Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on: 02.01.2025
Pronounced on: 21.02.2025
CR 55/2013
1(i).
Mohit Mahajan, age 34 years,
S/o Late Vijay Kumar Mahajan
R/o 256, Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
1(ii).
Veena Mahajan, age 57 years
Wife of Late Vijay Kumar Mahajan
R/o 256, Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
2.
Vidya Devi, age 81 years
w/o late Chet Ram
R/o 256 Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
3.
Neelam Devi, age 58 years
W/o Sham Lal
R/o 256 Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
4.
Vinod Mahajan, age 55 years
S/o Late Chet Ram
R/o 256 Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
… Petitioners/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Ankush Manhas, Advocate
Versus
1.
Sham Dass Gupta
S/o Nand Ram Gupta
R/o 256 Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
2.
Upender Mahajan
S/o Late Chet Ram
R/o 256 Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
… Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Aditya Gupta, Advocate, with Abhishek Wazir &
Mr. Munish Sharma, Advocate s
CR 42/2013
Rajesh Gupta,
S/o Sham Dass Gupta
R/o 256 Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
… Petitioners/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Aditya Gupta, Advocate, with Abhishek Wazir and
and Mr. Munish Sharma, Advocates
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Vidya Devi, w/o late Chet Ram
Neelam Devi, age 58 years, W/o Sham Lal
Upender Mahajan S/o Late Chet Ram
Vijay Kumar Mahajan S/o Late Chet Ram (dead)
Vinod Mahajan S/o Late Chet Ram
All R/o 256 Rampura Gandhi Nagar, Jammu.
… Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Ankush Manhas, Advocate.
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JAVED IQBAL WANI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The issues involved in the instant revision petitions are interconnected to each other, as such, are being taken up together for
disposal at this stage with the consent of the appearing counsel for
the parties.
Facts:
• One Sham Dass Gupta, original petitioner in CR 42/2013,
(hereinafter referred as “the landlord”) filed a suit for eviction
against one Chet Ram, the father of original petitioner 1 in Civil
Revision 55/2013 (hereinafter referred as “the tenant”) in respect
of a shop situated at Kanak Mandi, Jammu, under the tenancy of
said Chet Ram, before the court of first Additional Munsiff,
Jammu (Since both the original parties in the suit i.e. the landlord
and the tenant have expired and their legal heirs have been
bought on record, as such, for the sake of convenience they shall
now be referred as landlords and tenants hereafter).
• The aforesaid suit, however, came to be dismissed in terms of
judgment and decree dated 31.03.1992, whereafter the said
judgment and decree came to be appealed against by the
landlords before the court of Principal District Judge, Jammu,
which appeal came to be allowed and the judgment and decree
dated 31.03.1992 came to be reversed vide judgment and order
dated 30.07.1993 and the suit consequently decreed, aggrieved
whereof, the tenants preferred a civil second appeal before this
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
court wherein the judgment and decree passed by the appellate
court dated 30.07.1993 came to be set aside and suit dismissed,
whereupon the landlords filed a Special Leave Petition (SLP)
before the Supreme Court which SLP came to be allowed and the
suit again came to be decreed on 15.04.2010 in favour of the
landlords, however, upon a review petition filed by the tenants
before the Apex Court, the decree came to be modified on
05.10.2010 providing that the tenants be evicted by the landlords
for the purpose of building and rebuilding of the premises and
that the tenants thereafter shall be entitled to the benefit of reentry under section 13 of the J&K Houses and Shops of Rent
Control Act of 1966 (hereinafter referred as the Act of 1966),
whereafter upon the execution of the said decree, the landlords
took over the possession of the shop in question on 25.05.2010
from the tenants for the purpose of building and rebuilding.
• An application came to be filed by the tenants under Section 13
of the Act of 1966 for restoration of possession of the shop after
having been built and rebuilt by the landlords before the Rent
Controller, Jammu (hereinafter referred as “the Controller”) on
29.12.2010 which application after being contested by the
landlords came to be decided on 17.12.2011 by the Controller
and while allowing the same directed the landlords to handover
the possession of the shop in question to the tenants within a
period of two months from the date of the order while providing
further that the tenants shall pay rent to the landlords on the
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
prevalent market rate, to be settled between the parties and that
the patchwork, if any, required to be carried out for the purpose
of making the shop functional shall be done by the tenants at their
own costs which shall be adjusted later towards the rent payable
by the tenants to the landlords.
• The landlords aggrieved of the said order of the Controller dated
17.12.2011, filed an appeal before the court of Additional District
Judge, Jammu on 16.01.2012 (for short the appellate court),
which appeal came to be decided by the appellate court on
04.03.2013, and while allowing the said appeal, the appellate
court set aside the order of the Controller and remanded the
matter back to the Controller for passing fresh orders after giving
opportunity to both the parties to lead evidence with regard to
their case, in that, the appellate court opined that the order of the
Controller is self-contradictory. The said order dated 04.03.2013
is impugned in both the revision petitions before this court, one
filed b y the landlords and the other one by the tenants.
• While the tenant has challenged the impugned order dated
04.03.2013 in the revision petition 55/2013 on the premise that
the same is against the law and facts of the case inasmuch as has
been passed on misappreciation of facts as also misinterpretation
of section 13 of the Act of 1966, the landlords, had maintained
the revision petition 42/2013, essentially challenging yet again
the order of the Controller without spelling out the real grounds
of challenge against the orders of the appellate court dated
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
04.03.2013. The said grounds of challenge urged by the landlords
being relevant hereinabove are in extenso reproduced hereunder:
That the learned Rent Controller, Jammu, did not properly
appreciate either the facts and circumstances of the case or law
on the point and passed order directing the restoration of the
shop possession whereof was handed over to the petitioner
under the orders of the Apex Court. Such an order was passed
under total misconception and misinterpretation of the
provisions of the J&K Houses & Shops Rent Control Act, 1966.
The petitioner aggrieved of the order of the learned Rent
Controller, Jammu, challenged the legality & validity of the
same inter alia on the following grounds.
i. That a perusal of the application filed by the respondents
will show that it was utterly misconceived. The application
was purportedly filed under section 13 of the J&K Houses
& Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 without appreciating that
section 13 of the said Act was not at all attracted. The crux
of the application of the respondents is contained in
paragraph 4 of their application. Paragraph 4 of the
application of the respondents reads as under:
"That the respondent was required to complete
rebuilding within the period prescribed and offer
the possession to the applicants herein as required
under section 13 of the Houses & Shops Rent
Control Act."
ii. That as submitted above, the petitioner filed his objections
and submitted that the application of the respondents was
misconceived. A perusal of section 13 of the J&K Houses &
Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 will show that section 13 of
the Act gets attracted only if a landlord after getting
possession of the premises fails to commence the building &
rebuilding within the period of six months from the date of
delivery of possession to him. Section 13 of J&K Houses &
Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 is reproduced as under for
the convenience of this Hon'ble Court.
"13. When a tenant is entitled to restoration of possession and
compensation
(1) Where the landlord recovers possession of any house from
the tenant by virtue of a decree secured because of clause
2[(h)] of the proviso to sub-section (1) of 3(section 11 or
because of section II-A] and the building or re-building of
the house or shop is not commenced within six months, or
the house or shop is not occupied by the landlord or by the
person for whose benefit the house or shop is held within
two months of the date of vacation of the house or shop by
such tenant, or the house or shop, having been so occupied
is re-let within six months of the date of such occupation to
any person other than such tenant without the permission of
the Controller obtained in the prescribed manner, the
Controller may, on the application of such tenant made
within nine months of his vacating the house or shop, and
giving the landlord an opportunity of being heard, by order
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
direct the landlord to put such tenant in possession of the
house or shop or to pay him such compensation as may be
fixed by the Controller, or both:
Provided that the Controller may, on the
application of the landlord, extend the period
within which the building or re-building of the
house or shop is to be commenced, by two
months at a time and twelve months in all.
(2) Where the landlord obtains a decree for ejectment because of
clause l[(h)] of the proviso to sub-section (1) of section 11
and one of the principal reasons for passing such a decree is
the expected public benefit of the proposed project of building
or re-building by extending accommodation but the actual
building or re-building deviates materially from the said
project and fails substantially to provide the expected
extension of accommodation, the Controller may, on the
application of the previous tenant, and after giving the
landlord opportunity of being heard, levy a fine on the
landlord, which may extend to rupees one thousand and may
in addition, order the land-lord to pay such compensation to
the previous tenant as may be fixed by the Controller.
(3) Where the landlord obtains a decree for ejectment in terms of
clause (h) of sub-section (1) of section 11 and the tenant is
ejected on the ground that the house or shop is required by
him for building or rebuilding, the tenant thereof shall
have.... first .......right to tenancy.
Provided that the tenant shall pay the rent at market
rates notwithstanding anything contained in section 8."
iii. That the respondents were under misconception that section 13
of the J&K Houses & Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 requires a
landlord to complete building & rebuilding within the period
of six months from the date of getting possession of the shop. A
perusal of the aforesaid section will show that it only requires
commencement of building & rebuilding within the aforesaid
period. From the pleadings of the parties, the following facts
are clear.
a. Admittedly the possession of the shop in question was
handed over to the petitioner on 25.5.2010.
b. The application was filed by the respondents in
December 2010. In the application itself it was stated
that when the application was filed first & second
floors of the structure of the building had been
completed and lentil had been placed but the
completion of building was still in process.
iv. That as submitted above section 13 of the J&K Houses &
Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 reproduced hereinabove
important portion of which has been highlighted clearly
provides that if a landlord does not commence building &
rebuilding within the period of six months, he is required to
return the possession of the suit shop to the tenant or pay such
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
compensation as may be fixed by the Rent Controller. The
argument of the petitioner was three fold:
a. That the petitioner had commenced the construction
within the period of six months and the application was
not maintainable;
b. That otherwise also section 13 of the Houses & Shops
Rent Control Act, 1966 did not get attracted in as much
as, section 13 of the Act provided that it was only if the
building is relet, then the erstwhile tenant has prior
right of tenancy. If the premises are not at all rented
out and retained by the landlord himself, then the
tenant does not have any right at all.
c. That the provisions of section 13 of the J&K Houses &
Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 otherwise also are not
mandatory. A perusal of the section 13 of the Act itself
shows that it was not obligatory on the part of the
learned Rent Controller, Jammu, to direct the return of
possession of the shop. He could direct the payment of
such compensation to the erstwhile tenant as he may fix
in lieu of non-return of the possession of the shop. The
application of the respondents was, therefore, utterly
misconceived and was not maintainable.
d. That even otherwise a perusal of sub section 3 of
section 13 of the Houses & Shops Rent Control Act,
1966 important part of which has been highlighted
hereinabove shows that if section 13 of the Act gets
attracted, then the tenant shall have 'first right of
tenancy'. The legislature by using the term "first" has
clearly indicated that the legislature has directed first
prior right of tenancy if the suit shop is rented out after
vacation. However, in case the landlord does not
decide to rent out the premises then section 13 of the
Houses & Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 did not get
attracted. All these aspects of the matter were not
appreciated by the learned Rent Controller, Jammu.
v. That the learned Rent Controller, Jammu totally ignored the
arguments advanced by the petitioner and utterly
misinterpreted the provisions of section 13 of the J&K Houses
& Shops Rent Control Act, 1966. The application of the
respondents was, therefore, utterly misconceived and
deserved dismissal.
vi. That the order of the learned Rent Controller, Jammu is
perverse within the meaning of the provisions of law in as
much as it is incapable of execution. A perusal of the order
passed by the learned Rent Controller, Jammu will show that
it directed the parties to sit among themselves and settle the
market rate of rent. It did not realize that the parties have
been litigating for last thirty years and a court cannot direct
for any mechanism in the event of disagreement. The courts
have neither provided any mechanism nor law, in as much as,
law does not permit a court to pass such an order.
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
vii. That on these grounds, the appeal was filed by the petitioner
before the learned Court below. The aforesaid grounds were
addressed before the learned Court below and the judgment
of this Hon'ble Court was cited where it was clearly held by
this Hon'ble Court that no direction can be passed to a
landlord to complete the rebuilding within any specified
period. The section. requires only commencement of
rebuilding and not any time limit for the completion of
construction.
viii. That an important development took place during the
pendency of appeal before the learned Court below. J&K
Houses & Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 was repealed and it
was replaced by 2012 Act which contained statutory provision
that all the pending appeals shall automatically stand
transferred after the expiry of specified period. In other
words, after the expiry of specified period, the learned Court
below did not have any jurisdiction to hear the case.
ix. That the learned Court below despite repealing Act insisted
upon hearing the case and passed the impugned judgment.
The impugned judgment is without jurisdiction also.
x. That the learned Court below committed an error in not
following the judgment of this Hon'ble Court which held that
no specified period can be specified directing the landlord to
complete the building.
xi. That it was not obligatory for the learned Court below to
return the possession of the premises to the tenant. If the
landlord rents out the premises then of course the erstwhile
tenant has prior right of tenancy. In the present case, the
landlord chooses not to rent out the premises and chooses to
do the business himself in the premises in question. Section 13
of J&K Houses & Shops Rent Control Act, 1966 therefore,
does not get attracted.
xii. That the learned Court below did not appreciate that the
provisions of section 13 of J&K Houses & Shops Rent Control
Act, 1966 are not mandatory but obligatory. Instead of
returning the possession to the erstwhile tenant, it was open
for the learned Court below to direct the payment of such
compensation as he thinks fit.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
2.
Before proceeding further in the matter, it would be pertinent to
refer hereunder to the following provisions of the Act of 1966,
being relevant and germane to the controversy:
11. Protection of a tenant against eviction.—(1) Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary in any other Act or law, no order of
decree for the recovery of possession of any house or shop shall be
made by any Court in favour of the landlord against a tenant,
including a tenant whose lease has expired:
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Provided that nothing in this sub-section shall apply to any
suit for decree for such recovery of possession—
(h) where the house or shop is reasonably required by the
landlord either for purposes of building or re-building, or for his
own occupation or for the occupation of any person for whose
benefit the house or shop is held:
Provided that all sub-tenants in the house or shop are made
parties to the suit and allowed opportunity of contesting
claim to decree for ejectment.
13. When a tenant is entitled to restoration of possession and
compensation.—
(1) Where the landlord recovers possession of any house from the
tenant by virtue of a decree secured because of clause i[(h)] of the
proviso to sub-section (1) of 2 [section 11 on because of section 11A] and the building or re-building of the house or shop is not
commenced within six months, or the house or shop is not
occupied by the landlord or by the person for whose benefit the
house or shop is held within two months of the date of vacation of
the house or shop by such tenant, or the house or shop, having
been so occupied is re-let within six months of the date of such
occupation to any person other than such tenant without the
permission of the Controller obtained in the prescribed manner,
the Controller may, on the application of such tenant made within
nine months of his vacating the house or shop, and giving the
landlord an opportunity of being heard, by order direct the
landlord to put such tenant in possession of the house or shop or
to pay him such compensation as may be fixed by the Controller,
or both:
Provided that the Controller may, on the application of
the landlord, extend the period within which the building or
re-building of the house or shop is to be commenced, by two
months at the time and twelve months in all
(2) Where the landlord obtains a decree for ejectment because of
clause 3[(h)]of the provision to sub-section (1) of section 11 and
one of the principal reasons for passing such a decree is the
expected public benefit of the proposed project of building or rebuilding by extending accommodation but the actual building or
rebuilding deviates materially from the said project and fails
substantially to provide the expected extension of accommodation,
the Controller may, on the application of the previous tenant, and
after giving the landlord opportunity of being heard, levy a fine
on the landlord, which may extend to rupees one thousand and
may, in addition, order the landlord to pay such compensation to
the previous tenant as may be fixed by the Controller.
(3) Where the landlord obtains a decree for ejectment in terms of
clause (h) of subsection (1) of section 11 and the tenant is ejected
on the ground that the house or shop is required by him for
building or rebuilding, the tenant thereof shall have first right to
tenancy:
Provided that the tenant shall pay the rent at market rates
notwithstanding anything contained in section 8.)
3.
Keeping in mind the aforesaid provision and coming back to the
case in hand it is an admitted fact that the final eviction decree
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 10 of
came to be passed on 05.10.2010 by the Apex Court in the review
petition arising out of civil appeal no. 3599 of 2007 in favour of the
landlords and against the tenant on the premise and ground of
building and rebuilding of the premises by the landlords under
Section 11(1)(h) of the Act of 1966, with all consequences.
4.
Perusal of the record reveals that admittedly the tenants maintained
an application in terms of section 13 (3) of the Act of 1966, before
the
Controller
on
29.12.2010, on
the
premise
that
the
landlordhaving completed the construction of the shop in question
are bound to restore the possession of the shop to them, the tenants,
as they, the tenants, are ready to pay the rent of the shop to the
landlords at the prevalent market rate.
5.
Record also tends to show that the landlords, in opposition to the
said application, stated in the objections filed thereto that they, the
landlords, commenced the construction in question and raised it up
to third floor and that the tenants have no right to re-occupy the
shop upon its completion as they, the landlords, are not going to let
out the same, but are going to keep it with themselves for their
personal use.
6.
It is significant to mention here that during the pendency of the
instant revision petitions before this court, a Commissioner was
appointed by this court on 15.03.2016 in order to ascertain as to
whether the construction in question is raised or to what extentis
completed, as also as to whether any portion of the said
construction has been let out to any party for conducting any
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 11 of
business by the landlord, and also as to whether any business is
actually being conducted therein the construction and details
thereof, as the appearing counsel for the parties, i.e., of the
landlords and the tenants had joined an issue with regard to
completion of the construction.
Record reveals that the said Commissioner conducted spot
inspection of the premises in presence of the parties as also their
respective advocates and reported that the shop in question has
been reconstructed on RCC pillars and the roof has also been
lintelled and above it construction of two more floors has been
raised which two floors are not fully complete and that one
staircase has been raised from the ground floor, i.e., from the shop
in question with a gate which opens on right side of the lane for
entry to the said first and the second floors and that the plaster on
the walls of the shop has been done and that no business was found
being carried on at the time of inspection as the shop was found
locked and upon being opened by the landlord the same was found
empty with scattered bricks and boulders in it, however, on
enquiring from nearby shopkeepers about the shop in question, two
shopkeepers namely Ashu Gupta proprietor of Durga Sales, Kanak
Mandi being adjacent to the shop in question and Mr. Akhil Gupta
proprietor Mool Chand Krishan Lal , Kanalk Mandi, being opposite
to the shop in question revealed that one Ashok Gupta was running
business of general items in the shop about 10 to 15 days back and
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 12 of
thereafter it remained closed from the last fortnight and that the
shop stands constructed two to three years back.
7.
Perusal of the record available on the file also tends to show that
none of the parties herein opposed the said report or else filed any
objections thereto the same, which, as such, is deemed to have
assumed finality.
8.
Before proceeding further in the matter, an analysis of the provision
of Section 13 supra of the Act of 1966 becomes imperative. A
closer and deeper examination of Section 13 supra suggests that a
tenant who has been evicted from any house or shop by the
landlord pursuant to a decreeunder and in terms of clause (h) of
proviso appended to sub-section (1) of section 11 or section 11-A
of the Act of 1966, such tenant is entitled to the restoration of
possession of the said house or shop and compensation thereof, if
the landlords commits violation of any condition enumerated in
Section 13 (1) itself, however, within the timeframe prescribed
therein, which for the sake of convenience and brevity are referred
hereunder:
i)
ii)
iii)
Where the building or re-building of the house or shop is not
commenced within six months from the date of recovery of
possession by the landlord from the tenant by virtue of the
decree obtained under clause (h) supra.
Where the house and shop is not occupied by the landlord or
by the person for whose benefit it is held within wo months
from the date of its vacation b the tenant.
Where the house or shop has been occupied by virtue of
clause (h) supra by the landlord and is re-let within six
months from date of such occupation to any person other
than such tenant without the permission of the Controller.
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 13 of
Thus in view of the aforesaid position, a tenant can seek restoration
of possession under section 13(1) supra by approaching the
Controller within the time specified therein and the Controller may,
on an application of such tenant and after giving the landlord an
opportunity of being heard, by order direct the landlord to put such
tenant in possession of the house or shop or to pay him such
compensation as may be fixed by the Controller, or both.
However, it transpires that sub-section (2) of Section 13 supra
operates in a different situation qua the house or shop obtained for
reconstruction pursuant to a decree by the landlord from the tenant
and provide that if the landlord deviates from the project while
building or rebuilding the house or shop and fails substantially to
provide the expected extension of accommodation, a tenant can
approach the Controller in this regard and the Controller after
affording the landlord an opportunity of being heard, can levy a
fine on the landlord to the extent provided in sub-section (2) supra,
and may in addition thereto order the landlords to pay such
compensation to such tenant as may be fixed by the Controller. It is
significant to mention here that no timeframe as is provided in subsection (1) of section 13 supra is provided in sub-section (2) or subsection (3) of Section 13 supra.
9.
Reverting back to the case in hand, it is not in dispute that the
tenants maintained the application before the Controller under subsection (3) of Section 13 and not either under sub-section (1) or
sub-section (2) of Section 13 supra, and as is manifest from the
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 14 of
plain reading of Section 13(3) when a house or shop has been
obtained by the landlord pursuant to an eviction decree from the
tenant on the ground of building or rebuilding, such tenant has first
right of tenancy therein such house or shop after its building or
rebuilding with a caveat that the tenant shall have to pay to the
landlord rent at the market rate notwithstanding anything contained
in section 8 of the Act of 1966 which section provides for cases in
which fair rent shall be fixed by the Controller in accordance with
the mode provided therein.
In regard to above a reference to the judgement of this Court
passed in case titled as Amar Nath v. Hans Raj reported in AIR
1984 J&K 67 (2) would be relevant wherein it has been
specifically held that law does not forbid a suit for ejectment on the
ground of personal requirement to permit the landlord to occupy it
after reconstruction, but law forbids a landlord in occupying a
building, the possession of which he has secured by a decree of
ejectment solely on the ground that he the landlord requires the
building for the purpose of building or rebuilding, making it further
clear that in the first class of cases, i.e.where the landlord obtains a
decree of eviction on the ground of personal occupation, after
building or rebuilding the premises, there is no obligation on his
part to offer the same to a tenant on a reasonable rent, whereas in
the later class of cases, i.e., where the landlord obtains the building
pursuant to a decree of ejectment only on the ground that he
requires the building for reconstruction, law under section 13(3)
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 15 of
enjoins upon such a landlord to offer the building to the evicted
tenant on a rent at the market rate.
10.
Indisputably, as has been observed in the preceding paragraphs, the
tenants have sought restoration of possession of the shop in
question from the landlord under and in terms of Section 13(3) of
the Act of 1966 specifically, and had offered to occupy the shop in
question upon payment of rent at market rate, thus, as such, the
provision of sub-section (1) or sub-section 2 of Section 13 supra
cannot be said to have any application to the case in hand by any
stretch of imagination.
However, perusal of the impugned order dated 04.03.2013
passed by the appellate court reveals that the said court has
completely misdirected itself while having considered the matter
under sub-section (1) of Section 13 as the said sub-section was
never applicable to the case in hand as is held above. Not only that
the observations of the appellate court in the impugned order qua
the status of the building in question are also misplaced and have
now in fact paled into insignificance in view of the factual position
obtained by this court regarding the status of the building in
question by the appointment of the Commissioner, which
Commissioner in the report supra has specifically reported that the
shop in question stands reconstructed. Thus once the shop in
question stands reconstructed pursuant to the eviction decree by the
landlords, the tenants, under and in terms of section 13(3) have the
first right to tenancy thereof upon payment of rent at market rate
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 16 of
and the landlords in view of the law laid down by this court in case
of Amar Nath supra cannot deny the said first right of tenancy to
the tenant on the ground that they, the landlords, intend to retain the
shop for their personal use and does not want to let it out, in that,
the same has been held to be forbidden by law in the said judgment.
11.
As has been noticed in the preceding paragraphs the landlords have
not in essence challenged the impugned order passed by the
appellate court, although, in the cause title and prayer clauses,
setting aside of the said impugned order has been prayed, yet the
ground of challenge urged in the review petition filed by the
landlord relate to the order passed by the Controller. Be that as it
may, insofar as the plea of the landlords raised in the revision
petition quathe repealing of the Act of 1966 and the applicability of
the Provisions of J&K, Residential and Commercial Act of 2012 to
the case in hand is concerned, the said issue stands considered by
the Division Bench of this Court in CMA No. 279 of 2012dated
13.12.2012, wherein, by way of an interim orderit came to be
directed that the suit and appeals which are pending shall continue
to be adjudicated upon under the Act of 1966, thus rendering the
said plea of the landlords insignificant.
12.
It is significant to mention here that a considerable period of time
has elapsed from the date of passing of order dated 17.2.2011 by
the Controller requiring the landlords to hand over the possession
of the shop in question to the tenants within a period of two months
from the date of order while directing the tenants to pay the rent to
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 17 of
the landlords at prevalent market rate, and admittedly, the litigation
in hand has commenced in the year 1983 when the suit for eviction
was filed by the original landlord against the original tenant and,
therefore, in view of the attending facts and circumstances of the
case, there must and has to be an end to the instant litigation now.
13.
For what has been observed, considered and analysed hereinabove,
CR 42/2013 is found to be without any merit and is accordingly
dismissed. The CR 55/2023 is allowed and the impugned order
dated 04.03.2013 passed by the Additional District Judge, Jammu,
is set aside.
14.
The landlord/s consequently are directed to handover the
possession of the shop in question to the tenant/s forthwith
preferably within a period of ten days, commencing from
01.03.2025 and the tenant/s shall pay rent to the landlord/s in lieu
thereof at the present market rate without any fail from the date of
occupation of the shop. However, if the landlords are dissatisfied
with the said rent, the landlord/s shall be well within their right to
seek determination of fair rent in this regard under and in terms of
Section 8 of the Act of 1966. In the event the landlords fail to
handover the possession of the shop in question to the tenant/s as
directed above, the Superintendent of Police concerned in that case,
in furtherance of execution of this order, shall ensure the delivery
of the possession of the shop in question by the landlords to the
tenants, without any fail, and shall file a compliance report before
the Rent Controller in this regard.
CR 55/2013 c/w CR 42/2013
Page 18 of
15.
Disposed of along with all CMs (applications).
16.
A copy of this order shall be placed on the record of each of the
Revision Petition.
17.
Record of courts below is directed to be sent back.
(JAVED IQBAL WANI)
JUDGE
Srinagar
21.02.2025
N Ahmad
Nissar Ahmad Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
27.02.2025 10:51
Whether the order is speaking:
Yes
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review