Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
134421
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE EIGHTEENTH DAYOF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
clvlL REVISION PETITION NO:4039 OF 2024
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of lndia, aggrieved by the Order
Dated: 02.09.2024 passed in l.A.No. 606 of 2023 in OS No. S1O of 2O14, on the fite
of the Court of the Xl Additional District and Sessions Judge, at LB Nagar,
Rangareddy District.
Between:
Mohammed Abdul Nayeem, S/o. Mohammed Abdul Raheem, aged about 54
years, Occ: Business, R/o. H.No. 22$-1O1O,lrani Galli, Hyderabad
...PETITIONER/RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF
AND
1. Sri Rajendra Prasad Sanghi, S/o. Late Bajrang Prasad Sanghi, A,/a. 54 years,
Occ: Business, R/o. H.No. 8-2-58311, Road No.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
2. Smt. Shakuntala Bai, Wo. Satyanarayana, Na. 52 years, Occ: House Hold,
R/o. H.No. 3-5-141 11 lN1, Ramkoti, Hyderabad.
Respondent No. 2 is not necessary party to this petition
...RESPONDENT'DEFENDANT
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 15'l CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all
further proceedings in OS No. 51O of 2014, pending on the file of Hon'ble Xl
Additional District and Sessions Judge, at LB Nagar, Rangareddy District.
Counsel for the Petitioner: Sri. Ali Farooq
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: Sri. Shyam S Agrawal
The Court made the following: ORDER
INTHEIIIGIICOURTF0RTHESTATEoFTELANGAIIAAT
HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE
RENUKA YARA
l8'n DAY oF MARcH,2o26
I
Between:
Mohammed Abdul NaYeem'
...Petitioner
AND
Sri Rajendra Prasad Sanghi and another'
...ResPonden ts
ORDER:
HeardSriAliFarooq,learnedcounselforthepetitionerandSri
Shyam S.Agarwal, learned counsel for
respondent No'l' Perused the entire
record.
by
2. This civil Revision petition is preferred
by the order passed by the
petitioner/respondent/plaintiff aggrieved
XI Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy
the
leamed
District at L.B.Nagar (for short
.theTrialCourt,),int.A.No.606of2023ino.S.No.510of2014,dated
O2.Og-2024, wherein, a
petition filed by respondent No'1
Order XIII Rule 3 read
herein/petitioner/defendant No.2 under
the insufficiently
151 of CPC, to de-exhibit/demark
stamped agreement of
sale dated 22.112006/Ex.Al and receipt-cum-letter
v
possession dated 19.10.2011/Ex.A3 and
with Section
of delivery of
expunging them from record' has
been allowed-
\
)
)
I
\
RY,J
cRP 4039 2024
und of facts:
3.
The brieffacts ofthe case are that respondent No.r herein
fired suit
in o's'No.1568 of 2013 against the petitioner herein seeking perpetuar
injunction with respect to property consisting of plot No.14,
forming part of
Sy.Nos.357 and 358 situated ar Attapur Village, Rajendranagar
Ranga Reddy District. The extent of plot is g00 Sq.yds.
Mandal,
While so, the
petitioner herein filed suit in o.S.No.5r0 of 2014
seeking specific
performanr:c of agreement of sale dated 22.1 1.2006
with respect to
property consisting of plot No.l, admeasuring about
241 Sq.yds., and plot
Nos.2, 3 and 4 total admeasuring about 339 Sq.yds., both
old plot No.14 in Sy.Nos.357 and 35g situated at Arrapu!"
forming part of
Village, Rajendra
Nagar GHV.{C, Ranga Reddy District, and also sought perpetual
to restrain the respondents herein from interfering with the
the property. Both the suits are being tried together,
injunction
possession of
with common evidence
being led. \lhile leading common evidence, the petitioner
had exhibited
Exs'A-l to A"23'which incrudes rhe agreement of sale dated22.,.2006
as
Ex'Al and the receipt-cum-letter of delivery of possession dated
19.10.2011 as Ex.A3. These documenrs were not properly
stamped as per
Article 6 (b) o:"Schedule l-A of the Indian Stamp Act, lg99 (.Stamp
Act,).
As per Stamp Act, the agreement of sale of immovable property
attract
RY,J
cw 4tJ39 2tJ'.24
payment of stamp duty of SYo of the market value of the property. While
so, the agreement of salelEx.Al was executed only on a Rs.100/- stamp
paper and the same is insufficient. Further, Ex.A3lreceipt-cum-letter of
delivery of possession attracts stamp duty in terms of Article 47-A of
Schedule l-A of the Stamp Act. Since there was deficit stamp duty paid on
both the documents, said documents ought not to have been exhibited and
ought not to be considered even for collateral purpose. Insufficiently
stamped documents are inadrnissible in evidence. Since said documents
ought not to have been exhibited, respondent No.l herein/defendant No.2
filed petition under Order XIII Rule 3 of CPC to de-exhibit said documents.
4.
The petitioner herein tiled counter before the trial Court denying the
averments of the petition referring to each paragraph. However, the specific
contention about insufficiency of stamp duty being the reason for deexhibiting has not been addressed.
5.
The learned trial Court considered the case of respondent No.1 for
de-exhibiting referring to Sections 35,36 and 61 of the Stamp Act and the
judgment of this Court in the case of Venu Gopal Baldawa v. Reddy
Saritha Reddy I rendered on 27.04.2023, wherein it is held that an
unstamped or deficitly stamped document cannot be admitted into evidence
\
MANU/TLI0704/2023
I
l
RY,J
cRP 4039 2024
for any plrrpose including collateral pulpose. Further, it is observed that the
petitioner herein could not come up with any evidence or reason to oppose
the petition. It is held that even in case an insufficiently stamped document
gets marked it can be de-exhibited. An unregistered document affecting
immovabl: property is governed by the Registration Act, 1908 and the
Transfer oiiProperty Act, 1882. An un-registered document can be received
in evidenco as a contract in a suit for specific performance. This exception
is not applicable with respect to insufficiently starnped paper in terms of
Section 35 ,of the Stamp Act and the bar is absolute. It is held that the view
of Section 316 of the Stamp Act does not come in the way of de-exhibiting.
Therefore, allowed the petition leading to filing of the present revision.
Grounds of revision:
6.
In grounds of revision, it is pleaded that Exs.A- I and A-3 were
marked on 17.09.2019 in the presence of the counsel for respondent No.l
and several adjoumments had been taken for the purpose of crossexamination. Thereafter, without proceeding for further cross-examination,
respondent No.l came up with I.A.No.130 of 2020 for impounding Exs.A-
1 and A-3 and saidpetition was dismissed on 21.03.2023 with a finding
that respondent No.l remained silent at the time of rnarking of the
insufficientl y stamped documents and therefore, said documents cannot be
RY,J
cRP_4039 2024
t:f;:
questione d at alater stage. It is held by the trial
Court that as per Section 36
of the Stamp Act, a duty is cast upon the respondents
to raise an objection
when an insufficiently stamped document get tendered
in proceedings to be
marked. In the light of embargo under Section 36 of
the Stamp Act' it is
under Exs'A-l
hetd that the respondents cannot claim that the documents
and A-3 cannot be admitted for want of stamp duty. Further,
that there is failing to consider the judgment of this Court in
it is pleaded
cases of Venu
Gopal Baldava (supra) and judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court
of India
in the case of Avinash Kumar Chauhan v. Vijay Krishna Mishra2'
submitted that having dismissed I.A.No.130 of 2020, the leamed
It is
trial Court
went wrong in de-exhibiting Exs.A-t and A-3 by ignoring settled
principle
of law about section 36 of the Stamp Act, prohibiting questioning
the
admission of an instrument in evidence on the ground of
insufficiency' of
stamp duty except as provided in Section 61 of the Stamp
AcL There is an
effoneous conclusion that Section 36 of the Stamp Act
does not come in the
way of de-exhibiting the documents. Further, reference is made
to the
judgement of Hon'ble Supreme Court of tndia in the case of Javer Chand
v. Pukhraj Surana3, wherein, the Apex Court clearly stated that
document is admitted in evidence, no objection can be raised
on the ground
\
I
'RtR zoog SUPREME couRT 1489
,
' tserlol supreme (SC) 21L
once a
\
RY,J
cRP 4039 2024
of insufliciency of stamp duty. On the basis of aforementioned, it is
pleaded ttrat the impugned order is liable to be set aside.
Coptentions of the petitioner:
7.
The learned counsel for petitioner relied upon judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Javed Chand (supra), wherein it is held that
once a document has been marked as an exhibit and the trial has proceeded
on the footing that the document was an exhibit and it has been used by the
parties in examination and cross-examination of their witnesses Section 36
of the Act c;omes into operation. It is argued that once a document has been
admitted in evidence, it is not open either to the trial Court or the Court of
Appeal or Revision to go behind that order as Section 36 of rhe Stamp Act
does not mention any exceptions. When there is a question of adrnissibility
of a document on the ground of insufficient stamping, it has to be decided
then and there when the document is tendered in evidence. Once the Court
admits the document, as far as the parties are concerned the matter is
closed. A doc:ument has been marked as an exhibit and when it is used by
the parties in cross-examination, Section 36 of the Stamp Act comes into
operation, and thus, the issue of admissibility cannot be revisited.
cw
8.
RY,J
4039 2024
Further, as per judgment in Shyamal Kumar Roy v. Sushil Kumar
Agarwala, Section 36 of the Stamp Act prohibits a Court from questioning
the admission of an instrument in evidence on the ground of insufficient
stamp duty, except as provided in Section 61 of the Stamp Act. Further, it
is urged that if a party to the suit intends to produce an instrument which is
insufficiently stamped to be admitted in evidence, the objection must be
raised at the appropriate stage. The objection has to be specifically to the
effect that the document is not duly stamped. Upon making of such an
objection, the question is required to be determined judicially.
9. In the case of R.V.E. Venkatchala Gounder v. Arulmigu
Viswesaraswami & V.P. Temples, it is held that failure to raise a prompt
and timely objection about admissibility of a documentary evidence
amounts to waiver of the necessity for insisting on formal proof of a
document, the document itself which is sought to be proved being
admissible in evidence.
10. In the case of T.A. Khaja Hussain v. C. Irshad Basha Nizami6, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that with regard to Section 49 of the
\
Stamp Act about the effect of non-registration of documents required to be
registered, Section 36 of the Stamp Act about admission of instruments
o
)
2006 0 Supreme (sc) 1oo7
t
2oo3 8 Supreme 193
t
\
2oo9 o ALD 497
)
\
RY,J
cRP 4039 2024
which were not questioned when said instrument was admitted in evidence,
Section 6l of the Stamp Act deals with revision of decisions of Court
regarding sufficiency of stamps.
ll.
In the case of lsra Fatima v. Bismillah BegumT, the Hon'ble
Supreme oourt held that in a suit filed for perpetual injunction, when a
petition is liled to be de-exhibit, document Ex.B-2 on the ground that it was
not suff,rciently stamped, when there is failure to raise obiection at the time
of marking of document, once the document is admitted in evidence, there
can be no qrrestion of challenging the same subsequently.
12. Furthr:r, in the case of Varri Jayalakshmi v. Badiga Bswara Rao8,
the High Cc'urt of Andhra Pradesh held that it is well settled principle of
law that res iudicara applies at different stages of the same suit. Once a
plea is not taken in a previous application and it is admitted by the
petitioner, that such a plea though available was not taken, such a plea
cannot be tak,:n in a second application.
Contentions of respondent No.I:
13. Leamecl counsel for respondent No.1 relied upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supre,ms Court in the case of Veena Hasmukh Jain v. State of
'2oozs ALD 600
c.aTo.no6 of 2024,dated 11.11.2024.
RY,J
cRP_4039 ]024
Maharashtra
e
, wherein it is held that the duty with respect to an
agreement covered by the explanation under Entry No.44 of List No' 3 of
concurrent listed shows that duty is leviable as if it is a conveyance. The
conditions to be fulfilled are that the agreement is to sell immovable
property and delivery of possession of such an immovable property. When
there is delivery of possession of property, the same is deemed to be
conveyance.
14. Further, reference is made to judgment of this Court in the case of
Venu Gopal Baldava (supra), wherein it is held as follows at paragraph
Nos.2 | and 22:
"21. fn the present case, the trial Court received the documents along
with chief affidavit of PW-l and marked the documents as Exs.A2 to
Al3. However, supplementary deeds Exs-A2, A4, A6, A8, Al0 and
Al2 require registration and receipts Exs.A3, A5, A7, A9, All and
Al3 are subject to stamp duty. The said exhibits which were tendered
in evidence affrdavit of plaintiffs were deemed to be formally
approved. As held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Javer Chand's
case (2 supra), the Court has to judiciously determine the matter as
soon as the document is tendered in evidence before it is marked as an
exhibit. ApparentlY, tfus record discloses that there is no judicial
recognition with regard to admissibility of the documents Exs.A2 to
Al3 which were tendered by the plaintiffs along with the affidavits in
the form of chief examination. Therefore, it cannot be said that the
documents Exs.A2 to A13 are admitted in evidence, merely because
they are marked.
22. For the above reasons, I am of the view that Exs.A2 to Al3 were
marked mechanically though there was no judicial determination of
the admissibility of the said documents as required by law."
)
)
\
' uaruu/sc/0039/19s9
\
RY,J
cp.P 4039 2024
15. On the basis of aforementioned judgments, the learned counsel for
respondent No.l submits that there is no infirmity in the order passed by
the learnecl trial Court in de-exhibiting the documents Ex.A-l agreement of
sale and Ex.A-3 letter-cum-receipt and delivery of possession.
Findines of the Court:
16. The crux of the dispute is exhibiting of Ex.A-l agreement of sale
dated 22.1I .2006 and Ex.A-3 receipt-cum-letter of delivery of possession
dated 19.10.2011. The agreement of sale has been executed on a starnp
paper of Rs.l00/-. Any agreement or contract where the subject matter is
above vaiue of Rs.2,00,000i- said agreement has to be executeci on a stamp
paper of Rs.200/-. To said extent it can be said that the Ex.A-t agreement
of sale is executed on an insufficient stamp paper. When it comes to Ex.A3, letter of delivery of possession-cum-receipt dated 19.10.201l, it exhibits
delivery of p<>ssession of immovable property. For such a document, stamp
duty has to b,e paid as it was existing in the year 2011, which would be a
fixed atnount as per the G.O. in operation in the said year and not 5%o of
market value rtf the property which is the current rate brought into force in
the year 2021 by a G.O.Ms.No.S9 dated 20.07.2021 issued by the Revenue
Department. V/hen these two documents were admitted in the presence of
/
I
RY,J
cRP 4039 2024
the learned counsel for respondents before the trial Court without any
objection, then the bar under Section 36 of the Stamp Act comes into force,
i.e., an objection with respect to insufficiency of stamp duty cannot be
raised at alater stage once the document is exhibited.
17. In the instant case, there is a specific plea in the counter filed by the
petitioner in I.A.No.606 of 2023 that the documents were exhibited in the
presence of the counsel for respondent before the trial Court and therefore,
no objection can be raised after its admission in evidence. Respondent No.1
herein has not given any reply or rejoinder to the contention of the
petitioner that the Ex.A-l agreement of sale and Ex.A3 letter-cum-receipt
have been exhibited in the presence of the counsel.
18. When the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for
respondent No. t in the case of Venu Gopal Baldava (supra) is considered,
it is seen that there is a specific finding about marking of the documents
without application of mind, when admissibility is not decided. [t was
found that Exs.A-2to A-13 were submitted along with the chief affidavit of
P.W.l. The said documents were formatly approved. There was no
recognition with respect to admissibility of Exs.A-2 to A-13. About their
admissibility merely because said documents were tnarked, it is held that
ta
)
)
R.Y,J
cRP 4039 2024
there was no judicial determination about admissibility of the documents
and therelbre, de-exhibiting of the documents was permitted.
19. In the instant case, said analogy cannot be applied because
respondent No.l had already filed I.A.No.l30 of 2020 to send the Exs.Al
and A-3 f<rr impounding and said petition was dismissed vide order dated
21.03.2023. The very dismissal of the petition in I.A.No.130 of 2020
clinchingly establishes that when the documents were produced for being
marked in evidence and they were admitted, an interlocutory application
was filed ftrr the purpose of ref'erring the documents for impounding. The
learned trial Court considered the issue under Section 36 of the Stamp Act
and disnnissr:d the sanle holding that once a dccurnent is admitted, the issue
of admissibility on the ground of insufficient stamp duty cannot be
countenance,C. Once the issue of insufficient stamp dufy as to Exs.AI and
A-3 is consi,lered in t.A.No.l30 of 2020 and the same was dismissed, in
case respondent No.l had any grievance, respondent No.l ought to have
challenged said order. Once the order in I.A.No.130 of 2020 dated
21.03.2023 br:came final. Respondent No.t had no locus to file the present
petition under order XIII Rule 3 of CPC to de-exhibit the very same
documents on the very same ground of insufficiency of stamp duty. On
account of filing of I.A.No.l30 of 2020 and since the learned trial Court
. r-.
RY,J
cl<P 4039 2024
f,ua ,t."aay uppiiea nii judicial mind"to the issue of impoundirrg the
documents i.e. Exs.A-l and A-3, this Court is of the opinion that the facts
i
i
l
of the present case are not similar to the facts in the case of Venu Gopal
Baldava (supra).
20. [n view otthe foregoing discussion, this Court is of the opinion that
the learned trial Court already considered the issue of admissibility on
I
t
account of insufficient stamp duty in t.A.No.l30 of 2020 and passed an
order on merits on 2[.03.2023. Since said order was not challenged, said
order has becorne final. Once said order has become final, there is no
(
(
occasion fior respondent No. t to file the I.A. under revision to de-exhibit
said documents on the ground of the same being executed on insufficient
stamp paper.
21. [n view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the opinion that
I
t
t
the learned trial Court had exercised its jurisdiction improperly, having
I
I
I
made a decision in t.A.No.130 of 2020 and revisiting the same in
i
I.A.No.606 of 2023 (t.A. under revision). As such, the impugned order is
liabte to be set aside
22- [n the result, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed setting aside the
order dated 02.09.2024 in I.A.No.606 of 2023 in O.S.No.510 of 2014 on
the fite of the learned trial Court and consequently, the said I.A.No.606 of
i
I
I
I
\
I
\
\
I
RY,J '(-.}
cn-p +org zo2+
2023 is dismissed. There shatl be no order
as to costs' Miscellaneous
appticaticns, if any, pending sha[[ stand closed'
SD'. A.JAYASREE
ANT REGISTRAR
I'TRUE COPY"
SEGTION OFFICER
To
l.TheXlAdditionalDistrictandSessionsJudge,atLBNagar,
District. With Records)
O". C'Oio Sri: Ali Farooq, Advocate [OPUCI
OneC,3toSri.ShyamSAgrawal,AdvocateIOPUCI
4. Two CD CoPies
PT/PSL
L4
RangareddY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 18/0312026
ORDER
1 H E SIa
CRP.No.4039 of 2024
.)
t
()
21 Arfl
*
ALLOWING THE
b
CRP
b
G):
?0?6
.Li,
5 /.',
t
rt{Tt-t,.'".'
,i'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review