Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP(C) 2308/2026
CM(6291/2026)
Reserved on: 18th September, 2026.
Pronounced on: 22nd September,2026
Uploaded on: 24th September,2026
Whether Operative Part or Full
Judgment has been pronounced: Full
1. Mohammad Akbar Bhat Age: 76 years.
…Petitioner(s)
2. Abdul Salam Bhat, Age:66 years
3. Ghulam Hassan Bhat, Age:64 years,
Sons of Ghulam Rasool Bhat
4. Lassa Mohammad Wani, Age:71 years
Son of Subhan Wani
5. Abdul Rashid Wani, Age:53 years
Son of Abdul Khaliq Wani
6. Mst. Zaina, Age:70 years
7. Mst. Fatima, Age:60 years
Daughters of Abdul Aziz Wani;
8. Mst Fatima, Age: 62 years,
Wife of late Ghulam Hassan Wani.
All Residents of Village Utressoo, Tehsil
Shangus, District Anantnag.
Through:
Mr. M. Saleem Parray, Advocate.
Vs.
1.
Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir,
through Commissioner/Secretary, to
Government, Revenue Department, Civil
Secretariat, J&K.
2.
Additional
Deputy
Commissioner,
Anantnag, exercising the powers of
Commissioner
Agrarian
Reforms,
Anantnag.
3.
Tehsildar (Agrarian Reforms) Shangus,
District Anantnag.
...Respondent(s)
WP(C) 2308/2026
4.
Mohammad Maqbool Bhat.
5.
Bashir Ahmad Bhat.
6.
Abdul Hamid Bhat.
Sons of Ali Mohammad Bhat.
7.
Nisar Ahmad Bhat.
8.
Manzoor Ahmad Bhat.
Sons of Abdul Aziz Bhat.
All Residents of Village Utressoo, Tehsil
Shangus, District Anantnag.
Through:
CORAM:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal, Judge.
JUDGMENT
PRAYER:
01.
Through the medium of the instant petition filed
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioners
have sought quashment of Order dated 28.09.2023 passed
by the respondent No. 2-Additional Deputy Commissioner
(exercising the powers of Commissioner Agrarian Reforms),
Anantnag, whereby the application filed by the petitioners
seeking
condonation
of
delay,
was
rejected,
and
consequently the appeal so preferred by the petitioners, was
also dismissed as being barred by time and also the order
dated 15.01.2026 by virtue of which the review petition filed
by the petitioners was also dismissed being devoid of any
merit. For facility of reference, the reliefs sought by the
petitioners are reproduced below:
a.
Issue a Writ of Certiorari quashing
order dated 28.09.2023 passed by
respondent
No.
2,
whereby
petitioners
application
the
seeking
condonation of delay was rejected
WP(C) 2308/2026
and
their
statutory
appeal
was
consequentially dismissed as timebarred, together with consequential
interference
with
order
dated
15.01.2026 to the extent necessary
to give effect to the relief granted;
b.
Issue a Writ of Mandamus directing
respondent No. 2 to restore the
application seeking condonation of
delay and the accompanying appeal
to their original numbers; permit the
parties
to
place
supplementary
affidavits and supporting documents
on record; call for and examine the
material
concerning
knowledge,
notice, participation, possession and
the endorsement recording stay of
Mutation
No.
1888;
decide
the
condonation application afresh by a
reasoned order; and, if delay is
condoned,
decide
the
appeal
on
merits in accordance with law;
c.
In the alternative, if this Hon'ble
Court
finds
sufficient
cause
established from the admitted or
proved material, condone the delay
and direct respondent No. 2 to decide
the
statutory
appeal
on
merits,
confined to the petitioners' claimed
portions measuring 3 Kanals under
Khasra No. 336 and 4 Kanals under
Khasra
No.
339,
aggregating
Kanals, within a stipulated period
and
after
hearing
all
affected
parties;
WP(C) 2308/2026
d.
Call for the complete original records
relating to Mutation No. 1657 under
Section 4, Mutation No. 1888 under
Section
8,
the
proceeding
and
interim
order
underlying
the
endorsement
including
dated
the
18.04.1987,
order/
reference
described in the endorsement as No.
113-87, or such other correct number
as may be disclosed by the original
record; and, if any record is stated to
be unavailable, direct the competent
record custodian to file an affidavit
specifying the searches undertaken,
circumstances
destruction
of
and
its
loss
or
availability
of
duplicate or reconstructable records;
and
e.
Any other Writ, order or direction as
the Hon'ble court deems fit and
proper in the circumstances of the
case be passed in favour of the
Petitioners
and
against
the
respondents.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE:
02.
The controversy in hand pertains to land measuring
4 Kanals and 16 Marlas under Khasra No. 336; and 7 Kanals
and 11 Marlas under Khasra No. 339, situated at Village
Utressoo Tehsil Shangus, District Anantnag. Out of Khasra
No. 336, the petitioners’ predecessors held 3 Kanals in
tenancy and cultivating possession, whereas the respondents'
predecessors held the remaining 1 Kanal and 16 Marlas out
of the said survey number; similarly, out of Khasra No. 339,
the petitioners’ predecessors held 4 Kanals, whereas the
WP(C) 2308/2026
respondents’ predecessors held the remaining 3 Kanals and
11 Marlas.
03.
The petitioners claim cultivating tenancy rights
through their predecessors-in-interest over the aforesaid 7
Kanals out of the aforesaid survey numbers, while the
predecessors of the private respondents held the rest of the
land in both Khasra numbers.
04.
The cultivating possession of predecessors of both
the parties over their respective shares was recorded in the
Kharif 1971 Khasra Girdawari and affirmed under Section 4
of the J&K Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976 via Mutation No. 1657
attested on 25.04.1981.
05.
On 11.10.1986, Mutation No. 1888 was attested
under Section 8 of the Act, which conferred the proprietary
rights
exclusively
upon
the
predecessors
of
private
respondents to the extent of 1 kanal 11 marlas under Khasra
No. 336 and 3 Kanals 11 Marlas under Khasra No. 339,
corresponding to the portions separately recognized in their
cultivating possession under the foundational Section 4
determination.
The
petitioners
do
not
challenge
the
conferment made in favour of the private respondents’
predecessors insofar as it remains confined to those
separately recognized portions but left the petitioners’
predecessors' 7 Kanals completely omitted without any
recorded order of resumption, surrender, or spot inquiry.
06.
A subsequent endorsement dated 18.04.1987 on
Mutation No. 1888 recorded an interim stay of the mutation
granted by the Joint Agrarian Reforms Commissioner,
Kashmir.
The
petitioners
claim
they
remained
in
uninterrupted, continuous physical cultivating possession on
WP(C) 2308/2026
the ground of having no notice of the adverse Section 8
mutation.
07.
It is submitted that the petitioners allegedly acquired
knowledge for the first time in the second week of November,
2021 when revenue field staff attempted to interfere with their
possession on the strength of Mutation No. 1888.
08.
It is pleaded by the petitioners that on 27.11.2021,
they filed an appeal along with an application for condonation
of
delay
before
the
Additional
Deputy
Commissioner
(Commissioner Agrarian Reforms), Anantnag, who by virtue of
order dated 28.09.2023, the rejected the condonation
application as being barred by time and consequently, the
appeal was also dismissed the appeal as being time-barred.
09.
Being aggrieved of the order dated 28.09.2023, the
petitioners preferred a review petition, which was dismissed
by the appellate authority on 15.01.2026, being devoid of
merit.
10.
I have heard the learned counsel for the
petitioners and perused the record.
11.
the
A perusal of the order dated 28.09.2023 passed by
appellate
court
i.e.
court
of
Additional
Deputy
Commissioner, (exercising the powers of Commissioner
Agrarian Reforms), Anantnag would reveal that the mutation
No. 1888 which was attested way back on 11.10.1986 was
challenged by the petitioners on 27.11.2021 after a gap of
more than 34 years. Merely the petitioners having pleaded
before the Appellate Court that the appellants/petitioners
herein got knowledge from the Patwari concerned, will not
suffice huge delay in filing the appeal. In absence of any
documentary evidence to substantiate the plea of knowledge,
this Court is in agreement with the view so taken by the
WP(C) 2308/2026
Additional Deputy Commissioner, exercising the power of
Commissioner Agrarian Reforms, that no sufficient cause has
been pleaded by the appellants/petitioners to condone the
delay of three and half decades.
12.
The application which has been preferred under
Section 5 of the Limitation Act was bereft of any merit as no
cogent reason was given to justify such huge delay. The
limitation period for filing the appeal under Section 12 of the
Land Revenue Act is 60 days. For facility of reference, Section
12 of the Land Revenue Act is reproduced as under:
“12. Limitation for appeals,
revisions and reviews:
(1) [Save as otherwise provided
in the Act] the period of limitation
for
an
foregoing
appeal
under
section
the
last
be
as
shall
follows:(a) When the appeal lies to the
Collector or Assistant Collector of
the first class:
60 days
(b)When the appeal lies to [xxx] the
Financial
Commissioner
Divisional Commissioner:
or
90 days
Provided that, in the District
of Ladakh and Gilgit twice the
ordinary period of limitation for
appeals under this Section shall be
allowed.
(2) Such provisions of the Limitation
Act
as
apply
to
appeals,
applications for revision and review
in civil suits shall also apply to
WP(C) 2308/2026
appeals, applications for revision
and review under this Act.”
13.
In absence of any sufficient cause, the concerned
Additional Deputy Commissioner has rightly rejected the
application for condonation of delay, being devoid of any merit
and the appeal as a consequence thereof was also dismissed
as
time-barred,
vide
order
dated
28.09.2023,
and
consequently, the interim direction was also vacated.
14.
Feeling aggrieved of the order of dismissal of the
appeal, the appellants/petitioners preferred a review petition
before the same court, without specifying the date as to when
the review petition was preferred and the review petition also
came to be dismissed in terms of Order dated 15.01.2026,
with the following observations:
“A review cannot be sought to reopen or
re-argue the matter, nor to
substitute a fresh decision in place of the
one
already
rendered
after
due
consideration.
In the present case, the applicant
has not been able to demonstrate any error
apparent on the face of the record, nor any
clerical or arithmetical mistake in the
order dated 28.09.2023, which would
justify invocation of review jurisdiction.
The grounds urged relate entirely to
merits of the case and amount to seeking
a
re-hearing
of
the
condonation
application, which is impermissible under
settled law governing review.
Even though
the
applicant
has
relied on limited review powers recognized
by judicial precedent, those powers can be
WP(C) 2308/2026
exercised only where a patent error is
shown. No such error, accidental slip, or
omission is found in the impugned order.
For the reasons recorded above, and
there being no apparent error, clerical
error, arithmetical error, or any mistake
on the face of the record, the review
application is rejected being devoid of any
merit. Interim orders, if any, passed by
this court are hereby rejected. File be
consigned
to
records
after
due
completion.”
15.
This Court has gone through the order passed by the
review court and concur with the view so taken by the review
court that there was no error apparent on the face of the
record, which could have given a justifiable cause to the
review court to have reviewed the order and rightly so, the
review petition was rejected being devoid of any merit.
16.
After hearing learned counsel for the petitioners and
also perusing the record meticulously as also the orders
impugned in the instant petition, this Court is of the
considered view that there is no legal infirmity in both the
orders and court below has rightly exercised the jurisdiction
by dismissing the appeal as well as the review petition by
virtue of orders impugned. Therefore, the challenge thrown to
the impugned orders through the medium of the instant writ
petition by invoking the power under Article 226 is ill-founded
and devoid of any merit.
17.
The law of limitation is essentially procedural in
nature. Its purpose is to prescribe the period within which a
legal remedy may be invoked and, upon expiry of that period,
to restrict the exercise of such remedy. The provisions
governing limitation are therefore neither redundant nor
WP(C) 2308/2026
merely technical; they serve an important public purpose and
must be construed in a manner that gives effect to the
legislative intent behind prescribing definite periods for legal
recourse. The underlying rationale of limitation law is that
every legal remedy must have a defined temporal boundary.
Litigation
cannot
be
permitted
to
remain
open-ended
indefinitely, as such an approach would give rise to
uncertainty and undermine the orderly administration of
justice
18.
In Sheo Raj Singh v. Union of India & Anr,
reported as AIR 2023 SC 5109, the Supreme Court has
considered the issue regarding delay and laches. It would be
profitable to reproduce Para 29 of the above judgment which
reads as under:
“29.
Considering
the
aforementioned decisions, there cannot
be any quarrel
that this Court has
stepped in to ensure that substantive
rights of private parties and the State
are not defeated at the threshold
simply due to technical considerations
of
delay.
However, these decisions
notwithstanding,
we
condonation
of
discretionary
power
reiterate
delay
that
being
a
available
to
courts, exercise of discretion must
necessarily
depend
upon
the
sufficiency of the cause shown and the
degree
of
acceptability
of
the
explanation, the length of delay being
immaterial. Sometimes, due to want of
sufficient cause being shown or
an
WP(C) 2308/2026
acceptable being proffered, delay of the
shortest range may not be
condoned
whereas, in certain other cases, delay
of long periods can be condoned if the
explanation
is
satisfactory
and
acceptable. Of course, the courts must
distinguish between an ‘explanation’
and an ‘excuse’.
An ‘explanation’ is
designed to give someone all of the
facts and lay out
something.
It
helps
the cause for
clarify
the
circumstances of a particular event
and allows the person to point out that
something that
has happened is not
his fault, if it is really not his fault.
Care
must,
however,
be
taken
to
distinguish an 'explanation' from an
‘excuse’. Although people tend to see
'explanation' and 'excuse' as the same
thing
and struggle to find out the
difference between the two, there is a
distinction which, though fine, is real.
An 'excuse' is often offered by a person
to
deny
responsibility
and
consequences when under attack. It is
sort of a defensive action. Calling
something as just an 'excuse' would
imply that the explanation proffered is
believed not to be true. Thus said, there
is
no
formula
that
caters
to
all
situations and, therefore, each case
for condonation of delay based on
existence
or
absence
of
sufficient
cause has to be decided on its own
WP(C) 2308/2026
facts. At this stage, we cannot but
lament that it is only excuses, and not
explanations,
that
accepted
condonation
for
are
more
often
of
long
delays to safeguard public interest
from those hidden forces whole sole
agenda is to ensure that a meritorious
claim does not reach the higher courts
for adjudication."
19.
The question of condonation of delay has to be
considered in the backdrop of the settled principle that
limitation is not a mere technicality, but a statutory mandate
intended to bring finality to legal proceedings.
20.
In Basawaraj & Anr. v. Special Land Acquisition
Officer, (2013) 14 SCC 81, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that where the statute prescribes a period of limitation, the
same has to be applied with all its rigor and cannot be
extended merely on equitable considerations or on the ground
of hardship. The Court observed as under:
“It is a settled legal proposition
that law of limitation may harshly affect
a particular party, but it has to be applied
with all its rigor when the statute so
prescribes. The Court has no power to
extend
the
period
of
limitation
on
equitable grounds. ‘A result flowing from
a statutory provision is never an evil. A
court
has
no
power
to
ignore
that
provision to relieve what it considers a
distress resulting from its operation.’ The
statutory provision may cause hardship or
inconvenience to a particular party but
WP(C) 2308/2026
the court has no choice but to enforce it
giving full effect to the same. The legal
maxim dura lex sed lex, which means ‘the
law is hard but it is the law’, stands
attracted in such a situation. It has
consistently
been
held
that,
‘inconvenience is not’ a decisive factor to
be
considered
while
interpreting
a
statute.”
21.
This Court in case titled Mohd Bashir vs Union
Territory of J&K and Others bearing WP(C) No. 551/2025
decided on 10.03.2026, has observed as under:
“Rules of limitation are prima facie
rules of procedure and do not create any
rights in favour of any person nor do they
define or create cause of action but simply
prescribe
that
the
remedy
could
be
exercised only upto a certain period and
not beyond it. The Rules of Limitation are
not superfluous or vestigial but are to be
interpreted in a meaningful manner so as
to save the system from anarchy. Law of
Limitation fixes a life span for every legal
remedy. Time is precious and the wasted
time would never resist. So, a life span
must be fixed for each remedy. Unending
period for launching the remedy may lead
to
an
uncertainty
anarchy.
It
is
and
consequential
enshrined
in
maxim,
“Interests reipublicae ut sit finis litium (It
is for the general welfare that a period be
put to litigant). Every legal remedy must
be kept alive for legislatively fixed period
of time. Law is also clear each day after
WP(C) 2308/2026
limitation time, is required to be explained
by cogent means."
22.
The principle enunciated above is attracted with
greater force in the facts of the present case. The statutory
remedy against Mutation No. 1888, attested on 11.10.1986,
was invoked only on 27.11.2021, after a lapse of more than
34 years. The petitioners were, therefore, required to disclose
a cogent and satisfactory explanation accounting for the
entire period of delay. A mere assertion of having acquired
knowledge of the mutation in November, 2021, not supported
by any material demonstrating the circumstances in which
such knowledge was acquired or explaining the intervening
period, cannot constitute sufficient cause for condoning such
an extraordinary delay. In the absence of such explanation,
the statutory period of limitation cannot be enlarged on
equitable considerations.
CONCLUSION:
23.
Keeping in view the authoritative enunciation of law
as referred to above, this Court does not find any legal
infirmity in the impugned order dated 28.09.2023 passed by
the respondent No. 2-Additional Deputy Commissioner
(exercising the powers of Commissioner Agrarian Reforms),
Anantnag, and consequently order dated 15.01.2026 by virtue
of which review application was also dismissed being devoid
of any merit.
24.
Therefore, writ petition preferred by the petitioners
challenging the aforesaid orders being devoid of merit, on
account of huge delay, deserves dismissal and the same is,
accordingly, dismissed in limine along with connected
application(s). Resultantly, both the orders passed by the
learned Additional Deputy Commissioner (exercising the
WP(C) 2308/2026
powers of Commissioner Agrarian Reforms), Anantnag, are
upheld as the appeal preferred by the petitioners was barred
by law of limitation and there was no error apparent on the
face of record nor any clerical mistake in the order dated
28.09.2023
which
would
justify
invocation
of
review
jurisdiction. However, no order as to costs.
(Wasim Sadiq Nargal)
Judge
SRINAGAR:
22.09.2026
“Hamid”
Abdul Hamid Bhat
Page
I attest to the accuracy
and 15 of 15
authenticity of this
document
❖
Whether Judgment is Reportable?
Yes/No.
❖
Whether Judgment is Speaking?
Yes/No.
WP(C) 2308/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review