Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION Nos.15135 and 15582 of 2026
(CNR No.HBHC010636902026 (Crl.P.No.15135 of 2026)
(CNR No.HBHC010650772026 (Crl.P.No.15582 of 2026)
DATED: 26th OCTOBER, 2026
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026
Between:
Bhogyam Shekar @ Dish Shekar
1. The State of Telangana
And
... Petitioner-Accused No.4
... Respondent No.1-State
2. Manemma Bogini
... Respondent No.2-Complainant
Crl.P.Nos.15582 of 2026
Between:
Mohammed Pasha @ Yagouse
1. The State of Telangana
2. Manemma Bogini
And
... Petitioner-Accused No.5
... Respondent No.1-State
... Respondent No.2-Complainant
COMMON ORDER
1.
These Criminal Petitions are filed under Sections 480
and 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
(BNSS) praying this Court to enlarge the petitioners on bail
who are arrayed as accused Nos.4 and 5 in connection with
Crime No.54 of 2026 of P.S. Pentlavelly Nagar Kurnool
District. The offences alleged against the petitioner Nos.1 and
2-A4 and A5 are punishable under Sections 103(1), 332(a),
61(2), 238, 351(2), 49 r/w 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita
Act, 2023 (for short ‘BNS’) and Section 4(1) of the Telangana
Advocates Protection Act, 2026 (for short ‘TAP Act’).
2.
Heard Sri Lakshmikanth Reddy Desai, learned counsel
for the petitioner No.1-A4, Sri N.Joy, learned counsel for the
petitioner No.2-A5, Sri D.Arun Kumar, learned Additional
Public
Prosecutor
V.Raghunath
Ms.Sakshi
Rao,
Jha,
for
respondent
learned
learned
Senior
counsel
No.1-State
Counsel
for
and
Sri
representing
respondent
No.2-
complainant.
3.1.
Learned counsel for the A4 submits that A1 to A3 were
arrested on 02.08.2026 and the petitioner No.1-A4 is shown
as absconding. A perusal of the original FIR-complaint dated
01.08.2026 would demonstrate that no specific overt act
whatsoever is attributed against A4. The allegations of
criminal tresspass, assault with sticks, throwing of chilly
powder and the fatal attack with sharp weapons resulting in
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
the death of the deceased are attributed exclusively to A1 to
A3.
In so far as petitioner No.1-A4 is concerned, the
complainant’s own FIR assumes him only as ‘instigator’ on
account of previous disputes involving him and the persons of
his village. Petitioner No.1-A4 was arrested and remanded to
judicial custody on 17.08.2026 and the confession cum
seizure panchanama stated to have been recorded by the
Investigating Officer on the same day after his apprehension.
FIR and the remand report discloses that there has been a
long-standing civil and criminal disputes between the families
of the deceased and A1 over the agricultural land in
connection with multiple criminal cases and counter cases.
Petitioner No.1-A4 has filed regular bail petition before the
District Court vide Crl.MP.No.599 of 2026 which came to be
dismissed on 10.09.2026, entire investigation is completed
and prayed to enlarge the petitioner No.1-A4 on bail.
4.2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner No.2-A5 submits that
basing on the confession of petitioner No.1-A4, petitioner
No.2-A5 was arrested on 24.08.2026. It is recorded that the
petitioner No.2-A5 upon interrogation, admitted that A4 who
is his friend, came to his house on 31.07.2026 at about 20.00
hours i.e., after the assault of the deceased which had
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
occurred at about 19.30 to 19.50 hours. Confession of
co-accused is a weak piece of evidence and does not fall within
the definition of evidence. The penal provisions invoked
against the petitioner No.2-A5 are not attracted. The material
objects are already recovered under confession cum seizure
panchanama on 24.08.2026 in the presence of mediators. The
wife of the petitioner No.2-A5 by name Smt. Thahera Begum,
aged 49 years developed severe abdominal pain three days
back and was examined at Ayra Hospital, Wanaparthy on
08.09.2026.
Investigation
revealed
severe
Anaemia.
The
treating Doctor classified the case as high-risk on account of
co-existing conditions. The petitioner undertakes to abide by
any condition. Petitioner No.2-A5 is in jail since 24.08.2026,
entire investigation is completed. In support of his contention
has relied on the decisions in the cases of (1) Dr.Haniraj L.
Chulani Vs. Bar Council of Maharashtra and Goa1 (2)
Prabhakar Tewari Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another2
and prayed to enlarge the petitioner-A5 on bail.
5.1.
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor has filed separate
written instructions of Sub-Inspector of Police, Pentlavelly
(1996) 3 SCC 342
(2020) 11 SCC 648
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
P.S., Nagar Kurnool District of petitioner Nos.1 and 2-A4 and
A5.
5.2.
In the written instructions of petitioner No.1-A4, it is
stated that A4 is involved in seven other cases. Petitioner
No.1-A4 allegedly instigated and abetted A1 to A3 to murder
the deceased due to long-standing land dispute and instructed
them to eliminate him, thereby participating in the criminal
conspiracy. During 01.07.2026 to 01.08.2026, petitioner No.1A4 has made 11 calls to A1, 5 calls to A2, 94 calls to A3, in
total he has made 110 calls to A1 to A3. The deceased has
sustained
cut
and blunt injuries to vital organs and
succumbed to injuries on the spot in a pool of blood, later A1
has extracted petrol from his motorcycle and A3 retrieved a
set of clothes from her bathroom and changed her attire.
Petitioner No.1-A4 explicitly instigated and abated A1 to A3 to
commit the premeditated murder of the deceased with
conspiracy.
5.3.
In the written instructions filed for petitioner No.2-A5, it
is stated that petitioner No.2-A5 is involved in three other
crimes. Petitioner No.2-A5 has helped petitioner No.1-A4 in
harbouring after the commission of offence. Investigation is
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
under collection of evidence, FSL report is awaited and CDRs
of 17.03.2026 of the accused have to be obtained and prayed
to dismiss the petitions.
6.1.
Respondent
No.2-complainant
has
filed
separate
counters in both the petitions.
6.2.
In the counter filed for the bail petition of petitioner
No.1-A4, respondent No.2 stated that petitioner No.1-A4 had
made an attempt to murder the deceased with an axe.
However, the deceased somehow escaped with severe injuries,
even the complainant who is the wife of the deceased has
categorically stated that they had a threat to their lives from
A1 and his family members including petitioner No.1-A4. Her
husband is a renowned Advocate and the petitioner No.1-A4
bore grudge against her husband for no fault of his and
actively conspired with each other, committed the heinous
crime by brutally murdering her husband.
6.3.
In the counter filed in the bail petition of petitioner
No.2-A5, it is stated that petitioner No.2-A5 along with
co-accused were earlier involved in criminal acts and also part
of conducted surveillance on the deceased’s movements for
the
past
one
year,
particularly
near
her
residence.
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
Complainant has lodged a private complaint and the same is
registered as Crime No.16 of 2026 wherein petitioner No.2-A5
is arrayed as A5 in the same case and he is also involved in
Crime No.47 of 2023 (CC No.367 of 2024). The police has filed
charge sheet as the case is made out against the petitioner
No.2-A5 in the above said crime. Petitioner No.1-A4 has
confessed about the assistance given by the petitioner No.2-A5
and the same is corroborated with his confession, his
confession further led to the police to seize the vehicle
corroborating his direct involvement in the logistic of the
conspiracy. Medical emergency of A5’s wife cannot be a
ground to be considered for bail and prayed to dismiss the
same.
7.
Learned Senior Counsel for respondent No.2 submits
that specific overt acts are attributed against the petitioner
Nos.1 and 2-A4 and A5 about the manner in which the
heinous crime has taken place.
8.
Respondent No.2-complainant has lodged a report
before P.S. Pentlavelly on 01.08.2026. It is stated in the
complaint that her husband B.Mallaiah @ Dr.Mallaiah was
working as an R.M.P. Doctor and running a clinic in one of the
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
shutters belonging to Vishwa Brahmana Society at Pentlavelly
Village beside steamy Cafe. On 31.07.2026, she and her
husband went to the Court and returned home, later in the
evening at about 4.30 P.M. her husband Mallaiah went to the
Clinic. At about 8.00 P.M. in the evening, a villager by name
V.Yellaiah came to her house and informed that Bingi
Krishnaiah-A1,
Bingi
Yellamma-A2,
Bingi
Nagamma-A3,
altogether had criminally trespassed into the clinic and
dragged Mallaiah on the road with an intention to kill him as
part of premeditated plan, bet him with large stick, threw
chilly powder into his eyes and used sharp weapons and
slashed him on his forehead. Respondent No.2-complainant
rushed to the spot and noticed her husband lying on the
ground in a pool of blood with severe injuries on his head and
neck region and died on the spot. Dish Shekar and few others
were the main instigators because in the past he (A4) and
some of their villagers were involved. Basing on the said
complaint, FIR came to be registered under Sections 103(1),
332(a), 49 r/w 3(5) of the BNS against A1 to A4.
9.
A1 to A3 were arrested and remanded to judicial
custody on 02.08.2026. A4 – B.Shekhar @ Dish Shekar is
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
shown as absconding. Remand case diary of A1 to A3 goes to
show that respondent No.1-State has examined 13 witnesses.
10.
Petitioner No.1-A4 was arrested on 17.08.2026 and was
remanded to judicial custody wherein Section 4(1) of the
Telangana Advocates Protection Act, 2026 is added in the
remand
report
of
petitioner
No.1-A4.
On
interrogating
petitioner No.1-A4, he admitted the guilt and confessed his
involvement in the crime stating that he supported A1 – Bingi
Krishnaiah in his land dispute against the deceased Mallaiah,
confession cum seizure panchanama is recorded by LW.10 –
A.Kurmaiah in the presence of witnesses. The remand report
of petitioner No.1-A4 further states that petitioner No.1-A4
has confessed that on 30.07.2026 and 31.07.2026, he
instructed A1 to A3 to attack and kill Mallaiah at his Clinic
following which A1 to A3 executed the murder. Petitioner
No.1-A4 absconded with his family members to his friend’s
house Yaghouse @ Pasha's car and Yaghouse @ Pasha
continually provided him with information regarding police
movements to help him evade arrest, during which time
petitioner No.1-A4 also discarded two SIM cards to prevent
detention until his eventual apprehension. Remand report of
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
petitioner No.1-A4 goes to show that respondent No.1-State
has examined 16 witnesses.
11.
Petitioner No.2-A5 was arrested and remanded to
judicial custody on 24.08.2026, since then he is in judicial
custody. Petitioner No.2-A5 was arrested at his residence in
Pentlavelly Village. LW.18 - B.Srinivas has interrogated
petitioner No.2-A5, upon interrogation, he admitted that he
helped petitioner No.1-A4-B.Shekar @ D.Shekar to escape and
screening him from police after the commission of the murder
of deceased – B.Mallaiah @ Dr.Mallaiah. Confession cum
seizure panchanama is prepared in respect of A5 in the
presence of mediators in which his car is seized. Confession
statement of petitioner No.2-A5 further states that he
continuously monitored local police movements in Pentlavelly
and tipped off A4 over phone warning him to be cautious and
helping him to evade arrest. Later, petitioner No.2-A5 sent his
brother-in-law Mohammed to prepare to retrieve the vehicle
back to Pentlavelly. Remand report of petitioner No.2-A5 goes
to show that the respondent No.1-State has altogether
examined 18 witnesses.
12.
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
Petitioner No.1-A4 has filed anticipatory bail petition
before this Court vide Crl.P.No.12868 of 2026 in respect of
FIR No.54 of 2026, as he was arrested and remanded to
judicial custody on 07.08.2026, his anticipatory bail petition
became infructuous. A4 has filed Crl.MP.No.599 of 2026
before the learned Sessions Judge for grant of regular bail,
which came to be dismissed vide order dated 10.09.2026 with
an observation that the allegations that are levelled against A1
to A5 are very grave and it is not a fit case to enlarge the
petitioner No.1-A4 on bail.
13.
Petitioner No.2-A5 has also filed Crl.MP.No.579 of 2026
and Crl.MP.No.609 of 2026 before the learned Sessions Court
for grant of regular bail, both the applications came to be
dismissed vide orders dated 02.09.2026 and 15.09.2026
holding that the allegations levelled against the petitioner
No.2-A5 are very grave and it is not a fit case to enlarge the
petitioner No.2-A5 on bail.
14.
On careful reading of the complaint, Respondent No.2-
complainant stated that Dish Shekar-A4 and few others are
the main instigators because in the past, he and some of their
villagers were involved. As per the complaint, V.Yellaiah is the
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
eye witness, his name does not surface in the remand case
diary in the list of witnesses.
15.
Counsel for petitioner No.1-A4 has filed a chart showing
the cases filed against A4. In Crime No.10 of 2018 A4 was not
found guilty; in Crime No.31 of 2021 charge sheet is filed and
is numbered as CC.No.230 of 2021, settled before Lok
Adalath; in Crime No.32 of 2022 case is closed on 30.08.2023
as dispute is civil in nature; in Crime No.27 of 2023 charge
sheet is filed and it is numbered as CC.No.262 of 2023 for the
offences under Sections 447, 427, 504, 324 r/w 34 of IPC; in
Crime No.47 of 2023 charge sheet is filed and numbered as
CC.No.367 of 2024 for the offences under Sections 447, 427,
452, 455, 504 r/w Section 34 of IPC; in Crime No.104 of 2023
charge sheet is filed and it is numbered as CC.No.201 of 2024
for the offences under Sections 447, 427, 415, 425, 417, 418,
441, 503, 506 r/w 34 of IPC and Crime No.16 of 2026,
investigation is pending and the offences are 351(2)(3) of BNS
and 175 of BNSS. Three cases are disposed of and the
petitioner No.1-A4 is facing trial in three more cases, and one
case is pending investigation.
16.
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
Counsel for petitioner No.2-A5 has filed the chart
showing the cases pending against A5. Petitioner No.2-A5 is
involved in Crime No.10 of 2018 of Pentlavelly P.S., which is
numbered as Spl.SC.No.155 of 2018 under different Sections
of IPC and SCs/STs Act, which came to be acquitted vide
judgment dated 02.11.2023. In Crime No.47 of 2023 of
Pentlavelly P.S. and Crime No.16 of 2026 of Pentlavelly P.S.,
he was enlarged on station bail.
17.
Learned Senior counsel for respondent No.2 has filed
Crime Petition Acknowledgement, dated 08.06.2026. The
purport of the petition is to do justice for land dispute. For
brevity, the Telugu written complaint states as under:
నేను అనగా మన్నెమ్మ W/O మల్లయ్య, వయస్సు :55
సంలు::, కులంబోయ :,
వృత్తి :వ్యవసాయం అయిన నేను
పెంట్లవెల్లి గ్రామము మరియు మండలము, నాగర్ కర్నూల్
జిల్లా అయిన నాకు పెంట్లవెల్లి గ్రామ శివారులో సర్వే
నెం.657 వి ::4.03 గుంటల భూమి కలదు భూమిని అట్టి .2007లో
కొంత భూమిని బింగి నాగన్న మరియు 2018 -2019 లో వడ్డే
కురుమయ్య, వడ్డే బాలస్వామి దగ్గర కొన్నాను అట్టి .
అట్టి
.చేసుకుంటున్నాను
వ్యవసాయం
నేను
భూమిని
నాకు భూమిపై2016 లో కొల్లాపూర్ కోర్టు వారు భూమి
నాదే అని డిక్రీ ఇచ్చినారు .కానీ ఇప్పుడు బింగి కృష్ణయ్య
S/o
నాగన్న,
నాగమ్మ W/o జనార్ధన్, ఎల్లమ్మ
W/o
కృష్ణయ్య వీరితో పాటు డిష్ శేఖర్ S/o రామకృష్ణ,
డాక్టర్ కురుమయ్య S/o బిచ్చన్న, యాగౌస్ భాష, చిన్న
ఎల్లయ్య S/o బాలయ్య, బీరయ్య S/o పెద్ద నాగయ్య
జటప్రోల్ వీరందరూ కలిసి నన్ను నా పొలములో వ్యవసాయం
చేసుకోకుండా
నన్ను,
నా
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
భర్త
మలయ్యను
కొట్టి
చంపడానికి భూమి గుంజుకోవడానికి ప్రయత్నిస్తున్నారు .
కేసు
లో
స్టేషన్
పోలీస్
పెంట్లవెల్లి
వారిపై
పెట్టినా పోలీస్ వారు పట్టించుకోవడం లేదు.
The above said complaint is given to the Superintendent of
Police, Nagar Kurnool.
18.1. In Dr. Haniraj L.Chulani1, the appellant a permanent
resident of Bombay and a medical practitioner, obtained a
degree of law, while continuing his medical profession and
applied to the Bar Council of Maharashtra and Goa for being
enrolled as an Advocate under Advocates Act, 1961. The
Enrollment Committee rejected his request for being enrolled
as an Advocate simultaneously with his carrying on his
medical practice as a Surgeon. A Writ Petition was filed before
the High Court which came to be dismissed and the same is
challenged before the Supreme Court. The said judgment is
not at all applicable to the facts of the case.
18.2. In Prabhakar Tewari2, Supreme Court observed at Para
No.7 which reads as under:
“7. On considering the submissions of the learned counsel
for the parties, having regard to the circumstances of this
case, in our opinion, there has been no wrong or improper
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
exercise of discretion on the part of the High Court in
granting bail to the accused. The factors outlined in
Mahipal V. Rajesh Kumar, (2020) 2 SCC 118, for testing
the legality of an order granting bail are absent in the
order impugned. The materials available do not justify
arriving at the conclusion that the order impugned suffers
from non-application of mind or the reason for granting
bail is not borne out from a prima facie view of the
evidence on record. The offence alleged no doubt is grave
and serious and there are several criminal cases pending
against the accused. These factors by themselves cannot
be the basis for refusal of prayer for bail. The High Court
has exercised its discretion in granting bail to the accused
Vikram Singh upon considering relevant materials. No ex
facie error in the order has been shown by the appellant
which would establish exercise of such discretion to be
improper. We accordingly sustain the order of the High
Court granting bail. This appeal is dismissed”.
19.
Specific overt acts are attributed against A1 to A3 in
respect of the manner in which the incident has taken place.
Complaint states that petitioner No.1-A4 and others are the
main instigators. Petitioner No.1-A4 is in judicial custody
since 17.08.2026.
20.
The name of petitioner No.2-A5 has surfaced in the
crime only after the confession statement of petitioner No.1-A4
that he has instigated and facilitated the murder and that
petitioner No.2-A5 has provided Suzuki Fronx car to petitioner
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
No.1-A4 to flee to Alampur and Yemmiganu and that he is
continuously monitored local police movements in Pentlavelly
and passed such information to petitioner No.1-A4 over the
phone and warned him to be cautious and helped him in
evading the arrest.
21.
It is mentioned in the written instructions of petitioner
No.1-A4 that deceased B.Mallaiah was a member of Bar
Association, Kollapur Court vide Enrollment No.TS/901/2014
dated 07.08.2014. As such, they added Section 3 r/w Section
4 of the Telangana Advocates Protection Act, 2026 to the
existing Sections of BNS. In the written instructions of
petitioner No.1-A4, it is stated that PME report is received.
The same is also stated in the written instructions of
petitioner No.2-A5. FSL report is awaited and CDR of
17.03.2026 of accused has to be obtained.
22.
Respondent No.1-State has altogether examined 18
witnesses in support of the case. Except receiving FSL report
and CDRs of the accused, investigation appears to be at the
fag end. Record goes to show that major portion of the
investigation is completed. Furthermore, petitioner No.1-A4 is
in judicial custody since 17.08.2026 and petitioner No.2-A5 is
in
judicial
custody
since
24.08.2026,
detaining
the
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
petitioners-A4 and A5 further in judicial custody will not serve
the purpose.
23.
The
apprehension
of
learned
Senior
counsel
for
respondent No.2-complainant is that if the petitioner Nos.1
and 2-A4 and A5 are enlarged on bail, there is life threat to
the complainant and her family members, the same can be
taken care of by imposing stringent conditions on the
petitioner Nos.1 and 2-A4 and A5.
24.
Accordingly, petitioner Nos.1 and 2-A4 and A5 are
granted bail, subject to the following strict conditions :
i.
The petitioner Nos.1 and 2-A4 and A5
shall execute a personal bond for a sum
of Rs.20,000/- (Rupees Twenty Thousand
only), with two sureties for a like sum
each to the satisfaction of the concerned
Court.
ii.
The petitioner Nos.1 and 2-A4 and A5
shall appear before the concerned SHO in
between 10:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., on
every Sunday, Tuesday and Thursday for
a period of eight (8) weeks or till filing of
charge sheet whichever is earlier, for the
purpose of investigation and thereafter,
as and when required.
iii.
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
The petitioner Nos.1 and 2-A4 and A5
shall abide by the conditions stipulated in
Section
437(3)
of
Cr.P.C.
(presently,
Section 480(3) of the BNSS).
iv.
The petitioner Nos.1 and 2-A4 and A5
shall not directly or indirectly influence,
threaten, or induce any of the prosecution
witnesses and they shall not involve in
similar offences.
v.
In the event of violation of any of the
above conditions, the prosecution is at
liberty
to
file
an
application
for
cancellation of bail.
Miscellaneous applications, if any pending, shall stand
closed.
26th October, 2026
PLV
______________________________
B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO, J
Crl.P.Nos.15135 of 2026 &
15582 of 2026
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION Nos.15135 and 15582 of 2026
(CNR No.HBHC010636902026 (Crl.P.No.15135 of 2026)
(CNR No.HBHC010650772026 (Crl.P.No.15582 of 2026)
DATE: 26.10.2026
PLV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review