Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:2680-DB
NAFR
Digitally
signed by
ROHIT
ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA KUMAR
CHANDRA
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 184 of 2026
Mitul Enterprises A Proprietorship Firm Through Its Proprietor, Shri Bipin
Chandra Kothari, Aged About 79 Years, Having Office At Shop No. 13,
Vijeta Complex, Main Road, Shastri Market, Raipur (C.G.) 492001
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department of
Agriculture, Govt. of Chhattisgarh, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar,
Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2 - The Director Directorate of Horticulture And Farm Forestry, Indrawati
Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur (C.G.)
3 - The Assistant Director (Horticulture) Directorate Of Horticulture And
Farm Forestry, Indrawati Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur (C.G.)
4 - Government E-Market Place (Gem) Through Its Chief Executive
Officer, Ministry of Commerce And Industry, New Delhi
5 - The Director (States) Govt. E-Marketplace, Ministry of Commerce
And Industry Having Its Office At 2nd Floor, Jeevan Tara Building 5Sansad Marg, Near Patel Chowk, New Delhi
6 - The Sr. Asst. Director- Chhattisgarh State Govt. E-Marketplace,
Ministry of Commerce And Industry Having Its Office At 2nd Floor,
Jeevan Tara Building 5- Sansad Marg, Near Patel Chowk, New Delhi
... Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioner
: Mr. Manoj Paranjpe, Senior Advocate
assisted by Mr. Sudhanshu Upadhyay, Advocate
For Respondents :
/State
Mr. Shashank Thakur, Addl. Adv. General
For Respondents : Ms. Annapurna Tiwari and Ms. Anmol Sharma,
/UOI
Central Government Counsels
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Hon'ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Mr. Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
16.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Manoj Paranjpe, learned Senior Advocate assisted by
Mr. assisted by Mr. Sudhanshu Upadhyay, learend counsel for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. Shashank Thakur, learned Additional
Advocate General, appearing for the State-respondents and
Ms.Annapurna Tiwari and Ms. Anmol Sharma, learned Central
Government Counsel, appearing for UOI-respondents.
2.
Though the matter is listed for hearing on admission, but as all the
respondents are represented by their respective counsels and
they are ready to argue the matter finally, hence, there is no need
issue notices to the respondents and with the consent of learned
counsel for the parties, the matter is heard finally.
3.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioners under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, with the following prayers :-
“(i) That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
allow the present writ petition & call for the entire record
pertaining to the present case.
(ii) That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue an appropriate Writ/order/direction for quashing
and setting aside the Respondents' unilateral decision
taken via letter dated 08-12-2025 and email
communication dated 12-12-2025 and action whereby
which
the
Tender
bearing
GeM
Bid
No.
GEM/2025/B/6604538 awarded to the Petitioner via
contract bearing GEMC No. 511687741466556, pursuant
to Letter No. 4510 dated 10.10.2025 and the executed
Agreement dated 13.10.2025, was arbitrarily cancelled
by the Respondents.
(iii) That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue an appropriate Writ/order/direction declaring a
valid, binding, and executable contract exists between
the Petitioner and the State/Department of Horticulture
under GeM GTC, ATC, and the executed offline
agreement, and that the Respondents are legally bound
and mandated to honour the contract issued in favor of
the Petitioner via letter dated 10-10-2025;
(iv) That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue an appropriate Writ / order / direction directing the
Respondents
to
forthwith
issue
district-wise
purchase/work orders and supply instructions to the
Petitioner for the quantity envisaged under the ATC
(approximately 75,00,000 seedlings) at the RAdiscovered L-1 rate of Rs. 9.26 per seedling (inclusive of
all taxes and levies), or such quantity as may still be
feasible and viable in the current agricultural season,
within a reasonable time period
(v)
In the alternative and without prejudice, direct the
Respondents to compensate the Petitioner by way of
damages, compensation, or ex gratia relief for the loss
suffered on account of deterioration and destruction of
grafted seedlings produced in reliance on the
Respondents' representations and the concluded
contract, together with interest at 12% per annum from
the date of loss until payment;
(vi) Issue a Writ of Prohibition or Mandamus restraining
the Respondents from issuing, finalizing, or proceeding
with any fresh/parallel tender in relation to the same
subject matter (Grafted Vegetable Hybrid Seedlings
Tomato and Brinjal), pending final adjudication of the
present petition or until lawful cancellation of the existing
GEMC/contract in accordance with law and GeM GTC
with full compliance to principles of natural justice;
(vii) That, Award the costs of the petition in favour of the
Petitioner;
(viii) Grant such other and further reliefs as this Hon'ble
Court may deem fit, proper, and just in the facts and
circumstances of the case.”
4.
Mr. Manoj Paranjpe, learned Senior Advocate assisted by
Mr.Sudhanshu Upadhyay, learned counsel for the petitioner
vehemently argued that the petitioner is a registered MSME
proprietorship firm engaged in the business of supplying
horticultural inputs, including grafted vegetable hybrid seedlings,
and is a regular participant in Government procurements via the
GeM portal. Respondent No. 2 floated a Custom Bid on the GeM
portal under Tender No. GEM/2025/B/6604538 dated 25.08.2025
for the supply of grafted tomato and brinjal seedlings for the
horticultural season 2025-26, with an approximate requirement of
75,00,000 seedlings with basic rates per unit, which is evident
from sub-clause 3 and 4 of Clause 5.11 of the tender document
itself. The bid was open for participation by accredited nurseries
or authorized distributors sourcing from accredited nurseries. The
petitioner, as a consortium bidder with M/s Shreeji Nursery (an
accredited nursery), submitted its bid, qualified technically,
participated in the Reverse Auction, and emerged as L-1 at a rate
of Rs. 9.26 per seedling and upon completion of the Reverse
Auction, the GeM system generated a binding GeM Contract
(GEMC No. 511687741466556) in favor of the petitioner. Following
this, the respondent department issued an official letter dated
10.10.2025, declaring the petitioner as L-1, directing the execution
of an offline agreement in stamp of Rs.100/- and requesting
submission of performance security. In compliance of the same,
the petitioner has submitted the agreement on 13.10.2025,
wherein, it has specifically mentioned the quantity of seedlings as
75,00,000 at the rate of Rs. 9.26 per grafted plant Tomoto/Brinjal
as quoted by the petitioner. He further argued that thereafter, the
dispute arose at the instance of Horticulture Department saying
that the work order was issued for 1 piece and the agreement
which was submitted is for 75,00,000 pieces. The said dispute
has been resolved by Committee constituted by the Department
itself which is evident from Annexure-P/18 dated 13.11.2025,
wherein it has been specifically mentioned that in the reverse
auction, rates per unit have been quoted by all the firms except
M/s. Balaji Automobiles, which is L-5 and accordingly, guidance
regarding entering into a contract with the petitioner, L-1 institution
has been sought for. Thereafter, Annexure-P/1 dated 08.12.2025
has been issued by respondent No.2, whereby whole tender has
been cancelled assigning the reason that “Since the department
invited the tender for the supply of 75 lakhs grafted plants and the
contract signed with the L-1 organization after the tender resulted
in only one plant being displayed and as per GeM Rules, the
supply order must be issued online, therefore, the contract is being
cancelled due to discrepancy between the number of plants listed
in the departments invited tender and the number of plants
displayed upon contract issuance”, which is evident from page 37
part of Annexure-P/1. He further submitted that the cancellation
predicated solely on alleged "quantity confusion" (system: 1 unit
Rs. 9.26 vs. ATC: 75 lakhs) is legally untenable as GeM Helpdesk
(Ticket 12771100) categorically confirmed that such representation
is "correct and intentional for Custom Bids", evaluation was on
per-unit basis, and Petitioner remains valid L-1.
5.
On the other hand, learned State counsel as well as learned CCG,
appearing for respective respondents though tried to justify the
order passed by respondent No.2, but could not dispute that the
petitioner participated in the Reverse Auction and emerged as L-1
bidder at the rate of Rs. 9.26 per seedling. However, they
submitted that the tender documents and the entire procurement
process were based on the understanding that the quantity of
seedlings to be supplied was 75 lakh, as specified in the terms of
the tender. They further submitted that the issue at hand arises
from the fact that the GeM system displayed a quantity of "1" unit
for the contract awarded to the petitioner, which was contrary to
the tender specifications, which clearly outlined the requirement of
75 lakh seedlings and as such, the cancellation of the contract by
Respondent No. 2 on 08.12.2025 was based on this very
discrepancy. The cancellation was done in accordance with the
provisions of the General Terms and Conditions (GTC) of the GeM
platform and the applicable guidelines governing such contracts.
6.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents appended with the writ petition.
7.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Gas Authority of India Ltd. vs.
Indian Petrochemicals Corporation Ltd. [(2023) 3 SCC 629) ,
held that writ jurisdiction under Article 226 can be exercised when
a government enterprise (being a State) in its contractual dealings,
fails to exercise a degree of fairness or practices discrimination.
Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Uttar Pradesh Power
Transmission Corporation Ltd. vs. CG Power and Industrial
Solutions Ltd. ((2021) 6 SCC 15) held that relief under Article 226
can be granted in a case arising out of a contract if the act of the
state smells of malafides, arbitrariness and non-transparency.
8.
Recently the Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of Subodh Kumar
Singh
Rathour
v.
Kolkata
Metropolitan
Development
Authority, reported in (2024) 15 SCC 461 has held & observed
that:
“61. Therefore, what can be culled out from the above is
that although disputes arising purely out of contracts are
not amenable to writ jurisdiction yet keeping in mind the
obligation of the State to act fairly and not arbitrarily or
capriciously, it is now well settled that when contractual
power is being used for public purpose, it is certainly
amenable to judicial review.
62. Now coming to the facts of the case at hand, the
appellant has challenged the cancellation of the tender
at the instance of the respondent on the ground of being
manifestly arbitrary and influenced by extraneous
considerations. It is evident from the Notice of
Cancellation dated 7-2-2023, that the tender was not
terminated pursuant to any terms of the contract
subsisting between the parties, rather, the respondent
"cancelled the tender saying that there was technical
fault in the tender that was floated.
63. Thus, the respondent could be said to have
exercised powers in its executive capacity as the action
to cancel the tender falls outside the purview of the
terms of the contract. Hence, it cannot be said that the
present matter is purely a contractual dispute. It is also
not a breach of contract, as no such breach has been
imputed to the appellant in terms of the contract, but
rather a plain and simple exercise of the executive
powers.
64. Thus, the present dispute even if related to a tender,
cannot be termed as a pure contractual dispute, as the
dispute involves a public law element. Although there is
no discharge of a public function by the respondent
towards the appellant yet there is a right to public law
action vested in him against the respondent in terms of
Article 14 of the Constitution. This is because the
exercise of the executive power by it in the contractual
domain ie. the cancelling of the tender carries a
corresponding public duty to act in a reasonable and
rationale manner. Thus, we find that the writ petition filed
by the respondent was maintainable and the relief
prayed for could have been considered by the High
Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction.
xxx
xxx
xxx
71. To ascertain whether an act is arbitrary or not, the
court must carefully attend to the facts and the
circumstances of the case. It should find out whether the
impugned decision [Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour v.
Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority, 2023 SCC
OnLine Cal 6553) is based on any principle. If not, it may
unerringly point to arbitrariness. If the act betrays
caprice or the mere exhibition of the whim of the
authority it would sufficiently bear the insignia of
arbitrariness. In this regard supporting an order with a
rationale which in the circumstances is found to be
reasonable will go a long way to repel a challenge to
State action. No doubt the reasons need not in every
case be part of the order as such. If there is absence of
good faith and the action is actuated with an oblique
motive, it could be characterised as being arbitrary. A
total non-application of mind without due regard to the
rights of the parties and public interest may be a clear
indicator of arbitrary action.
72. One another way, to assess whether an action
complained of could be termed as arbitrary is by way of
scrutinising the reasons that have been assigned to
such an action. It involves overseeing whether the
reasons which have been cited if at all genuinely formed
part of the decision-making process or whether they are
merely a ruse. All decisions that are taken must
earnestly be in lieu of the reasons and considerations
that have been assigned to it. The Court must be mindful
of the fact that it is not supposed 72. to delve into every
minute details of the reasoning assigned, it need not to
go into a detailed exercise of assessing the pros and
cons of the reaso ns itself, but should only see whether
the reasons were earnest, genuine and had a rationale
with the ultimate decision. What is under scrutiny in
judicial review of an action is the decision-making
process and whether there is any element of
arbitrariness or mala fide.
73. Thus, the question to be answered in such situations
is whether the decision was based on valid
considerations. This is undertaken to ensure that the
reasons assigned were the true motivations behind the
action and it involves checking for the presence of any
ulterior motives or irrelevant considerations that might
have influenced the decision. The approach of the court
must be to respect the expertise and discretion of
administrative authorities while still protecting against
arbitrary and capricious actions. Thus, now the only
question that remains to be considered is: whether the
action of the respondent to cancel the tender could be
termed as arbitrary?
xxx
xxx
xxx
128. The sanctity of public tenders lies in their role in
upholding the principles of equal opportunity and
fairness. Once a contract has come into existence
through a valid tendering process, its termination must
adhere strictly to the terms of the contract, with the
executive powers to be exercised only in exceptional
cases by the public authorities and that too in loathe.
The courts are duty bound to zealously protect the
sanctity of any tender that has been duly conducted and
concluded by ensuring that the larger public interest of
upholding bindingness of contracts are not sidelined by
a capricious or arbitrary exercise of power by the State.
It is the duty of the courts to interfere in contractual
matters that have fallen prey to an arbitrary action of the
authorities in the guise of technical faults, policy change
or public interest, etc.
129. The sanctity of contracts is a fundamental principle
that underpins the stability and predictability of legal and
commercial relationships. When public authorities enter
into contracts, they create legitimate expectations that
the State will honour its obligations. Arbitrary or
unreasonable
terminations
undermine
these
expectations and erode the trust of private players from
the public procurement processes and tenders. Once a
contract is entered, there is a legitimate expectation, that
the obligations arising from the contract will be honoured
and that the rights arising from it will not be arbitrarily
divested except for a breach or non-compliance of the
terms agreed thereunder. In this regard we may make a
reference to the decision of this Court in Sivanandan
C.T. v. High Court of Kerala (Sivanandan C.T.v. High
Court of Kerala, (2024) 3 SCC 799: (2024) 1 SCC (L&S)
67] wherein it was held that a promise made by a public
authority will give rise to a legitimate expectation that it
will adhere to its assurances. The relevant portion reads
as under: (SCC pp. 812 & 822, paras 18 & 45)
“18. The basis of the doctrine of legitimate
expectation in public law is founded on the
principles of fairness and non-arbitrariness in
Government dealings with individuals. It
recognises that a public authority's promise or
past conduct will give rise to a legitimate
expectation. The doctrine is premised on the
notion that public authorities, while performing
their public duties, ought to honour their
promises or past practices. The legitimacy of an
expectation can be inferred if it is rooted in law,
custom, or established procedure. (Salemi v.
MacKeller (No. 2), 1977 HCA 26: (1977) 137
CLR 396)
45. The underlying basis for the application of
the doctrine of legitimate expectation has
expanded and evolved to include the principles
of good administration. Since citizens repose
their trust in the State, the actions and policies of
the State give rise to legitimate expectations that
the State will adhere to its assurance or past
practice by acting in a consistent, transparent,
and predictable manner. The principles of good
administration require that the decisions of public
authorities must withstand the test of
consistency, transparency, and predictability to
avoid being regarded as arbitrary and therefore
violative of Article 14."
(emphasis supplied)
130. Cancellation of a contract deprives a person of his
very valuable rights and is a very drastic step, often due
to significant investments having already been made by
the parties involved during the subsistence of the
contract. Failure on the part of the courts to zealously
protect the binding nature of a lawful and valid tender,
would erode public faith in contracts and tenders.
Arbitrary terminations of contract create uncertainty and
unpredictability, thereby discouraging public participation
in the tendering process. When private parties perceive
that their contractual rights can be easily trampled by the
State, they would be dissuaded from participating in
public procurement processes which may have a
negative impact on such other public-private partnership
ventures and ultimately it is the public who would have
to bear the brunt thereby frustrating the very object of
public interest.
131. We caution the public authorities to be circumspect
in disturbing or wriggling out of its contractual obligations
through means beyond the terms of the contract in
exercise of their executive powers. We do not say for a
moment that the State has no power to alter or cancel a
contract that it has entered into. However, if the State
deems it necessary to alter or cancel a contract on the
ground of public interest or change in policy then such
considerations must be bona fide and should be
earnestly reflected in the decision-making process and
also in the final decision itself. We say so because
otherwise, it would have a very chilling effect as
participating and winning a tender would tend to be
viewed as a situation worse than losing one at the
threshold.”
9.
In the present case, it is undisputed that the petitioner, a
registered MSME proprietorship firm, participated in the GeM
portal
procurement
process
under
Tender
No.
GEM/2025/B/6604538 for the supply of 75,00,000 grafted tomato
and brinjal seedlings. The petitioner emerged as the L-1 bidder
following the Reverse Auction, quoting a rate of Rs. 9.26 per
seedling.
Subsequently,
a
GeM
contract
(GEMC
No.
511687741466556) was generated, and an official letter dated
10.10.2025 was issued to the petitioner, declaring it as L-1 and
directing the execution of the agreement and submission of
performance security. The petitioner duly complied by submitting
the signed agreement on 13.10.2025, which clearly specified the
quantity of seedlings as 75,00,000 at the agreed rate.
10.
The respondents have raised a concern regarding the quantity
discrepancy in the GeM system, which displayed “1” unit instead
of the 75 lakh seedlings required under the tender. However, the
GeM Helpdesk, through Ticket No. 12771100, clarified that such
quantity representation is intentional for Custom Bids and that the
evaluation was conducted on a per-unit basis. Therefore, the
discrepancy was not a genuine error but rather a technical aspect
of the system that should not have impacted the execution of the
contract. The respondents failed to adequately address this
clarification and proceeded with the unilateral cancellation of the
contract.
11.
The respondents issued the cancellation order on 08.12.2025,
citing the quantity discrepancy as the reason. However, the
respondents did not issue a show-cause notice or provide the
petitioner an opportunity to present its case before making this
decision. This is a clear violation of the principles of natural justice,
which require that no party be condemned unheard. The absence
of procedural fairness in cancelling the contract undermines the
legitimacy of the respondents’ action. The respondents have failed
to establish any valid legal grounds for the cancellation of the
contract. No fraud, misrepresentation, or breach of terms by the
petitioner has been alleged. The cancellation is based solely on
the technical issue of a system-generated quantity discrepancy,
which was clarified by the GeM Helpdesk. Therefore, the
cancellation is arbitrary and unreasonable.
12.
In light of the above findings, this Court is of the considered view
that the actions of the respondents in cancelling the contract are
arbitrary, illegal, and in violation of the principles of natural justice.
The petitioner, having fulfilled all contractual requirements and
having acted in good faith, is entitled to the enforcement of the
contract.
13.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed with the following
directions:
(i)
The unilateral cancellation of the GeM contract by the
respondents,
as
communicated
through
the
letter
dated
08.12.2025 and email communication dated 12.12.2025, is hereby
quashed and set aside.
(ii)
A valid, binding, and enforceable contract exists between the
petitioner and the respondents under the GeM GTC, the ATC, and
the executed offline agreement. The respondents are directed to
honor the contract issued in favor of the petitioner via letter dated
10.10.2025.
(ii)
The respondents are directed to immediately issue district-
wise purchase/work orders to the petitioner for the supply of
approximately 75,00,000 seedlings at the rate of Rs. 9.26 per
seedling (inclusive of all taxes and levies) or such quantity as may
still be feasible within the current agricultural season, within a
reasonable time period.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Chandra
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review