Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3303 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAO
MONDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PET|TION NO: 11113 OF 2026
Between:
1. Mohammed Abdullah, S/o Mohammed Sardar, Aged about 27 yearc'
Occupation. Pvt. Service, H.No. 20, O.0 Campus - 5, Tarnaka, Habsiguda,
Hyderabad - 500007, Telangana.
2. Mohammed Sailani, S/o Mohammed Sardar, Aged about 29 years'
Occupation. Pvt. Service, H.No. 20, O.0 Campus - 5, Tarnaka, Habsiguda,
Hyderabad - 500007, Telangana.
...Petitioner/Accused No.1 & 2
AND
1. State of Telangana, High Court of Telangana at Hyderabad, Telangana.
2. Sri. Golla Sathyanarayana, Sio Kistaiah. Aged about 35 years, Occupation.
Shephard, R/o Nalthur Village, Jinnaram Mandal, Sangareddy District'
Telangana.
...Respondents
Petition under section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in
the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to
call for records relating to and in connection with Crl. M P. No. 6'1 of 2025 in S.C'
No. 147 ol 2018 pending on the file of the ll Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Sangareddy District at Sangareddy, and quash the same.
l.A. NO: 'l OF 2026
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in
the Memorandum of Grounds of criminal Petition, the High court may be pleased to
stay all further proceedings of s.c No. 147 ol 2018 of Police Jinnaram pending on
the file of the ll Additional District and sessions Judge, sangareddy District, at
Sangareddy, pending disposal of the Criminal petition
Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum of Grounds
- -This
of criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of sri H,lorro. lslamuddin Ansari,
Advocate for the Petitioners and sri Jithender Rao Veeramalla, Additional public
Prosecutor on behalf of Respondent No.1 and none appeared for the Respondent
No 2.
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN TH I' HI GHC OU R'l .FOR
1'tI rl s-I'A1'E OF..I .ELAN
-r
GAN A
A Hy DEII N BAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI
JTJSTICE J.SREENIVAS
CRIM INA LPE TITI ONN
RAO
O.I I I l3 of 2026
f)ate 20.07.2026
Betwe en:
Mohammed Abdullah and
another
Petitioners
ANI)
fhe State of 1'eiangana
and anothcr
I(espondents
::o RDE R::
f'his Crinrinal petition has
docket order d'ated 02.02.2026
District and Sessions Judge,
passed by the rearned
PWs.2, 5, 6 and 7 lor
2.
tiled b1 the petitioners fbr
I leard Mohd. Islarnuddin
stage of admission.
where
seeking recall o1_
Ansari. learned counsel
lbr the
Additional public
No.l.
\\'irh ritcir conscnr. rhc
of
in a tion was clismissed.
Jithendar Rao, learnecl
Prosecutor for respondent
i.
short, .the triai Coun,)
f.urther cross_exam
petitioners, and Mr V
II Additionar
Sanga Reddy in cri.M.p.No.6l
l0l5 in S.C..\o. 147 ol. l0l8 (lbr
under the application
been filed aggneved
by the
crirrrinal pctiLion is disposed
ot.a1 the
1.
Noticc in rcspecr of'rcspondent No.l is dispensed ,,,,,ith solclr.
on thc grou nd thaL the petitioncr has tjled Lhe pr'esenr crinrinal
petition ag.grievccl br the crvptic docket orcler dated 02.02.1026
passcd br thc lcurn:d trial ('ou11 and on beha I of respondent \o.2
helbrc the trial iloLrrt lcarnecl Additional Pub,lic Prosecr.rtor
appearc'd
5.
[.earncd ctrunscl lbr the petirioners sr-Lbmits the petitioners
uerc arrarccl oS aeCrS.'d \o:. Iancl I in S.C.\o. 1.17 o1'10 t8 1br the
ot-f.nce punishahle Lrncier Scctions 301 and 379 of the Indian Penal
Coclc. 186() (firr sholL 'lP(").
In rhe said case. the petitioners
harc tlled r petitior r idc ('rl.\l.l).\o.61 ol'l(|l,i on lE.()-l.l0l5 to
recall the n iLnesscs P\\'s.]. 5. 6 and 7 for ftrrlher
cross-eramination. I he lealned trial Court. rr ithout considerins
the ar enne'rrts nradc
ln
the pctition. disnrissed thc samc on
0l.0l 1016 encl passcd a clrptic order riithout assigning anr
r!'a:(.)ns anil thc sur.t'tr is sross r iolation ol'thc principles ol natural
ir-rs1iccs. I I.' tr.rrth.'r' sul.,urits that r.'callirlc of' I)\\'s.1. 5. 6 anci 7 are
\er\ rnuch neccss:ir1 tbl adjudication of the proceedings IN
S C \o. l17
oll0l 8
6'
Learned Additionar pubric prosecutor l-airry submirs
iearned trial Court ought ro have given reasons
that the
while dismissing
the C'ri.M.P.No.6t of 2025 in S.C.No. 147 ol20lg.
7.
Ilar ing considered the subrrissions made by the respective
parties and afier upon of the ntarcrial available
on recorcl, it is not
in disputc that the petitioncrs wcrc arraved accusccr in
o1' 2018 and are lacing trial lbr the of-1ence
punishable under
Sections 302 and 379 ol IpC. Thc record lufther
petitioners have filed a peririon vide
reveals that the
Crl.M.p.No.6l ol 2025
inroking rhe pro.,isions of SccIion 3ll of Cr.p.C.
sceking recall of t)\\,s.2, 5. 6 and 7 tbr further
-fhe
S.c.No. I47
on 2g.04.2025
cross_examination.
trial Courr. b-r u ar ol' a clockcr orcic_r dared 02.02.2026.
disnrissed the said apprication. 'fhe docker
order dared 02.02.2026
rcads as under:''Both Counsels presenr.
8.
Crl.\Lp.\o.61 of 2015 is t)ismissed...
The above docket ordcr clearly reveals that the
Sessions Judge has not considered the averments
respectire panies in rhc. application whilc
Crl.M.P.No.6l of 2025. 'l herclbrc, rhis Courl is
view that the learned Sessions Judgc ought to
learned
made by the
dismissing thc
ol the considercd
have considered the
I
conrcntions raised bl the parties and ought to hare giren
reasons
rr h ilc disrnissinu thc application
9.
It is r crr nltrch rcle r allL to tnention hcre that the [1on'ble
Supreme Cotrrt in Ra,j Kishore Jha v. Statc of Bihar/.
hcld as
undcr
l() lletLrrc \\c pa t \\ltll tlle ca:c. sc lccl i( ll'ccssal! l()
Cotlrts arc
indicarc that trot -teasL'lled cotlclrt:iot'ls b} appellate
ol'the lor'rer Cclurt arc
n(rt al)fr(rpriate. tnore so- r*hen
"iervs
thc lleetl ttr agaill rcpcat
rrf
cLrttattrl-ctrce
clt'e
lt
liLrnt
tlilleretl
lclrso,\ 1la\ st t 1.rt thcre. It i: tlot st' itl iasc ili' rercrsal'
Rcasor ir tllc llelllthcat (rl e\cr) collclusiol' \\'ithout
the
\arne. il bccorlle) lltcles:
10. In State of Pub.iab
llhag Singhr^ the tlon'ble SLrprenrc
C oL rrt hcld as tlndct
6 E\c!l i11 lc\l)e!t (rl adlllinistlati\e o11ls1-s [-c'rcl [)ennirlg'
\l.R irr llr,','rr t. lrtt.tlgttrttttleLi lttgg. Lntrt't (l9'l) L\l'l-
l ll.
lt
r1() lr I
(lll l-5: (l9rl) I \\'l-lt lll
(CA)
,rbserr cd "Ilrc qirlrluot rcast)ns is one ol thc llndantcnt:!s
of
ltl \lcr.alr'.lcr \laihincrr t t)trdlc) ) ['td'
r.. ( rabrree 1.,'-l l( Il ll0 (\lR(')l it uas ohserred "FrtilLtte
gor-ro .rJnrini.tti,tii'tr.
t() g \c feas(ills anl()tlllts l(r rlerliel ol.]Lrstice' l(easons
ar': lile
lrfk. bct\r'. tl Lllc ttlilr,J ,rt tlle (lecisi(rtl takcr tc lhe
a\)r'lt-\r\cr.\ ll ( ua\tiL\11 .trt,l tllc tlccisi()ll !)l i(rL)clLl\lr)rl alll\ed
lt llca.ott. \lll)\l ltltc \tltric.ll\ it) br 'rblcctir ity I hc
cll]ll rl\i\ of .erLrrilllr-r.] r.ll\(rtt: \ rhat it rhc decision rereals
rlre 'irscrtrtrbir lrrcc ol tltc sphrrtr". it can. br rt., silerrcerend.r rt \ irlLraliJ rl]11rrsrrlrlc li)l lhc courts t0 pclfitrrn theit
l
)
appellalc tirnctrort ol erelcise titc porrcr ol' judicial rer ien in
adludging thc raliditr ol tlrc clccision. Rrglrt to reason is an
indispensable paft ol a sound .iudicial s\slenr. reasons'at least
sulficieirt to indicate an application of mind to the mafter
bclbrc Court. Another rationale is that the allected party can
knorr *h1 thc decision has gonc against lrirn. Onc ol the
salLrtar) requirelnerlts ot rlatural.justicc is spelling out rcasons
fbr the order Tlre rnade, in otlrer words. a speaking-out.
"inscrutable face of the sphinr" is ordinarilf incongruous with
a.ludiciaI ol quasi iudiciai perlirrnrance.
I l.
Sirnilarll . in Stalc of Rajasthan r. Rajendra Prasad .lainr,
the Hon'ble Apcx Court held thaL rcason is the heartbcat of e\or\
conclusion, and withollt the same it becomes lileless.
12, It is relevant to r.nerrtion that thc learned trial Courl ought to
have give reasons while deciding the interlocutory application. In
thc case on hand, thc learne-d trial (lourt. without assigning an\
rcasons and \\ithour application ot- rnind. passed a crvptic orc.ler.
and the same is contrar) to the settled principles of lar.r laid don,n
by' the FIon'ble Apex Court lsupru).
li.
lror the lbregoing reasons, the irnpugned order dated
02.02.2026 passed by the leamed rrial Coun is liable to be set aside
and accordingly, set aside and the learned trial Court is directed to
considcr thc applicarion tilcd by' thc pctitioncrs virle Crl.M.p.No.6l
of 2025 afresh and pass appropriatc orders in accordancc w,ith lar.l,
' (100E) l5 scc ?
()
as c\peditioLrslr as possible. prct'erabl) \\ ithin a period ol' tbur
\\ccl(s liolr the datc ()l lccclpt ol'cop\ of this older'
13. 'rVith the abor c saicl direction. the criminal petition is
disposecl of,
I'en<ling misccllaneous applications' it' any' shall stand
c loscd.
SD/. U SUDHA,
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copv to the Hon'ble Sri Justice J Sreenivas Rao
iFor His LordshiP's kind Perusal)
To,
1. The ll Addrtional District and sessions Judge, sangareddy District at
SangareddY
'1
1 LR Copies
g. fntUnO"|. Secretary, Union of lndia. Ministry of Law' Justice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi
2.
4.TheSecretary,AdvocatesAssociationLibrary,HighCoUrtfortheStateof
Telangana, High Court Buildings at Hyderabad
5. one ic to Sri-laono. lslamuddin Ansari, Advocate [oPUC]
6. i;; ccs to pUBL|C pRosEcuToR High court for the state of Telangana'
at Hyderabad [OUT]
7. Two CD CoPies
ADK
N2
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2010712026
ORDER
(
CRLP.No.11113 of 2026
1 lr,
C
2 5 JUt 2026
iL\
DISPOSING OF THE CRLP
/
t Q),^.r
rL-1t t
t
).
)t
€
(
;-)
o
'.:.
r_ S r41
I
'..Tc$ eA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review