Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP No.122/2025
Reserved on: 16.04.2026
Pronounced on: 22.04.2026
Uploaded on: 23.04.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced:
Full
Mohd Ashraf Mantoo
S/O Mohd. Ismail Mantoo
Through his mother Shahmala
W/O Mohd Ismail Mantoo
R/O Takiya Maqsood Shah,
Bijbehara, District Anantnag.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Adv. M. Usman Gani.
Vs.
1. Union Territory of J&K through
Principal Secretary to Govt.
Home Department,
J&K Civil Sectt. Srinagar.
2. District Magistrate, Anantnag.
3. Senior Superintendent of Police,
District Anantnag.
4. Superintendent, Central Jail,
Jammu.
…Respondent(s)
Through: GA Ilyas Nazir Laway.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Preventive detention refers to the practice of detaining
individuals without trial, to prevent them from committing
potential offenses. Laws like the ‘Jammu & Kashmir
Public Safety Act’ empower authorities
to
detain
Page |2
individuals based on perceived threats to Public Order or
Security.
2.
Through the medium of the present petition, the petitioner
has challenged Order No. 12/DMA/PSA/DET/2025 dated
26.04.2025 passed by the District Magistrate, Anantnag
(‘Detaining Authority’ for short), whereby he has been
taken into preventive custody with a view to prevent him
from acting in any manner prejudicial to the security of the
State/UT of J&K.
3.
The petitioner seeks quashment of the impugned order of
detention on the grounds that the same has been passed in a
mechanical manner in utter disregard of the constitutional
and statutory safeguards. It has been contended that the
impugned order of detention has been passed without
application of mind and without drawing subjective
satisfaction, simply on the basis of dossier submitted by the
Senior Superintendent of Police, District Anantnag; that the
petitioner has not been informed as regards the period
within which he was entitled to make a representation
against the impugned order of detention to the Detaining
Authority as well as to the Government; that the allegations
leveled against the petitioner in the grounds of detention
are without any basis and that the grounds of detention are
replica of the Police dossier; and that the petitioner has not
been furnished whole of the material forming basis of the
grounds of detention. According to the petitioner, the
Page |3
allegations made in the impugned order of detention are
absolutely false and frivolous and that the same are vague.
4.
Counter affidavit has been filed by the respondent No.2 in
which it has been submitted that all the constitutional and
statutory safeguards have been adhered to by the
respondents while detaining the petitioner; that the whole
of the material forming basis of the grounds of detention
has been furnished to the petitioner. According to the
respondents, the petitioner has been actively involved in
separatist and secessionist ideologies and his involvement
with terrorist networks and narcotic trafficking reveals a
dangerous nexus between terrorism and drug trade. His role
in creating hideouts, providing material support to the
terrorists and facilitating their clandestine movements
poses a direct threat to the national security and public
tranquility. It has also been submitted that the petitioner
has been providing logistic support to the terrorists and he
is also harbouring such elements. It has been submitted that
the petitioner’s constant engagement in terror related
activities have created disturbance, fear and atmosphere of
insecurity in the UT of Jammu and Kashmir.
5.
Thus, according to the respondents, the petitioner poses a
great threat to the safety and security of the State/UT. It has
also been submitted that the Detaining Authority has after
examining
the
dossier
submitted
by
the
Senior
Superintendent of Police, Anantnag, analysed the material
and drawn its subjective satisfaction after due application
Page |4
of mind. It has also been submitted that contents of the
material supplied to the petitioner have been read over and
explained to him in Urdu/Kashmiri languages, which he
fully understands.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the record
and considered the matter.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner during the course of
arguments has restricted his arguments only to three
grounds. Firstly, that the petitioner has not been furnished
whole of the material forming basis of the grounds of
detention which has prevented him from making an
effective representation against the impugned order of
detention; secondly that the grounds of detention is a
replica of the Police dossier which indicates that there has
been non-application of mind on the part of the Detaining
Authority while drawing its subjective satisfaction in the
matter; and thirdly that representation filed on behalf of
detenue was not considered.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondents, ex adverso, argued
that the detenue was involved in two criminal cases
registered vide FIR No.192/2021 under NDPS Act and FIR
No.94/2022 under UAP Act at Police Station Bijbehara and
on being admitted to bail, the detenue was found involved
himself in creation of underground hideout in orchards to
facilitate shelter to terrorists and providing of logistic
support to them; that he indulged in subversive activities
being affiliated with LeT; that he was provided whole of
Page |5
the material relied upon; and that representation filed on
behalf of detenue was considered and rejected by the
Government of which he was informed.
9.
So far as the first ground raised by the learned counsel for
the petitioner is concerned, it appears from the detention
record that the petitioner was provided with detention order
(01 leaf), notice of detention (01 leaf), grounds of detention
(02 leaves), dossier of detention (05 leaves), copies of FIR,
statements of witnesses and other related relevant
documents (27 leaves) total (36 leaves). The receipt
executed by the petitioner clearly indicates that he has
received copies of all the aforesaid documents upon his
detention.
10.
So far as the second contention of learned counsel for the
petitioner is concerned, the same also appears to be without
any substance. A perusal of grounds of detention and their
comparison with the dossier of detention does not lead this
Court to the conclusion that the grounds of detention are
replica of the dossier. Merely because there is reproduction
of the certain factual aspects narrated in the Police dossier
in the grounds of detention, does not necessarily prove
non- application of mind by the Detaining Authority. The
grounds of detention clearly indicate that the Detaining
Authority has applied its mind after noticing the facts
mentioned in the dossier of detention. The Detaining
Authority has noted that the petitioner’s involvement with
terrorist networks and narcotic trafficking divulge a
Page |6
dangerous nexus between terrorism and drug trade. It has
also been noted by the Detaining Authority that the
petitioner is deeply affiliated with the banned terrorist
outfit Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) and he has been providing
material support to the terrorists and facilitating their
clandestine movements. His activities have the potential to
influence vulnerable youth towards radicalization and
insurgency,
thereby
disturbing
the
fragile
security
environment of the UT of J&K. Upon noticing all these
facts, the Detaining Authority has drawn its subjective
satisfaction that in order to uphold the security interests of
the UT of J&K and the Indian State, it is imperative to
detain the petitioner. Thus, it cannot be stated that there has
been any mechanical exercise of power on the part of the
Detaining Authority while passing the impugned order of
detention.
11.
The third contention by the learned co0unsel for the
respondents that representation filed on behalf of detenue
was not considered is concerned, as per record the
representation was considered and rejected by the
Government
as
conveyed
to the detenue through
Superintendent, Central Jail, Jammu vide communication
No.Home/PB-V/156/2025/7643551 dated 10.06.2025.
12.
As such, the impugned detention order was passed by the
detaining authority against the detenue in order to prevent
him from indulging into the activities that are detrimental
to the security of the State, on the grounds that the detenue
Page |7
is an anti-national element and figuring adversely in the
Police records for his involvement in anti-national
activities; that the activities of detenue had emerged a
threat to the Security of State/UT of J&K; that the detenue
has an incorrigible criminal bent of mind which is quite
evident from his conduct over a period of time; that the
detenue facilitated creation of an underground hideout in
orchards to shelter terrorists and provided logistic support
to them; that a case FIR No. 192/2021 U/S 8/15/NDPS Act
and FIR No. 94/2022 U/S 18, 19, 38 UAP Act was
registered against the detenue at P/S Bijbehara; that despite
securing bail in both the cases, the detenue post-release
continues to indulge in anti-national and subversive
activities and remains deeply affiliated with the banned
terrorist outfit ‘LeT’; that the detenue is a staunch follower
and an associate of anti-nationals involved in a series of
criminal activities which have potentially disturbed the
public peace and tranquility; that he is actively involved in
instigating and provoking the gullible youth of the area for
indulging in activities which are prejudicial to the Security
of State/UT of J&K; that the detenue remains persistently
involved with terrorist networks and narcotic trafficking
which reveals a dangerous nexus between terrorism and
drug trade; that the detenue has voluntarily developed
contacts with various secessionist/ nefarious organizations
to carry out the anti- national activities; that the ordinary
law of the land does not seem sufficient to deter the
Page |8
detenue from his nefarious/ anti-national activities; that the
detaining authority found it necessary and imperative to
invoke the relevant provisions of Public Safety Act, 1978
and detain the detenue in order to preclude the detenue
from indulging in activities which would be prejudicial to
the Security of State/UT of J&K.
13.
It would be apposite to say that right of personal liberty is
most precious right, guaranteed under the Constitution. A
person is not to be deprived of his personal liberty, except in
accordance with procedures established under law and the
procedure as laid down in the case ‘Maneka Gandhi vs.
Union of India, (1978 AIR SC 597)’, is to be just and fair.
The personal liberty may be curtailed where a person faces a
criminal charge or is convicted of an offence and sentenced
to imprisonment. Where a person is facing trial on a
criminal charge and is temporarily deprived of his personal
liberty owing to criminal charge framed against him, he has
an opportunity to defend himself and to be acquitted of the
charge in case prosecution fails to bring home his guilt.
Where such person is convicted of offence, he still has
satisfaction of having been given adequate opportunity to
contest the charge and also adduce evidence in his defense.
14.
However, framers of the Constitution have, by incorporating
Article 22(5) in the Constitution, left room for detention of
a person without a formal charge and trial and without such
person being held guilty of an offence and sentenced to
imprisonment by a competent court. Its aim and object are
Page |9
to save society from activities that are likely to deprive a
large number of people of their right to life and personal
liberty. In such a case it would be dangerous, for the people
at large, to wait and watch as by the time ordinary law is set
into motion, the person, having dangerous designs, would
execute his plans, exposing general public to risk and
causing colossal damage to life and property. It is, for that
reason, necessary to take preventive measures and prevent a
person bent upon to perpetrate mischief from translating his
ideas into action. Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India,
therefore, leaves scope for enactment of preventive
detention law.
15.
Those who are responsible for national security or for
maintenance of public order must be the sole judges of
what the national security, public order or security of the
State requires. Preventive detention is devised to afford
protection to society. The object is not to punish a man for
having done something but to intercept before he does it
and to prevent him from doing. Justification for such
detention is suspicion or reasonable probability and not
criminal conviction, which can only be warranted by legal
evidence. Thus, any preventive measures, even if they
involve some restraint or hardship upon individuals, as held
by the Supreme Court in the case ‘Ashok Kumar v. Delhi
Administration & Ors.’ reported as AIR 1982 SC 1143,
do not contribute in any way of the nature of punishment.
P a g e | 10
16.
In the backdrop of foregoing discussion, the petition is
found devoid of any merit and is, accordingly, dismissed.
17.
Scanned detention record, as produced, be returned to
learned counsel for respondents.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
Srinagar
22.04.2026
Muzammil. Q
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review