The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. In view of the above, I do not find any illegality and infirmity in the order passed by the learned Trial Court. The present revision petition, being devoid of any merit, is accordingly dismissed. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed off.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
CR-8701-2025 (O&M)
Date of Decision : 24.02.2026
MOHIT KATYAL
.... Petitioner
VERSUS
MANOJ KUMAR AND ANOTHER
.... Respondents
CORAM : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE ALKA SARIN
Present :
Mr. Sanchit Punia, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Ajay Jain, Advocate for respondent No.1.
None for respondent No.2.
ALKA SARIN, J. (ORAL)
1.
The present revision petition has been filed under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India challenging the order dated 13.10.2025 (Annexure
P-9) passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Hisar whereby the
application filed by defendant No.1-petitioner under Order VII Rule 11 CPC
was dismissed.
2.
Brief facts relevant to the present lis are that plaintiff-respondent
No.1 herein filed a suit for mandatory injunction for directing the defendants
(petitioner and proforma respondent No.2 herein) to hand over the vacant
possession of first floor of house bearing No.5, M.C. No.512-B situated in
Krishna Nagar, Hisar, Tehsil and District Hisar. In para No.9 of the plaint it
has specifically been stated that the defendants (petitioner and proforma
respondent No.2 herein) were inducted as licencee and that the permission had
AMAN JAIN
2026.02.25 09:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CR-8701-2025 (O&M)
-2-
since been revoked by plaintiff-respondent No.1. Written statement was filed
and issues were framed. Thereafter, an application was filed by the applicant,
namely, Manoj Kumar, son of Gulshan Rai (plaintiff-respondent No.1) under
Order XXII Rule 10 CPC for substitution on the ground that plaintiffrespondent No.1 had transferred the house in question to the applicant vide
lease deed dated 06.02.2019. The said application was allowed vide order
dated 20.08.2024. Subsequently, an application was filed by defendant No.lpetitioner herein under Order VII Rule 11 CPC for rejection of the plaint on
the ground that the suit itself was not maintainable as the licencee rights were
not heritable. Reply was filed to the said application. Vide impugned order
dated 13.10.2025 the said application was dismissed.
3.
Learned counsel for defendant No.1-petitioner would contend
that the plaint deserves to be rejected on the ground that a licence is not
transferrable and since the application filed by the son of plaintiff-respondent
No.1 for substitution had been allowed, therefore, there was no cause of
action. It is further the contention of the learned counsel that at the time of
deciding the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the contents of the
substitution application are to be seen and not the plaint. In support of his
arguments, learned counsel has relied upon the judgment in the case of
Chinnan & Ors. vs. Ranjithammal [1931 AIR (Madras) 216] to contend
that a licence is not heritable or transferable.
4.
Per contra, learned counsel for plaintiff-respondent No.1 would
contend that only the contents of the plaint are to be seen at the time of
deciding the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
AMAN JAIN
2026.02.25 09:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CR-8701-2025 (O&M)
-3-
5.
Heard.
6.
In the present case the only ground for rejection of the plaint is
on the basis of the fact that a substitution application had been filed by the son
of plaintiff-respondent No.1. The argument of the learned counsel for
defendant No.1-petitioner that since a licence is not heritable, therefore, the
suit itself was not maintainable as the case set up by plaintiff-respondent No.1
was that defendant No.1-petitioner is the licencee, deserves to be rejected. The
judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for defendant No.1-petitioner in
the case of Chinnan & Ors. (supra) would not come to his aid, rather it
supports the case of the applicant, namely, Manoj Kumar, inasmuch as in the
said case it has been held that a transferor is not bound by the licence and the
licence comes to an end with the death of the original licensor. In the present
case since the licence would be considered to be transferred and since licence
is not transferable, therefore, it would be deemed to have come to an end. In
any case, even in the plaint the very case set up is that the licence had been
revoked. It has further been held that a successor-in-interest of a licencee
cannot inherit the rights as the licence is not heritable or transferable. As stated
above, the licensor is stated to have transferred his rights in favour of the son
who has now stepped into his shoes. It would, in any case, mean that the
licence has come to an end. The judgment relied upon by the learned counsel
for defendant No.1-petitioner in the case of Chinnan & Ors. (supra) would
therefore have no relevance in the present case.
7.
It is trite that at the time of deciding the application under Order
VII Rule 11 CPC only the contents of the plaint are to be seen. The argument
AMAN JAIN
2026.02.25 09:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CR-8701-2025 (O&M)
-4-
of the learned counsel for defendant No.1-petitioner that it would be the
contents of the substitution application which would need to be seen for
deciding the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC is wholly misplaced.
8.
In case of Chhotanben & Anr. vs. Kiritbhai Jalkrushnabhai
Thakkar & Ors. [2018 (5) RCR (Civil) 163] the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held as under :
“12. What is relevant for answering the matter in issue in
the context of the application under Order VII Rule 11(d),
is to examine the averments in the plaint. The plaint is
required to be read as a whole. The defence available to
the defendants or the plea taken by them in the written
statement or any application filed by them, cannot be the
basis to decide the application under Order VII Rule
11(d). Only the averments in the plaint are germane. It is
common ground that the registered sale deed is dated
18th October, 1996. The limitation to challenge the
registered sale deed ordinarily would start running from
the date on which the sale deed was registered. However,
the specific case of the appellants (plaintiffs) is that until
2013 they had no knowledge whatsoever regarding
execution of such sale deed by their brothers - original
defendant Nos.1 & 2, in favour of Jaikrishnabhai
Prabhudas Thakkar or defendant Nos.3 to 6. They
acquired that knowledge on 26.12.2012 and immediately
AMAN JAIN
2026.02.25 09:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CR-8701-2025 (O&M)
-5-
took steps to obtain a certified copy of the registered sale
deed and on receipt thereof they realised the fraud played
on them by their brothers concerning the ancestral
property and two days prior to the filing of the suit, had
approached their brothers (original defendant Nos.1 &
2) calling upon them to stop interfering with their
possession and to partition the property and provide
exclusive possession of half (1/2) portion of the land so
designated towards their share. However, when they
realized that the original defendant Nos.1 & 2 would not
pay any heed to their request, they had no other option
but to approach the court of law and filed the subject suit
within two days therefrom. According to the appellants,
the suit has been filed within time after acquiring the
knowledge about the execution of the registered sale
deed. In this context, the Trial Court opined that it was a
triable issue and declined to accept the application filed
by respondent No.1 (defendant No.5) for rejection of the
plaint under Order VII Rule 11(d). That view commends
to us.”
Further, in the case of Urvashiben & Anr. vs. Krishnakant Manuprasad
Trivedi [2019(1) RCR (Civil) 366] it has been held as under :
“15. By applying the aforesaid principles in the
judgments relied on by Sri Dushyant Dave, learned senior
AMAN JAIN
2026.02.25 09:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CR-8701-2025 (O&M)
-6-
counsel appearing for the respondent, we are of the
considered view that merits and demerits of the matter
cannot be gone into at this stage, while deciding an
application filed under O.VII R.11 of the CPC. It is fairly
well settled that at this stage only averments in the plaint
are to be looked into and from a reading of the averments
in the plaint in the case on hand, it cannot be said that
suit is barred by limitation. The issue as to when the
plaintiff had noticed refusal, is an issue which can be
adjudicated after trial. Even assuming that there is
inordinate delay and laches on the part of the plaintiff,
same cannot be a ground for rejection of plaint under
O.VII R.11(d) of CPC.”
9.
In view of the above, I do not find any illegality and infirmity in
the order passed by the learned Trial Court. The present revision petition,
being devoid of any merit, is accordingly dismissed. Pending applications, if
any, also stand disposed off.
10.
It is made clear that any observation made herein shall not be
treated as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case.
24.02.2026
Aman Jain
NOTE:
AMAN JAIN
2026.02.25 09:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
(ALKA SARIN)
JUDGE
Whether speaking/non-speaking: Speaking
Whether reportable: Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review