Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Bail App No. 16/2025
Reserved on 26.12.2025
Pronounced on 31.01.2026
Updated on
31.01.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Mohammad Ashraf Dar
Through: Mr. Asif Wani, Adv.
(through virtual mode)
Vs
.…. Respondent(s)
U. T. of J&K and another
Through: Mr. Pawan Dev Singh, Dy.AG for No. 1
Mr. Aseem Sawhney, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. Khushboo Sharma, Adv. for No. 2
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Through the medium of instant application, the petitioner is seeking bail in
anticipation of arrest in FIR No. 13/2023 dated 11.10.2023 registered with
Police Station, Anti Narcotic Task Force(ANTF), Jammu under sections 8,
15, 25 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act,
1985, 420, 465, 468, 471, 120-B IPC and 52, 182A(4) MV Act.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that on 11.10.2023, Police Station, ANTF
Jammu apprehended a vehicle (mini oil tanker) carrying Poppy Straw
weighing 445 Kilograms, driven by one Jagjeet Singh, R/o Tehsil Phillaur,
District Jalandhar, Punjab. The accused was arrested and disclosed the
names of other persons including Nadeem Ahmad Sofi, resident of Anantnag
Kashmir, Mohammad Yaqoob Bhat from Shopian and Jaswinder Singh from
Punjab. Accused Nadeem Ahmad Sofi also disclosed the names of three
persons including the petitioner herein to be part of the drug trafficking
racket and pursuant to his disclosure, the petitioner is being sought to be
connected with FIR No. 13/2023 (supra).
3.
It is contended that there is absolutely no material with respondent No. 1 to
connect the petitioner with the FIR under reference and the sole basis for
connecting the petitioner with the FIR is a bank transaction reflecting
transfer of an amount of ₹1.00 lac from the account of accused Nadeem
Ahmad Sofi to the account of petitioner. It is stated by the petitioner that
said transaction was made around 36 days before the registration of the FIR
in connection with sale of the vehicle bearing registration No. JK18C 6493
on 09.08.2023.The sale agreement executed between the petitioner and
Mohammad Yaqoob Bhat substantiates the said transaction. It is stated that
pursuant to the disclosure made by Nadeem Ahmad Sofi, the petitioner was
summoned by the then Investigating Officer-Amandeep Singh. The
petitioner, being a law-abiding citizen, immediately joined the investigation
and on the directions of Investigating Officer-Amandeep Singh, submitted
himself to the Investigating Officer at Chenani on Batote Doda highway on
23.06.2024 and thereafter at Ghat No. 23 Makai Park Boulevard Road,
Srinagar on 06.07.2024. The petitioner got disturbed, when the Investigating
Officer demanded a huge amount of money and threatened him with longer
incarceration in jail in case of failure to meet the demand. Threats were also
extended through Nisar Ahmad Bhat and Mohammad Afzal Bhat, both
residents of Marhama Anantnag, Kashmir. The petitioner claims to have
Bail App No. 16/2025
disposed of some of his valuables including his Alto Car, ornaments of his
sister and one cow, to meet the demand of Investigating Officer Amandeep
Singh. He paid an amount of Rs. 8.00 lacs to the above-named persons, sent
by the Investigating Officer. The said persons, however, tried to extort more
money from the petitioner leaving him with no option but to approach Police
Station, Qazigund, Kashmir with a complaint against the Investigating
Officer and two others acting on his behalf. The Police Station, Qazigund
registered FIR against all three persons including Investigating Officer,
Amandeep Singh and recovered the amount of Rs. 8.00 lacs from them. The
Investigating Officer was later admitted to anticipatory bail by the Srinagar
Wing of this Court vide order dated 07.08.2024 read with order dated
11.09.2024.
4.
It is stated by the petitioner that except the alleged false disclosure made by
the accused-Nadeem Ahmad Sofi, there is no other proof to connect the
petitioner with the commission of offence and further the arrest of the
petitioner will bring him under the absolute control of the Investigating
Officer, who is bent upon taking revenge, after the petitioner exposed him
for illegally demanding and extorting money. In such a situation, there is
every likelihood that the investigation of FIR No. 186/2024 registered with
Police Station Qazigund may get hampered. It is also urged that the said
Amandeep Singh Investigating Officer had hired a separate lawyer to oppose
the motion made by the petitioner before the Special Judge (NDPS Cases),
Jammu seeking anticipatory bail, which clearly shows the ulterior motive of
the said Investigating Officer to get the petitioner arrested. It is also
contended that one accused Imtiaz Ahmad Teli, who was sought to be
Bail App No. 16/2025
connected with the FIR on the strength of a bank transaction and phone
connection with another accused from Punjab has already been exonerated
by the respondents for having transacted with the accused in good faith and
the bank transaction to the tune of ₹1.00 lac with Nadeem Ahmed Sofi,
being the only explanation available with the Investigating Agency to
connect the petitioner with the allegations contained in the police report
cannot sustain in view of duly executed agreement entered into between the
petitioner and another accused, on whose behalf Nadeem Ahmad Sofi
transferred the said amount to the petitioner some 36 days before the
registration of the present FIR.
5.
Respondent No. 1 has filed the response stating therein that the petitioner
has been found involved in commission of offence of illegal trafficking of
Poppy Straw measuring 445 Kilograms recovered from the possession of coaccused, as such, the pre-arrest bail sought by the petitioner needs to be
rejected and the investigating agency needs to be given free hand to
interrogate the petitioner to trace the backward and forward linkages and
also for identifying the illegally acquired property with the proceeds of the
unlawfully transported contraband. It is further stated that 445 kilograms of
Poppy Straw was seized/recovered from mini oil tanker bearing registration
No. UP16DT1460 driven by Jagjit Singh S/o. Balbir Sing R/o Sangowal,
Punjab, who was found to be part of the bigger nexus, in which petitioner
has been found to be actively involved. During investigation, accused Jagjit
Singh revealed the names of Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat S/o Mohd. Abdullah Beigh
R/o Keegam A/P Hergan Shopian and Nadeem Ahmed Sofi S/o Gull Mohd.
Sofi R/o Marhama, Bijbehara Anantnag as smugglers/suppliers, who have
Bail App No. 16/2025
indulged in smuggling of seized Poppy Straw from Kashmir to Punjab, to be
handed over to Jaswinder Singh S/o Surat Singh R/o Village Jhande Kllian
Mansa, Punjab, receiver of seized narcotic consignment in the instant case. It
is further stated that during investigation, the vehicle Mini Oil Tanker
bearing registration No. UP16DT 1460 seized in the instant case was
verified through the concerned RTO UP, Noida and it came to the fore that
the said vehicle was registered in the name of Jagveer S/o. Kripal Singh R/o
Village Rohi, Goutam Buddha Nagar UP and is a goods carrier with open
body
having
chasis
No.
MAT455042F8J21901
and
engine
No.
497SP67JUY630499 colour G-Brown and as per mechanical inspection
conducted
by
the
RTO
Office
Jammu,
engine
number
is
497SPTC39JYY645931 and as per Vahan Portal, the said vehicle is SFC
407 TATA Truck having registration No. JK06 4461 having original chasis
No. MAT455026B8J38391 registered in the name of Maturi Begum W/o.
Abdul Majeed Lone R/o. Baja Charala Tehsil Thathri District Doda. She, in
her statement, has stated that the said vehicle has already been sold by her.
Further it was found that the vehicle was sold multiple times i.e. from one
person to another and Nadeem Ahmed Sofi was the last person who
purchased the vehicle SFC 407 TATA Truck having registration No. JK06
4461 and the said vehicle was later on altered and was converted into a Mini
Oil
Tanker
with
a
cavity
made
under
the
oil
container
for
concealing/smuggling and transportation of narcotic substances from
Kashmir to Punjab. The chasis number was also erased and tampered. JK06
4461 number plate was also changed/replaced with No. UP16DT 1460 and a
forged registration certificate of the vehicle was prepared to dodge the
Bail App No. 16/2025
agencies to avoid the risk of being caught. Hence offences under sections
420, 465, 468, 471, 120-B IPC and 52 and 182-A (4) MV Act were also
established in the said case. After the completion of the investigation, the
preliminary charge-sheet was presented against Driver Jagjit Singh in the
court of Principal Sessions Judge, Jammu on 04.04.2024.
6.
During further investigation, on 17.05.2024, accused Nadeem Ahmed Sofi
S/o Gull Mohd. Sofi R/o. Marhama Bijbehera Anantnag was arrested, who
revealed the names of three more persons as his co-partners, namely, Mohd.
Yaqoob Bhat of Wachii, Shopian, Bilal Ahmed Bhat and Mohd. Ashraf Dar,
petitioner herein both of Okey Kulgam, who were also involved in the
commission of crime. They all with common criminal intention hatched
conspiracy to smuggle 445 kilograms of seized Poppy Straw from Kashmir
Valley to Punjab. On analysis of CDRs, it came to fore that all the abovementioned persons were interconnected with each other frequently during
the commission of crime and on analysis of bank account statements of all
the above said persons, it came to fore that ₹50,000/- has been credited into
the personal account No 078301010000022 of Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat from
account No. 0487020100000328 of Rehan Garments on 19.08.2023 and
₹1.00 lac has been credited into the personal account of Mohd. Ashraf Dar,
petitioner herein from the account of Rehaan Garments on 05.09.2023 by
Nadeem Ahmed Sofi, as a part of their share which was credited into his
account from Punjab, as an advance money for smuggling of illegal
consignment by accused Jaswinder Singh through online transaction. Hence,
offences under sections 8, 15 and 29 of the NDPS Act were established
against both the accused. Notices under sections 67 of the NDPS Act were
Bail App No. 16/2025
sent to Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat and Mohd. Ashraf Dar repeatedly but they
deliberately avoided their presence and evaded their arrest. As such, arrest
warrant under section 25 of the Police Act from City Judge, JMIC Jammu
was obtained against Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat and Mohd. Ashraf Dar, petitioner
herein. Further, on 13.07.2024, Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat S/o Ghulam Ahmed
Bhat R/o Wacchi, Shopian was arrested from Udhampur. The supplementary
charge-sheet No. 01 was presented against other co-accused namely,
Nadeem Ahmed Sofi and Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat in Special NDPS Court
Jammu on 30.12.2024. The supplementary investigation was kept open and
continued as further investigation under section 173(8) Cr.P.C. The
supplementary charge sheet shall be produced in the court of law after the
arrest of absconding accused persons, namely, Mohd. Yaqoob Beigh, Mohd
Ashraf Dar, petitioner herein and Jaswinder Singh.
7.
It is also stated that during investigation, the then Investigating Officer
Amandeep Singh received notice under section 35(3) BNSS sent through
wireless from SHO, Police Station, Qazigund to Police Station, ANTF,
Jammu. In this regard, the then Investigating Officer was relieved vide GDR
No. 6 dated 25.07.2024 to appear before the SHO Police Station, Qazigund
and the investigation in FIR No. 13/2023 was entrusted to Inspector Annayat
Ali for further investigation of the case.
8.
In the status report, it is stated that the FIR No. 186/2024 of Police Station
Qazigund is under investigation and the same has been registered at the
behest of Mohd. Ashraf Dar, petitioner herein just to downplay the
investigation in the present case (FIR No. 13/2023), whereas on the basis of
cogent evidence, the petitioner was summoned, but he has been avoiding his
Bail App No. 16/2025
arrest and not cooperating with the Investigating Agency. As per section 37
of the NDPS Act, there is no scope for bail when the accused is involved in
smuggling of commercial quantity of Poppy Straw.
9.
Respondent No. 2, earlier Investigating Officer, Amandeep Singh in the FIR
No. 13/2023(supra), was arrayed as respondent vide order dated 15.04.2025,
has also filed the response and opposed the present bail application.
10.
Mr. Asif Wani, learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that
there is absolutely no evidence to connect the petitioner with the commission
of crime. He has stated that the sole basis made by respondent No. 1 to
implicate the petitioner in the commission of crime is the bank transaction of
₹1.00 lac, which Nadeem Ahmed Sofi transferred on account of sale
agreement entered into between the petitioner and Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat with
regard to sale of vehicle bearing registration No. JK18C 6493 on
09.08.2023. He has further submitted that the petitioner has been implicated
as accused by respondent No. 2 only to extract the money, which is duly
substantiated by FIR No. 186/2024 registered with Police Station, Qazigund.
He has placed much reliance upon the Police Report submitted in FIR No.
186/2024. He has further relied upon the judgment of the Delhi High Court
in case, titled, Rahish Nadiar Ali Shah vs. Narcotics Control Bureau,
decided on 08.07.2025 and Joy Mitra v. Narcotics Control Bureau, 2025
SCC OnLine Del 3016.
11.
Per contra, Mr. Pawan Dev Singh, learned Dy.AG representing respondent
No. 1 has vehemently argued that the petitioner is a part of a drug syndicate
involved in illegal trafficking of drugs and narcotics and there is cogent
evidence in respect of transfer of ₹1.00 lac from the account of co-accused,
Bail App No. 16/2025
namely, Nadeem Ahmed Sofi and further that the agreement relied upon by
the petitioner has been executed between him and Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat and
the amount has not been transferred by Mohd Yaqoob Bhat in the account of
the petitioner in respect of a sale of a vehicle. Rather this amount was
transferred by Nadeem Ahmed Sofi as a share of the advance money
received by him for smuggling of 445 kilograms of Poppy Straw from
Kashmir to Punjab. He has further submitted that the investigation is being
conducted by the new Investigating Officer, Inspector Annayat Ali and as
such, any apprehension of false implication of the petitioner is misconceived
and meaningless. He has further submitted that assuming the allegations
against the Investigating Officer, Amandeep Singh, respondent No. 2 herein
in respect of demand of money are true, still even before the alleged demand
was made by Amandeep and his associates, there was ample evidence on
record against the petitioner.
12.
Mr. Aseem Sawhney, learned Senior Counsel appearing for respondent No.
2 has submitted that huge quantity of contraband is involved and rigors of
section 37 of the NDPS Act are applicable in the instant case, therefore, the
petitioner is not entitled to even regular bail what to say of bail in
anticipation of arrest. He has also relied upon the order dated 07.07.2025 of
the Apex Court in Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. 9540/2025, titled,
Dinesh Chander v State of Haryana to assert that anticipatory bail cannot
be granted in NDPS cases.
13.
Heard and perused the record including the CD file.
Bail App No. 16/2025
14.
Before the Court proceeds further, it is pertinent to observe that Section 37
of the NDPS Act is applicable in the instant case, as the quantity of
contraband recovered falls within the category of commercial quantity.
15.
According to the prosecution, the petitioner is linked to a drug syndicate
comprising Nadeem Ahmad Sofi and Mohd Yaqoob Bhat. The petitioner
does not dispute the receipt of ₹1.00 lac from Sofi; however, he projects a
defense that the amount was a legitimate payment for the sale of a vehicle to
Mohd Yaqoob Bhat, despite the funds being transferred from Sofi’s account
instead of Bhat’s.
16.
Admittedly, Nadeem Ahmed Sofi was not a party to the sale agreement
dated 09.08.2023. Whether the sum was transferred by Nadeem Ahmed Sofi
to the petitioner at the behest of Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat remains a matter for
investigation and trial. However, at this stage, given that Nadeem Ahmed
Sofi (who transferred ₹1.00 lac) is an arrayed accused and the funds did not
originate from Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat, the balance of probability tilts in favour
of the prosecution's theory that the money constituted advance payment
received by Sofi from contraband receivers in Punjab. Notably, the
purported vehicle purchaser is also a co-accused.
17.
The Case Diary (CD) reveals that on 18.05.2024, Nadeem Ahmed Sofi
disclosed the conspiracy, implicating both Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat and the
petitioner, Mohd. Ashraf Dar. Following Mohd. Yaqoob Bhat’s arrest on
13.07.2024, Charge-sheet No. 1 was filed on 30.12.2024.
18.
Insofar as the petitioner is concerned, notices under Section 67 of the NDPS
Act were served through SHO P/S Kulgam for his appearance on 08.06.2024
and 10.07.2024. The Case Diary entries dated 30.05.2024 and 29.06.2024
Bail App No. 16/2025
substantiate these facts. Upon the petitioner’s failure to appear, warrants
were obtained from the City Judge (JMIC), Jammu, on 11.07.2024 under
Section 25 of the Police Act.
19.
Consequently, as on 18.05.2024, the Investigating Officer was in possession
of sufficient material to link the petitioner to drug trafficking activities. The
petitioner, however, has sought to raise a defense alleging that the thenInvestigating Officer (Respondent No. 2) had made demand for money. In
relation to this, FIR No. 186/2024 was registered at Police Station Qazigund
under Sections 61(2) and 308(7) of the BNS.
20.
As per the Police Report in that matter, a sum of ₹8.00 lacs was recovered
from Mohd. Afzal and Nissar Ahmed Sofi and their interrogation reportedly
established the allegations against Respondent No. 2, Amandeep Singh.
Notably, FIR No. 186/2024 was registered on 09.07.2024. In the status
report pertaining to said FIR, the petitioner has admitted receipt of a notice
from ANTF Jammu (served through P/S Kulgam), directing his appearance.
This confirms that the petitioner was aware of the proceedings against him
prior to raising the allegations against the officer.
21.
The petitioner’s contention that Respondent No. 2 demanded a bribe for his
exoneration, relates to an alleged act occurring subsequent to 18.05.2024,
the date on which the petitioner’s involvement in the drug trafficking
syndicate first surfaced. While the allegations against Respondent No. 2 are
subject to the outcome of the investigation in FIR No. 186/2024, they do not,
at this stage, negate the petitioner’s status as a co-accused in FIR No.
13/2023.
Bail App No. 16/2025
22.
It remains an independent fact that the petitioner is implicated in grave
offenses under Sections 8, 15, 25, and 29 of the NDPS Act, in addition to
charges of forgery and conspiracy under the IPC and violations of the Motor
Vehicles Act. Therefore, the investigation into the conduct of the
Investigating Officer does not automatically wash away the material against
the petitioner.
23.
The petitioner cannot claim the benefit of the FIR registered against the
previous Investigating Officer to seek anticipatory bail in the present case.
The allegations in FIR No. 13/2023 are of a grave nature, involving the
smuggling of 445 kilograms of Poppy Straw from the UT of Jammu &
Kashmir to Punjab, alongside the use of a vehicle with a tampered number
plate.
24.
Furthermore, a documented money trail exists, which necessitates a
thorough investigation. At this stage, it cannot be held that the allegations
against the petitioner are false, frivolous, or that no offense is made out.
While the petitioner acknowledges receiving ₹1.00 lac from co-accused
Nadeem Ahmed Sofi, his defense regarding a 'sale agreement' is a matter for
trial, especially since the purported purchaser is also an accused in the same
conspiracy.
25.
Given that the contraband recovered is of commercial quantity, the rigors of
Section 37 of the NDPS Act are fully attracted. This Court finds no
reasonable grounds to believe that the petitioner is not guilty of the offences
under the NDPS Act. Consequently, the plea for anticipatory bail is devoid
of merit.
Bail App No. 16/2025
26.
The legal precedents relied upon by the petitioner are distinguishable on
both facts as well as in law. The judgment in Rahish Nadiaar Ali Shah’s
case (supra) is inapplicable to the present case, as the said matter pertained
to an application for regular bail after he remained in custody for two years
and 10 months, whereas the petitioner herein has sought anticipatory bail.
27.
Similarly, the decision of the Delhi High Court in Joy Mitra vs. Narcotics
Control Bureau does not aid the petitioner. In that case, the prosecution had
failed to place on record any material, such as financial trails or electronic
communications, to link the applicants to the recovery. Conversely, in the
instant case, a clear financial link has been established through the transfer
of ₹1.00 lac from a co-accused to the petitioner, a fact, which directly
connects him to the alleged syndicate and clearly distinguishes this matter
from the cited authority.
28.
For all that has been stated, discussed and analyzed hereinabove, this Court
is of the considered view that the petitioner has miserably failed to make out
a case for grant of bail in anticipation of arrest. Accordingly, the instant
petition is found to be bereft of any merit, the same is dismissed.
29.
CD file has been handed over to the learned counsel for respondent No. 1 in
the open court.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
JAMMU
31.01.2026
Rakesh PS
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
KARAM CHAND
2026.01.31 14:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Bail App No. 16/2025
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review