Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC040008772026
2026:GAU-AP:880
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : BA/54/2026
Mohammad Azad
Son of Shri Sheikh ali Hasan, resident of Village Gonchhi, Ward No.10, PO Bairiya,
PS Kesariya, East Champaran, Bihar.
VERSUS
The State of AP
represented through the PP of AP
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
Advocate for the Petitioner
:
Mr. R. Sonar, ld. Adv.
Advocate for the Respondents
:
Mr. T. Ete, ld, Addl.PP
Date on which Judgment is reserved
:
31.08.2026
Date of Hearing
:
31.08.2026
Date of Judgment and Order
:
03 .09 .2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the Operative part of the Judgment? :No
Whether the full Judgment has been pronounced ? : Yes
Page No.# 2/12
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
Heard Mr. R. Sonar, learned counsel for the applicant. Also heard Mr. T.
Ete, learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State respondent.
2.
The accused is facing trial before the Session Court, Yupia in connection
with Sessions Case No. 31/2022 arising out of Chimpu P.S. Case No. 18/2022,
under Sections 302/201 of the IPC. His earlier two bail applications were
rejected by the learned Sessions Judge, Yupia, on merits. The last one was
rejected on 29.04.2026.
3.
By filing the present application, the applicant, who is stated to be the
elder brother, prays for the release of the accused, Ashik Hussain on regular bail
in the above P. S. Case.
4.
The learned counsel for the applicant submits that, the accused was
arrested on 06.04.2022 in connection with the aforesaid case, and since then,
he has remained in custody for a considerable period of more than four years
and that his continued incarceration, pending conclusion of the trial, would
amount to a violation of his fundamental right to life and personal liberty
guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
5.
At the very outset, the learned counsel for the applicant made it clear and
submits that the present petition has been filed seeking the release of the
accused on bail and it is not on consideration or re-appreciation of the merits of
the prosecution case, but solely on the ground of the length of incarceration and
the constitutionally guaranteed right to a speedy trial.
Page No.# 3/12
6.
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the accused has been in
custody for a long period for more than 4 years and that, although 36
prosecution witnesses have already been examined, some more witnesses are
still to be examined and, at this pace, the trial of the case would take
considerable long time to conclude. He further submits that the accused cannot
be kept in custody for an indefinite period without concluding the trial. He,
therefore, prays that the accused be released on bail to enable him to properly
defend his case while remaining outside the jail custody. The learned counsel
further submits that keeping the Under Trial Prisoner for such a long
incarceration would amount to violation of the personal liberty guaranteed
under Article 21 of the constitution. In support of his submission, the learned
counsel for the applicant relies upon the decision of Javed Gulam Nabi
Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra & Anr. , reported in (2024) 9 SCC 813,
wherein it was held in paragraphs 16, 17 and 18, which are relevant and are
reproduced below: “16. Criminals are not born but made. The human potential in everyone is good and
so, never write off any criminal as beyond redemptions. This humanist fundamental is
often missed when dealing with delinquents, juveniles and adult. Indeed, every saint
has a past and every sinner a future. When a crime is committed, a variety of factors
is responsible for making the offender commit the crime. Those factors may be social
and economic, may be, the result of value erosion or parental neglect; may be,
because of the stress of circumstances, or the manifestation of temptations in a milieu
of affluence contrasted with indigence or other privations.
17.
If the State or any prosecuting agency including the court concerned has no
wherewithal to provide or protect the fundamental right of an accused to have a
speedy trial as enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution then the State or any
other prosecuting agency should not oppose the plea for bail on the ground that the
Page No.# 4/12
crime committed is serious. Article 21 of the Constitution applies irrespective of the
nature of the crime.
18.
We may hasten to add that the applicantis still an accused; not a convict. The
over-arching postulates of criminal jurisprudence that an accused is presumed to be
innocent until proven guilty cannot be brushed aside lightly howsoever stringent the
penal law may be.”
7.
The learned counsel for the applicant also relied upon the decision
in Lalpian Mawii @ Khumi Khabug v. The State of Assam , [Bail
Appl.No.3068/2024, decided on 22.01.2025], reported in 2025 (2) GLT 231,
wherein it was held in paragraphs 14 and 15, which are reproduced below:“14. From the above decisions so rendered by the Supreme Court, it is therefore
clear that the right to speedy and expeditious trial is not only a vital safeguard to
prevent undue and oppressive incarceration, but it is also to mitigate anxiety and
concern accompanying the accusation, as well as to curtail any impairment in the
ability of an accused to defend himself. There is also an overarching societal interest
paving way for a speedy trial. The concept of speedy trial is amalgamated into Article
21 as an essential part of the fundamental right to life and liberty, guaranteed and
preserved under our constitution. The right to speedy trial begins with the actual
restraint imposed at the time of the arrest of the accused and the consequent
incarceration which continues at all stages, namely the stage of investigation, inquiry,
trial, appeal and revision, so that any possible prejudice that may result due to
impermissible and avoidable delay since the time of the commission of the offence till
the criminal proceedings consummates into a finality, could be averted. The speedy
trial, early hearing and quick disposal are sine quo non of criminal jurisprudence. The
overcrowded Court-dockets, the heavy volume of work and the resultant pressure on
the prosecution and the police, indubitably keeps the entire criminal jurisprudential
mechanism under stress and strain. However, this cannot be an excuse to keep the
accused in incarceration for an indefinite period of time. It does not serve any credit to
Page No.# 5/12
the criminal justice system, rather it makes for a sad state of affairs.
15.
The guarantee of a speedy trial is intended to avoid oppression and prevent
delay by imposing on the court and the prosecution an obligation to proceed with the
trial with a reasonable dispatch. The guarantee serves a threefold purpose. First, it
protects the accused against oppressive pre-trial imprisonment; secondly, it relieves
the accused of the anxiety and public suspicion due to unresolved criminal charges
and lastly, it protects against the risk that evidence will be lost on memories dimmed
by the passage of time, thus, impairing the ability of the accused to defend himself. It
goes without saying that the consequences of the pre-trial detention are grave. It is a
settled position as per criminal jurisprudence that an accused is presumed innocent, till
proven otherwise. This court cannot be unmindful that the burden of detention of such
an accused frequently falls heavily on the innocent members of the family.”
8.
On the contrary, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor, while opposing
the bail application, submits that the allegation against the accused is very
serious and it is for commission of offences punishable under Sections 302/201
of the IPC and that the accused is alleged to have participated in the
commission of the offence along with two others. Another ground of objection
raised by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor is that the trial is progressing
continuously and that the examination of the prosecution witnesses is almost
complete. It is further submitted that there is incriminating material evidence
against the accused for the commission of the alleged offence. Under these
circumstances, if the accused is released on bail, there is every likelihood that
he may abscond and evade the process of law.
9.
The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further submits that prolonged
incarceration is neither an automatic nor the sole ground for release of an
accused on bail. There is no delay attributable either to the prosecution or to
the Court, and since the trial is at an advanced stage and is likely to be
Page No.# 6/12
concluded within a short period, it cannot be said that the trial is being stalled
indefinitely, as alleged by the learned counsel for the petitioner.
10.
The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further submits that there is
sufficient material against the accused and that he is likely to be convicted in
the case. Therefore, at this stage, the release of the accused on bail would
cause serious prejudice to the prosecution case.
11.
In support of his submissions, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
relies upon the following decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the High
Court:
i.
Md. Shabuddin v. State of Assam, [BA 63/2026, decided on
05.08.2026];
ii.
Rajesh Ranjan Yadav Alias Pappu Yadav v. CBI through the
Director, reported in 2006 SCC OnLine SC 1229;
iii.
Virupakshappa Gouda & Anr. v. State of Karnataka & Anr. ,
reported in (2017) 5 SCC 406;
iv.
Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan Alias Pappu Yadav
& Anr., reported in (2005) 2 SCC 42; and
v.
Rajendra Prasad v. State of Goa & Anr. , reported in 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 1657.
12. Learned Addl. P.P submits that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has laid down
certain principle to be followed while considering the bail. He submits that for
consideration of the bail of the applicant who is stated to be incarcerated for
Page No.# 7/12
long, the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and High Court in the
above referred cases relied upon by him may also be considered.
13.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and upon
perusal of the trial court record, it appears that 36 prosecution witnesses have
already been examined and that the case is now at an advanced stage of trial
and is likely to be concluded within a short period.
14.
The learned Trial Court, while rejecting the bail application, had observed
that the accused is a resident of Bihar and that he had allegedly committed the
offence of murder of a Police Sub-Inspector in Arunachal Pradesh and thereafter
fled to the State of West Bengal from where he later on was arrested, and if he
is released on bail, there is every possibility of his fleeing from the clutches of
law.
15.
There can be no dispute with the proposition that the right to a speedy
trial is an integral part of the guarantee contained in Article 21 of the
Constitution. Prolonged pre-trial incarceration is undoubtedly a matter of
constitutional concern. However, at the same time, it does not mean that due to
mere length of incarceration, irrespective of the circumstances in which the trial
is progressing, it has accrued an indefeasible right to bail to the accused.
16. Learned counsel for the parties has relied upon the decisions where the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and High Court have laid the principles governing
consideration of bail. The principles emerging from the various decisions of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, and High Court in the above referred cases to be
considered, while considering an application for bail, including a prayer based on
prolonged incarceration and alleged violation of Article 21 of the Constitution,
Page No.# 8/12
may be summarized as follows:
(I)
Bail is discretionary: Grant of bail is a discretionary relief.
However, such discretion has to be exercised judiciously, cautiously
and on sound principles, and not arbitrarily.
(ii)
Prima facie case: The Court has to examine whether there are
reasonable grounds or prima facie materials to believe that the
accused has committed the alleged offence. At the stage of bail, the
Court is not required to determine the guilt of the accused.
(iii)
Nature and gravity of offence: The nature and gravity of the
accusation are important considerations. In a serious and heinous
offence, particularly an offence carrying severe punishment, the
Court is required to exercise greater caution while considering
release of accused on bail.
(iv)
Nature of evidence: The Court has to consider, the nature and
strength of the evidence supporting the prosecution case. The Court
is not required to conduct a detailed examination of the evidence or
a mini-trial.
(v)
Severity of punishment: Where the offence entails severe
punishment, the possibility of the accused evading the process of
law cannot be ignored.
(vi)
Possibility of absconding: The Court has to consider whether, if
released on bail, there is a likelihood of the accused fleeing from
justice or not being available to face the trial. His roots in the
locality, character, antecedents, means, position and other relevant
circumstances may be considered.
Page No.# 9/12
(vii)
Possibility of influencing witnesses: The Court has to consider
whether there is a reasonable apprehension that the accused, if
released, may influence, threaten or intimidate the witnesses or
otherwise interfere with the prosecution evidence.
(viii)
Possibility of tampering with evidence or obstructing
justice: The Court has to consider whether release of the accused
may result in tampering with evidence or otherwise frustrate or
obstruct the course of justice.
(ix)
Likelihood of repetition: The possibility of the accused repeating
the alleged offence, if released on bail, is also a relevant
consideration.
(x)
Stage and progress of trial: The Court should consider the stage
of the trial and its progress. If substantial evidence has already been
recorded and the trial is proceeding expeditiously, the Court may
take that circumstance into account while considering a prayer for
bail based on prolonged custody of accused.
(xi)
Delay
and
responsibility
for
it:
While
considering
long
incarceration, the Court should examine whether the delay in
conclusion of the trial is attributable to the prosecution, the accused,
the Court or the system. Where the accused is in custody for a long
period because of unexplained or unjustified delay not attributable
to him, the consideration under Article 21 of the Constitution
assumes greater significance.
(xii)
Article 21 and prolonged incarceration: The right to speedy
trial is a part of the guarantee of life and personal liberty under
Page No.# 10/12
Article 21. Prolonged pre-trial incarceration is, therefore, an
important consideration while deciding bail. However, the mere
length of incarceration does not automatically confer a right to bail.
The period of custody has to be considered along with the nature of
the offence, prima facie material, stage and progress of the trial and
other relevant circumstances.
(xiii)
Balance between liberty and administration of justice: While
protecting the personal liberty of the accused, the Court must also
ensure that the criminal justice process is not prejudiced. The Court
has to consider a reasonable balance between the right of the
accused to personal liberty and the interest of society in a fair,
effective and unhindered trial.
(xiv)
No mini-trial: At the stage of bail, the Court is not expected to
undertake a meticulous appreciation of evidence or record findings
which may prejudice the trial. The Court has only to make a broad
assessment of the material available for the limited purpose of
determining whether bail should be granted.
(xv)
Totality of circumstances: No single factor can ordinarily be
considered in isolation. The Court has to examine the totality of the
circumstances and determine whether, having regard to all the
relevant factors, the accused should be released on bail.
17.
Thus, while prolonged incarceration and the constitutional guarantee
under Article 21 are undoubtedly relevant and important considerations.
However, they have to be balanced against the seriousness of the offence,
prima facie material against the accused, the stage and progress of the trial, the
Page No.# 11/12
likelihood of the accused being available for trial, the possibility of influencing
witnesses or tampering with evidence, and the overall interests of the
administration of criminal justice.
18.
In the present case, the record does not indicate that the progress of the
trial has been unduly delayed on account of any inaction or default either on the
part of the prosecution or on the part of the Court. On the contrary, the record
reveals that the trial has made substantial progress. Altogether, 36 prosecution
witnesses have already been examined, and there is no material to demonstrate
that either the prosecution or the Court has caused any avoidable delay. The
allegation against the accused is for commission of grave offences punishable
under Sections 302 and 201 of the IPC. The record reveals that after committing
of alleged murder of police officer, the accused fled from the State, and
remained absconding till he was arrested from the other State. Further, there is
allegedly prima facie incriminating material against him. In the facts and
circumstances of the case, the apprehension regarding the availability of the
accused for the remaining proceedings also cannot be completely discarded.
Furthermore, in the present case, the applicant has not been able to
demonstrate or disclose any circumstance indicating that the accused is being
subjected to indefinite incarceration owing to unjustified or unexplained delay in
the conclusion of the trial proceedings. Thus, the constitutional protection of the
accused under Article 21 remains fully operative.
19. In view of the above and considering the totality of the circumstances,
particularly the advanced stage of the trial and the absence of any deliberate
delay on the part of the prosecution or the Court, this Court is not persuaded
that the continued custody of the accused, at the present stage, amounts to
such a violation of Article 21 as would warrant his release on bail. Consequently,
Page No.# 12/12
this Court finds no sufficient ground to grant bail to the accused at this stage.
20. Accordingly, the bail application seeking the release of the accused stands
rejected.
21.
However, considering that the accused has remained in custody since his
arrest on 06.04.2022, the learned Trial Court shall make every endeavour to
proceed with the remaining evidence, if any; expeditiously and in accordance
with law.
22. With the above observations, this bail application stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Sabnam Mepo (Senior Personal Assistant)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review