Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
P.SAM KOSHY
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.2592 of 2026
(CNR No.HBHC010571852026)
DATE: 02.11.2026
Reserved on: 09.10.2026
Pronounced on: 02.11.2026
Uploaded on: 02.11.2026
Between:
Mohammed Zakir Osman
…Petitioner
v.
M/s. IRIS Hospitals Private Limited and 6 Others.
…Respondents
ORDER: (per Hon’ble The Acting Chief Justice P.Sam Koshy)
Heard Mr. R.A.Achutanand, learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner.
2.
The present Civil Revision Petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India has been filed by the petitioner assailing the
proceedings dated 13.08.2026 in O.S. No. 19697 of 2026, passed by
the Honourable Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad.
3.
Vide the impugned order; the City Civil Court issued a memo
dated 13.08.2026, that the suit has to be valued under Section 37(a)(1)
of the Court Fee Act.
4.
The petitioner was a businessman and Chairman of prestigious
institutions in the twin cities of Hyderabad and in Ranga Reddy
District. He was a long-term friend of, and well acquainted with, one
Mr. Sukesh Gupta, Proprietor of M/s. MBS Jewelers. The said Mr.
Sukesh Gupta represented to the petitioner that he was travelling
abroad to Dubai, and that, being a common friend of the directors of
respondent No.4-Company and being preoccupied, he was unable to
attend the office of the Sub-Registrar. He therefore requested the
petitioner to attend in his place, stating that a representative of
respondent No.4, the owner of the property, would hand over a
resolution nominating the petitioner to execute a sale deed in favour of
respondent No.1. It was further represented that the exercise would
take only about two hours, being confined to presence before the SubRegistrar for affixing the thumb impression, biometrics and signature.
The date of registration was fixed as 21.05.2019, between 4:00 and
5:00 P.M., before the District Registrar, Red Hills, Hyderabad.
5.
The office of the District Sub-Registrar was accordingly visited
by the petitioner, where his thumb impression was affixed and the sale
deed presented to him was signed, whereupon he left the office. It was
the petitioner’s case that, by the time he reached the registration
office, the documentation process had already been completed, and
that only his biometrics were given for the purposes of registration.
6.
Respondent No.4-Company thereafter lodged FIR No.367 of
2019, dated 19.09.2019, at Worli Police Station, for offences under
Sections 405, 420, 465, 468, 471 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code,
1860. The petitioner was summoned by the police to Mumbai, and his
statement was recorded, following which a report was submitted by
the Station House Officer to the Magistrate to the effect that the matter
was a civil dispute. A protest petition was thereafter filed by
respondent No.4, which remained pending before the Court.
7.
The petitioner, having been subjected to harassment and mental
turmoil, instituted the suit seeking a declaration that the registered sale
deed executed by the company in favour of respondent No.1 was
illegal, null and void and not binding on him. He also claimed
damages and compensation of Rs.1,00,00,000/- (Rupees One Crore)
against respondent Nos.1 to 4.
8.
The relief of declaration was valued by the petitioner at
Rs.1,00,000/-, and court fee of Rs.3,426/- was paid thereon. A note
was put up by the office of the learned Chief Judge, City Civil Court,
Hyderabad, before the learned Chief Judge, who, while sitting in his
chamber and without hearing the petitioner, issued a Memo dated
13.08.2026, directing that the suit be valued under Section 37(a)(1) of
the Court Fee Act.
9.
Being aggrieved by the proceedings in O.S.S.R. No.19697 of
2026, taken pursuant to the Memo dated 13.08.2026 issued by the
learned Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, whereby the
petitioner was called upon to value the suit under Section 37(a)(1) of
the Court Fee Act, the present Civil Revision Petition was filed.
10.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner argued that the
Hon'ble Court has failed to take into consideration if it is not satisfied
with the valuation made by the plaintiff, the same has to be called on
bench and the plaintiff counsel has to be heard. In the present case,
without hearing the plaintiff counsel, the order has been passed
violating the principles of natural justice.
11.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submitted that under
Section 11(1) (a) of the Court Fee Act, the Court before ordering the
plaint, to be registered, decide on the allegations contained in the
plaint and the material furnished by the party, the proper fee payable.
It is submitted that the said decision is subject to a review from time to
time as required. Similarly, under Section 11(2) of the Act, the
Defendant can always raise a plea in the written statement that the
court fee is paid insufficient. All the questions on the plea shall be
heard and decided before the hearing of the suit as contemplated under
Order XVIII, in the 1st Schedule CPC. If the Court decides the subject
matter on the suit is not properly valued or that the fee is not
sufficient, the Court shall fix a date before the subject matter of the
suit shall be valued according with the court's decision.
12.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner furthersubmitted that
the Section 11 of Act deals with the registration of the suit based on
the valuation. In case, if the Court intends to decide a proper hearing
has to be made before the Court passes an order. There cannot be a
chamber order passed by the Court, without hearing the petitioner.
Such an order violates the principle of natural justice and fair play and
it is mandatory on the part of the Hon'ble Court to hear the petitioner
and to pass a suitable order, if the court fee has to be revised in the
present case, no opportunity has been given to the petitioner.
13.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner contended that the
Court below has failed to take into consideration that under Section 19
of the ‘Telangana Court Fee Suit Valuation Act, 1956’, the fees to be
computed in accordance with the Chapter 6, 7 & Schedule 1 & 2 of
the Act. The suit is filed under Section 24 of the Court Fee Act and the
valuation which the Plaintiff made was Rs. 1,00,000/-. It is submitted
that the law has been laid down by the Hon'ble Court in pursuance to
the court fee to be paid in a suit for declaration or in suit for
cancellation of the sale deed.
14.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner relied on the decision
of the Madras High Court in the case of Siddha Construction (P)
Ltd. v. M. Shanmugam1, to support his contentions. The relevant
paragraph is reproduced below for ready reference:
“11. For deciding the value of the Court Fee payable by the plaintiff
the averments in the plaint alone are to be considered. In O.S. No.
13/2002, the prayer sought for is to declare the sale deed executed by
the 1st defendant (the 5th respondent herein) in favour of the 3rd
defendant (Revision Petitioner) as null and void and not binding on
them. It is averred at para 10 of the plaint that since they are not party
2006 SCC OnLine Mad 710
to the sale deed dated 31.10.2001, which is to be declared as null and
void, the plaintiff valued the Suit for the purpose of the Court Fee
under Section 25(d) of the Tamil Nadu Court Fees Act. It is also
further averred in para 7 of the plaint that the plaintiffs did not
execute the sale deed and they did not receive any sale consideration.
It is the further case of the revision petitioner that they did not make
any alienation to and in favour of any one till today in respect of the
suit schedule property.”
15.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner also relied on the
decision of this Court in the case of Nade Ali Mirza v. Khalida
Mohammed Salim Dawawala2, in support of his arguments for
valuation of appropriate court fees. The relevant paragraphs are
reproduced below for ready reference:
17. Clause (a) of Sub-section (1) of Section 11 of the Act mandates a
Court before which a plaint is presented, to register it as a suit only
after deciding, on the allegations contained in the plaint and the
materials furnished by the plaintiff, the proper court fee payable
thereon. Clause (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 11 thereof makes
the decision of the Court under Clause (a) regarding the proper fee
payable subject to review, from time to time, as occasion requires.
19. In view of this settled principle of law, the court has to proceed
on the basis of the averments in the plaint. At this point of time, when
even a written statement is not filed by respondents 1-7, it is not
possible to say that by a trick of pleading the petitioners are evading
payment of court fee. So the contention of the respondents that the
petitioners should have also sought for declaration of title
2015 SCC OnLineHyd 505
specifically in the plaint and valued the same on the basis of the
market value of the property comprised in the 107 documents sought
to be declared as null and void, cannot be accepted because whether
such a relief also ought to have been prayed for by the , without
which the reliefs sought in the plaint by them as framed cannot be
granted, is a matter to be decided after trial and after arguments are
heard in the suit after the suit is registered.
... ... ...
31. However, as stated above, since the petitioners are not parties to
the 107 documents which they seek to be declared as null and void
and not binding on them, they are not bound to seek the relief of
cancellation of these 107 documents and they are not bound to pay
court fee as computed under Section 37 of the Act. Therefore, the
above decisions cited by the counsel for respondent nos. 1 to 7
cannot be applied to the present case.
16.
Having heard learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner and on a
consideration of the material on record the question that falls for our
determination is“whether the learned Chief Judge could in chambers
and without hearing the plaintiff direct under Section 11 of the
Telangana Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act 1956 that the suit be
valued under Section 37(a)(1) of the Act and whether on the
averments in the plaint a plaintiff who is not a party to the impugned
sale deed in his own right and who seeks a declaration that it is illegal
null and void and not binding on him is liable to pay court fee under
Section 37(a)(1) in place of the fee paid under Section 24 on the
valuation declared by him.”
17.
The impugned memo was issued at the stage of scrutiny of the
plaint and the matter proceeds on the record and on the submissions
made for the petitioner. The memo is more than an administrative
note. It records a decision on the proper fee payable on the plaint and
directs the plaintiff to value the suit in a particular manner. That
decision falls under Section 11(1)(a) of the Act and is a judicial
determination that affects the right of the plaintiff to have his plaint
registered. It is open to supervision by this Court under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India where it is shown to be vitiated by a breach
of natural justice or by an error of law.
18.
The memo dated 13.08.2026 was issued on a note put up by the
office and the learned Chief Judge decided the question while sitting
in chambers. The petitioner was not told that the valuation was under
doubt and was not heard. A direction of this kind exposes the plaint to
the risk of rejection if the fee demanded is not paid. It has civil
consequences for the plaintiff. If the Court was not satisfied with the
valuation the plaintiff or his counsel should have been called to the
bench and heard before any order was made. A decision taken without
such a hearing offends the principles of natural justice and the memo
is liable to be set aside on that ground alone.
19.
The settled approach to court fee is that the averments in the
plaint alone are to be considered. This is the principle stated by the
Madras High Court in Siddha Construction (P) Ltd. v.
M. Shanmugam where the Court held that for deciding the value of
the court fee payable the averments in the plaint alone are to be looked
at. This Court applied the same approach in Nade Ali Mirza (2
supra) and held that the Court must proceed on the plaint averments
and cannot at that stage assume that the plaintiff is evading fee by a
trick of pleading. It was also held that whether a further relief ought to
have been claimed is a matter to be decided after the suit is registered
and after trial.
20.
The plaint avers that the sale deed was executed by respondent
No.4 company in favour of respondent No.1. It avers that the
petitioner was a long standing friend of one Mr. Sukesh Gupta and
attended the office of the Sub-Registrar at his request and on the
footing that a representative of the company would hand over a
resolution nominating him to execute the sale deed. It states that by
the time he reached the office the documentation had been completed
and that he only gave his biometrics and affixed his signature. He does
not claim title to the property. He does not seek to recover possession
of it or to undo a transaction that he entered into for his own benefit.
He seeks a declaration that the registered deed is illegal and null and
void and not binding on him and he claims damages for the
harassment that followed.
21.
On these averments the petitioner does not stand in the position
of an executant who seeks to avoid his own deed. Section 37 provides
for the fee in a suit for cancellation of a document that creates or
extinguishes rights in property and is measured on the value of the
property covered by the document. In Nade Ali Mirza (2 supra) this
Court held that where the plaintiffs are not parties to the documents
that they seek to have declared null and void and not binding on them
they are not bound to seek cancellation and are not bound to pay the
fee computed under Section 37. The same reasoning applies here. The
decisions that apply the cancellation provision proceed on the footing
that the plaintiff is a party to the instrument and seeks to get rid of his
own act. That footing is not available on the plaint as it stands.
22.
The question whether the petitioner in truth attended in the
limited role that he describes and whether his act of signing amounts
to execution of the deed in any capacity of his own is a question of
fact. It will be decided on evidence at trial. The fee cannot be fixed by
anticipating the answer to it. The criminal proceedings that arose at
Worli Police Station are also collateral to the question. The fee
depends on the reliefs that are claimed and the manner in which they
are pleaded and not on the history of the dispute between the parties.
23.
The decision in favour of the petitioner does not prejudice the
defendants. None of them has yet been heard and the Act itself
protects them. If they consider that the suit is undervalued it is open to
them to raise a plea under Section 11(2) in the written statement. The
plea will be heard and decided before the hearing of the suit on the
merits. If the Court finds the fee to be insufficient it must give the
plaintiff an opportunity to make good the deficiency in terms of the
Act.
We also make it clear that the impugned memo and this
judgment concern the relief of declaration. The claim for damages is a
separate relief and the fee payable on it is to be determined in
accordance with the Act and is not affected by this judgment.
24.
We therefore hold that on the averments in the plaint it has not
been shown that the declaration sought is liable to be valued under
Section 37(a)(1) of the Act. The valuation of the relief of declaration
at Rs.1,00,000/- and the payment of court fee of Rs.3,426/- under
Section 24 cannot be said to be incorrect at this stage. The memo
dated 13.08.2026 and the proceedings taken pursuant to it cannot
stand.
25.
For the foregoing reasons the Civil Revision Petition stands
allowed. The memo dated 13.08.2026 issued by the learned Chief
Judge City Civil Court Hyderabad and the proceedings in O.S.S.R.
No.19697 of 2026 taken pursuant to it insofar as they direct the
petitioner to value the suit under Section 37(a)(1) of the Act, are all set
aside.
26.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand
closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
_____________________
P. SAM KOSHY, ACJ
Date: 02.11.2026
GSD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review