Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List with
Serial No. 02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 483 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 462 of 2022
Date of Decision: 14.08.2023
Shri Mithu B. Marak & Ors.
Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Smti Sympahunlang Syiemlieh & Ors.Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. V.K. Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. B. Jyrwa, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
Both these writ petitions being identical and similar are
being disposed of by this common Judgment and Order.
2.
The writ petitioners numbering 54 (fifty-four) in all, by
way of these two applications are before this Court praying for
directions to regularize their services w.e.f. the date of their joining to
the post of Peon in the SAD (N) Department of the Government of
Meghalaya, and further to set aside the advertisement dated 09.02.2022
calling for applications for filling up different categories of Grade-IV,
in the said Department. The petitioners’ stated case is that, the posts
against which they are serving are sanctioned posts and though they
were appointed after due selection, pursuant to an advertisement dated
20.01.2012 however, were engaged on a casual daily wage basis. The
petitioners who have completed a number of years of service, were
expecting regularization against the said posts, but however, were
informed vide the impugned letter dated 05.01.2021, that their services
were instead under consideration for regularization under the Regular
Casual Worker Scheme, 1996 after completion of 10 years of service.
Being aggrieved thereby, they have filed the instant writ petitions.
3.
The main ground set up by the petitioners, is that they
having been appointed after undergoing through a selection process,
cannot be treated to be casual workers, inasmuch as, the recruitment of
employees into the Secretariat is governed by Rules namely; “The
Meghalaya (Civil) Secretariat (Records Supplier, Duftry, Zamadar,
etc. and other Grade-IV Staff) Service Rules, 1986” (hereinafter called
the Service Rules 1986). It has been contended, that since the
appointment of the writ petitioners was made in accordance with the
Service Rules 1986, formulated by the State respondents under Article
309 of the Constitution of India, they have acquired a statutory right of
conferment of permanent status and confirmation after completion of
5(five) years of service. It has also been contended that the State
respondents violated the Service Rules, 1986 by non-conferment of
permanent status as provided under Rule 22 (1) of the Service Rules,
1986.
4.
Other points that have been urged are that though the
advertisement dated 20.01.2012 against which the petitioners applied
for and were appointed, was for temporary engagement on payment of
daily wages under the Minimum Wages Act as prescribed, the first batch
of Peons (60 in number) were however appointed as Casual Peons on
contract basis for a period of 1(one) year on a fixed remuneration.
Thereafter, the subsequent engagements of the petitioners, it has been
submitted were until further orders, which are continuing as on date. The
additional ground made out by the petitioners, is that though the
advertisement may have been for temporary engagement, the
methodology adopted by the State respondents for recruitment to the
post of Peon, was that of permanent employees which is as per the
Service Rules, 1986. It has further been urged, that casual appointments
are only for a short period and the same cannot extend for a longer period
of more than 10 years, as has been occasioned in the instant case and
that casual appointments are not generally made pursuant to a selection
process.
5.
Mr. V.K. Jindal, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. B.
Jyrwa, learned counsel for the petitioners has also argued that the posts
occupied by the petitioners were vacant sanctioned posts, inasmuch as,
the respondents in their affidavit-in-opposition has stated that since there
was a restriction in the creation of regular posts, the requirement was
met through casual or contractual appointment purely on a daily basis,
in order to ensure the smooth functioning of the offices. The learned
Senior counsel has also argued that the State respondents have
contradicted their own statement in the affidavit itself, by stating that
the subsequent advertisement that was issued was only for vacant posts
and that the posts occupied by the petitioners were not put up for
advertisement. It is submitted by the learned Senior counsel therefore,
that since as per the State respondents the posts occupied by the
petitioners were not put for advertisement, it supports the contention that
the petitioners were working against vacant existing sanctioned posts.
6.
Learned Senior counsel submits that as the manner of
recruitment was clearly as per the Rules, coupled with the stand of the
State respondents that the petitioners are working against the posts
which have not been advertised, the offer of regularizing them under the
RCW Scheme does not arise, and they are liable to be regularized and
confirmed in their service by the operation of Service Rules, 1986. Apart
from these main points of contention, the learned Senior counsel has
argued that the petitioners are also entitled for pay at the rate higher than
the one fixed under the Minimum Wages Act, inasmuch as, they are
discharging the same duties and functions as Peons, who are in a regular
service in the Department.
7.
In support of his submissions, the learned Senior counsel
has cited the following Judgments:A. On the point of conferment of permanent status
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
R.N. Nanjudappa vs. Thimmiah & Anr. reported in (1972) 1
SCC 409
B.N. Nagarajan & Ors. vs. State of Karnataka reported in
(1979) 4 SCC 407
Secretary, State of Karnataka & Ors. vs. Uma Devi & Ors.
reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1
Dr. DC Wadhwa & Ors. vs. State of Bihar reported in (1987)
1 SCC 378
Chief Conservator of Forest & Anr. vs. Jaganath Maruti
Kondhare & Ors. reported in (1996) 2 SCC 293
B. On the point of equal pay for equal work
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
vi)
8.
Randhir Singh vs. Union of India reported in (1982) 1
SCC 618
Dharwad Dist. PWD Literate Daily Wages Employment
Association vs. State of Karnataka reported in (1990) 2
SCC 396
D.S. Nakara & Ors. vs. Union of India reported in
(19893) 1 SCC 305
Daily Rated Casual Labour Employed under P & T
Department through Bhartiya Tar Majdoor Manch vs.
Union of India reported in (1988) 1 SCC 122
Chief Conservator of Forest & Anr. vs. Jaganath Maruti
Kondhare & Ors. reported in (1996) 2 SCC 293
Union of India vs. Dineshan K.K. reported in (2009) 1
SCC 586
Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG assisted by Ms. R. Colney,
learned GA for the respondents, submits that the advertisement dated
20.01.2012, was issued by the State respondents specifically calling for
temporary engagement of Peons in Meghalaya (Civil) Secretariat,
Shillong on payment of daily wages, as there was a restriction in the
creation of regular posts, the same which had been notified by the State
vide various letters and Office Memorandums. Learned AAG submits
that, as the recruitment of the writ petitioners in 2012 was made
considering the restrictions, the said recruitment was not one conducted
as per the Service Rules, 1986. The petitioners he contends, were fully
aware of the nature of appointment which was offered under the
advertisement 2012, and having voluntarily taken part in the selection
process and worked on a casual basis, cannot at this stage, turn around
to question the same. It is further submitted that the petitioners do not
hold sanctioned post and were specifically engaged as Peon on payment
of daily wages, and therefore their status being that of casual workers,
their regularization, has necessarily to be considered under Clause 3 and
5 of the Meghalaya Regular Casual Workers Scheme, 1996.
9.
With regard to the advertisement dated 09.02.2022, for
appointment against the vacancies of Grade-IV posts in the Secretariat
Administration Department, the learned AAG submits that the said
advertisement will in no manner affect the engagement of the writ
petitioners, who were appointed as Casual Peons in the Department, and
that the said advertisement does not debar the writ petitioners from
applying for the post advertised therein.
10.
The learned AAG has also submitted that on the issue of
equal pay for equal work raised by the counsel for the writ petitioners
during the course of hearing, the same would not be applicable to daily
wage employees as they do not hold a sanctioned post. The terms and
conditions of appointment by which the writ petitioners were appointed
on the basis of the advertisement dated 20.01.2012, he submits is very
clear as it called only for temporary engagement as Peon on daily wages
fixed under the Minimum Wages Act. In this context, the judgment of
the Supreme Court in the case of State of Haryana & Ors. vs. Tilak Raj
& Ors. reported in (2003) 6 SCC 123, has been cited to show that the
petitioners were not entitled in the circumstances for equal pay. He lastly
submits, that in view of the advertisement, mode of appointment and
engagement of the writ petitioners, there has been no illegality or
arbitrariness on the part of the respondents and the impugned
advertisement dated 09.02.2022, does not prejudice the writ petitioners
in any manner. The writ petitions he submits being filed on a misapprehension is therefore, liable to be dismissed.
11.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties. The main
issue for consideration before this Court, is whether the writ petitioners
who were recruited for temporary engagement on payment of daily
wages, would be entitled or eligible to be considered for conferment of
permanent status by way of regularization. Though, it is correct that the
Service Rules 1986, provide for the method of recruitment into the
Meghalaya (Civil) Secretariat and are special rules specifically
governing the services of the Grade IV staff, however, in the
advertisement dated 20.01.2012, under which the petitioners were
recruited, there is no mention of the rules therein, but only that the same
was for temporary engagement as Peons on payment of daily wages.
The advertisement being very relevant is reproduced herein below.
“GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
SECRETARIAT ADMINISTRATION DEPARTMENT (NAZARAD)
No. SAN.150/09/10
Dated Shillong, the 20th January, 2012.
ADVERTISEMENT
Applications are invited from the citizens of India (as
defined in Article 5 to 8 of the Constitution of India) for temporary
engagement as Peons in Meghalaya (Civil) Secretariat, Shillong on
payment of Daily Wages at rates as fixed by the State Government
under the minimum wages Act from time to time for unskilled labour
and will be received by the undersigned on or before 6.2.2012 during
office hours.
Application should be accompanied by – Treasury
Challan of Rs.10/- (Rupees ten) only and Rs.5/- (Rupees five) in favour
of Schedule Caste/Schedule Tribe to be deposited under the head of
account “0051-Public Services Commission 102-State Public Service
Commission (02) Receipt of other Department”. No Postal Order or
Money Order will be accepted.
Applications may be submitted in the Standard Form as
published in the last page of Part XI of the Meghalaya Gazettee.
Application must be accompanied by attested copies of School
Certificate, Scheduled Tribe/Scheduled Caste Certificates, etc.
Incomplete and defective application will be summarily rejected.
Age:-
A candidate should not be less than 18 years on
1.3.2012.
Qualification:-
The minimum qualification is class VI passed from
any recognised Education Institution.
Details of the test/interview will be communicated
in due course of time to eligible candidates.
Sd/(F.J. Mairom)
Deputy Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Secretariat Admn: Department, Nazarat.
Memo No.SAN.150/09/10-A Dated Shillong, the 20th January, 2012.
Copy to :1.
The Director, Information & Public Relations, Shillong for
favour of immediate publication in the local newspapers, one
each in English, Khasi and Garo.
2.
Notice Board.
By order etc.,
Sd/Deputy Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Secretariat Admn: Department, Nazarat.”
12.
The recruitment of the writ petitioners therefore, was as per
the above quoted advertisement and de hors the rules. Though, the
recruitment was by way of a written test and interview, there is no
mention, as to whether the said temporary engagement was against any
existing vacancies, but what is conveyed by the advertisement, it can be
seen, is for temporary engagement on payment of daily wages. The
status of the writ petitioners on being appointed therefore, in view of the
advertisement would only be that of temporary employment on a daily
wage basis.
13.
A pertinent point that has been put forward by the State
respondents which deserves consideration is that, at that relevant point
of time, as there was a restriction in the creation of regular posts, the
department in order to ensure the smooth functioning of the office, had
proposed that the requirement be met through casual or contractual
appointment on a daily wage basis, which was the basis and purpose for
the issuance of the advertisement dated 20.01.2012. The relevant
communication dated 19.01.2011, and Office Memorandum dated
17.07.2011, mandating this embargo on the creation of posts has also
been annexed by the State respondents in their additional affidavit,
which substantiates the stand of the State respondents. It is clear
therefore that, the advertisement of 2012, by virtue of which the
petitioners were appointed, were to non-sanctioned posts, which were
created due to administrative exigencies and for the stated purpose of
the smooth functioning of the office.
14.
The status of the writ petitioners therefore being that of
temporary and casual status, it is to be examined as to whether, they
have acquired any vested right to be considered as members of the
service as given in Rule 3(e) of the Service Rules, 1986. This is in view
of the fact that, the writ petitioners were appointed through a selection
process, which they assert was in accordance with the Service Rules,
1986, and should be confirmed on completion of 5(five) years of service
under Rule 22(1). Rule 3(e) & 22(1) for easy reference are quoted
hereinbelow:“3. Constitution of the Service(e) Persons recruited to the Service in accordance with
the provisions of these rules.
22. Confirmation- (1) Subject to availability of permanent
posts every member of the service shall be confirmed in
the post to which he is appointed if he has completed at
least five years of service to the satisfaction of the
Appointing Authority and is otherwise considered fir for
confirmation.”
15.
At this juncture, it is relevant to note that, the writ
petitioners from the initial date of appointment were paid a fixed
remuneration of Rs. 4,000/- (Rupees Four Thousand only), which was
thereafter revised from time to time, and presently stands at Rs.15,000/(Rupees Fifteen Thousand only) p.m. Further, the appointment order of
the writ petitioners dated 12.03.2013 (Annexure-3 to the writ petition),
has in clear terms defined the nature of employment/engagement of the
writ petitioners as casual peons in the Meghalaya (Civil) Secretariat, on
a fixed remuneration. In the considered view of this Court, therefore,
though the recruitment was by way of a qualifying test, the employment
of the petitioners does not have the trappings of an appointment that can
be said to be under the Service Rules, 1986, to allow them the benefit of
being considered ‘member’ of the service as provided in Rule 3(e), on
the basis of completion of 5(five) years of service.
16.
The writ petitioners in the acceptance and continuance in
their service, for about 10(ten) years now, on being appointed pursuant
to the advertisement, in the considered opinion of this Court cannot at
this stage therefore, clamour for being included or claim to be governed
by the Service Rules, 1986, when their case is already being favourably
considered for regularization under the Regular Casual Worker Scheme,
1996, by the respondents. The writ petitioners by their conduct have
clearly acquiesced to their service conditions and to the fact that, their
recruitment was not on the basis of the Service Rules, 1986. As such
therefore, they cannot have any quarrel with the impugned
advertisement dated 09.02.2022, calling for applications for filling up
different categories of Grade-IV posts in the Department. Furthermore,
this advertisement as has been stated by the State respondents does not
concern the posts presently held by the writ petitioners, who have also
not been debarred from applying for the same.
17.
The other contention raised by the writ petitioners as to the
application of the principle of equal pay for equal work, is of no
relevance in the instant matter. A casual, daily or temporary employee
such as the writ petitioners, has no scale of pay attached to the post, and
as such, there cannot be any claim for any comparison with the regular
and permanent staff, wherein a scale of pay is prescribed.
This
observation is made in view of the fact that as held in the judgment of
State of Haryana & Anr. vs. Tilak Raj (supra) the principles of equal
pay for equal work is not an abstract one and for it to be applicable,
requires complete and wholesale identity between a group of employees
claiming identical pay scales, and others who have already earned such
pay scales, and that it is for the claimant to substantiate a clear-cut basis
of equivalence and a resultant hostile discrimination. The petitioners
being appointed and engaged on a purely casual basis, independent of
the Rules, apart from not having demonstrated the factum of equivalence
or hostile discrimination, there is no question therefore of the principle
being applicable in the instant case.
18.
It is also worthwhile to note that in the case of State of
Maharashtra & Ors. vs. Anita & Anr. (2016) 8 SCC 293 the Supreme
Court held that an estoppel was created against challenging the nature
of appointment once having duly accepted the same. Para-15 which has
some relevance is reproduced hereinbelow:“15. The above terms of the agreement further reiterate
the stand of the State that the appointments were purely
contractual and that the respondents shall not be entitled
to claim any right or interest of permanent service in the
Government. The appointments of the respondents were
made initially for eleven months but were renewed twice
and after serving the maximum contractual period, the
services of the respondents came to an end and the
Government initiated a fresh process of selection. The
conditions of the respondents’ engagement are governed
by the terms of agreement. After having accepted the
contractual appointment, the respondents are estopped
from challenging the terms of their appointment.
Furthermore, the respondents are not precluded from
applying for the said posts afresh subject to the
satisfaction of other eligibility criteria.”
19.
As such in view of the facts and circumstances of the case,
apart from the long delay in challenging the terms of employment and
engagement, no case has been made out by the petitioners for
consideration of their services to be regarded as regular employees
under the Service Rules, 1986. The judgments relied upon by the
learned Senior counsel for the petitioners being of no assistance to their
case are not discussed. Further, the aspect of the writ petitioners’
eligibility for regularization under the Regular Casual Workers
Scheme, 1996 as proposed by the respondents and opposed by the
petitioners, in view of the fact that the same might have an impact on
their future career prospects, is also not discussed at this stage and is
left open.
20.
Accordingly, these writ petitions stand dismissed,
21.
There shall be no orders as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
14.08.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review