Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 19810/2025
Modern Emergency Services JV Pvt. Limited, Having Its
Registered Office At 407, 4Th Floor, Jaipur Center, B2 By Pass
Junction, Tonk Road Jaipur Through Authorized Representative
Shri Shrikant Taneja, S/o Sudhir Kumar Taneja, Aged About 34
Years, R/o 312 Surya City, Bharatpur, Rajasthan
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
State Of Rajasthan, Through Additional Chief Secretary,
Department Of Medical Health And Family Welfare
Government Secretariat, Jaipur.
2.
Mission Director, National Health Mission, Rajasthan,
Swasthya Bhawan, C-Scheme, Jaipur.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Madav Mitra, Sr. Adv. assisted by
Mr. Sanjay Sharma,
Mr. Vibhuti Bhushan Sharma,
Ms. Jaya Mitra &
Mr. Sharukh Khan
Mr. Vibhuti Bhushan Sharma
Mr. Harshit Tiwari
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Archit Bohra, AGC with
Mr. Rahul Verma &
Mr. Prakhar Jain
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANEESH SHARMA
Order
29/01/2026
1.
The present writ petition has been filed with the following
prayers "It is therefore, humbly prayed before Your Lordships that your
Lordships after going through the entire record of the case may
very graciously allow the instant Writ Petition and further:
(i)
By appropriate writ, order or direction, Your
Lordships may kindly be pleased to quash and set aside the
impugned order dated 10.12.2025 (Annexure-1) passed by
Respondent No. 2 herein; and
(ii)
By appropriate writ, order or direction, Your
Lordships may kindly be pleased to direct the Respondents to
give extension of the contract/agreement dated 11.12.2020 in
favour of the petitioner for a further period of six months; and
(iii)
By appropriate writ, order or direction, Your
Lordships may kindly be pleased to strike down Condition No.
6.4(35) contained in the Request for Proposal dated
26.11.2025 (Annexure-18); and
(iv) By an appropriate writ, order or direction, Your
Lordships may kindly be pleased to direct the Respondents to
reimburse the cost of newly procured 350 vehicles/ambulances
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
(2 of 9)
[CW-19810/2025]
strictly in accordance with the letter dated 11.07.2023
(Annexure-16) and/or
(v)
Any other order or direction as Your Lordships
deem just, appropriate and equitable in the facts and
circumstances of the case may also kindly be passed in favor of
the petitioner."
2.
Brief facts giving rise to the present writ petition are that the
petitioner is a Joint-Venture Company comprising of M/s Gunesh
India Private Limited, M/s Sammaan Foundation and M/s Golden
Path Lab Private Limited. All the aforementioned three companies
are duly incorporated under the Indian Companies Act and decided
to form a Joint Venture by executing a Joint Venture Agreement
on 01.09.2020. The respondent issued a Request for Proposal
('RFP') on 07.07.2020 for the operation and management of 104
Janani Express in the State of Rajasthan as per the terms and
conditions contained therein and the petitioner participated and
succeeded in obtaining a Letter of Intent ('LOI') on 17.11.2020.
3.
Pursuant to the LOI dated 17.11.2020, the petitioner signed
a service agreement dated 11.12.2020. The duration of the
service agreement was initially from 10.12.2020 to 10.12.2023,
which was extended vide order dated 24.08.2023 for a further
period of two years up to 10.12.2025, which came to an end on
10.12.2025.
4.
From the averments of the writ petition, it is borne out that
in the present writ petition, the petitioner is assailing: the legality
and validity of the order dated 10.12.2025 passed by respondent
No.2, wherein respondent No.2 rejected the petitioner's request to
extend the period of the service agreement dated 11.12.2020 for
a further period of six months; reimburse the cost of newly
procured 350 vehicles/ambulances; as well as Clause 6.4(35) of
(3 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
[CW-19810/2025]
the subsequent RFP No. F-23 (178)/NHM/IAP/104JE/2025-26/627
dated 26.11.2025.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the action of
the respondents is wholly arbitrary, perverse, and deserves to be
set aside, being contrary to the terms and conditions of the
service agreement dated 11.12.2020. He further submits that the
petitioner has been duly performing their obligations under the
service agreement dated 11.12.2020, and the same was due to
expire
on 10.12.2023
initially and
the
cost
of the newly
purchased/deployed vehicles could not be paid back to the
petitioner by the respondents by 10.12.2023, the respondent No.2
acknowledged
the
same
vide
letter
dated
11.07.2023
and
formulated a mechanism to pay back the cost of the newly
procured
vehicles.
Thereafter,
the
service
agreement
was
extended upto 10.12.2025, and when the extension period was
about to end, the petitioner vide letter dated 25.11.2025
requested the respondents for extension of the service agreement
dated 11.12.2020 for a further period of six months since the
respondent No.2 had neither taken over the vehicles and assets in
accordance with the 'Exit Clause' stipulated under Clause 10.4(d)
of the RFP dated 07.07.2020 nor paid the cost of the vehicles to
the petitioner in accordance with the letter dated 11.07.2023, and
in an arbitrary manner the respondents declined the prayers qua
extension of the service agreement and reimbursement of the cost
of newly procured vehicles/ambulances, even before deciding the
petitioner's representation vide letter dated 25.11.2025, and
issued a fresh RFP on 26.11.2025. He further submits that the
fresh RFP dated 26.11.2025 incorporated a new clause i.e. Clause
(4 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
[CW-19810/2025]
6.4(35), as per which the outstanding bank loan for the
vehicles/ambulances deployed on turnkey basis by the old service
provider, will be payable by the new service provider, which is
contrary to both, the letter dated 11.07.2023 and the RFP dated
07.07.2020; he therefore prays that the impugned order may
kindly be set aside and the present writ petition may kindly be
allowed.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent-State, while
supporting the action of the respondents, raises preliminary
objection about the maintainability of the writ petition in the light
of Clause 10.6 of the RFP dated 07.07.2020, which provides an
alternate and efficacious remedy to the petitioners, since prayers
No.(i), (ii) and (iv) can very well be determined by the mechanism
provided under Clause No.10.6 of the RFP.
7.
He further submits that, as far as the prayer No.(iii) is
concerned, since the erstwhile clause 6.4(35) contained in the
subsequent
RFP
stood
23.12.2025,
and
the
amended
amended
vide
provision
corrigendum
has
never
dated
been
challenged by the petitioner, therefore prayer No.(iii) also cannot
be accepted.
8.
Heard and considered the submissions made at bar and
perused the material available on record.
9.
It is an undisputed fact that in terms of the RFP dated
07.07.2020, the petitioners were issued an LOI dated 17.11.2020
and a service agreement was executed on 11.12.2020 between
the parties consciously, wherein the parties mutually accepted
their covenants in accordance with the terms and conditions
encapsulated in the RFP dated 07.07.2020. It is also not disputed
(5 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
[CW-19810/2025]
that the service agreement dated 11.12.2020 had initially expired
on 10.12.2023, and was extended vide order dated 24.08.2023
for a further period of two years up to 10.12.2025.
10.
From a bare perusal of the prayer clause of the writ petition
and the RFP dated 07.07.2020, it is evident that the petitioner
vide prayer No.(i), (ii) & (iv) qua quashment of the order dated
10.12.2025,
reimbursement
extension
of
of
the
service
the
cost
of
agreement
newly
and
procured
vehicles/ambulances, respectively, is seeking redressal of a
dispute, squarely falling within the ambit of the word 'dispute'
between the parties arising in connection with or arising out of the
agreement. It is apt to reproduce Clause 10.6 of the RFP dated
07.07.2020 as under:
"10.6 Settlement of Disputes
10.6.1 Settlement of Disputes:
If any dispute with regard to the interpretation, difference or
objection whatsoever arises in connection with or arises out of the
agreement, or the meaning of any part thereof, or on the rights,
duties or liabilities of any party, the same shall be referred for
decision to the committee constituted as below:1. Principal Secretary Medical and Health, GoR.
2. Representative of Secretary Finance, GoR.
3. Representative of Secretary Law, GoR.
4. Representative of Secretary IT, GoR.
If either of the party is not satisfied with the decision of
above committee it may refer the matter for arbitration as per
clause 10.6
10.6.2 Arbitration:
If dispute or difference of any kind arises between the NHM
and the Service Provider in connection with or relating to the
agreement, the parties shall make every effort to resolve the same
amicably by mutual consultations.
If the parties fail to resolve their dispute or difference by
such mutual consultations and even after the decision of Dispute
Settlement Committee decision then either party may give notice,
within thirty days of decision of Dispute Settlement Committee, to
the other party of its intention to commence arbitration, as
hereinafter provided. The applicable arbitration procedure will be
as per the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 of India. In that
event, the dispute or difference shall be referred to the sole
arbitration of an officer as the arbitrator to be appointed by the
NHM. If the arbitrator to whom the matter is initially referred is
transferred or vacates his office or is unable to act for any reason,
(6 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
[CW-19810/2025]
he/she shall be replaced by another person appointed by NHM to
act as Arbitrator.
Work under the agreement shall, notwithstanding the
existence of any such dispute or difference, continue during
arbitration proceedings and no payment due or payable shall be
withheld on account of such proceedings unless such payments are
the direct subject matter of the arbitration.
Reference to arbitration shall be a condition precedent to
any other action a law.
Venue of Arbitration: The venue of arbitration shall be
Jaipur, Rajasthan."
11.
Thus, a bare look to Clause 10.6 above reveals that in case
of a dispute between the parties arising in connection with or
arising out of the agreement, the same will have to be referred to
a committee constituted under Clause 10.6.1, and if either party is
not satisfied by the decision of such committee, the said dispute/
decision of the committee can further be referred to arbitration in
terms of Clause 10.6.2. Therefore, when the parties to a
commercial
contract
have
mutually
agreed
to
a
particular
mechanism of redressal, this Court ordinarily should not exercise
the powers conferred by Article 226 of the Constitution of India to
obviate such arrangement made between the parties.
12.
That time and again, the Hon'ble Apex Court has reiterated
that in contractual matters where an alternate mechanism of
redressal is provided for and accepted by the parties to the
contract, Courts ought not to entertain such dispute under Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
13.
The above position of law is fortified by the judgment of the
Hon'ble Apex Court in State of U.P. & Ors. Vs. Bridge & Roof
Co. (India) Ltd.1, wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court has held as
under:
"21. There is yet another substantial reason for not entertaining
the writ petition. The contract in question contains a clause
providing inter alia for settlement of disputes by reference to
arbitration [Clause 67 of the Contract]. The Arbitrators can decide
(1996) 6 SCC 22
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
(7 of 9)
[CW-19810/2025]
both questions of fact as well as questions of law. When the
contract itself provides for a mode of settlement of disputes arising
from the contract, there is no reason why the parties should not
follow and adopt that remedy and invoke the extra-ordinary
jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226. The existence of
an effective alternative remedy - in this case, provided in the
contract itself - is a good ground for the court to decline to
exercise its extra-ordinary jurisdiction under Article 226. The said
Article was not meant to supplant the existing remedies at law but
only to supplement them in certain well-recognised situations. As
pointed out above, the prayer for issuance of a writ of mandamus
was wholly misconceived in this case since the respondent was not
seeking to enforce any statutory right of theirs nor was it seeking
to enforce any statutory obligation cast upon the appellants.
Indeed, the very resort to Article 226 - whether for issuance of
mandamus or any other writ, order or direction-was misconceived
for the reasons mentioned supra."
(Emphasis Supplied)
14.
Further, the Hon'ble Apex Court in Pimpri Chinchwad
Municipal Corporation & Ors. Vs. Gayatri Construction
Company and Anr.2 opined that where the agreement provides
for an in-house remedy for settlement of disputes, the High Courts
ought not to entertain such disputes under the supervisory writ
jurisdiction conferred by Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
15.
In view of the above settled position of law, prayer No.(i), (ii)
& (iv) of the present writ petition cannot be entertained as the
petitioner can always seek appropriate remedy available under
Clause 10.6 of the RFP dated 07.07.2020.
16.
Lastly, as regards to prayer No.(iii), the same assails
erstwhile Condition No.6.4(35) of the subsequent RFP dated
26.11.2025 (Annexure-18).
From the record of the case it
transpires that the reply to the writ petition was filed on
05.01.2026 and along with the said reply, the respondent has
annexed a copy of the corrigendum dated 23.12.2025 in relation
to Clause 6.4(35) of the subsequent RFP dated 26.11.2025, and
substantial change has been made in the original clause, as now a
specific loan amount of Rs.11,57,25,000/- has been explicitly
(2008) 8 SCC 172
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
(8 of 9)
[CW-19810/2025]
quantified as payable by the incoming service provider or as
quantified at the time of the said agreement in order to wipe out
misplaced apprehension of the petitioner/protect and secure the
financial interest of the petitioner. It is also pertinent to mention
here that the petitioner has neither challenged the amended
provision contemplated under Condition No.6.4(35), nor filed a
rejoinder/counter-affidavit in the present matter to refute the
same.
Therefore, as
of today,
prayer
No.(iii) has
become
redundant in view of the corrigendum dated 23.12.2025.
17.
Even otherwise, the petitioner is always at liberty to assail
the amended provision of Clause 6.4(35) in case they consider it
prejudicial to their financial interest or otherwise, before the
appropriate forum, in accordance with law.
18.
Before parting with this writ petition, it is pertinent to
mention that both the parties have urged several contentions of
fact, relied upon several other clauses of the contract apart from
those mentioned supra, and cited various provisions of the
Rajasthan Transparency in Public Procurement Act, 2012. I have
not set them out herein because I am of the considered opinion
that they are outside the ken of a writ petition. It shall be open to
the parties to urge and rely upon them at the proper stage and
before the appropriate forum as any finding on the said aspect by
this Court would affect the case of the parties before the
appropriate forum.
19.
In view of the aforesaid deliberation, considering the facts
and circumstances of the present case, arguments advanced by
respective counsels for the parties and judgments of the Hon'ble
[2026:RJ-JP:4142]
(9 of 9)
[CW-19810/2025]
Apex Court, this Court is not inclined to entertain the present writ
petition.
20.
Accordingly, the present writ petition fails, and is hereby
dismissed with liberty to the petitioner to avail the remedies
available under Clause 10.6.1 and 10.6.2 of the RFP dated
07.07.2020 qua relief sought for vide prayer No.(i), (ii) and (iv),
and seek remedy before the appropriate forum qua prayer No.(iii)
in accordance with the law.
21.
All pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(MANEESH SHARMA),J
DEEPA RANI /19
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review