Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
Reserved On: 3rd of September, 2026.
Pronounced On: 22nd of September, 2026.
Uploaded On: 22nd of September, 2026.
Whether the operative part or
full Judgment is pronounced:
Full.
Mohammad Amin Rather, (50 Years)
S/O Ghulam Hassan Rather
R/O Bonigam, District Kulgam,
Kashmir.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Shuja-ul-Haq Tantray, Advocate.
V/S
1. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir,
Through Financial Commissioner,
(Additional Chief Secretary),
Home Department, J&K,
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar/ Jammu.
2. Director General of Police,
Srinagar, Kashmir.
3. Additional Director General of Police,
(Security), Srinagar, Kashmir.
4. Sr. Superintendent of Police,
(Security), Srinagar, Kashmir.
… Respondents
Through: Ms Maha Majeed, Assisting Counsel vice
Mr Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri, Sr. AAG.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE.
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The Petitioner, through the medium of the instant Writ Petition
filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, is aggrieved of and has
challenged Order No. 312 of 2023 dated 21 st of December, 2023 issued by
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
the Senior Superintendent of Police (Security), Kashmir/ Respondent No.4
herein, whereby Petitioner’s services as SPO were disengaged from the
rolls of the Security Kashmir with immediate effect and he was further
directed to deposit all Government articles issued to him, from time to time,
in the Stores of Security Kashmir.
02.
The Petitioner claims to have been engaged as SPO in the
Respondent-Department in the year 2004; that, thereafter, a process was
initiated by the Respondents in the year 2007 for conversion of SPOs as
Constables on compassionate grounds, wherein the Petitioner along with
other five SPOs was not considered for their conversion as Constables
despite recommendations having been made by the competent authority,
constraining the Petitioner along with aforesaid five SPOs to file SWP No.
1218/2011 before this Court; that the said SWP No. 1218/2011, vide
Judgment dated 23rd of February, 2012, came to be disposed of by this
Court on the analogy of SWP No. 1563/2009 by directing the Respondents
to treat the Petitioners at par with the private Respondents therein and
consider their case for appointment and absorption in the Police
Organization as Constable Drivers, with all consequential benefits,
including seniority within a period of three months from the date private
Respondents were appointed.
03.
Aggrieved of the Judgment dated 23rd of February, 2012, the
Respondents assailed the same by way of LPA No. 190/2012 which,
however, came to be dismissed by the Division Bench on 19 th of
September, 2013; that, thereafter, while facing Contempt proceedings
having been initiated by the Petitioner along with other SPOs, the
Respondents issued Government Order No. 155-Home of 2022 dated 24th of
May, 2022, whereby ten (10) SPOs, including the Petitioner herein, came to
be absorbed/ appointed as Constables with effect from the dates shown
against the names of each of them.
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
04.
The Petitioner further proceeds to state in his Petition that, on
perusal of Government Order dated 24th of May, 2022, the Petitioner claims
to have come across the fact that his date of birth has been wrongly
reflected as 4th of March, 1981 instead of 1st of January, 1973, as such, he
approached the Respondents and sought correction of his date of birth,
whereafter, various inter se communications were issued by the
Respondents on the subject; that, in terms of communication dated 26 th of
December, 2022, the AIG of Police (Personnel) in the office of Director
General of Police, J&K, while enclosing a copy of communication dated
12th of December, 2022 of ZPHQ, Kashmir Zone, along with its enclosures,
including copy of DOB certificate and genuineness report of DOB received
from JK BOSE, requested the Respondent No.1 herein that necessary
rectification in DOB of the Applicant/ Petitioner herein as 1 st of January,
1973 instead of 4th of March, 1981 in the above Government Order dated
24th of May, 2022 may kindly be made, so that formal appointment order of
the subject could be got issued by the concerned quarters.
05.
It is further pleaded by the Petitioner that, when despite the
aforesaid inter se communication(s), the date of birth of the Petitioner was
not rectified and formal appointment order was not issued in his favour, the
Petitioner moved a representation before the Respondents for rectifying the
error with regard to the date of birth of the Petitioner in Government Order
dated 24th of May, 2022, vide which the Petitioner, along with other
similarly situated SPOs were appointed/ absorbed as Constables in the
Respondent-Department; and that, instead of considering the representation
of the Petitioner with reference to recording his date of birth in the
Government Order dated 24th of May, 2022, the Respondents, in terms of
the impugned Order, disengaged the services of the Petitioner from the rolls
of the Security Kashmir, with immediate effect.
06.
Upon notice having been issued, the Respondents have filed
their Reply/ Objections, inter alia, stating therein that the Petitioner has
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
willfully produced fake and fabricated documents to suppress his actual age
with an ill-design to manage his engagement as SPO in the Security
Kashmir, deceitfully, on the basis of fabricated documents; that, on the
basis of authenticated records, the actual date of birth of the Petitioner was
found as 1st of January, 1973 instead of 4th of March, 1981, thereby
substantiating the fact that his age was 32 years, 10 months and 02 days at
the time of his engagement as SPO and, therefore, was not meeting the
eligibility criteria of age laid down by PHQ/ Security Headquarters for
engagement of SPO; that, having regard to this factum of deceitfully
fabricating his age, the Petitioner was later disengaged by the SSP Security
Kashmir vide Order dated 21st of December, 2023.
07.
Heard and considered.
08.
Admittedly, the Petitioner was engaged as SPO in Respondent-
Department in the year 2004, whereafter, he came to be absorbed/
appointed as Constable in the year 2022. Subsequently, the Respondents,
vide the impugned Order, disengaged the services of the Petitioner from the
rolls of Security Kashmir with immediate effect, on the ground that that he
has willfully produced a fake and fabricated document to suppress his
actual age with an ill-design to manage engagement as SPO Driver in
Security Kashmir, deceitfully, on the basis of a fabricated document.
09.
From a plain reading of the Order impugned, it is clearly
discernible that the Respondents, while disengaging the services of the
Petitioner, have not referred to any notice having been issued to the
Petitioner or any inquiry having been conducted by them on the subject
before proceeding to inflict the heavy punishment of dismissal from service
upon the Petitioner. Even, from the perusal of the relevant record made
available before this Court by the Respondents, there is nothing
forthcoming as to fact that the Respondents have issued any prior notice to
the Petitioner or conducted any enquiry before disengaging the services of
the Petitioner.
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
10.
Given the above factual position, let us now appreciate the law
on the subject.
11.
It has been consistently held by the constitutional Courts that if
an employee is sought to be disengaged on whatever ground(s), he is at
least entitled to a show cause notice, if not to be subjected to an enquiry
under the Rules governing the subject. The issuance of a show cause notice,
before issuing an order which is prejudicial to the rights and interests of an
employee, is based upon the sound legal doctrine of ‘Audi Alteram Partem’,
which doctrine, inter-alia, provides that no person should be condemned
unheard, in that, the right to hear would mean that party must know the
cause he or she has to meet and must have a reasonable opportunity to
present his or her case and the said requirement of issuance of show cause
notice as also affording an opportunity of hearing has been held to be
flowing directly from the said doctrine of ‘Audi Alteram Partem’.
12.
In this regard, a reference can be made to the Judgment passed
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in a case titled “Canara Bank & Ors. V.
Debasis Das & Ors., (2003) 4 SCC 557”. Paragraphs No. 13 and 15, being
relevant, are extracted as under:
“13. Natural justice is another name for commonsense
justice. Rules of natural justice are not codified canons. But they are
principles ingrained into the conscience of man. Natural justice is the
administration of justice in a common-sense liberal way. Justice is
based substantially on natural ideals and human values. The
administration of justice is to be freed from the narrow and restricted
considerations which are usually associated with a formulated law
involving linguistic technicalities and grammatical niceties. It is the
substance of justice which has to determine its form.
15. The adherence to principles of natural justice as
recognized by all civilized States is of supreme importance when a
quasi-judicial body embarks on determining disputes between the
parties, or any administrative action involving civil consequences is
in issue. These principles are well settled. The first and foremost
principle is what is commonly known as audi alteram partem rule. It
says that no one should be condemned unheard. Notice is the first
limb of this principle. It must be precise and unambiguous. It should
apprise the party determinatively of the case he has to meet. Time
given for the purpose should be adequate so as to enable him to
make his representation. In the absence of a notice of the kind and
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
such reasonable opportunity, the order passed becomes wholly
vitiated. Thus, it is but essential that a party should be put on notice
of the case before any adverse order is passed against him. This is
one of the most important principles of natural justice. It is after all
an approved rule of fair play. The concept has gained significance
and shades with time. When the historic document was made at
Runnymede in 1215, the first statutory recognition of this principle
found its way into the “Magna Carta”. The classic exposition of Sir
Edward Coke of natural justice requires to “vocate, interrogate and
adjudicate”.
13.
In
“Dharampal
Satampal
Limited
V.
Deputy
Commissioner of Central Excise & Ors., 2015 (8) SCC 519”, the
Hon’ble Apex Court, at Paragraph Nos. 21, 24, and 28, has held as under:
“21. In common Law, the concept and doctrine of natural
justice, particularly which is made applicable in the decision-making
by judicial and quasi-judicial bodies, has assumed a different
connotation. It is developed with this fundamental in mind that those
whose duty is to decide, must act judicially. They must deal with the
question referred both without bias and they must give (sic an
opportunity) to each of the parties to adequately present the case
made. It is perceived that the practice of aforesaid attributes in mind
only would lead to doing justice. Since these attributes are treated as
natural or fundamental, it is known as “natural justice”. The
principles of natural justice developed over a period of time and
which is still in vogue and valid even today are: (i) rule against bias
i.e. nemo debet esse judex in propria sua causa; and (ii) opportunity
of being heard to the party concerned i.e. audi alteram partem.
These are known as principles of natural justice. To these principles
a third principle is added, which is of recent origin. It is the duty to
give reasons in support of decision, namely, passing of a “reasoned
order”.
24. The principles have a sound jurisprudential basis. Since
the function of the judicial and quasi-judicial authorities is to secure
justice with fairness, these principles provide a great humanizing
factor intended to invest law with fairness to secure justice and to
prevent miscarriage of justice. The principles are extended even to
those who have to take an administrative decision and who are not
necessarily discharging judicial or quasi-judicial functions. They are
a kind of code of fair administrative procedure. In this context,
procedure is not a matter of secondary importance as it is only by
procedural fairness shown in the decision-making that a decision
becomes acceptable. In its proper sense, thus, natural justice would
mean the natural sense of what is right and wrong.
28. It is on the aforesaid jurisprudential premise that the
fundamental principles of natural justice, including audi alteram
partem, have developed. It is for this reason that the courts have
consistently insisted that such procedural fairness has to be adhered
to before a decision is made and infraction thereof has led to the
quashing of decisions taken. In many statutes, provisions are made
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
ensuring that a notice is given to a person against whom an order is
likely to be passed before a decision is made, but there may be
instances where though an authority is vested with the powers to
pass such orders, which affect the liberty or property of an individual
but the statute may not contain a provision for prior hearing. But
what is important to be noted is that the applicability of principles of
natural justice is not dependent upon any statutory provision. The
principle has to be mandatorily applied irrespective of the fact as to
whether there is any such statutory provision or not.”
14.
Again, the Apex Court, in “Pawan Kumar V. Union of India,
(2023) 12 SCC 317”, while relying upon its earlier Judgment passed in
“Avtar Singh V. Union of India, (2016) 8 SCC 471”, has held that mere
suppression of material information or furnishing of false information in a
given case does not mean that the employer can arbitrarily discharge/
terminate an employee.
15.
Similar views were taken by three different Division Benches
of this Court in: (i) Letters Patent Appeal (LPA) titled “Sharaz Hussain
Shah V. State of J&K and Ors., 2024 (2) JKJ 38 [HC]”; (ii) WP (C) No.
289/2025 titled “Union Territory of J&K and Ors. V. Arsam Imtiyaz
Malik” in its Judgment dated 17th of February, 2025 (authored by me); and
(iii) LPA No. 152/2025 titled “UT of J&K and Ors. v. Shaheen Shah”
vide Judgment dated 6th of August, 2025.
16.
Recently, a Division Bench of this Court headed by the Lord
Chief Justice, in “LPA No. 90/2026 titled Union Territory of J&K and
Ors. v. Mushtaq Ahmad Shah”, reported as 2026:JKLHC-SGR:320-DB,
in identical facts, as are in the present case, while concurring with the
Judgments passed by this Court in “State of J&K and Ors. V.
Mohammad Iqbal Mallah, 2014 SCC OnLine J&K 58”; and “UT of
J&K and Ors. v. Shahen Shah (LPA No. 152/2025 decided on 6 th of
August, 2025)”, held that in these cases Sections 18 and 19 of the Police
Act, 1983 and Article 311 of the Constitution of India will not operate and
that only the immediate safeguard of a notice and a reply to the satisfaction
of the Respondent therein shall operate. It has been further held that it shall
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
be the requirement that wherever a stigma or allegation has resulted into
such disengagement of the SPOs, they shall be entitled to a notice prior to
the disengagement and after such notice is given and reasonable
opportunity for filing reply or hearing is given, the authority shall be free to
pass appropriate orders. It has been further laid down that where the
services of an SPO are terminated or disengaged on account of any
misconduct, then the opportunity of hearing shall be a minimum
requirement and doctrine of audi alteram partem has to be followed.
17.
Applying the aforesaid exposition of law to the facts of the
case on hand, admittedly, no show cause notice (SCN) or enquiry was held
in the case of the Petitioner, before passing the impugned Order to remove
him from the rolls of SPOs of Security Kashmir, for furnishing alleged fake
documents of his DOB. The Respondents have, thus, proceeded against the
Petitioner raising stigmatic accusation, for which he was required to be
heard in his defence. Therefore, the irrefutable conclusion that could be
drawn is that the Respondents indeed have violated the basic fundamental
principle of natural justice, while ordering disengagement of the services of
the Petitioner as SPO, thereby condemning him unheard. The Petitioner was
entitled to be afforded an opportunity of hearing before inflicting the major
punishment of disengagement of service from the Respondent-Department.
Therefore, the Order impugned having been passed in direct conflict with
the rules of natural justice, if allowed to stand, would compound gross
injustice against the Petitioner.
18.
Viewed thus, the instant Petition is allowed and, as a corollary
thereto, by issuance of a ‘Writ of Certiorari’, the impugned Order No. 312
of 2023 dated 21st of December, 2023 issued by the Respondent No.4 is
hereby quashed. The Respondents, by a ‘Writ of Mandamus’, are directed to
reinstate the Petitioner back into service with all consequential benefits,
excluding the payment of emoluments for the period with effect from the
date of his disengagement till the date of restoration of his services.
WP (C) No. 186/2024
CM No. 341/2024
However, the Respondents shall be at liberty to revisit and re-consider the
case of the Petitioner with reference to the alleged production of fake DoB
certificate, after following due process of law and providing him adequate
opportunity of hearing as per Rules.
19.
Record, as produced, be returned to the Respondents through
their Counsel, against proper receipt.
20.
Writ Petition is, thus, disposed of as allowed on the above
terms, along with the connected CM.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
September 22nd, 2026
“TAHIR”
i.
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Whether the Judgment is approved for reporting?
Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review