Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
CM No. 7381/2023
Reserved on: 10.02.2026
Pronounced on: 25.02.2026
Uploaded on: 26.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Mohd Ashraf, age 52 years S/o Nasrullah Malik,
R/o Bharat, Tehsil & District Doda.
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. M A Bhat, Advocate
Vs
1. UT of J&K through its Commissioner Secretary, Public
Works(R&B) Department, Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2. The Chief Engineer, PMGSY (JKRRDA) JKPCC
building, 4th Floor, Panama Chowk, Jammu.
3. District Development Commissioner, Doda.
4. Superintendent Engineer, PMGSY Circle, Batote
5. Executive Engineer, PMGSY Division Doda.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG vice
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG
Coram:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01. The present petition has been filed by the petitioner seeking writ of
Mandamus to command the respondents to forthwith release the admitted
balance payment of ₹12.60,800/- along with interest at the bank lending
rates from the date the payment became due till the same is actually paid, in
favour of the petitioner on account of the execution of restoration works for
various PMGSY roads in Sub-Division Assar and Division Doda, which
were washed away by unprecedented flash floods in September 2014 and
February-March 2016. The restoration work was carried out under the
Disaster Management Programme and the payment was to be made from
SDRF.
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
02. The petitioner, who was requested by respondents 3, 4 and 5, being a
registered A-class contractor to undertake the restoration works of 13
PMGSY roads, the details of which find mention in para 2 of the writ
petition i.e Ludna to Gundana Road Km 3rd 2014, Doda to Malwana Jagir
Km 1st to 8 2014, Chakri to Kalihand Road 2014, Dhar to Dashnan Road
20 2014, Khilot to Shira road 2014, Malwana Jagir to Abli Masri Road
2014, Doda Bharat to Al Road Km 2nd to Km 4th 2024, Bhabore to Jijote
Road 2014, Beoli to Koti road 2014, Dongroo to Gadether Road 2014,
Jodhpur to Parsulla Road 2014 and Dali-Kulhand Road Km 1st to 8th 2014
in Division Doda. It is specific case of the petitioner that the petitioner
successfully completed all the works to the entire satisfaction of the
respondents and the necessary measurements were also taken on-site by the
concerned field staff and the final bills were also submitted by the
petitioner for payment. The petitioner has also placed on record the
requisite documents, estimate, measurement and the final bills with a view
to advance his case by way of an Annexure-I with the instant writ petition.
03. The further fact of the matter is that in the year 2016, during the months of
February and March, unusual and heavy rains caused havoc, damaging the
roads throughout the erstwhile State of J&K, particularly in District Doda.
Accordingly, the services of the petitioner were once again requisitioned by
the respondents to undertake the restoration works of at least nine roads,
such as Bhargran to Behota Road in 2016, Bhargran to Rote 2016,
Bhargran to Behota in 2016, Bhargran to Rote Road 2016, Chakri to
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
Kalihand road 2016, Bhargran to Rote Road 2016 and three more roads,
bills of which have already been submitted before the concerned authority.
At this stage also, the concerned engineering staff, according to the
petitioner, conducted the necessary measurements and prepared the
estimate and based on the work completed, the petitioner submitted the
requisite bills to the respondents for payment. The further case of the
petitioner is that the petitioner executed 22 works with the respondentdepartment for the work costs to the tune of ₹14,20,800/- for all these
works. As per the petitioner, only a meager amount of ₹1,60,000/- was
released in favour of the petitioner way back on 01.12.2015, while the
balance amount of ₹12,60,800/- till date has not been paid by the
respondents despite the petitioner’s repeated requests for such payment.
04. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the requisite balance
payment was supposed to be made by the respondent under the State
Disaster Relief Fund i.e SDRF and since sufficient funds are available with
the respondents, there is no justifiable reason for the respondents not to
make the payment to the petitioner for the work which the petitioner has
executed well in time. Since the balance payment was not released, the
petitioner was constrained to file various representations from time to time
for the release of aforesaid amount in spite of the fact that the respondents
have admitted the liability towards the petitioner which can be
substantiated from a bare perusal of a communication issued by the
concerned Executive Engineer, PMGSY Division Doda in pursuance of the
communication filed by the petitioner way back on 10.02.2022.
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
05. From a bare perusal of the aforesaid communication, it is apparently clear
that the respondents have admitted the liability for 22 works to the tune of
₹12,60,800/- and accordingly a request has been made by the concerned
Executive Engineer to the District Development Commissioner, Doda to
release the work done claim of the contractor-petitioner as the petitioner
was pushing hard for the same. Thus, according to Mr. Bhat, once the
respondents have admitted the claim of the petitioner way back in the year
2022, there is no justifiable cause for not making the said payment in
favour of the petitioner when the work has been executed by the petitioner
for the aforesaid 22 works which has been acknowledged and the part
payment has already been released.
06. At this stage Mr. Bhat submits that the issue which has been projected in
the instant petition is covered by the judgment passed by this Court in
WP(C) No. 2472/2022 titled M/s Saint Soldier Engineer and contractor
Pvt. Ltd vs UT of J&K & Ors, decided on 26.09.2025 and also various
other judgments passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court, wherein it
has been made clear that “post facto” the respondents cannot raise any
objection for the release of the amount for the work which has already been
executed and also for the work where the respondents have admitted the
said liability.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
07. Per Contra, the reply stands filed on behalf of the respondents 1,2 4 & 5 in
which the respondents have taken a specific stand that since there is delay
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
by the petitioner in approaching this Court, thus the claim being time
barred is liable to be rejected by placing reliance upon the judgments
referred in the reply affidavit. The respondents have also taken a stand that
the petitioner ought to have filed the petition within a period of three years
to be reckoned from the date the work in question was completed in terms
of Article 56 of the Schedule appended with the J&K Limitation Act of
1995 which Act at the relevant point of time was in vogue.
08. The respondents have pleaded that although the law of limitation is not
strictly applicable to the case in hand, yet in reliance upon the aforesaid
provisions, it has been prayed that since the remedy under Article 226 of
the Constitution is a discretionary remedy, the Court should have refused to
entertain the instant claim which is not brought within the reasonable
period and thus the writ petition which is not maintainable is liable to be
dismissed. The respondents, however, while filing reply affidavit have not
denied the execution of work, measurement, certification or else the
admitted liability towards the petitioner but have taken the solitary ground
of the claim being time barred.
LEGAL ANALYSIS.
09. Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the record.
10. The petitioner completed the restoration works in 2016 and submitted
claims for payment. The respondents released the part payment of works
but despite an admitted balance amount of ₹12,60,800/-, the same was
withheld without justification even after the final bills were settled and
repeated representations were made in this regard.
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
11. Upon consideration, it is evident that the petitioner satisfactorily executed
the contractual work as per the revised specifications sanctioned by the
respondents. The liability has been acknowledged by the respondents from
time to time which can be authenticated from bare perusal of the official
record and final bills. The respondents’ counsel however, has argued that
the claim of the petitioner is time-barred which as per record is not tenable
and cannot be justified.
12. The legal position regarding the payment of dues for contractual work
executed is well-settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in several
authoritative pronouncements. These judgments collectively underscore the
imperative that “contractual payments must not be unduly delayed or
withheld by the State without valid reasons.”
13. As held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Ramakrishna Construction Co.
v. Union of India”, (2010) 3 SCC 579, it is a settled proposition that once
work has been executed and the liability is admitted, the State cannot
arbitrarily withhold payment.
14. Similarly, in “Surya Constructions v. State of U.P”, (1986) 3 SCC 247,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that “Courts can exercise writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution in cases where admitted
contractual dues are withheld without justification.’’
15. In view of the above, this Court holds that where the delay in releasing
payments is attributable to the State, and there is no legal impediment or
contractual dispute, the Government must explain the cause of such delay.
Each day’s delay in the release of payment must be justified. In the absence
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
of such justification, the Government shall be liable to pay interest for the
delayed period to the affected contractor/petitioner. Further, the
Government shall also be liable to compensate the petitioner for the
financial loss and distress caused due to such delay. The principle of
fairness demands that the State cannot have a ‘win-win’ situation, where it
delays payment for years and still discharges only the principal amount,
without any consequence or accountability. The State can’t retain benefits
of executed work without corresponding payments.
16. In the similar facts and circumstances, this view finds support from the
judgment passed by this Court in case titled “M/s Saint Solider Engineer
and Contractor Pvt Ltd vs Union Territory of J&K & Ors”, decided
on 26.09.2025, wherein it has been held as under:
“20. It is well settled that execution of work gives rise to a corresponding
obligation upon the State to honour its financial commitments. Any
administrative approval or availability of funds is a matter to be ensured by
the department prior to the allotment of work. After the execution of the
contract, no “post facto” objection can be raised to deny or delay payment.
21. This Court is constrained to observe that in numerous cases involving
government contracts, despite completion of work in accordance with the
terms and conditions of the contract, the payments due to contractors are
not released in a timely manner. The delay is often attributed to
administrative reasons, such as the need for administrative approval or the
alleged paucity of funds or the funds being diverted to other projects to
frustrate the claim of the contractors. In the present case as well, despite
admitted liability and due completion of work by the petitioner well in time
the payment has been unjustifiably withheld for a considerable period of
time.”
In the aforesaid judgment, this court has also issued various
directions to ensure the effective enforcement of contractual payments and
to uphold the principles of fairness and accountability. For ready reference,
the same are reproduced as under:
“A. Obligation to Pay Post Completion: Once the work has been executed
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
strictly in accordance with the terms and conditions set out in the tender
and the agreement, the respondents shall be under a clear statutory and
contractual obligation to release the due payment without any undue or
arbitrary delay.
B. Rejection of Post-facto Administrative Objections: After the execution of
work, the respondents shall not be permitted to raise objections pertaining
to administrative approvals, sanction of funds, or diversion of funds as
grounds to withhold or delay payment.
C. Payment of Interest on Delayed Amounts: In cases, where the delay in
payment is not attributable to the contractors, the respondents shall be
liable to pay interest on the outstanding amount at the prevailing rates in
nationalized banks, calculated from the date the payment fell due until the
actual date of payment.
D. Personal Accountability for Malafide Conduct: Where delay or
withholding of payment arises from negligence, omission, or mala fide
conduct on the part of any officer or official, the accrued interest shall be
recovered from the salary or emoluments of such officer, thereby fixing
personal accountability and deterring arbitrary exercise of power.
E. Constitutional and Welfare Considerations: A welfare State cannot
legitimately plead “paucity of funds” when payments for works already
executed and utilized are withheld. The principle of economic justice
obliges the State to ensure that contractors, having fulfilled their part of the
bargain, are not subjected to financial distress on account of arbitrary or
habitual withholding of dues. In cases of habitual or willful withholding,
apart from interest, the Court may impose exemplary costs against the
erring department, to be deposited with the State Legal Services Authority
for utilisation towards public welfare purposes.”
17. Reliance has also been placed on the judgment passed by this Court in
WP(C) No. 2513/2022 titled “M/s Tech Build & Associate vs UT of J&K
& Ors”, decided on 09.05.2025, wherein it has been held as under:.
“The execution of works stands admitted by the respondents, and the
relevant details have also been provided by them. The respondents cannot
avoid their liability to pay by taking refuge in the absence of technical
sanction and administrative approval, especially when the responsibility for
obtaining such approvals rested solely with them. Despite this, the
respondents are denying the claim on the ground of lack of administrative
approval. This plea is not available to them, as it was within their domain to
ensure the requisite approvals were obtained. They cannot now raise this
plea at this stage to defeat the legitimate claim of the petitioner.
18. This Court is of the considered view that the duty of the State to pay for
work executed and enjoyed is a constitutional obligation flowing from
Article 14, and delay in seeking enforcement of such right cannot absolve
the State from its responsibility. Article 14 of the Constitution of India
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of laws. The
jurisprudence under Article 14 has evolved far beyond formal equality, it
now encompasses the principle that State action, whether legislative,
executive, or contractual, must not be arbitrary, unreasonable, or unfair.
The Government, when entering into contracts or dealing with contractors,
does not shed its constitutional obligations. Unlike a private party, the State
is bound to act as a model litigant. Once the liability is admitted such as
when work is duly executed, measured, and certified the withholding of the
payment without justification amounts to arbitrary action and thus falls foul
of Article 14.
19. What clearly emerges from the record is that the liability is admitted by the
respondents themselves. Once liability is admitted, the only surviving issue
relates to the delay in release of payment which in the opinion of this Court
warrants inquiry so as to fix the responsibility upon the officers concerned.
If contractors are repeatedly compelled to approach the Court for the
release of legitimate dues, the fault lies with the respondents and not the
petitioner.
20. This Court notes with concern that such instances of withholding admitted
dues are recurring reflecting systemic inaction. The writ court cannot turn a
blind eye to such grievances on hyper-technical pleas of limitation, when
non-payment of the admitted liability being acknowledged by the
respondents from time to time is a recurring cause till the actual amount is
released.
21. Further this Court is of the view that once work has been executed by the
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
contractor in conformity with the terms and conditions of the contract
agreement, the concerned department is under a legal obligation to release
the payment without undue delay. The straight jacket formula of claim
being time barred on hyper technical grounds cannot be imported or
applied in the present matter.
22. The only ground which has been projected by the learned counsel for the
respondents is that it is a time barred claim and the writ petition is required
to be dismissed on this solitary ground. The respondents have not denied
viz-a-viz the specific averments of the petitioner that the respondents have
admitted the liability of the petitioner to the tune of ₹12,60,800 /- and
having not denied the said averments, it can safely be concluded that the
respondents have admitted the claim of the petitioner. After having
admitted the claim of the petitioner, it does not lie in the mouth of the
respondents to agitate that the present claim is time barred when in fact the
petitioner has approached well in time before the respondents for the
release of the payment and have also filed various representations from
time to time. No objection of claim being time barred was ever raised by
the respondents and now, the respondents are precluded to take this
objection by way of a preliminary objection at the time of filing of the
reply. Thus, the stand taken by the respondents is factually incorrect,
legally untenable and liable to be rejected.
23. With regard to the said issue of the petition being time barred, this Court in
“Saint Soldier Enginner and Contractor Pvt Ltd” (supra), had also
observed as under:-
WP(C) No. 3061/2023
“13……Once liability is admitted and the State continues to enjoy the fruits
of the work executed by the petitioner, it cannot be permitted to turn around
and deny payment on the plea of limitation.
14. The liability in the present case is in the nature of a recurring liability.
The work has been executed, utilized, and the benefits continue to accrue to
the respondents. In such cases, the cause of action is a continuing one, and
every day of non-payment constitutes a fresh infraction of the petitioner’s
rights. Therefore, the bar of limitation cannot be rigidly applied to defeat
such claims.
15. It is equally well settled that the power under Article 226 of the
Constitution is discretionary in nature. While it is true that ordinarily
claims which are stale, delayed, or barred may not be entertained, the Court
retains discretion to intervene where arbitrariness, admitted liability, or
unjust enrichment of the State is writ large”.
CONCLUSION
24. In the light of the what has been discussed above and also in the light of the
law laid down by this Court, the instant writ petition is allowed and the
respondents are directed to release the admitted liability in favour of the
petitioner, which is by way of balance amount to the tune of ₹12,60,800 /within a period of four weeks from the date, a copy of this order as well as
copy of the instant writ petition along with the annexures are made
available to the said respondents, failing which the petitioner will be
entitled for the interest @6% from the date the said amount was due and
not paid by the respondents.
25. The instant writ petition is, accordingly, disposed of along with connected
application(s).
(WASIM SADIQ NARGAL)
JUDGE
JAMMU
25.02.2026
Vijay
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes/No
Vijay Kumar
2026.02.08 23:50
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review