Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Before:
The Hon’ble Justice Anuj Singh.
W.P.A. No. 25799 of 2023
Mithun Biswas
V
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioner : Mr. Arka Pratim Chowdhury
Ms. Puja Rajbhor
Mr. Swattik Batabyal
……… Advocate.
For the State
: Mr. Goutam Misra
……… Advocate
Heard on
: 28.09.2026
Judgement on
:09.10.2026
Anuj Singh, J:.
1. The Writ petitioners claim to be eligible candidates for recruitment to
teaching posts and state that they participated in a demonstration
against alleged irregularities in recruitment by the School Service
Commission.
2. By this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, the Writ
Petitioners, assail Maidan Police Station Case No. 86 of 2021 dated
20.10.2021, registered under Sections 188/ 283 and 34 of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860 read with Section 51(b) of the Disaster
Management Act, 2005, and the consequential G.R. Case No. 1120
of 2021 pending before the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, 7th
Court, Calcutta. The petitioners seek a writ of certiorari directing the
respondents to strike them off the records of Maidan P.S. Case No.
86 of 2021.
3. The writ petitioners contend that the prosecution is mala fide,
actuated by an ulterior motive to brand genuine candidates with a
criminal record, and violative of Articles 14, 15, 16, 19(1)(a),(b) and
(g), 20 and 21 of the Constitution.
4. The written complaint dated 20.10.2021 was lodged at Maidan Police
Station by Sub-Inspector Debabrata Saha of Maidan Police Station.
On the same day, it was registered as Maidan P.S. Case No.
86/2021. The complainant alleges that at about 1:40 p.m. on
20.10.2021, while on his round, he found two sit-in-demonstration
programmes of SSC SLST-2016 candidates going on at Gandhi
Statue beside Mayo Road, one of which was under the leadership of
the petitioner. It is alleged that at about 2:00 p.m., some 25 to 26
demonstrators under the leadership of the petitioner arranged a
Lakshmi Puja in the course of the sit-in-demonstration programme,
occupying and blocking the footpath of Mayo Road beside Gandhi
Statue till about 4:50 p.m., causing obstruction to pedestrians, in
violation of the conditions imposed by this Court and the Covid19
pandemic protocols, then in force. The complaint names the
petitioner, Mithun Biswas, and 25/26 other persons as being among
the protesters.
5. Upon completion of investigation, Charge-Sheet No. 85 of 2021
dated 30.12.2021 was submitted under Sections 188/283/34 of IPC
read with Section 51(b) of the Disaster Management Act, 2005
against the petitioner alone, the other demonstrators having
remained unidentified.
6. Both the parties have submitted that upon submission of the charge
sheet in the instant case, the learned magistrate has taken
cognizance of the offences.
7. At the outset, this Court called upon the parties to address the
Court on the issue as to whether this Court, under Article 226 of the
Constitution, can quash the proceedings arising out of Maidan Police
Station Case No. 86 of 2021 dated 20.10.2021, registered under
Sections 188/ 283 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 read with
Section 51(b) of the Disaster Management Act, 2005, which has
culminated in a Charge Sheet, most significantly, where the learned
Magistrate has proceeded to take cognizance of the offences.
8. Learned advocate for the petitioner, however, argued that there is no
bar on the powers of this Court in quashing the proceedings,
notwithstanding the fact that the charge sheet had been submitted
and cognizance of the offences has been taken by the learned
Magistrate.
9. Learned Advocate representing the State has, however, opposed the
petition by submitting that the Charge sheet has several allegations
which, if taken at their face value, constitute an offence. As such,
the only remedy available to the petitioner is to face trial.
10.
The question, therefore, which falls for consideration of this
Court is whether the present writ Petition is maintainable under
Article 226 of the Constitution in light of the fact that the charge
sheet has been submitted and cognizance of the offences has been
taken by the learned Magistrate.
11.
In Neeta Singh v. State of U.P., (2026) 6 SCC 817, a writ
petition under Article 226 challenging an FIR had been dismissed
because the charge-sheet was filed and cognizance taken during its
pendency. Upholding that course, the Supreme Court held that once
the competent criminal court takes cognizance, the High Court is
disabled from proceeding with the writ petition, "owing to a judicial
order having intervened". The following passage of the judgment is of
significance and reproduced hereunder.
“3. We have no doubt in our mind about the contours of
jurisdiction of a High Court when a challenge is presented
asserting that the impugned FIR ought to be quashed on the
settled parameters. However, sight cannot be lost of the settled
legal position that it is entirely within the discretion of a High
Court whether to interfere or not when other remedies are
available. If during the pendency of a writ petition under Article
226 of the Constitution before a High Court where an FIR is
challenged the investigation is completed and charge-sheet
filed, in pursuance whereof the competent criminal court takes
cognizance of the offence, the court would be disabled in
proceeding with the writ petition owing to a judicial order
having intervened.
4. We can profitably refer to the decision of the Bench of three
Judges of this Court made on a reference in Radhey
Shyam v. Chhabi Nath [Radhey Shyam v. Chhabi Nath, (2015)
5 SCC 423 : (2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 67] . While disapproving the
view expressed in Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai [Surya
Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai, (2003) 6 SCC 675] , it was held
that judicial orders of the civil court are not amenable to writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution and that
jurisdiction under Article 227 is distinct from jurisdiction under
Article 226 [Radhey Shyam v. Chhabi Nath, (2015) 5 SCC 423,
para 29] .”
12.
Further, the Supreme Court in Radhey Shyam v. Chhabi
Nath, (2015) 5 SCC 423, has held that judicial orders are not
amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226. A judicial order
cannot be said to breach a fundamental, constitutional or statutory
right so as to attract a writ of certiorari. The law provides its own
fora for redressal. The following passage of the judgment is of
significance and reproduced hereunder.
“18 While the above judgments dealt with the question whether
judicial order could violate a fundamental right, it was clearly
laid down that the challenge to judicial orders could lie by way
of appeal or revision or under Article 227 and not by way of a
writ under Articles 226 or 32.
25. …All the courts in the jurisdiction of a High Court are
subordinate to it and subject to its control and supervision
under Article 227. Writ jurisdiction is constitutionally conferred
on all the High Courts. Broad principles of writ jurisdiction
followed in England and applicable to India and a writ of
certiorari lies against patently erroneous or without jurisdiction
orders of tribunals or authorities or courts other than judicial
courts. There are no precedents in India for the High Courts to
issue writs to the subordinate courts…”
13.
Neeta Singh (supra) further rejected the argument that the
High Court should simply treat such a writ petition as one under
Article 227 or Section 482 Cr.P.C. Relying on State of Rajasthan v.
Prakash Chand, (1998) 1 SCC 1, which approved the Division
Bench decision of this Court in Sohan Lal Baid v. State of West
Bengal, AIR 1990 Cal 168, it held that nomenclature read with
substance does matter. A Judge assigned petitions under Article
226, cannot treat a petition as one under Article 227 and decide it
unless the Chief Justice has also assigned that jurisdiction to him.
The following passage of the judgment is of significance and
reproduced hereunder.
“17. In view of the decision in Prakash Chand [State of
Rajasthan v. Prakash Chand, (1998) 1 SCC 1], we hold that
nomenclature of a petition read with the substance thereof does
matter. Much depends on what the subject-matter of the petition
is and who is entrusted to hear and decide it. A Judge of a High
Court having been assigned petitions under Article 226 for
hearing and decision by its Chief Justice cannot, if he (the
Judge) finds that the petition filed under Article 226 should
have ideally been filed under Article 227, treat the petition as
one under Article 227 and proceed to hear and decide it, unless
the Chief Justice has also assigned to such Judge petitions
under Article 227 of the Constitution for hearing and decision. If
not so assigned, the learned Judge may, in his discretion, direct
the petition to be treated as one under Article 227 for being
placed before the learned Judge having assignment. This is
mandatory and, therefore, one finds the caution sounded by
this Court in the opening sentence of para 26 of Pepsi Foods
[Pepsi Foods Ltd. v. Judicial Magistrate, (1998) 5 SCC 749 :
1998 SCC (Cri) 1400] to be of extreme significance.”
14.
In Pradnya Pranjal Kulkarni v. State of Maharashtra,
(2026) 6 SCC 813, the Supreme Court clarified the distinction
between a petition invoking Article 226 alone and one also invoking
the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court. It held that, until
cognizance is taken, an FIR or charge-sheet may be quashed under
Article 226. Once an order taking cognizance intervenes, the power
under Article 226 is unavailable, although the inherent power under
Section 528 BNSS remains available, subject to the requisite
pleadings and a case being made out for interference. Since the
petition before the Bombay High Court also invoked Section 528
BNSS and the concerned Bench had the necessary assignment, the
Supreme Court set aside the order disposing of that petition and
remanded the matter for fresh consideration.
15.
Further, the Supreme Court in Rajendra Bihari Lal v. State
of U.P., 2025 INSC 1249, has put the matter beyond doubt. While
recognising in paragraphs 85 to 87 of the said report that the filing
of a charge-sheet does not by itself denude the High Court of its
inherent power to quash the proceedings, the Court drew the
jurisdictional line at cognizance in paragraph 88 holding that an
accused may approach the High Court under Article 226 for
quashing the FIR and charge-sheet till cognizance is taken. But once
cognizance is taken, the remedy is under Section 528 BNSS.
16.
Tested against these principles, the petition cannot be
entertained in the aforesaid facts of the case.
17.
The petitioners' contentions that the protest was peaceful, that
the allegations disclose no offence and that the prosecution is mala
fide go to the merits of the prosecution case. This Court expresses no
opinion on any of them. They remain open to be urged in the
appropriate proceeding.
18.
For the reasons above, W.P.A. No. 25799 of 2023, being a
petition under Article 226 directed against a criminal proceeding in
which a judicial order taking cognizance had intervened before its
disposal by this court, is accordingly, dismissed.
19.
This order, however, shall not preclude the petitioners from
challenging the charge-sheet and the order taking cognizance in G.R.
Case No. 1120 of 2021 by an appropriate application under Section
482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 or Section 528 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, as may be applicable, in
accordance with law, nor shall it preclude them from seeking
discharge before the learned trial court at the appropriate stage, if at
all, advised.
20.
Nothing in this order is an expression of opinion on the merits
of the allegations or on any contention of the parties.
21.
With the above directions, W.P.A. No. 25799 of 2023 is
dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
22.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
supplied
to
the
parties
upon
compliance
with
all
requisite
formalities.
(Anuj Singh J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review