Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.05
Regular Cause List
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CM(M) 121/2024
CM(2222/2024)
CM(2223/2024)
CM(3851/2025)
CM(4950/2025)
1. Mohammad Ashraf Shah (Age: 65 years)
S/O Late Mohammad Shafi Shah
R/O Chota Bazar, Kani Kadal, Srinagar
At present Hyderpora, Srinagar.
…Petitioner(s)
2. Mst. Shameema (Age:62 years)
D/O Late Mohammad Shafi Shah
R/O Chota Bazar, Kani Kadal, Srinagar
Through:
Mr. B. A. Bashir, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Azeem Rasic Nabi, Advocate.
Vs
Zahoor Ahmad Shah
S/O Late Mohammad Shafi Shah
R/O Wakeel Colony, Brein Nishat, Srinagar.
Through:
...Respondent(s)
Respondent in Person.
CORAM:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Sekhri, Judge.
JUDGMENT
(09.09.2026)
(ORAL)
01.
Petitioners have invoked supervisory jurisdiction of this
Court, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India for the
quashment of order dated 06.03.2024, passed by learned 3rd
Additional District Judge, Srinagar [“the Trial Court”], in case titled
“Zahoor Ahmad Shah Vs Mohammad Shafi Shah & Ors.”
02.
Before a closer look at the grounds urged in the memo of
petition, some admitted facts of the case are required to be noticed;
they are stated thus:
CM(M) 121/2024
2.1 Respondent instituted a suit in the year 2004, against
the petitioners and their deceased father, for the
following reliefs:
A.
A decree in the nature of declaration be issued
in favour of plaintiff and against defendants
declaring the documents (1) Sale Deed (2) Rent
Deed (3) Surendar Deed filed as part of
pleadings as invalid, and be further declared
opposed to rights of plaintiff and public policy,
further decree be issued in favour of plaintiff
and against defendant declaring the Sale and
purchase
of
land/orchard
at
Badampora,
Kurhama Ganderbal, Srinagar as benami.
B.
A decree for declaration be issued in favour of
plaintiff and against defendants declaring him to
be entitled to receive his due share out of whole
property mentioned in suit in accordance with
rights of inheritance and succession.
C.
A decree for prohibitory injunction be issued in
favour of plaintiff and against defendants
restraining them from causing any interference
in the possession and occupation of plaintiff
over the orchard mentioned here-to-fore.
D.
Any other decree order or direction though hot
prayed for yet this Hon'ble court deems just and
proper be issued in favour of plaintiff.
2.2 The petitioners filed written statement and learned
Trial Court vide order dated 30.12.2011 framed the
issues.
2.3 After the demise of the father of the petitioners, in
February, 2018, respondent filed an application in the
Trial Court for amendment of the suit, which came to
be allowed on 16.08.2021. The said order was assailed
CM(M) 121/2024
by the petitioners by way of a revision petition in this
Court, which was dismissed.
2.4 Subsequently, petitioners preferred an application in
the Trial Court for rejection of plaint under Order VII
Rule 11 CPC and it came to be dismissed by the Trial
Court in terms of order dated 13.12.2021.
2.5 The petitioners thereafter filed their written statement
to the amended plaint, whereby it was asserted by the
petitioners that, since challenge to the surrender deed
and lease deed was barred by limitation, the suit in the
present form could not be entertained. Relevant part of
the written statement for the facility of reference is
extracted below:
(i)
As per relief clause, surrender/relinquishment deed
executed on 1993 is sought to be declared as nullity
by virtue of this suit which has been initially filed in
2004 after ten years when limitation period provided
is only three years. How a non-maintainable suit hit
by limitation, is being tried on the face of it, is not
understandable.
(ii)
Rent deed executed by Masjid Committee with
respect to a shop in favour of Defendant No. 2 way
back in 1983, is sought to be declared invalid for
which suit has been filed in 2004 after twenty years,
how the said relief is maintainable, is not
understandable.
(iii)
Sale deed description of which is sought to be
declared invalid, is not shown in the relief clause,
how can such a relief be granted, is not
understandable. Yet, the suit is being tried. Rest of
the relief being dependent on relief "a", naturally
will fall to the ground if relief "a" for one or the
reason, cannot be granted.
CM(M) 121/2024
(iv)
This Court has no territorial as well as pecuniary
jurisdiction to entertain the suit. The plaintiff seeks
nullification of surrender deed for execution of
which, he has received consideration of Rs. 4.50 lacs
way back in 1993. Even if same valuation is fixed in
the suit, he had to pay proper court fee for that also
ad valorem, which he has not paid because when
declaratory decree is sought with consequential
reliefs, ad valorem court fee has to be paid which he
has not done. Hence, suit is not maintainable. Even
on this valuation to seek cancellation of surrender
deed for which he has received consideration of Rs.
4.50 lacs, pecuniary jurisdiction is lacking this court
to try the suit.
(v)
That part of the suit is alleged to be orchard at
Sopore for which there is not an iota of details given,
yet this court is trying the suit without territorial
jurisdiction.
(vi)
That the suit filed in 2004, was not maintainable
during the lifetime of Defendant No. 1, which has
been admitted in the present amended plaint also,
hence, on the basis of a non-maintainable suit under
the garb of amendment, same cannot be maintained,
therefore, the suit deserves to be dismissed with
exemplary costs.”
2.6 On the basis of amended pleadings, learned Trial Court
vide order dated 08.07.2023 framed issues in addition
to the issues already framed in the unamended
pleading, in terms of order dated 30.12.2011
2.7 The petitioners, subsequently invoked Order XIV Rule
5 CPC by filing an application in the Trial Court for
recasting the issues and framing of additional issues,
which came to be dismissed by the Trial Court, in terms
of the impugned order dated 06.03.2024, primarily on
the ground that since the suit has suffered a number of
CM(M) 121/2024
transfer
applications,
amendments
and
revision
petitions, the long pendency of the suit is to be given
due weightage. Learned Trial Court was of the view
that issues already framed in terms of orders dated
30.12.2011 and 08.07.2023, are sufficient to determine
the controversy between the parties, the issues
proposed by the petitioners were not necessary.
03.
Petitioners are aggrieved of the impugned order primarily
on the ground that since it was their categoric stand in the written
statement that surrender/relinquishment deed executed in 1993, and
the rent deed in question, those are sought to be annulled by the
respondent by virtue of the suit instituted in the year 2004, were
barred by limitation, the issue of limitation was material to decide the
controversy at the threshold.
04.
It is also contention of the petitioners that they also raised a
specific plea in the written statement that since respondent had
admittedly received consideration of ₹4.50 lakhs at the time of
execution of the compromise/surrender deed in the year 1993, he
was estopped from seeking its annulment at this length of time.
05.
Having heard the rival contentions, I have gone through the
trial court record.
06.
The controversy on hand revolves are round a well-known
maxim “ei incumbit probatio, qui dicit, non qui negat” which means that
the burden of proof lies upon the person who affirms, but not who
denies. To put it differently, the burden lies on the party who asserts
the fact to be taken note of by the court in his favour because by the
very nature of the pleadings, one who denies the fact cannot be
burdened to produce the proof of the same. In other words, a
negative is ordinarily incapable of proof.
CM(M) 121/2024
07.
Order XIV CPC deals with framing of issues and a bare
reading of Rule 1(1) of Order XIV would indicate that when a
material proposition of fact or law is affirmed by one party and
denied by the other, then, an issue has to be framed by the Court. In
other words, whoever desires the court to pronounce a judgment as
to a legal right dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts,
must prove that those facts exist.
08.
When a material proposition of fact or law is affirmed by
one party and denied by the other, every such proposition shall form
the subject of a distinct issue. It is settled in law that primarily it is the
obligation of the Court to frame the issues, and failure on the part of
the Court may be remedied by either of the parties inviting attention
of the Court to the need of framing such an issue, either by
participating in the process of settlement of issues or by moving an
application in terms of Rule 5 of Order XIV CPC. In other words, it is
obligatory on the part of the Court to frame an issue once it is satisfied
that an issue which should have been framed escaped its attention.
Be it noted that if the Trial Court fails in framing an issue, or fails to
remedy its failure, then even Appellate Court is vested with the
power to frame an issue under Order XLI Rule 25 CPC.
Order XIV Rule 5 reads as below:
“5. Power to amend, and strike out, issues.—(1) The Court may
at any time before passing a decree amend the issues or frame
additional issues on such terms as it thinks fit, and all such
amendments or additional issues as may be necessary for
determining the matters in controversy between the parties shall
be so made or framed.
(2) The Court may also, at any time before passing a decree, strike
out any issues that appear to it to be wrongly framed or
introduced.”
09.
It is evident from a plain reading of Rule 5 of Order XIV CPC
that Court is vested with wide discretionary power to amend the
CM(M) 121/2024
issues framed or frame additional issues at any time before passing a
decree on such terms as it thinks fit, which may be necessary for
determining the matter in controversy between the parties.
Pertinently, the Court in terms of sub-rule (2) of Rule 5 of Order XIV
is also vested with the power, at any time before passing a decree, to
strike out any issue that appears to it to be wrongly framed or
introduced. [see P.S. Shivakumar vs P.H. Subbarayappa; 2017 SCC
OnLine Kar 2263, Abbott Healthcare Private Limited vs Raj Kumar
Prasad & Anr; 2018 SCC OnLine Del 6657, and Sana Herbals Private
Limited vs Mohsin Dehlvi, 2022 SCC OnLine Del 4482]
10.
If the present case is approached with the aforesaid
principles of law, there is no denial of the fact that petitioners in the
written statement have taken a categoric stand that surrender/
relinquishment deed, admittedly executed between the parties in the
year 1993, which is sought to be annulled by the respondent by way
of the suit filed in the year 2004 after a gap of 10 years, was barred by
limitation. It was also a specific stand of the petitioners that the rent
deed executed by the Masjid Committee with respect to a shop in
favour of defendant No. 2, in the suit, in 1983, which is sought to be
annulled by the respondent by way of suit filed in 2004 after a gap of
about twenty years, was also barred by limitation. They also raised a
plea in the written statement that since respondent had admittedly
received consideration of ₹ 4.50 lakhs at the time of execution of the
aforesaid compromise/surrender deed in the year 1993, he was
estopped from seeking its annulment.
11.
It is manifest from a plain reading of the written statement
filed by the petitioners that they had raised some material issues with
respect to the maintainability of the suit and learned Trial Court was
obliged to frame appropriate issues and return a finding on the said
issues in accordance with law.
CM(M) 121/2024
12.
As stated, learned Trial Court dismissed the application
filed by the petitioners for recasting and framing of additional issues
holding that since suit has already suffered a number of transfer
applications, amendments and revision petitions, the long pendency
of the suit is to be given due weightage, and the issues already framed
were sufficient to determine the controversy between the parties.
13.
Benjamin Franklin once remarked —“Great haste makes great
waste.” The Courts, while endeavoring to deliver speedy justice, must
be alive to the controversy between the parties and the issues raised
in the pleadings, and must never deny justice in overzeal to dispose
the cases.
14.
On a coalesce of the precedents rendered by Hon’ble
Supreme Court and various High Courts of the country from time to
time, what would unmistakably emerge is, that civil court has wide
powers to frame issues, recast issues and frame additional issues at
any stage of the proceedings before passing a decree, as may be
necessary for determining the matter in controversy between the
parties.
15.
Mr. Z. A. Shah, the respondent, a practicing advocate of this
Court, as always, has fairly admitted the legal position, but
strenuously argued that the draft issues proposed by the petitioners
are not pure legal issues, but mixed issues of law and fact.
16.
Learned Trial Court framed additional issues in terms of
order dated 08.07.2023 only on the basis of amended plaint filed by
the respondent, but it was incumbent upon the Trial Court to have
framed the additional issues on the basis of amended pleadings of
both the parties. Whether the draft issues are pure legal or mixed
questions of law and fact, can be left to the wisdom of learned Trial
Court.
CM(M) 121/2024
17.
Having regard to what has been analyzed, observed and
discussed above, the impugned order is found erroneous and is liable
to be quashed. Hence, the present petition is allowed and impugned
order dated 06.03.2024 is set aside. As a result, the application filed
by the petitioners for recasting of issues and framing of additional
issues shall stand allowed in part. Learned Trial Court shall frame the
following additional issues:
(i)
Whether
the
present
suit
challenging
Surrender/
Relinquishment deed executed in 1993 and registered in
1994 is time barred?
(ii)
OPD
Whether the lease deed executed in 1983 challenged in the
present suit is time barred? OPD
(iii)
Whether suit is barred by the Doctrine of Estoppel? OPD
(iv)
Whether the sale deed executed and registered by the
deceased father of the petitioners in favour of his divorced
daughter, defendant 3 is invalid? OPP
18.
Learned Trial Court is directed to regulate its procedure in
terms of this order and proceed with the trial of the case, in
accordance with law.
19.
Petition is accordingly disposed of along with the
connected application(s) in the manner indicated above.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
SRINAGAR:
09.09.2026
Hamid”
Abdul Hamid Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this Page 9 of 9
document
❖
Whether Judgment is Speaking?
Yes
❖
Whether Judgment is Reportable?
Yes
CM(M) 121/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review