that the representation may be
rejected, basing on the recommendation by the Police Department. This led to the
actual rejection order being passed on 03.11.2022.
[6]
Though the Central Government did not file a separate reply,
Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned Sr. PCCG, placed before this Court a copy of the e-mail
instructions received by him from the PITNDPS Division, Ministry of Finance,
Department of Revenue, Government of India. Perusal thereof reflects that the
representation of the petitioner was kept in abeyance in terms of the judgment of
the Supreme Court in Ankit Ashok Jalan Vs. Union of India and others
{(2020) 16 SCC 127}, awaiting the report of the Advisory Board. Thereafter,
W.P. (Crl) No. 55 of 2022
Page 3
upon receipt of the comments from the State Government on 02.11.2022 and the
confirmation order on 10.01.2023, the petitioner’s representation was stated to
have been examined by the competent/appropriate authority, viz., the Secretary
(Revenue), Government of India, and it was rejected on 20.01.2023. In this regard,
it may be noted that the aforestated judgment of the Supreme Court did not arise
under the provisions of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988, and had no application to consideration of a
representation made by a detenu under this enactment. In any event, the
aforestated facts disclose that there was delay at every stage, be it at the level of
the State Government or at the level of the Central Government.
[7]
Trite to state, the liberty of an individual is at stake when he is
subjected to preventive detention and the Constitutional scheme guarantees him
the right to have his representation considered without delay, as he is deprived of
his personal freedom without following the ordinary procedures laid down by law.
When a concerted and dedicated effort is launched by the State Government to
arrest the menace of illicit drug-trafficking in the State of Manipur, leading to a
plethora of preventive detention orders being issued, it is not open to the Home
Department to put forth the volume of work generated in that regard as an excuse
to explain the delay on its part in dealing with a detenu’s representation. Having
created the volume of work by its own actions, the State Government must
necessarily equip itself with sufficient personnel and infrastructure to ensure that
there are no delays or shortcomings in the processing of the files in relation to such
detention orders.
[8]
Be it noted that in Rajammal vs. State of T.N. and another
[(1999) 1 SCC 417], the Supreme Court observed that if delay is caused in
consideration of the detenu’s representation owing to indifference or any other
W.P. (Crl) No. 55 of 2022
Page 4
lapse, such delay would adversely affect further detention of the prisoner.
According to the Supreme Court, it is for the authority concerned to explain the
delay, if any, in disposing of the representation and it is not enough to say that the
delay is very short, as even longer delay can as well be explained and so, the test
is not the duration or range of delay, but how it is explained by the authority
concerned. The unexplained delay in that case was a mere 5 days.
[9]
Earlier, in Professor Khaidem Ibocha Singh vs. The State of
Manipur [AIR 1972 Supreme Court 438], the Supreme Court set aside an
order of detention on the ground that there was unexplained delay of 17 days in
the passing of an order on the representation made by the detenu.
[10]
More recently, in Sarabjeet Singh Mokha vs. The District
Magistrate, Jabalpur, and others [(Criminal Appeal No. 1301 of 2021,
decided on 29.10.2021 = 2021 SCC OnLine SC 1019], the Supreme Court
held that by delaying a decision on such representation, the State Government
denied the detenu a valuable statutory right. The Supreme Court observed that the
delay by the State Government in disposing of such representation strikes at the
heart of the procedural rights and guarantees granted to a detenu.
[11]
Though it is laudable that the Government of Manipur is waging a
‘war on drugs’ and initiating stringent measures to arrest the menace of illicit drug
manufacture, trafficking and marketing in and through the State of Manipur, it is
equally its responsibility to ensure that procedural safeguards are taken note of
strictly so as to protect the Constitutional and statutory rights of persons detained
under preventive detention laws. Despite this Court stating to this effect time and
again, scant regard is shown by the authorities concerned to compliance with the
prescribed norms.
W.P. (Crl) No. 55 of 2022
Page 5
[12]
The unexplained inaction on the part of the State authorities in
dealing with the detenu’s representation dated 13.10.2022 clearly indicates a
lackadaisical and casual approach on their part, which is inimical to the mandatory
legal requirements in a matter of this nature. The same would also be fatal to the
very validity and continuance of the impugned detention order.
[13]
The order of detention dated 13.09.2022 issued by the Special
Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur, is accordingly set aside. All
consequential proceedings based thereon shall also stand set aside. The petitioner,
Moichingmayum Ongbi Epham Yasmine @ Kebisana, presently incarcerated in
Manipur Central Jail, Imphal, shall be set at liberty forthwith unless her continued
incarceration is validly required in connection with any other case.
WP (Cril.) No. 55 of 2022 is accordingly allowed.
In the circumstances, there shall be no order as to costs.
A copy of this order shall be sent to the Chief Secretary, Government
of Manipur, for information and necessary further action in the context of educating
the detaining authorities in the State of Manipur as to what are the procedural
norms that they need to adhere to while exercising power and jurisdiction under
preventive detention laws.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sandeep
W.P. (Crl) No. 55 of 2022
Page 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review