Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CM(M) No. 534/2025
CM No.7994/2025
CM No. 4209/2026
CM No. 717/2026
Reserved on: 16.09.2026
Pronounced on: 22.09.2026
Uploaded on: 22.09.2026
Operative part or full judgment - Full
Mohammad Ayoub Bhat
S/O Abdul Rehman Bhat,
R/O Tulbagh Pampore
District Pulwama.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Adv. Fayaz Ahmad Lone.
Vs.
Abdul Rehman Bhat
S/O Mohammad Abdullah Bhat
R/O Tulbagh Pampore
District Pulwama.
…Respondent(s)
Through: Sr.Adv. Z.A.Qureshi with
Advs. Babar Bilal Malik
& Anurag Verma.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M. A.CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Petitioner has invoked the supervisory jurisdiction of this Court
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India calling in question the
order dated 28.11.2025 passed by the court of learned Civil Judge
(Jr. Division), Pampore, in the Execution Petition No.71/2019 titled
Abdul Rehman Bhat Vs. Mohammad Ayoub Bhat, whereby
Tehsildar, Pampore was directed to ensure eviction of the petitioner,
from the residential house in his possession within a period of fifteen
days.
Page |2
2.
It may be noticed at the outset that this Court vide order dated
03.12.2025 had directed the parties to maintain status quo with
regard to the subject matter of the petition. The said interim direction
has continued to operate and, therefore, the petitioner has remained
protected from dispossession pursuant to the impugned order.
3.
The grievance of the petitioner is that the impugned direction for
eviction has been issued without first ensuring compliance with the
terms of the compromise/settlement which constituted the basis of
the awards passed by the Lok Adalat on 29.03.2014 and 06.12.2014
followed by the subsequent award dated 23.06.2018; that under the
settlement so arrived at between the parties, the petitioner was
entitled to land measuring 28.32 marlas falling under Survey No.
2799 situated at Tulbagh, Pampore and that delivery of the said land
was a necessary concomitant of the settlement before the petitioner
could be called upon to vacate the residential house; that pursuant to
the settlement the petitioner has received only 5 marlas of land
falling under Survey No. 2799 on the strength of the settlement deed
and that said 5 marlas constitute the land underneath the residential
house; that directing the eviction of the petitioner from the
residential house without first identifying and delivering the
remaining land allegedly falling to his share under the compromise,
would amount to enforcing only one part of the settlement while
leaving the corresponding obligation of the other side unperformed.
4.
Factual background of the instant case is that, in the year 2013
differences arose in the family over the property consisting of
residential house and land appurtenant to the said house; that the
petitioner instituted Civil Original Suit No.124 of 2013 before the
Page |3
court of learned Munsiff, Pampore and the suit was taken up in Lok
Adalat on 29.03.2014; that the respondent approached the petitioner
and thereafter to Lok Adalat, wherein he gave his consent to give
28.32 marlas of proprietary land falling under survey No.2799 in
lieu of share of the petitioner in the residential house situated at
Namblabal, Pampore in full and final settlement of the petitioner’s
share provided the petitioner vacated the residential house; that the
petitioner agreed to the said settlement and accordingly award dated
29.03.2014 was passed on the basis of the joint compromise; that
since the land could not be immediately demarcated and delivered,
the matter was again taken to the National Lok Adalat on 06.12.2014
where another compromise was recorded reiterating the same terms
and fixing further time for demarcation and registration of a formal
settlement deed; that on 31.12.2014 a family settlement deed was
executed and registered on 14.02.2015 and in terms of that
settlement land measuring 5 marlas got transferred and recorded in
the name of petitioner and 4 marlas were recorded in the name of
Mst. Shazia-daughter of the respondent, on his instructions; that the
remaining land as agreed in the award is yet to be delivered to the
petitioner; that the respondent still failed to deliver the agreed
proprietary land measuring 28.32 marlas under survey no. 2799;
that the proprietary portion that exists under survey no.2799 which
was agreed to be delivered in favour of the petitioner in lieu of his
share in residential house is in the physical possession of Mushtaq
Ahmad Bhat and Mehraj ud Din Bhat (real brothers of respondent),
as such, cannot be delivered to the petitioner. Hence the instant
petition.
Page |4
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner while arguing the matter submits
that the executing court has no jurisdiction to execute an Award
partly without ensuring delivery of land measuring 28.32 marlas
falling under survey No.2799 situated at Tulbagh, Pampore in favour
of the petitioner before ordering eviction from the residential house
which is in possession of the petitioner; that the petitioner is not
seeking to obstruct or defeat execution of the Awards but his limited
grievance is that execution ought to proceed in terms of the
compromise/settlement which forms the foundation of the Awards
and not in a manner which would render the petitioner's
corresponding entitlement under the settlement, illusory; that the
impugned order be set aside and the Executing Court be directed to
first ensure delivery of the land measuring 28.32 marlas falling
under Survey No. 2799 in accordance with the terms of the
settlement before directing the petitioner to vacate the residential
house.
6.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent, ex adverso,
contends that the Awards have attained finality and are required to
be executed as civil decrees, in accordance with their terms; that the
petitioner cannot resist delivery of possession merely on the basis of
an interpretation sought to be placed by him upon the
compromise/settlement. He has made reference to the admission of
the petitioner as judgment debtor made before the Executing court
on 23.06.2018; that he has received possession of entire land
measuring 28.32 marlas of the suit land, to which he was held
entitled in view of amicable settlement in Lok Adalats and the
resulting Family Settlement made of his father- decree holder
Page |5
(respondent herein) in favour of petitioner and petitioner’s sister,
which was executed on 31.12.2014 and registered on 14.02.2015;
that the only part of Award/Decree left to be executed is that the
petitioner has to hand over vacant possession of the residential house
to the respondent. The petition, thus, being misconceived, is liable to
be dismissed outrightly.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the material placed on
record and considered the same.
8.
The scope of interference under Article 227 of the Constitution is
undoubtedly limited. This Court does not exercise such jurisdiction
as an appellate Court. However, where an Executing Court proceeds
in a manner which may result in enforcement of an Award without
examining the corresponding terms of the compromise on the basis
whereof the Award came to be passed or where the execution is
likely to cause manifest prejudice to a party by enforcing one
component of the settlement while leaving another component
unaddressed, interference may be warranted to ensure that the
process of execution remains confined to and consistent with the
decree/award sought to be executed.
9.
In the present case, the Awards dated 29.03.2014, 06.12.2014 and
23.06.2018
admittedly
have
their
genesis
in
the
settlement/compromise between the parties. The question which
arises is not whether the said Awards are executable, but whether the
direction for eviction of the petitioner from the residential house
could have been issued in isolation, without first examining whether,
under the very settlement which forms the basis of the Awards, the
petitioner was entitled to delivery of the land claimed by him.
Page |6
10.
The petitioner's specific assertion is that the settlement contemplated
allotment/delivery of 28.32 marlas of land falling under Survey No.
2799, whereas only 5 marlas have actually been received by him
and that the said 5 marlas constitute the land underneath the
residential house. If this assertion is borne out from the compromise,
settlement deed and the Awards, the execution of the settlement
cannot ordinarily be permitted to operate to the prejudice of the
petitioner by directing his eviction first, without simultaneously
securing compliance with the corresponding obligation under the
settlement.
11.
It is also significant that immediately after the passing of the
impugned order, this Court, vide order dated 03.12.2025 directed the
parties to maintain status quo. The said order was passed during the
pendency of the present petition and has, therefore, preserved the
existing position with regard to the subject property. The
continuance of the status quo direction also makes it appropriate that
the rights and obligations flowing from the compromise/settlement
be first examined by the learned Executing Court before any
coercive step pursuant to the impugned order is undertaken.
12.
Petitioner filed a suit for declaration and permanent injunction,
seeking declaring him as owner in possession of half of the share out
of land measuring 15 marlas falling under Survey No.3909 and half
of share out of 12.25 marals under Survey No.2799, alongwith half
share in the house i.e., 1st floor of residential house constructed over
Survey No.2799, partition by metes and bounds and permanent
injunction.
Page |7
13.
Parties settled the matter in Lok Adalat on 29.03.2014, wherein it
was resolved that petitioner shall be entitled to two shares out of five
shares, which comes to 12 marlas under Survey No.2799 of village
Namblabal Pampore and in lieu of his share in the residential house;
the petitioner shall retain another 12 marlas out of same Survey No;
the respondent shall exclusively retain the remaining 6 marlas of
land from Survey No.2799 and the residential house, with common
12 feet road from the share of the petitioner and that settlement deed
shall be executed and registered within a period of one month.
14.
The Execution Petition under Order 21 Rule 11 CPC moved to
enforce the aforestated Lok Adalat Award dated 29.03.2014 again
came up before Lok Adalat on 06.12.2014 and the matter was settled
in mutual compromise that the respondent had delivered possession
of 12 marlas of land to the petitioner, besides petitioner agreed to
make payment of Rs.21,500/- including electric charges arrears upto
November, 2017 within 30 days.
15.
Based on the mutual compromises and the Awards dated 29.03.2014
and 06.12.2014, both the parties executed a Family Settlement Deed
on 31.12.2014. The parties to the Deed were respondent as father
and petitioner as son and one Shazia-daughter, with the covenants
that respondent being father as settler divided the property as
follows:
5 Marlas of land to petitioner (Son); 4 Marlas of land to
daughter (Shazia); and that the settler (respondent) shall
have no right or interest or claim over the said distributed
Page |8
land and that son and daughter of the settler can seek their
entries in the Revenue Records.
16.
Based on earlier Lok Adalat Awards dated 29.03.2014 and
06.12.2014, and the Family Settlement Deed, the Execution Petition
was again decided in Lok Adalat on 23.06.2018, on admission by the
petitioner as judgment debtor that he had taken over the possession
of complete land of 28.32 Marlas of his share in the month of
November, 2017, which is also reflected in demarcation report of
Tehsildar Pampore vide his No.TP-OQ136 dated 09.05.2018, in
terms of court order dated 26.02.2018; that he shall vacate the
residential house within a period of 15 months by the end of March
2019.
17.
Decree holder (respondent herein) sought execution of the latest Lok
Adalat Award dated 23.06.2018 in continuation of earlier Awards
dated 29.03.2014 and 06.12.2014, as decree. Vide impugned order
the Executing Court allowed the Execution Petition directing
Tehsildar, Pampore to ensure that the judgment debtor/petitioner
herein vacates the house within 15 days and if required with Police
assistance, with the condition that provisions of Order XXI Rule 35
of CPC (warrant of possession) and Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC
(arrest and civil detention), shall be resorted to.
18.
The contention on the part of the petitioner and submissions made on
his behalf that the petitioner had not received the delivery of the
possession of the land measuring 28.32 Marlas falling under Survey
No. 2799 situate at Tulbagh, Pampore, as such, he cannot be asked
to vacate the residential house which is subject to the condition that
Page |9
the aforesaid land is to be spared for him and possession is required
to be handed over to him before asking him to vacate the residential
house to be given to the respondent. The petitioner, after the Lok
Adalat Awards dated 29.03.2014 and 06.12.2014 and the Family
Settlement Deed settled by the respondent in favour of the petitioner
and his sister, the petitioner had admitted on 23.06.2018 before the
Lok Adalat that he had been handed over the possession of complete
land measuring 28.32 Marlas of his share in the month of
November, 2017, which has also been reflected in the demarcation
report prepared by the local Tehsildar on 09.05.2018 in terms of the
court order dated 26.02.2018. The petitioner had also undertaken that
he would vacate the residential house within a period of 15 months
i.e. by the end of March, 2019.
19.
It is not the case of the petitioner that he had not been handed over
the possession of the land to which he was entitled to as per the
Award sought to be executed in the Execution Petition as he had
fairly conceded that he had received whole of the land to which he is
entitled to as per the Lok Adalat Awards. Despite undertaking that
he shall vacate the residential house and hand over its vacant
possession to the respondent by the end of March, 2019, he had not
vacated the said house and, as such, the Executing Court was
compelled to pass the impugned order, whereby Tehsildar, Pampore
had been directed to vacate the petitioner from the residential house
in his possession within a period of 15 days.
20.
Having regard to the factual background of the case, there does not
seem to be any illegality or perversity in the impugned order so as to
warrant any interference by this Court. The scope of a petition under
P a g e | 10
Article 227 of the Constitution of India is strictly supervisory and
correctional empowering High Courts to keep Subordinate Courts
and Tribunals within the bounds of their authority rather than acting
as an appellate court. A High Court cannot re-appreciate or reway
evidence, review findings of fact or substitute a reasonable decision
of a lower court with its own view just because another
interpretation is possible. Interference is permitted only when a
lower court acts without jurisdiction, exceeds its jurisdiction, fails to
exercise a vested jurisdiction or violates the principles of natural
justice. This supervisory power is to be exercised exceptionally and
sparingly to correct patent errors of law, grave injustice, flagrant
abuse of law or perverse views that no reasonable court could hold.
21.
Viewed thus, the impugned order having been passed by the court
below perfectly in consonance with law, does not call for any
interference. The petition is thus, found, to be bereft of any merit and
substance and is liable to be rejected. As a result, the petition is
dismissed along-with pending application(s). Interim direction shall
also stand vacated.
( M. A. CHOWDHARY )
JUDGE
Srinagar
22.09.2026
Muzammil. Q
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review