Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.227
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
CM No. 2568/2023
CM No. 741/2025
CAV No. 380/2023
Reserved on:20.07.2026
Pronounced on:23.07.2026
Uploaded on:24.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Mohd. Yaqoob, age 47 years,
S/O Late Sain Mohd, R/O Channi Kamala,
Tehsil and District Jammu.
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Rakesh Sharma, Advocate
Vs
1. Financial Commissioner (Revenue)Jammu and
Kashmir/Commissioner Agrarian Reforms J&K
Rail Head Complex, Trikuta Nagar, Jammu.
2. The Residents of Channi Kamala at present
Extension No. 3 Bhawani Vihar Trikuta Nagar,
Jammu
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Meharban Singh, AAG for R-1
Mr. Pranav Kohli, Sr. Advocate with
M/s Aftab Malik& Muddassir Zubair, Adv R-2
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Through the medium of the instant writ petition filed under Articles 226
and 227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner has called into
question the order dated 27.02.2023 passed by the learned Financial
Commissioner (Revenue), J&K, whereby the revision petition filed by
respondent No. 2 came to be allowed, the order dated 21.05.1991 passed
by the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner, Jammu was set aside
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
and Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959 pertaining to Estate Channi
Kamala, Tehsil Bahu, District Jammu was upheld.
BRIEF FACTS
2.
The controversy in the present petition relates to land measuring 48
kanals and 03 marlas comprised in Khasra Nos. 73, 85 and 88 min
situated at Estate Channi Kamala, Tehsil Bahu, District Jammu. The case
projected by the petitioner is that the said land, after extinguishment of
the rights of the erstwhile landlords under the provisions of the Jammu
and Kashmir Big Landed Estates Abolition Act, vested in Shera, who
was an occupancy tenant. It is further pleaded that, after the demise of
Shera, the property devolved upon his successors and, by way of
successive mutations of inheritance, ultimately came to vest in the
petitioner's father, Sain Mohd., and thereafter in the petitioner by virtue
of Mutation No. 1674.
3.
The dispute essentially revolves around Mutation No. 39 dated
10.03.1959, whereby ownership rights in respect of the land in question
were conferred upon Abdul Rahim and Mohd. Hussain. According to the
petitioner, Abdul Rahim was neither a member of the family of Shera
nor otherwise entitled to claim ownership under the provisions of the
Jammu and Kashmir Big Landed Estates Abolition Act. It is further
alleged that Mutation No. 39 suffered from various legal and factual
infirmities,
including
interpolation
in
the
mutation
register,
chronological inconsistencies in the revenue record and its attestation in
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
favour of Mohd. Hussain despite his alleged demise prior to the date of
attestation.
4.
Aggrieved of Mutation No. 39, the petitioner's father, Sain Mohd.,
preferred an appeal before the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Jammu. It is a matter of record that vide order dated 21.05.1991, the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner allowed the appeal and set
aside Mutation No. 39. According to the petitioner, the said order was
subsequently implemented by attestation of Mutation No. 596 in favour
of Sain Mohd. and, upon his demise, Mutation No. 1674 came to be
attested in favour of the petitioner.
5.
Respondent No. 2 thereafter instituted a revision petition before the
learned Financial Commissioner on 16.11.2020 challenging the aforesaid
order dated 21.05.1991. The case set up in the revision petition was that
the persons who had acquired interest in the land through registered sale
deeds executed by Abdul Rahim were necessary parties to the
proceedings before the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner but
had not been impleaded. It was further pleaded that knowledge of the
order dated 21.05.1991 was acquired only in the year 2017, when the
concerned revenue authorities declined to issue revenue extracts on the
basis of the said order.
6.
The learned Financial Commissioner, by the impugned order dated
27.02.2023, allowed the revision petition, condoned the delay in its
institution, held that the purchasers were necessary parties who had been
condemned unheard before the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
and further concluded that the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner
had failed to consider the issue of limitation before entering into the
merits of the appeal. Consequently, the order dated 21.05.1991 was set
aside and Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959 was upheld.
7.
Aggrieved of the aforesaid order, the petitioner has approached this
Court by way of the present petition, contending, inter alia, that the
revision petition itself was not maintainable and had been entertained
after an inordinate and unexplained delay. It is further contended that the
learned Financial Commissioner travelled beyond the scope of revisional
jurisdiction while deciding the matter on merits and that the impugned
order suffers from errors of law warranting interference by this Court.
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
8.
Mr. Rakesh Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that if the
law of limitation was applicable while challenging Mutation No. 39
before the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner, the same principle
would equally govern the revision petition preferred by respondent No.
2, which was admittedly instituted after nearly 29 years. According to
the learned counsel, respondent No. 2 could not claim a different
yardstick in the matter of limitation.
9.
He further submits that the learned Financial Commissioner exceeded
the scope of revisional jurisdiction while setting aside the order passed
by the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner. According to the
learned counsel, the revisional authority travelled beyond the limited
jurisdiction vested in it by reassessing the merits of the controversy and
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
virtually substituting its own findings for those recorded by the appellate
authority, which, according to the petitioner, was impermissible in law.
10.
It is further submitted that the learned Financial Commissioner erred in
entertaining the revision petition at the instance of respondent No. 2. It is
argued that the revision petition was preferred in the name of "Residents
of Channi Kamala" without disclosing the legal basis for instituting such
proceedings or establishing the representative capacity in which the
revision had been filed. According to the learned counsel, the
maintainability of the revision petition itself was, therefore, liable to be
rejected.
11.
Mr. Sharma vehemently argued that the impugned order passed by the
learned Financial Commissioner is legally unsustainable and deserves to
be quashed. He contended that the order dated 21.05.1991 passed by the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner deserves to be restored, as
Mutation No. 39 had, according to the petitioner, been attested in favour
of Abdul Rahim and Mohd. Hussain, despite Mohd. Hussain having
allegedly expired prior to the date of its attestation, which, according to
the petitioner, rendered the mutation void in law.
12.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, therefore, submits that the impugned
order dated 27.02.2023 passed by the learned Financial Commissioner is
legally unsustainable and deserves to be quashed. It is, accordingly,
prayed that the order dated 21.05.1991 passed by the learned Additional
Deputy Commissioner, Jammu be restored.
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
13.
Per Contra, it has been vehemently argued by the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for respondent No. 2, Mr. Pranav Kohli, that the
order passed by the learned Financial Commissioner is legally
sustainable in the eyes of law, inasmuch as the mutation, which had been
attested as far back as on 10.03.1959, came to be challenged before the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner after more than three decades
without any plausible explanation for such inordinate delay or, for that
matter, without filing any application seeking condonation thereof.
14.
It is contended that no finding whatsoever came to be recorded by the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner on the issue of limitation and
yet the said authority proceeded to set aside Mutation No. 39. Feeling
aggrieved thereof, respondent No. 2 preferred a revision petition before
the learned Financial Commissioner on 16.11.2020 and the delay in
filing the said revision stands duly explained and has been specifically
dealt with by the learned Financial Commissioner in paragraph 6 of the
impugned order.
15.
Thus, according to Mr. Pranav Kohli, learned Senior Counsel, the
learned Financial Commissioner has duly considered all the issues raised
in the revision petition, including the question of limitation in preferring
the revision after nearly 29 years, and has assigned cogent reasons while
condoning the delay and deciding the matter.
16.
It is further submitted that the learned Financial Commissioner has also
taken note of the fact that the purchasers under the registered sale deeds
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
were necessary parties to the proceedings before the learned Additional
Deputy Commissioner. However, despite being aware of the registered
sale deeds executed as far back as in the year 1981, the petitioner
deliberately chose not to implead the purchasers as party respondents in
the appeal preferred before the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner
after a lapse of more than 30 years.
17.
According to the learned Senior Counsel, this fact was very much within
the knowledge of the petitioner and yet, for reasons best known to him,
the purchasers were not arrayed as party respondents before the learned
Additional Deputy Commissioner, resulting in an order being passed
behind their back.
18.
Learned Senior Counsel further submits that respondent No. 2 came to
know of the order dated 21.05.1991 only when the concerned Patwari
declined to issue the requisite revenue extract on the ground that the
order passed by the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner had
affected the revenue record. It was only thereafter that the revision
petition
came
to
be
preferred
before
the
learned
Financial
Commissioner.
19.
When a query was raised by this Court as to how and under what
circumstances the revision petition had been instituted under the title
"Residents of Channi Kamala", Mr. Pranav Kohli submitted that the
persons in whose favour the registered sale deeds had been executed
were residents of Channi Kamala and had, according to the learned
Senior Counsel, passed a resolution and instituted the revision petition
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
feeling aggrieved of the order dated 21.05.1991 passed by the learned
Additional Deputy Commissioner.
20.
Another query was put to the learned Senior Counsel as to what
constituted the fresh cause of action for challenging the order dated
21.05.1991 after nearly 29 years. In response, it was submitted that the
purchasers, who had acquired the suit land through registered sale deeds,
came to know of the said order only in the year 2017 when the
concerned Patwari refused to issue the requisite revenue extract on the
strength of the order passed by the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner.
21.
It is, thus, submitted that the delay in filing the revision occurred
because respondent No. 2 was never a party to the proceedings before
the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner and could obtain a copy of
the order only after acquiring knowledge thereof. Immediately
thereafter, steps were taken to institute the revision petition, and all these
aspects have been duly considered by the learned Financial
Commissioner while passing the impugned order.
22.
The learned Senior Counsel has also invited the attention of this Court to
the observations recorded by the learned Financial Commissioner that
Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959 had been challenged before the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner only on 29.01.1990, that is,
after a lapse of more than 30 years. According to him, it was, therefore,
incumbent upon the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner to have
first determined the issue of limitation before entering into the merits of
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
the controversy. Having failed to do so, the order passed by the learned
Additional Deputy Commissioner could not be sustained in law.
23.
The learned Senior Counsel has further drawn the attention of this Court
to the observations recorded by the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner himself that the suit land might have changed several
hands during the intervening period. Despite recording such an
observation, the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner proceeded to
set aside the mutation without condoning the delay or recording any
reasons in that regard, which, according to the learned Senior Counsel,
rendered the said order legally unsustainable.
24.
Mr. Kohli, therefore, submits that the learned Financial Commissioner,
while exercising revisional jurisdiction, has rightly set aside the order
dated
21.05.1991
passed
by
the
learned
Additional
Deputy
Commissioner, Jammu and upheld Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959
pertaining to Estate Channi Kamala, Tehsil Bahu, District Jammu by
virtue of the impugned order dated 27.02.2023.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
25.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the record.
26.
Before adverting to the merits of the controversy, it would be apposite to
notice that the present petition has been instituted under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India without clearly indicating the precise
constitutional jurisdiction invoked. The scope, nature and ambit of the
powers exercisable under Articles 226 and 227 are distinct and operate
in different fields. It is, therefore, incumbent upon a litigant invoking the
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
jurisdiction of this Court to lay the requisite factual and legal foundation
corresponding to the constitutional provision under which relief is
sought. In the present case, however, the challenge is directed against the
revisional order passed by the learned Financial Commissioner and the
relief claimed is essentially supervisory in nature. Accordingly, this
Court proceeds to examine the present petition within the well-settled
parameters governing the exercise of supervisory jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
27.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the pleadings and
considered the material available on record, this Court deems it
appropriate to formulate the following questions for determination:
QUESTION NO. 1
Whether the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner
committed a material irregularity amounting to a
jurisdictional error in deciding the appeal on merits
without first adjudicating upon the issue of limitation,
despite the challenge to Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959
having been instituted after more than three decades?
QUESTION NO. 2
Whether the learned Financial Commissioner was
justified in condoning the delay in entertaining the
revision petition preferred by respondent No.2?
QUESTION NO. 3
Whether the persons claiming rights through the
registered sale deeds executed by Abdul Rahim or his
successors-in-interest were necessary parties to the
proceedings before the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner and, if so, whether the order dated
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
21.05.1991 amounted to a violation of the principles of
natural justice on account of their non-impleadment?
QUESTION NO. 4
Whether the learned Financial Commissioner acted
within the permissible bounds of revisional jurisdiction
while setting aside the order dated 21.05.1991 passed by
the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner?
QUESTION NO. 5
Whether the impugned order dated 27.02.2023 passed by
the learned Financial Commissioner suffers from any
jurisdictional error, patent perversity or manifest illegality
so as to warrant interference by this Court in exercise of its
supervisory
jurisdiction
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India?”
QUESTION NO. 1:Whether the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner committed a material
irregularity amounting to a jurisdictional error in deciding the appeal on
merits without first adjudicating upon the issue of limitation, despite the
challenge to Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959 having been instituted after
more than three decades?
28.
A perusal of the order dated 21.05.1991 reveals that the learned
Additional Deputy Commissioner proceeded to examine the validity of
Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959 on merits and ultimately set aside the
same. However, despite the specific issue arising with regard to the
extraordinary delay in challenging a mutation which had remained
operative for more than thirty years, no adjudication came to be made on
the question of limitation nor any reasons were recorded for entertaining
such belated proceedings. The learned Financial Commissioner has
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
noticed this jurisdictional infirmity and has held that the issue of
limitation ought to have been addressed before entering upon the merits of
the controversy.
29.
The aforesaid conclusion also finds support from the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in ‘Union of India and another v. British India
Corporation Ltd. and others’, (2003) 9 SCC 505, wherein the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, while emphasizing the mandatory nature of the law of
limitation, observed that:
“The question of limitation is a mandate to the forum and,
irrespective of the fact whether it was raised or not, the forum must
consider and apply it, if there is no dispute on facts.”
30.
The aforesaid dictum leaves no manner of doubt that the question of
limitation is not a mere procedural formality but goes to the very root of
the maintainability of the proceedings. Once the appeal before the learned
Additional Deputy Commissioner disclosed, on the face of the record, that
Mutation No.39 dated 10.03.1959 was being challenged after more than
three decades, it was incumbent upon the appellate authority to first
determine the issue of limitation before embarking upon an examination
of the merits of the controversy. The omission to do so constituted a
material irregularity, which was rightly corrected by the learned Financial
Commissioner in exercise of revisional jurisdiction.
31.
The view taken by the learned Financial Commissioner also finds
support from the recent judgment of this Court in ‘Abdul Gani Ganie
and others v. Habibullah Ganie’, WP(C) No.1303/2025, decided on
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
19.12.2025, wherein this Court reiterated that the question of limitation
goes to the very root of the maintainability of proceedings and is
required to be examined before the authority proceeds to consider the
merits of the controversy. The relevant observations are reproduced as
under:
“45. It is a settled principle of law that the question of
limitation is a pure question of law, which goes to the very root
of the maintainability of the proceedings. A court or statutory
authority is not only empowered but is duty-bound to examine
the issue of limitation suo motu, even if the same has not been
specifically pleaded or argued by the parties.
46. Where a proceeding appears, on the face of the record, to
be barred by delay or suffers from gross laches, the authority
cannot shut its eyes to such illegality and proceed to examine
the matter on merits. Entertaining a time-barred claim would
itself amount to a jurisdictional error.”
32.
The aforesaid principles are squarely applicable to the facts of the
present case. The appeal before the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner was directed against Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959
and admittedly came to be instituted after more than three decades. Once
such issue arose from the record itself, it was incumbent upon the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner to have first determined
whether the appeal deserved to be entertained notwithstanding the
extraordinary delay and whether sufficient cause had been made out for
condoning the same. Without recording any finding on that foundational
issue, the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner proceeded to
adjudicate the validity of the mutation on merits. This Court is,
therefore, of the view that the learned Financial Commissioner was,
therefore, justified in holding that the omission to first decide the
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
question of limitation constituted a material irregularity warranting
interference in exercise of revisional jurisdiction.
33.
Accordingly, Question No. 1 is answered in favour of respondent No.
2 and against the petitioner by holding that the learned Additional
Deputy Commissioner committed a material jurisdictional error in
deciding the appeal on merits without first adjudicating upon the issue of
limitation.
QUESTION NO. 2:Whether the learned Financial Commissioner was justified in
condoning the delay in entertaining the revision petition preferred by
respondent No. 2?
34.
It is a settled principle of law that while considering the question of
condonation of delay, it is not the mere length of the delay which
constitutes the determinative criterion but the acceptability and
sufficiency of the explanation furnished. Though delay has occurred on
the part of both sides at different stages of the proceedings, the
circumstances attending each delay are materially different. The appeal
preferred before the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner against
Mutation No. 39 dated 10.03.1959 was instituted after more than three
decades without any explanation whatsoever for such extraordinary
delay, much less any material demonstrating sufficient cause.
Conversely, respondent No. 2 satisfactorily explained the delay in
approaching the learned Financial Commissioner by establishing that
neither they nor the other purchasers claiming through registered sale
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
deeds had been impleaded before the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner and that they acquired knowledge of the order dated
21.05.1991 only when the concerned Patwari declined to issue the
requisite revenue extracts. The explanation furnished by respondent No.
2 cannot be said to be either mala fide or indicative of negligence and, in
the considered opinion of this Court, constituted sufficient cause for
condoning the delay. Upon examining the reasons assigned by the
learned Financial Commissioner in the light of the pleadings and the
material placed before him, this Court is of the considered opinion that
the learned Financial Commissioner committed no illegality in
condoning the delay while entertaining the revision petition.
35.
The
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
“N.
Balakrishnan
v.
M.
Krishnamurthy”, (1998) 7 SCC 123, while considering the scope of
interference with an order condoning delay, has observed as under:
“9. ….Length of delay is no matter, acceptability of the
explanation is the only criterion. Sometimes delay of the shortest
range may be uncondonable due to want of acceptable
explanation whereas in certain other cases delay of very long
range can be condoned as the explanation thereof is satisfactory.
Once the court accepts the explanation as sufficient it is the
result of positive exercise of discretion and normally the
superior court should not disturb such finding, much less in
revisional jurisdiction, unless the exercise of discretion was on
whole untenable grounds or arbitrary or perverse…”
36.
What, therefore, emerges is that the question of condonation of delay is
not to be determined with reference to the mere length of the delay but
with reference to the acceptability of the explanation furnished. If the
authority, upon consideration of the material placed before it, finds that
the explanation constitutes sufficient cause, the delay deserves to be
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
condoned notwithstanding its duration so as to advance substantial
justice. However, where the explanation is found to be wholly
unacceptable or lacking in bona fides, no such indulgence can be shown.
37.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, this
Court finds that the explanation furnished by respondent No. 2 before
the learned Financial Commissioner cannot be said to be either fanciful
or devoid of substance. The learned Financial Commissioner considered
the said explanation, recorded reasons for accepting the same and
thereafter, exercised the discretion vested in him. Such exercise of
discretion does not suffer from arbitrariness, perversity or manifest
illegality so as to warrant interference in exercise of writ jurisdiction
under Article 227.
38.
The submission advanced on behalf of the petitioner that the same
principle of limitation ought to govern both the appeal preferred before
the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner and the revision petition
instituted before the learned Financial Commissioner also deserves to be
rejected. The two proceedings stand on entirely different foundational
factual pleadings. While the appeal before the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner was preferred after more than three decades without any
application seeking condonation of delay or any explanation whatsoever
for such extraordinary lapse of time and respondent No.2 was also
admittedly not a party to the proceedings before the learned Additional
Deputy Commissioner and, therefore, had no occasion to assail the order
until knowledge thereof was acquired. The learned Financial
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
Commissioner has accepted the explanation after recording cogent
reasons. Thus, the delay which has occasioned in both the cases neither
arise from identical circumstances nor warrant identical treatment in law.
39.
Question No. 2 is, therefore, answered in favour of respondent No. 2
by holding that the learned Financial Commissioner rightly exercised his
discretion in condoning the delay upon being satisfied that sufficient
cause had been established.
QUESTION NO. 3:Whether the persons claiming rights through the registered sale deeds
executed by Abdul Rahim or his successors-in-interest were necessary
parties to the proceedings before the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner and, if so, whether the order dated 21.05.1991
amounted to a violation of the principles of natural justice on account
of their non-impleadment?
40.
Equally significant is the finding recorded by the learned Financial
Commissioner that the purchasers claiming through registered sale deeds
executed by Abdul Rahim or his successors-in-interest were directly
affected by the order dated 21.05.1991 passed by the learned Additional
Deputy Commissioner and, therefore, constituted necessary parties to
those proceedings. Despite the existence of such registered conveyances,
none of the purchasers were impleaded before the learned Additional
Deputy Commissioner, although the order ultimately passed had the effect
of unsettling rights flowing from those conveyances. Any adjudication
affecting such civil rights could not have been undertaken without
affording the concerned persons an effective opportunity of hearing.
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
Indeed, no order affecting vested civil rights ought ordinarily to be passed
behind the back of the persons whose rights stand directly affected
thereby. The learned Financial Commissioner was, therefore, justified in
holding that the purchasers had been condemned unheard and that such
omission constituted a material irregularity and also falls within the realm
of an illegality warranting interference in revisional jurisdiction.
41.
The aforesaid conclusion also finds support from the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in ‘Canara Bank v. Debasis Das’, (2003) 4 SCC
557, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while emphasizing the
paramount importance of the principles of natural justice, observed as
under:
“15. The adherence to principles of natural justice as
recognized by all civilized States is of supreme importance
when a quasi-judicial body embarks on determining disputes
between the parties, or any administrative action involving
civil consequences is in issue. These principles are well settled.
The first and foremost principle is what is commonly known
as audi alteram partem rule. It says that no one should be
condemned unheard. Notice is the first limb of this principle.
It must be precise and unambiguous. It should appraise the
party determinatively the case he has to meet. Time given for
the purpose should be adequate so as to enable him to make
his representation. In the absence of a notice of the kind and
such reasonable opportunity, the order passed becomes wholly
vitiated. Thus, it is but essential that a party should be put on
notice of the case before any adverse order is passed against
him. This is one of the most important principles of natural
justice. It is after all an approved rule of fair play.”
42.
The aforesaid principle squarely governs the facts of the present case. The
order dated 21.05.1991 passed by the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner directly affected the rights of respondent No. 2 and other
purchasers claiming through registered sale deeds. Despite being persons
whose civil rights stood liable to be adversely affected, they were neither
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
impleaded as parties nor afforded an opportunity of hearing before the said
order came to be passed. Such an adjudication, rendered behind the back of
necessary parties, was clearly contrary to the principles of audi alteram
partem. The learned Financial Commissioner, therefore, rightly held that
the proceedings before the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner stood
vitiated on account of violation of the principles of natural justice and
warranted interference in exercise of revisional jurisdiction.
43.
Question No. 3 is likewise answered in favour of respondent No. 2 by
holding that the purchasers under the registered sale deeds were necessary
parties and the order dated 21.05.1991 amounted to a violation of the
principles of natural justice owing to their non-impleadment.
QUESTION NO. 4:Whether the learned Financial Commissioner acted within the
permissible bounds of revisional jurisdiction while setting aside the
order dated 21.05.1991 passed by the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner?
44.
Revisional jurisdiction is intended to correct jurisdictional errors, material
irregularities and illegal exercise of jurisdiction committed by subordinate
authorities. Where the authority of first instance proceeds to determine the
merits of a controversy without first deciding an issue which goes to the
root of the maintainability of the proceedings or renders an adjudication in
violation of the principles of natural justice, the revisional authority would
be fully justified in exercising its jurisdiction to correct such illegality. The
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
impugned order passed by the learned Financial Commissioner is,
therefore, a legitimate exercise of such revisional jurisdiction.
45.
The learned Financial Commissioner did not re-appreciate the evidence
merely because another view was possible. Rather, the interference was
occasioned by the failure of the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner
to determine the foundational issue of limitation and by the omission to
implead persons whose civil rights stood directly affected by the outcome
of the proceedings. These defects went to the legality of the proceedings
themselves and fully justified the exercise of revisional jurisdiction
46.
This Court also cannot lose sight of the fact that the learned Additional
Deputy Commissioner himself observed that the property in question might
have changed several hands during the long intervening period. Once such
an observation had been recorded, greater circumspection was required
before unsettling long-standing revenue entries. Rights flowing from
registered conveyances could not have been adversely affected without first
determining the maintainability of the appeal on the touchstone of
limitation and without affording an opportunity of hearing to all persons
likely to be prejudiced by the proposed adjudication. The omission assumes
added significance in the peculiar facts of the present case. The learned
Financial Commissioner was, therefore, justified in treating such omission
as a jurisdictional infirmity warranting interference in revisional
jurisdiction.
47.
The contention of the petitioner that respondent No. 2 lacked locus to
maintain the revision also does not persuade this Court to interfere with the
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
impugned order. The learned Financial Commissioner has returned a
categorical finding that the purchasers were in possession of the property,
had acquired interest through registered conveyances and were directly
affected by the order passed by the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner. Such a finding is essentially one of fact based upon the
material placed before the revisional authority. No perversity or patent
illegality in the said finding has been demonstrated before this Court.
48.
It is true that the petitioner has raised several contentions touching upon
the legality of Mutation No. 39, including alleged interpolation in the
mutation register, chronological discrepancies and attestation in favour
of Mohd. Hussain despite his alleged demise prior to the date of
attestation. However, the revisional authority has examined the material
before it and recorded reasons for disagreeing with the conclusions
drawn by the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner. Re-appreciation
of disputed questions of fact is not the function of this Court, particularly
when the findings recorded by the revisional authority are based upon
appreciation of the material available on record and are shown to be
neither perverse nor unsupported by evidence.
49.
Examined in the aforesaid backdrop, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the learned Financial Commissioner exercised the revisional
jurisdiction vested in him for correcting the jurisdictional error
committed by the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner in deciding
the appeal without first addressing the issue of limitation and without
ensuring that the persons whose rights were likely to be affected were
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
before the Court. The reasons assigned by the learned Financial
Commissioner cannot be said to be arbitrary, irrational or otherwise
contrary to law. The learned Financial Commissioner, therefore, acted
within the permissible bounds of revisional jurisdiction.
50.
Consequently, Question No. 4 is answered in affirmative and in
favour of respondent No.2 by holding that the learned Financial
Commissioner acted well within the permissible limits of revisional
jurisdiction while correcting the jurisdictional errors committed by the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner.
QUESTION NO. 5:Whether the impugned order dated 27.02.2023 passed by the learned
Financial Commissioner suffers from any jurisdictional error, patent
perversity or manifest illegality so as to warrant interference by this
Court in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India?
51.
Having held that the learned Financial Commissioner acted within the
bounds of revisional jurisdiction, this Court now proceeds to examine
whether the impugned order nevertheless warrants interference in exercise
of supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution.
52.
The submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner, though elaborately
argued, do not demonstrate any jurisdictional error, manifest illegality or
perversity in the impugned order dated 27.02.2023. The petitioner has,
therefore, failed to make out a case warranting interference by this Court
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
53.
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
The jurisdiction of this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution is
supervisory and not appellate. Unless the findings recorded by the authority
suffer from patent lack of jurisdiction, manifest perversity or an error
apparent on the face of the record, this Court would not interfere merely
because another view on the facts is possible.
54.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in ‘Shalini Shyam Shetty v. Rajendra
Shankar Patil’, (2010) 8 SCC 329, has held that the supervisory
jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution is to be
exercised sparingly and only where the impugned order suffers from
lack of jurisdiction, patent perversity, manifest illegality or gross failure
of justice. In the present case, the order passed by the learned Financial
Commissioner suffers from none of these infirmities. Rather, the learned
Financial Commissioner lawfully exercised the revisional jurisdiction
vested in him to correct the jurisdictional errors committed by the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner. Consequently, no ground for
interference is made out.
55.
Accordingly, Question No. 5 is also answered in favour of respondent
No.2 by holding that the impugned order dated 27.02.2023 does not
suffer from any jurisdictional error, patent perversity or manifest
illegality warranting interference by this Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
CONCLUSION
56.
In view of the foregoing discussion and the findings returned on each of the
questions formulated hereinabove, this Court is of the considered opinion
WP (C) No. 1103/2023
that the impugned order dated 27.02.2023 passed by the learned Financial
Commissioner (Revenue), J&K does not suffer from any jurisdictional
error, patent perversity, manifest illegality or failure of justice warranting
interference in exercise of the supervisory jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India. On the contrary, the learned
Financial Commissioner has rightly exercised the revisional jurisdiction
vested in him by correcting the material irregularities committed by the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner, Jammu.
57.
Accordingly, the writ petition, being devoid of merit, is dismissed. The
order dated 27.02.2023 passed by the learned Financial Commissioner
(Revenue), J&K is upheld. Pending application(s), if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
(Wasim Sadiq Nargal)
Judge
Jammu:
23.07.2026
Nikhil
Whether the judgment is speaking :
Whether the judgment is reportable :
Vijay Kumar
2026.07.24 13:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review