Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010597692025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
[3327]
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE 21st DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SREENIVASA REDDY
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3548/2025
Between:
1. MOHAMMED JAMAL, S/O LATE ABDUL RAZAK, AGED ABOUT
64 YEARS, R/O. D.NO. 38-40-105, MAIN ROAD MARRIPALIM,
VISAKHAPATNAM, ANDHRA PRADESH.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. SHAIK ZAHUR AHMED, S/O. (LATE) ANSAR, AGED ABOUT 63
YEARS. DO. N. 38-2-5, MUSLIM STREET, MARRIPALIM,
VISAKHAPATNAM.
2. THE COMMISSIONER GREATER VISAKHAPATNAM MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION, VISAKHAPATNAM.
3. THE ZONAL COMMISSIONER ZONE 5 PREVIOUSLY ZONE 4,
GANAYAPURAM, VISAKHAPATNAM.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may
be pleased to allow the CRP and set aside the order dated 15-07-2025
passed in I.A. No. 271 of 2023 in O.S. No. 108 of 2022 on the file of the
Civil Judge (Junior Division), Visakhapatnam and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
be pleased to stay of all further proceedings in O.S. No. 108 of 2022 on
the file of the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Visakhapatnam and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. B R S KALYAN REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. P RAJKUMAR
The Court made the following:
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
ORDER
Civil Revision Petition No.3548 of 2025 came to be
filed challenging the Order dated 15.07.2025 passed in I.A.No.271
of 2023 in O.S.No.108 of 2022 by the learned II Additional Civil
Judge (Junior Division), Visakhapatnam (for brevity „the trial
Court‟), whereunder and whereby, the application filed by the
petitioner/ property party under Order I Rule 10 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (for brevity „CPC‟) to permit him to come on
record as defendant No.3 to the suit proceedings, was dismissed.
2.
Petitioner herein is proposed Defendant No.3, 1st
respondent herein is the plaintiff, and respondent Nos.2 and 3 are
defendant Nos.1 and 2, in O.S.No.108 of 2022, pending on the file
of the trial Court. Parties hereinafter are referred to, as they were
arrayed in the suit proceedings pending before the trial Court.
3.
The respondent No.1/plaintiff filed O.S.No.108 of 2022
against D1 and D2 on the file of the trial Court seeking decree
directing the defendants to vacate and hand over the vacant
physical possession of the schedule property; to direct the
defendants to pay Rs.7,20,000/- towards arrears of rent from
January, 2020 to December, 2021, and for Permanent Injunction.
The schedule property is entire second floor with carpet area 2000
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
square feet out of total extent of 256 square yards or 209.536
square meters located in an RCC slab house ground + 2 floors
bearing Door No.30-5-26, GVMC Property Assessment No.69666
situated at Muslim Veedhi, Marripalem, Visakhapatnam District,
covered by survey No.83/1 part of Gopalapatnam Village.
4.
It is the case of R1/plaintiff that his father viz. late
Shaik Ansar purchased the schedule property on 30.10.1970 under
a Registered Sale Deed vide Document No.5078/1970, and
subsequent to demise of his father on 11.10.1971, R1/plaintiff
succeeded to the schedule property, and constructed an RCC
building; that the Commissioner, GVMC assessed the house tax in
the name of R1/plaintiff, and he has been in possession and
enjoyment of the schedule property with absolute rights without any
interruption. The officials of D2 said to have taken the schedule
property on lease for running the office of Marripalem Ward
Sachivalayam on monthly rental basis at Rs.15/- for square feet for
a period of one year; that as per the terms and conditions of lease
agreement dated 09.01.2020, the lease hold period was effective
from 01.01.2020 for a period of one year and the defendants were
said to have agreed to pay rent at Rs.30,000/- per month.
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
It is the further case of R1/plaintiff that since January,
2020, the defendants postponed to pay the rents as per the
agreement, on the pretext that they received complaint from the
proposed party and one Madeena of Marripalem with regard to
earmarking the boundaries of Peerla Panja; that a joint survey was
conducted, wherein it was found by the Surveyor that the schedule
property is situated towards Western side of Peerla Panja, and on
11.09.2021 a letter was addressed to the Chief Executive Officer of
Andhra Pradesh Waqf, Vijayawada stating that the schedule
property belongs to R1/plaintiff, thereby, the allegations made by
the proposed party and one Madeena proved false; that the
defendants intentionally created doubt about the title of R1/plaintiff
in order to avoid payments of rent for their wrongful gain, and
though lease period was mentioned for one year as per the lease
agreement, period of two years completed i.e. from 01.01.2020 to
31.12.2021, till date the defendants failed to pay the rent at
Rs.7,20,000/- for the said two years period.
The defendant No.2 filed written statement and is
contesting the suit proceedings.
5.
While the suit is pending for adjudication, the proposed
party filed the subject application under Order I Rule 10 of CPC
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
contending that the subject suit was filed against the Government,
and though the schedule property was used as Waqf Property and
used from time immemorial, the property was used for Asir Khana
(Function Hall) bearing Door No.38-5-26, as the schedule property
was related to Masjid-E-Alfatha attached Waqf property, which
means, profits accrued from the schedule property will be used for
Masjid and Madarasa; that the schedule property was issued by his
father viz. Md. Abdul Razak to the father of R1/plaintiff in the
capacity of Waqf Gazette notified Muttavalli in Gazette No.47,
dated 30.11.1961; that though the schedule property was not
mentioned in Waqf Survey Register, the property was Waqf by user
since then and it was developed by Masjid Honorary Members
only, but not either R1/plaintiff or his father, and in order to submit
these facts, the proposed party is to be added as D3 to the suit
proceedings.
6.
Respondent No.1/plaintiff filed counter, denying the
contents of the petition-affidavit, contending inter alia that the
proposed party and his entire family members are most culprit
persons in the locality of Marripalem, Visakhapatnam, and several
cases are pending against them; that the subject application was
filed to harass R1/plaintiff and to have wrongful gain. It is further
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
stated that the proposed party has no right to dispute with regard to
title of R1/plaintiff; that on the allegations of proposed party, the
Inspector Auditor, Waqf Board conducted joint survey and
submitted report to the Chief Executive Officer, Andhra Pradesh
State Waqf Board, Vijayawada stating that R1/plaintiff is the land
owner, he constructed slab in the schedule property, and the
property is exclusively belongs to R1/plaintiff, but not to the
proposed party. Hence, it is prayed to dismiss the application.
7.
The trial Court, after conducting inquiry, considering
the contentions and rival contentions of both parties, and
documents marked Exs.R1 to R11 on behalf of R1/plaintiff, vide
Order dated 15.07.2025, dismissed the subject application
observing as under:
“It is well settled law that in a suit for eviction, landlord
and tenant relationship is the paramount consideration between
the parties and it is for the plaintiff in a suit to identify the parties
against whom they have any grievance and to implead them as
defendants. Moreover, the petitioner is not claiming right, title or
at least possession over the suit schedule property. If at all the
petitioner is aggrieved by the acts of the respondent/ plaintiff,
he is at liberty to take steps against him by filing separate suit.
In such circumstances, the Court is of the view that the
presence of the petitioner is not essential for adjudication of the
matter since this is a suit filed for eviction and permanent
injunction, but not for declaration of right or title.”
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
Aggrieved of the impugned Order, the Civil Revision
Petition came to be filed by the proposed party/proposed D3.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner herein/proposed
party would contend that the trial Court failed to properly appreciate
the nature of the claim made by him regarding the schedule
property. He further contends that the petitioner herein/proposed
party claims that the schedule property is a Waqf property by user
and that the rights and interests associated with the Masjid would
be affected if the suit is decided without his impleadment. Learned
counsel would further contend that the subject application was to
implead him to the suit proceedings only to bring the relevant facts
with regard to nature of the schedule property, and the presence of
petitioner herein/proposed party would assist the Court for effective
adjudication of the dispute and avoiding of conflicting findings in
suit proceedings. Learned counsel concludes that trial Court
dismissed the subject application without properly appreciating the
petitioner's claim concerning the nature of the schedule property.
9.
Per contra, learned counsel for R1 herein/plaintiff
would contend that the suit is filed for Eviction, recovery of arrears
of rent and for Permanent Injunction against the defendants, who
are alleged to have occupied the schedule property under a Lease
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
Arrangement dated 01.01.2020. Learned counsel further contends
that the petitioner herein/proposed party is neither a party to the
Lease Agreement nor a person against whom the reliefs sought in
the suit are claimed. The petitioner herein failed to establish his
right of possession over the schedule property or any semblance of
right which makes his presence necessary for deciding the lis
involved in the suit. Learned counsel would further contend that the
petitioner
herein/proposed
party
cannot
insist
upon
being
impleaded merely by raising a dispute regarding the title or the
alleged nature of the schedule property. According to learned
counsel, if the petitioner herein/proposed party has grievance with
regard to title or ownership of R1/plaintiff, he can always avail the
remedies available to him in accordance with law, but not by
impleading him to the suit proceedings. Considering these aspects,
the trial Court rightly dismissed the subject application. Hence, it is
prayed to dismiss the Revision Petition.
10.
Now the point that arise for consideration is Whether
the Order dated 15.07.2025 passed in I.A.No.271 of 2023 in
O.S.No.108 of 2022 by the learned II Additional Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Visakhapatnam suffers from any illegality, material
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
irregularity or jurisdictional error warranting interference by this
Court?
11.
A perusal of the material on record goes to show that
R1 herein/plaintiff filed O.S.No.108 of 2022 on the file of the trial
Court against R2 and R3 herein/defendants, seeking eviction,
delivery of vacant possession of the schedule property, recovery of
arrears of rent of Rs.7,20,000/- for the period from January, 2020 to
December, 2021, and Permanent Injunction. It is also evident that
R2 and R3 herein/defendants are contesting the suit proceedings
and they filed written statement, and while the suit is pending for
adjudication, the subject application was filed by the petitioner
herein/proposed party.
12.
The prime question is whether the petitioner is a
necessary or proper party to the suit filed by R1/plaintiff against the
defendants who are respondent Nos.2 and 3 herein. Order I Rule
10 (2) of CPC empowers the Court to strike out the name of an
improperly joined party or to add a person whose presence before
the Court is necessary to enable it to effectively and completely
adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit. A
necessary party is a person in whose absence no effective decree
can be passed. A proper party is a person whose presence may be
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
required for the complete and effective adjudication of the
questions involved in the suit, even though an effective decree may
be passed in his absence. Therefore, a person cannot claim
impleadment as a matter of right merely because, he is interested
in the subject matter of the litigation. Indeed, it is the Court to
examine as to whether his presence is necessary or proper for
deciding the actual dispute involved in the suit.
13.
In the case on hand, the suit is filed for eviction of
existing defendants from the schedule property, recovery of arrears
of rent and Permanent Injunction. It is the case of R1 herein/plaintiff
that by virtue of Lease Agreement dated 01.01.2020, the
defendants occupied the schedule property and later, failed to pay
the agreed rentals. The petitioner herein/proposed party, on the
other hand, seeks his impleadment to the suit proceedings on the
ground that the schedule property is attached to Masjid-E-Alfatha
and it is Waqf property by user. The claim made by the petitioner
herein/proposed party regarding the nature of the property is
distinct from the dispute raised in the suit proceedings. The suit is
with regard to the reliefs sought by the plaintiff against the
defendants in relation to their alleged occupation of the schedule
property and non-payment of rent. The question to be considered
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
at this stage is not whether the petitioner‟s claim regarding the
schedule property is true or false, indeed, the question is whether
the presence of petitioner herein/proposed party is necessary for
adjudicating the reliefs claimed by R1 herein/plaintiff against the
defendants.
14.
The petitioner failed to establish that for effective
adjudication of the lis involved in the subject suit, his presence is
necessary or proper. Merely asserting that the property is Waqf
property by user does not, by itself, establish that the petitioner is a
necessary party to the present suit. If the petitioner herein/
proposed party claims an independent legal right or interest in the
schedule property, he can as well pursue such remedy available to
him before the competent Court in accordance with law. Therefore,
for the purpose of adjudication of the reliefs sought in the subject
suit, presence of the petitioner/proposed party is not necessary.
15.
A perusal of the material on record goes to show that
the trial Court rightly concluded that the petitioner‟s presence was
not essential for adjudicating the suit. It was also observed that the
petitioner could take appropriate steps independently if he was
aggrieved by the acts of the first respondent. Therefore, the trial
Court rightly exercised its discretionary power and there is no
SRK, J
CRP No.3548 of 2025
jurisdictional error or material irregularity warranting interference
with the impugned Order. The petitioner herein/proposed party is at
liberty to pursue any independent remedy available to him in
accordance with law. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court
is of the considered view that the impugned Order does not warrant
interference of this Court in the present Civil Revision Petition.
16.
Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is dismissed,
confirming the Order dated 15.07.2025 passed in I.A.No.271 of
2023 in O.S.No.108 of 2022 by the learned II Additional Civil Judge
(Junior Division), Visakhapatnam.
There shall be no order as to costs of the Revision
Petition.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if
any, shall also stand closed.
JUSTICE K. SREENIVASA REDDY
st
21 September, 2026.
DNB
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review